CIS-496 / I.S. Auditing

Computer-Assisted Audit Toolsand TechniquesGroup IVLearning Objectives:Fall into three broad categories:INTRODUCTION TO INPUT CONTROLS4Input Controls designed to ensure that the transactions that bring data into the system are valid, accurate, and complete. Data input procedures can be either source document-triggered (batch) or direct input (real-time). Source document input requires human involvement and is prone to clerical errors. Direct input employs real-time editing techniques to identify and correct errors immediately.CLASSES OF INPUT CONTROLS5SOURCE DOCUMENT CONTROLS6Source Document Controls in systems that use physical source documents in initiate transactions, careful control must be exercised over these instruments. Source document fraud can be used to remove assets from the organization. To control against this type of exposure, implement control procedures over source documents to account for each document.

o Use Pre-numbered Source Documents source documents should come pre-numbered from the printer with a unique sequential number on each document. This provides an audit trail for tracing transactions through accounting records.o Use Source Documents in Sequence source documents should be distributed to the users and used in sequence, requiring the adequate physical security be maintained over the source document inventory at the user site. Access to source documents should be limited to authorized persons.oPeriodically Audit Source Documents the auditor should compare the numbers of documents used to date with those remaining in inventory plus those voided due to errors.

DATA CODING CONTROLS7Data Coding Controls coding controls are checks on the integrity of data codes used in processing. Three types of errors can corrupt data codes and cause processing errors: Transcription errors, Single Transposition errors, and Multiple Transposition errors. Transcription errors fall into three classes:Addition errors occur when an extra digit or character is added to the code.Truncation errors occur when a digit or character is removed from the end of a code.Substitution errors are the replacement of one digit in a code with another.Two types of Transposition Errors:Single transposition errors occur when two adjacent digits are reversed.Multiple transposition errors occur when nonadjacent digits are transposed.Check Digits is a control digit (or digits) added to the code when it is originally assigned that allows the integrity of the code to be established during subsequent processing. The digit can be located anywhere in the code: suffix, prefix, or embedded. This technique will detect only transcription errors. The popular method is modulus 11, which recalculates the check digit during processing. The use of check digits introduces storage and processing inefficiencies and should be restricted to essential data.

MODULUS 11:Code = 53725*5, 4*3, 3*7, 2*2 = 6262/11 = 5 with remainder of 711 7 = 4 [is check digit]Revised Code=53724DATA CODING CONTROLSBATCH CONTROLS9Batch Controls are an effective method of managing high volumes of transaction data through a system. It reconciles output produced by the system with the input originally entered into the system. Controlling the batch continues throughout all phases of the system. It assures that:All records in the batch are processed.No records are processed more than once.An audit trail of transactions in created from input through processing to the output.It requires the grouping of similar types of input transactions together in batches and then controlling the batches throughout data processing. BATCH CONTROLS10Two documents are used to accomplish this task: a batch transmittal sheet and a batch control log. The transmittal sheet becomes the batch control record and is used to assess the integrity of the batch during processing. The batch transmittal sheet captures relevant information such as:Unique batch numberA batch dateA transaction codeNumber of records in the batchTotal dollar value of a financial fieldTotal of a unique non--financial fieldHash Totals a simple control technique that uses non-financial data to keep track of the records in a batch. Any key field may be used to calculate a hash total.

BATCH CONTROL LOG\VALIDATION CONTROLS14Validation Controls intended to detect errors in transaction data before the data are processed. Most effective when they are performed as close to the source of the transaction as possible. Some validation procedures require making references against the current master file. There are three levels of input validation controls:

