CMS ECAL End Cap Meeting CERN 19 June to 23 June 2000 A.B.Lodge - RAL 1 ECAL End Cap High Voltage...

CMS ECAL End Cap Meeting CERN 19 June to 23 June 2000 A.B.Lodge - RAL 1

ECALEnd Cap

High Voltage Cards and 2000 Electrical/Thermal Model.

Progress on High Voltage Cards & 2000 Electrical/Thermal Model.

ECAL WEEK End Cap meeting held 19 June to 23 June

at CERN

Prepared by A.B.Lodge.


ECALEnd Cap


Status Report Structure.

• High Voltage PCB Design, Manufacture and Test.

• 2000 Electrical/Thermal Model at RAL.• Single Channel Test Box (Thermal/Electrical Tests).• 10 Channel Readout Module (RS Pre-amps).• 10 Channel Dummy Readout Module (Thermal Tests).


ECALEnd Cap


Review of High Voltage PCBs

Individual Card Assembly and Test.

• Ten New High Voltage Filter Cards have been received and assembled (using conventional components) at RAL.

• Two Low Voltage Signal Termination Cards have also been assembled.

• The combined sets of cards are enough to provide high voltage filtering for 2 Super Crystal Modules (2000 Electrical/Thermal Model).

• All of the High Voltage cards have been tested with an Anode voltage of 1KV and a Dynode voltage of 0.8 KV.


ECALEnd Cap


• High Voltage 5 Channel Filter Card.

Centre Ground Plane to close to the edge of PCB

ie. Increased risk of HV break down.

Via connecting Anode and Dynode together

ie. Needed drilling out to prevent a short.


ECALEnd Cap


• High Voltage Filter Card set for 1 Super Crystal Module (Dynode Side shown) with Signal Termination Card.


ECALEnd Cap


• High Voltage Filter Card set for 1 Super Crystal Module (Anode Side shown) with Signal Termination Card.


ECALEnd Cap


• High Voltage Filter Card set for 1 Super Crystal Module.


ECALEnd Cap


• High Voltage Filter Card set for 1 Super Crystal Module with Positional Spacer Fitted.

This shows the space available for the insertion of Monitoring Fibres.


ECALEnd Cap


2000 Electrical/Thermal Model.

It has been agreed that the design team at RAL will produce a 2000 Electrical / Thermal Model as part of its Development Programme for the ECAL End Cap design proposal during this year.

This Model will be used to carryout full Thermal and Electrical testing of the complete detector designs proposed at this time including:

• Full Mechanical/Electrical Structure of the SCM design.• Back Plate and Back Plate Cooling design proposals.• Mechanical mounting and layer structure (Monitoring System,

Moderator, Back plate Cooling, Umbilical, Low Voltage, High Voltage, Readout Electronics(RS Pre-Amps) and Cooling, etc….


ECALEnd Cap


2000 Model Structure.

• Two Full Super Crystal Module.• High Voltage Filtering System.• Positional Spacers (2 Off).• Section of Back Plate (Large enough for 4 SCMs).• Back Plate Cooling System.• Moderator.• Low & High Voltage System + Cabling.• 50 Channels of Readout Electronics (initially using RS pre-

amps) based on final design.• Readout Electronics Cooling System.• Environmental Enclosure.• Full Mechanical Support Structure base on final design.


ECALEnd Cap


2000 Model Development Programme.

Part of this development programme is to design and manufacture a 50 channel readout module. This module is to be as close as is possible (thermally and mechanically ) to the final design for the ECAL EE Readout Electronics. To achieve these goals we need to full understand:

• Full Mechanical/Electrical Structure of the 50 Channel Readout Module based on the EB design proposals.

• The full Thermal requirements and limitations of our Readout Module design.

• Is there any adverse interaction between Thermal / Mechanical and Electronics designs which will reduce system performance.

Due to the fact that the real electronics cards will not be available in the time scales required by this development programme we will be forced to use RS Pre-amps to carry out this work.


ECALEnd Cap


Single Channel Test Box containing RS single channel pre-amp.

Numbers 1 to 6 represent positions of PT100 thermal sensors.


ECALEnd Cap


Amplifier card shown with its mounting bracket. Amplifier mounted component side towards metal bracket on 4mm long spacers. Various different thermal compounds were used to transfer the heat from the amplifier card into the metal bracket.


