Comparison of Cleaning Methods on AR Coated Expanded Beam...
Transcript of Comparison of Cleaning Methods on AR Coated Expanded Beam...
Confidential
Comparison of Cleaning Methods on AR Coated Expanded Beam Connector
Tiger Ninomiya ([email protected])
ConfidentialConfidential
Background
• This is a follow up from last year’s meeting whereby SENKO presented results from various cleaning method on non-AR Coated expanded beam connectors
• This year we expand testing investigate the effectiveness of the various cleaning methods/materials on oil based contaminant on AR Coated expanded beam connectors
• Quantify the effectiveness of the cleaning method in terms of IL & ORL of the interconnector which will allow iNEMI to evaluate the impact/significance of the various cleaning methods against the transmitted signal’s BER/Power Penalty.
Confidential
Types of cleaners
Pen Type
Gel Pad
Wipe Dry/Wet
* Based on cleaners listed in IEC TR 62627-01 Edition 2.0 2016-01
Compressed Air
Dust is being deposited using a syringe and
sprayed on the endface manually
Confidential
Connector
Molex VersaBeam
MT connector
assembly was used
for the testing
ConfidentialConfidential
End Face Cleaning for Non-contact EBCCleaner Type
Lint Free + Alcohol Pen Type Compressed Gas Gel TypeAR-Coated
Initial
With dust
After cleaning
Confidential
Lint Free Wipe + Alcohol
Compressed Gas
Initial Cleaned
Initial Cleaned
Confidential
Gel Pad
Pen TypeDust
residue
Dust
residue
Initial Cleaned
Initial Cleaned
Confidential
Test Result (Lint Free + Alcohol)
before after
Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm) Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm)
-26.684 0.587 -56.571 -0.534 -26.684 0.274 -56.571 3.996
-26.516 0.304 -56.243 0.385 -26.516 0.445 -56.243 -0.566
-27.493 0.28 -58.47 0.887 -27.493 0.005 -58.47 13.33
-26.696 -0.012 -56.578 13.36 -26.696 0.03 -56.578 13.383
-29.488 0.048 -59.237 13.991 -29.488 0.076 -59.237 13.993
-29.268 0.044 -59.438 7.618 -29.268 0.068 -59.438 8.328
-29.848 -0.138 -59.826 13.311 -29.848 -0.109 -59.826 13.341
-29.647 -0.079 -59.343 13.928 -29.647 -0.045 -59.343 13.962
-29.054 -0.007 -59.037 12.933 -29.054 0.022 -59.037 13.045
-29.378 0.35 -47.033 14.448 -29.378 0.366 -47.033 14.387
-29.681 -0.007 -59.301 2.485 -29.681 0.03 -59.301 3.598
-29.218 0.131 -59.815 12.613 -29.218 0.138 -59.815 13.238
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
IL
(dB)
CH数
IL Result
Lint free+ Alcohol
Confidential
Test Result (Pen type)
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
IL
(dB)
CH数
IL result
Pen type cleaner
before after
Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm) Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm)
-26.684 0.552 -56.571 0.825 -26.684 0.426 -56.571 3.738
-26.516 0.37 -56.243 -1.126 -26.516 0.093 -56.243 3.35
-27.493 0.168 -58.47 1.429 -27.493 0.115 -58.47 3.556
-26.696 0 -56.578 6.02 -26.696 0.455 -56.578 -1.462
-29.488 0.547 -59.237 -1.624 -29.488 0.045 -59.237 7.686
-29.268 0.541 -59.438 -1.474 -29.268 0.306 -59.438 0.405
-29.848 -0.046 -59.826 13.501 -29.848 -0.017 -59.826 13.494
-29.647 -0.035 -59.343 13.794 -29.647 -0.055 -59.343 13.839
-29.054 -0.055 -59.037 13.506 -29.054 -0.063 -59.037 13.496
-29.378 -0.31 -47.033 18.089 -29.378 -0.3 -47.033 18.292
-29.681 -0.08 -59.301 13.688 -29.681 -0.1 -59.301 13.742
-29.218 -0.079 -59.815 13.862 -29.218 -0.052 -59.815 13.811
Confidential
