FORMCM-36

CITY OF GLENDALE CALIFORNIAREPORT TO CITY COUNCIL

March 4, 2008

AGENDA ITEM

Action Item: Proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District - Authorization for Funding to Updale an ExislingHistoric Resources Survey

1. Resolution of appropriation

COUNCIL ACTION

Public Hearin~ Ordinance I J

Approved for ~41~Consent Calendar 1)Cl,

calendar

Action Item I J Report Only I J

Ron Ahlers, Acting Director of Finance . .

ReviewedScott H. Howard, City Attorney .

ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION

Submitted-lf~~~~"1''{''~~......~e- ~Hassan Haghani, Director of Planning , .

PreparedJay Platt, Planner, Historic Preservalion &Urban Design.

ApprovedJames E. Starbird, City Manager .

........C==~~-'-~A"~~~~-

Alan Loomis, Principal Urban Designer ..... , . , .... ,., .. , .... -----,~_---1P'--''--~

5 D

Report on Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District Funding AuthorizationMarch 4. 2008

Page 2of 4

RECOMMENDATION

The Planning Department recommends that the Council adopt the attached resolution of appropriation, authonzingthe expenditure of $7,500.00 to retain Historic Resources Group to update an existing historic resources surveywith respect to the 87 properties within the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District.

SUMMARY

In August 2007, the Planning Department received an application from homeowners requesting that the Citydesignate an area being called Ard Eevin Highlands as a historic district. The proposed district in northwestGlendale consists of 87 homes all of which were included in the 2004 historic resource survey completed byHistoric Resources Group (HRG) for a proposed historic district in the Cumberland Heights neighborhood.

At its September 2007 meeting, the Historic Preservation Commission reviewed the Ard Eevin Highlandsapplication and made the preliminary finding that Ihe area is eligible to be a historic district overlay zone. Theapplication is now moving through the City's historic district designation process and has reached the step at whicha historic resources survey is required (see Exhibit 8 for a flowchart detailing this process).

Because the homes in Ard Eevin Highlands were surveyed within the last five years, Planning staff believes that anew survey of the area is unnecessary and has obtained a proposal from HRG to update their 2004 survey withrespect to the properties included in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands district. Because the survey update isbasically a continuation and refinement of the firm's earlier project, staff feels it is appropriate and beneficial tocontinue working with HRG on the update.

The Planning Department requests that City Council authorize the expenditure of $7,500.00 to retain HRG tocomplete the historic resources survey update.

FISCAL IMPACT

Historic resource surveys are not included in City budgets. The Cottage Grove Historic District survey will require aone-time expenditure of $7,500.00. The contract will be written with a "Not to Exceed" clause capping the amount.The attached resolution will authorize the appropriation of funds for this project.

BACKGROUND

Historic District ProcessIn 2003 and 2004, the City moved forward on the designation of a large historic district at the request ofhomeowners in northwest Glendale. The "Cumberland Heights" historic district would have encompassed over 500parcels, including all of the properties that are now included within the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands historicdistrict. HRG was retained to conduct a historic resources survey, which was completed in November 2004.Subsequently, questions and concerns raised by the community led the Planning Department 10 reconsider itsmethods for designating and regulating potential districts. In January 2005, homeowners officially withdrew theCumberland Heights nomination pending the City's resolution of its historic district process.

Report on Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District Funding AulhorilationMarch 4, 2008

Page 30t 4

In September 2006, the City Council revised the process for consideration of historic districts. A significant changeto the process was the institution of a preliminary petition requesting a historic resources survey (preliminary to thelater petition actually requesting the historic district overlay zone). See Exhibit B: Historic District ProcessFlowchart for more information

Proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic DistrictIn August 2007, the Planning Department received an application from homeowners requesting that the Citydesignate an area being called Ard Eevin Highlands as a historic district. The proposed district in northwestGlendale consists of 87 homes located on several blocks of Ard Eevin, Highland, and Mountain Avenues, andCumberland Road, almost all of which were built between 1903 and 1952. The area is notable for its concentrationof Period Revival style homes that date to the 1920s and 1930.

At its September 2007 meeting, the Historic Preservation Commission reviewed the application and made thepreliminary finding that the area is eligible to be a historic district overlay zone and authorized the circulation of apetition requesting a historic resource survey update. Area residents circulated the petition and returned it to theCity at the end of November 2007. The owners of thirty-eight properties signed the petition, well above the 25%threshold required to continue moving forward with the historic district process.

