Labor Supply and the Value of Non-Work Time: Experimental ...
Chicago Roundtable Discussionirpaai.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/CHI-Text-Next..pdf · Digital...
Transcript of Chicago Roundtable Discussionirpaai.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/CHI-Text-Next..pdf · Digital...
www.outsourcing.com www.IRPAnetwork.com
Chicago May 2, 2014
EXECUTIVE ROUNDTABLE SERIES
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE Agenda
2
8:30-9:00 Registration, Continental Breakfast & Networking
9:00-9:15 Welcome & opening remarks Raheem Hasan, CMO IRPA Frank Casale, Founder & CEO IRPA/OI Peter George, Attorney, Baker & McKenzie, LLP
9:15-10:00 Robotic Process Automation: The Emergence of Digital Labor, its Impact on the CIO and the Coming Shakeup among All Service Providers Globally - Presented by Josh Langford, Vice President, Midwest, IPsoft
10:00-10:15 Networking Break
10:15-11:00 Challenges and opportunities related to managing multi-vendor relationships and the impact that new technologies will have on the outsourcing ecosystem, Presented by John Lytle, Director, ISG
11:00-11:30 Roundtable discussion & Event Wrap up
Today’s objective is to both educate and learn!
© 2013 The Outsourcing Institute – Confidential
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE About OI
3
Founded in 1993, The Outsourcing Institute is a neutral professional association
dedicated solely to outsourcing.
Largest Network of Outsourcing Professionals in the World
with 70,000+ members
−the largest group of buyer executives globally
Outsourcing.com is one of the most trafficked outsourcing
websites on the internet
−Consistently ranked in top 3 when Searching Outsourcing
and other key phrases
© 2013 The Outsourcing Institute – Confidential
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE About OI
4
“At the center of the global outsourcing ecosystem”
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE About IRPA
IRPA helps business leaders position themselves at the cutting edge of knowledge work technology.
Get the latest trends, expert interviews, best practices and commentary from the pioneers and thought leaders of robotic process automation.
The Institute for Robotic Process Automation (IRPA),
located at IRPAnetwork.com, is an independent professional
association and knowledge forum for the buyers, sellers,
influencers and analysts of robotic process automation.
5
IRP
A S
ERV
ICES
Services for Providers
• Sponsorship opportunities to publish and promote thought leadership, company profiles, case studies and video segments.
• Goal: Increase marketplace visibility, drive education and awareness.
Content Marketing
• Promote partnerships and alliances through virtual (webinars) and live events (conferences and roundtables).
• Goal: Facilitate networking opportunities with buyers, providers, analysts and influencers.
Event Marketing
•Go-to-market program development (sales tools, lead generation programs, analyst outreach).
•Goal: Drive growth.
Sales & Marketing Advisory
6
Robotic Process Automation:
The Emergence of Digital Labor, its Impact on the CIO and the Coming Shakeup among All
Service Providers Globally
Presented by: Josh Langford Vice President, IPsoft Midwest
The Digital Labor Opportunity
McKinsey predicts over the next decade 1/3 of
this market will be replaced by digital labor
Knowledge Worker market is $9 Trillion
and represents 9% of Global Workforce
and 27% of Global Wage Base
$3 Trillion Industry will be replaced by innovation in
technology products, services, and software
Technology Heat Map
The Technology Heat Map is dynamic and suggest both risk and opportunity to the market participants in the coming years.
Issues th
at are on
the D
esk o
f Tech
no
logy
Lead
ers
Big Data
IT Consumerization
Talent Management
Cyber-Security
Internet of Things
Unified Communications
& Analytics
Commercial Market Trends
The pace of change in today’s market is exceeding our collective pace of learning. Services and pricing are changing, but our commercial models were not designed for this new world.
Pace o
f Ch
ange >
Pace o
f Learn
ing
Business Alignment
Technology & Services
Business Practices
We are here Growing
Misalignment
Market Disconnects Where is the misalignment?
Pricing • Pricing vectors for services are
dramatically dropping as Service Providers begin to implement
• Labor Automation • Big Data and Analytics • Software Tools & Platforms
Innovation • Normal commercial relationships (i.e.,
contracts) limit innovation by eliminating or severely restricting:
• Transparency • Risk Taking • Shared Failure • Shared Reward
Commercial Constructs • 1,000 page contracts with prescriptive
SOW’s, SLA’s, and pricing does not work well in a dynamic and sometime ambiguous market.
• More collaborative and dynamic approaches are required.
Wave View of Technology Trends: Virtualization
The common theme in today’s changing technology landscape is Virtualization. Cloud Computing leading to the virtualization of physical compute, Digital Labor leading to virtualization of labor.
