Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A...

77
Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going Beyond the Wheeze Richard M. Schwartzstein, MD Chief, Division of Pulmonary, Critical Care and Sleep Medicine Ellen and Melvin Gordon Professor of Medicine Harvard Medical School Director, Shapiro Institute for Education and Research COPYRIGHT

Transcript of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A...

Page 1: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

Education is at the heart of patient care.

A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School

ChronicObstructivePulmonaryDiseaseGoingBeyondtheWheeze

RichardM.Schwartzstein,MD

Chief,DivisionofPulmonary,CriticalCareandSleepMedicine

EllenandMelvinGordonProfessorofMedicine

HarvardMedicalSchool

Director,ShapiroInstituteforEducationandResearch

COPYRIG

HT

Page 2: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Disclosures

• Ihavenorelationshipswithcommercialentities.• IreceivesupportfromtheNIHformyresearchondyspnea.

COPYRIG

HT

Page 3: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GoalsandObjectives• Todescriberecentinsightsintotheepidemiologyand

pathologyofCOPD• ToincorporateknowledgeaboutCOPDphenotypesinto

decision-makingabouttreatmentoptions• Todelineatethekeyelementsofthephysiologyofairflow

obstructioninemphysemaandtheimplicationsoftheseprinciplesforclinicalpractice

• TodetailtheessentialelementsintheevaluationofpatientswithCOPDandtohighlightcommonpitfallsintheassessmentofthesepatients

• TooutlinetherapeuticadvancesinthetreatmentofCOPD

COPYRIG

HT

Page 4: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPD– Definitionincludes:• Chronicairflowobstruction• Rangeofpathologicchangesinthelung(abnormalinflammatoryresponsetonoxiousparticlesorgases)

• Extra-pulmonaryeffects• Theobstructionisprogressive• Mayhaveelementsofairwaysreactivity,i.e.,theobstructionmaybepartiallyreversible

• “Preventableandtreatable.”

COPYRIG

HT

Page 5: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

DiagnosisofCOPD– GOLDUpdate

AJRCCM2017;195:557-582 COP

YRIGHT

Page 6: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPD- Definition“…aclinicalsyndromecharacterized bychronicrespiratorysymptoms, structural abnormalities(airwaysdisease,emphysema, orboth),lung-function impairment (primarilyairflowlimitationthatispoorlyreversible)oranycombinationofthese.”

CelliB,WedzichaJA.NewEnglJMed2019;381:1257-1266.

COPYRIG

HT

Page 7: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPD–oldphenotypes• Chronicbronchitis:productivecoughfor3months ineachof2consecutive years

• Emphysema: abnormalpermanentenlargementoftheairspacesdistaltotheterminalbronchioles, accompaniedbydestructionoftheirwalls,andwithoutevidenceoffibrosis

• Other:bronchiectasis, airwayreactivity

COPYRIG

HT

Page 8: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDPhenotypesareGrowing• Hersh etal.,COPD2007;4:33191patientsearlyonset,severeCOPD(FEV1<40%pred):emphysemapredominant,lowFEV1,lessbronchospasm

• Friedlanderetal.,COPD2007;4:355“Frequentexacerbater,”pulmonarycachectic,rapiddecliner,airwayshyperresponsive,impairedexercisetolerance

• Jankowich andRounds,Chest2012;141:222 (review)Combinedpulmonaryfibrosisandemphysemasyndrome;spiro maybenormal,butCTwithextensiveemphysema

COPYRIG

HT

Page 9: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

FrequentExacerbator

2138 pts-ECLIPSE study (Eval of COPD Longitudinally to Identify Predictive Surrogate End points). Exacerbation freq in 3 yrs. Multivariate analysis. New Engl J Med 363:1128, 2010

COPYRIG

HT

Page 10: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDEPIDEMIOLOGY:StillGrowingNewEnglJMed2019;381:1257-1266

COPYRIG

HT

Page 11: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GOLDClassificationGlobalInitiativeforChronicObstructiveLung Disease

AmJRespCritCareMed176;532-555,2007

COPYRIG

HT

Page 12: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

ShouldPeoplebeScreened forCOPDwithSpiro?• Linetal.,AnnIntMed2008;148:535

– USPreventativeServicesTaskForce– Metaanalysis- couldyoupreventCOPDexacerbations?Reducemorbidityandmortality?Enhancesmokingcessation?

