The Congressional Subpeona: Power, Limitations and Witness ...
Congressional Power— Congressional power is limited by the fact that it has only those powers...
-
Upload
trevor-mathews -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of Congressional Power— Congressional power is limited by the fact that it has only those powers...
Congressional Power— Congressional power is limited by the fact that it has only those powers delegated to it by the Constitution. Congress cannot create national public schools. Congress cannot require people to vote. Congress cannot create a national religion. Congress cannot censor the content of newspapers or other
media outlets. Congress cannot abolish jury trials.
Expressed Powers—specifically mentioned in the Constitution.
Implied Powers—based on reasonable deduction.Inherent Powers—based on the creation of a sovereign
government in the world community.
Congressional Powers
Strict Constructionists—Led by Thomas Jefferson. Believed that Congress should only be able to exercise the expressed powers and the implied powers that are absolutely necessary to performing their duties.
Liberal Constructionists—Led by Alexander Hamilton. Favored a liberal interpretation of the Constitution. Over the years, the power of the National Government has grown substantially with the support of the American people.
Liberal Constructionists have won out over time due to wars, economic crises, national emergencies, improvements in transportation and communication, and demands by the people for more government services.
Strict vs. Liberal Construction
Power to Tax—a charge levied by the government on persons or propertyTaxes are used to meet public needs.Taxes (tariffs) are used to protect domestic
industry.Taxes protect health and safety (licensing drug
companies).Limits on taxation
Cannot tax churchesCannot impose poll taxesTaxes must be for public purposes, not private benefitCannot tax exports
Peacetime Expressed Powers
Borrowing PowerArticle I, Section 8, Clause 2 of the
Constitution gives the federal government the ability to borrow money on the credit of the United States.
There are no limits on the amount that we can borrow which has allowed the government to deficit spend.
Public Debt—is all of the money that has been borrowed over the years that has not been repaid.
http://www.usdebtclock.org/
Peacetime Expressed Powers (cont’d.)
Commerce PowerRepresents the power of the federal government to
regulate foreign and interstate commerce.Gibbons v. Ogden, 1824—was the 1st major court case
regarding the Commerce Clause to reach the Supreme Court. Read page 297 and explain this case below:The Supreme Court ruled in favor of Gibbons and the
federal government.Over the years, the Commerce Clause has been interpreted
more widely and applied to issues such as the minimum wage and the Civil Rights Act of 1965.
Limits on commerce power.Cannot tax exports.Cannot favor the ports of one state over another.
Peacetime Expressed Powers (cont’d.)
Currency and Bankruptcy PowerThe Constitution gives Congress the authority
to establish a single/common legal tender.Article 1, Section 8, Clause 4 gives Congress
the ability to establish uniform policies for bankruptcy. It is a concurrent power.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuGIgf-ICHM
Peacetime Expressed Powers (cont’d.)
To declare warTo raise and support armiesTo provide and maintain a navyTo make laws governing land and naval forcesTo summon, organize, arm, and discipline the
militia
War Powers (Expressed)
Given to Congress through the Necessary and Proper Clause or the “Elastic Clause”
The Supreme Court gave its approval to this concept in the court case McCulloch v. Maryland, 1819.
Complete the chart below explaining the implied powers given by the each expressed power (page 308):
The Implied Powers
Lay and Collect Taxes
Raise Armies and a Navy
Regulate Commerce
Borrow Money
Establish Naturalization Law
Establish Post Offices
-punish tax evaders-regulate or outlaw sale of some commodities-set standards for states to gain fed funding
-the draft -minimum wage-ban discrimination at work and public facilities-disability protection-regulate banks
-establish the Federal Reserve Banking System
-regulate and limit immigration
-prohibit mail fraud and obstruction-ban some items from being mailed
Nonlegislative PowersAmendments—Article V allows Congress to propose an
Amendment by 2/3 vote in each houseElectoral Duties—House will choose a President by state
if no majority in the electoral college / Senate will choose a VP by senator
Impeachment—House is Grand Jury / Senate is Trial JuryExecutive Appointments and Treaties—Appointments
must be approved by majority of the Senate / Senate Foreign Relations Committee is now very influential on treaties
Investigation—gather info for a bill, oversee executive operations, bring attention to a particular topic (steroids in baseball), expose public officials, promote interests of some members of Congress