Comparative Analysis: The VENTANA HE 600 system versus a traditional linear H&E stainer
-
Upload
ventana-medical-systems-inc -
Category
Health & Medicine
-
view
1.959 -
download
0
Transcript of Comparative Analysis: The VENTANA HE 600 system versus a traditional linear H&E stainer
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
Comparative Analysis
The VENTANA HE 600 system versus a traditional linear stainer
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
Study participantDr. Sandra Mueller, PETROGLYPH Pathology Services• Comparison of H&E stain quality between the VENTANA HE
600 system and a traditional linear “dip and dunk” stainer (Leica Autostainer XL)
• Dr. Mueller evaluated 480 slides total– 240 slides per instrument - 40 slides per instrument per tissue
sample• 6 tissue samples: Lymphoma 1, Lymphoma 2, Melanoma, Gastric Ca,
Lobular Ca, Liver– H&E stain quality assessed with four-point scale shown below
with Dr. Mueller’s definition for each rating:
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
ResultsThe VENTANA HE 600 system improves H&E stain quality
3.8Average quality
score out of 4.0
3.0
The VENTANA
HE 600 system
Average quality
score out of 4.0
Dip and dunk
stainer
Average H&E stain quality scores across all slides and tissue samples
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
ResultsThe VENTANA HE 600 system improves H&E stain quality
85%rated excellent quality
26.2%
The VENTANA HE 600
system
Dip and dunk stainer
rated excellent quality
0%rated poor quality
6.7%rated poor quality
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
ResultsMore slides rated excellent on the VENTANA HE 600 system
100%more stains
rated excellent
77.5% 60%
Gastric Ca Lymphoma 1
more stains
rated excellent
more stains
rated excellent
Liver
45%more stains
rated excellent
40% 30%
Lobular Ca Melanoma
more stains
rated excellent
more stains
rated excellent
Lymphoma 2
58.8%more stains rated
excellent overall
“Why should pathologists refuse to settle for good enough? Because patients deserve more than good enough! As physicians, we should strive for excellence in patient care by asking how we can make it better.”– Dr. Sandra Mueller, pathologist
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
Impressions on H&E stain quality consistencyA sampling of quotes from Dr. Mueller
The VENTANA HE 600 system Dip and dunk stainer• “This is very pretty tissue!
Consistent. Great detail. Nice H&E balance.”
• “Hematoxylin is very crisp, which highlights all the nuclear features.”
• “VERY consistent staining. Very crisp detail.”
• “This is a great stain. Beautiful contrast! Very consistent.”
• “Tissue has an edge effect…eosin is less differentiating…has a basophilic hue compromising degree of contrast.”
• “Eosin is lacking…hematoxylin lacks crispness.”
• “Eosin is inconsistent…hematoxylin has pink hue in many nuclei.”
• “Good stain…not great contrast.”
“On the VENTANA HE 600 system, eosin was more differentiating, which makes low power magnification more effective in achieving a diagnosis.”– Dr. Sandra Mueller, pathologist
Confidential and proprietary to Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. For internal use only. Do not copy. Do not distribute.
Individual slide staining improves performanceEliminates reagent carry over and other stain quality defects
“Depletion, dilution, evaporation and oxidation – all commonplace with dip and dunk methods – are completely resolved with individual slide staining on the VENTANA HE 600 system. Fewer defects means fewer distractions, decreased eye fatigue and improved diagnostic performance.”– Dr. Sandra Mueller, pathologist
www.roche.comwww.ventana.com© 2015 Ventana Medical Systems, Inc. VENTANA and VENTANA HE are trademarks of Roche.All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. 6051A 0915 RTDPCPS0025a
Doing now what patients need next