– Screen833ptstoprevent1COPDexacerbation– NodatatosuggestdecreaseM&M– Nodatatosupportenhancedsmokingcessation

• Note:FEV1/FVCratiodeclineswithnormalaging• Controversyabout“smalllungs”ingrowthanddevelopment

COPYRIG

HT

Page 13: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

LungSizeatBirth:DiagnosisofCOPDNewEnglJMed2019:381;1248-1256

COPYRIG

HT

Page 14: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

RateofHospitalizationforCOPD(comparedtoCAD)PersistsDespite

DecreaseinSmoking

Likely related to aging population.AJRCCM 2017;195:287-291.

COPYRIG

HT

Page 15: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDMortality• “Chroniclowerrespiratorydisease”nowthethirdleadingcauseofdeathintheUS.

• Numberofwomendying>men(studiessuggestwomenmaybemoresusceptibletocigs:Silvermanetal.AJRCCM2000;162:2152)

• Onlydiseaseintop10à mortality increasing.• Evensmokers<1ppdhaveé mortalitycomparedtonon-smokers Inoue-Choietal.JAMAIntMed2017

COPYRIG

HT

Page 16: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPD- CausesofDeathpulm>cardiovasc>cancer NEJM356;851854,2007

COPYRIG

HT

Page 17: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPD- RiskFactors• Cigarettes- activeandpassivesmoking(30-50%ofcurrent/formersmokershaveairflowobstruction)

• Airwaysreactivity:“DutchHypothesis”– commonlinksbetweenCOPDandasthma

• Geneticsusceptibility– alpha1anti- trypsindeficiency– Othergenesmayexplainvariabilityinriskwithsmoking

• Bacterial,viralinfections;cigsmokereducesimmuneresponse– interferon,IL-1(Chest143:196,2013)

• Airpollutionandoccupationalexposures

COPYRIG

HT

Page 18: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

SmokingasRisk:duration>intensity

Smokingdurationgreaterriskforemphysemathancigarettesperday

Thorax 2018;73:414-421

COPYRIG

HT

Page 19: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

DutchHypothesis• Firstproposedin1961• Threeprinciples

– VariousformsofCOPDhaveoverlappingfeatures– Oneformofobstructivelungdisease(asthma)mayevolveintoanother(COPD)

– Developmentofobstructivelungdiseaseresultofcombinationof:1)inflammationandairwayreactivity2)geneticpredisposition3)environmentalfactors

COPYRIG

HT

Page 20: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Asthma-COPDOverlapSyndrome(ACOS)

Chest 2019;155:168-177Estimated present in 15-45% of people with obstructive lung disease

COPYRIG

HT

Page 21: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Emphysema(lungsmorecompliant)inNonsmokingAsthmaPatients

Chest 2018;153;6118-629

COPYRIG

HT

Page 22: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GeneticRiskFactors• Alpha1anti-trypsin• 30-50%oflungfunctionmaybedeterminedbygenetics;susceptibilitytoCOPDlikelypolygenic.Familystudies:SiblingsofCOPDpatientsincreasedrisk

AmJRespirCritCareMed164:1419, 2001• Genesactivatedbysmokingmayleadtodisease(Chest133:1344, 2008)OR maybeprotective(protectivegenesinpromoterregionMMP12associatedwithhigherFEV1,reducedriskofCOPD-NewEnglJMed361:2599,2009)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 23: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GeneticsandDiseaseInsights• COPDGeneStudy

