CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 30, 2009 Now Is The Time To Buy Stocks - But Be Selective...
-
date post
21-Dec-2015 -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 30, 2009 Now Is The Time To Buy Stocks - But Be Selective...
November 30, 2009
CIBC Global Asset Management Inc.
Now Is The Time To Buy Stocks - But Be Selective
Fund Update
David Graham, MBA, CFAVice PresidentCanadian Equity
Craig JerusalimResearch AnalystCanadian Equity
| Page 2CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
David Graham, CFAVice-President, Portfolio Manager – Canadian EquitiesCIBC GLOBAL ASSET MANAGEMENT
Education/Accreditation
• MBA – York University (Toronto)
• BA – University of Western Ontario (London)
• CFA Charterholder
Background/Experience
David brings to CGAM over 35 years experience with various firms including:
2000-2002 - Senior Equity Analyst; Merrill Lynch Investment Managers
1998-1999 – Analyst; First Marathon Securities Ltd.
1996-1998 – Executive Vice-President, Institutional Sales; Marleau, Lemire Securities Inc.
1991-1996 – Institutional Salesperson; Richard Greenshields Ltd.
1986-1991 – Vice-President, Institutional Equities; McN Mantha Inc.
CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. (CGAM) ranks among Canada’s leading investment managers with over $60B in AUM’s, and has one of the broadest investment management platforms in Canada.
David Graham joined CIBC Global Asset Management in July of 2002. He is responsible for strategy and research and brings extensive experience to the Canadian equities team.
David is the manager of several CIBC and Renaissance Funds with assets totalling over $8 billion.
| Page 3CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
Portfolio Manager ChangesModest Implications For Our Clients
Source: CIBC Global Asset Management Inc.
Similarities:- Same Value Model- Bottom Up Oriented- Similar Value Style- Sector Agnostic- Dislike Balance Sheet Risk- Incremental Buyers/Sellers- Prefer Mgt Track Record
Differences:- Look For Value + A Catalyst- Use Other Valuation Measures (EV/EBITDA, Price/Cash Flow) As Well As P/E- Add Top Down Sector Selection- Not As Deep Value- Buy New Issues If Value Evident- Use Relative Strength Tools- Will Trade Around Core Positions
| Page 4CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
Portfolio Manager ChangesModest Implications For Our Clients
Recent Purchases
BCE – solid management, lean & mean, 6% yield
BTE.UN – solid heavy oil trust, 5.6% yield, benefits from narrow oil spreads
Crescent Point – solid management, excellent drill inventory, 7% yield
BMO, NA, RY, TD – bought were Funds less than 5% overweight – like banks in this environment
Recent Sales
IMO – trimmed 20-30 bps – good value but refining side weak
CLC.UN – trimmed 20-30 bps – good value but limited upside
GIB.A – trimmed 20 bps – at our target, took profits
T – owned small position (about 50 bps), switched to BCE
| Page 5CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
STRONG TEAM STRUCTURE
Value & Income Funds
David Graham
Craig Jerusalim
Research
Frank Settino
Andreas Hoppe
Monique Malo
Fixed Income
John Braive
Jeffery Waldman
Preferreds
Jeffery Waldman
Adam DitkofskyAsset Allocation
Luc de la Durantaye
Core & Dividend
Funds
Domenic Monteferrante
Derivatives
Patrick Thillou
Small Cap Funds
Jennifer Law
Shanthu David
Trading
Kathleen Gregoire
Thomas Litchfield
| Page 6CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
PORTFOLIO COMMENTS HOW WE CHOOSE OUR STOCKS
40-60 Stock
Universe
500 Stock Universe
Book Value
Normalized historical ROE
Normalized historical P/E
Intrinsic Value
Fundamental analysis
Corporate Interviews
Research reports
QualitativeQuantitative
| Page 7CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
PORTFOLIO COMMENTSHOW WE CHOOSE OUR STOCKS
Source: Reuters StockVal, Nov. 23, 2009
| Page 8CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
PORTFOLIO COMMENTSHOW WE CHOOSE OUR STOCKS
Value BV Avg EPS P/E Value Div Value Price ReturnYr 1 Yr 2 ROE (%)
National Bank 31.89 5.97 6.63 39.53 17.00 6.72 10.8 72.58 2.48 77.54$ 62.02 25.02%Toronto-Dominion Bank 39.66 5.43 6.46 46.67 15.00 7.00 13.6 95.20 2.44 100.08$ 67.81 47.56%
Cons.
