Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015
3
7/23/2019 Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015 http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/civil-society-security-expert-letter-opposing-csa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• :'%&1*,4" .1@63(,"+ %1 +,-(,;,.3(%02 "563() @1(,%1*,(- 1; %&",* '+"*+O 1(0,(" 3.%,/,%,"+# 3() 6"*@,% +&3*,(- 1; /3-'"02 )";,(") P.29"* %&*"3% ,(),.3%1*+Q 7,%&1'% 3)"R'3%" 6*,/3.2 6*1%".%,1(+ 6*,1* %1 +&3*,(-M F D<:5 #0?B9 &"5?B; :3 ;<" ?33"#"55.&A 5#&?;:3A 01 :330#"3; >3;"&3"; ?5"&5N 03B:3" .#;:@:;:"5* .39 ;<" 5<.&:34 01 ;<":& 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03* .5 E"BB .5 :310&$.;:03 .%0?; ;<.; >3;"&3"; ?5"* :3#B?9:34 #03;"3; 01 ;<":& 03B:3" #0$$?3:#.;:035L =80350&5 01 ;<" %:BB E.;"&"9 90E3 ;<" &"P?:&"$"3; 10& #0$8.3:"5 ;0 &"$0@" 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03 1&0$ ;<" 5;.39.&95 ;<.; E"&" :3#B?9"9 :3 ;<" Q0?5"R8.55"9 %:BB5L D<" #?&&"3; %:BB :3#B?9"5 . 5;.39.&9 ;<.; E0?B9 .BB0E #0$8.3:"5 ;0 9"1.?B; ;0 5<.&:34 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03 30; 3"#"55.&A ;0 9"5#&:%" . #A%"& ;<&".;* &.;<"& ;<.3 &"$0@:34 :;* .39 &"P?:&"5 03BA ;<.; #0$8.3:"5 "34.4" :3 . #?&50&A &"@:"E 01 :39:#.;0&5 ;0 :9"3;:1A 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03L D<:5 E".J 8&0;"#;:03 805"5 . ;<&".; ;0 8&:@.#A* .5 E"BB .5 ;0 9.;. 5"#?&:;A* .5 <.#J"&5 .39 3.;:03R 5;.;" .#;0&5 01;"3 5""J 0?; .39 5;".B 8"&503.BBA :9"3;:1:.%B" :310&$.;:03 E<"3 ;<"A %&".#< #0$8.3A .39 40@"&3$"3; 3";E0&J5L •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`L=L2L --+G%HHL a 2?&&"3; B.E .B&".9A 8"&$:;5 #0$8.3:"5 ;0 $03:;0& ;<":& 3";E0&J5 ;0 8&0;"#; ;<":& 0E3 &:4<;5 .39 8&08"&;A .39 %:BB 8&0803"3;5 <.@" 30; "_8B.:3"9 E<A @.5; 3"E $03:;0&:34 .?;<0&:;A :5 3""9"9L D<" %:BB 40"5 1.& %"A039 4&.3;:34 .?;<0&:;A ;0 $03:;0& 10& [email protected]#"9 8"&5:5;"3; ;<&".;5 ;<.; #0?B9 805" . &:5J ;0 58"#:1:# :310&$.;:03 5A5;"$5 01 ;<:&9 8.&;:"5L
-
Upload
defending-rights-dissent -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015
7/23/2019 Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/civil-society-security-expert-letter-opposing-csa-2015 1/3
