Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

download Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

of 22

Transcript of Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    1/22

    Archaeological Institute of Americais collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to American Journal

    of Archaeology.

    http://www.jstor.org

    The Christianization of Space along the via Appia: Changing Landscape in the Suburbs of RomeAuthor(s): Lucrezia SperaSource: American Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 107, No. 1 (Jan., 2003), pp. 23-43Published by: Archaeological Institute of AmericaStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565Accessed: 31-12-2015 16:10 UTC

    F R N SLinked references are available on JSTOR for this article:http://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents

    You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/publisher/aiahttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565http://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contentshttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contentshttp://www.jstor.org/stable/40026565http://www.jstor.org/publisher/aiahttp://www.jstor.org/
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    2/22

    h e

    hristianization

    o

    S p a c e

    a l o n g

    t h

    i a

    A p p i a

    hanging Landscape

    n

    t h u b u r b s

    o R o m e

    LUCREZIA SPERA

    Abstract

    This article examines

    the

    changes

    caused

    by

    the

    Christianization

    f the area

    along

    the Via

    Appia

    between

    the third and seventh

    century

    and its

    implications

    for

    our

    knowledge

    and

    understanding

    of

    the

    evolution

    of

    the suburban

    andscape

    in the Late

    Antique city.During

    the

    mid-Imperialperiod

    this area

    was characterized

    by

    a

    complex system

    of

    roads,

    residential

    districts, arms,

    and

    funerary

    monuments.

    Starting

    rom the late second

    cen-

    tury,

    t was

    increasingly

    devoted

    to the

    creation

    of

    "Chris-

    tian

    spaces,"

    first

    in the form of

    surface

    and

    subterra-

    nean

    funerary complexes,

    and later with churches and

    monuments associatedwith the presence of the martyrs'

    tombs.

    In

    the fourth and

    early

    fifth

    century,

    the

    pres-

    ence of Christian

    cemeteries,

    between the AurelianWall

    and

    the third

    milestone,

    contributed also to the

    growth

    of

    secondary

    access roads to the

    funerarycomplexes.*

    INTRODUCTION

    There has been a

    significant

    increase in re-

    search on suburban Rome

    in

    recent

    years geared

    to

    achieving

    a better

    understanding

    of

    the trans-

    formation that occurred in the area

    beyond

    the

    Aurelian Wall.1There

    are,

    to

    be

    sure,

    problems

    in

    the definition of the extra-urban

    space vaguely

    and

    indiscriminately

    referred

    to

    as "Suburbium"

    or

    "Campagna

    Romana."2

    In

    addition,

    studies of the

    suburban area of the

    city

    have often

    treated the

    evidence of

    funerary

    areas and

    residential sectors

    separately. Finally,

    there has been

    markedly

    little

    interest

    in

    the

    evolution of the

    suburban land-

    scape

    in

    the Medieval

    period.

    This

    paper

    is in-

    tended as a

    contribution to our

    knowledge

    and

    understanding

    of this

    question

    in

    its

    synthesis

    and

    analysis

    of the

    archaeological

    evidence

    relating

    to

    the Christianization of space between the third

    and

    seventh centuries

    along

    the Via

    Appia,

    one of

    several

    main roads

    connecting

    the

    city

    to its im-

    mediate hinterland.

    I

    have chosen to

    focus

    chiefly

    on the Via

    Appia

    as

    it is

    one of the few

    suburban areas of

    the modern

    city

    in which

    intensive

    development

    has not taken

    place,

    resulting

    in

    a

    largely

    intact

    archaeological

    record

    relating

    to the

    period

    under

    study.3

    As I

    hope

    to

    show,

    the

    picture

    that

    emerges

    from the

    evidence is

    of a suburban

    landscape

    profoundly

    changed

    as

    a direct

    result of the

    Christianizationof

    the

    urban core.

    *

    An earlier

    version

    of

    this

    paper

    was

    presented

    at the work-

    shop

    "FromVilla o

    Monastery:

    ransformations

    f

    the Italian

    Landscape

    n

    Late

    Antiquity

    nd n

    the

    Early

    MedievalPeriod"

    of the

    Norwegian

    nstituteat Rome in

    November

    2000.

    1

    am

    particularly

    rateful

    o Anna

    Leone for her

    help

    with the En-

    glishwriting.

    wish o thankBruce

    Hitchnerand LisaFentress

    for

    their

    comments

    and

    their efforts

    in

    editing

    the

    English

    text. Gratitude s also due to the

    AJA nonymous

    reviewer or

    his constructive riticism.

    1

    The

    startingpoint

    of this

    new

    stream n

    the

    study

    of the

    evolution f

    Rome n

    Late

    Antiquity

    as o be seen inthe Lexicon

    Topographicum

    rbisRomae

    the

    first

    volume has been recent-

    lypublished:LaRegina2001 and in thecolloquium"Suburbi-

    um:Dalla crisidel sistemadelleville a

    GregorioMagno," organized

    by

    L'Ecole

    Francaise

    e

    Rome,

    Soprintendenza

    Archeologica

    di

    Roma,

    Sovraintendenza

    Comunale ai Beni

    Culturali,

    and

    PontificiaCommissionedi

    Archeologia

    Sacra,

    16-18

    March

    2000,

    Rome

    (forthcomingproceedings

    include a

    CD with a

    collectionofdata rom newexcavations nd a

    reanalysis

    f

    old

    publications

    with he aim to

    understand

    he area

    surrounding

    the

    city

    defensive

    walls).

    These new data

    have

    to be

    consid-

    ered

    in

    connection with the

    published

    studies

    focusing

    main-

    ly

    on the evolutionof the classical

    city

    n

    Late

    Antiquity

    nd in

    the

    Early

    Medieval

    period:

    ee

    the

    papers

    n

    Christie nd Lose-

    by

    1996;

    n

    Brogiolo

    et al.

    2000;

    and in

    Lavan

    2001;

    on

    Rome

    see

    esp.

    Harris

    1999;

    PaniErmini

    1999.

    These

    articles

    lso

    pro-

    vide a

    complete

    collection of

    the

    large

    existing

    bibliography

    on this

    subject.

    2

    Often

    these

    two

    expressions

    are

    indifferently

    used. Nev-

    ertheless,

    t is

    necessary

    o

    point

    out

    that the

    idea

    of

    "Campa-

    gna

    Romana" s

    modern,

    commonly

    used

    principally

    n

    topo-

    graphical

    tudies

    n

    19thand

    20th

    centuries

    see

    Lanciani1909

    and Tomassetti

    1975-1980).

    Suburbium

    nd

    suburbanus,

    ven

    if

    it is

    literally

    referring

    to the

    space

    "suburben

    i.e.,

    beyond

    the

    city

    the

    area closer to the

    city

    walls),

    has been

    used

    by

    historical

    ourceswitha

    broad

    topographical

    meaning,gener-

    allywithin20-25 miles fromthe citywalls(occasionally t re-

    fers alsotoa

    larger

    distance,

    such as in

    Simmachuswho

    men-

    tions the

    "center

    of

    Spoletium"

    s

    "suburbanus,"

    ecause

    t

    is

    included within

    the 100

    miles

    of

    the

    jurisdiction

    of the urban

    praefectura

    [Simm.

    Epist.

    3.13.2]).

    On these

    problems,

    see

    Champlin

    1982,

    and more

    recently

    La

    Regina

    2001,

    1-2)

    .

    3

    On

    the

    archaeology

    f

    the Via

    Appia,

    ee

    Angelini

    and Fea

    1828;

    Canina

    1853;

    Ripostelli

    and

    Marucchi

    1908;

    Castagnoli

    1956;

    Castagnoli

    t

    al.

    1972;

    Quilici

    1977,

    1989;

    Quilici

    Gigli

    1990;

    FondazioneMemmo

    1997;

    Spera

    1999;

    and

    most

    recent-

    ly,

    Bruni

    et al.

    2001.

    American

    Journal

    of Archaeology

    07

    (2003)

    23-43

    23

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    3/22

    24

    LUCREZIA

    SPERA

    [AJA107

    THE

    SUBURBAN

    AREA

    ALONG

    THE VIA APPIA

    IN

    THE IMPERIAL

    PERIOD:

    A

    STARTING

    POINT

    The

    landscape

    of the Via

    Appia extending up

    to the

    eighth-ninth

    milestone4

    during

    the

    Impe-

    rial period was dominated by residential districts

    linked

    by

    a

    complex system

    of

    secondary

    roads.5

    The

    principal

    axis

    was,

    of

    course,

    the Via

    Appia,

    though

    some

    secondary

    roads connected to the

    Viae Ardeatina and Satricana

    to the

    southwest,6

    and the Via Latina to the northwest.7

    The resi-

    dential areas included

    large private properties,

    such as the

    Triopium

    f Herodes

    Atticus between

    the second and third

    miles,8

    and the villa of the

    Quintilii

    at the fifth mile.9 There were also a

    large

    number of

    buildings containing

    production

    and

    craft

    structures,10

    commercial

    areas,11

    as well as

    sanctuaries,

    including

    a

    temple

    of Mars

    at the first

    milestone, a

    temple

    of Rediculus at the second

    milestone,

    and a

    sanctuary

    of

    Hercules at the

    eighth

    milestone.12 There were

    numerous late

    Re-

    publican

    and

    early Imperial

    tombs,

    whose

    prop-

    erties were

    managed

    either

    by

    families or

    by

    colle-

    gia funeraticia.15Generally, during

    this

    period,

    the

    suburbium eems to

    have been

    characterized

    prin-

    cipally by

    the

    private

    property,

    well

    organized

    by

    functions of the different sector of

    the extramu-

    ral

    territory.