ECALEnd Cap


The amplifier in the Single Channel Test Box was powered for approximately 1 hour to allow it to reach a stable operating temperature.

• Each of the PT100 were then measured to obtain temperature measurements.

• Both Amplifier noise and gains were measured.

These tests were repeated using a number of different thermal compounds and the results plotted.


ECALEnd Cap


0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Temp (C)

None Raychem Warth Birgquist

Graph of temperature vs thermal compound

PT 1PT 2PT 3PT 4PT 5PT 6


ECALEnd Cap


0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Temp (C)

PT 1 PT 2 PT 3 PT 4 PT 5 PT 6

Graph of temperature vs thermal compound

NoneRaychemWarthBirgquist


ECALEnd Cap


Amplifier Noise Measurements.

• The electron noise of the amplifier was measured for each type of thermal compound.

• This was done by feeding in 16mV through a 1pF capacitor, which gives 105 electrons into the amplifier I/P.

• The output pulse was then measured (OP).

• Noise of the circuit was measured with (Npowered) and without power (Nunpowered), using a calibrated true RMS voltmeter.

Noise e- =(((Npowered-Nunpowered)0.5)*105)/OP


ECALEnd Cap


0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

Noise (e-)

Graph of noise vs thermal compound



ECALEnd Cap


1250126012701280129013001310132013301340

Noise (e-)

Graph of noise vs thermal compound



ECALEnd Cap


The results of these limited test were favourable so we continued with the Design Development Programme for the 2000 Electrical / Thermal Model by designing and manufacturing the following:

• 10 Channel Readout Module.– The design is based on the present design proposal for the

ECAL EE Electronic Readout Modules.• 10 Channel Dummy Readout Module.

– This module is also based on the same design but will be used to conduct more extensive thermal analysis on the

requirements for the final EE Readout Module Design.


ECALEnd Cap


Two boards with five amplifier cards on each.


ECALEnd Cap


Another view of the boards showing the protection network.


ECALEnd Cap


Boards fixed together using tapped and threaded spacers.


ECALEnd Cap


Another view of the boards.


ECALEnd Cap


Two views of the completed 10 channel assembly.


ECALEnd Cap


144014501460147014801490150015101520153015401550

Noise(e-)

Noise figures for each channel on a 10 channel module

12345678910


ECALEnd Cap


Again the results of these preliminary tests were favourable so we intend to continue and finalise the design and manufacture of the 5 * 10 Channel Readout Modules needed for the 2000 Electrical / Thermal Model.

– To date we have five sets of readout cards at this level of manufacture.

– This includes the Mechanics for all 10 channel modules.

Work Remaining to complete the Readout Module includes:

The final design and manufacture of the 50 Channel Readout Box.

The design and manufacture of the interconnection method between the Umbilical (50 way D-Type connectors) and the Signal I/P of the 5 channel readout Cards.

Final Cooling System design and manufacture for the 50 Channel Readout Module.

Full Electrical and Thermal testing, etc…


ECALEnd Cap


• 10 Channel Readout Module (Thermal Model).

RM Side Covers.

RM Fixing Plate.

RM Base Plate.

RM Cooling Plate.

RM Cooling Pipe.


ECALEnd Cap




ECALEnd Cap


• 10 Channel Readout Module (Thermal Model): Showing the simplified support structure for the readout cards.

Thermal Gaskets Required


ECALEnd Cap


• 10 Channel Readout Module:

Showing Cooling Plate with single cooling pipe.


ECALEnd Cap



• Board 2 showing the positions of the PRT100 temperature sensors:

– Board-1-TOP

– Board-1-MID

– Board-1-BOT

– Board-1-BTOP

– Board -1 BBOT

Board-1-TOP

Board-1-BOT

Board-1-BTOP

Board-1-BBOT

Board-1-MID


ECALEnd Cap



• Board 2 showing the positions of the PRT100 temperature sensors:– Board-2-TOP– Board-2-BOT

Board-2-TOP

Board-2-BOT


ECALEnd Cap



• Complete Readout Module with all Covers and Cooling Plates showing the positions of the PRT100 temperature sensors:

– Cover-1-TOP

– Plate-1-TOP

– Plate-2-BOT

Plate-1-TOP

Plate-2-BOT

Cover-1-TOP


ECALEnd Cap


Dummy Readout Card Structure and Measurement.

• Each card contained 25 Surface Mount resistor packs to represent the real Readout Electronics.