The homes in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands historic district were all previously surveyed in 2004 for aproposed Cumberland Heights historic district that would have encompassed over 500 homes. The application forthat district was withdrawn from consideration in January 2005 pending the City's development of its new historicdistrict ordinance and design guidelines, which were completed in 2006. Because the homes in Ard EevinHighlands were surveyed within the last five years, Planning staff believes that a new survey of the area isunnecessary. Professional preservation practice suggests that the shelf life of a historic resource survey isapproximately five years, after which point the incremental impacts of alterations to properties may invalidate adistrict's potential eligibility and require re-survey. Planning staff has asked Historic Resources Group (HRG), thefirm that completed the Cumberland Heights survey, to submit a bid for the survey update. Because the surveyupdate is basically a continuation and refinement of the firm's earlier project. staff feels it is appropriate andbeneficial to continue working with HRG on the update.

Historic Resources Survey UpdateThe existing Cumberland Heights historic resources survey has two main parts - a historic context statement andthe architectural survey. Both of these will be updated to evaluate only the area within the proposed Ard EevinHi9hlands historic district. The historic context statement examines the history of the area, including settlementand subdivision patterns, and determines the range of important years in the history of the proposed district- alsoknown as the "period of significance~. The survey also examines the individual buildings in the proposed district,identifying their architectural styles and integrity, and determining whether they contribute to the overall historiccharacter that is described in the context statement.

The updated survey will allow the City to determine whether the proposed Ard Eevin Hightands historic district,standing apart from the larger Cumberland Heights area, meets the criteria for designation in Glendale, as well asstate and federal tevels. In order to adequately update the existing survey, HRG proposes to: 1) revise the HistoricContext portion of the earlier survey, which will involve editing and amending the earlier document as required; 2)conduct field survey and permit research for each of the eighty-seven properties, which will establish any changes

Report on Ard Eevirl Highlarlds Historic Districl Funding AuthorizalionMarch 4, 2008

Page 4of 4

since the first survey and reassess the bUildings' status as "contributors" to the historic district and the area's periodof signficance; and 3) analyze fhe proposed boundary for its appropriateness under fhe City's historic districtcriteria.

Under the Glendale Municipal Code, an area must have at least 60% of its buildings be 'contributors' in order toqualify as a local district. "Contributors" continue to maintain enough physical integrity to display the traitsassociated with a period of development andlor architectural style, in addition to reflecting the history of theproposed district's development. The construction date (or date of historically significant alterations) also typicallyfalls with the Period of Significance proposed for the district. In addition, the survey update will reassess theearliersurvey's determination of buildings' eligibility as individual landmarks, at the local, state or national levels. (Pleasenote that the survey examines eligibility only. Declaring a building as an individual landmark still requires consentof the property ownef.)

EXHIBIT(S)

Exhibit A:

Exhibit B:

Exhibit C:

Petition Requesting Historic Resources Survey

Historic District Process Flowchart

Map of Proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District

PETITION FOR HlS'I'ORIC ReSOURCES SURVEY r~"..) 111V\1'" ~t· !"f'

The undersigned owners of property in lhe proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that tbe Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey for 111 r-r'the proposed districL r

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our aulhority to sign this petition under penalty ofpe~ury.

Date Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole ownerof this property.Yes No

if you are not the sole owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

e/lller. V-

10 Jt5'" (1,/+'.... ~1-.eMJ;( l:l""\. --" t/l

J

1

1A?£(

ArGLhsk"<L ~''''!viI< J"1lN\>\

~tJk,;~1 t.},;J;"~

"fjt,N°"pf'- 73....,.;~~

v'

v

v

v,.,-

btJAl,:"IL II~J "''I '\ w...t /11<,..)_1 I./""

4u_;.- J]/9""-c; ~ 1.$kd6:.v/AJ V

/7"'''-;/'' l> j!;v';"","L,D 4:. ;S C"73;(';;' c~

..

-.? i-i="r=--=--"---~

I~ \} ~"-'" Ole a..

/%/d;?

p/­/5"

, fc!r C' ~Z{c,,J,.,,i.,,,,-g

" I.