    EARLY CHRISTIAN

    ARCHAEOLOGICAL

    EVIDENCE

    The "Christianization"

    f

    the Via

    Appia appears

    to

    have

    begun

    in the

    late second

    or

    early

    third

    cen-

    tury with the establishment of the first cemeteries

    used

    by

    the

    community

    of

    the Church

    of Rome.14

    Prior to this

    period

    Christians

    were buried

    in the

    same areas as

    pagans.15

    This

    change suggests

    a

    pref-

    erence

    for an

    independent

    burial

    space

    where

    Chris-

    tians,

    reflecting

    a

    growing

    sense of

    community,

    could

    act

    charitably,

    celebrate

    funerary

    rites,

    and

    experi-

    ence death

    as a

    preparation

    for

    the

    resurrection.

    One

    of these

    cemeteries

    sub divo

    was

    built

    in the

    area

    between

    the Via

    Appia

    and

    the Via Ardeatina.

    Excavated

    n

    the

    late 19th

    and

    early

    20th

    centuries,

    it measured

    30

    x

    75

    m,

    and was

    occupied

    by graves

    disposed

    in different

    layers

    so as to

    exploit

    as

    much

    space as possible. Two underground axial galler-

    ies,

    reached

    by parallel

    stairs,

    were

    linked

    by

    cross-

    tunnels,

    with a

    grid pattern

    that

    respected

    the

    edges

    of the

    space

    above

    ground

    in relation with

    the ence-

    inte

    (fig.

    1).

    This

    cemetery

    has

    been

    plausibly

    den-

    tified

    as the one

    managed

    by

    the

    deacon

    and future

    Pope

    Callixtus,

    following

    the decision

    of

    Pope

    Ze-

    firinus

    (A.D.

    199-217).

    16

    Another

    cemetery,

    initiated

    in

    the

    early

    third

    century,

    has been

    identified

    in the

    Praetextatus

    4Theconventionaledgeof the suburbium f Romehasbeen

    established between the

    eighth

    and ninth miles.

    This con-

    ventional subdivisionbetween the

    territory

    f Rome and the

    LatiumVetuswas

    proposed

    for the firsttimein the

    plan by

    H.

    Kiepert

    n CIL

    4(1 887)

    The same

    map

    has been

    republished

    in

    CIL

    6.8.2

    (1996).

    The same convention has

    been also re-

    cently

    used

    in

    the LTUR

    La

    Regina

    2001,

    2).

    5

    For the

    private

    oads,

    see

    Capogrossi

    Colognesi

    1976,

    52-

    64, 197-221, 244-8;

    BeltranLlorisand ArasaGil

    1979-1980.

    6Spera

    1999,

    451-52

    and

    pl.

    2,

    y,6,K,A,o;

    omunedi

    Roma-

    UfficioCarta

    dell'Agro

    1988,

    F.

    24, 559s, 700s,

    and F.

    24,

    598s.

    See also

    Ashby

    1907,

    pl.

    1 Roads

    connecting

    withtheViaSatri-

    cana

    are ound

    n

    De Rossi

    1967,107;Cecchinietal.

    1989-1990,

    115,

    ig.

    78;

    Comunedi Roma-

    Ufficio

    Carta

    dell'Agro

    1988,

    F.

    25,

    501s.

    7Spera1999, 452, 456,pl. 2, e,el,o,o,T;Comune di Roma-

    Ufficio Carta

    dell'Agro

    1988,

    F.

    24-25, 393s,

    126s.

    8For

    Herodes

    Atticus,

    ee Graindor

    979;

    Neugebauer

    1934;

    Rutledge

    1960;

    Dickson1997.The name

    "Tpioniov"ppears

    n

    C/G1.26,3.6280;

    G14.1389-1

    391;

    C/L6.1342.

    Cf.

    Lugli

    1924,

    94-120;

    Quilici

    1968;

    Kammerer-Grothaus

    974;

    PisaniSarto-

    rio and Calza

    1976, 131-41;

    Coarelli

    1981,

    38-43.

    A

    summary

    is found

    in

    Spera

    1999,

    353-5.

    9Ashby

    1909;

    Ricci

    1998;

    Paris

    2000.

    10Manacorda

    979;

    Giitschow

    1938,

    106;

    Spera

    1999, 364,

    n.

    126,

    366.

    11

    E.g.,

    Caediciae abernae

    adomini

    . . . vocatae:Paul.

    39L)

    or

    tabernae

    plurimae,

    near the horti

    Crassipedis

    Cic.

    Q.

    Fr.

    3.7.2;

    Spera

    1999,54,

    363)

    For

    examples

    nearPortaSan

    Sebastiano,

    seeSpera1999, 63-4, 363; or a statio r deversoriumdXhe sixth

    mile,

    Quilici

    1977,

    86;

    Coarelli

    1981, 59;

    Cecchini

    etal. 1989-

    1990,

    119.

    12

    No clear

    archeaological

    vidence

    related

    o these sanctu-

    arieshas

    been recorded.

    Fora

    complete

    bibliography,

    ee

    Spera

    1999,

    50-2

    (on

    the

    temple

    of

    Mars),

    184

    (on

    the

    temple

    of

    Rediculus)

    Coarelli

    1981,

    62-3

    (on

    the

    sanctuary

    f

    Hercules)

    13The ombs

    fall into two

    categories:

    ate

    Republican

    and

    earlyImperial

    monumental

    private

    ombs

    along

    the Via

    Ap-

    pia

    and

    a

    well-organized

    series of

    funerary

    buildings

    lined

    up

    along

    secondary

    roads.

    The latterdate from

    the end

    of

    the first

    century

    A.D. Von

    Hesberg

    1994, 32-8,

    50-5,

    112-

    230,

    passim;

    1987,

    43-60.

    For these

    necropoleis,

    see Fasola

    1984;

    Spera

    1999,

    139-55

    ("della

    Torre

    ta"),

    209-25,

    238-

    9,

    246

    (under

    St.

    Sebastian)

    266-7,

    280-3

    (near

    the circus

    ofMaxentius) L.Fiorelli,NSc1877,272,311-2;R.Lanciani,

    NSc

    1878, 36, 67,

    134-6, 164-6,

    369-70;

    BullCom

    878,

    107-

    19;

    NSc

    1879,

    15-6;

    BullCom

    880,

    46-8

    (Forte

    Appio).

    For

    the

    necropolis

    called "of

    Lucina,"

    ee

    Reekmans

    1964,

    11-

    34;

    Spera

    1999,

    99-108, 373,

    376.

    14

    The

    evidence s earlier

    han that

    recorded

    nside the

    city,

    where information

    or this

    period

    is

    lacking

    or

    only

    partially

    known

    (Pani

    Ermini

    2000,

    withall earlier

    bibliography)

    15FiocchiNicolai

    1997, 121;

    1998,

    13-4.

    16Hyppol.

    Philosoph.,

    .12.14.

    For the

    open-air

    enclosure,

    see

    De Rossi

    1864-1877, 3:498-9;

    Fasola

    1983;

    1986,

    176-82;

    Spera

    1999,

    1

    1

    1-3,

    173.For he callistian

    "area

    ,"

    ee

    De Rossi

    1864-1877,

    vol.

    2;

    Styger

    925-1926;

    Fiocchi

    Nicolai

    1997,123;

    1998, 16-7;

    Spera

    1999, 124-7,

    378-9.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    4/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE

    IN

    THE SUBURBS

    OF ROME 25

    Fig.

    1. Catacomb of Callixtus:enclosure and

    underground

    tunnels of "area

    I"

    Fig.

    2.

    Necropolis

    of Praetextatus:

    pen-air

    graves.

    Courtesy

    of ArchivioCommissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    complex,

    located

    along

    a crosswiseaxis of the Via

    Appia, corresponding

    more or less to the modern

    Appia Pignatelli.17

    t included an enceinte sub divo

    (36

    x

    30

    m)

    with tunnels reached

    by

    two

    stairs that

    respected

    the

    edges

    of

    the enclosure

    (figs.

    2-3).

    On the

    east side of

    the enceinte

    a

    large

    abandoned

    cistern was transformed

    into a burial

    complex

    with

    numerous

    loculi

    dug

    into the walls.

    This structure

    was

    later connected

    to the

    main area

    by

    new tun-

    nels,

    which

    extended

    beyond

    the

    original

    limits

    of

    the enclosure.18

    These two burial

    complexes

    were

    established

    at

    some distance

    from

    the Via

    Appia,

    presumably

    re-

    flecting

    the need for

    undeveloped

    (and less ex-

    pensive)

    space.19

    The

    expanding

    demand

    for

    a col-

    lective

    and

    egalitarian

    funerary space

    must certain-

    ly explain

    the construction

    of

    tunnels,

    now

    widely

    17Spera

    1999, 454-5,

    ns.

    114-7;

    for the Via

    Asinaria,

    see

    also Man

    2001.

    18

    For the

    enclosure,

    see

    Josi

    1932;

    Tolotti

    1978, 160-1;

    Spera

    1999, 192, 375;

    for the earlier

    catacomb,

    Tolotti

    1978;

    Fiocchi Nicolai

    1997, 123; 1998, 18;

    Spera

    1999,

    199-203.

    19

    Many

    cemeteries,

    in

    fact,

    were created

    by private

    dona-

    tions,

    as shown

    by

    their

    toponomy,

    which

    often

    preserves

    he

    memory

    of

    the

    benefactor,

    as

    in

    the

    coemeteriumraetextati

    (Fiocchi

    Nicolai

    1998,

    23).