VALIDATION DURING DATA INPUT\VALIDATION CONTROLS161. Field Interrogation involves programmed procedures that examine the characteristics of the data in the field. Missing Data Checks used to examine the contents of a field for the presence of blank spaces. Numeric-Alphabetic Data Checks determine whether the correct form of data is in a field. Zero-Value Checks used to verify that certain fields are filled with zeros. Limit Checks determine if the value in the field exceeds an authorized limit. Range Checks assign upper and lower limits to acceptable data values. Validity Checks compare actual values in a field against known acceptable values. Check Digit identify keystroke errors in key fields by testing the internal validity of the code.2. Record Interrogation procedures validate the entire record by examining the interrelationship of its field values. Reasonable Checks determine if a value in one field, which has already passed a limit check and a range check, is reasonable when considered along with other data fields in the record. Sign Checks tests to se if the sign of a field is correct for the type of record being processed. Sequence Checks determine if a record is out of order.3. File Interrogation purpose is to ensure that the correct file is being processed by the system. Internal Label Checks verify that the file processed is the one the program is actually calling for. The system matches the file name and serial number in the header label with the programs file requirements. Version Checks verify that the version of the file processed is correct. The version check compares the version number of the files being processed with the programs requirements. Expiration Date Check prevents a file from being deleted before it expires. #5-INPUT ERROR CORRECTIONBatch correct and resubmit

Controls to make sure errors dealt with completely and accurately

Immediate Correction

Create an Error FileReverse the effects of partially processed, resubmit corrected recordsReinsert corrected records in processing stage where error was detected

Reject the Entire Batch17Input Error Correction when errors are detected in a batch, they must be corrected and the records resubmitted for reprocessing. This must be a controlled process to ensure that errors are dealt with completely and correctly. Three common error handling techniques are:1. Immediate Correction when a keystroke error is detected or an illogical relationship, the system should halt the data entry procedure until the user corrects the error.2. Create an Error File individual errors should be flagged to prevent them from being processed. At the end of the validation procedure, the records flagged as errors are removed from the batch and placed in a temporary error holding file until the errors can be investigated. At each validation point, the system automatically adjusts the batch control totals to reflect the removal of the error records from the batch. Errors detected during processing require careful handling. These records may already be partially processed. There are two methods for dealing with this complexity. The first is to reverse the effects of the partially processed transactions and resubmit the corrected records to the data input stage. The second is to reinsert corrected records to the processing stage in which the error was detected.3.Reject the Entire Batch some forms of errors are associated with the entire batch and are not clearly attributable to individual records. The most effective solution in this case is to cease processing and return the entire batch to data control to evaluate, correct, and resubmit. Batch errors are one reason for keeping the size of the batch to a manageable number. #6-GENERALIZED DATA INPUT SYSTEMS (GDIS) Centralized procedures to manage data input for all transaction processing systems

Eliminates need to create redundant routines for each new application

Advantages:

Improves control by having one common system perform all data validationEnsures each AIS application applies a consistent standard of data validationImproves systems development efficiency18Generalized Data Input Systems to achieve a high degree of control and standardization over input validation procedures, some organizations employ a generalized data input system (GDIS) which includes centralized procedures to manage the data input for all of the organizations transaction processing systems. A GDIS eliminates the need to recreate redundant routines for each new application. Has 3 advantages:Improves control by having one common system perform all data validation.Ensures that each AIS application applies a consistent standard for data validation.Improves systems development efficiency.

#6-GDISMajor components:

Generalized Validation Module

Validated Data File

Error File

Error Reports

Transaction Log20A GDIS has 5 major components:1. Generalized Validation Module (GVM) performs standard validation routines that are common to many different applications. These routines are customized to an individual applications needs through parameters that specify the programs specific requirements.2. Validated Data File the input data that are validated by the GVM are stored on a validated data file. This is a temporary holding file through which validated transactions flow to their respective applications.3. Error File error records detected during validation are stored in this file, corrected, and then resubmitted to the GVM.4. Error Reports standardized error reports are distributed to users to facilitate error correction.5. Transaction Log is a permanent record of all validated transactions. It its an important element in the audit trail. However, only successful transactions (those completely processed) should be entered in the journal. CLASSES OF PROCESSING CONTROLSRun-to-Run Controls

Operator Intervention Controls

Audit Trail Controls21#1-RUN-TO-RUN (BATCH)Use batch figures to monitor the batch as it moves from one process to another

