Complexities of Cognition in Art

8/21/2019 Complexities of Cognition in Art

1/25

!"#$%&! #$%&'()*+*(, $- #$./*+*$/ */ 0$(+*1 23+! 45++6(7 23/$'89, :;6(

'($)*+ ! 453.53(+ ?@ A3((%5/B 4C3*-*('8 D/,+*+E+( -$3 #$./*+*$/ 5/8 +6( 23+,

,-$&. ,&0&12&+ 3456

;6( 3*,( $- +6( 1$./*+*F( ,1*(/1(, 5/8 /(E3$,1*(/+*-*1 ()&'$35+*$/, */+$ +6( 7$3G*/., $- +6(

6E%5/ H35*/ 65F( H3$E.6+ E, .3(5+(3 5753(/(,, $- +6( 1$%&'()*+*(, $- 6E%5/ 1$./*+*$/@ IE3

35+*$/5'*J*/. %*/8, 65F( 8(F('$&(8 %5+6(%5+*1, 5/8 '$.*15' 3(5,$/*/. +65+ -$3% +6( H5,*, $-

,1*(/+*-*1 G/$7'(8.( $- +6( /5+E35' 7$3'8@ =( 5',$ 51KE*3( G/$7'(8.( +63$E.6 $E3 ,(/,(, 5, 7(

()&(3*(/1( +6( 7$3'8 7( '*F( */@


2/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Q

5'3(58C H((/ 511$%&'*,6(8 */ 5883(,,*/. +6(,( KE(,+*$/,B 5/8 *+ *, /$+ %C */+(/+*$/ */ +6*,

(,,5C +$ 1$F(3 +6( ,5%( .3$E/8@ U5+6(3B HC '$$G*/. 5+ $/( ()5%&'( $- &$(+3CB 45++6(7 23/$'8V,

N;6( 9&+#&80& OSWXRTB +6( &$(+ 5/8 6E%5/*+*(, ,16$'53 2316*H5'8 451


3/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Z

%(+6$8$'$.*(,B ,E16 5, +6( -35%( ,(%5/+*1, $- +6( SW\R, OA*''%$3( SW\XB SWaQTB 1$/1(&+E5' %(+5&6$3

+6($3C */ +6( SWaR, O


4/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ [

SZ #653.( $/1( %$3(B +6(/B 5/8 H( 8E%Hd

S[


5/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ c

=6(/ i+5''%5/ ,5C, +65+ +6( &$(% 1$/+358*1+, *+,('- */ %$$8 5/8 +6(%(B 6( *, 3('C*/. $/ +6( (F*8(/1( $-

+6( '5/.E5.( $- +6( &$(%B &3(,E%5H'C +6( 1$/+35,+ H(+7((/ +6( ,&(5G(3V, 3(1$%%(/85+*$/, +$ +6(

5883(,,(( +$ NH( ,+*''N 5/8 +6(/ +$ N_1`653.( $/1( %$3(@N 2'+6$E.6 *+ *, +3E( +65+ 5, 3(58(3, 7( 65F(

511(,, +$ :+6( &$(% 5'$/(B> +6*, :511(,,> *, /$+ 3(,+3*1+(8 +$ *+, '*/.E*,+*1 ()&3(,,*$/@ k(7 #3*+*1*,% 65,

5+ '(5,+ +7$ %5L$3 &3(,E&&$,*+*$/5' -'57,! +6( H('*(- +65+ %(5/*/. *, ,$'('C 1$/+5*/(8 7*+6*/ +6( &$(%V,

7$38, $/ +6( &5.(B 5/8 +6( -5*'E3( +$ 3(1$./*J( +65+ */+(3&3(+5+*$/ *, */(F*+5H'C */-'E(/1(8 HC 5 3(58(3V,

$7/ 1E'+E35' H51G.3$E/8 5/8 6*,+$3*15' G/$7'(8.(@

#63*,+$&6(3 k*('8V, 3(58*/. $- +6( &$(% *, %$3( 8(+5*'(8 */ *+, 5/5'C,*, +65/ i+5''%5/V, H3*(-

1$%%(/+ 5/8 1$/+35,+, 7*+6 *+ */ *8(/+*-C*/. 23/$'8V, */+(/+*$/!

D+V, +6( E/*F(3,5' ,+$3C $- +6( */8*F*8E5' 5.5*/,+ +6( .3$E&@ ;6( ,+5E/16 8(-(/8(3 $-

,*%&'( +3E+6B -$3 76$% .((,( 53( 65&&*'C .((,( 5/8 /$+ 5/C+6*/. %$3(B *, %(+ HC +6(

,&'(/(+*1 F(/$% $- N+6(%N—5 ,658$7C ('*+(B -$3 76$% +3E+6 *, '*++'( %$3( +65/ 5

'5/.E5.( .5%(@ hE+B 5, 23/$'8 3(%*/8, E,B +3E+6 *, ,$ %E16 %$3( *%&$3+5/+ +65/

H(*/. 1'(F(3 $3 &$7(3-E'g 5/8 +6( 3(5' 6(3$ *, +6( $/( 76$ 65, +6( KE*(+ 1$/-*8(/1(

+$ +E3/ +6( $+6(3 16((G@

2'+6$E.6 k*('8V, 5/5'C,*, 15&+E3(, 5/ *%&$3+5/+ 5,&(1+ $- +6( &$(% 5, 7( ,65'' ,((B *+ 35*,(, +6(

&3$H'(%5+*1 *,,E( $- 5 &$(%V, +$/(@ ;6( KE(,+*$/ *, +7$-$'8! 76(+6(3 $3 /$+ k*('8 65, 511E35+('C

*8(/+*-*(8 +6( +$/( $- 23/$'8V, &$(%B 5/8 76(+6(3 $3 /$+ *+ *, &$,,*H'( -$3 5 &$(% +$ ,E&&$3+

1$/-'*1+*/. +$/(,@ 4C 3(58*/. $- +6( &$(%B D 6$&( +$ ,6$7B 3(-E+(, H$+6 k*('8V, *8(/+*-*15+*$/ $-

+6( &$(%V, +$/( 5, 5316 5/8 &'5C-E' 5/8 i+5''%5/V, 1'5*% +65+ +6( &$(% -5*',@ D+ 8$(, ,$ HC -*3,+

(%&'$C*/. +6( -$''$7*/. 1$./*+*F( ,+35+(.*(, */ ()&(3*(/1*/. 5/8 */+(3&3(+*/. +6( &$(%!