    The

    Callixtan

    omplex,

    however,

    was

    probably

    urchased

    directly y

    he Church

    of Rome

    (Spera

    1999,373).

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    5/22

    26

    LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    3.

    Necropolis

    f

    Praetextatus:

    he

    original

    unnels

    under he

    enclosure

    understood to be the

    origins

    of the

    catacombs,20

    that occurs

    simultaneously

    with the

    exploitation

    of

    the

    aboveground funerary

    areas.

    Christians were not

    always

    and

    exclusively

    bur-

    ied

    in

    collective

    cemeteries;

    pagan family

    tombs

    were

    occasionally

    used

    for

    the

    insertion

    of Chris-

    tian

    graves.

    For

    instance,

    a

    third-century

    a cassa omb

    decorated with a scene from the

    Jonah

    cycle

    was

    inserted

    into a

    second-century

    columbarium,

    sited

    in

    front of the Circus of Maxentius

    (fig.

    4)

    .21Simi-

    lar

    evidence also has been recorded at the

    necrop-

    olis,

    later covered

    by

    the Basilica of Saint Sebastian.

    Around the

    middle

    of the third

    century

    a

    repre-

    sentation of the "Gadarene madman" from the

    Gospel

    of Matthewwas

    painted

    into the

    decoration

    of the attic of the monumental second-centurymau-

    soleum of Clodius Hermes.

    Evidence

    supporting

    the identification of a

    specifically

    Christian

    iconog-

    raphy

    here included several tombs

    placed

    in

    a cir-

    cle

    in the

    open

    area

    (piazzola)

    ocated

    in

    front of

    this

    mausoleum.

    On some of these an anchor or a

    fish

    was inserted

    into the

    epitaph,

    making

    a covert

    declaration of the

    Christian faith

    (fig.

    5).22

    This

    Christian

    presence

    ad catacumbas

    i.e., the necrop-

    olis

    below Saint

    Sebastian)

    at the

    third

    mile of the

    Via

    Appia

    became more

    evident from

    the

    second

    half of the third

    century

    onward. In

    this

    phase

    the

    burial

    ground

    on the

    piazzola

    was

    buried,

    and a

    new cult area

    dedicated to

    Saints

    Peter and Paul

    was created.23

    This

    change

    was

    perhaps

    brought

    about

    by

    the

    inaccessibility

    of the

    tombs of

    the

    two

    martyrs,

    one at the Vatican

    cemetery

    and the

    other

    along

    the

    Via

    Ostiensis as a result

    of the

    persecu-

    tions of

    Valerian

    in

    A.D.

    257.

    A

    small

    porch, pre-

    ceded

    by

    a

    square

    called

    the triclia

    by

    its

    excavator,24

    preserved

    on its

    walls hundreds of

    inscriptions

    with

    the names of the devotees gathered for the funer-

    ary

    banquets (refrigeria)

    n

    honor

    of the

    two saints

    (fig.

    6).25

    That the

    immediate area was not

    as

    yet

    monopolized

    by

    Christian

    structures is revealed

    by

    the dedication of

    three marble

    altars,

    two to

    the

    God Attis

    and one to

    Jupiter

    by

    the vir

    clarissimus

    20Fiocchi icolai

    1997,122-4;1998,15-24;

    Pergola

    997,

    57-64.

    21Nestori

    969;

    Brandenburg

    984, 0-1;

    Spera

    999,

    80-

    2,

    371.

    22Carletti

    981,287-307.

    23

    Spera

    1999,

    219-20.

    24Styger

    918,

    8-98.The

    space

    was

    onsidered

    y

    Rodolfo

    Lanciani

    Lanciani

    920)

    o be a tavern

    or

    wayfarers

    ecause

    of the

    modesty

    f its

    structure.

    25

    ICUR

    .12097-13096.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    6/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE IN THE SUBURBS OF ROME

    27

    Fig.

    4. The scene from the

    Jonah

    cicle

    in

    the colombarium near the

    Circus of Maxentius.

    (Courtesy

    of

    Archivio

    Commissionedi

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    Fig.

    5. "Piazzola"under the Basilica of Saint Sebastian: loculuswith Christian

    epitaph.

    (Courtesy

    of ArchivioCommissione di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    7/22

    28

    LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    6. The

    "Triclia" edicated to SaintsPeter

    and Paul under the Basilicaof Saint

    Sebastian:

    plastic

    model.

    (Courtesy

    of ArchivioCommissionedi

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    and

    augur

    Lucius Cornelius

    Scipio Orphitus, orga-

    nizer of a

    tauroboliumnd a criobolium

    n

    A.D.

    295.

    26

    Before the

    reign

    of Constantine and the so-called

    Peace of the Church the martyrs' graves were not

    visited

    by many

    devotees.

    They

    were not

    yet

    charac-

    terized

    by

    distinctive

    structures,

    and

    were

    general-

    ly

    similar to other burials

    within the

    cemetery.27

    hus

    the

    martyr Pope

    Sixtus the

    second,

    executed dur-

    ing

    the

    persecution

    of

    Valerian,

    had

    a

    simple

    mensa

    tomb,

    placed

    at the end of a cubiculum f the Callix-

    tan

    complex

    where

    other

    members of the

    clergy

    (nine

    third-century

    popes

    and some African bish-

    ops)

    were buried

    (fig.

    7).28

    TRANSFORMATIONS DURING

    THE

    FOURTH

    CENTURY A.D.

    As seen so

    far,

    the

    relatively undeveloped

    rural

    landscape along

    the

    Via

    Appia provided ample

    space

    for

    its initial

    exploitation

    as a burial area

    by

    the

    emerging

    Christian

    community

    of Rome. This

    process

    of

    exploitation

    gains speed

    and

    takes on

    new forms in the fourth century,most notablyin the

    development

    of

    funerary complexes

    both above-

    and

    underground,

    and

    in

    the

    emergence

    of struc-

    tures

    relating

    to

    the Christian

    cult,

    principally

    con-

    nected with the

    presence

    of the

    martyrs'

    tombs.29

    The New

    Funerary Complexes

    During

    the fourth

    century,

    the

    collective ceme-

    teries of the third

    century,

    such as those

    of Callix-

    tus and

    Praetextatus,

    developed

    in

    an

    unprecedent-

    ed fashion.

    In

    both

    cases the areas

    sub divo were

    enlarged

    with the

    addition of the

    mausolea of

    wealthy

    families

    (fig.

    8).30

    At the same

    time,

    the

    underground

    complexes

    were extended, with new

    nuclei connected

    to the earlier

    tunnels,

    creating

    26

    CIL6.505

    =

    30781,

    506

    =

    30782,

    402.

    This evidence is

    significant

    (but

    not the

    only

    one)

    to

    highlight

    the closeness

    of

    Christian nd

    Pagan unerary

    and cult

    spaces.

    See Verma-

    seren

    1977, 357;

    Chioffi

    1998,

    62;

    Spera

    1999,

    259.

    27

    Spera

    1998,

    21-36.

    28

    Spera

    2000,

    49-50.

    29

    For the

    Christianization f Roman suburbs

    ee,

    in

    gener-

    al,

    Reekmans

    1968, 1989;

    Fiocchi Nicolai

    1997,

    122-34.

    30

    E.g.,

    the mausolea

    of the Cercennii

    nd the Calventii

    n

    Praetextatus

    emetery

    (Windfeld

    Hansen

    1969;

    Rausa

    1997,

    76-87)

    . These mausolea

    became the

    focal

    point

    for other

    modest

    graves:

    lso,

    in the Callixtus

    area,

    during

    excavation,

    De Rossi

    ound numerous ormaeand burials

    on different

    ay-

    ers all

    around the east trichora

    De

    Rossi

    1864-1877,

    vol.

    3,

    tav.

    39;

    Spera

    1999,

    109-11,

    115).

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    8/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATION

    OF SPACE IN

    THE SUBURBS

    OF ROME 29

    Fig.

    7.

    Catacomb

    of Callixtus:cubiculumwithhe tomb of

    Pope

    Sixtus.

    (Courtesy

    of

    ArchivioCommissionedi

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    new ramifications and

    resulting

    in

    a

    more elabo-

    rate network.

    These

    new

    extensions contrasted

    sharply

    with the

    uniformity

    of

    the earlier

    complex-

    es: more

    grandiose

    architectural

    volumes

    were

    ob-

    tained

    by

    the excavation

    of the

    bedrock,

    with

    the

    principal

    aim of

    showing

    off

    privileged

    social

    sta-

    Fig.

    8.

    Necropolis

    of Praetextatus:mausoleum

    of the Calventii.

    Courtesy

    of

    ArchivioCommissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    9/22

    30 LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    9. Catacombof Callixtus:monumental cubiculum.

    (Courtesy

    of

    ArchivioCommissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    tus,

    as

    was the case with the

    open-air

    mausolea

    (fig.

    9)

    .31The same

    features

    are

    evident

    in

    the new

    necro-

    poleis

    of the

    fourth

    century,

    such as the

    complexes

    of

    Marcus and Marcellianus and of Marcus and Bal-

    bina,both of whichwerecreated near the ViaArdeat-

    ina,

    or that "of

    the

    Holy

    Cross,"32

    n the eastern

    side of the Via

    Appia,

    and

    in

    the burial area con-

    nected with the Basilica

    Apostolorum.33

    These new

    complexes

    were located

    within the third

    milestone

    and

    contained both an

    aboveground cemetery

    and

    a catacomb.

    These new

    necropoleis

    marked a

    major

    trans-

    formation

    in

    the earlier

    patterns

    of the suburban

    area.