Test Result (Lint Free + Alcohol)
before after
Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm) Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm)
-26.684 0.587 -56.571 -0.534 -26.684 0.274 -56.571 3.996
-26.516 0.304 -56.243 0.385 -26.516 0.445 -56.243 -0.566
-27.493 0.28 -58.47 0.887 -27.493 0.005 -58.47 13.33
-26.696 -0.012 -56.578 13.36 -26.696 0.03 -56.578 13.383
-29.488 0.048 -59.237 13.991 -29.488 0.076 -59.237 13.993
-29.268 0.044 -59.438 7.618 -29.268 0.068 -59.438 8.328
-29.848 -0.138 -59.826 13.311 -29.848 -0.109 -59.826 13.341
-29.647 -0.079 -59.343 13.928 -29.647 -0.045 -59.343 13.962
-29.054 -0.007 -59.037 12.933 -29.054 0.022 -59.037 13.045
-29.378 0.35 -47.033 14.448 -29.378 0.366 -47.033 14.387
-29.681 -0.007 -59.301 2.485 -29.681 0.03 -59.301 3.598
-29.218 0.131 -59.815 12.613 -29.218 0.138 -59.815 13.238
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
IL
(dB)
CH数
IL Result
Lint free+ Alcohol
Confidential
Test Result (Compressed Air)
before after
Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm) Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm)
-26.684 0.103 -56.571 14.198 -26.684 0.095 -56.571 14.138
-26.516 -0.12 -56.243 13.993 -26.516 -0.127 -56.243 13.99
-27.493 -0.048 -58.47 13.837 -27.493 -0.06 -58.47 13.811
-26.696 -0.022 -56.578 13.302 -26.696 -0.036 -56.578 13.289
-29.488 -0.042 -59.237 13.895 -29.488 -0.049 -59.237 13.887
-29.268 -0.043 -59.438 13.717 -29.268 -0.045 -59.438 13.706
-29.848 -0.029 -59.826 13.47 -29.848 -0.029 -59.826 13.462
-29.647 -0.06 -59.343 13.962 -29.647 -0.059 -59.343 13.96
-29.054 -0.104 -59.037 13.476 -29.054 -0.106 -59.037 13.476
-29.378 0.086 -47.033 13.476 -29.378 0.073 -47.033 13.561
-29.681 -0.08 -59.301 13.768 -29.681 -0.073 -59.301 13.921
-29.218 -0.042 -59.815 13.911 -29.218 -0.008 -59.815 13.898
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
IL
(dB)
CH数
IL Result
Compressed Air
Confidential
Test Result (Gel)
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
IL
(dB)
CH数
IL Result
Gel
before after
Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm) Ref(dBm) IL(dB) Ref(dBm) RL(dBm)
-26.684 0.121 -56.571 13.544 -26.684 0.134 -56.571 13.947
-26.516 -0.013 -56.243 14.074 -26.516 -0.006 -56.243 14.051
-27.493 0.007 -58.47 13.896 -27.493 0.043 -58.47 13.88
-26.696 0.012 -56.578 13.365 -26.696 0.04 -56.578 13.383
-29.488 0.01 -59.237 13.946 -29.488 0.07 -59.237 13.932
-29.268 0.12 -59.438 6.671 -29.268 0.136 -59.438 7.277
-29.848 0.02 -59.826 13.444 -29.848 0.052 -59.826 13.458
-29.647 0.045 -59.343 13.711 -29.647 0.06 -59.343 13.735
-29.054 0.009 -59.037 13.342 -29.054 0.032 -59.037 13.388
-29.378 0.204 -47.033 13.935 -29.378 0.21 -47.033 14.057
-29.681 0.013 -59.301 13.932 -29.681 0.04 -59.301 13.988
-29.218 0.032 -59.815 14.017 -29.218 0.044 -59.815 13.983
ConfidentialConfidential
Summary• AR Coated connectors were not damaged by the cleaning process
• Nevertheless, the non-abrasive cleaners (i.e. compress gas & gel) provides best consistency on the before & after IL & ORL
• Traces of residue dust around guide-pin areas are found after cleaning by pen-type cleaners
Future work• Continue discussion between HPE and Resolute Technologies on Dust Maze to
further investigates effect of dust on connectors in a controlled/predictable environment
• Any other suggestion regarding to cleaning?
Confidential
Discussion
ConfidentialConfidential