(%&*3*15' $H,(3F5+*$/, $- 3(58(3, 3(58*/.B 5--(1+*F( &3$,$8CB 1$/1(&+E5' %(+5&6$3 +6($3CB


6/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ X

H'(/8*/.B -35%( ,(%5/+*1,B 5/8 ,+3E1+E35' 5%H*.E*+C@ D +6(/ &3$&$,( 5 3(58*/. +65+ ,6$7, 6$7

'*+(353C 13*+*15' */,*.6+, */+$ 5''E,*$/ 5/8 H*$.35&6*15' H51G.3$E/8 %5C 1$/+3*HE+( +$

E/8(3,+5/8*/. +6( &3$1(,,(, $- 5E+6$3l3(58(3 %*/8*/.@

0$(+*1 +$/( *, (,+5H'*,6(8B /$+ HC 1$/+(/+ $3 */+(3&3(+*F( .*,+B HE+ HC &3$,$8*1 (--(1+,! +6(

75C */ 76*16 5/ 53.E%(/+ *, &3(,(/+(8 HC %(+5'*/.E*,+*1 -(5+E3(, ,E16 5, %(+(3 5/8 36C%(B +6(

&6$/(+*1 &5++(3/*/., $- 5''*+(35+*$/ 5/8 5,,$/5/1(B ,C/+51+*1 3(&(+*+*$/,@ 2++351+(8 5, D 5% HC

k*('89, 3(58*/.B D 5% /$+ 1$/F*/1(8 +65+ +6( +$/( $- +6( &$(% *, 5, 6E%$3$E, 5, 6( ,E..(,+,B $3

+65+ 23/$'8 *, 58F$15+*/. +E3/*/. +6( $+6(3 16((G HC .*F*/. E& +6( .5%( */ +6( -*.6+ -$3 +3E+6@ ;$

+(,+ %C */+E*+*$/ 5H$E+ +6( &$(%V, +$/(B D 1$/8E1+(8 5/ */-$3%5' ,E3F(C 5%$/. ,(F(35' 3(58(3,B

/$/( $- 76$% 7(3( ,+E8(/+, 5/8 76$ 15%( -3$% 8*--(3(/+ 75'G, $- '*-(@ k$/( $- +6(% *8(/+*-*(8

6E%$3 $3 5/ N5316 5/8 &'5C-E'N +$/(@ U5+6(3B 5'' +6(*3 3(,&$/,(, (%&'$C(8 /(.5+*F(

+(3%*/$'$.C! H'(5GB 5/.3CB 8(,&(35+(B ,538$/*1B 6$&('(,,B 7*+6 -(('*/., $- ()65E,+*$/ 5/8

3(,*./5+*$/B +6( ,58 */(,15&5H*'*+C $- 511(&+*/. 8(-(5+ */ +6( -51( $- 5/ *%&'515H'( $&&$,*+*$/@ 2

1$./*+*F( 5/5'C,*, $- +6( &$(%V, &3$,$8C 1$/-*3%, %C */-$3%5/+,V */+E*+*$/, $- *+, /(.5+*F( +$/(@

D/ 1$%&53*/. +7$ ()+3(%( 5&&3$516(, ̂ 45''53%mV, 53.E%(/+ -$3 +6( (/65/1(%(/+ $- %(5/*/.

+63$E.6 +6( ,+3E1+E3( $- 7$38, 5, ,$E/8, 5'$/( F(3,E, +6( *8(5 +65+ %(5/*/. 53*,(, +63$E.6 7$38,

5, &E3('C */+(''(1+E5' ,C%H$',^451


7/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ \

03$,$8C 1533*(, (%$+*$/5' 7(*.6+@ ;6( -51+ +65+ +6( &$(% *, 1$/,+3E1+(8 */ 3(.E'53 +3$165*1

%(+(3 $- ,(F(/ ,C''5H'(, &(3 '*/( 13(5+(, 5 -$31(-E' +$/( $- 3('(/+'(,, E3.(/1C@ ;65+ (516 '*/( (/8,

7*+6 ,$%( -$3% $- ,C/+51+*1 1'$,E3(B ()1(&+ -$3 +6( 1'*%51+*1 '5,+ +63(( '*/(,B 5',$ 3(*/-$31(, +6*,

,+5115+$ ,(/,( $- E3.(/1C@ ;6( $/'C ()1(&+*$/ +$ +6( 3(.E'53*+C $- +6*, %(+(3 $11E3, */ +6( +6*38

,+5/J5B 76(/ +6( 7$38 :+6((> $11E&*(, 5/ ()+35Y%(+3*15' &$,*+*$/ */ '*/(, WYSR@ :;6((> -5'', $/ +6(

7(5G ,+3(,, &$,*+*$/ +63(( +*%(, */ '*/( W@ D- +6( '*/( *, 58LE,+(8 ,$ +65+ :+6((> -5'', $/ +6( ,+3$/.

