What’s the evidence for Climate Change? Aim: To find out what evidence there is for climate change.
Climate Change: Evidence and Implication€¦ · Climate Change: Evidence and Implication Thursday,...
Transcript of Climate Change: Evidence and Implication€¦ · Climate Change: Evidence and Implication Thursday,...
Climate Change: Evidence and Implication Thursday, July 25, 2013, 9:20 a.m.
Dr. Mark Seeley Faculty Member University of Minnesota St. Paul, Minn. Mark Seeley joined the faculty of the University of Minnesota in 1978. He has served as an extension climatologist and meteorologist working closely with the National Weather Service, the Minnesota State Climatology Office, and various state agencies. Since 1992, Mark has been a weekly commentator on Minnesota Public Radio's "Morning Edition" news program and helped Minnesota Public Television produce award-winning documentaries about historical weather events. Seeley is the author of Minnesota Weather Almanac, published by the Minnesota Historical Society Press in 2006. In 2011, he co-authored “Voyageur Skies: Weather and the Wilderness in Minnesota’s National Park” with photographer Don Breneman. His honors include the Sigma Xi Scientific Communication and Education Award in 2001 and 2008, the Extension Dean and Director’s Award for Distinguished Extension Faculty in 2006, the University of Minnesota President’s Award for Outstanding Service in 2012. Session Description: The analysis of data from a number of regional climate networks (some of which go back to the 19th Century) shows some significant change in the climate behavior. There have not only been changes in central tendencies and extremes, but also in pattern and character. These changes have not been without consequences. This session will examine statistical measures of temperature, water vapor, and precipitation to illustrate these changing quantities and patterns, and then link these changes to observed and documented consequences.
Top Three Session Ideas Tools or tips you learned from this session and can apply back at the office.
1. ______________________________________________________________________
2. _______________________________________________________________________
3. ________________________________________________________________________
Climate Change: Evidence and Implication Session Outline
Overview 2012 Climate Headlines
• Year-to-Date Temperature Anomalies for Contiguous U.S. • January-December 2012 Statewide Ranks • 2012 Drought Specific Disaster Declarations by County-Most Ever • Billion Dollar Weather/Climate Disasters
Recent Significant Climate Trends in the Western Great Lakes
• Seasonality in Temperature Change • Warm Nights are Increasing • Minnesota State-Averaged Mean Annual Temperature • Seasonal Temperature Trends in MN • Frequency of Temperatures -30 Degrees F and Colder at Pokegama Dam, MN • Historical Ranking and Distribution of Statewide Mean Daily Temperature Over the Past
15 heating Seasons • Trends in Mean Monthly Temperatures at Austin, MN • Trends in Mean Monthly Temperatures at Willmar • Amplified Trends in Average Winter Minimum Temperatures International Falls, MN • Trend in Dewpoints of 70 F or Higher in the Twin Cities • Minnesota Statewide May Through September Mean Temperature - Ranking of the Past
19 Air Conditioning Seasons • Frequencies of July Tropical Dew Points (70 F or Higher) and Associated Heat Index
Values for the Twin Cities Since 1945 Historical Perceptions
• Historical Minnesota Heat Waves • Minnesota State-Averaged Annual Precipitation • Change in Annual Precipitation Normals at Willmar, MN • Change in Annual Precipitation Normals at Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN • Change in Annual Precipitation Normals at Brainerd, MN • Measurable Attributes of Precipitation • Percentage Change in Very Heavy Precipitation • Historical Recurrence Interval of 2 Inch Rains in Northern IA and Southern MN Once
Per Year • NOAA Atlas 14 - Precipitation Frequency Estimates • June 2012 – Excessive Rainfall • St. Louis River at Scanlon, MN
Changing Minnesota Climate Features • Shift in Precipitation Recurrence Intervals? • Wright Flood – July 17-19, 1867 • Historic Droughts • Climate Singularity • Number of MN Counties Designated for Federal Disaster Assistance in 2012 • Can Natural Variability Explain Recent Tropopause Height Changes? • 2010 Minnesota Tornadoes
Climate Consequences
• Some Consequences of Climate Change • Cloud Variations
Scales of Extremes Q & A
Climate Change:Evidence and Implication
Dr. Mark SeeleyDept of Soil, Water, and Climate
University of MinnesotaSt Paul, MN 55108
National Association of Mutual Insurance CompaniesAgricultural Risk Inspection School
July 23-25, 2013Bloomington, MN
TOPICS2012 Climate Headlines
Historical Perceptions
Changing Minnesota Climate Features
Climate Consequences
Scales of Extremes
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 1 of 21
Stationary (1)
Cyclical (2)
Variability (3)
Trend Shift (4)
Changnon et el
Perceptions of climate behavior are built into the design of our
infrastructure (1,3)
Climate Science Fundamentals
Three Reasons to Accept That Climate Change is Real
• Measured attributes of the Earth climate system are changing (temp, precip, cloud)-3 data sets
• Models mimic measured climate changes more accurately with parameterized human disturbance (land use, emissions) included
• Observed and measured physical and biological consequences fit with the measured climatic changes
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 2 of 21
www.cloudappreciationsociety.org
For those who doubt or wish to dismiss the evidence that climate is changing in Minnesota….the data indicate it is happening and already producing
consequences. It is clearly poor judgment to ignore this!