"
!"#"$%"& ()* +,(-
!".& /"$%"& 01 2034&"556
!"# %&" '()"*+,-(") .,/,0 +1.,"%2 1*-3(,43%,1(+ 3() +".'*,%2 "56"*%+ 7*,%" %1 '*-" 1661+,%,1( %1 %&"
829"*+".'*,%2 :.% 1; <=>?# ;1*@"*02 .300") %&" 829"*+".'*,%2 A(;1*@3%,1( B&3*,(- :.% C8AB:# BD E?FG># ,; ,% .1@"+
%1 %&" H1'+" ;011* ;1* 3 /1%"D !" +%*1(-02 1661+" ,%+ ,(.0'+,1( ,( I,/,+,1( J 1; %&" 1@(,9'+ ;'(),(- 63.K3-"DL&,+ 9,00 +"*,1'+02 %&*"3%"(+ 6*,/3.2# .,/,0 0,9"*%,"+# 3() -1/"*(@"(% 3..1'(%39,0,%2# 3() 71'0) '()"*@,("
.29"*+".'*,%2# *3%&"* %&3( "(&3(." ,%D :+ +'.&# ,% +&1'0) 9" )"93%") 6'*+'3(% %1 *"-'03* 6*1."++# 3() @"@9"*+
+&1'0) &3/" %&" 1661*%'(,%2 %1 *".1*) %&",* /1%"+ 1( %&,+ &,-&02 .1(%*1/"*+,30 9,00D
75 8.55"9 :3 ;<" ="3.;"* 2>=7 &.:5"9 5?#< 5"&:0?5 8&:@.#A .39 5"#?&:;A #03#"&35 ;<.; ;&.9" .550#:.;:035 :3#B?9:34
;<" C=7 D<" =01;E.&" 7BB:.3#"* ;<" 20$8?;"& F 20$$?3:#.;:035 >39?5;&A 7550#:.;:03 G22>7H* .39 $.I0&
;"#<30B04A #0$8.3:"5 B:J" 788B" .39 =.B"5K0&#"* .5 E"BB .5 $.3A 0;<"&5* @0#.BBA 08805"9 ;<" B"4:5B.;:03L+ D<"
2A%"&5"#?&:;A 7#; 01 +,(- :5 . &"3.$"9 @"&5:03 01 2>=7 ;<.; 1.:B5 ;0 .99&"55 #0&" 8&:@.#A #03#"&35* E<:B" E".J"3:34
;<" $.&4:3.B 8&:@.#A 8&0;"#;:035 ;<.; E"&" 8&"@:0?5BA :3#B?9"9 :3 ;<" %:BBL
D<:5 3"E %:BB E0?B9 5:43:1:#.3;BA :3#&".5" ;<" M.;:03.B ="#?&:;A 74"3#AN5 GM=7H .39 ;<" K"9"&.B C?&".? 01
>3@"5;:4.;:03N5 GKC>H .##"55 ;0 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03* .39 .?;<0&:O" ;<" 1"9"&.B 40@"&3$"3; ;0 ?5" ;<.; :310&$.;:03
10& . $A&:.9 01 8?&805"5 ?3&"B.;"9 ;0 #A%"&5"#?&:;AL >; .B50 1.:B5 ;0 8&0@:9" 5;&034 8&:@.#A 8&0;"#;:035 0& .9"P?.;"
#B.&:;A .%0?; E<.; .#;:035 #.3 %" ;.J"3* E<.; :310&$.;:03 #.3 %" 5<.&"9* .39 <0E ;<.; :310&$.;:03 $.A %" ?5"9
%A ;<" 40@"&3$"3;L
!" +%*1(-02 1661+" %&,+ ,(;1*@3%,1( +&3*,(- 9,00 9".3'+" ,% 71'0)MN
• :'%&1*,4" .1@63(,"+ %1 +,-(,;,.3(%02 "563() @1(,%1*,(- 1; %&",* '+"*+O 1(0,(" 3.%,/,%,"+# 3() 6"*@,% +&3*,(- 1;
/3-'"02 )";,(") P.29"* %&*"3% ,(),.3%1*+Q 7,%&1'% 3)"R'3%" 6*,/3.2 6*1%".%,1(+ 6*,1* %1 +&3*,(-MF D<:5 #0?B9
&"5?B; :3 ;<" ?33"#"55.&A 5#&?;:3A 01 :330#"3; >3;"&3"; ?5"&5N 03B:3" .#;:@:;:"5* .39 ;<" 5<.&:34 01 ;<":& 8"&503.B