    Rural areas that were once used for

    farming

    were

    occupied by

    two

    large funerary complexes,

    one associated

    with

    Pope

    Marcus34 nd

    the other

    with

    the

    martyrs

    Marcus and Marcellianus.

    Excava-

    tions

    by

    the

    Trappist

    fathers at the

    beginning

    of

    the

    20th

    century

    demonstrated

    that

    the latter cem-

    etery

    was

    located over a rural villa

    of the

    late Re-

    publican or early Imperial period.35A rural land-

    scape

    can also

    be

    suggested

    from the

    archaeolog-

    ical evidence

    under

    the

    large

    funerary

    basilica

    dedicated

    to

    Pope

    Marcus

    (336)

    and

    partially

    ex-

    cavated

    by

    Vincenzo

    Fiocchi Nicolai

    (fig.

    10)

    .36

    This

    structure and the

    Basilica

    Apostolorum

    later ded-

    icated to Saint

    Sebastian at

    the third

    mile of the

    Via

    Appia

    are "circiform"

    or

    ambulatory

    basilicas,37

    and their

    construction

    changed

    the

    physical

    land-

    scape

    considerably.

    In

    both

    cases the land

    first was

    terraced and leveled

    to create

    large

    areas

    for the

    construction

    of

    imposing

    structures.38

    It is inter-

    31

    Fiocchi Nicolai

    1997, 126,

    esp.

    129-31; 1998,

    41-5. On

    the Callixtus

    complex,

    see

    Spera

    1999,

    123-33, 403;

    on the

    Praetextatus

    atacomb,

    ee Tolotti 1978

    (see

    also

    Spera

    1999,

    199-205,403-4).

    32

    The catacombhasbeen named aftera

    painted

    cross ocat-

    ed

    in

    one of the

    galleries

    n

    the

    complex

    by

    the

    discoverer,

    Antonio Ferrua

    Ferrua1953)

    33

    For the

    cemetery

    of Marcusand

    Marcellianus,

    ee Saint

    Roch

    1999;

    Spera

    1999,

    88-9

    and,

    most

    recently,

    Saint

    Roch

    2001;

    for that of Marcusand

    Balbina,

    see

    Spera

    1999, 80-7;

    2001

    on the catacomb f the

    Holy

    Cross,

    ee Ferrua

    953;

    Spera

    1999,

    178-82.

    For the Basilica

    Apostolorum,

    see

    Spera

    1999,

    252-6.

    34

    Fiocchi Nicolai

    1995;

    Fiocchi

    Nicolai et al.

    1995-1996

    (1999).

    35

    O.

    Marucchi,

    JV&1906, 10-2;

    Nestori

    1990,

    110-1

    (see

    also

    Spera

    1999,

    87-9).

    36

    Fiocchi Nicolai et

    al. 1995-1996

    (1999),

    73-5,

    139-45.

    37

    Six structureswith

    these characteristics

    re

    known

    n

    the

    suburbsof Rome.

    The most

    important

    studies

    on them are

    Krautheimer

    1960;

    Tolotti

    1982;

    Torelli

    1992;

    Jastrzebowska

    1993.

    38Quilici

    1968, 334-7,

    n.

    2;

    De

    Angelis

    Bertolotti

    1983.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    10/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE IN

    THE SUBURBS OF ROME

    31

    Fig.

    10.Ambulatoria-basilicaf

    Pope

    Marcus.

    (Courtesy

    f ArchivioCommissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    esting

    to

    note that the

    complex

    of the

    emperor

    Maxentius,

    which included a

    villa,

    the mausole-

    um of

    Romulus,

    and a

    circus,

    was also undertaken

    during

    the

    same

    period.39

    These simultaneous

    developments highlight

    the

    emerging importance

    of the

    new ecclesiastical

    purchaser

    relative to the

    emperor.

    The basilica of

    Marcus was

    built

    in

    an area

    of ir-

    regular

    landforms,

    where

    substantial

    terracing

    of

    the bedrock

    must have been

    necessary.40

    imilarly,

    the Basilica

    Apostolorum,

    dedicated to

    Sts. Peter

    and

    Paul

    in

    the Constantinian

    period,

    was

    built on

    irregular

    terrain

    covered

    by

    earlier

    buildings

    (fig.

    11).

    Here

    all of the earth and earlier

    structures

    39Pisani artorioand Calza 1976 on the

    villa;

    Rasch 1984

    on

    the

    mausoleum;

    Ioppolo,

    Pisani Sartorio et al. 1999 on

    the circus.

    40Fiocchi

    Nicolai et al.

    1995-1996

    (1999),

    74-5,

    142-5.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    11/22

    32

    LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    11. Basilicaof Saint Sebastian:

    plastic

    model.

    (Courtesy

    of Archivio Commissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    near the Via

    Appia

    (on

    the

    east)

    which

    lay

    at a

    high-

    er

    level,

    were cut

    away,exposing

    traces of the under-

    ground

    tunnels while the lower structures on

    the

    west side were filled in.41The

    huge ambulatory

    ba-

    silicas,

    created as collective

    funerary

    areas,

    also served

    as the focal

    points

    for

    the construction of

    rich mau-

    solea,

    which were

    distributed all

    around

    them42and

    influenced the

    position

    of the catacombs.

    These Christian cemeteries

    were

    the

    principal

    feature of the

    landscape

    between the Aurelian Wall

    and the third milestone of the

    Via

    Appia during

    the

    late fourth and

    early

    fifth

    century.

    New

    roads and

    secondary

    lanes were created to reach the

    funerary

    complexes.

    This

    phenomenon

    is

    particularly

    clear

    in

    the area near the Via

    Ardeatina,

    on the northern

    side of the

    cemetery

    of

    Callixtus,

    where the

    align-

    ment of the stairs of some of the

    underground

    com-

    plexes

    follows that of the basilica of

    Marcus,

    which

    suggests

    the existence of at least

    two new

    tracks that

    were

    used

    to reach the cemeteries

    (fig. 12).43

    The rise of collective Christian cemeteries re-

    duced the number and

    importance

    of

    smaller

    prop-

    erties owned

    privately

    or

    by

    collegia

    r different

    reli-

    gious

    groups.

    A

    few

    are known the

    Jewish

    cata-

    combs44 nd

    the one dedicated

    to devotees

    of

    Mith-

    ras and Sabatius45

    fig.

    13)

    -

    but

    they

    do not seem

    to have

    had much

    impact

    on the

    landscape.

    There

    are

    very

    few

    burials sub divo

    that are

    not connected

    to the

    large

    cemeteries,46

    while

    the

    number of

    pri-

    vate

    underground

    complexes,

    with a limited

    amount

    of

    burials,

    is

    exiguous.47

    Although

    the creation

    of the new

    cemeteries

    must be

    considered

    in the

    light

    of a mass

    phe-

    nomenon of

    Christianization

    that

    included all

    social

    classes,48

    we must consider

    the

    degree

    to

    which

    the new structures

    themselves

    trans-

    formed

    the

    funerary

    customs of the suburbs.

    The

    evidence

    from the

    Via

    Appia

    provides

    a

    signifi-

    cant

    example

    of these

    changes.

    Before the Chris-

    tian

    period

    both

    epigraphic

    evidence

    and his-

    torical

    sources describe

    the

    Roman desire

    for

    commemoration

    in

    the

    eyes

    of

    passers-by.49

    Land-

    owners often built

    their tombs

    within

    the

    limits

    of their

    praedia,

    and

    adjacent

    to

    a

    major

    road

    (fig.

    41

    Spera

    1999,

    esp.

    229-30,

    387-8.

    42

    See

    fig.

    15.

    43

    Spera

    1999,

    455-6 and

    pl.

    2, 6,91,1.

    44Forhe

    Vigna

    Randamm

    atacomb,

    Vismara

    1986,371-8;

    Rutgers

    1990;

    Vitali

    1994,

    25-9;

    Spera

    1999,

    262-5.

    For the

    Vigna

    Cimarra

    atacomb,

    De Rossi

    1867;

    Vismara

    1986, 360;

    Vitali

    1994, 29;

    Spera

    1999, 258, 325-6;

    see also the historical

    discussionn

    Rutgers

    1992.

    45

    For the

    catacombof

    Vibia,

    see Ferrua

    1971,

    1973

    (Spera

    1999,

    174-5).

    46

    E.g., heone whereConstantinian oins havebeenfound,

    located

    near he mausoleum

    of Cecilia

    Metella

    (Cereghino

    nd

    Meogrossi

    1986;

    Spera

    1999, 292,

    392).

    47

    E.g.,

    the

    Schneider

    Hypogeum

    (Ferrua1963)

    or

    the one

    of the Hunters

    (Wumbrand-Stuppach

    927)

    both located

    on

    the east

    side of the Via

    Appia

    (Spera

    1999, 171,

    400-1).

    48Mazzarino

    974,

    esp.

    51-73;

    Sordi

    1984, 79-103;

    Meeks

    1992.

    See also Brown

    1972;

    Pietri

    1978;

    Brown

    1982.

    49Purcell

    987;

    von

    Hesberg

    1994,

    esp.

    32-50;

    see

    also Susi-

    ni

    1978;

    Eck1996.

    On theVia

    Appia,

    within he

    third

    mile,

    Spera

    1999,

    esp.

    347-50.

    Forsome

    images,

    ee Canina

    1853,

    pls.

    2,

    6,

    16-18, 20-21, 25-26, 29-31, 33, 36, 39, 41-42,

    44-47.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    12/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE IN THE

    SUBURBS OF ROME

    33

    Fig.