,+3(,, &$,*+*$/! :IE+Y+5'G98 +6((B 6*,,98 +6((B +$3( +6((]> %$3( (%&65,*, *, &'51(8 $/ +6( 5883(,,((

+65/ $/ 6*, 5/+5.$/*,+,@ ;6( (--(1+ $- +6( 51+E5' '*/(B :;6(C $E+Y+5'G98 +6((B 6*,,98 +6((B +$3( +6((]>B

76(3( +6( &3$/$E/ -5'', $/ +6( 7(5G &$,*+*$/, $- +6( '*/(B *, +$ ,+3(/.+6(/ +6( -$31( $- +6( F(3H, 5/8

+$ 7(5G(/ +6( -$31( $- +6( 3(-(3(/1( +$ +6( 5883(,,((B 1$/-*3%(8 HC +6( ()+35%(+3*15' &'51(%(/+ $-

:+6((B> 3(&(5+(8 5.5*/ */ '*/( SRB 76*16 -E3+6(3 8$7/&'5C, +6( ,+3(/.+6 $- +6( 5883(,,(( 1$%&53(8

7*+6 :H(++(3 %(/@> ;6*, &3$,$8*1 8(%(5/*/. 65, *+, */+(/+*$/5' (--(1+,B 5, 7( ,65'' ,((@

2''*+(35+*$/ &'5C, ,EH+'C $F(3 +6( &$(%@ n/F$*1(8 &'$,*F(,B ,*H*'5/+,B 5/8 -3*15+*F(, &3(8$%*/5+(

*/ +6( ,&((16 $- +6( &$(%9, &(3,$/5B 7*+6 F$*1(8 1$/,$/5/+, &3*%53*'C 3(,+3*1+(8 +$ %(/+*$/, $- +6(

5883(,,(( 5/8 6*, 5/+5.$/*,+,@ ;6( -3*15+*F( _-` +65+ 5&&(53, */ +6( -*3,+ ,+5/J5 '*/G*/. :-5,+> 5/8 :Y

,('-> 3(5&&(53, */ ,+5/J5 Z */ :-53(8B Y-$3(B -*3(8> +$ 1E'%*/5+( */ (F(/ .3(5+(3 -$31( */ :-$3+,B -$''CB

-5''B -*/8> */ +6( -*/5' ,+5/J5B 7*+6 +6(*3 %$/$,C''5H'(, ,E..(,+*/. +6( -3E,+35+*$/ 5,,$1*5+(8 7*+6 +6(

E,( $- +6( -$E3Y'(++(3 :-> 7$38@

2,,$/5/1(B +$$B &'5C, *+, &53+@ #$/+35,+ *, ,(+ E& H(+7((/ +6( +(/,( -3$/+ _*` $- 0+&&9B 0&-:&B F&&:&G

$)&& 5/8 +6( '$7 H51G _5` $- *8:&$ B %*8FB :A-8:B :A-8:B :)*$G )*$%7 B *80&G E*%%7G 2*


8/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ a

;6( 5,,$/5/+5' 1$/+35,+ H(+7((/ :A-8: 5/8 F&&:& $- ,+5/J5 Q *, 3(-'(1+(8 */ +6( /(.5+*F('C 1653.(8

,*H*'5/+, 5/8 &'$,*F(, $- *($H$-%IJ 5+ +6( (/8, $- +6( -*3,+ 5/8 ,(1$/8 ,+5/J5,g 3(-'()*F( :+6C,('-> $/'C */ '*/( [g 5/8

$HL(1+ :+6((> -$E3 +*%(, */ +6( +6*38 ,+5/J5@ ;6( %$3( $'8Y-5,6*$/(8 E,( $- $)&& 5/8 $)7 ,(3F(, +$

3('5+( +6(*3 ,$E/8 +$ $)&7 B 76*16 7*( 5/8 7*(+ 7$E'8 /$+B 5/ 5''*+(35+*F( (--(1+ +65+ 8357, H$+6

$&&$,*/. ,*8(, */+$ ,*%*'53 15+(.$3*15' .3$E&*/. 5, 8*,+*/1+ -3$% +6( ,&(5G(3B 76$ 5, 5 3(,E'+

5&&(53, 5H$F( +6( -35C@

U(&(+*+*$/, 53( KE*+( ,+3*G*/.B /$+ $/'C */ +6(%,('F(, HE+ */ +6( 75C +6(C H3*/. 8*--(3(/+ &53+, $-

+6( +()+ */+$ 3('5+*$/@ D+ $11E3, */ +6( 36C%( ,16(%(B 7*+6 :-5,+ l '5,+> 3(&(5+(8 */ :&5,,98 l '5,+B>

3('5+*/. ,+5/J5 S 7*+6 ,+5/J5 ZB 5/8 :7*'' l ,+*''> (16$(8 HC :-5'' l 75''B> 3('5+*/. ,+5/J5 Q +$ ,+5/J5 [@

;6( :13((& l 13((&> $- '*/(, SYQ &535''(', +6( :1653.98 l 1653.(> $- '*/(, SQYSZB 5, 8$ +6( :/$ %$3( H(

,5*8> $- '*/( Q 5/8 :$/1( %$3(oH( 8E%H> $- '*/( SZ@ hC +6E, 8357*/. +6( -*3,+ 5/8 '5,+ ,+5/J5,

+$.(+6(3B +6(,( 3(&(+*+*$/, 6*.6'*.6+ +6( ,((%*/. 1$/+358*1+*$/ i+5''%5/ /$+*1(8@ ;6( 58%$/*+*$/

:'(+> $11E3, -$E3 +*%(,B 5'' 511$%&5/*(8 HC 5/ ()1'5%5+*$/ &$*/+ ,(3F*/. +$ 35*,( +6( '(F(' $- ()1*+(8

E3.(/1C */ +6( ,&(5G(3V, F$*1(@ I/'C +7$ $+6(3 ()1'5%5+*$/ &$*/+, 5&&(53B H$+6 5+ ,*./*-*15/+ &$*/+,!

+6( ,&(5G(3V, 5,,(3+*$/ +65+ +6( 5883(,,((V, $/,(+ *, */ F5*/ O'*/( ZTB 1$/+35,+(8 7*+6 +6( ,&(5G(3V,

58%$/*+*$/ +$ 1653.( $/1( %$3( O'*/( SZT@ i+5/J5 Z ,+5/8, $E+ -3$% +6( 3(,+ $- +6( &$(% HC H(*/.

+6( $/'C ,+5/J5 7*+6$E+ 5 F(3H $- 58%$/*+*$/ $3 5/ ()1'5%5+*$/ &$*/+@ D+ *, 5',$ +6( $/'C ,+5/J5 +65+

65, 5 KE(,+*$/ %53G@ 2/8 +6( $/'C $/( +$ 1$/+5*/ +6( &3$/$E/B :+6((@>


9/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ W

;6( ,6$3+/(,, $- +6( ,(/+(/1(, 513$,, +6( (/+*3( &$(% &3(1'E8(, &$,,*H'( 5%H*.E*+*(, $- ,C/+5)@

;6( $/'C &EJJ'( -$3 %( 1$%(, */ E/8(3,+5/8*/. +6( %(5/*/. 5/8 ,*./*-*15/1( $- :&5,,98> */ '*/( SSB

7*+6 +6( O5'%$,+ ,EH'*%*/5'T ,E..(,+*$/ +65+ +6( 1653.(3, %*,,(8 +6(*3 %53G@ 4$,+ '*/(, 53(

1$%&'(+( ,(/+(/1(,@ ;6( $/'C ()1(&+*$/, O5&53+ -3$% +6( $&(/*/. +7$ '*/(, 76*16 53( */ (--(1+ H$+6

1$%&'(+( ,(/+(/1(, */ +6(%,('F(,T $11E3 */ '*/(, SRYSQ 5/8 S[YSX@ ;6(,( +7$ ,(+, $- '*/(, +6E, 5',$

5&&(53 5, &535''(' 76*16 7( 7*'' ,(( '5+(3 53( ,(++*/. E& +6( 1$%&53*,$/ H(+7((/ 8(-(5+ 5/8

F*1+$3C@ ;6( -*/5' +7$ ,+5/J5, 1$/+5*/ +7$ 7$38, +65+ &3$F*8( 1'E(, +$ +6( &$(%9, '$.*15'

&3$.3(,,*$/! :+6E,> */ ,+5/J5 Z +65+ 1$%&53(, +6( 5883(,,((9, ()&(3*(/1( 7*+6 :H(++(3 %(/B> 5/8

:+6(/> */ ,+5/J5 [ +65+ */+3$8E1(, +6( &3(8*1+*$/ $- 8(-(5+B H$+6 */8*15+*/. 5 1$/,*,+(/+ %$F(%(/+ $-

+6( ,&(5G(39, +6$E.6+ +63$E.6$E+ +6( &$(%@

A*3,+ 3(58*/., &3$F*8( 5/ *%%(8*5+( 3(,&$/,( $- (/.5.(%(/+ $3 $+6(37*,( $/ +6( &53+ $- +6(

3(58(3@ h(15E,( D -*3,+ 3(58 +6( &$(% */ 3(,&$/,( +$ i+5''%5/9, 1$%%(/+B D 75, /(1(,,53*'C