Iq5 l(llt.aic.I<PJv.e",--, I -(JJ~ - l~a'u,(Lclro.tl.-k;!J__ 1X -hA,"t"'~ ('e.!V<ar.,,'+... ,

e

6MfG;~t/'i? I"./e..x

a wt NOl<ftkZS'?> w. I'-iD"rt14'

~ bf<l w.l HO"-n\CLV~/' / I

to "P>u..t Cv" ~ '8'67 (,J II. T,",,", sf- O...J1l.1 r.: ~ ..,"Owner of Property" shall be one of the following.:-{l W Ii Yis held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Where the property isheldin a form of co-tenancy, inc1udingjoim tenan9((enants in common, tenants in partnership or community property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by 8 business entity, such as a corporation. limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agenl of such business entityshall sign the pelition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Wbere the property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the Califomia Probate Code allows otherwise.

EXHIBIT A

PETITION I'OR H1SI'0({1C RESOURCES SUJ{VEY

The undersigned owners of propeny in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City CluncH initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (sec definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and OUf authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

1

-

If you 8fC not the sole owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

(vi I (1+,4-E~ I' C. V1'-1

)(. I p;'J-,'fr:oi4.R

y I A-r>,,~ I4c5'M

;z-/ Thn""ld. Sic/Onoe!'J1>< rv1afC{Cire+-'i?ic.bv111(

x1am the sole ownerorthis property.Yes ~~.r.

II

'7 H {,,,

7H CW'''~'_D

vAddress

=fWt;~1 feels ~ ,~-c I ; Jt~~~~.- I I. ~ J'I.

),."J;1/1;',S 1l,J

'/;

{;

d v rf IN iAj(MtTtirU1AfJ:.2 ?l:N /u.!1Ct1rr1-C/I

../bh

t~7£::;I.....e... ;; 'I/'o-() •

I!?::~~

~tJl6JtWib' ,

~~'-

vM \C'I-\·A€"<.. ~'-'~

MfA rC\~ye +- bid,,··

Name (Printed)

11 "', ce f"'~

I ,_ 1

\\)1/Inn

Datc

!o/q I -)Q<...'" S,,,,,d-c. r~t~ I j&.7_A-at c.v:. a....j.. I l I U1A(;"./JJ~ rz..

IO/r I Rz;!ern.aJTo

/0'17 I&_~1I0,- -i.

IDlY Ir~w !0j;~; r:~ J( ih.b."..tt/P"' I/( a74' rd ~",... h .. I I >- I 1'1 vc< '" Jt« rt,\1!ull Ktl~ OGatlJ1ar ~t2tA 18~5~:4 '~II, I':ai§;?i'{~ IIhh~~ ,l)A7aek ".:I:rT~ /70d-,,?.-M-/d.,; y; .E"/~ ?)A"">f/~

@A

{II; -16 .p'....,.

"Owner ofPropeny" shall be 0 of the followmg: (1) Where th property is held by c indivi ulll, the pelition shall be signed by that individual: (2) e the property is heldin a form ofc('Hcnancy, indudingjoinl tenancy, tenants in common,tenants in partnership or community property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the pelition:(3) Where the property is held by 8 business entity, such as a corporation, limited panncrship, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition: (4) Where the propeny is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designmed in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Where the propeny is held in trust, al\ co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the CaJiromia Probate Code allows otherwise.

------'j

(." ~)

PETITION rOI{ HISTOKlC RESOURCES SURVEY..-

The undersigned owners of propeny in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request thai the: Glendale City Council initialc a hislOric resources survey forthe proPJsed district.

IP TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this pelition under penalty of perjury.

Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by thaI individual; (2) Where the property is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property, then each such co-tcnant shall be required 10 sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authori7..ed agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest developmem. as defined in California Civil Code Section 13$1, the Buthorized agent of the homeowll(,,'!'Sassociation or oUier agcnt designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or ($)Whcre the property is held in trust, nil co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

D," Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, lisl other

I'lW'/t7 EA4 &AlXt:."f ~)j3..d') f~1 w i{l(uvi"A,"': 57 OfthiSPro~ owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEYes No PETITION. ,cL.~£//Vtf- /3/2/J.bu..,.,..

\'/'~!c1!c O~IN-"'~I<''''''I'''>\...(..,-1 ~,,' --= IG "" ,,' ""--+ .,' ,; 0/ FAI\-L ~ 1::1I~.""tlLE..

\ (J \

,,-----------------.