Wave V
iew o
f Tech
no
logy
Tren
ds - V
irtualizatio
n
Big Data Unified Communications
IT Consumerization
Automation Of Knowledge Work
Talent Management
Cyber-Security
Big Data & Analytics
Mobile Internet
Current Cresting Wave
Virtualization of physical computing leading to greater reliance on network technologies.
New Wave Forming
Virtualization of technology labor resources leading to a full reliance on network technologies.
Increase in Network-Enabled
Architecture
Reliance on Network-Centric
Architecture
This will put Network Technologies center stage in coming years.
Network Centric Service Delivery Evolution N
etwo
rk C
entric Serv
ice Delivery
Evo
lutio
n
Network As Communications
Network Enabled Compute
Network Centric Business Platforms
Past Present Near Future
The role of the network will have increasingly central role in the delivery of business platforms and service delivery. Cloud Computing – Phase 1. Digital Labor – Phase 2.
History of Models in One Chart Su
pp
ly C
hain
F
rom
On
e to M
any
As technologies evolve, Functional Out-Tasking and Service Integration will emerge as the growth areas for Third Party Services. SI Management is strategic.
Multi Tower
One Neck To Choke
Model
Tower 2
Tower 3
Tower 4
Market last 3 years
Importance of Labor Arbitrage
Importance of Software, Platforms, Labor Automation,
Scalability
FUN
CTI
ON
AL
OU
T-TA
SKIN
G Tower 1
Next 3-5 years
Serv
ice
In
tegr
atio
n
Strategic Out-Tasking Players
EMC
Akamai
VMWare
Hitachi
IPsoft
Oracle
SFDC
Amdocs
Amazon
Xerox
IBM
Etc.
Strategic Tactical
Sourcing Evolution Labor Wave Theory So
urcin
g Evo
lutio
n L
abo
r Wave T
heo
ry
Think of the market progression from the left hand side of the chart to the right in two waves: Wave 1: Labor Arbitrage; Wave 2: Labor Automation
Wave 2 Characteristics Wave 1 Characteristics
• 15%-30% cost take out
• Model is scalable to the extent that you can scale labor
• Custom/complex, legacy :“Your mess for less”
• Access to Low Cost Labor necessary to provide continuous value
• Revenue/Profit correlated to People
• 40%-75% cost take out for relevant functions
• Model is scalable and is largely independent of labor growth
• Transformative – New way of doing business
• Access to “Rocket Scientists” who can codify manual processes
• Revenue/Profit NOT correlated to People
Wave 1 Labor Arbitrage
Wave 2 Labor
Automation
The Road Ahead
Polar Shift in the Relation of Technology & Labor P
olar Sh
ift in th
e Relatio
n o
f Tech
no
logy
& L
abo
r
Bu
sin
ess
Pro
cess
Te
chn
olo
gy
Peo
ple
Bu
sin
ess
Pro
cess
Te
chn
olo
gy
Peo
ple
Big Data
& Analytics
Moore’s Law
Cognitive
Polar Shift Old: Technology Supports Labor New: Labor Supports Technology
Today Tomorrow
Cognitive Technologies: Sci-Fi Meets Reality C
ogn
itive Tech
no
logies: Sci-F
i Meets R
eality
Language comprehension • Nuance Technologies
Language production • Narrative Science – news articles written by bots
Understanding • IPsoft’s Amelia – avatar with a neural processor capable
of dynamic process grafting
Pattern Recognition • Opera Solutions – signal to noise data parsing
• Google Brain
Subjective Assessment • IBM Watson
Synthesis of Complex or Large Scale Data • Google Car
Self Aware Systems • Kurzweil’s Singularity
Innovation will Transform the Business Landscape In
no
vation
Form
ula
Essential Ingredients = Risk Taking + Acceptance of Failure
Individuals
Are Creative
Groups
Deliver Innovation
Business Knowledge + Execution Skill
Innovation = Creativity + Business Knowledge + Execution + Essential Ingredients*
* - 1 part Risk Taking & 3 parts Acceptance of Failure
Innovation over the next few years will:
•Virtualize physical labor into logical labor
•Reduce the role of Labor in the Supply Chain of Services
•Expand the role of Expert Systems and AI into the ecosystem
Dynamic Market Changes: Two Sides of the Coin D
yn
amic M
arket C
han
ges – T
wo
Sides o
f the C
oin
Risk Reward
Two Sides of the Coin
Marginalization Diminishing Returns Obsolescence Existential
Profit Expansion Significant Returns Market Leadership Relevance
Change is neither wholly good or bad. There are two sides of the coin when it comes to change – Risk on one side – Reward on the other. There is no Reward without the corresponding Risk – the preverbal “no free lunch” axiom.