Projected Book Value = Current Book Value + consensus earnings - dividends
Normalized EPS = Proj BV x average ROE from past 10 years
Intrinsic Value = Normalized EPS x 10 year average P/E multiple + dividends
Outcome: In this case, we conclude that TD Bank is 48%
undervalued and National Bank is just 25% undervalued, thus more upside potential in TD.
| Page 9CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
Source: CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. as of October 31, 2009
PORTFOLIO COMMENTBALANCE OF CYCLICAL VS NON CYCLICAL
Renaissance Canadian Core Value Fund
Dec 2007 Sept 2008 Oct 2009 S&P/TSX
Natural Resources 35% 25% 34% 46%Energy 22% 17% 21% 25%
Materials 13% 8% 13% 21%
Economically Sensitive 3% 8% 11% 8%Industrials 1% 5% 5% 5%
Information Technology 2% 3% 6% 3%
Consumer Related 31% 32% 16% 12%Consumer Discretionary 12% 9% 4% 4%Consumer Staples 10% 12% 7% 3%Health Care 0% 0% 0% 1%
Telecom 9% 11% 5% 4%
Interest Sensitive 31% 35% 40% 33%Financials 30% 33% 34% 30%
Utilities 1% 2% 2% 1%
| Page 10CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
Renaissance Canadian Core Value FundTop 10 Holdings & Overweights - As at October 31, 2009
Top 10 Holdings
Company(%)
Royal Bank of Canada 8.0
Toronto Dominion Bank 7.1
Encana Corp. 6.4
Cdn. National Resources 5.4
Barrick 4.5
Bank of Nova Scotia 4.4
Franco Nevada Corp. 4.4
Suncor Energy 4.2
Bank of Montreal 4.2
Cdn. National Railway 4.1
Source: CIBC Global Asset Management Inc.
Top 10 Overweights
Company(%)
Franco Nevada Corp. 4.1
Empire Co. 3.3
Toronto Dominion Bank 2.7
Encana 2.6
Bell Aliant 2.4
Aastra Technologies 2.2
Canadian Natural Resources 2.2
CGI Group 2.1
Canadian National Railway 1.9
Celestica 1.9
| Page 11CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARY Key Conclusions
THE RECESSION IS ENDING
THE CONSENSUS IS FOR A WEAK, BUT POSITIVE ECONOMY IN 2010
THERE WILL BE DISAPPOINTMENTS AND CONCERNS ABOUT THE RECOVERY, BUT THE FEDERAL RESERVE STILL HAS ITS FOOT ON THE GAS PEDAL
IN OUR BALANCED PORTFOLIOS, WE HAVE MOVED FROM 35% EQUITIES IN MARCH 2009 TO 61% TODAY
OUR GOAL IS THE PROPER BALANCE BETWEEN THE POTENTIAL OF COMMODITY STOCKS AND OTHER CYCLICALS, AND THE SAFETY OF STAPLES, BANKS AND OTHER VALUE-ORIENTED STOCKS (WITH DIVIDENDS)
IN THE VALUE PORTFOLIOS, OUR MAIN OVERWEIGHTS ARE BANKS (5%), STAPLES (5%) AND TELCOS (3%)
THE MAIN UNDERWEIGHTS ARE FERTILIZERS (-4%) AND BASE METALS (-4%)
OUR GOAL IS TO PARTICIPATE IN ANY MARKET UPSIDE WHILE HOLDING NAMES THAT SHOULD PROTECT THE DOWNSIDE
| Page 12CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYThe Key Issues
THE POSITIVES
Economic Indicators Have Turned Up
Strong Growth in Asia (China)
Interest Rates Are Low, Credit Is Easy
Consumer Confidence Is Improving
Corporate Profits Are Stronger Than In Past Recessions
Valuations Are Fair If Earnings Meet Expectations
Many Investors Have Been Skeptical Throughout The Entire Rally
Investors Still In Money Market Funds
THE CONCERNS
Job Growth and Consumer Spending
Will The Fed/Bank of Canada Tighten?