*/-'E(/1(8 HC 6*, LE8.%(/+@ D 1$E'8 ,(( *%%(8*5+('C 6*, &$*/+ 5H$E+ +6( -*3,+ 5/8 '5,+ ,+5/J5,

,((%*/. +$ 1$/+358*1+ (516 $+6(3@ A*3,+B +6( ,&(5G(3 +('', 6*, 5883(,,(( +$ 13((& */+$ H(8 5/8 +6(/ 5+

+6( (/8 +$ .$ 56(58 5/8 1653.(@S =( /((8 +$ 8(+(3%*/( 765+ 65, 165/.(8 H(+7((/ +6( -*3,+ 5/8 '5,+

,+5/J5,@ D -('+ ,+3$/.'C +6( (%$+*$/5' -$31( $- +6( ,&(5G(39, 58%$/*+*$/, +$ 6*, 5883(,,((B 5/8

8(1*8(8 +$ '$$G %$3( 1'$,('C@ ;6( -51+ +65+ +6( F$*1( 7( 51+E5''C 6(53 */ +6( (/+*3( &$(% *, +65+ $-

+6( ,&(5G(3 $/'C 8$(, /$+ %(5/ +65+ 7( 53( /$+ .*F(/ 1'E(, */ +6( ,*'(/1(, H(+7((/ 5, +$ +6( /5+E3(

$- +6( 5883(,,((9, 1$/1(3/, $3 &$,,*H'( 7$38, 6( %*.6+ 65F( ,&$G(/ */ +6( 835%5 $- +6( ,1(/(

S@ =6(/ .(/8(3 *, /$+ *8(/+*-*(8 */ +6( &$(% *+,('- *+ *, %C &351+*1( +$ 5++3*HE+( *+ +$ +6( 5E+6$3@

;6*, *, &E3('C -$3 +6( ,5G( $- (5,( $- 8*,1E,,*$/ 5/8 /$+ +$ H( +5G(/ 5, 8(+(3%*/5+*F(@


10/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SR

&$3+35C(8@ =( /((8 +$ 1$/,*8(3 +6( 1$/,+35*/+, +65+ $&(35+( +$ &3$F*8( +6( G*/8 $- +$/( +65+ +6(

'5/.E5.( $- +6( +()+ *, 13(5+*/.@Q

#$./*+*F( ,+E8*(, 65F( ,6(8 /(7 '*.6+ $/ +6( $'8 KE(,+*$/ */ '*/.E*,+*1, 5, +$ 76(+6(3 165/.*/.

5/C ('(%(/+ */ 5 ,(/+(/1( O,E16 5, 7$38, $3 ,C/+5)T 165/.(, *+, %(5/*/.@ hC 3(1$./*J*/. +6(

*%&$3+5/1( $- 5H,(/+*5' ('(%(/+, ,E16 5, */+(/+*$/ $3 %$+*F5+*$/B 1$./*+*F( ,+E8*(, 3(8(-*/( +6(

KE(,+*$/ 5, $/( H(+7((/ +6( 1$/+(/+ $- 5/ E++(35/1( 5/8 ,*./*-*15/1( +65+ 3(,E'+, -3$% *+, %5//(3

5/8 %(5/, $- ()&3(,,*$/@ #$/,*8(3B -$3 ()5%&'(B 5/ 51+E5' (&*,$8( +65+ $11E33(8 */ 5 &$,+Y

#63*,+%5, 16(1GY$E+ '5/( 5+ 5 %5'' 5, 8(,13*H(8 HC %C +6(/ ,(F(/YC(53Y$'8 /*(1(@ 2 7$%5/ */ '*/(

658 5'3(58C *33*+5+(8 +6( &($&'( H(6*/8 6(3 HC +5'G*/. '$E8'C */+$ 6(3 1('' &6$/(@ i6( +6(/

5//$E/1(8 +65+ +6*, 75, 6(3 &'51( */ '*/( 5/8 ,6( ()&(1+(8 +$ 3(+E3/ +$ *+ 5-+(3 3E//*/. 5/ (335/8@

;6( &($&'( H(6*/8 7(3( 5.65,+! :#5/ ,6( +6(C 5,G(8@ ?58 +6( 7$%5/ ,5*8 */,+(58B :=$E'8

C$E %*/8 6$'8*/. %C &'51( -$3 5 %*/E+( 76*'( D 3E/ 5/ (335/8]> +6( 3(,&$/,( 7$E'8 65F( H((/

%E16 %$3( 3(,&$/,*F( O+6$E.6 +6( 5'3(58C 53$E,(8 *33*+5+*$/ %5C 65F( %58( 511(&+5/1(

.3E8.*/.T@ D/ 8(,13*H*/. +6*, (&*,$8(B %C ,(F(/YC(53 $'8 */-$3%5/+ 5,G(8! :=6C *, *+ +65+ +6( ,5%(

%(,,5.( 15/ H( 8*--(3(/+ 8(&(/8*/. $/ +6( 7$38, E,(8 +$ ()&3(,, *+]> D+ *, &3(1*,('C +6( 5H,(/+*5'