• Each resistor pack had 7 * 470ohm resistors connected in parallel (~ 67ohms).

• All Resistor packs on each card were again connected in parallel resulting in a total resistive load for the 10 Channel Module of ~ 1.34 ohms.

– By varying the supply voltage to the module we could set the module power dissipation.

• Simple PT100 temperature sensors were used to measure the relative changes in temperature during testing.

Temp ‘C = (((Rmeas. - Rlimit) - Rlead) - 100/ temp Coef. 0.385 ohms per ‘C)+/- 0.1

Note - Rlimit = 0 and Rlead = 0.423 ohms.


ECALEnd Cap


T1 - Temperature on an IC at the top of the Dummy Readout Cards.

T2 - Temperature in the Bell Jar.

T3 - Ambient Temperature of the surroundings.

10 Channel Supply Voltage = 4.153 Volts.

Current = 3.06 Amps.

Rload = 1.36 ohms.

Module Power ~ 12.71Watts.

Temperature No Power:

T1 ~ 23.2 ‘C

T2 ~ 23.2 ‘C

T3 ~ 23.1 ‘C

After 1 hours: T1~75.1’C

T2~35.5’C, T3~23.2’C.


T2~37.9’C, T3~23.3’C.


T2~38.8’C, T3~23.6’C.

10 Channel RM (No covers).

Glass Bell Jar.


ECALEnd Cap


TEST-1Temp-sensor No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5

108.85 116.19 123.8 123.78 123.86 124.35Board-1-TOP(Degrees C). 21.9 40.9 60.7 60.6 60.9 62.1 40.3

108.75 115.94 124.05 124.18 124.19 124.3Board-1-MID(Degrees C). 21.6 40.3 61.3 61.7 61.7 62.0 40.4

108.75 114.15 118.05 118.1 118.14 118.53Board-1-BOT(Degrees C). 21.6 35.6 45.8 45.9 46.0 47.0 25.4

108.79 112.05 119.32 119.54 119.62 119.59Board-1-BTOP(Degrees C). 21.7 30.2 49.1 49.6 49.8 49.8 28.1

108.67 110.1 112.44 112.3 112.54 112.6Board-1-BBOT(Degrees C). 21.4 25.1 31.2 30.8 31.4 31.6 10.2

108.77 117.76 123.83 124 124.06 124.51Board-2-TOP(Degrees C). 21.7 45.0 60.8 61.2 61.4 62.5 40.9

108.73 114.92 117.87 118.18 117.89 118.16Board-2-BOT (Degrees C). 21.6 37.6 45.3 46.1 45.3 46.0 24.5Cover-1-TOP

Plate-1-TOP

Plate-2-BOT

Ambient Temp(Degrees C). 21.5 21.6 21.9 22.1 22.1 22.4Supply Voltage (Volts). 4.31 4.31 4.33 4.33 4.35Supply Current (Amps). 3.16 3.18 3.19 3.19 3.21Module Power (Watts). 13.6196 13.7058 13.8127 13.8127 13.9635


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Test1 of ECAL EE Dummy Readout Module (NO COVERS FITTED).

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0

No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5

Time Interval between Samples.

Deg

rees

Cel

siu

s

Board-1-TOP(Degrees C).

Board-1-MID(Degrees C).

Board-1-BOT(Degrees C).

Board-1-BTOP(Degrees C).

Board-1-BBOT(Degrees C).

Board-2-TOP(Degrees C).

Board-2-BOT (Degrees C).


ECALEnd Cap



109.26 113.8 121.21 121.5 121.4 121.47Board-1-TOP(Degrees C) 22.9 34.7 54.0 54.7 54.5 54.6 31.7

109.27 115.31 124.18 124.24 124.32 124.33Board-1-MID(Degrees C) 23.0 38.6 61.7 61.8 62.0 62.1 39.1

109.53 114.3 120.26 120.44 120.5 120.5Board-1-BOT(Degrees C) 23.6 36.0 51.5 52.0 52.1 52.1 28.5

109.22 110.84 114.06 114.22 114.14 114.37Board-1-BTOP(Degrees C) 22.8 27.0 35.4 35.8 35.6 36.2 13.4

109.23 111.74 118.3 118.36 118.47 118.31Board-1-BBOT(Degrees C) 22.9 29.4 46.4 46.6 46.9 46.4 23.6