:310&$.;:03* .5 E"BB .5 :310&$.;:03 .%0?; ;<.; >3;"&3"; ?5"* :3#B?9:34 #03;"3; 01 ;<":& 03B:3" #0$$?3:#.;:035L
=80350&5 01 ;<" %:BB E.;"&"9 90E3 ;<" &"P?:&"$"3; 10& #0$8.3:"5 ;0 &"$0@" 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03 1&0$ ;<"
5;.39.&95 ;<.; E"&" :3#B?9"9 :3 ;<" Q0?5"R8.55"9 %:BB5L D<" #?&&"3; %:BB :3#B?9"5 . 5;.39.&9 ;<.; E0?B9 .BB0E
#0$8.3:"5 ;0 9"1.?B; ;0 5<.&:34 8"&503.B :310&$.;:03 30; 3"#"55.&A ;0 9"5#&:%" . #A%"& ;<&".;* &.;<"& ;<.3&"$0@:34 :;* .39 &"P?:&"5 03BA ;<.; #0$8.3:"5 "34.4" :3 . #?&50&A &"@:"E 01 :39:#.;0&5 ;0 :9"3;:1A 8"&503.B
:310&$.;:03L D<:5 E".J 8&0;"#;:03 805"5 . ;<&".; ;0 8&:@.#A* .5 E"BB .5 ;0 9.;. 5"#?&:;A* .5 <.#J"&5 .39 3.;:03R
5;.;" .#;0&5 01;"3 5""J 0?; .39 5;".B 8"&503.BBA :9"3;:1:.%B" :310&$.;:03 E<"3 ;<"A %&".#< #0$8.3A .39
40@"&3$"3; 3";E0&J5L
• S"R',*" ;")"*30 "(%,%,"+ %1 3'%1@3%,.3002 ),++"@,(3%" %1 %&" JB: 300 .29"* %&*"3% ,(),.3%1*+ %&"2 *".",/"#
,(.0'),(- 6"*+1(30 ,(;1*@3%,1( 391'% ,(),/,)'30+M D<:5 1.:B5 ;0 "11"#;:@"BA #"$"3; #:@:B:.3 #03;&0B 01 90$"5;:#
#A%"&5"#?&:;A :310&$.;:03 5<.&:34 .39 #0?B9 @.5;BA :3#&".5" ;<" M=7N5 .##"55 ;0 7$"&:#.35N :310&$.;:03L
( /.3A 01 ;<" ?39"&5:43"9 4&0?85 <.@" 5:43"9 B";;"&5 5;&034BA 08805:34 2>=7 .39 S2M7 10& $.3A 01 ;<" 5.$" &".5035 9";.:B"9
:3 ;<:5 B";;"&L !"" 20.B:;:03 T";;"& U8805:34 2>=7 .5 V"80&;"9 U?; 01 20$$:;;"" G78&:B +,* +,(-H* <;;86WW%:;LBAW(!X+/$EY #$%
20.B:;:03 T";;"& U8805:34 S2M7 G78&:B +,* +,(-H* <;;86WW%:;LBAW(Q%PE<1 L+ V0%A3 Z&""3"* '"() *$%+,-./ 0"#%"., 1221," 34!5 #, %#$6".1+, -1 2.*7#(/ #$% ,"(+.*-/8 D<" Q:BB* U#;L +(* +,(-*
<;;86WW;<"<:BBL#0$W%B045W8?39:;5R%B04W;"#<30B04AW+-)[,(R;"#<R:39?5;&ARB".9"&5R08805"R#:5.R.5R9.34"&0?5R;0R8&:@.#AR.39 L\ /.3A 01 ?5 <.@" 5"@"&.B 0;<"& #03#"&35 ;<.; .&" 30; 9";.:B"9 :3 ;<:5 B";;"&* :3#B?9:34 ;<" %&".9;< 01 ;<" 9"1:3:;:035 10& ]#A%"&
;<&".;*^ .39 ]#A%"& ;<&".; :39:#.;0&*^ E<:#< E0?B9 .BB0E #0$8.3:"5 ;0 5<.&" :310&$.;:03 ;<.; 9"5#&:%"5 $"&" .;;&:%?;"5 01
;<&".;5L 799:;:03.B #03#"&35 :3#B?9" ;<" 5#08" 01 ;<" B:.%:B:;A 8&0;"#;:03 10& :310&$.;:03 5<.&:34 .39 $03:;0&:34* E<:#< #0?B9
B".9 ;0 0@"&R5<.&:34Y .39 ;<" ?33"#"55.&A .39 "_8.35:@" &"P?:&"$"3; ;<.; #A%"& ;<&".; :39:#.;0&5 .39 9"1"35:@" $".5?&"5
