CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection...

70
CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 That’s Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CIC’s Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program Officer, OCLC Research

description

What numbers of borrows and loans has each institution executed in each of the various resource sharing venues in the past 5 years? What factors determine the requesting method or model used for each request? How is all this changing over time? How will it most likely change in the future? OCLC/CIC ILL Study

Transcript of CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection...

Page 1: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015

That’s Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CIC’s Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015

Dennis MassieProgram Officer, OCLC Research

Page 2: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

• What numbers of borrows and loans has each institution executed in each of the various resource sharing venues in the past 5 years?

• What factors determine the requesting method or model used for each request?

• How is all this changing over time?• How will it most likely change in the future?

OCLC/CIC ILL Study

Page 3: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

• What numbers of borrows and loans has each institution executed in each of the various resource sharing venues in the past 5 years?

• What factors determine the requesting method or model used for each request?

• How is all this changing over time?• How will it most likely change in the future?

OCLC/CIC ILL Study

Page 4: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

• What numbers of borrows and loans has each institution executed in each of the various resource sharing venues in the past 5 years?

• What factors determine the requesting method or model used for each request?

• How is all this changing over time?• How will it most likely change in the future?

OCLC/CIC ILL Study

Page 5: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

THAT OTHER ILL DATA STUDY

Page 6: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

#1:Total sharing activity is going up.

2010 2011 2012 20130

200,000

400,000

600,000

800,000

1,000,000

1,200,000

ARL BD study

Page 7: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

#2: Circ-to-Circ is where BD growth is.

2010 2011 2012 20130

100,000

200,000

300,000

400,000

500,000

600,000

700,000

C2CTrad

Page 8: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

#3. BD Growth is due to new players.

2010 2011 2012 20130

50,000

100,000

150,000

200,000

250,000

300,000

350,000

400,000

450,000

Overall ILL Activity

Founders J2002 Newbies

Page 9: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

9 APPARENTLY TREND-LIKE SUBSTANCES RELATING TO CIC COLLECTION-SHARING ACTIVITY

Page 10: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

Overall CIC Collection Sharing Activity

11 CIC 5-yr.

Page 11: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

Overall CIC Collection Sharing Activity

11 CIC 5-yr. with 3 Newbies

Page 12: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

Overall CIC Collection Sharing Activity

11 CIC 5-yr. with 3 Newbies All 15 CIC

Page 13: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

200000

400000

600000

800000

1000000

1200000

1400000

1600000

1800000

Overall CIC Collection Sharing Activity

11 CIC 5-yr. with 3 Newbies All 15 CIC

#9:Total sharing activity is going down.

Page 14: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

350000

CIC Overall via OCLC (15 institutions)

Lend Ret Lend Non Borr Ret Borr Non

Page 15: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

CIC Overall via OCLC (14 institutions)

Lend Ret Lend Non Borr Ret Borr Non

Page 16: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

CIC Overall via OCLC (14 institutions)

Lend Ret Lend Non Borr Ret Borr Non

#8:On OCLC, Sharing Ret’s up, Non’s down.

Page 17: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

CIC Overall via RapidILL (14) and Docline (9)

Rapid Borr Rapid Lend Docline Borr Docline Lend

Page 18: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

70000

80000

CIC Overall via RapidILL (13) and Docline (8)

Rapid Borr Rapid Lend Docline Borr Docline Lend

Page 19: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

70000

80000

CIC Overall via RapidILL (13) and Docline (8)

Rapid Borr Rapid Lend Docline Borr Docline Lend

#7: RapidILL up & down, Docline down.

Page 20: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

CIC Other Consortial Borrowing Activity (8)

Borr Lend

Page 21: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

CIC Other Consortial Borrowing Activity (7)

Borr Lend

Page 22: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

CIC Other Consortial Borrowing Activity (7)

Borr Lend

#6: Other Consortial Borrowing: Down-ish.

Page 23: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

CIC Overall Free Online (5) and POD (11)

Free Borr Free Lend POD - Ret POD -Non

Page 24: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

CIC Overall Free Online (5) and POD (10)

Free Borr Free Lend POD - Ret POD -Non

Page 25: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2012 2013 2014 20150

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

CIC Overall Free Online (5) and POD (10)

Free Borr Free Lend POD - Ret POD -Non

#5: Free online, POD of non-returnables up.

