Combating Unethical Behavior in Tertiary Education
description
Transcript of Combating Unethical Behavior in Tertiary Education
Combating Unethical Behavior in Tertiary Education
Jamil Salmi
International Conference on Fighting Corruption and Promoting Good Governance
Astana, 16-18 September 2009
4
outline of the presentation
• what types of unethical behaviors?
• why and how do they impact tertiary education?
• how to combat fraud and corruption?
definitions• fraud: “intentional perversion of truth in order to induce
another to part with something of value or to surrender a legal right”
– academic fraud: improper behavior to gain an unfair advantage (admission, grades, exams, degree)
• corruption: “abuse of public or private office to gain personal advantage”, “impairment of integrity, virtue, or moral principle”
– financial realm
• “unethical behavior” used to refer broadly to all forms of improper and/or illegal actions in tertiary education
the “what”: an inventory
• categories based on educational and institutional processes
• “protagonists” identified
• examples provided from around the world
• summary matrix on p. 33 of the report
sources of information
– news reports• popular press• tertiary education publications, e.g. The Chronicle of Higher
Education
– Boston College Higher Education Corruption Monitor
– direct communications
exclusions
• criminal behavior by students and staff outside the context of institutions and their roles
• negligence and failure to adequately perform one’s duties
• violations of academic freedom
the “what”: an inventory
• admission process
• teaching and learning
• false credentials
• quality assurance
• research
• academic staff career
• financial management
corruption in the admission process
• examination fraud• bribery• favoritism• undue influence• discrimination
• protagonists are students and their families, faculty, administrators, government officials, and outside agents
dishonesty in the academic process
• cheating
• plagiarism
• students, faculty, and outside agents
awarding of false credentials
• bribery and undue influence in grading and degree conferral
• fake / unearned degrees• from legitimate institutions• from “degree mills”
• students, faculty, administrators, and outside agents
informal payments for education
Colombia
Zambia
Madag
asca
r
Paragu
ayPeru
Guatem
ala
Tajikis
tan
Bulgari
a
Mozam
bique
Namibi
a
Ghana
Nepal
India
Albania
Bangla
desh Hait
i
Sri Lan
ka
Pakist
an0
102030405060708090
100
2 6 7 7 7 8 916 16 20 24 25
34 3540
60 61
92
% of households that make informal payments
undermining of quality assurance measures
• misrepresentation• providing false data• bribery• accreditation “mills”
• institution administrators, government officials, and representatives of accrediting bodies
research misconduct
• failure to follow standards
• falsification of results
• conflicts of interest
• plagiarism / theft of ideas or work
• primary protagonists are faculty
corruption in faculty and staff career management
• bribery• undue influence• use of false credentials• discrimination• harassment
• faculty, institution administrators, government officials, and outside parties
financial fraud and mismanagement
• profiteering
• theft
• embezzlement
• financial mismanagement
• student loan fraud
• institutional administrators, government officials, and outside parties
18
outline of the presentation
• what types of unethical behaviors?
• why and how do they impact tertiary education?
why does corruption happen?economic dimensions
• high levels of corruption in tertiary education often mirror high levels of corruption in countries overall
• low teacher and administrator salaries
• supply out of sync with demand
why does corruption happen?political dimensions
• lack of oversight and accountability• managerial capacity
• political tolerance
negative impact
• contrary to basic purpose of education– ethical values– academic merit – loss of trust in system and outputs
• teachers (role models)• students (code of conduct)• institutions (reputation)
• misuse of limited resources
23
outline of the presentation
• what types of unethical behaviors?
• why and how do they impact tertiary education?
• how to combat fraud and corruption?
what can be done?
• four types of interventions:– preventative measures– measures for detecting and monitoring– punitive measures– multiple purpose measures
preventive measures
– legislation and other government policies
– institutional policies and governance arrangements• diversified, independent Board• strong leadership• honor code
– standardized / automated procedures
corruption in Kyrgyz universities
KTUKAU
NGUBGU
Bishke
k Med
ical A
cade
my
KGUSTAKRSU
MUK
KGAFKiSAUCA
0
20
40
60
80 68 67.5 64.9 62 59.6 5951 49.5
34.3
5.1
Percentage
detecting and monitoring
– computer programs and other IT instruments
– tip lines and other reporting venues
– surveys
– audits
punitive measures
– protests and violence
– legal action
– career / status sanctions
– academic / professional sanctions
multi-purpose measures
– accreditation systems
– education / awareness raising
– publicity
30
31
Fighting Corruption
Upgrade your knowledge –
Make your universities more ethical
Ian Whitman
32
the integrity imperative
• social justice (moral dimension)• trust in the meritocratic process• proper use of public resources• potential loss of talent
33
the way forward
• more documentation and closer monitoring (surveys, reporting mechanisms)
• more systematic assessment of which policies and instruments work
34
Everybody is equal.
But some are more equal than others.
George Orwell