5<.&"9 8?&5?.3; ;<:5 %:BB E0?B9 %" "_"$8; ?39"& ;<" K&""90$ 01 >310&$.;:03 7#; G- `L=L2L --+G%HHLa 2?&&"3; B.E .B&".9A 8"&$:;5 #0$8.3:"5 ;0 $03:;0& ;<":& 3";E0&J5 ;0 8&0;"#; ;<":& 0E3 &:4<;5 .39 8&08"&;A .39 %:BB
8&0803"3;5 <.@" 30; "_8B.:3"9 E<A @.5; 3"E $03:;0&:34 .?;<0&:;A :5 3""9"9L D<" %:BB 40"5 1.& %"A039 4&.3;:34 .?;<0&:;A ;0
$03:;0& 10& [email protected]#"9 8"&5:5;"3; ;<&".;5 ;<.; #0?B9 805" . &:5J ;0 58"#:1:# :310&$.;:03 5A5;"$5 01 ;<:&9 8.&;:"5L
7/23/2019 Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/civil-society-security-expert-letter-opposing-csa-2015 2/3
#
• :0017 81@63(,"+ %1 B&3*" A(;1*@3%,1( I,*".%02 7,%& %&" JB: 1* TUAM D<" %:BB E0?B9 .?;<0&:O" #0$8.3:"5 ;0
5<.&" :310&$.;:03 E:;< .3A 1"9"&.B "3;:;A* :3#B?9:34 B.E "310&#"$"3; .39 :3;"BB:4"3#" .4"3#:"5 B:J" ;<" M=7 .39
KC>* 30;E:;<5;.39:34 .3A 0;<"& 8&0@:5:03 01 B.EL 20$8.3:"5 E0?B9 03BA 4"; .99:;:03.B B:.%:B:;A 8&0;"#;:035 10&
5<.&:34 ;<&0?4< .3 .?;<0&:O"9 80&;.B* E<:#< E0?B9 :3:;:.BBA %" .; ;<" !"8.&;$"3; 01 Q0$"B.39 ="#?&:;A G!Q=HL
• :0017 %&" 6*"+,)"(% %1 "+%390,+& %&" V;;,." 1; %&" I,*".%1* 1; J3%,1(30 A(%"00,-"(." CIJAG# %&" TUA# 3() 3(2 1%&"*
366*16*,3%" .,/,0,3( ;")"*30 "(%,%2 3+ 3 61*%30 %&*1'-& 7&,.& .1@63(,"+ @32 +&3*" ,(;1*@3%,1( 7,%& 0,39,0,%26*1%".%,1(M D<:5 ?39"&$:3"5 "110&;5 ;0 "35?&" ;<.; ;<" #A%"&5"#?&:;A 8&04&.$ 90"5 30; ?39"&$:3" 8&0;"#;:035
.110&9"9 ;0 B.E "310&#"$"3; 5?&@":BB.3#" .39 #0?B9 .B50 E".J"3 #A%"&5"#?&:;A %A :3#&".5:34 ;<" B:J"B:<009 ;<.;
!Q= E0?B9 3"@"& 5"" #A%"& ;<&".; :310&$.;:03 "55"3;:.B ;0 :;5 #A%"&5"#?&:;A $:55:03L-
• :'%&1*,4" 1/"*9*13) 037 "(;1*."@"(% '+"+ %&3% -1 ;3* 1'%+,)" %&" +.16" 1; .29"*+".'*,%2M T.E "310&#"$"3;
E0?B9 %" .BB0E"9 ;0 ?5" #A%"& ;<&".; :39:#.;0&5 ;0 :3@"5;:4.;" .39 8&05"#?;" #&:$"5 .39 .#;:@:;:"5 ;<.; <.@"
30;<:34 ;0 90 E:;< #A%"&5"#?&:;A* 5?#< .5 ;<&".; 01 5"&:0?5 %09:BA :3I?&A 0& 9".;<* ;"&&0&:5$* 0& 5"&:0?5 "#030$:#
<.&$* &"4.&9B"55 01 E<";<"& ;<" <.&$ :5 :$$:3"3;L D<"&" :5 . &"P?:&"$"3; ;<.; ;<"&" %" . ]58"#:1:# ;<&".;*^ %?;
;<" %:BB 1.:B5 ;0 9"1:3" ;<.; ;"&$* .39 :3;"BB:4"3#" .4"3#:"5 5?#< .5 ;<" M=7 0& KC> #0?B9 :3;"&8&"; :; :3 5?#< .