Page 26: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2102 2013 2014 20150

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

CIC International Borrowing and Lending

Borr Non Borr Ret Lend Non Lend Ret

Page 27: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2011 2102 2013 2014 20150

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

CIC International Borrowing and Lending

Borr Non Borr Ret Lend Non Lend Ret

#4: International lending of Non-ret’s is big.

Page 28: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000Within CIC via OCLC (Including UBorrow)

Ret Non Total

Page 29: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

140000Within CIC via OCLC (Excluding UBorrow)

Ret Non Total

Page 30: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

140000Within CIC via OCLC (Excluding UBorrow)

Ret Non Total

#3: Non-UBorrow CIC OCLC traffic down.

Page 31: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

Total UBorrow – Filled Requests

Total Lend Borrow

Page 32: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2013 2014 20150

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000Loans Within CIC via OCLC

Non-Ret Ret UBorrow

Page 33: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

UBorrow Loans 2012-2015

Chi IL Ind IA MD MI MST MINNEB NW OSU PSU PUR RUT WI

Page 34: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

UBorrow Borrows 2012-2015

Chi IL Ind IA MD MI MST MINNEB NW OSU PSU PUR RUT WI

Page 35: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

UBorrow Borrows 2012-2015

Chi IL Ind IA MD MI MST MINNEB NW OSU PSU PUR RUT WI

#2: UBorrow borrowing & lending patterns are very, very different.

Page 36: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

UBorrows: Unmediated vs Mediated

Borrows Unmediated Mediated

Page 37: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

UBorrows: Unmediated vs Mediated

Borrows Unmediated Mediated

67%-33%

Page 38: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

UBorrows: Unmediated vs Mediated

Borrows Unmediated Mediated

60%-40%

67%-33%

Page 39: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

UBorrows: Unmediated vs Mediated

Borrows Unmediated Mediated

60%-40%

55%-45%

67%-33%

Page 40: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

2012 2013 2014 20150

20000

40000

60000

80000

100000

120000

UBorrows: Unmediated vs Mediated

Borrows Unmediated Mediated

60%-40%

55%-45%

59%-41%

67%-33%

Page 41: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU

NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-UPur

WI

Neb

UBorrow Universe

Page 42: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

NebUBorrow Universe

Page 43: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

NebUBorrow Universe

Page 44: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Page 45: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Page 46: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Page 47: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MI MST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Page 48: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Page 49: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Page 50: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Page 51: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Page 52: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Page 53: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Page 54: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

Page 55: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

Page 56: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

Page 57: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg. 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

Page 58: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

Page 59: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 60: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 61: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 62: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 63: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 64: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 65: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 66: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 67: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

Page 68: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

Chi

OSU

IA

Ind

PSU NW

MD

MN

MIMST

Rut

IL-U

Pur

WI

Neb

Net Lenders, UBorrow MediatedUBorrow Universe

Net Borrowers, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Lenders, UBorrow Unmediated

Net Borrower, UBorrow Mediated

Net Borrower, Evolved

From Mediated to Unmediated

2015 avg: 6,489 lends, 3,405 borrows

2015 avg: 5,607 lends, 11,677 borrows

2015 avg: 6,555 lends, 3,024 borrows

MI and NW 2015 avg: 6,179 lends, 14,895 borrows

#1: Mediated or Unmediated as a predominant borrowing method within UBorrow seems to have

no correlation with relative borrowing volume.

Page 69: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

• Interview each CIC ILL unit (or selected ones)• Chart OCLC ILL interactions in detail as new

members joined CIC• Look at fill rates• Isolate returnables and non-returnables• Overlay other variables on sharing data• Repeat study with the Go8?• Report out

Next steps/further study

Page 70: CIC ILL Directors Meeting, October 22, 2015 Thats Just Gross: A Macro-style Look at CICs Collection Sharing Activity 2011-2015 Dennis Massie Program.

SMTogether we make breakthroughs possible.

Thanks! Comments? Questions?

Dennis MassieProgram Officer, OCLC Research

[email protected]

CIC ILL Directors Meeting