Rabbits in the sky A Poodle in the sky
Snail in the skyPig in the sky
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 3 of 21
2012 Drought specific disaster declarations by county-most everRecord number of counties, and record subscription to Federal Crop Insurance
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 4 of 21
Vulnerability and Consequences Remain Key Societal Issues
Implications for land use, building codes, insurance, and infrastructure
Nearly $1.0 trillion in losses from the past 32 years (current dollars)
RECENT SIGNIFICANT CLIMATE TRENDS IN THE WESTERN GREAT LAKES
•TEMPERATURE: WARMER WITH SEASONALITY AND DIURNAL CYCLES SHIFTS
•DEWPOINTS: SHIFTS IN FREQUENCY OF TROPICAL-LIKE ATMOSPHERIC WATER VAPOR
•MOISTURE: AMPLIFIED PRECIPITATION SIGNAL (VARIABILITY), THUNDERSTORM CONTRIBUTION
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 5 of 21
Figure 3.10Seasonality in temperature change
Warming is weighted towards minimum temperature change
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 6 of 21
Temp trend is upward and more frequently above the 90th
percentile
Seasonal Temperature Trends in MN
Winter (D,J,F) Spring (M,A,M)
Summer (J,J,A) Fall (S,O,N)
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 7 of 21
Frequency of temperatures -30 degrees F and colder at Pokegama Dam, MN
1887-1936 average 10 nights per year1937-2012 average 3 nights per year
Last two decades less than 1 night per year
Historical ranking and distribution of statewide mean daily temperature over the past 15 heating seasons (Nov-Mar) in MN: 1=warmestWinter Mean Temp (F) Ranking (since 1895)
1997-1998 24.2 6th
1998-1999 23.0 9th
1999-2000 26.0 2nd
2000-2001 15.8 80th
2001-2002 25.0 3rd
2002-2003 19.3 42nd
2003-2004 20.3 29th
2004-2005 21.2 21th
2005-2006 23.2 7th
2006-2007 22.3 12th
2007-2008 16.9 64th
2008-2009 16.4 73rd
2009-2010 21.5 18th
2010-2011 17.1 62nd
2011-2012 27.8 1st
2012-2013 18.6 39th
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 8 of 21
Trends in mean monthly temperatures at Austin, MN 1971-2000 normals vs 1981-2010 normals (F)
Month Min Change Max Change Mean ChangeJanuary +3.0 +2.1 +2.5February +0.1 +0.2 +0.1March -0.1 -0.1 -0.2April +1.3 +0.2 +0.7May +0.9 -0.8 +0.1 June +1.6 -0.4 +0.5July +1.1 +0.2 +0.7August +1.6 +0.4 +1.0September +1.3 +0.6 +1.0October +1.7 -0.3 +0.7November +2.1 +1.7 +1.9December +2.2 +1.4 +1.8
Trends in mean monthly temperatures at Willmar 1971‐2000 normals vs 1981‐2010 normals (F)
Month Min Change Max Change Mean ChangeJanuary +3.4 +1.5 +2.9February +0.8 +0.9 +0.8March +0.9 +1.2 +1.0April +0.7 +1.5 +1.1May +0.1 -0.1 NC June +0.5 +0.2 +0.3July +0.7 +0.5 +0.6August +0.4 +0.7 +0.5September +0.9 +1.0 +0.9October +0.5 +0.5 +0.5November +1.3 +2.3 +1.7December +2.1 +1.7 +1.8
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 9 of 21
Amplified trends in average winter minimum temperatures International Falls, MN