Q@ ;6*, *, 765+ U$%5/ D/.538(/ OSW\Z! ZZ\YZ[QT 15'', 5 :&3(5(,+6(+*1 3(-'(1+*F( 1$./*+*$/> $-

+6( 7$3G@ ;6*, 3(1$/,+3E1+*$/ */F$'F(, H(*/. 5, -5*+6-E' 5, &$,,*H'( +$ +6( 51+E5' '5/.E5.( $- +6(

+()+B &5C*/. 5++(/+*$/ +$ +6( ,$E/8,B %(5/*/.,B 5/8 ,+3E1+E3(,B :+6( &$,,*H'( 5%H*.E*+C $- 7$38,

5/8 .3$E&, $- 7$38,B 5/8 ,C/+51+*1Y'$.*15' -E/1+*$/, 5%$/. ,(/+(/1(,B> 5/8 +$ 8*,1$F(3 (*+6(3

653%$/*$E, E/*+C $3 ,$E31(, $- 8*,1$38 */ +6( +()+ 5, 5 76$'(@ I/'C +6(/ 15/ $/( %$F( +$ +6(

,(1$/8 ,+(& $- :1$/13(+*J*/.> +6( +()+ +63$E.6 :3(-'(1+*F( 1$./*+*$/ $- +6( '*+(353C 5(,+6(+*1

$HL(1+> 76*16 */F$'F(, 1$/,+*+E+*/. +6( :$3*.*/5' 5(,+6(+*1 (%$+*$/ 5/8 765+ 8(F('$&, $E+ $- *+

*/ +6( 5(,+6(+*1 ()&(3*(/1(> */ $38(3 +$ 13(5+( :8*3(1+ 511(,, +$ +6( 5(,+6(+*15''C F5'E5H'( $3 +$

+6( 5(,+6(+*1 F5'E(,> HC -*''*/. */ 765+ 65, H((/ $%*++(8 $3 *, *%&'*(8 */ +6( '5/.E5.( $- +6( +()+

*+,('- OD/.538(/ SW\Z! ZR[T@


11/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SS

-(5+E3(, $- */+(/+*$/B %$+*F5+*$/B (+6*15' F5'E(B 5/8 ,$ $/B +65+ %5G( +6( 8*--(3(/1( HC '$58*/. +6(

'5/.E5.( 7*+6 (%$+*$/5' ,*./*-*15/1(@

D/ 3(,&$/8*/. +$ 23/$'8V, &$(%B 7( /((8 +$ 5,G KE(,+*$/, ,E16 5, +6( -$''$7*/. ! =6$ 53( +6(

165351+(3, */ +6*, &$(%] =65+ 53( +6(*3 3('5+*$/,6*&, +$ (516 $+6(3] =65+ 53( +6( 8(*1+*1 ,+5/1(,

+5G(/] =65+ 1$/1(&+E5' %(+5&6$3, ,+3E1+E3( +6( ,1(/53*$ H(*/. &'5C(8 $E+] 2.5*/,+ 765+ &$,,*H'(

,+(3($+C&*15' 5++*+E8(, *, +6*, &$(% +5G*/. *+, &$,*+*$/]

;6( $F(35'' 1$/1(&+E5' %(+5&6$3 &3$F*8*/. +6( &$(%V, ,+3E1+E3( *, 2Ufn4pk; Di =2U O^76$% +6( ,&(5G(3 H('*(F(, 15/ /(F(3 H( &(3,E58(8 +$ 165/.( +6(*3 %*/8,@ ;6( ,&(5G(3 *,

+6E, E3.*/. +6( 5883(,,(( +$ .*F( E& +6( ,+3E..'( H(15E,( 6(B 5'3(58C :+*3(8> O5, 7( 53( +$'8 */

,+5/J5 QTB 7*''B */ +6( -51( $- ,E16 3(15'1*+35/1(B :H3(5G 5+ '5,+@>

=65+ i+5''%5/ 5&&53(/+'C %*,,(, */ 6*, 13*+*1*,% $- +6( &$(% *, *+, 835%5+*1 %$F(%(/+@ bE,+ 5,

+6( %$/$'$.E( $- +6( %(+5&6C,*15' &$(+ b$6/ P$//(9, ,&(5G(3 */ :;6( A'(5> */8*15+(, +6( 51+*$/, $-

6*, %*,+3(,, */ +6( ,&51(, H(+7((/ +6( ,+5/J5,B ,$ 8$(, 23/$'89, ,&(5G(39, %$/$'$.E( */8*15+( +6(

3(,&$/,(, $- 6*, 5883(,,(( H(+7((/ +6( ,+5/J5, O+6*, *, 5/ ()5%&'( $- 765+ D/.538(/ 15'', -*''*/. */

+6( &'51(, $- */8(+(3%*/51C 5/8 765+ P(51$/ 3(-(3, +$ 5, 5H,(/+*5' -(5+E3(, +65+ 1$/,+35*/ 765+

$11E3,T@ ;65+ *,B 76(/ +6( ,&(5G(3 */ ,+5/J5, S 5/8 Q E3.(, +6( 5883(,,(( +$ ,5C /$ %$3(B H( ,+*''B 6(

*, ,5C*/. ,$ */ +6( -51( $- 6*, 5883(,,((9, 1$/+*/E5' &(3+E3H5+*$/@ ;6( 36(+$3*15' KE(,+*$/ */ '*/( WB

N;6(C $E+Y+5'GV8 +6((B 6*,,V8 +6((B +$3( +6((]N &$*/+, +$ +6( 5883(,,((V, &3(,E%(8 &3$+(,+ 5, +$ 76C

6( %E,+ 1$/+*/E( +$ -*.6+@ ;6( ,&(5G(3V, 3(,&$/,( ()&'5*/, 76C ,+5/J5 Z ,+5/8, $E+ '*/.E*,+*15''C 5,

8*--(3(/+@ ?( +3*(, +$ &(3,E58(B /$+ /$7 +63$E.6 8*3(1+ E3.*/.B HE+ HC &3(,(/+*/. ()5%&'(! 6$7 %(/

(F(/ H(++(3 5+ 53.E%(/+ 65F( '$,+ */ ,*%*'53 1*31E%,+5/1(,@ D/ +6( ,&51( H(+7((/ ,+5/J5, Z 5/8 [B


12/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SQ

+6( 5883(,,(( *, 3*,*/. +$ +6( 165''(/.( +63$7/ 8$7/ O7( 15//$+ G/$7 *- +65+ &635,(B :H(++(3 %(/B>

&3$F$G(8 6*%T +$ 3(L(1+ +6( ,&(5G(39, &(3,E5,*F( E3.*/.@ i$ +6( ,&(5G(3 6*%,('- .*F(, E& 6*,

5++(%&+! :#653.( $/1( %$3(B +6(/B 5/8 H( 8E%Hd> hE+ /$+ 7*+6$E+ 753/*/. 6*, 5883(,,(( $- +6(

1$/,(KE(/1(,@

?(3H(3+ OSWRZ! SRQTB 76*'( 8(,13*H*/. +6( &$(% 5, N+6( &'*.6+ $- 5 6$&('(,, 5/8 ()65E,+(8

,+3E..'(3 5.5*/,+ 5 06*'*,+*/( 7$3'8 +$$ ,+3$/. -$3 6*%BN -*/8, 5 N1E3*$E, 5/8 35+6(3 57G7538

5%H*.E*+CN */ *+, '5,+ ,+5/J5! N;6( /5+E35' %(5/*/. $- +6( 7$38, 7$E'8 H( +65+ +6( &(3,$/

5883(,,(8 658 H((/ (/.5.(8 */ 8(-(/8*/. +6( -$3+, $- -$''CB 76*16B *+ /((8 6538'C H( ,5*8B *, +6(

&3(1*,( $&&$,*+( $- 765+ 43@ 23/$'8 */+(/8(8@N


13/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SZ

1$%(BN 7*'' 8*,1$F(3 76(/ +6(C -*/8 6*, 8(58 H$8C +65+ 6( -5*'(8 +$ ,E11((8@ ;65+ *,B +6(3( 53( -$E3B

/$+ +63((B ,(+, $- &3$+5.$/*,+,! +6( ,&(5G(3B 6*, 5883(,,((B +6( $&&$/(/+,B 5/8 +6$,( 76$ 7*''