One Defines the Other
Minimizing Risk Minimizes Reward
The goal is not to minimize risk in a changing market, but to understand the nature of the changes in the environment and Manage Risk and Capitalize on Reward.
GOAL: Manage Risk & Capitalize on Reward
The Zero Concept T
he Z
ero C
on
cept
Zero Concept
Zero Cost
Zero Cycle Times
Zero Defects
Cost Cycle Time Defect Rate
Time
As Cost, Cycle Times, and Defect Rates trend to zero from their current levels, the businesses that are supported by the underlying Service Delivery models will themselves transform into new businesses and new business models.
Digital Labor: Waves of Value D
igital Lab
or: W
aves of V
alue
The primary impacts of labor automation in the business case are obvious: lower cost, shorter cycle times, improved quality, etc.
The secondary and tertiary waves, enabled from Service Delivery Telemetry, are less obvious, but can dwarf the primary impacts.
Lower Costs Reduce Cycle Times
Improved Quality
Consequential Benefits Big Data Monetization
Business Transformation Revenue Opportunities
Process Redesign Through
Big Data/Analytics
More Less Benefits Visibility
Digital Labor
Begets
Service
Delivery Telemetry
Base Business Case
Primary Secondary Tertiary
Questions?
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE Coffee Break
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Proprietary and Confidential. No part of this document may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means,
including information storage and retrieval devices or systems, without prior written permission from Information Services Group, Inc.
Outsourcing Institute: TechNext Innovation Briefing John Lytle, Director
02 May 2014
Building Collaboration & Integrating Disruption
Multi-Vendor Sourcing in a New Age
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 25
Agenda
1. The Multi-Sourcing Trend
2. Benefits and Challenges of Multi-Sourcing
3. The SMAC Factor
4. Service Integration: Key to Success
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 26
ISG Research shows that outsourcing contracts are getting increasingly smaller in total contract value and increasingly shorter in duration.
The Multi-Sourcing Trend
► The ISG Outsourcing Index – a quarterly analysis of sourcing contract activity – shows a consistent trend towards higher deal volumes, smaller deals and shorter terms.*
► This trend is being driven by clients’ interest in leveraging specialized capabilities and developing best-of-breed service delivery models.
*Spike in “mega-deals” in Q1-14 an anomaly
24 31 36
68 70
57
1,063
673
482
2013 2008 2004
$5-39M $40-99M $100M +
Comparing Broader Market Contracting Awards ($B)*
Grouping in ACV Contract Size Bands
$153
$185 $179
$55 $57 $55
$11 $13 $14
2013 2008 2004
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 27
Multi-sourcing shakes up the competitive landscape and offers significant potential benefits, but also creates risks.
Implications, Benefits and Challenges of Multi-Sourcing
► Competitive implications of multi-sourcing include:
Increasing fragmentation of the marketplace as vendors focus on developing specialized capabilities
For clients, challenge becomes knowing the players and finding the best solution
For service providers, challenge becomes differentiating themselves in an increasingly crowded field
► Potential benefits of multi-sourcing include:
Ability to leverage best-of-breed capabilities
Flexibility in bringing new providers in and exiting others
► Potential challenges include:
Facilitating collaboration among multiple vendors with conflicting agendas
Ensuring integration across the service delivery chain – defining ownership, roles and responsibilities
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 28
Keys to Success: Service Integration
As IT and outsourcing evolved so too did the Integration of IT Services:
The evolution of Service Integration
ITIL first published IT is delivered
in-house
Large single-source/ Prime contractor deals. (Provider acts as integrator)
ITIL v2 and 3 Early 2000s, SI
overlooked Late 2000s SI
sourced as a discrete function
Global awareness and interest in SIAM SIAM models
mature and vary
The evolution of Outsourcing
Outsourcing is a business strategy
Outsourcing is in vogue Long duration
(~7-10 )
Lift and shift
Diversification of supply base Drop duration
(~5 – 7) Rise of Eastern
based Providers
Multi-sourcing in vogue Shorter
duration (~5 years)
1980s 1990s
Monolithic
2000s
Bipartisan
2010s
Pluralistic
2020s
Confederate
Focus on plug & play, flexibility, scalability, automation Standard
interaction model
Functional out-tasking New
technology based players Duration – 3
Years
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 29
Automation and SMAC = Multi-Sourcing on Steroids
AccessISGTM
Momentum Automation Survey 2013
Big Data and Little Devices – Hospitality Firms Seek a Competitive Edge
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 30
The Exponential Need for Service Integration
Integrated Demand – Supply Dynamics
Security
LAN / WAN
Collaboration
App Maintenance
Salary/Benefits
Workplace
Sales
Purchasing
Claims Processing
Service Integration
Distribution
. . .