%&0.9 $.33"& ;<.; ;<"A E0?B9 ;.J" :; .5 B:#"35" ;0 #03;:3?.BBA $:3" ;<" #A%"& ;<&".; :39:#.;0&5 ;<"A &"#":@" 10&
:310&$.;:03 ;0 %" ?5"9 :3 ?3&"B.;"9 #&:$:3.B :3@"5;:4.;:035L 799:;:03.B #03#"&3:34 ?5" .?;<0&:O.;:035 :3#B?9"
:3@"5;:4.;:035 ?39"& ;<" b58:03.4" 7#;* E<:#< #0?B9 &"5?B; :3 "@"3 $0&" .44&"55:@" #&.#J90E35 .4.:35; 3.;:03.B
5"#?&:;A I0?&3.B:5;5 .39 ;<":& 50?&#"5* .39 &";.B:.;:03 .4.:35; 40@"&3$"3; E<:5;B"%B0E"&5Y .39 :3@"5;:4.;:035 :3;0
:9"3;:;A ;<"1; .39 ;&.9" 5"#&"; @:0B.;:035L D<" ?5" .?;<0&:O.;:035 :3#B?9"9 :3 ;<:5 %:BB ?39"&$:3" ;&.9:;:03.B 9?"
8&0#"55 8&0;"#;:035* .39 ;?&3 :; :3;0 . #A%"&R5?&@":BB.3#" %:BB &.;<"& ;<.3 . #A%"&5"#?&:;A %:BBY .39
• :'%&1*,4" 81@63(,"+ %1 "(-3-" ,( 6*190"@3%,. )";"(+,/" @"3+'*"+M D<" %:BB E0?B9 8&0@:9" . 5E""8:34
.?;<0&:O.;:03 10& #0$8.3:"5 ;0 "34.4" :3 9"1"35:@" $".5?&"5* 8&"@:0?5BA &"1"&&"9 ;0 .5 #0?3;"&$".5?&"5L
20$8.3:"5 .B&".9A B"4.BBA "34.4" :3 . &.34" 01 .#;:@:;:"5 ;0 8&0;"#; ;<":& 5A5;"$5 .39 ;<" :310&$.;:03 ;<.;
&"5:9"5 03 0& ;&.35:;5 ;<":& 5A5;"$5* 50 :; :5 ?3#B".& E<A 2034&"55 5<0?B9 .?;<0&:O" #0$8.3:"5 ;0 9"8B0A @.4?"BA
9"1:3"9 9"1"35:@" $".5?&"5 ]30;E:;<5;.39:34 .3A 0;<"& 8&0@:5:03 01 B.EL^
D<" 2A%"&5"#?&:;A 7#; 01 +,(-* 10&$"&BA #.BB"9 2>=7* 1.:B5 ;0 "11"#;:@"BA #"$"3; #:@:B:.3 #03;&0B 01 90$"5;:#
#A%"&5"#?&:;A :310&$.;:03 5<.&:34* ;<&".;"35 8&:@.#A .39 #:@:B B:%"&;:"5* .39 #0?B9 <.&$ #A%"&5"#?&:;A .39 9.;.
5"#?&:;AL !" '*-" 21' %1 1661+" %&" 9,00 3() ,%+ ,(.0'+,1( ,( %&" 1@(,9'+ ;'(),(- 63.K3-"D !" ;'*%&"* '*-" 21'%1 /1%" PJ1Q 1( %&" 9,00 ,; ,% .1@"+ %1 %&" ;011* ;1* 3( ,()"6"()"(% /1%"D
D<.3J A0? 10& A0?& #035:9"&.;:03L
=:3#"&"BA*
8,/,0 B1.,"%2 V*-3(,43%,1(+
7##"55 M0E
79@0#.#A 10& S&:3#:8B"9 7#;:03 :3 Z0@"&3$"3;
7$"&:#.3R7&.% 73;:R!:5#&:$:3.;:03 20$$:;;""
7$"&:#.3 2:@:B T:%"&;:"5 `3:03
7$"&:#.3 T:%&.&A 7550#:.;:03
7$:#?5
7&.% 7$"&:#.3 >35;:;?;"
C:BB 01 V:4<;5 !"1"35" 20$$:;;""
C&"33.3 2"3;"& 10& c?5;:#"
- 7B"I.390 ML /.A0&J.5* !"8?;A ="#L* !"8;L 01 Q0$"B.39 ="#L* T";;"& ;0 ="3L 7B K&.3J"3 #03#"&3:34 ;<" 2A%"&5"#?&:;A
>310&$.;:03 =<.&:34 7#; 01 +,(- Gc?BA \(* +,(-H* <;;86WWEEEL1&.3J"3L5"3.;"L40@W1:B"5W90#?$"3;5W(-,)\(!Q=&"58035"L891 L
