Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N...
Transcript of Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N...
![Page 1: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Comparing Abundances of 44Ti and other Isotopes
![Page 2: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
4444TiTi γγ--rays fromrays from CasCas AA
44Ti Ejected Mass ~0.8-2.5 10-4 M
44Ti
44Ca
τ =85y, EC
44Sc
τ = 5.4 h, β+
τ=85y (Ahmad et al. 2006)
SPIMartin et al.'06
IBISRenaud et al. '06
![Page 3: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
4444Ti Yield of ccTi Yield of cc--SNe: UncertaintiesSNe: UncertaintiesAt Discovery Time of Cas A: 44Ti Lifetime UncertaintyNow: 44Ti Abundance Measurement on Cas A, Astrophysics
Absolute Abundances are a Challenge!What about abundance ratios?
![Page 4: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Abundances in Stellar PhotospheresAbundances in Stellar Photospheres
Asplund et al. 2005
The Reference: Our SunSolar Abundances are Difficult to Assess
Main Components: X=0.7392, Y=0.2486, Z= 0.0122 (Asplund et al. 2004)But, e.g.:
Metal Fraction Z/X: now 1.65%, was 2.75% (Anders & Grevesse 1989)
C Abundance: down by 0.17 dex, overall more consistent now(Lodders 2003)
Change of BASELINE for Nucleosynthesis-Yield Evaluations!
re-analyzed (3D)
![Page 5: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
1D versus 3D Photosphere Models1D versus 3D Photosphere Models
Convective Motion Inadequately Addressed in 1D"Microturbulence" CorrectionsNon-Matched Line Profiles
3D EffectsGranulation of Convection CellsDoppler Shifts of Lines are Depth-Dependent
M. Asplund 2000; 2005;...
![Page 6: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Impact of 3D Models of the Solar PhotosphereImpact of 3D Models of the Solar Photosphere
Intermediate-Mass Element Systematics:non-LTE Effects are Significant -> ~0.1-0.2 dex UncertaintyGranulation/3D Effects Uncertain (only LTE-Studies so far)
![Page 7: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Cas A: How Much Cas A: How Much 5656Ni?Ni?Cas A was NOT Seen as Bright SN
No Historical "SN Report" – (except controversial:
Flamsted 6thmag 16 Aug 1680)– Cas A = "sub-luminous" SN?
Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?Abnormal Ratio of NH versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS
– Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell-> Occultation of SN Light
– Destroyed by SN Shock -> Seen in NH Excess
Indirect Cas A Brightness EstimateSN Light Echo
– Krause et al. 2008, Cloud at 266 ly from Cas A– Similarity to SN1993J, i.e. Cas A = SN Type IIb
– 56Ni Mass Estimated as 0.05...0.15 M
![Page 8: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
SN1987ASN1987A• Radioactivity as Energy Source of SN Light
Energy Deposition and -Conversion ModelRadioactivity Gamma-Rays and PositronsSN Envelope Composition and Dynamics HistoryLight Curve Models, with M(56Ni/57Ni/44Ti) as Parameters -> Fit to Obs
Observational AccessBolometric SN LightOptical LinesIR Lines
– [FeI] at 24.05 μm– [FeII] at 25.99 μm
Fransson & Kozma 2001
![Page 9: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
SN1987A: Amounts of SN1987A: Amounts of 5656Ni/Ni/5757Ni/Ni/4444TiTi
Early LightcurveM(56Ni)=0.071 M (Sunzeff&Bouchet'90)M(57Ni)=3.3 10-3 M (Fransson & Kozma 1993)
Late IR Light CurveM(44Ti)=1.5 10-4 M (Kozma+ 2000)
– (bolometric LC at <3270d)
M(44Ti)=1-2 10-4 M (Chugai+ 1997) – (optical lines at 2875d)
M(44Ti)=<1 10-4 M (Lundquist+ 2001) – (Far-IR lines FeII 26μm at 2875d)
M(44Ti)=<1.5 10-5 M (Borkovski+ 1997) – (Far-IR lines FeII 26μm at 3425d)
M44Ti=5 10-5M
Lundquist+, 2001
Fransson & Kozma 2001
![Page 10: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Light Curve Models: DiscussionLight Curve Models: Discussion
Basic ProcessesRadioactive Energy Deposits (gamma-rays, positrons)
– gamma-ray deposit ~ gas density– positron deposit ~gas density & magnetic-field structure
Inelastic Photon Scattering in Expanding Envelope– line opacities, line energy ~ expansion velocities
Thermal / Collisional Excitations– collisional temperature
Approximately:Local Energy Deposit & Dominating Photon Diffusion (t<40...50 days)Distributed Energy Deposit & Energy Conversion (t>50 d)
CaveatsNo thermodynamic equilibrium, Tcollisional < TionizationLine opacities are importantResonant scatterings are important3D mixings of radioactivity are importantCompositions of Envelope & Swept-Up ISM are importantAnisotropy of E deposit & photon transport incurs limb brightenings
![Page 11: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
CoreCore--Collapse SN NucleosynthesisCollapse SN NucleosynthesisWoosley & Weaver 1995
44Ti Yields are Sensitive to Explosion DetailsLarger Variations/FLuctuations with Progenitor MassVery Massive Progenitors >30 M : No 44Ti (BH formation), or Huge (Ekin>1052 erg, asymmetries) 44Ti Yields
In Comparison, Most other Isotope Yields Behave More Smoothly with Progenitor MassesAre Less Sensitive to Explosion Details
![Page 12: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Aspherical SNe: Aspherical SNe: 4444Ti Enhancements?Ti Enhancements?