E'+*%5+('C ,E11((8 */ (,+5H'*,6*/. G/$7'(8.( 5/8 +3E+6 5.5*/,+ *./$35/1( 5/8 '*(,@

iE16 5 3(58*/. ,E..(,+, 5/$+6(3 75C $- &(31(*F*/. +6( */+(/+*$/5'*+C $- 53.E%(/+ ()&3(,,(8 */

+6( &$(%@ 2+ '(5,+ +7$ 5,&(1+, $- +6( 2Ufn4pk; Di =2U 1$/1(&+E5' %(+5&6$3 */ +6*, &$(% 53( /$+

-E''C 511$E/+(8 -$3 HC +6( H53( H$/(, $- D+ *, /$+(7$3+6C +65+ +6( '5,+ $- +6(,( ,5C*/., -$3%, +6( +*+'( $- +6(

&$(%B +6( -*3,+ -$3%, +6( (--(1+ $- +6( '5,+ '*/(@ ;$ 65F( $/(9, H51G 5.5*/,+ +6( 75'' */8*15+(, +65+

+6(3( *, /$ $+6(3 75C $E+ $- +6( ,*+E5+*$/ C$E -*/8 C$E3,('- */! C$E 65F( +$ -51( 765+ *, 1$%*/. +$

C$E@ ;6( ,&(5G(3 65, 5'3(58C 753/(8 6*, 5883(,,(( +65+ 6( 7*'' $/'C 15E,( 6*%,('- +$ -5*' O:;6$E

+6C,('- 7*'' H3(5G 5+ '5,+>T *- 6( 1$/+*/E(, +$ -*.6+ +6( ,+(58-5,+/(,, O:5'' ,+5/8, -5,+>T $- 6*,

$&&$/(/+,@ ;6( 2Ufn4pk; Di =2U %(+5&6$3 */ +6*, &$(% *, /$+ $/( H(+7((/ (KE5',@ 2, *+ *,B +6(

,&(5G(39, 5++*+E8( H(+35C, +6( -51+ +65+ 6( H('*(F(, 6*, 5883(,,(( *, 5 '$,(3 5/8 +6(3(-$3( H$E/8 +$

-5*'@

;6( +*+'( $- +6( &$(% 35*,(, +6( ,E,&*1*$/ +65+ +6(3( *, %$3( +65/ $/( 2Ufn4pk; Di =2U H'(/8

$&(35+*/.@ A$3 76$ 65, +6( '5,+ 7$38] D/ 3(58*/. +6( %(+5&6$3 5, $/( H(+7((/ +6( 5883(,,(( 5/8

6*, 5/+5.$/*,+,B +6( ,+3E1+E3*/. -35%( -$3 +6( H'(/8 1$%(, -3$% +6( 753 ,&51(B 5/8 *, (/.5.(8 */

8(,13*H*/. +6( 1$/-'*1+ H(+7((/ +6( 5883(,,(( 5/8 +6( 5/$/C%$E, :+6(C> 76$ 53( 5++51G*/. 6*%@ D/

3(58*/. +6( %(+5&6$3 5, $/( H(+7((/ +6( ,&(5G(3 5/8 6*, 5883(,,((B +6( ,+3E1+E3*/. -35%( -$3 +6(

H'(/8 1$%(, -3$% +6( 53.E%(/+ ,&51(B 5/8 -$1E,(, $/ +6(*3 F(3H5' */+(351+*$/@ ;65+ *,B +6(3( *, 5


14/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ S[

8E5' 1$%&'()*+C $- H'(/8*/. */ +6*, &$(%B +6( =2U H'(/8 +65+ k*('8 65, *8(/+*-*(8B 5/8 +6(

2Ufn4pk; H'(/8 D 5% 5H$E+ +$ 8(,13*H(@

2+ +6( $E+,(+B +6( ,&(5G(3 65, E3.(8 6*, 5883(,,(( +$ ,5C /$ %$3(B +$ :H( ,+*''@> ;6( ,&(5G(3

1$/+3$', +6( ,1(/53*$ HC 1$/+*/E5''C 8(%(5/*/. +6( 5883(,,((B H$+6 */ 7$38 16$*1( O:13((&>g

:/533$7>g :F5*/>g :+*3(8>g :H(++(3 %(/>g :-$''C>T 5/8B 5, 7( 65F( ,((/B */ +6( &3$,$8*1 &'51(%(/+ $-

:+6((> */ ,+5/J5 Z@ ;6( ,&(5G(39, +$/( *, ,E&(31*'*$E, +63$E.6$E+@ ?58 6( ,5*8B -$3 ()5%&'(B :U(,+

E&$/ +6C 5%&'( H(8B l U(,+B 5/8 '(+ /$ %$3( H( ,5*8B> +6( (--(1+ 7$E'8 65F( H((/ %$3( .(/+'(B %$3(

&(3,E5,*F(@ ?$7 1$%%*++(8 *, +6*, ,&(5G(3 +$ 51+E5''C 6('&*/. 6*, 5883(,,((] ?*, 7$38, 53(

$--(/,*F(B /$+ 1$/1*'*5+$3C@ pF(/ +6( '5,+ '*/( $- +6( -*3,+ ,+5/J5 1533*(, 5/ */,E'+*/. *%5.(B +6$E.6

/$+ $/( 5E+$%5+*15''C 5F5*'5H'( +$ %$/$'*/.E5' ,&(5G(3, $- p/.'*,6@ 2, 5 1'5,,*15' ,16$'53B 7(''

F(3,(8 */


15/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Sc

$&&$,(8 +$ +6( 3(1$%%(/8(8 :'(+ /$ %$3( H( ,5*8> 5/8 :H( ,+*''>T *, (16$(8 5/8 1$/+35,+(8 */ +6(

-*/5' 3E/Y$/ '*/(, S[YSX $- +6( '5,+ ,+5/J5 +65+ 8(,13*H(B /$+ +6( '$,(3, +6*, +*%( HE+ +6( F*1+$3, 76$

533*F(B 15E,( +6( -$3+, +$ -5''B 5/8 -*/8 +6( 5883(,,((9, '*-('(,, H$8C@ =6(/ 6*, 5883(,,(( 3(-E,(, +$

1$%&'C 7*+6 6*, 58%$/*+*$/ +$ 1$/1(8(B +6( ,&(5G(3 5&&53(/+'C .*F(, E& +6( 53.E%(/+B +(''*/. +6(

5883(,,(( +$ .$ 56(58 5/8 :1653.( $/1( %$3(B> HE+ /$+(, +6( (--(1+ $- 8$*/. ,$ 7*'' %5G( +6(

5883(,,(( >8E%HB> 5 ,E3('C 7('' */+(/+*$/(8 &E/ $/ ,+E&*8*+C 5/8 ,*'(/1(@ D+ *,B 5-+(3 5''B +6( ,&(5G(3

76$ 65, +6( '5,+ 7$38@

23/$'89, ,&(5G(3B +6(/B *, /$+ ,*%&'C +6( &35.%5+*,+ 76$ 58F*,(, 3(+3(5+ */ +6( -51( $-

$F(376('%*/. $88,B HE+ $/( 76$ 6*%,('- 3('*,6(, 5/8 &'5C, E&$/ +6( 7(5G/(,, $- 6*, 5883(,,((@

n/8(3 +6*, 3(58*/.B +6( 3(&(+*+*$/, $- +6( F(3H, $- 58%$/*+*$/ +5G( $/ 5 8*--(3(/+ 3(,$/5/1(@