Period of Record1951 - 19801961 - 19901971 - 20001981 - 20101951 - 19801961 - 19901971 - 20001981 - 20101951 - 19801961 - 19901971 – 20001981 - 2010
Ave Min Temp in Deg. FJan -11.0Jan -8.4Jan -8.3Jan -6.6Feb -4.8Feb -0.7Feb -0.6Feb -1.3Mar 8.9Mar 12.3Mar 12.6Mar 12.5
Trend in dewpoints of 70 F or higher in the Twin Cities
Hours with dewpoints of 70 degrees F or higher at Voyageurs National Park
Latitude 45 degrees
Latitude 48.5 degrees
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 10 of 21
Minnesota Statewide May Through September Mean Temperature Ranking of the past 19 Air Conditioning Seasons (1994-2012)
1=warmestYear Percentile Rank since 1895 (mean temp)
1994 48 (62.8 F)1995 * 36 (63.3 F)1996 * 75 (61.9 F)1997 67 (62.1 F)1998 6 (64.8 F)1999 * 36 (63.3 F)2000 64 (62.3 F)2001 * 22 (63.8 F)2002 * 36 (63.3 F)2003 * 42 (63.1 F)2004 105 (60.3 F)2005 * 30 (63.6 F)2006 * 19 (63.9 F)2007 * 10 (64.6 F)2008 84 (61.7 F)2009 89 (61.4 F)2010 * 31 (63.5 F)2011 * 39 (63.2 F)2012 * 6 (64.8F)
* Indicates dewpoints of 80 F or higher, +preliminary data
Frequencies of July tropical dew points (70 F or higher) and associated Heat Index values for the Twin Cities since 1945
Year Hours with DP of Range of Heat70 F or greater Index Values (F)
1949 223 98 - 1121987 223 98 - 1041955 206 98 - 1131999 192 98 – 115 (116*)1957 192 99 – 1142001 182 98 - 1101977 160 100 - 1081983 157 102 - 1101995 110 98 - 1162002 305 98 – 1092004 108 98 - 1052011 243 98 – 118 (*134)2012 186 99 - 117
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 11 of 21
1883, 1894, 1901, 1910, 1917, 1921, 1931, 1933, 1934, 1936, 1937, 1947, 1948, 1949, 1955, 1957, 1959, 1964, 1976, 1977, 1983, 1988, 1995,1999, 2001, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2010, 2011,
2012(pattern is episodic but increasing in frequency)
Historical Minnesota Heat Waves:
Red denotes dewpoint driven
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 12 of 21
Change in Annual PrecipitationNormals at Willmar, MN
PERIOD AMOUNT (IN.)
1921-1950 23.01”1931-1960 24.47”1941-1970 27.63”1951-1980 27.71”1961-1990 28.21”1971-2000 28.23”1981-2010 29.46”
28 percent increase since 1921-1950 period
Change in Annual Precipitation“Normals” for Minneapolis/St Paul, MN
PERIOD AMOUNT (IN.)1941-1970 25.93”1951-1980 26.36”1961-1990 28.36”1971-2000 29.40”1981-2010 31.16”
20 percent increase since1941-1970 period
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 13 of 21
Change in Annual Precipitation“Normals” at Brainerd, MN
PERIOD AMOUNT (IN.)
1921-1950 23.03”1931-1960 24.68”1941-1970 25.59”1951-1980 26.02”1961-1990 26.40”1971-2000 27.55”1981-2010 28.38”
23 percent increase since 1921-1950 period
Quantity
Type (liquid,frozen)
Intensity (9-15”)
Frequency (74-145 days)
Duration (10 days)
Seasonality (shifting)
Landscape relationship
(interception, absorption, runoff, evaporation)
Measurable Attributes of Precipitation
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 14 of 21
Historical recurrence interval of 2 inch rains in northern IA and southern MN is once per year.