Aspherical SN Explosions:Stronger Shock in Polar RegionHigher Entropy behind ShockIncreased 44Ti Synthesis
– Nagataki 1998– Mass Cut Choice
from 0.07 M of 56Ni
Maeda & Nomoto 2003
![Page 13: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Using SN Profiles to Obtain Using SN Profiles to Obtain 4444Ti and Ti and 5656NiNiNuclear-Reaction Weighting with SN Structure & Dynamics
Magkotsios et al. 2008; Parikh et al. / NARF Project
![Page 14: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
““NormalNormal”” Core Collapse Supernovae (?)Core Collapse Supernovae (?)
Consistency Check: Cas A vs. what we know about 44Ti…
44Ti from SAD/Models/SN1987A/γ-Rays, vs. 56NiOnly Non-Spherical Models Reproduce Observed Ratios
Non-spherical explosions?? (->GRB)
Cas A
![Page 15: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Abundance InterrelationsAbundance Interrelations
Ti Abundances Show (somewhat) Larger Scatter than Si and CaHint for rare-event synthesis?
Sestito+ 2008
![Page 16: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Abundances in our GalaxyAbundances in our Galaxy
Abundance Gradient within the GalaxyGeneral Trend of a Decline with Galactocentric RadiusTi and Ca are Similar to Fe
![Page 17: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
SpatioSpatio--temporal temporal Evolution of the GalaxyEvolution of the Galaxy
Radial Gradients Provide a Key Diagnostic of Evolution
Prantzos & Boissier 1999, 2003
![Page 18: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Chemical Evolution of the GalaxyChemical Evolution of the Galaxy
• Modeling Abundance EvolutionsStar Formation HistorySource YieldsMixing and Infall Works for Some Elements, not for Others…
Modeling Standard Abundances(same ingredients) Agreement is Good, ~Factor 2
There are Missing Pieces…Nuclear Reactions?Stellar & SN Models?Matter Cycling / ISM Flows?
![Page 19: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Inverting the Argument: Inverting the Argument: What the Galaxy Tells Us About YieldsWhat the Galaxy Tells Us About Yields
Fitting GCE-Model Predictions to Observation-Inferred Abundance Histories
– assuming Star-Formation and Infall Histories and IMF are Fixed by Various Constraints (e.g. star & gas distributions, spatial abundance gradients)
best
-fit
yie
lds
WW
95 y
ield
s
![Page 20: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Ref.: Woosley & Weaver 1995Yields for O, IM Elements (Ca) and Fe Group Fe/Zn/Ni ~okCorrections Suggested for Mg, Ti, Cr, Mn, Co
Yield Consistency CheckYield Consistency Check
![Page 21: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
Ref.: Limongi & Chieffi 2003Same as WW95: most ~ok
Massive Stars & cc-SNe ~ok
Corrections Suggested for SNIa Yields
Yield Consistency CheckYield Consistency Check
![Page 22: Comparing Abundances of Ti and other Isotopes · Dust-Enshrouded SN Explosion?)Abnormal Ratio of N H versus X-ray Scattering in ISM along LoS – Cas A Progenitor-Produced Dust Shell->](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042301/5ecbf2c76fe8fc6a9e30db89/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Roland Diehl"The Origin of 44Ti", 15 Jan 2009
““AbnormalAbnormal”” Core Collapse Core Collapse SupernovaeSupernovaeas as 4444Ca (=Ca (=4444Ti) Sources?Ti) Sources?
44Ti vs. 56Ni: Models compared toSolar 44Ca/56FeSN1987A & Cas A
Only Non-Spherical Models Reproduce Observed 56Ni/44Ti Ratios
Abundance Scatter:Somewhat Increased for Ti?Sky Regions with Most Massive Stars are 44Ti Source-Free (COMPTEL, INTEGRAL)
Rare Events??
The et al. 2006Cas A is the ONLY Source Seen(Iyudin et al 1994)
expectation
-100 0 100 Longitude [o]
Lati
tude
[o]