    12.

    General

    map

    with

    the

    catacombs

    of

    Marcus-Marcellianus nd Balbina at the

    beginning

    of

    fifth

    century:

    1,

    basilica of

    Pope

    Marcus;2,

    catacomb

    of

    Balbina; 3,

    catacomb

    of

    Saints Marcusand Marcellianus.

    (After

    Fiocchi

    Nicolai et al.

    1995-96

    [1999])

    14).50 Of course, many people were buried far

    from their homes inside the

    city.

    In

    the late

    Republican

    and

    early

    Imperial

    periods,

    the in-

    scriptions on some tombs mention not only the

    dead

    person's profession,

    but also the

    area of

    Rome

    in

    which

    they

    worked.51

    50Mansuelli

    978.

    51

    E.g.,

    an

    argentarius

    banker)

    macelli

    magniwas

    buried at

    the fourth mile of

    the Via

    Latina

    (

    CIL

    .9183)

    while another

    manworked

    n

    a wine

    forum,

    perhaps

    on the

    Campus

    Martius,

    and wasburiedbetween the

    eighth

    and

    the

    ninth

    miles of the

    ViaLabicana CIL

    .9182)

    The

    epitaphs

    of two nhabitants f

    Rome,

    a

    crepidarius

    shoemaker)

    deSubura

    CIL6.9284)

    and

    a

    midwifeat

    MonsEsquilinvs

    CIL

    .972

    1

    both come fromTor

    Sapienza,

    on the Via

    Praenestina,

    long

    way

    rom

    the

    center

    of the

    city.

    Some similar

    inscriptions

    were

    found

    along

    this

    route,

    heading

    toward he Via

    Appia.

    The

    epitaphs

    ound far

    from

    the

    city

    wallmention a vinarius

    wine

    seller)

    de

    Velabro

    (CIL6.9993)

    from

    Casal

    Rotondo,

    a

    pigmentariusperfumer)

    in

    vicusLorariusCIL

    .9796)

    found in Torre

    Selci,

    both

    locat-

    ed at the sixth

    mile;

    and a

    margaritariusjeweler)

    de ViaSacra

    (

    CIL

    .9545)

    who

    probably

    ivedat

    the end of the

    Republican

    period,

    was

    buried between the sixth

    and the

    seventh mile of

    the Via

    Appia.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    13/22

  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    14/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE

    IN

    THE

    SUBURBS

    OF ROME

    35

    Fig.

    15. Basilicaof Saint Sebastian:

    plastic

    model with the south-sidemausolea.

    (Courtesy

    f Archivio

    Commissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    From this it

    appears

    that,

    prior

    to

    the

    Christian

    development

    of the

    area,

    there was an

    unregulated

    and

    unsystematic

    quality

    to the

    placement

    of tombs

    as far as the eighth-ninth mile.52In the third and

    fourth

    centuries, however,

    there is notable decrease

    in

    funerary activityalong

    the Via

    Appia, beyond

    the

    zone

    intensively occupied by

    the common

    Christian

    cemeteries,

    that

    is,

    between the third and

    eighth-

    ninth

    mile.53

    Specifically, only

    10

    funerary inscrip-

    tions are known

    beyond

    the third milestone that can

    be dated to the fourth

    century

    A.D. or later as

    op-

    posed

    to the over

    6,000

    Christian

    epitaphs

    from the

    Christian

    complexes along

    the Via

    Appia published

    in

    ICUR4 and 5.

    In

    essence,

    the

    population

    of Rome

    seems to

    have

    accepted

    the creation of an articulat-

    ed network of suburban

    necropoleis,

    ringing

    the

    city

    up

    to the thirdmilestone,

    marking

    a clear break with

    the

    burial

    patterns

    of

    the

    Imperial

    period.

    Senators

    and

    members

    of the

    upper

    classes

    generally

    changed

    their custom

    of

    building

    isolated

    mausolea

    on

    their

    own properties,and began to build them inside the

    collective cemeteries

    (fig.

    15).

    The

    individual

    iden-

    tity

    of the owner

    and

    his

    family

    was

    maintained,

    along

    with

    the

    display

    of his

    wealth,

    but

    now the

    principal

    determinant

    of

    the location

    of the

    tomb was

    the

    vi-

    cinity

    of the tomb

    of a

    martyr.

    This is

    particularly

    rue

    of the

    imperial

    mausolea associated

    with

    some

    of

    the

    major complexes.54

    THE

    CHRISTIAN

    PRESENCE

    IN RURAL

    AREAS

    Beyond

    the

    ring

    of Christian

    complexes

    we find

    cemeteries

    associatedwith

    rural settlements.

    These

    are often

    very simple

    and

    poor,

    and,

    for this

    reason,

    difficult to date with precision. The only example

    52

    Evidenceof

    people working

    n

    the Via

    Sacracomes from

    distinct

    parts

    of the Via

    Appia:

    rom the

    necropolis

    near

    the

    gate

    (

    C/L6.9548,9935, 5287,

    9212)

    from the areaat the third

    mile

    (

    CIL

    .9239)

    aswell as for the

    already

    ited

    margaritarius;

    then two

    inscriptions

    related to

    people

    ab ara marmoreaere

    found

    respectively

    ear Porta

    Capena

    (

    CIL

    .9403)

    and at the

    third-fourthmile of the

    Appia

    (CIL6.10020).

    53Canina

    853,

    9.

    E.g.,

    CIL

    .1428,

    31651

    (a.

    241;

    see Can-

    ina

    1853, 113-5;

    Quilici

    1977,

    70;

    Coarelli

    1981,

    51).

    E.g.,

    the

    sarcophagus

    f L. AnniusOctaviusValerianus

    CIL

    .117

    43)

    third/fourth

    century

    comes

    from the

    Via

    Appia,

    at the sixth

    mile

    (Casal

    Rotondo):

    see Felletti

    Maj

    1976,

    245-7.

    The

    only

    exception

    is the

    site at the fourth

    mile,

    which

    I will

    analyze

    below.

    54

    Examples

    nclude

    Helen's

    mausoleumadduos

    hums

    Guy-

    on

    1987,

    217-9)

    ,

    Constanza's

    mausoleum

    n Sant

    Agnese

    (Fru-

    taz

    1976,

    72-93)

    ,

    and

    Theodosius's

    mausoleum

    near the

    Vat-

    ican Basilica

    (Biering

    and von

    Hesberg

    1987;

    Johnson

    1990,

    38-43;

    Rasch

    1990).

    See also

    Fiocchi

    Nicolai

    1997,

    128.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    15/22

    36 LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    16. The site on the west side of the Via

    Appia (proprieta

    Lugari) map

    of the

    archaeological

    vidence.

    (After

    Ripostelli

    and Marucchi

    1908)

    along

    the via

    Appia

    is a site on the west side at the

    fourth milestone

    excavated at the

    end of the 19th

    century

    (fig.

    16)

    55 t includes a late Roman

    necrop-

    olis located on the remains

    of a

    second-century

    villa

    connected to the

    Via

    Appia by

    a

    private

    ane flanked

    by opus

    mixtum

    walls.56 t the end

    of the fourth

    centu-

    ry

    the road was

    partially

    blocked

    by

    a

    monumental

    tomb in brick,which has recentlybeen excavatedby

    a

    Norwegian

    team. The

    tomb was intended to

    con-

    tain

    sarcophagi,

    but was also

    used for

    burials in

    for-

    mae,

    which

    were covered

    by

    an

    opus

    ectile

    pavement.57

    Two

    sepulchral

    exedrae

    on the sides

    of the

    building

    were

    found,

    while the tombs

    were located in

    the

    open

    area. There

    were also several

    burials in

    amphorae,

    probably

    for

    children,58

    randomly

    distributed

    around

    the abandoned

    spaces

    of

    the

    villa,

    some of

    which were

    intentionally

    restored

    to be

    reused as

    funerary

    areas.59

    The 61

    graves

    recorded

    to date in

    the area

    belong

    to the late

    fourth or

    early

    ifthcentu-

    ry.60 nscriptions,

    lamps,

    and

    decorated

    glassware

    containing Christiansymbolswere also found (fig.

    17).61

    n

    sum,

    the

    site

    appears

    to be a

    large funerary

    complex

    with a

    single

    distinctive

    tomb,

    the

    mausole-

    um

    that

    belonged

    to the dominus

    f the

    fundus

    and

    his

    family.

    The

    high

    number of

    burials

    suggests

    the

    presence

    of a

    settlement

    nearby,

    perhaps

    in

    the villa

    itself; indeed,

    the creation

    of a

    late

    storeroom con-

    taining

    dolia

    was recorded

    during

    the

    excavation.62

    CHRISTIANIZATION F

    SPACEAND

    MARTYRS

    CULTS

    In

    addition to

    the

    expansion

    of

    cemeteries

    in

    the

    fourth

    century,

    the role of

    the

    martyrs'

    cults

    increased. The "Holy Space"that

    they

    defined had

    a

    significant

    new role in

    the

    organization

    of the

    suburbs.

    In

    the course of

    a

    very

    few decades

    new

    basilicas and

    oratories were

    constructed,

    although

    not all of these

    have been

    recovered

    (fig.

    18).

    Many

    of these

    were

    constructed above

    the

    early

    funerary

    complexes:

    for

    example,

    above the

    catacomb of

    Callixtus a

    sanctuary

    was

    constructed over the

    tomb

    of

    Pope

    Zefirinus,

    associated

    with the

    one of

    the

    55

    NSc

    1883, 130, 420-1; 1884, 80,

    104;

    1885,

    71;

    1887,

    277-

    83;1889,272;

    1893,

    33

    (Lanciani

    884,

    54;

    Lanciani

    885,

    104)

    See also

    Lugari

    890,1882,1910;

    Ripostelli

    nd

    Marucchi

    908,

    196-204;mostrecently,WindfeldHansen1990;1996.