PETITION FOR HISTORIC RESOURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study nrea request lhnt the Glendale City Council initiate II historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (5""(; definition of'·owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

Owner of Property" shall be one or tile following: (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Where the proper1y1Sl;cldin a fonn of co-tenancy, ineludingjoint tenaney, tenants in common, tenants in pannership or community propeny, then each such ro-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the propeny is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnmhip, general pannmhip, or limited liability, an authori7.ed agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common inlerest development, as defined in Cslifornla Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest developmem's govemingdocuments shall sign the petition; or (5)Wherc the propeny is held in truSt, all co-trustecsshall sign the petition unless the Califomia Probate Code allows otherwise.

Dale Name (Printed) Signature Address , am the sole owner If you are not the sale ownL'!', list otherorlllis property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THE

A ~ Yes No PETITION.

I'ln C,hVl's Pv-VI) ~'J- ~ 1'4b A,-J fM'~ Ar-r. x,10(r) K"~f [Avo') f&j'lvo! lw.. " " " " '!

..

PETITION FOR HlSTOJ{JC RESOURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate I historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Olherwise, the signature is nol valid. We acknowledge OUT ownership and OUT authority 10 sign this petition under penalty ofpcrjury.

Dale Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you art not the sole owner, list otherof this property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THE

n Yes No PETITION.

UII,Io1~~c".,;~ \ fJt[ ,,,,0 I1I"HV\l.l'I)Ai~ 3b X.tlblal M/ooIP>.1 !.Vi~oJ J /:.- ~ .11.<;"0 fh::~ iW'E )6- Ix

V

--- -''Owner of Property" shall be one of the following; (1) Where the property is held by one individUllI, the petition shall be: signed by that individual; (2) Where the property is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property, lhen each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liBbility, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development. as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351. the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation Or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Where the property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows othetv.'ise.

1

Pb'l'lTION FOK HlSTOIUC KbSOUKCbS SUKVbY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request thai the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownenhip and our authority to sign lhis petition under penalty ofperjury.

)

oWner of Property" shall be one of the following: (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Where the propeny is heldin a fonn of co-tcnllflCY, including joint tenancy, tenants in common., tenants in partnership or community propeny, then each such co-tcnant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the propeny is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the propeny is a common interest development, as defined in Califomia Civil Code Section 135 I, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (S)Where the propeny is held in trost, aU co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

0." Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, list otheroflhis property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEy", No PETITION.

!OI"b, TIt,M~; i1.'\u>E'd..j'J ~ 1h-~ (f.1,5 A'!) I!(;,," Ad: .( J"- 6U'Lj

l:lk:.b, ~ "" A'I;) F:..." ~"" ./ ~ .6'7;pJ(..L"~ 1rJ~"(,-

,

.,

"-

PETITIUN FUR HlSTURlC R.l=:SUUKCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of··owner". below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by thal individulil; (2) wile-it the property is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property. then each such co-tenont shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Wh~ the property is a common int~st development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Where the property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, list otherof this property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEYes No PETITION.

,0. j-ill .•4 1660 ARD EEVIN AVE. X

10/12/ 7 CHARLA B. JANECEK GLENDALE, CA 91202

JU

~- -- ----

rJ::TITIUN FUR H1STURlC R.t::SUURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate II historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, TI-lEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of~owner", below). Otherwise. lhe signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this pelition under penalty of perjury.

''Q\Yller ofPropcrty'; shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be sigm.."d by thot individual; (2) Whe-re the propcny is heldin a form of co-tenancy. including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community propeny, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the propcny is held by a business entity, such as a corporation. limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the propeny is a common interest development, as defined in Califomia Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeo....llcrsassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (S)Where the propeny is held in trust. all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you ore not the sole owner, list otherof this property. o....lleT$. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THE

- Ves No PETITiON.

10{I-I; D1"""" 1>,t~~-e) A,;0-0z,~v.,ru: j ins> h7J.. [eu-i.. fwc. -;< blfl/?J ~/c:"'_L.

,ol,~ (jl1 l lW t>A-ti/G'> LA. Ill) .. j 67~ Ift.b. €Ell);'; AIr )<.. 1\/AWC MYles;. ..,,)i~u~

./

~--- ~-- ----- ---- -------- -

PETITIUN FUR HlSTUIUC IlliSUURCES SURVEY

___rhe undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is nOI valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of peJjury.

Dale Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you arc not the sole owner, list otherof this property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEy" No PETITION.