Recalculate Control TotalsCheck Transaction CodesSequence Checks22Run-to-Run Controls use batch figures to monitor the batch as it moves from one programmed procedure (run) to another. It ensures that each run in the system processes the batch correctly and completely. Specific run-to-run control types are listed below:Recalculate Control Totals after each major operation in the process and after each run, $ amount fields, hash totals, and record counts are accumulated and compared to the corresponding values stored in the control record.Transaction Codes the transaction code of each record in the batch is compared to the transaction code contained in the control record, ensuring only the correct type of transaction is being processed.Sequence Checks the order of the transaction records in the batch is critical to correct and complete processing. The sequence check control compares the sequence of each record in the batch with the previous record to ensure that proper sorting took place.

#2-OPERATOR INTERVENTIONWhen operator manually enters controls into the system

Preference is to derive by logic or provided by system24Operator intervention increases the potential for human error. Systems that limit operator intervention through operator intervention controls are thus less prone to processing errors. Parameter values and program start points should, to the extent possible, be derived logically or provided to the system through look-up tables #3-AUDIT TRAIL CONTROLSEvery transaction becomes traceable from input to output

Each processing step is documented

Preservation is key to auditability of AISTransaction logsLog of automatic transactionsListing of automatic transactionsUnique transaction identifiers [s/n]Error listing25Audit Trail Controls the preservation of an audit trail is an important objective of process control. Every transaction must be traceable through each stage of processing. Each major operation applied to a transaction should be thoroughly documented. The following are examples of techniques used to preserve audit trails: Transaction Logs every transaction successfully processed by the system should be recorded on a transaction log. There are two reasons for creating a transaction log: It is a permanent record of transactions. Not all of the records in the validated transaction file may be successfully processed. Some of these records fail tests in the subsequent processing stages. A transaction log should contain only successful transactions. Log of Automatic Transactions all internally generated transactions must be placed in a transaction log. Listing of Automatic Transactions the responsible end user should receive a detailed list of all internally generated transactions. Unique Transaction Identifiers each transaction processed by the system must be uniquely identified with a transaction number. Error Listing a listing of all error records should go to the appropriate user to support error correction and resubmission. OUTPUT CONTROLSEnsure system output:

Not misplacedNot misdirectedNot corruptedPrivacy policy not violated

Batch systems more susceptible to exposure, require greater controls

Controlling Batch Systems OutputMany steps from printer to end userData control clerk check pointUnacceptable printing should be shreddedCost/benefit basis for controlsSensitivity of data drives levels of controls26Output Controls ensure that system output is not lost, misdirected, or corrupted and that privacy is not violated. The type of processing method in use influences the choice of controls employed to protect system output. Batch systems are more susceptible to exposure and require a greater degree of control that real-time systems.

Controlling Batch Systems Output Batch systems usually produce output in the form of hard copy, which typically requires the involvement of intermediaries. The output is removed from the printer by the computer operator, separated into sheets and separated from other reports, reviewed for correctness by the data control clerk, and then sent through interoffice mail to the end user. Each stage is a point of potential exposure where the output could be reviewed, stolen, copied, or misdirected. When processing or printing goes wrong and produces output that is unacceptable to the end user, the corrupted or partially damaged reports are often discarded in waste cans. Computer criminals have successfully used such waste to achieve their illicit objectives. Techniques for controlling each phase in the output process are employed on a cost-benefit basis that is determined by the sensitivity of the data in the reports.

OUTPUT CONTROLSOutput spooling risks:

Access the output file and change critical data valuesAccess the file and change the number of copies to be printedMake a copy of the output file so illegal output can be generatedDestroy the output file before printing take place28Output Spooling applications are often designed to direct their output to a magnetic disk file rather than to the printer directly. The creation of an output file as an intermediate step in the printed process presents an added exposure. A computer criminal may use this opportunity to perform any of the following unauthorized acts:Access the output file and change critical data values.Access the file and change the number of copies to be printed.Make a copy of the output file to produce illegal output reports.Destroy the output file before printed takes place.