    56

    See,

    in

    general,

    Cantino

    Wataghin

    1994,

    esp.

    145- 6 with

    bibliography.

    57

    Windfeld Hansen

    1990,

    1996.

    58

    Becker

    1994.

    For burials

    n

    amphoras,

    see Green

    1977,

    esp.

    47;

    Soren and Soren

    1999,

    463-651

    (esp.

    490s).

    59

    NSc

    1884, 80; 1887, 177-283; 1889, 272; 1893,

    33.

    60

    The excavationsdid not

    identify

    the limits of the cem-

    etery,making

    t

    likely

    that that there were more burials.

    The

    chronological

    imits for this

    cemetery

    are determined

    by

    an

    inscription

    dated

    betweenAD. 365and373

    (/CC/R5.15351),

    a coin

    of

    Constans,

    a

    fragment

    of a

    sarcophagus

    with

    a

    crossat

    either

    side,

    a transenna

    ecoration,

    and a

    stamp

    referring

    to

    the

    emperors

    Valens,Valentinian,

    and Gratian.For the sar-

    cophagus,

    NSclSS7,

    278

    (Deichmann

    etal.

    1967,

    n.

    243, 687,

    856 aresimilarsarcophagi) orthestampon abrick,probably

    CIL

    5.1662

    (Archivio

    Centraledello

    Stato,

    Roma,

    Ministero

    della

    pubblica

    struzione.

    Direzione

    Generate

    Antichita Belle

    Arti,

    2

    versamento: affari

    generali

    -

    scavi e

    antichita

    musei gallerieepinacoteche

    oggetti

    d'artedivisi

    per prov-

    ince:

    busta246

    (Roma

    Suburbio-ViaLatinae

    ia

    Appia)

    .

    4270

    (Relazione

    1882-1883).

    61

    ICUR

    5.15351,

    15427,

    15431;

    NSc

    1887, 277, 279,

    282;

    1889,

    272.

    62

    NSc

    1883, 420-1;

    1884, 80; 1893, 33;

    Spera

    (forthcom-

    ing),

    n. 133. From the

    villa of the

    Quintilii

    comes other

    evi-

    dence connected to

    Christianity.

    An

    alabasterdisc

    (fig.

    17)

    showedthe

    monogram

    of Christ

    and was

    nscribedwitha

    gen-

    itive

    plural

    name,

    perhaps

    [

    Quintili

    arum

    ICUR5.

    5413)

    The

    integration

    s that of

    De Rossi

    (1873,

    88-94);

    most

    recently

    Carletti

    1999,

    16 n.

    12

    (fourth/fifth

    century).

    A

    fourth-centu-

    ry

    nscription,

    discovered

    n

    the

    17th

    century

    at the

    same

    site,

    asksGodfor

    protection

    or the land

    belonging

    to the

    virperfec-

    tissimus ustus

    (ICUR

    .15410;

    see C.

    Lega

    and S.

    Orlandi,

    n

    Di Stefano Manzella1997,270-1). It is possiblethat thissite

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    16/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATION

    OF SPACE IN THE SUBURBS OF ROME 37

    Fig.

    17. Alabaster

    disc with the

    Christgram

    rom the Villa of

    the

    Quintili.

    (After

    De Rossi

    1873)

    Fig.18.Mapwith allsanctuariesn the areaAppia-Ardeatina.

    martyr

    Tarsicius

    (fig.

    19).63

    Not far

    from

    the

    basilica

    dedicated to

    Marcus,

    and close to the sub divo sanc-

    tuary

    of the

    martyrs

    Marcus and

    Marcellianus,

    Pope

    Damasus ordered

    the

    building

    of a tomb for him-

    self, his mother, and his sister at the end of the

    fourth

    century.64

    At

    the

    same time

    another

    complex

    was dedicated

    to Soter

    probably

    on the east side of

    the Via

    Appia,65

    while

    in

    the

    fifth

    century

    Pope

    Leo

    I founded a basilica

    apud corpus

    dedicated to Cor-

    nelius.66 The cult of the

    martyrs

    was

    directly

    related

    to the

    development

    of collective

    open-air

    cemeter-

    ies in the

    period

    between

    the fifth and seventh cen-

    turies,

    when the

    suburban

    necropoleis

    remained

    in

    use,

    although

    there

    is a

    notable decrease

    in

    the

    evidence,

    possibly

    caused

    by

    the

    appearance

    of

    burials

    in

    the

    city

    itself67 and

    to an

    evident decline

    in the

    population

    of Rome after the sack of Alaric.68

    The complexes were transformed into large areas

    retrosanctos,

    or burials near

    martyrs'

    tombs,

    with the

    creation

    of

    privileged

    spaces

    and the reuse of earli-

    er sites

    and

    sepulchral

    structures.69

    For

    instance,

    Fasola

    interpreted

    the

    cemetery

    at Torretta as asso-

    ciated with

    the

    many

    tombs of saints

    in

    the Callix-

    tus

    complex, reoccupying

    an earlier

    necropolis

    at

    the

    beginning

    of the fifth

    century

    with

    poor

    burials

    and a small

    catacomb,

    which reused

    existing

    drain-

    age

    channels.70

    The tombs of the

    martyrs,

    now decorated and

    refurbished,

    also became

    important

    sanctuaries for

    the

    living. They

    continued

    to

    attract

    pilgrims

    even

    after their abandonment as

    funerary

    sites. The cult

    had been

    partially

    nhabited because some

    parts

    of the villa

    were

    clearly

    estored

    during

    Late

    Antiquity

    nd the

    Early

    Mid-

    dle

    Ages.

    Evidence of this can be discerned from the brick

    stamps

    datedtothe

    reign

    of Theodoric oundinthe

    collapsed

    wallsof the smallbaths

    (Ricci

    1986;

    Paris

    2000,

    41)

    or the sev-

    eral late walls dentifiable n different

    parts

    of the

    complex,

    which was

    probably

    ransformed nto a

    farm,

    as shown

    by

    the

    Sustus

    inscription.

    The

    same evidence

    of

    continuity

    of occu-

    pation

    seems to be confirmed

    by

    the burial

    area,

    dated

    to the

    fifth-sixth

    centuries,

    cut in the

    ground,

    at that time

    probably

    a

    swamp,

    and found on the eastern side of the "smallbaths"

    (Ricci

    1991,

    467).

    63Fasola1980.

    64SaintRoch

    986;FiocchiNicolaietal.

    1995-1996

    (1999),

    127-9;

    Spera

    1999,

    91.

    65

    The cult was

    promoted

    by

    the

    BishopAmbrogius

    Spera

    1999,

    part.

    77-8,

    178-81).

    66

    Spera

    1999, 108,415.

    57

    In this

    period,

    in

    fact,

    the

    phenomenon

    of the intra

    moe-

    raas-burials

    egan:

    see

    Meneghini

    and

    Santangeli

    Valenzani

    1993,

    1994.

    68

    On

    demography

    f

    late

    Imperial

    Rome,

    see

    esp.

    Lo Cascio

    1997,

    58-76.

    69

    As

    recently

    shown

    by

    the excavationof the

    ambulatoria-

    basilica

    along

    the

    Via

    Ardeatina,

    where

    the

    upper ayers

    of the

    burial areaswere

    systematically

    eused:Fiocchi Nicolai et al.

    1995-1996

    (1999),

    188-95.

    70Fasola 984, 1985;Spera1999, 139-51, 398, 410.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    17/22

    38 LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Fig.

    19.

    Necropolis

    of Callixtus: he WestTrichora.

    (Courtesy

    of Archivio Commissione

    di

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    areas

    were

    enlarged

    to

    receive

    more

    people.

    In

    the fifth

    century

    a

    small tunnel

    in

    the Balbina cem-

    etery

    was turned into a

    basilica,

    perhaps

    dedicat-

    ed to the Greek martyrs (fig. 20). 71During the

    same

    period, Pope

    Leo

    I

    (440-461)

    ordered the

    building

    of a

    ground

    basilica,

    probably

    near the

    stairs to

    the

    hypogeum,

    to

    preserve

    the under-

    ground

    tomb of Cornelius.72

    Meanwhile

    the old

    cemeteries

    were

    expanded by

    a series of new struc-

    tures

    connected with the

    martyrs'

    cults and the

    reception

    of

    visitors.

    In

    the fifth

    century,

    for exam-

    ple,

    Sixtus III founded

    the first suburban monas-

    tery

    on the Via

    Appia,

    connected to the Basilica

    Apostolorum.73

    CONCLUSION

    Despite

    changes

    in

    the

    organization

    of

    the

    land-

    scape

    connected with the

    funerary complexes

    of

    the Christian

    community,

    the

    course

    of the Via

    Appia

    was not

    affected;

    it

    continued to serve trav-

    elers,

    offering

    them a view of Rome's ancient

    pros-

    perity through

    the

    preservation

    of

    many

    of the

    monumental classical

    buildings.74

    Similar transfor-

    mations,

    it is

    intuitable,

    mark

    generally

    the

    histo-

    ry

    of all Roman

    suburbs from

    Late

    Antiquity

    to the

    Middle

    Ages;

    but

    only

    a

    careful and

    complete

    ar-

    chaeological analysis will reveal exactly the fea-

    tures of

    these

    landscape

    changes.