/0/1/ MIC!W:t- 1"'M-nt0 l/tdJi ,( Ib[S A,12..0{;f!I;Uv Ale K-' \<JL,STI<'-' I>c A/'J:\J.'-..--

/0 III ¥(I"iIM ~i, j -YOI ! Qo,h~< l(pla A",{ ,"VIUA, Ie v i\A IciuuQ IJ. 0 r'Cn ,v

'Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by thai individual; (2) Where the propcrty is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in pannership or community property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 135J, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest developmcnt's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (S)Where the property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

\

PET1TlON FUR HISTOK.lC RESOURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

JF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETlTJON (see definition of"owner". below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ov.nership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

'Owner of Property" shalfbe one of the following: (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by thlldndividual;-(2) When;- the--proPerty is"heldin a form of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy. tenants in common, tenants in partnership or communilY property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a husiness entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership. or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351. the t1ulhorizcd agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (S)Wherc the property is held in lrust, all co-trusleesshall sign the petition unless the Califomia Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (Printed)Signi::~

Address I am lhe sole owner If you are not the sole owner. list other

'1"~1 (IIt.",Ci (}.M.i/;' 1m A,o&Vlit Ale. oflhis property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEYes No PETITION.

/o/l.!" G,...IL. ~ c......n ((0/'~J::P~ ,-:I I.e.? A<o~J/)~ X #-1M:'1 C""''''£4

~.

PETITIUN FUR HIS'I'URlC RESUURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of propert)' in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District stud)' area request that the Glendale Cit)' Council initiate II historic resources survey rorthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition or"owner". below). Otherwise. the sig.nlltUfC is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our lIuthorit)' to sign this petition under penalt)' of pc~ury.

Owner of Property" shall be onc ofthe rollowing: (I) Where the property is held b)' one individual, thc petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Whero- thc properly is heldin a fonn of ca·tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenanlS in cammon, tenants in partnership orcammunity property, then each such co-tenant shall be required 10 sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a busincss entity, sucb as II corporation, limited partnership, geneml partnership, or limited liability, an lJuthorized agent of such business cntit)'shall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is II common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351,the authorized agent of tile homeowners 1association or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents &hall sign the petition: or (5)Wbere the property is held in trust, all co·trusteesshall sign the petition unless the Califomia Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, Jist olherorthis property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEy" No PETITION.

ID!I{Iu+ Ali" PruFli [J..1M i:(udf 1106 +J;/,,1l (,vc) k; V Snve>J Hu1?TrIlof{~ '0- S+~ (/r~ .>i- t> I rc8 H<c/J...J ,A" \/"'" !i1,s rrv

./

- ---_.,

PEI'JTION FOR HJSTORIC RESOURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners ofpropeny in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area requcstlhat the GJendak City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PErmON (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise. the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty ofperjury.

'Owner of Property" shall be one of the following; (I) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Where the property is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenllllcy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property, then each !\leh co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by B business entity, such as a corporation. limited partnership. general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the propeny is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 135 I, the authorized agent of the homeownersllSSOCiation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documenls shall sign the petition; or (S)Where thc property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (printed) Signature Address I am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, list otherarlhis property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEY" No PETITION.

)(;( lq~ ~ ~,...v CoI215f--r-( ca /..r1.o- \,,32. ,JIU:> f=,~ Ao<

--- Xr;, G\1.'2.0'L

~-"l"" KlttA€L.A Co...,~, .<.'£./~ II S~

~ ~ ~ ~ -

PETITION FOR HlS'j'OKIC KESOURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners af property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (sec definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is nat valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty afpe~ury.

Date Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole ownerof this property.Yes No

If you nrc not the sole owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

7,ffi C(V

X'X,

"Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by olle individual, the petition shall be signed by that individuiiJ;--(2) Wh-e-rc -the property is heldin a form of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property. then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited pnnnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of sueh business entity .....,shall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeowners £.....association or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition: or (5)Where the property is held in lI'ust, all eo·trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

PETITION FOR HJSTO/{JC RESOURCES SURVEY

',-The undersigned owners of property in thc proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our owncrship and our authority to sigrrthis petition under penalty of pe1jury,

'Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) Where the property is heldin a form of co'tenancy. ineludingjointlenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property. then each sucb co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general p<lMership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition: (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in Caliromia Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agenl orlhc homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Where the propeny is held in trust. all co-trustees )shall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

Date Name (printed) Signature Address , am the sole owner If you are not the sole owner, list otherof this property. J owners, ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEYes No PETITION.

