Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
-
Upload
nick-vella-muskat -
Category
Documents
-
view
223 -
download
0
Transcript of Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
1/23
Nicholas Vella Muskat
Advanced Theory and History
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
2/23
Introduction
Attended Cambridge University and graduated with an
undergraduate degree in Mathematics and Chemistry.
He then went into the Architecture program but was
dissatisfied with it since he wanted to learn to make beautiful
buildings which have a timeless quality (Grabow, 1983).
Alexander did not complete his Architecture degree at
Cambridge but instead went to Harvard to do his PhD.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
3/23
Alexanders design theory was initially based on Cartesian
rationalism for solving design problems.
Problems are broken into their smallest components; each component is solved separately, and then finally synthesized into a
grand solution.
Later on, Alexander moved into almost the opposite direction where the importance to a holistic approach was emphasized.
The development of his design theory can be analysed in 3 stages using his different books as guidelines:
The Rational ApproachThe Emphasis of Wholeness
The Development of Pattern Language
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
4/23
What creates successful design
He uses specific terms to lay out his thoughts such as:
Form, context, fit, misfit, conscious, self conscious
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
Alexander attempts to find out
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
5/23
Spaces around buildings are dealt with afterwards - no
figure/ground
relationship
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
TODAYbuildings are designed as art objects - little
importance to context
During the RENAISSANCE cities in Europe designed buildings and the landscape together as one element Proper fitbetween form and context
Something rarely seen in modernarchitecture
Nuragic and Contemporary
Art Museum, Cagliari, Italy
by Zaha Hadid
Falling Water, Pennsylvania
by Frank Lloyd Wright
The Rational Approach
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
6/23
They are highly context driven -products of their environment
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
Makes important observations between the Unselfconscious(traditional) and Selfconscious(specialised) approach to designing
and building
Alexander states indigenous buildings from traditional societies define good design in architecture
For example if the hut was to break or
culture to change, the inhabitants would
fix the hut in a tiny way
Changes in society were slow - conditions were well adapted to the system of building.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
7/23
Yemen - small country in middle east
Foreign aid in the form of architects and engineers from the West
Yemen already developed their on own unique urban architecture suited to their environment
Foreign professionals built almost everything with reinforced concrete putting their trust in modern
technology and construction systems
Yemen has differential temperature of 30/40 degrees in 24 hours
Thus expansion and contraction cause almost every new construction from concrete to crack and endangered
the structure of the building
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
Alexander argues that rapid changes in technology affect the quality of materials produced
EXAMPLE
In these modern times, change can be caused by the introduction of newsophisticated technology
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
8/23
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
Within a short space of time wealthy Yemeni who wanted the
status of modern houses returned to their traditional homes
This shows that a study of traditional way of creating buildings can enrich our current
built environment
Traditional building material used in Yemen was mud bricks -
allowed for greater error and flexibility
in construction
Studies showed that in a traditional Yemeni house the inside
temperature varied only two degrees while the exterior temperature
fluctuated by 30 degrees
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
9/23
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
A metal face is tested against a steel block.
The face of the block is inked and the metal face
is rubbed against it. Any high spot shows immediately
and demonstrates the misfit of form to the context
Alexander states that the final objective of design is form and the problem of design is to fit form to its context
Alexanders approach is to take care of all the misfits in the physical environment.
The idea of the misfit is a difficult notion to quantify in itself.
Misfits are mismatches between the capacities and
expectations on a form in a specific context.
Form is an important part of design over which designers have control
Contextis also a part of design which puts demands on this form
Example by Alexander to
explain misfit
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
10/23
Notes on the Synthesis of Form 1964
Treating cattle as sacred and village women gossiping while
fetching water or taking a bath
MAIN PROBLEM IN DESIGN : to find all relevant variables of misfit
1)it is difficult to find all the misfits
2) if there isnt enough information on what fits then we might not choose the best
appropriate solution to design and end up creating another misfit
3)the world is not simply divided into fits and misfits
To put the idea of misfits to practice Alexander studies an existing village in
India
Examples of
these misfits
- He identifies 141 misfits
However factors which may be considered a misfit according to Western standards may not be misfits according toEastern ones.
- Linked to culture
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
11/23
A City is Not a Tree 1965
The Emphasis of Wholeness
Planned cities are not working well the way they are planned; as they are planned according to a rational method -.
There is no overlapping of functions thus not allowing for things to work
together
Makes comparison between the tree likeplanned like
cities and the semi-latticenatural cities
Scale model of Brasilia -
Planned city
Traditional cities however grew organically and have a complex
pattern of an overlapping structure.
The landuses in a natural city merge together and are not neatlyzoned and segregated like a planned city.
problems and functions are broken into various categories
London City
Plan -
Natural city
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
12/23
A City is Not a Tree 1965
To explain further we must define a set as a collection ofelements we think as belonging together
Both the tree and the semi-lattice are ways of thinking about how a large collection of manysmall systems go together
to make up a large and complex system
As designers we are concerned with the physical fabric of a city and
usually restrict ourselves to considering sets which are collections of
material elements like people, cars, bricks etc..
When the elements on a set belong together and co operate we call this set of elements a system
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
13/23
A City is Not a Tree 1965
On the corner of the street lies a drug store, and outside the drug store a traffic light. In the entrance of the drug store there is a newsrack
where the days papers are displayed. When the light is red, people who are waiting to cross the street stand idly by the light and since they
have nothing to do, they look at the papers displayed on the newsrack which they can see from where they stand. Some of them just read
the headlines, others actually buy a paper while they wait.