    The

    complex

    network of sanctuaries

    for which

    evidence

    exists

    in

    the

    pilgrims'

    guides

    of the seventh

    and

    eighth

    centuries is the end

    point

    of the Christianization

    of

    the suburban areas

    developed

    here.75

    The

    ring

    of sites

    outside the

    city

    walls in the seventh

    centu-

    ry,

    before the transfer

    of the

    bodies of

    the

    martyrs

    to the urban

    churches,

    indicates

    the new

    ideology

    defined

    by

    the diffusion

    of the

    Christian

    faith and

    reflected

    in

    the

    organization

    of the suburbs.

    The most

    obvious

    consequence

    of this

    phenom-

    enon is the

    transformation

    of

    private

    into

    public

    and collective

    spaces

    that combined

    funerary

    and

    cult functions

    in

    a

    new

    way.

    Classical

    writers

    men-

    tioned

    horti,

    praedia,

    and

    vMae sometimes

    in con-

    nection with

    sanctuaries

    and mausolea. In the

    Re-

    publican

    and

    early

    Imperial period,

    a denser

    net-

    work of cult

    spaces

    was

    found farther

    out,

    such

    as

    the

    group

    of sanctuaries

    between the fifth and

    the

    71Nestori

    1990;

    Fiocchi Nicolai et al. 1995-1996

    (1999),

    134-5;

    Spera

    1999,

    85-7.

    72

    Supra,

    n.

    66.

    73

    Spera

    1999,

    248.

    74Proc. goth. 1, 14 = La guerragotica di Procopiodi Cesarea.

    Testo

    greco

    emendatosui manoscritti

    on traduzione

    taliana,

    a cura

    di Domenico

    Comparetti,

    ol.

    1,

    Roma

    1895,

    110-1.

    75

    See

    Reekmans

    (1968;

    1989,

    n.

    32);

    most

    recentlySpera

    1998.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    18/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATIONOF SPACE

    IN THE SUBURBS

    OF ROME

    39

    Fig.

    20.

    Cemetery

    of Balbina: he small basilica

    probably

    dedicated

    to the Greek

    martyrs.

    Courtesy

    of Archivio

    Commissionedi

    Archeologia

    Sacra)

    sixth

    milestones,

    where

    they

    functioned as meet-

    ing places

    for

    country people

    for

    religious

    festivals

    such as the

    purification

    of the land and

    the

    propi-

    tiation of the harvest.76The urban population by

    contrast used the

    public spaces

    inside

    the

    city.77

    t

    is

    only

    with the diffusion of

    Christianity

    and the

    acquisition by

    the

    Church

    of

    large

    areas outside

    the

    walls

    that the suburban

    area

    acquire

    a

    new

    and

    important

    "public"

    role.

    Although

    it is not

    possible

    to draw

    general

    schemes,

    especially

    for Late

    Antiquity,

    similar

    trends

    have

    been

    recorded not

    only

    in

    Rome

    but

    in

    other

    regions

    of the

    Mediterranean,

    especially

    in

    Italy,

    Africa

    Proconsularis,

    and Gaul.78There-

    fore

    Christianity

    had an

    important

    role in

    the

    trans-

    formation

    of

    cities

    from

    the

    third

    to seventh

    cen-

    turies

    A.D.,

    in

    both intramural and suburban

    ar-

    eas.

    In

    studies that have focused on extramural

    sectors,

    such as in

    Milan,

    Carthage,

    or in some cit-

    ies of

    Gaul,79

    mportant

    elements of this transfor-

    mation have been

    recorded,

    and these data are

    comparable

    with the information from Rome.

    In

    all of

    them,

    the

    creation

    of

    ecclesiastical

    proper-

    ties related to the

    presence

    of common cemeter-

    ies

    and of

    martyrs'

    sanctuaries

    centers

    of

    devel-

    opment

    and visitation

    are two

    of the

    most

    impor-

    tant

    elements related to the

    evolution of

    subur-

    ban areas in Late Antiquity.

    This article

    represents

    a detailed

    approach

    to

    a

    circumscribed

    suburban

    area

    of

    Rome,

    highlight-

    ing

    that

    a

    development

    of

    new studies

    on the

    sub-

    urbs

    could contribute

    to the

    comprehension

    of

    the transformations

    of

    post-Classical

    cities

    and

    to

    the

    ongoing

    debates

    about the

    continuity

    or dis-

    continuity

    of urban areas.

    Evidence

    presented

    here

    from

    the area of the

    Via

    Appia

    shows

    the slow "de-

    structuring"

    of

    one

    landscape

    followed

    by

    the cre-

    ation of a

    new,

    Christianized

    panorama,

    a

    phenom-

    enon

    that had

    started

    already during

    the

    Roman

    empire.

    UNIVERSITA

    DEGLI

    STUDI

    DI ROMA

    "TOR VERGATA"

    FACOLTA

    DI LETTERE

    DIPARTIMENTO

    DI

    ANTICHITA

    VIA A. CAVAGLIERI

    ROME,

    ITALY

    [email protected]

    76Legal995.

    77

    Regardingconcepts

    of

    public space

    n

    antiquity,

    ee Zac-

    cariaRuggiu

    1995.

    78

    Ageneraldescriptionof these towns s found in Carandi-

    ni

    et

    al. 1993.

    79

    On these

    cities,

    see Rebecchi

    1993;

    Fevrier

    1993;

    Enna-

    bli 1997.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    19/22

    40 LUCREZIASPERA

    [AJA107

    Works Cited

    Angelini,

    G.,

    and

    A.

    Fea.

    1828.

    1

    monumenti

    iii insigni

    del

    Lazio istribuitin viedelineatid ncisi

    da

    Giovanni

    nge-

    lini edAntonio ea

    e

    da

    questo

    llustrati

    on

    osservazioni

    antiquariedichiarati. ol.1, ViaAppia. oma:Societa

    tipografica.

    Ashby,

    T. 1907. The Classical

    Topography

    of the Ro-

    man

    Campagna

    II

    (The

    Via

    Latina)

    "

    PBSR4.1-159.

    . 1909."La illadei

    Quintili."

    A

    usonia :48-88.

    Becker,

    MJ.

    1994."ANote on Children'sBurials

    n

    Cen-

    tral

    Italy:

    The 1978 Excavations t

    a Late Roman

    Se-

    pulchral

    Building

    at the

    Fourth

    Milestone

    along

    the

    Via

    Appia (Proprieta

    Lugari)

    near Rome."ArchNews

    19:15-7.

    Beltran

    Lloris,E,

    and F.ArasaGil. 1979-1980. "Los tin-

    era

    privata

    n la

    epigrafia

    atina:una nueva

    inscrip-

    tion en

    Algimia

    de Almaiacid."

    HispAnt

    -1

    0:7-29.

    Biering

    R.,

    and H. von

    Hesberg.

    1987. "Zur

    Bau-

    und

    Kultgeschichte

    on St. Andreas

    apud

    S.

    Petrum

    Vom

    Phrigianum

    um

    Kenotaph

    Theodosiusd. Gr.?" bm-

    QSchrS2:

    45-82.

    Brandenburg,

    . 1984.

    "Uberlegungen

    u

    Ursprung

    nd

    Entstehung

    der KatakombenRoms."

    n

    'Vivarium':

    Festschrift

    heodor

    lauser

    um90.

    Geburtstag,

    dited

    by

    E. Dassmann nd K.

    Traede,

    11-49.

    Munster:

    Aschen-

    dorff.

    Brogiolo,

    G.P.,

    and S. Gelichi. 1998. La cittanelValtome-

    dioevo

    taliano:

    Archeologia

    storia.Bari:Laterza.

    Brogiolo,

    G.P.,

    and B.

    Ward-Perkins,

    ds. 1999. The dea

    and deal

    of

    theTown

    etween

    ate

    Antiquity

    ndthe

    Early

    Middle

    ges.

    Leiden:Brill.

    Brogiolo,

    G.P.,

    N.

    Gauthier,

    nd

    N.

    Christie,

    eds.

    2000.

    Towns

    nd

    TheirTerritoriesetweenate

    Antiquity

    nd

    he

    Early

    Middle

    Ages.

    Leiden:

    Brill.

    Brown,

    P.

    1972.

    Aspects

    of the Christianization f the

    Roman

    Aristocracy."

    n

    Religion

    nd

    Society

    nthe

    Ageof

    Saint

    Augustine,

    dited

    by

    P.

    Brown,

    161-82.

    London:

    Faberand Faber.

    .

    1982.

    "Dalla

    lebs

    romanaalia

    plebs

    Dei:

    Aspet-

    ti della cristianizzazione i Roma." n Governantiin-

    tellettuali,

    opolo

    di Roma

    popolo

    di Dio

    (I-VI secolo),

    edited

    by

    P.

    Brown,

    L. Cracco

    Ruggini,

    and M. Maz-

    za,

    123-45.

    Torino:

    Giappichelli.

    Bruni,S.,

    R.

    Pans,

    and

    S.

    Mineo.

    2001.

    Appia

    via.

    In

    Lexicon

    opographicum

    rbis

    omae:

    uburbium,

    dited

    by

    V.Fiocchi

    Nicolai,

    M.G.

    Granino,

    and

    Z. Mari.

    Vol.

    1:84-135.Roma:

    Quasar.

    Canina,

    L. 1853.

    Laprimaparte

    ella ia

    Appia

    dallaPorta

    Capena

    Bovillae escrittadimostrataon monumenti

    superstiti

    al

    commendatore

    .