Will The Economic Rebound Fizzle & Need More Stimulus?
Can China Maintain Its Growth?
Strength/Weakness of $U.S.
Government Deficits and Taxes
Country Risk
| Page 13CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYECONOMIC INDICATORS, EMPLOYMENT ARE IMPROVING
Source: Ned Davis Research, September 30, 2009
Time Before Job Growth
| Page 14CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYLOW INTEREST RATES CONTINUE TO PROVIDE STIMULUS
Source: Ned Davis Research, September 30, 2009
| Page 15CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYWHERE WILL SAVINGS RATE STABILIZE?
| Page 16CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYECONOMIC OUTLOOK – WEAK BUT POSITIVE RECOVERY
Source: CIBC Economic Insights, October 27, 2009
Economists expect weaker growth following stimulus
| Page 17CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYRISE IN INTEREST RATES EXPECTED TO BE MODEST
Source: CIBC Economic Insights, October 27, 2009
| Page 18CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYPROFITS HELD IN THIS RECESSION – MORE ROOM TO HIRE
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
U.S.: Should we brace for another “job-loss” recovery?Profit margins of non-financial corporations and payroll jobs
%
* Before tax profits as a share of the gross value added of non-financial corporationsNBF Economy & Strategy (BEA data via Global Insight)
Payrolljobs
(quarterly change)
Profit margins*
The 2001 job-loss recoverywas due to unusually depressed profit margins…
…this is not the case this time
around
Source: National Bank Financial, Economic & Financial Outlook, September, 2009
| Page 19CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYCHINA – STRONG CAPITAL SPENDING DRIVING COMMODITIES
Source: Ned Davis Research
| Page 20CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
Analyst Estimates 2009 2010
Dec 31, 2008 $840 $1005
Feb 28, 2009 $713 $872
Apr 30, 2009 $653 $812
Aug 31, 2009 $618 $789
Oct 30, 2009 $623 $790
Source: TD Newcrest, Investment Strategy, September 2, 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYTOP-DOWN & BOTTOM-UP ESTIMATES HAVE STABILIZED
| Page 21CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYSTOCK VALUATIONS ARE IN NEUTRAL TERRITORY
Source: TD Newcrest Investment Strategy, September 2, 2009
| Page 22CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYCOMMODITIES – OIL, GAS, COPPER, GOLD
Source: Reuters StockVal November 24, 2009
Oil
Gas
Copper
Gold
| Page 23CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYBANKS FAIRLY VALUED BUT SOLID YIELDS
Source: Thomson One IM Estimates November 24, 2009
EPS P/E
Price 2009E 2010E 2011E 2010 2011 Yield
BMO $53.80 $4.20 $4.15 $5.11 12.96 10.53 5.22%
BNS $49.62 $3.57 $3.60 $4.45 13.78 11.15 3.96%
CM $68.88 $5.81 $5.78 $6.72 11.92 10.25 5.06%
NA $63.43 $6.31 $5.97 $6.63 10.62 9.57 3.91%
RY $58.09 $4.43 $4.37 $5.16 13.29 11.26 3.45%
TD $67.41 $5.35 $5.46 $6.45 12.35 10.45 3.62%
Totals 12.49 10.53 4.2%
| Page 24CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYWHICH SECTORS LEAD AFTER A RECESSION?