=6(3(5, :13((&> 5/8 :1653.(> 53( 8*3(1+ 1$%%5/8, +$ +6( 5883(,,((B +6( -$E3 $11E33(/1(, $- :'(+>

H(1$%( 5%H*.E$E,@ 2'+6$E.6 5+ -*3,+ +6(C 5&&(53 +$ .*F( ,$%( 1$/+3$' +$ +6( 5883(,,(( */

(/1$E35.*/. 6*% +$ 5''$7 51KE*(,1(/1( */ +6( -51( $- 6*, $&&$/(/+,B */ +6( (/8 *+ 5&&(53, */ +6(

-$3% $- *+, .$8'C E,( */ :


16/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SX

+65+ 7$38,B */ ,&*+( $- +6(*3 $,+(/,*H'( *%%5+(3*5'*+CB 8$ 65F( 15E,5' (--(1+@ D+ *, +6( ,&(5G(39,

,1$3/-E' ()&3(,,*$/,B D ,E..(,+B +65+ 15E,( 6*, 5883(,,(( +$ 3(,*,+ 6*, 58F*1(@ =65+(F(3 23/$'89,

$3*.*/5' */+(/+*$/ 75, */ 73*+*/. +6*, &$(%B 5 1$./*+*F('C */-'(1+(8 3(58*/. 35*,(, +6( E'+*%5+(

KE(,+*$/, +65+ -51( E, 5'' */ $E3 (+6*15' &E3,E*+ $- +3E+6 5/8 %$35' H(65F*$3@

i$ %E16 -$3 6$7 5 1$./*+*F( 5/5'C,*, %*.6+ 5*8 $/(V, 5(,+6(+*1 5&&3(1*5+*$/@ hE+ 765+ 15/

'*+(353C ()&(3+*,( $--(3 1$./*+*F( 5/5'C,*,] h(C$/8 %C 53.E%(/+ +65+ D H('*(F( &3$8E1(, 5 %$3(

1$6(3(/+ 3(58*/. +65/ (*+6(3 i+5''%5/V, $3 k*('8V,B 15/ *+ H( ,6$7/ +65+ *+ &3$F*8(, */,*.6+ */+$

23/$'8V, &$(+*1 %*/8*/.] ;6*, *, 76(3( +6( &351+*1(, $- '*+(353C 13*+*1*,% */ ,E16 53(5, 5, 6*,+$3*15'

5''E,*$/ 5/8 H*$.35&6*15' H51G.3$E/8 H(1$%( ,*./*-*15/+@ 4C 1$./*+*F( 5/5'C,*, 5'$/( 8$(, /$+

()&'5*/ 765+ 23/$'8 %*.6+ 65F( H((/ N.(++*/. 5+N */ 73*+*/. +6( &$(%B $3 76(+6(3 $3 /$+ %C

&3$F$15+*F( 3(58*/. $- +6( ,&(5G(3V, */+(/+*$/, *, -(5,*H'(@ D/ +6( -$''$7*/. ,(1+*$/B +6(3(-$3(B D

&3(,(/+ '*+(353C (F*8(/1( +$ ,E&&$3+B 165''(/.(B 5/8 1$%&'*15+( %C 3(58*/.@

D/ 6*, '*-(+*%(B 45++6(7 23/$'8 75, H(++(3 G/$7/ -$3 6*, ,$1*5' 5/8 '*+(353C 13*+*1*,%@ ?*, 7$3G

5, 5 ,16$$' */,&(1+$3B 76*16 */1'E8(8 .358*/. %5/C ,+E8(/+ ()5%*/5+*$/,B %58( 6*% */+*%5+('C

-5%*'*53 7*+6 h3*+*,6 (8E15+*$/5' &351+*1(,@ 2, 5 6E%5/*,+B 6( 75, 8((&'C 1$/1(3/(8 7*+6 765+ 6(

,57 5, 06*'*,+*/*,% */ ,$1*(+C 5+ '53.(@ D+ 75, +6*, 1$/1(3/ +65+B 511$38*/. +$ #$E''*/. OSW\[! QSTB

N511$E/+,B %$3( +65/ 5/C $+6(3 ,*/.'( -51+$3B -$3 +6( -3(KE(/1C $- 23/$'8V, &$'(%*15' (/.5.(%(/+,B

-$3 H$+6 +6( 6$,+*'*+C $- +6( 13*+*1, 76$ 5++51G(8 6*% 5/8 -$3 6*, 8(+(3%*/5+*$/ +$ 8(-(/8 5/8

()&5/8 $/ 765+ 658 H((/ 5++51G(8@N


17/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ S\

OiE&(3 SWXQ! SR\T@ k*('8 OQRR\T ,E..(,+, +65+ 23/$'8 %5C 65F( */ %*/8 +6( ,+$3C $- 216*''(, 5/8

05+3$1'E, */ ?$%(39, K%#- D/ k*('8V, 3(58*/.B +6( &$(%9, ,&(5G(3 *, *8(/+*-*(8

7*+6 23/$'8 5/8 7( 5, 3(58(3, 53( 15,+ */ +6( 3$'( $- */+35/,*.(/+ 05+3$1'E,@ ?$7(F(3B E/'*G(

05+3$1'E, */ ?$%(39, K%#-


18/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Sa

-*.6+ 76*16 %5C +3*..(3 6(3$*,%B HE+ 5 6$&('(,, 6(3$*,% '(58*/. +$ 8(-(5+!

O%C +35/,'5+*$/Tc

;6(,( '*+(353C 3(58*/., 5'' 8(5' 7*+6 +6( F*1+*% $- 23/$'8V, &$(%B HE+ 765+ 5H$E+ +6( ,&(5G(3]

;63$E.6$E+ 6*, 73*+*/.,B 23/$'8 E,(, +6( 2Ufn4pk; Di =2U %(+5&6$3B 5'*./*/. +6( 15E,( $- 6*,

$7/ -*.6+ 7*+6 +65+ $- I)-$38B N+6( 6$%( $- '$,+ 15E,(,N */ 6*, SaXc ;+&E-0& $* =::-7: #8 B+#$#0#:1!