Business Services
Service Desk
Facilities
End User Equipment
. . .
Payment Processing
PM Services
Component Services
Who will correlate Service Levels?
Who will manage cross-provider
incidents? Who will ensure
capacity is meeting demand?
Who will hold Providers
accountable?
Who will assure change
orchestration?
Who will drive end to end continuous improvement
Who will manage cost to value?
New players, more automation, XaaS solutions … the ability to orchestrate services becomes more complex.
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 31
Imperatives for successful Service Integration
Success in Service Integration is dependent on having clarity of the Target Operating Model – which is based on measurable objectives and controlled by disciplined Governance.
Derived from ISG‘s Target Operating Model
Drivers Objectives Measures
End-to-end Service Management Processes in the right depth and breadth for operational control
SIAM Model that meets organizational and functional requirements
Supportive Contract language and incentives for collaboration
The right Components in terms of business service/ process enabling Data, Application and Technology Architecture
Clear Roles & Responsibilities in the context of the overall Target
Operating Model (TOM)
Skills or Competencies required to perform SIAM
Common Tools for integrated processes and data transparency
Correlated Reporting and data management
Business Architecture
Data, Application & Technology Architecture
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 32
Having a holistic map and detailed definition of all Service Integration functions is key to establish a solid end-to-end business value oriented service delivery.
Scope of Service Integration – Services Framework
Service Strategy, Planning & Control
Corporate Support Functions
Legal Audit Compliance Procurement Human
Resources Finance
& Controlling Communication & Change Mgt.
Risk
Dem
and
(Bu
sin
ess)
Sup
ply
Internal and External Service Delivery
End User Computing & Collaboration
Hosting
Data and Voice Network
Application Developm. & Maintenance
Business Services (HR, F&A, etc.)
Service Integration and Management
Project Delivery
Program & Project Mgt.
Cross-Functional
Aligning Services to Business Needs
& Aggregating Demand
Management of Service Delivery (Internal & External)
Business Value Management
Demand Mgt.
Request Mgt.
Customer Satisf. Mgt.
Pricing and Chargeback
Service Catalog Mgt.
Systems Integration
Supplier Management
Contract Mgt.
Commercial Mgt.
Performance Mgt.
Relationship Mgt.
Service Desk Services
Service Lifecycle Mgt.
Project Portfolio Management
Service Portfolio Management
Sourcing Strategy & Lifecycle Management
Enterprise Architecture Management
Security Policy & Standards
P P P P P
P
P
P
P
P
S P
P
P
S
S
S
P
S
S
S
S
P
S = Service P = Process
OPERATIONAL INTEGRATION
Initial focus
SERVICE INTEGRATION AND MANAGEMENT (SIAM)
Today‘s focus
© 2014 Information Services Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved 33
ISG’s Prediction: The Future of Sourcing
Multi-Sourcing and confederation brings new players, more automation, provides room for XaaS solutions.
Internal Shared Services / Captives
Function
Function
Function
Function
Function
All Towers
OR
Infrastructure ADM BPO Function(s)
Tower
Tower
Tower
Tower
Importance of Labor Arbitrage
Importance of Software, Platforms,
Labor Automation, & Scalability
Function
Social Media Collaboration
Mobility BYOD
Analytics & Big Data
Cloud
Computing & Storage
Service Integration
Strategic & Selective Sourcing Multi-Sourcing Confederation
MARKET 5 – 10 YEARS AGO LAST 5 YEARS NEXT 3 TO 5 YEARS
www.isg-one.com
Information Services Group is a leading technology insights, market intelligence and advisory services company, serving more than 500 clients around the world to help them achieve operational excellence. ISG supports private and public sector organizations to transform and optimize their operational environments through research, benchmarking, consulting and managed services, with a focus on information technology, business process transformation, program management services and enterprise resource planning. Clients look to ISG for unique insights and innovative solutions for leveraging technology, the deepest data source in the industry, and more than five decades of experience of global leadership in information and advisory services. Based in Stamford, Conn., the company has more than 800 employees and operates in 21 countries.
knowledge powering results®
TEC
H NEX
T INN
OV
ATIO
N R
OU
ND
TAB
LE Discussion and Networking
KEEP IN
FOR
MED –
STA
Y CO
NN
ECTED
Please Visit Us
www.IRPAnetwork.com
www.outsourcing.com
36
Join the IRPA and OI networks to get the latest trends, expert interviews, best practices and commentary from thought leaders.
Frank Casale [email protected]
Raheem Hasan [email protected]
Dan Goodstein [email protected]