– Analysisof2500peopleofAfricanandEuropeanancestry;multivariatelogisticregressionmodeling

– African-Americansmorelikelytohaveearlyonsetdisease

AmJRespirCritCareMed2011;184:414-420• GeneticsandCOPDphenotypes

– 12,031subjects– Fivelociidentifiedwithemphysemarelatedphenotypes,onewithairway,twowithgastrapping

AmJRespirCritCareMed2015;192:559-569

COPYRIG

HT

Page 24: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Smoking® Inflammation• Inflammation- increasedneutrophilsinmucosa;increasedCD-8cellsinsubepithelium.

MaestrelliP.AmJRespirCritCareMed2001

• LVHmorecommoninCOPDpts(evenwithnormalO2levels)withouthxofhypertensionc/wcontrols

Andersonetal.Chest143:91,2013

• Datafeedscontroversyaboutsteroidsandanti-oxidants

COPYRIG

HT

Page 25: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PresenceofIL-17AinLungTissueandSeverityofDiseaseAmJRespirCritCareMed2016:193:1092-1100

COPYRIG

HT

Page 26: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Mepolizumab– AntibodytoInterleukin5• Phase3trial;

randomized,placebo,doubleblinded

• 462patients;eosinophilicphenotype(eos150-300/ml);highdoseICS

• Reducedcumulativeexacerbationsover52weekswhenaddedtosteroids

COPYRIG

HT

Page 27: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

MuscleDysfunctioninCOPDSystemiccatabolicstate?

Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2015;191:616COP

YRIGHT

Page 28: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

MuscleDysfunctioninCOPDAm J Resp Crit Care Med2018;198;175-186

COPYRIG

HT

Page 29: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDPhysiology

• Lossofelasticrecoil• Airwaysobstruction- the‘equalpressurepoint’

• Hyperinflation• AutoPEEPCOPYRIG

HT

Page 30: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

LungParenchymasupportsAirwaysSchwartzsteinRM,ParkerMJ,RespiratoryPhysiology2005

COPYRIG

HT

Page 31: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Hyperinflation

• Shorteningofmusclesleadstoamechanicaldisadvantageintheattempttogeneratenegativeintra-pleuralpressure

• Contributestothedevelopmentofventilatorymusclefatigue

• Maystimulatechestwallreceptorscontributingtodyspnea

COPYRIG

HT

Page 32: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Auto-PEEP

• Persistenceofpositivepressureintheairwaysattheendofexhalation

• Associatedwithhyperinflation• Resultsinanadditionalburdenduringinspiration- a‘thresholdinspiratoryload’COPYRIG

HT

Page 33: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

AutoPEEP• AutoPEEPaccompaniesexpiratoryflowlimitation

• Heterogeneouslungunitswithvariabletimeconstants(TC=RXC)

• Contributestoworkofbreathing,dyspnea

Marini,AJRCCM2011;184:756

COPYRIG

HT

Page 34: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Dyspnea:Morethanyouthought…• Basicphysiologyofdyspnea iscomplex- manyfactorscontributetorespiratorydiscomfort

• Thequalitiesofrespiratorydiscomfort vary;mayprovideinsightintotheetiologyofthedyspnea

• Levelofdyspneamore closelycorrelatedwith5-yearsurvival thanFEV1(Chest121:1434, 2002)

• Dailyphysicalactivity isindependentpredictorformortalityandhospitalizationduetoexacerbation (Chest142:338, 2012;andThorax67:117,2012)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 35: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

DescriptorsofDyspnea• Mybreathdoesnotgoinall

theway• Mybreathingrequireseffort• IfeelthatIamsmothering• I feelahungerformoreair• Mybreathingisheavy• Icannottakeadeepbreath• Ifeeloutofbreath• Mychestfeelstight• Mybreathingrequiresmore

work

• IfeelthatIamsuffocating• Ifeelthatmybreathstops• Iamgaspingforbreath• Mychestisconstricted• Mybreathingisrapid• Mybreathingisshallow• IfeelthatIambreathingmore• Icannotgetenoughair• Mybreathdoesnotgooutall

theway

COPYRIG

HT

Page 36: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PhysiologyofDyspnea• ‘Tightness, constriction’ - bronchospasm• ‘Urgetobreathe,airhunger’- increasedrespiratorydrive:e.g.,CO2,severeasthma, CHF