OUTPUT CONTROLSPrint Programs

Operator Intervention:

Pausing the print program to load output paperEntering parameters needed by the print runRestarting the print run at a prescribed checkpoint after a printer malfunctionRemoving printer output from the printer for review and distribution

Print Program Controls

Production of unauthorized copiesEmploy output document controls similar to source document controlsUnauthorized browsing of sensitive data by employeesSpecial multi-part paper that blocks certain fields29Print Programs the print run program produces hard copy output from the output file. Print programs are often complex systems that require operator intervention. 4 common types of intervention actions are:Pausing the print program to load the correct type of output documents.Entering parameters needed by the print run.Restarting the print run at a prescribed checkpoint after a printer malfunction.Removing printed output from the printer for review and distribution.

Print program controls are designed to deal with two types of exposures: production of unauthorized copies of output and employee browsing of sensitive data. One way to control this is to employ output document controls similar to source document controls. The number of copies specified by the output file can be reconciled with the actual number of output documents used. To prevent operators from viewing sensitive output, special multi-part paper can be used, with the top copy colored black to prevent the print from being read. OUTPUT CONTROLSBurstingSupervision

WasteProper disposal of aborted copies and carbon copies

Data controlData control group verify and log

Report distributionSupervision30Bursting when output reports are removed from the printer, they go the bursting stage to have their pages separated and collated. The clerk may make an unauthorized copy of the report, remove a page from the report, or read sensitive information. The primary control for this is supervision.Waste computer output waste represents a potential exposure. Dispose properly of aborted reports and the carbon copies from the multipart paper removed during bursting.Data Control the data control group is responsible for verifying the accuracy of compute output before it is distributed to the user. The clerk will review the batch control figures for balance, examine the report body for garbled, illegible, and missing data, and record the receipt of the report in data controls batch control log.Report Distribution the primary risks associated with report distribution include reports being lost, stolen, or misdirected in transit to the user. To minimize these risks: name and address of the user should be printed on the report, an address file of authorized users should be consulted to identify each recipient of the report, and maintaining adequate access control over the files. The reports may be placed in a secure mailbox to which only the user has the key.The user may be required to appear in person at the distribution center and sign for the report.A security officer or special courier may deliver the report to the user.OUTPUT CONTROLSEnd user controlsEnd user detection

Report retention:Statutory requirements (govt)Number of copies in existenceExistence of softcopies (backups)Destroyed in a manner consistent with the sensitivity of its contents31End User Controls output reports should be re-examined for any errors that may have evaded the data control clerks review. Errors detected by the user should be reported to the appropriate computer services management. A report should be stored in a secure location until its retention period has expired. Factors influencing the length of time a hard copy report is retained include:Statutory requirements specified by government agencies.The number of copies of the report in existence.The existence of magnetic or optical images of reports that can act as permanent backup.Reports should be destroyed in a manner consistent with the sensitivity of their contents.

OUTPUT CONTROLSControlling real-time systems output

Eliminates intermediaries

Threats:InterceptionDisruptionDestructionCorruption

Exposures:Equipment failureSubversive acts

Systems performance controls (Ch. 2)

Chain of custody controls (Ch. 5)32Controlling Real-time Systems Output real-time systems direct their output to the users computer screen, terminal, or printer. This method of distribution eliminates various intermediaries and thus reduces many of the exposures. The primary threat to real-time output is the interception, disruption, destruction, or corruption of the output message as it passes along the communications link. Two types of exposure exist:1. Exposures from equipment failure.2. Exposures from subversive acts where the output message is intercepted in transmit between the sender and receiver. TESTING COMPUTER APPLICATION CONTROLSBlack box (around)

White box (through)33Testing Computer Application Controls control-testing techniques provide information about the accuracy and completeness of an applications processes. These test follow two general approaches:

Black Box: Testing around the computer

White Box: Testing through the computerTESTING COMPUTER APPLICATION CONTROLS-BLACK BOXIgnore internal logic of application

Use functional characteristicsFlowchartsInterview key personnel

Advantages:Do not have to remove application from operations to test it

Appropriately applied:Simple applicationsRelative low level of risk34Black Box (Around the Computer) Technique auditors performing black box testing do not rely on a detailed knowledge of the applications internal logic. They seek to understand the functional characteristics of the application by analyzing flowcharts and interviewing knowledgeable personnel in the clients organization. The auditor tests the application by reconciling production input transactions processed by the application with output results. The advantage of the black box approach is that the application need not be removed from service and tested directly. This approach is feasible for testing applications that are relatively simple. Complex applications require a more focused testing approach to provide the auditor with evidence of application integrity.