~7 .-;;:,.,-"" /..Y";"H ----I/p~) /~Ii !JR~£..>/,;J Avo! / LISA MAR SOL-;IDIrS/n7 114,1} "':''''01,1 [/\ '7:10. 0 1./IA""CP,,,,,·t1ve. ,/ 11/l'lO-l-hv 1.-"",-10

.~

-t:" ,~' +0

•

,_ ,-'~

,,~

.~

- -- --- --

"

PETJTION FOI{ HlSTOI{]C KESOUI{CcS SUI{VCY

1be undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area requcstlhat the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, lhe signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority 10 sign this petition under penalty ofpe~ury.

AddressSignatureName (Printed) t am the sole ov.'Dcr IIf you are not the sole owner, list otherof this property. owners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THE

I I " I /") ~ r 1 I I Yes No PETITION.

Date

')~i L-;. t.£.r,-;'; &~~ r-- -rYrr1f~cJc~ If;' ~:Jc- -...L. ~£"1 '(i£

HQwner of Property" shall 1:iC-one oC-the following: (I) Where the propeny is held by olle individual, thc petition shall be signed by thaiindividuaf; (2) Where: the property is heldin a fonn ofco-tenancy. including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation. limited partnership. general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent ofsuch business entityshall sign the petition: (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeownersassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documenlS shall sign the petition; or (5)Where the property is held in trust. all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows otherwise.

PETITIUN FUR HJSTUJ<.IC IlliSUURCES SURVEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic District study area request lhat Ihe Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (sec definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

Date I Name (Printed)

11/11/07 I !Sill ~(,:,"

"("fJ Je~"r(, Sf/,,,,

Signature

Mill'Om~A..

Address

!"fC 1f,':l~t.'Yi Av<1.1~ Ihll<f.. ; A'K

, am the sole ownerof this property.Yes No

xy

If you are not the sale owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

.1." fie >k,:"i3,' II ~ k,";

"Owner ofPropeny" shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that In-dividual;-(2jWhcre the property is heldin a fonn of co-tenancy, includingjointtennncy, tenants in common, tenants in pannership or community property, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeowners Jassocimion or other agent designoted in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition: or (5)Where the property is held in trust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allo'WS otherwise.

PETITION WI{ HJSTOJ{JC J{ESOUI{CES SUI{VEY

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin HigWands Historic District study area request that the Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed district.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, TIlEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPERTY MUST SIGN THE PErmON (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of perjury.

I' I

IIh9(st I {,iU(,O('OST4flO (

••

Date Name (printed) Signature

~ / ...

re

Address

I ',;/ '1'. l U~"" I',v<­{.[...J.k ~A '11>'"-

I'~ \tiA" twul kr<-.!1M fu... ()} q~

II (.,$"4 /+")(DW\(JC.

I am the sole O\vnerof this property.Yes No

)(x/'--

If you are not the sole owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

l'1'et:> K'J'WLANCb ~1l ;l

"Owner of Property" shall be one of the following: (1) Where the property is held by one individual, the petition shall be signed by that individual; (2) \\!here the property is heldin a form of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in common, tenants in partnership or community propeny, then each such co-tenant shall be required to sign the petition;(3) Where the property is held by a business entity, such as a corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshaH sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common intc~rest development, as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the authorized agent of the homeowners 1association or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (5)Whcre the property is held in trust, all co-trustees '\shall sign the petition unless the California Probate Code allows othenvise.

"".TITIUN FUJ{ HJSTUl<.IC IlliSUUJ{C"S SUJ{V~Y

The undersigned owners of property in the proposed Ard Eevin Highlands Historic Dislrici study area request that lhe Glendale City Council initiate a historic resources survey forthe proposed dislriCt.

IF TWO OR MORE PEOPLE ARE LISTED AS OWNERS OF A PROPERTY, THEN ALL OWNERS OF THE PROPI::RTY MUST SIGN THE PETITION (see definition of"owner", below). Otherwise, the signature is not valid. We acknowledge our ownership and our authority to sign this petition under penalty of peJjury.

Dale Name (Printed) Signature Address I am the sole ownerarthis property.Yes No

If you are nol the sole owner, list otherowners. ALL OWNERS MUST SIGN THEPETITION.