109.22 117.12 121.03 121.07 121.15 121.4Board-2-TOP(Degrees C) 22.8 43.3 53.5 53.6 53.8 54.5 31.6

109.29 116.54 120.3 120.4 120.44 120.56Board-2-BOT(Degrees C) 23.0 41.8 51.6 51.9 52.0 52.3 29.3Cover-1-TOP

Plate-1-TOP

Plate-2-BOT

Ambient Temp 'c 22.4 22.4 22.7 22.7 22.8 22.6Supply Voltage (Volts) 4.27 4.31 4.32 4.33 4.32Supply Current (Amps) 3.16 3.17 3.18 3.19 3.18Module Power (Watts). 13.4932 13.6627 13.7376 13.8127 13.7376


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Test2 of ECAL EE Dummy Readout Module (NO COVERS FITTED - UPSIDEDOWN).

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0



Deg

rees

Cel

siu

s.

Board-1-TOP

Board-1-MID

Board-1-BOT

Board-1-BTOP

Board-1-BBOT

Board-2-TOP

Board-2-BOT


ECALEnd Cap



109.38 111.55 118.6 121.83 122.94 123.4Board-1-TOP 23.2 28.9 47.2 55.6 58.5 59.7

109.35 112.13 119 122.12 123.21 123.68Board-1-MID 23.2 30.4 48.2 56.3 59.2 60.4

109.4 112.14 116.35 119.13 120.09 120.58Board-1-BOT 23.3 30.4 41.3 48.6 51.1 52.3

109.36 110.48 117.51 120.68 121.76 122.31Board-1-BTOP 23.2 26.1 44.4 52.6 55.4 56.8

109.28 110.02 115.16 118.2 119.35 119.66Board-1-BBOT 23.0 24.9 38.3 46.2 49.1 49.9

109.3 112.6 118.96 121.91 122.98 123.32Board-2-TOP 23.0 31.6 48.1 55.8 58.6 59.4

109.26 111.8 116.35 118.95 119.89 120.26Board-2-BOT 22.9 29.5 41.3 48.1 50.5 51.5

109.92 111.44 116.63 119.33 120.31 120.69Cover-1-TOP 24.6 28.6 42.1 49.1 51.6 52.6

109.32 109.82 113.9 116.56 117.55 117.92Plate-1-TOP 23.1 24.4 35.0 41.9 44.5 45.4

109.37 109.82 113.89 116.52 117.49 117.86Plate-2-BOT 23.2 24.4 35.0 41.8 44.3 45.3Ambient Temp 21.5 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.5 22.3Supply Voltage 4.16 4.24 4.26 4.24 4.27Supply Current 3.07 3.12 3.14 3.13 3.14Module Power (Watts). 12.7712 13.2288 13.3764 13.2712 13.4078


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Test3 of ECAL EE Dummy Readout Module (Covers Fitted, No Cooling).

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0


Time Interval Betwen Samples.

Deg

rees

Cel

siu

s.

Board-1-TOP

Board-1-MID

Board-1-BOT

Board-1-BTOP

Board-1-BBOT

Board-2-TOP

Board-2-BOT

Cover-1-TOP

Plate-1-TOP

Plate-2-BOT


ECALEnd Cap


TEST-4Temp-sensor No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5 Time-6

107.34 109.9 116.7 117.55 117.64 117.55 117.54Board-1-TOP 17.9 24.6 42.3 44.5 44.7 44.5 44.4

107.05 110.46 116.68 117.37 117.4 117.3 117.29Board-1-MID 17.2 26.0 42.2 44.0 44.1 43.8 43.8

107.02 109.53 113.21 113.61 113.63 113.55 113.55Board-1-BOT 17.1 23.6 33.2 34.2 34.3 34.1 34.1

107.36 108.85 115.8 116.68 116.76 116.68 116.69Board-1-BTOP 18.0 21.9 39.9 42.2 42.4 42.2 42.2

106.81 107.92 111.7 112.09 112.13 112.07 112.07Board-1-BBOT 16.6 19.4 29.3 30.3 30.4 30.2 30.2

107.3 111.2 116.88 117.51 117.55 117.45 117.45Board-2-TOP 17.8 28.0 42.7 44.4 44.5 44.2 44.2

106.92 109.9 112.84 113.15 113.17 113.08 113.1Board-2-BOT 16.9 24.6 32.2 33.0 33.1 32.9 32.9