TESTING COMPUTER APPLICATION CONTROLS-WHITE BOXRelies on in-depth understanding of the internal logic of the application

Uses small volume of carefully crafted, custom test transactions to verify specific aspects of logic and controls

Allows auditors to conduct precise test with known outcomes, which can be compared objectively to actual results36White Box (Through the Computer) Technique relies on an in-depth understanding of the internal logic of the application being tested. Several techniques for testing application logic directly are included. This approach uses small numbers of specially created test transactions to verify specific aspects of an applications logic and controls. Auditors are able to conduct precise tests, with known variables, and obtain results that they can compare against objectively calculated results.WHITE BOX TEST METHODSAuthenticity tests:Individuals / usersProgrammed procedureMessages to access system (e.g., logons)All-American University, student lab: logon, reboot, logon *

Accuracy tests:System only processes data values that conform to specified tolerances

Completeness tests:Identify missing data (field, records, files)37 Authenticity Tests verify that an individual, a programmed procedure, or a message attempting to access a system is authentic. Accuracy Tests ensure that the system processes only data values that conform to specified tolerances. Completeness Tests identify missing data within a single record and entire records missing from a batch.

* At All-American University, a student built a Trojan horse and installed in on computer labs. The Trojan horse was a carbon copy of the actual login screen. Once the student/user typed in his/her ID and password, the Trojan horse captured it, sent it to the culprit, and called the real login program. Students begin to complain to the IT services that the Login Program was faulty, asking for ID and password twice. Upon investigation, IT services at All-American University found the Trojan horse and eventually the culprit. All American is a fictitious name of a real university and real Trojan horse case.WHITE BOX TEST METHODSRedundancy tests:Process each record exactly once

Audit trail tests:Ensure application and/or system creates an adequate audit trailTransactions listingError files or reports for all exceptions

Rounding error tests:Salami slicingMonitor activities excessive ones are serious exceptions; e.g, rounding and thousands of entries into a single account for $1 or 138 Redundancy Tests determine that an application processes each record only once. Access Tests ensure that the application prevents authorized users from unauthorized access to data. Audit Trail Tests ensure that the application creates an adequate audit trail. Produces complete transaction listings, and generates error files and reports for all exceptions. Rounding Error Tests verify the correctness of rounding procedures. Failure to properly account for this rounding difference can result in an imbalance between the total (control) interest amount and the sum of the individual interest calculations for each account. Rounding problems are particularly susceptible to so-called salami funds, that tend to affect a large number of victims, but the harm to each is immaterial. Each victim assumes one of the small pieces and is unaware of being defrauded. Operating system audit trails and audit software can detect excessive file activity. In the case of the salami fraud, there would be 1000s of entries into the computer criminals personal account that may be detected in this way.

COMPUTER AIDED AUDIT TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES (CAATTs)Test data methodBase case system evaluationTracingIntegrated Test Facility [ITF]Parallel simulationGAS40Computer Aided Audit Tools and Techniques for Testing Controls there are 5 CAATT approaches: #1 TEST DATAUsed to establish the application processing integrity

Uses a test deckValid dataPurposefully selected invalid dataEvery possible:Input errorLogical processesIrregularity

Procedures:Predetermined results and expectationsRun test deckCompare41Test Data Method used to establish application integrity by processing specially prepared sets of input data through production applications that are under review. The results of each test are compared to predetermined expectations to obtain an objective evaluation of application logic and control effectiveness.Creating Test Data when creating test data, auditors must prepare a complete set of both valid and invalid transactions. If test data are incomplete, auditors might fail to examine critical branches of application logic and error-checking routines. Test transactions should test every possible input error, logical process, and irregularity.