• ‘Effortofworkofbreathing’ - increasedmechanical impedance

• ‘Unsatisfied inspiratory effort’ - hyperinflation• ‘Heavybreathing, breathingmore’-deconditioning

COPYRIG

HT

Page 37: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PulmonaryFunctionTests• Spirometry - maybemoreconsistent inCOPDthanarepeakflows

• Lungvolumes- airtrapping, hyperinflation;bewareofimpactofbullousdiseaseonheliumdilutionmeasurements oflungvolumes

• Diffusingcapacity- predictiveofdesaturation• Flowvolume loop- mayhelpdistinguish“pure”emphysemaandasthma

COPYRIG

HT

Page 38: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PFT’sinCOPD

COPYRIG

HT

Page 39: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Flow-volumeCurveinCOPD

COPYRIG

HT

Page 40: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Oximetry• Assessoxygenationatrest• Desaturationonexercise(correlatewithlowdiffusingcapacityPFT’s)

• Considernocturnaloximetryifevidenceofrightheartfailureorpolycythemia

• Increasingdataonroleofpulmonaryhypertensionasfactorindecreasedexercisecapacity

COPYRIG

HT

Page 41: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

It’sNeverTooLateToStopSmokingSchwartzsteinRM

Smokers lose one decade of life expectancy; stop by age 40, reduces risk by 90%NEJM 368:4, 2013

COPYRIG

HT

Page 42: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

SmokingCessation:Multi-prongedApproach• Behavioral(telephoneandgroupcounseling)andpharmacotherapyinterventionscombinedbestresults

• PatnodeCDetal.AnnIntMed,2015-- ReviewofreviewsforUSPreventiveServicesTaskForce– Behavioralinterventions(phone,counseling,etc.)pluspharmacotherapy1.76oddsratioofsuccesscomparedtousualcare

– Nicotinereplacement,buproprionandvareniclinealleffective(vareniclinemosteffective)

• Quitesmokingà reducedriskofdementia(Choietal.AnnClinandTranslationalNeuro2018)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 43: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

ElectronicCigarettesNEJM2016;375:1372-1381

• Batteryoperated,nicotinedeliverydevices;producevaporwithnicotineandpropyleneglycolorglycerol

• 18%quitsmokingwithe-Cigsinrandomizedtrialc/w10%incontrol(standardnicotinereplacement;lowersuccessratethanmoststudies)(NEJM2019;380:629)

• 1/3ofusershaveneversmokedcigarettes;vapormaycontainformaldehydeandothercarcinogensà recentmini-epidemicofacutelungreactionsanddeaths(NEJMSeptember6,2019- epub)

• Nicotinemaybe“gatewaydrug;”associatedwithotherdrugabuse(NEJM2014;371:932);particularproblemforadolescentssusceptibletoaddiction(AnnIntMed2015;163:59-60)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 44: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

E-CigarettesandSmokingCessation• Supplementaryuseofe-cigsforpatientsbeingdischargedfromhospitalwithgoalofsmokingcessationà lessabstinencefromsmokingat6months(Rigottietal.,AnnIntMed2018)

• PopulationstudyinEurope;cross-sectionallogisticalregressionofassociationofe-cigsandbeingformersmokerà e-cigsassociatedwithloweroddsofbeingaformersmoker(Kuliketal.,AmJPrevMed2018;54:603-609)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 45: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

BronchodilatorsinCOPDInspirationorExpiration?