Consider the following example:
This effect makes the newsrack and the traffic light interdependent
The newsrack, the newspapers on it, the money going from peoples pockets to the dime slot, the people who stop at the light and read
papers, traffic light, the electric impulses which make the lights change, the sidewalk which they stand on all form a systemthey all work
together
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
14/23
A City is Not a Tree 1965
For a designer, the physicalunchanging part of the system is of special interest. The news rack, traffic light and sidewalk between them,related as they are, form thefixed part of the system . It is theunchanging part of the system that allows the changing part of the system(people,newspapers,money and electrical impulses) to work.
In this case, one set consists of the newsrack, sidewalk, and traffic light. Another set consists of the drug store itself, with its entry and thenewsrack. Both units overlap somewhat satisifying the semi lattice structure that Alexander uses to describe traditional cities..
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
15/23
A City is Not a Tree 1965
When we have a tree structure, it means that within this structureno piece of any unit is ever connected to other units, except through
the medium of that unit as a whole
City is made up of sectors based on functional land use: residential, commercial, educational, recreational and industrial. All connected together by an efficient
transportation system.
The designers made assumptions about how people were going to use the city without considering the traditional Indian way of life .
Example of the Indian city of Chandigarh:
A linear park area running from north to south through the entire city was provided for the residents but itis hardly used by them. This is because Indians are family oriented and their recreation takes place at home.
The green spaces around the houses and backyard gardens are therefore important because they follow the
traditional pattern very closely.
Many of these problems couldve been avoided if Corbusier had realised the durability of traditions: how
society and the traditional city are related to on another.
Alexander concluded that environmental planners and designers should think of cities in terms of semi-lattices rather than trees.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
16/23
A New Theory of Urban Design 1988
When we say something grows as a whole, we mean that....its new growth emerges from the specific, peculiarstructural nature of its past... We feel this quality very strongly, in the towns which we experience as organic.
1) the whole must grow gradually
2) the whole must be unpredictable - should be unclear how it will develop
or end
3) the whole must becoherent - truly whole and not fragmented
4) the whole must inspire feeling
Such growth requires certain fundamental rules:
Alexander argues that a new process of urban design is required:
...a process which has the creation of wholeness as its overriding purpose, and in
which every increment of construction, no matter how small, is devoted to thispurpose.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
17/23
A Timeless Way of Building and A Pattern Language (1977,1979)
Alexander developed pattern on the way people built and used their physical environment
Alexander believes patterns can provide answers to design problems byacting as a guideline
Each pattern describes a problem which recurs over and overin the environment. Like
words can be strung to form a different sentences, patterns can generate an infinitenumber of design solutions
253 patterns divided into : 1. Towns
2. buildings
3. construction
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
18/23
A Timeless Way of Building and A Pattern Language (1977,1979)
It is important to specify that Pattern language does NOT provide a solution to all design problems.
- each situation is unique.
- important to analyse the problem within its context
T h e e n t r y t o a b u i l d i n gFOR EXAMPLE
- must fully understand the function and purpose of the entry, whether it is for a residential
or an industrial building, the number of people who will use it, the form, and, context of
the building
The 2 books can provide valuable input for the design if the design is visualised
properly
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
19/23
A Timeless Way of Building and A Pattern Language (1977,1979)
Alexander describes two types of order:
Functional order
Functional And
Form
These two order tie the design with human nature and feelings
based on function and efficiency
can be described and analysed objectively
Form orderbased on the experiential factor
can only be described subjectively
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
20/23
Conclusion
Alexander began with a rational approach to design only to then show that it fails to consider the inter-relationship of various parts in planning and design. The example of Chandigarh shows that the city does notrespond to the needs of its residents because it had been conceived of as a tree.In Theory of urban design he emphasises the importance of using wholeness as a basis for urban design andplanning taking an opposite direction to the rational approach he encourages in Synthesis of form.
A Pattern Language and A Timeless Way of Building provide rich material about the patterns of the builtenvironment. The Yemen example shows how the patterns of the traditional way of building and constructioncan be helpful in creating successful design solutions. Designs based on an understanding of patterns have agreater probability to be successful because they are the result ofpeoples experience over time. Pattern Languagecan therefore provide a useful basis for the design of the physical environment.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
21/23
Questions
Alexander began with a rational approach to design only to then show that it fails to consider the inter-
relationship of various parts in planning and design. The example of Chandigarh shows that the city does not
respond to the needs of its residents because it had been conceived of as a tree.
-
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
22/23
References
Alexander, Christopher (1964). Notes on the Synthesis of Form. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
Alexander, Christopher (1966). City is not a Tree.Design. No.206. Feb.issue pp 44-55
Alexander, Christopher (1977). A Pattern Language. New York: Oxford University Press
Alexander, Christopher (1988). A New Theory of Urban Design. New York: Oxford University Press.
http://wiki.uelceca.net/avamsccomputingdesign/files/Notes%2Bon%2Bthe%2Bsynthesis%2Bof%2Bform%2BBD.pdf
http://www.katarxis3.com/Review_Nature_Order.htm
http://www.patternlanguage.com/archives/alexander1.htm
http://www.rudi.net/books/201
http://wiki.uelceca.net/avamsccomputingdesign/files/Notes+on+the+synthesis+of+form+BD.pdfhttp://www.katarxis3.com/Review_Nature_Order.htmhttp://www.patternlanguage.com/archives/alexander1.htmhttp://www.rudi.net/books/201http://www.rudi.net/books/201http://www.patternlanguage.com/archives/alexander1.htmhttp://www.katarxis3.com/Review_Nature_Order.htmhttp://wiki.uelceca.net/avamsccomputingdesign/files/Notes+on+the+synthesis+of+form+BD.pdf -
8/3/2019 Christopher Alexander-Titles 24pt
23/23