    Canina,

    n

    seguito

    elle

    e-

    golari cavazioni lavoridiversiseguitiperodevoli ispo-

    sizioni

    elGoverno

    Pontificio

    alVanno DCCCLlMDC-

    CCLIIInde

    procurarne

    l ristabilimento.vols.

    Roma:

    G.A.Bertinelli.

    Cantino

    Wataghin,

    G. 1994. "TardoAntico e Altomed-

    ioevo

    nel

    territorio

    padano:

    I territorio." n La storia

    delValto

    medioevo taliano

    (VI-X secolo)

    alia luce

    deW

    rcheologia,

    dited

    by

    R.

    Francovich

    nd G.

    Noye,

    142-50.

    Convegno

    Internazionale,

    2-6

    December

    1992,

    Siena.Firenze:

    All'Insegna

    del

    Giglio.

    Capogrossi

    Colognesi,

    L.

    1976.Lastruttura

    ella

    proprieta

    e

    laformazione

    ei Hura

    praediorum

    nelVeta

    epubblicana.

    Vol.

    2.

    Milano:A. Giuffre.

    Carandini,

    A.,

    L.

    Cracco

    Ruggini,

    and

    A.

    Giardina,

    ds.

    1993. Storiadi Roma.Vol.

    3,

    Leta

    tardoantica,

    t.

    2,

    /

    luoghi

    le culture. orino:

    Einaudi.

    Carletti,

    C. 1981.

    Pagani

    e cnstianinel

    sepolcreto

    della

    'piazzola'

    otto la

    Basilica

    Apostolorum

    a Roma."Vet-

    eraChristianorum8:287-307.

    . 1999. "IX0YE

    ZONTON: Chiose a ICUR II

    4246."

    Vetera hristianorum6:

    15-30.

    Castagnoli,

    F. 1956.

    Appia

    Antica.Milano:

    Domus.

    Castagnoli,

    E,

    A.M.

    Colini,

    and G.Macchia.

    1972.

    La via

    Appia.

    Roma

    and Bari:Banco di

    Roma and

    Dedalo

    litostampe.

    Cecchini, M.G.,

    M.N.

    Pagliardi,

    and

    L. Petrassi.1989-

    1990.

    "ViaAppia:

    ocalitaTorricola."ullCom9?>:\\4-

    21.

    Cereghino

    R.,

    and P.

    Meogrossi.

    986."Tomba i

    Cecilia

    Metella

    circ.

    XI)."

    BullCom1:601-7.

    Champlin,

    E.

    1982.

    "The Suburbiumof

    Rome."

    AJAH

    7:97-117.

    Chioffi,

    L.

    1998.

    Mummificazione

    imbalsamazioneRoma

    ed n altri

    uoghi

    elmondoomano.

    OpuscolaEpigraphi-

    ca 8. Roma:

    Quasar.

    Christie,

    N.,

    and S.T.

    Loseby.

    1996. Townsn Transition:

    Urban volutionn

    Late

    Antiquity

    nd the

    Early

    Middle

    Ages.

    Guildford:Scolar.

    Coarelh,

    F.

    1981. Dintorni iRoma.Ban:

    Laterza.

    Comune di Roma Ufficio Carta

    dell'Agro.

    1988. Carta

    storica

    rcheologica

    onumentale

    paesistica

    elsuburbio

    delVagro

    omano: arco

    dell

    Appia

    Antica.

    Roma: Co-

    mune

    di

    Roma.

    De

    Angelis

    Bertolotti,

    R.

    1983. "Contributi

    lle ricerche

    sull'areamassenzianadell

    Appia

    Antica."

    Archeologia

    Laziale

    :155-62.

    De

    Rossi,

    G.B.

    1864-1877. La

    Roma otterranea

    ristiana

    descritta

    d

    llustrata al

    Cav.

    G.B.

    deRossi.

    Pubblicata

    per

    ordine

    della Santitadi N.S.

    Papa

    Pio

    Nono. 3vols.

    Roma:Cromo-litografiapontificia.

    . 1867.

    "NotizieRoma:

    Scoperta

    d'un cemetero

    giudaicopresso 'Appia."

    BACrist

    (5)

    :16.

    .

    1873. "Carta

    topograficadegli

    antichi

    monu-

    menti cristiani

    nei territori

    Albano e

    Tusculano."

    BA

    Crist

    (4)

    :83-l 17.

    De

    Rossi,

    G.M.1967. Tellenae.

    orma taliae.

    Regio

    I,

    vol.

    4. Roma:De

    Luca.

    Deichmann,F.W.,

    G.

    Bovini,

    and

    H.

    Brandenburg.

    967.

    Repertorium

    er hristlich-antiken

    Sarkophage,

    rsterBand:

    Romund Ostia.

    Wiesbaden:

    Franz

    Steiner.

    Di

    Stefano

    Manzella,

    .,

    ed. 1997.Le

    scrizioniei

    cristianin

    Vaticano: ateriali

    contributi

    cientifici

    er

    unamostra

    epi-

    grafica.

    nscriptiones

    Sanctae Sedis

    2.

    Citta del Vati-

    cano:

    Monumenti,

    Museie

    Gallerie

    Pontificie.

    Dickson,K.M.1997. "HerodesAtticus:The Politics of

    Patronage."

    h.D.

    diss.,

    EmoryUniversity.

    Eck,

    W. 1996. "Iscrizioni

    sepolcrali

    romane:

    ntenzione

    e

    capacita

    di

    messaggio

    nel contesto

    funerario." n

    Tra

    epigrafia, rosopografiaarcheologia,

    dited

    by

    W.

    Eck,

    227-50.

    Roma:

    Quasar.

    Ennabh,

    L. 1997.

    Carthage:

    ne

    metropole

    hretiennee Va

    la

    in

    du VIP

    iecle. aris:CNRS.

    Fasola,

    U.M. 1980.

    "Indagini

    nel

    sopratterra

    ella cata-

    comba

    di S.

    Callisto."RA

    56:221-78.

    .

    1983.

    "Scoperta

    i

    nuovi

    dati

    monumentali

    per

    lo studio dell'area

    prima

    callistiana."

    ACrist

    9:257-

    73.

    This content downloaded from 142.150.190.39 on Thu, 31 Dec 2015 16:10:08 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
  • 7/25/2019 Christianization of Space along Via Appia.pdf

    20/22

    2003]

    CHRISTIANIZATION OF

    SPACE IN THE SUBURBS OF

    ROME

    41

    . 1984. "Un tardo cimitero cristiano inserito in

    una

    necropoli pagana

    della

    via

    Appia

    I: L'area sub

    divo." RACrist

    0:7-42.

    . 1985. "Un tardo cimitero cristiano inserito

    in

    una

    necropoli pagana

    della via

    Appia

    II: La catacom-

    ba." iMCritf 61: 13-57.

    . 1986. "Santuari otterranei di Damaso nelle cata-

    combe romane:

    I

    contributi

    di una recente

    scoperta."

    In baeculanadamasiana:Atti del

    Convegno

    nternazionale

    per

    l XVIcentenario ellamorte i

    papa

    Damaso

    ,

    1

    73-20

    1

    Citta del Vaticano:

    Pontificio Istituto di

    Archeologia

    Cristiana.

    Felletti

    Maj,

    B.M. 1976. "Considerazioni sull'arte del

    periodo

    fra Gallieno

    e la Tetrarchia."

    RACrist

    2:223-

    56.

    Ferrua,

    A. 1953. "La catacomba

    della Santa Croce nel

    predio

    Franchetti." RACrist

    9:7-45.

    . 1963.

    "Un

    piccolo ipogeo sull'Appia

    Antica."

    RACrist 9:175-87.

    . 1971.

    "La

    catacomba

    di

    Vibia." RACrist

    7:7-62

    . 1973. "Lacatacomba diVibiall."

    RACrist 9:131-

    61.

    Fevrier,

    PA. 1993. "Le Gallie meridionali." In Storia di

    Roma.Vol.

    3,

    L'etd

    ardoantica,

    t.

    2,

    Iluoghi

    e le

    culture,

    edited

    by

    A.

    Carandini,

    L.

    Cracco

    Ruggini,

    and A.

    Giardina,

    405-27.

    Torino: Einaudi.

    Fiocchi

    Nicolai,

    V.

    1995.

    "Una nuova basilica a deambu-

    latorio

    nel

    comprensorio

    della catacomba di S. Cal-

    listo a Roma."

    In

    Aktendes

    XII

    Internationalen

    Kongress-

    es

    fur

    christliche

    Archdologie,

    2-28

    September

    1991,

    Bonn,

    776-86. Citta del

    Vaticano,

    Minister: Pontifi-

    cio Istituto di

    Archeologia

    Cristiana,

    Aschendorffsche

    Verlagsbuchhandlung.

    . 1997. Strutture

    funerane ed edihci di culto

    pa-

    leocristiani

    di

    Roma dal

    III

    al VI secolo." In Leiscrizioni

    dei cristiani n Vaticano:Materiali contributi

    scientifici er

    una mostra

    epigrafica,

    dited

    by

    I. Di Stefano Manzella,

    121-41.

    Inscriptiones

    Sanctae Sedis

    2.

    Citta

    del

    Vati-

    cano:

    Monumenti,

    Musei e

    Gallerie Pontificie.

    . 1998.

    "Origine

    e

    sviluppo

    delle

    catacombe

    ro-

    mane." In Le

    catacomberistianedi Roma:

    Origini, vilup-

    po,

    apparati

    decorativi,

    ocumentazione

    epigrafica,

    dited

    by

    V. Fiocchi

    Nicolai,

    F.

    Bisconti,

    and D.

    Mazzol