Observed 2 inch rainfalls for the period 1991 – 2012 and maximum single day value for various communities:Location No. 2 in. rains Maximum Value (date)Rosemount 42 5.80 (7/23/1987)Albert Lea 39 7.50 (6/15/1978)Waseca 43 5.63 (9/23/2010)Winona 35 4.95 (8/19/2007)Zumbrota 43 6.46 (6/27/1998)Winnebago 41 8.64 (9/25/2005)Bricelyn 39 9.22 (9/14/2004)Amboy 36 9.48 (9/23/2010)Hokah 33 15.10 (8/19/2007)
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 15 of 21
Access to NOAA-Atlas 14
http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/climate/noaa_atlas_14.html
June 14, 2012nearly 9 inches of
rainfall at Cannon Falls.
June 19-20, 20127-10 inches of rainfall in
parts of Carlton, St Louis, and Lake Counties
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 16 of 21
St Louis River at Scanlon, MN90 fold difference in 5 months
Nov, 2012
Jun, 2012
Shift in Precipitation Recurrence Intervals?
(Three “1000 year events since 2004)
New NOAA Atlas 14 due out in March 2013
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 17 of 21
Wright Flood
July 17-19, 1867
All-time greatest MN flash flood with 30-36 inches of rainfall
Chippewa River 4 miles wide
Mississippi River rose by 12 ft in 24 hours
All log booms on the Mississippi were flushed (35 million logs)
1829, 1852, 1856
1863-1864, 1871-1872
1894, 1896, 1900,
1910, 1918, 1921-1923
1926, 1929-1934,
1936-1939, 1948,
1954-1956, 1961,
1976, 1980, 1984,
1987, 1988, 1997, 2006,2007, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012
Historic Droughts(Associated fires)
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 18 of 21
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
XX
X
X
X
X
X
X
XX
X
X
X
XXX
X
X = 24 counties included in USDA drought disaster declaration of August 7, 2007
Note: adjacent 32 counties were also eligible for assistance
X= Counties included in federal flood disaster declaration of August 20, 2007 and eligible for FEMA assistance
Climate Singularity
MN Counties designated for federal disaster
assistance in 2012
All are associated with drought
except those with
Which designates for flood or severe
storm
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 19 of 21
Can natural variability explain recent tropopause height changes?
Increase in mixing depth as the atmosphere warms
48 on June 17, 2010
First ever EF‐5 Tornado in Canada, (Elie, Manitoba) June 22, 2007
First 4 inch thunderstorm rainfallChurchill, Manitoba, Aug 24, 2010
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 20 of 21
Some Consequences of Climate Change
Longer growing seasons-change in plant hardiness zonesShorter duration of soil and lake freezingLater fall nitrogen applications (soil temp too high)Change in over winter survival rates of biological organismsChange in fisheries management (stocking, fishing opener, etc)Opportunities for invasive species (insects, pathogens, etc.)Increased number of freeze/thaw cycles (damaged roads)Longer mold and allergen season (health care)Amplified moisture variability-impacts on tile drainage, irrigation, surface and ground water systems-growing list of impaired watersMore heat advisories and heat warnings (health care/livestock)Increased risk of soil erosionWork on flood mitigation and storm sewer runoffGrowing list of impaired waters
Looking for cloud nine
Kissing clouds
Mouse cloud
Donut cloud
Michelin Man cloud Duck cloud
Images courtesy of the Cloud Appreciation Society
2013 NAMIC Agricultural Risk Inspection School - Seeley Page 21 of 21
Recommended resources:
Emanuel, Kerry, Layzer, Judith, and William Moomaw. 2007. What
We Know About Climate Change. By Boston Review Books.
Henson, Robert. 2006. The Rough Guide to Climate Change. 2nd
Edition. Published by Rough Guides, 320 pp.
My web sites:
www.climate.umn.edu
www.climate.umn.edu/seeley