:1~/lv/d i=up 0f"u>~~L~o ,£ ._ L2<.J c y",17-'''' 7: roU>t.J£".,loMlo~ CVn+k,q T. SolOw.,;.,1 (If 7.~JL"'~2._l:I..J..,1.~JAve I I X 11'~E:D D· Soww.n..,

oll'tk1l f!/lc.j~ 1"~/o ..;;' fi.<CI~Wft.-1 l.x I &#::,jal1le..ltr&Hsh~~~~~--+4:W~~Lal:1.-t/J.~4-+-'&--+-rZ~ ./h, j,. /I. /'1 hi 1",-'4>'1F. vJA-VGiJ ,ANI! A"'0'1--/07 SAL '" L4--r. IV< V,,,,,,..,,,, 4". llC ~ 7OtWi.

I t>/r'l/o {)R.f:.IfH h 6 L~ 7;lll2q \

, _ Mf} ,/ V~

fnMgJ ~U

'0/"/'7 bJ 1,GO'Lju I

b 7VI-~ u

- . . Wi,,~I~~u.4~W&.cJ,..",.,,~fY.tATO y is held by on individual, the petition shall be signed by that IdividLiaI; (2) Where the property is held

in II fonn of co-tenancy, including joint tenancy, tenants in com on, tenants in partnership or community property, then each such cO-leno.nt shall be required to sign the petition:(3) Where the property is held by II business entity, such as 1I corporation, limited partnership, general partnership, or limited liability, an authorized agent of such business entityshall sign the petition; (4) Where the property is a common interest development. as defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, the lluthoriz.ed agent orthe homeownt:rsassociation or other agent designated in the common interest development's governing documents shall sign the petition; or (S)Where the property is held in uust, all co-trusteesshall sign the petition unless the California Probatc Code allows otherwise, l

ity of Glendale Historic District Application

istoric District IPlanning Department -rocess review and recommendation

Public InputI

Historic Preservation CommissionAdministrative Preliminary Review

/voteto Voteto e~proceed not proceed .

Public Meeting - Review of District Proposal Options to make changesNotice and information sent to all owners and and resubmit

residents in proposed districtorand within a 300' radius

appeal to City CouncilPetition

Proponents circulate petition requestinghistoric resource survey of area

(requires 25+% homeowner support w/in 3 months toproceed - may begin before public meeting)

"-Planning Department completes Historic

Resources Survey

"-Historic Preservation Commission

review and recommendation

"-Public Meeting - Review of Survey

Notice and information sent to all owners andresidents within proposed district .

PetitionProponents circulate petition requesting a

historic district overlay zone(requires 50+0/ 0 homeowner support w/in 6 months to

proceed - may begin before public meeting)

"-Historic Preservation Commissionreview and final recommendation

"-Planning Commission

review and final recommendation

Approval;; new Historic District I '"f-City Council -

Denial;; no district '"final determination -::X

CHP

oo

Matilija,-,

i607

'" -----­M'~cJ"

1106 -.l1ha

1702

,e_.:.~

ArdEevin HighlandsHD Study Area

Uf--'"->l:X

'"

RESOLUTION NO. _

RESOLIITION OF nn: COUNCIL OF nn: OTY OF GLENDALEMAKING AN APPROPRIATION

BE IT RESOLYED BY l1fE COUNOL OF THE CITY OF GLENDALE'

SECTION I: That the sum 0[$7,500 is hereby appropriated and transferred from the followingaccounts:

ACCOUNTS25300-101431 10-10 I- I84

DESCRJPTONGeneral Fund, Undesih'l13ted Fund BalanceGeneral Fund, Contractual Services, Planning

FROMS7,500

TO

S7,500

To provide funds to conduct a Historic Resources Survey for lhe proposed Ard EevinHighlands Historic District.

SECTIO 2: The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution.

Adopted this day of ~, 2008

ATTEST:

City Clerk

STATE OF CALIFORNIA )COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ) SSCITY OF GLENDALE )

I, Ardashes Kassakhian, City Clerk of the City of Glendale, certify that the foregoing ResolutionNo. was adopted by the Council of the City of Glendale, California, at a regular meetingheld on the day of , 2008 and that the same was adopted by the followingvote:

Aye"oes:

Absent:

APPROVED AS TO FORM City Clerk

e-;=r:- :>CITY ATTORNEY

nATE z: -z4i =x2FZ:'

5 D 1