• Taubeetal.AJRCCM162:216,2000

– Betaagonists:∆FIV1(inspiratoryflow!)bestpredictorofdecreaseddyspnea;∆ICalsobetterthanFEV1.

• O’Donnelletal.EurRespirJ.18:914,2002

– Postsalbutamol,83%ofpatientsimprovedlungvolumemeasurements,i.e.,lesshyperinflation,inabsenceof∆FEV1

• Cellietal.Chest124:1743,2003

— TiotropiumincreasedICmorethanFEV1

COPYRIG

HT

Page 46: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GoalsofTherapyinCOPD?• FEV1– severity• ChangeinFEV1–progression

• Exacerbations–activity

• Qualityoflife,symptoms– Impactonpatient

• Future:biomarkers;diseaseactivity Am J Resp Crit Care Med 2016;194:541-549

COPYRIG

HT

Page 47: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GoalsofTherapyinCOPDEvolving

Am J Resp Crit Care Med 2016;194:541-549COPYRIG

HT

Page 48: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

LABA+LAMAvs.LABA+ICSNEJM2016;374:2222-2234

• Indacterol+GlycopyrroniumvsSalmeterol+Fluticasone

• 11%reductioninannualrateofCOPDexacerbationwithoutsteroids

• Absoluteratereduction:4.03to3.59

Time to First Exacerbation

COPYRIG

HT

Page 49: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

WithdrawalofInhaledSteroidsDecreasesPFTsNEJM2014;371:1285

• 2485pts,hxofCOPDexacerbation;tio+salmeterol+ICS

• RandomlyassignedtostopICSover12weeks

• NodiffinexacerbationsbutgreaterdeclineinFEV1withstopinICS

AJRCCM2017;195:1189

• ↑bloodeos→↑riskexacerbationpoststoppingICS

COPYRIG

HT

Page 50: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

De-escalationofTripleTherapyandIncreasedExacerbations:Assoc.WithEosOverall,smalldecreaseinFEV1withnodiff.inexacerbations.HigherexacerbationriskandfallFEV1inpts.with> 300bloodeos/microliter

Am J Resp Crit Care Med 2018;198;329-339

COPYRIG

HT

Page 51: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GOLDSummaryonBronchodilators

COPYRIG

HT

Page 52: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Corticosteroids• Approximately1/3ofpatientswillrespondtosteroidswithimprovedlungfunction

• Cannotpredictwhichpatientswillrespondbasedonpreandpostbronchodilatorchallengewithbetaagonist

• SmallchangesinFEV1maymakebigchangesindyspnea

• Increasingevidenceonroleofbloodeosinophilsasmarkerforresponsiveness

COPYRIG

HT

Page 53: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PneumoniaandMortalityinCOPD• LimitsofstudiesofpneumoniainCOPDandICS

– Riskofbias– Lackofsystematicascertainmentofpneumonia;dependenceonadverseriskreporting

– Retrospective,observationalstudydesigns

• Noevidenceofincreasedmortality• Possible“double-effect”– anadverseeffectplusanunexplainedmitigatingeffect;ICSmayimprovemortality

AmJRespirCritCareMed2015;191:141-148

COPYRIG

HT

Page 54: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

InhaledSteroidsandPneumonia• CochraneDatabaseSystematicReview2014

– Randomizedcontrolledstudies;atleast12weeksduration

– BudesonideorFluticasonevs.placebowith/withoutLABA

– ICSincreasednon-fatalseriousadversepneumoniaevents,i.e.,requirehospitaladmission

– Nodifferenceinoverallmortalityrates

COPYRIG

HT

Page 55: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

ICSAssociatedwithLowerRiskofHospitalizationinOlderPtswithCOPD

Retrospective longitudinal population cohort age > 66 with COPD in Canada.Exposure = new receipt of ICS.Y-axis = proportion free of hospitalization.AnnalsATS 2019;16:1252-1262