Asset/Sector Performance in Period of U.S. Recession
6-M Before First Half 2nd Half 12-M AfterRecession of Recession of Recession Recession
S&P 500 -3% -10% 13% 8%
S&P 500 (C$) 1 -1% -9% 11% 10%S&P/TSX 0% -11% 10% 7%
DXY 2 3% 0% 1% 5%
USD-CAD 1 -1% 0% -1% -1%
S&P/TSX SectorsTechnology 1% -11% 11% 21%
Discretionary 3 -6% -10% 9% 21%
Staples 3 -1% -5% 10% 16%Metals-Mining 13% -16% 9% 11%Energy 6% -16% 11% 8%
Industrials 3 -3% -14% 10% 8%Financials -1% -7% 14% 7%Utilities 1% -7% 12% 4%Telecom -6% 0% 7% 3%Gold 7% 1% 15% -5%Recession and economic peak define by NBER (Recession: '61, '70, '75, '80, '82, '91 and '01).
1: Since 1971. 2: Since 1967
3: We use historical sub-industry performance as a proxy for the group prior to Dec. 1987.
Source: Scotia Capital, NBER
Average Performance Since 1960
Source: Scotia Strategic Edge Report, September 2009
| Page 25CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
MARKET COMMENTARYWHEN WILL INVESTORS SHIFT OUT OF MONEY MARKET?
U.S. Mutual Funds -- Money Market Assets As % of Total Assets (%)
Source: Scotia Capital, ICI
36%
43%
23%
36%
24%
47%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
50%1
98
6
198
8
199
0
199
2
199
4
199
6
199
8
200
0
200
2
200
4
200
6
Oct
-08
De
c-08
Feb
-09
Apr-
09
Jun-0
9
Aug
-09
Source: Scotia Strategic Edge Report, September 2009
| Page 26CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
CONCLUSIONS
WE BELIEVE THE GLOBAL ECONOMY IS PAST THE BOTTOM
THE KEY QUESTION IS WHETHER INVESTORS ARE EXPECTING TOO FAST A RECOVERY
THERE IS ROOM FOR A MARKET CORRECTION ON ANY DISAPPOINTING ECONOMIC OR EARNINGS NEWS, BUT WE DO NOT EXPECT IT TO BE MAJOR
OUR STRATEGY CONTINUES TO BE FOCUS ON STOCKS THAT SHOW THE BEST VALUE MAINTAIN A BALANCE OF CYCLICALS VS NON-CYCLICALS EMPHASIZE STOCKS THAT PAY DIVIDENDS AND CAN GROW THOSE DIVIDENDS
| Page 27CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. November 2009
“This presentation is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute investment advice nor does it constitute an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities referred to. This information contained in this presentation has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable and is believed to be accurate at the time of publishing, but we do not represent that it is accurate or
complete and it should not be relied upon as such. All opinions and estimates expressed in this presentation are as of the date of publication unless otherwise indicated, and are subject to change. CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. uses multiple investment
styles for its various investment platforms. The views expressed in this document are the views of the Global Equity Team and may differ from the views of other teams. The material and/or its contents may not be reproduced or distributed without the express
written consent of CIBC Asset Management.”
©2008 CIBC Global Asset Management Inc. operates under the brand name of CIBC Asset Management and is a member of the CIBC Group of Companies.
"CIBC Securities Inc. is a wholly-owned subsidiary of CIBC and is the principal distributor of the CIBC Mutual Funds. Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees, and expenses all may be associated with mutual fund investments. Please read the simplified prospectus before investing. To obtain a copy of the CIBC Mutual Funds and CIBC Family of Managed Portfolios simplified prospectus, call CIBC Securities Inc. at 1-800-465-3863. Alternatively, you may obtain a copy from your advisor. Mutual funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently, and past performance may not be repeated.
(tm) CIBC Asset Management and the CIBC logo are registered trademarks of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce."
Any Questions?
THANK YOU