N2&&53*+*$/, $- 5 85CB 765+ *, $E3 &E/C 753-53( 5.5*/,+ +6( 06*'*,+*/(,B 1$%&53(8 7*+6 +6( 753-53(

76*16 +6*, KE((/ $- 3$%5/1( 65, H((/ 75.*/. 5.5*/,+ +6(% -$3 1(/+E3*(,B 5/8 7*'' 75.( 5-+(3 7( 53(

.$/(]N OiE&(3 SWXQ! QWRT@ UE+6 U$H(3+, OSWaZ! ca\TB ,((*/. N5 73C '*/GN */ iE&(3V, 163$/$'$.*15'

5335/.(%(/+ $- 23/$'8V, &3$,( 73*+*/., +65+ &'51(, +6( %$++$ -3$% I,,*5/B N;6(C 7(/+ -$3+6 +$ +6(

753B HE+ +6(C 5'75C, -(''BN 76*16 H(.*/, +6( (,,5C L8 $)& M$(


19/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ SW

hE--$/ OS\R\YS\aaT +$7538 6*, 13*+*1,! NhE--$/B +6( .3(5+ A3(/16 /5+E35'*,+B *%&$,(8 $/ 6*%,('- +6(

3E'( $- ,+(58*'C 5H,+5*/*/. -3$% 5'' 5/,7(3 +$ 5++51G, %58( $/ 6*%N O23/$'8 SaXQg 4*'-$38 Z\WT@ 2-+(3

&35*,*/. hE--$/ -$3 6*, 3(,+35*/+ */ /$+ ,E11E%H*/. +$ N+6( H5/(-E' (--(1+, $- 1$/+3$F(3,CBN 23/$'8

1$/+*/E(,! NhE--$/V, ()5%&'( ,((%, +$ %( 7$3+6C $- 5'' *%*+5+*$/B 5/8 */ %C 6E%H'( 75C D %(5/

5'75C, +$ -$''$7 *+@ D 65F( /(F(3 3(&'*(8B D /(F(3 7*'' 3(&'CB +$ 5/C '*+(353C 5,,5E'+g */ ,E16 (/1$E/+(3,

+(%&(3, 53( '$,+B +6( 7$3'8 '5E.6,B 5/8 +3E+6 *, /$+ ,(3F(8N OZaRT@ f*F(/ 23/$'8V, '*-('$/. 15%&5*./

5.5*/,+ '*+(353C 5,,5E'+, 5.5*/,+ 6*%B $/( *, '(8 +$ 7$/8(3 76(+6(3 *+ 75, ,*%&'C -5*'E3( $/ 23/$'8V,

&53+ +$ 6((8 6*, $7/ 58F*1(B $3 76(+6(3 6( 75, H(*/. *3$/*1@ ;6( 5/,7(3 +$ +65+ KE(,+*$/ '(58,

8*3(1+'C +$ 5/ E/8(3,+5/8*/. $- 23/$'8V, $7/ %*/8*/. 5, *+ *, ()&3(,,(8 */ N;6(


20/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ QR

6*, 53.E%(/+, 5.5*/,+ 6*, $&&$/(/+,V 5++51G,B ,$ +65+ +6( *3$/C *, 8*3(1+(8 5.5*/,+ 6*, 13*+*1,B $3 *, *+

35+6(3 5 15,( +65+ +6( *3$/C *, ,('-Y8*3(1+(8]

hE,6 OSW\S! Z\T 1$%%(/+, $/ N+6( '51G $- *3$/C */ 23/$'8V, F(3,(B */ 1$/+35,+ 7*+6 6*, 5HE/85/+

E,( $- *+ */ &3$,(@N #(3+5*/'CB %C 1$./*+*F( 3(58*/. $- N;6(


21/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ QS

-$3 7( ,65'' 5'' 8(+(3*$35+( E/8(3 *+@ =6*'( +6(3( *, +*%(B D 7*'' 8$ 5'' D

15/B 5/8 */ (F(3C 75CB +$ &3(F(/+ *+ 1$%*/. +$ &5,,@ OK+8@ */ #$E''*/.

SW\[! QST

2, 5 3(,E'+B D 1$/1'E8( +65+ 23/$'8 */ 73*+*/. N;6(


22/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ QQ

=$38N *, +6( $/( &$(% +65+ 3(516(, +$ +6( F(3C 1$3( $- 23/$'8V, *//(3 ,('- 5, 6( */+(351+, 7*+6 6*,

7$3'8@ ;6( *3$/C +65+ '*+(353C 13*+*1, -*/8 */ 6*, &$'(%*15' 73*+*/., 1$%(, -3$% 23/$'8V, NF('F(+

.'$F(N 5&&3$516 +$ 6*, 13*+*1,@ D +6*/G +65+ +6( &$3+35C5' $- +6( ,&(5G(3 */ 6*, &$(% 5, 5 HE''C*/.

%5/*&E'5+$3 5/8 +6( 5,,E%(8 7(5G/(,, $- +6( 5883(,,(( */8*15+( +6( ()+(/+ $- *//(3 1$/-'*1+ */

23/$'8V, $7/ ,('- */ +6( +(%&+5+*$/ +$ +5G( $-- +65+ F('F(+ .'$F(@ D/ ,&*+( $- ,E16 *//(3 1$/-'*1+B

6$7(F(3B +6(3( *, 5 &53+ $- 23/$'8B ()&3(,,(8 */ +6( */F$15+*$/ $- +6$,( NF*1+$3,B 76(/ _8*$ #E ̀ +6(C

1$%(BN +65+ 3(-'(1+, 23/$'8V, E/8(3'C*/. 1$%%*+%(/+ +$ 5 %$3( 6$&(-E' -E+E3( 76(3( G/$7'(8.(

5/8 +3E+6 7*'' &3(F5*'@ 2'+6$E.6 ?$/5/ OSWaS! ZZ\T /$+(, +65+ N_&`$(+3CB -$3 23/$'8B 75, /$+ 5 .$$8

F(6*1'( -$3 $&+*%*,%BN N;6(


23/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ QZ

U(-(3(/1(,

2&U$H(3+,B UE+6@ SWaZ@ '+8*%< -8< N*


24/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Q[

A*''%$3(B #653'(,@ SW\X@ ;$&*1, */ '()*15' ,(%5/+*1,@ D/ 0(+(3 #$'(B (8@ B(++&8$ K::(&: #8 D#8F(#:$#0

")&*+7 B \XYSZa@ h'$$%*/.+$/! D/8*5/5 n/*F(3,*+C 03(,,@

A*''%$3(B #653'(,@ SWaQ@ A35%( ,(%5/+*1,@ D/


25/25

#$%&'()*+*(, $- 0$(+*1 23+ Qc

05E'B ?(3H(3+ =@ SWRZ@ R-$$)&A '+8*%

Complexities of Cognition in Art

Documents

Transcript of Complexities of Cognition in Art