#2 BASE CASE SYSTEM EVALUATION (BCSE)Variant of Test Data method

Comprehensive test data

Repetitive testing throughout SDLC

When application is modified, subsequent test (new) results can be compared with previous results (base)43Base Case System Evaluation there are several variants of the test data technique. When the set of test data in use is comprehensive, the technique is called a base case system evaluation (BCSE). BCSE tests are conducted with a set of tests transactions containing all possible transaction types. These results are the base case. When subsequent changes to the application occur during maintenance, their effects are evaluated by comparing current results with base case results. #3 TRACINGTest data technique that takes step-by-step walk through application

The trace option must be enabled for the application

Specific data or types of transactions are created as test data

Test data is traced through all processing steps of the application, and a listing is produced of all lines of code as executed (variables, results, etc.)

Excellent means of debugging a faculty program443. Tracing performs an electronic walk-through of the applications internal logic. Implementing tracing requires a detailed understanding of the applications internal logic. Tracing involves three steps: The application under review must undergo a special compilation to activate the trace option. Specific transactions or types of transactions are created as test data. The test data transactions are traced through all processing stages of the program, and a listing is produced of all programmed instructions that were executed during the test. TEST DATA: ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGESAdvantages of test data

They employ white box approach, thus providing explicit evidenceCan be employed with minimal disruption to operationsThey require minimal computer expertise on the part of the auditors

Disadvantages of test data

Auditors must rely on IS personnel to obtain a copy of the application for testingAudit evidence is not entirely independentProvides static picture of application integrityRelatively high cost to implement, auditing inefficiency45Advantages of Test Data TechniquesThey employ through the computer testing, thus providing the auditor with explicit evidence concerning application functions. Test data runs can be employed with only minimal disruption to the organizations operations. They require only minimal computer expertise on the part of auditors.Disadvantages of Test Data TechniquesAuditors must rely on computer services personnel to obtain a copy of the application for test purposes.Audit evidence collected by independent means is more reliable than evidence supplied by the client.Provide a static picture of application integrity at a single point in time. They do not provide a convenient means of gathering evidence about ongoing application functionality.Their relatively high cost of implementation, resulting in auditing inefficiency.#4 INTEGRATED TEST FACILITYITF is an automated technique that allows auditors to test logic and controls during normal operations

Set up a dummy entity within the application system

Set up a dummy entity within the application systemSystem able to discriminate between ITF audit module transactions and routine transactionsAuditor analyzes ITF results against expected results46Integrated Test Facility an automated technique that enables the auditor to test an applications logic and controls during its normal operation. ITF databases contain dummy or test master file records integrated with legitimate records. ITF audit modules are designed to discriminate between ITF transactions and routine production data. The auditor analyzes ITF results against expected results.

ITF: ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGESAdvantages of ITF

ITF supports ongoing monitoring of controlsApplications of ITF can be economically tested without the intervention of computer services personnel.

Disadvantages of ITF

Potential for corrupting the data files of the organization with test data. 48Advantages of Test Data TechniquesThey employ through the computer testing, thus providing the auditor with explicit evidence concerning application functions. Test data runs can be employed with only minimal disruption to the organizations operations. They require only minimal computer expertise on the part of auditors.Disadvantages of Test Data TechniquesAuditors must rely on computer services personnel to obtain a copy of the application for test purposes.Audit evidence collected by independent means is more reliable than evidence supplied by the client.Provide a static picture of application integrity at a single point in time. They do not provide a convenient means of gathering evidence about ongoing application functionality.Their relatively high cost of implementation, resulting in auditing inefficiency.#5 PARALLEL SIMULATIONAuditor writes or obtains a copy of the program that simulates key features or processes to be reviewed / tested

Auditor gains a thorough understanding of the application under review

Auditor identifies those processes and controls critical to the application

Auditor creates the simulation using program or Generalized Audit Software (GAS)

Auditor runs the simulated program using selected data and files

Auditor evaluates results and reconciles differences49

End of Report51