107.29 109.56 114.19 114.71 114.75 114.66 114.67Cover-1-TOP 17.8 23.7 35.7 37.1 37.2 37.0 37.0

107.29 107.3 107.93 108.05 108.03 107.99 108Plate-1-TOP 17.8 17.8 19.5 19.8 19.7 19.6 19.7

106.5 106.89 107.54 107.63 107.6 107.56 107.59Plate-2-BOT 15.8 16.8 18.5 18.7 18.6 18.5 18.6Water in 'C 14.7 14.7 14.7 14.7 14.7 14.5 14.6Water Out 'C 14.9 14.8 15 15 15 14.9 14.9Ambient Temp 21.5 21.6 21.6 21.8 21.8 21.9 22Supply Voltage 4.18 4.29 4.26 4.25 4.25 4.22Supply Current 3.07 3.15 3.13 3.13 3.13 3.1


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Test4 of ECAL EE Dummy Readout Module (Covers Fitted, Water Cooling @ 3l/min.).

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

30.0

35.0

40.0

45.0

50.0

No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5 Time-6


Deg

rees

Cel

ciu

s.

Board-1-TOP

Board-1-MID

Board-1-BOT

Board-1-BTOP

Board-1-BBOT

Board-2-TOP

Board-2-BOT

Cover-1-TOP

Plate-1-TOP

Plate-2-BOT

Water in 'C

Water Out 'C


ECALEnd Cap


Sheet 5Temp-sensor No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5Board-1-TOP 21.9 40.9 60.7 60.6 60.9 62.1Board-1-MID 21.6 40.3 61.3 61.7 61.7 62.0Board-1-BOT 21.6 35.6 45.8 45.9 46.0 47.0Board-1-TOP(UD) 22.9 34.7 54.0 54.7 54.5 54.6Board-1-MID(UD) 23.0 38.6 61.7 61.8 62.0 62.1Board-1-BOT(UD) 23.6 36.0 51.5 52.0 52.1 52.1


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Testing of ECAL EE Dummy Board (Effect of LV Supply Cables?).

20.0

25.0

30.0

35.0

40.0

45.0

50.0

55.0

60.0

65.0



Deg

rees

Cel

siu

s.

Board-1-TOP

Board-1-MID

Board-1-BOT

Board-1-TOP(UD)

Board-1-MID(UD)

Board-1-BOT(UD)


ECALEnd Cap


Sheet 6Temp-sensor No-Power Time-1 Time-2 Time-3 Time-4 Time-5 Temp-changeBoard-1-TOP(NC) 23.2 28.9 47.2 55.6 58.5 59.7 36.4Board-1-MID(NC) 23.2 30.4 48.2 56.3 59.2 60.4 37.2Board-1-BOT(NC) 23.3 30.4 41.3 48.6 51.1 52.3 29.0Board-1-TOP(WC) 17.9 24.6 42.3 44.5 44.7 44.5 26.5Board-1-MID(WC) 17.2 26.0 42.2 44.0 44.1 43.8 26.6Board-1-BOT(WC) 17.1 23.6 33.2 34.2 34.3 34.1 17.0


ECALEnd Cap


Thermal Testing of ECAL EE Dummy Readout Module (With and Without Cooling).

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0



Deg

rees

Cel

siu

s.

Board-1-TOP(NC)

Board-1-MID(NC)

Board-1-BOT(NC)

Board-1-TOP(WC)

Board-1-MID(WC)

Board-1-BOT(WC)


ECALEnd Cap


Cost of Thermal Compounds:

The cost of (small quantity) Thermal Foams and Gaskets vary considerable depending on type, manufacturer and required thickness etc….

Ie. From ~ 5.5 CHF/Channel to 24 CHF/Channel therefore the cost could be:

EB @ 61,000 Channels - ~335,500 CHF to ~1,464,000 CHF.

EE @ 16,000 Channels - ~88,000 CHF to ~ 384,000 CHF.Note - Just for the thermal compound between IC’s and module covers.

Even if we can reduce the price by 1/2 for large quantities this still seems to be a large amount money?

CMS ECAL End Cap Meeting CERN 19 June to 23 June 2000 A.B.Lodge - RAL 1 ECAL End Cap High Voltage...

Documents

Transcript of CMS ECAL End Cap Meeting CERN 19 June to 23 June 2000 A.B.Lodge - RAL 1 ECAL End Cap High Voltage...