7/23/2019 Civil Society Security Expert Letter Opposing CSA 2015
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/civil-society-security-expert-letter-opposing-csa-2015 3/3
$
2.$8.:43 10& T:%"&;A
2"3;"& 10& !"$0#&.#A F D"#<30B04A
2035;:;?;:03.B 7BB:.3#"
D<" 2035;:;?;:03 S&0I"#;
D<" 208:. >35;:;?;"
!"1"39:34 !:55"3; K0?39.;:03
!"$.39 S&04&"55bB"#;&03:# K&03;:"& K0?39.;:03
K:4<; 10& ;<" K?;?&"
K&""90$ 01 ;<" S&"55 K0?39.;:03
K&""90$d0&J5
K&"" S&"55 7#;:03 K?39
Z0@"&3$"3; 7##0?3;.%:B:;A S&0I"#;
Q.#J"&5WK0?39"&5
Q?$.3 V:4<;5 d.;#<
M.;:03.B 7550#:.;:03 01 2&:$:3.B !"1"35" T.EA"&5
M"E 7$"&:#.N5 U8"3 D"#<30B04A >35;:;?;"
M:5J.3"3 2"3;"&
U8"3/"9:.
U8"3D<"Z0@"&3$"3;L0&4
SbM 7$"&:#.3 2"3;"&
S&:@.#A V:4<;5 2B".&:34<0?5"
V"5;0&" ;<" K0?&;<
V =;&"";
e"3;?&" S0B:;:#5
fRT.%
B".'*,%2 W56"*%+ 3() :.3)"@,.+
="&4"A C&.;?5* V"5".&#< 7550#:.;" S&01"550&* !.&;$0?;< 20BB"4"L
b&:# C&?33"&Rd:BB:.$5* &";:&"9
c0<3 20@:#:* =A5;"$5 79$:3:5;&.;0&* 20@:#: 20$8?;"& =A5;"$5S&01L !.@:9 TL !:BB* =;.310&9 `3:@"&5:;A
V:B"A bBB"&* >3@"3;0& .39 ="#?&:;A =;&.;"4:5;Y 2<:"1 D"#<30B04A U11:#"&* 2020 20$$?3:#.;:035
V0%"&; ZL K"&&"BB* =8"#:.B 74"3;* >310&$.;:03 ="#?&:;A GV";LH* ̀ L=L !"8;L 01 !"1"35"
!&L V:#<.&9 K0&30* c&L 711:B:.;" =#<0B.&* =;.310&9 2"3;"& 10& >3;"&3"; .39 =0#:";Ag
c0" Z&.39* S&:3#:8.B b34:3""& .39 ="#?&:;A V"5".&#<"&* Z&.39 >9". =;?9:0* >3#L
2.&B Q"E:;;* C0.&9 2<.:&* =;.39.&9 >0D K0?39.;:03
V:#<.&9 =L h?B.E:"#* ="3:0& >3;"&3"; ="#?&:;A 7&#<:;"#;* K:&" 03 ;<" /0?3;.:3* TT2
VA.3 T.#J"A* ="#?&:;A S&09?#; =;&.;"4A .; 2B0?9KB.&"g
2<&:5;08<"& T:BI"35;0B8"* 20R2<.:& >bDK U8"3SZS E0&J:34 4&0?8 F >3;"&3"; :31&.5;&?#;?&" .&#<:;"#;g
/0&4.3 /.&P?:5RC0:&" R 2:;:O"3 T.%* /?3J =#<00B 01 ZB0%.B 711.:&5* ̀ 3:@"&5:;A 01 D0&03;0
S";"& ZL M"?$.33* ="3:0& S&:3#:8.B =#:"3;:5;* =V> >3;"&3.;:03.B* 20$8?;"& =#:"3#" T.%* /09"&.;0& 01 ;<" 72/ V:5J5
K0&?$g
C"3I.$:3 2L S:"&#"* Q"3&A =.B@.;0&: S&01"550& 01 20$8?;"& .39 >310&$.;:03 =#:"3#"
T.?&"3 d":35;":3* 20RK0?39"&* S"08B" K0& >3;"&3"; V"58035:%:B:;A
g7550#:.;:035 .&" 10& :310&$.;:03.B 8?&805"5 03BA