ICS

No ICSCOPYRIG

HT

Page 56: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

InhaledSteroidsandRiskofTBandFlu

• Systematicreview;randomized,controlledtrials– 25forTB(showningraph),26forinfluenza

• HigherriskforTB(butfewevents);nodifferenceforflu

Chest 2014;145:1286

COPYRIG

HT

Page 57: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

ProphylacticAntibioticsandCOPDExacerbations

• CochraneReview2013• SevenRCTs;studiesinvolvedmacrolideseithercontinuousorintermittent;duration3to36months

• Results:numberofpatientsexperiencingexacerbationsreducedfrom69to54%;statisticallybutnotclinicallysignificant↑QOL

• Nomajorproblemswithresistantorganisms

COPYRIG

HT

Page 58: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Azithromycinfor3monthsforHospitalizedCOPDExacerbations

• Randomized,double-blinded,placebocontrolled• PatientshospitalizedforCOPDexacerbation;randomizedwithin48hourstoazithromycinvsplacebofor3months(addedtostandardtreatmentwithsteroidsandin-hospitalantibiotics).

• Followedfor6months;treatmentfailure(increaseinmedsorhospitalization)was49%intreatmentgroup;60%inplacebo

Vermeersch K,etal.AmJRespir Crit CareMed- October2019- epub

COPYRIG

HT

Page 59: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDReadmissions– onlyhalfduetoRespiratoryillness

• 26millionadmits• 3.5%COPD• 20.2%readmitin30days;onlyhalfduetorespillness

• Dualmedicare–medicaidhigherrisk

Chest 2015;147:1219

COPYRIG

HT

Page 60: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

KeyPointsonAnti-Inflammatories

COPYRIG

HT

Page 61: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

OxygenTherapy- IndicationsChest 138:179, 2010

Note: use of O2 for sats 89-93 with mild exercise desat–no mortality benefitNEJM 2016;375:1617.

COPYRIG

HT

Page 62: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

OxygenandMortality• COT– continuousoxygentherapy(24hrs/day)

• MRC– MedicalResearchCouncil(15hrs/day)

• NOT– nocturnaloxygentrial

Chest138:179,2010

COPYRIG

HT

Page 63: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Roflumilast– Phosphodiesterate4Inhibitor• Anti-inflammatoryagent• 2placebo-controlled,multi-

centertrials;note:inhaledsteroidsstopped

• 3091pts,overage40,FEV1<50%predicted

• Roflumilast500mcg/day• Exacerbationsreduced1.37

to1.14(p<0.003)• FEV1increased48ml

• Calverleyetal.Lancet2009;374:686

Roflumilast reduced frequency of exacerbations in severe COPD patients with freq exacerbator phenotype. Wedzicha et al.Chest 143:1302, 2013; Martinez et al. AJRCCM 2016;194:559-567

Eos > 150 predictor of effect as wellAJRCC 2018;1268

COPYRIG

HT

Page 64: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDandPrognosisThe“BODE”Index

• MultidimensionalgradingsystemthatincorporatesrespiratoryandsystemicexpressionsofCOPDüBody-massindex(B)üAirflowobstruction(O)üDyspnea(D)üExercisecapacity(E)

• HigherBODEscore® greaterriskofhospitalizationanddeathCellietal.NEnglJMed350:1105,2004Ongetal.Chest128:3810,2005

COPYRIG

HT

Page 65: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

NutritionandCOPD• Bodyweighthasindependenteffectonsurvival• Thresholdvalueof25kg/m2 belowwhichmortalityriskincreased

• Possibleroleofsystemicinflammation;notmalnutritionperse.Increasedmarkersofcatabolism,e.g.,IL-6DebigareRetal.Chest124:83,2003

• Inunderweightpatient,unclearweightgainenhancessurvival

• VitDinptswithlowlevelsmayreduceexacerbationsLehoucketal.AnnIntMed156:105,2012

COPYRIG

HT

Page 66: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

Exercise

COPYRIG

HT

Page 67: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PulmonaryRehabilitation• Importanceofdeconditioningasalimitingfactorinmany

patientswithCOPD;• Mechanismofeffectprobablyvarieswithpatient:

1)reconditioning;2)moreefficientuseofbreathingmuscles;3)strengtheningofbreathingmuscles;4)desensitizationtodyspnea

• Upto14%ofptswithCOPDstopexercisingduetolegdiscomfort(FEV144%pred.)Chest144:491,2013

• Patientsreporting“moderateorvigorousphysicalactivity”eachweek,significantreductioninreadmitrateafterexacerbationAnnAmThorSoc11:695;2014

COPYRIG

HT

Page 68: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PulmonaryRehab• Riesetal.,AnnIntMed1995A)IncreasedtreadmillenduranceB)DecreaseddyspneaC)Decreasedmusclefatigue

-- Effectslastedfor12monthsoffollow-up

A

B

CCOPYRIG

HT

Page 69: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

MaintenanceRehabforTwoYears

Afterinitialrehabprogram,groupsrandomizedtorepeatvisitsq2weeksvs.controlworkingontheirown.Maintained6MWDbetterwithsupervision.BaselineFEV1<40%predicted.AJRCCM2017;195:622-629

COPYRIG

HT

Page 70: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

PulmonaryRehab- EfficacyCochraneDatabase; systematicreview2015;February 23

• 65RCT’sreviewed;3822participants• MeanFEV139%predicted• Statistically significant improvement inQOLoutcomes

• Significant increase in6MWTdistance

COPYRIG

HT

Page 71: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDExacerbations

COPYRIG

HT

Page 72: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

VolumeReductionSurgery• Physiologicprinciples:A)reducethehyperinflationofthechest;B)allowmorenormalportionsofthelungtoexpandandreceivegreaterventilation/perfusion

• Appeartobefewercomplicationswiththoracoscopic vsmediansternotomyapproach

• Improvement inQOLmeasures, eg.,physicalandsocialfunctioning, vitality (Chest115:383, 1999)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 73: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

NETTStudySubgroupAnalysis

• PredominantlyUpperLobeEmphysemaand LowExerciseCapacity– Mortalitylowerinsurgeryvsmedicaltherapy(p=0.005)

• Non-upperLobeEmphysemaand HighExerciseCapacity– Mortalityhigherinsurgerythanmedicalgroup(p=0.02)

COPYRIG

HT

Page 74: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

EndobronchialValvesandCoilsHomogeneousemphysema;nocollateralvent;93patients;randomized

• SignificantbutmarginalabsolutechangeinFEV1

• Improvedqualityoflifeat3months

AmJRespir Crit CareMed194:1073,2016

Endocoilscompressemphysematouslung•315pts;bilateralcoils•↑6MWD(10mvslossof7.6m)•ImprovedQOLmeasures•Complications34.8%vs19.1%incontrolJAMA2016;315;2178

COPYRIG

HT

Page 75: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

LungTransplantation

• Singlelungtransplantationissuccessfuldespitetheverycompliantnatureofthelungleftbehind

• Longwaitfordonororgan• Survivalstill50%atfouryearsCOPYRIG

HT

Page 76: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

GOLDSummaryforAdvancedCOPD

COPYRIG

HT

Page 77: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease YRIGHT …...Education is at the heart of patient care. A teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Going

A teaching hospital ofHarvard Medical School

COPDSummary• COPDassociatedwithvaryingphenotypes;roleofinflammationleadstotherapeuticstrategies

• Elasticrecoilkeytophysiologyofemphysema• SmallchangesinFEV1andlungvolumesmayresultinbigchangesindyspnea;hyperinflationmajorconsequenceofobstruction

• FunctionallimitmaynotbefromCOPD;considerrehab• HypoxicpatientsneedsupplementalO2

• Increasinglylinktreatmenttophenotype,impactonpatient

COPYRIG

HT