Chapter 5 THE ASHTAVAIDYAS OF KERALA: SYSTEMS OF MEDICINE AND...
-
Upload
doannguyet -
Category
Documents
-
view
250 -
download
26
Transcript of Chapter 5 THE ASHTAVAIDYAS OF KERALA: SYSTEMS OF MEDICINE AND...
Chapter 5
THE ASHTAVAIDYAS OF KERALA:
SYSTEMS OF MEDICINE AND TRANSFORMATIONS
This chapter seeks to provide a detailed description of the families of
Ashtavaidya practitioners -Mooss-in Kerala. It describes their systems of
therapy, and it's transfonnations over the years. While first part of the chapter
deals with the senior medical practitioners from Ashtavaidya cluster, the
second part is devoted to an analysis of the data on their patients. This corpus
of infonnation-dealing with highly personalized experiences of illness
(rogam), treatment (Chikitsa) and cure (shamanam)-is basically ~tched-out
from my field-work. More than one hundred patients, experimenting with the
Ashtavaidya system of therapy, constitute themselves as the most important
segment of infonnants for this study. They are been interviewed with a pre
planned questionnaire, which anticipate answers shedding valuable insight on
their conception of the systems of Ashtavaidya therapeutics. Apart from this,
all the important practitioners from existing Ashtavaidya clans had been
consulted. These personal consultations were so crucial that they provided
'authentic' / expertised substrata of opinions internal to tbe craft of their
therapy (Astavaidyam).
Ashtavaidyas were famous for their skills Slllce time immemorial.
Previously, they were known as Ashtaangavaidyans, for they were proficient in
all the eight branches of Ayurveda. In the beginning, there were eighteen
122
families practicing Ayurveda; which indicates that Ashtavaidyas does not mean
just eight families I as commented by some of the scholars2• Vagbhata, who was
a native of 'Sindudesh', migrated to south and reached Kerala. He gained a
spate of disciples there, and breathed his last at the famous Ashtavaidya family
Pulamantol Mooss. 3 Kerala was divided into eighteen districts for
administrative convenience in ancient times and it is believed that each of these
districts had Ashtavaidya families. Gradually the number of vaidya families
decreased. Only five families exist now. They are, Olassa Mooss in Kottayam
District, Eledath Thaikkattu and Thrissur Thaikkattu (Pazhanellipurathu
Thaikkattu) in Thrissur district, Pulamantol Mooss in Malappuram district, and
Vaidyamadham in Palakakkaddistrict.4
Ashtavaidyas' practice of medicine IS mainly based on traditional
knowledge which gets transmitted from generation to generation. Almost all
the senior Mooss in the Ashtavaidya families had their initial training in a non-
fonnal way. Later, these new entrants were incorporated into Gurukula method
where a more systematized curricula was followed for medical instruction.
Most of them had acquired their skills of practice from their ancestors
themselves. Their education process starts after the ceremony of investiture-
upanayana. First, they have to learn the language of the therapy i.e. Sanskrit.
At least, a moderate level of expertise in the -grammar and the literature of
Sanskrit is necessary as all the treatises on diagnosis and pharmacy were
written in it. At around the age of twelve or thirteen, they used to start learning
I Interview conducted with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, Vaidyamadham, May 51h , 2006, 5.p.m
1 K.N Panikkar, Indigenous medicine and cultural hegemony: A study of the revitalization movement in Keralam, Studies in HistOlY, 8, 2, n.s 1992, New Delhi. 3 Interview conducted with Sankaran Mooss, Pulamanthol I1Iam, 20th January 2007. 4 Interview conducted with E.T. Narayanan Mooss, Eledath Thaikkattu, April 261
\ 2006, IO am
123
Ashtangahridayam, 'the fundamental book of reference' for all the
Ashtavaidyas. After learning all the chapters of Ashtangahridayam, there
would be a reciting ceremony (bhajanam) in front the family deity.5 The
notion of an all powerful intra-clan patron deity (Kuladevta) which is
benevolent in its constitution (svarupam) is so central to the transmission of
medical knowledge within this traditional setting. Usually these intra-clan
patron deities are conceived (sankalpam) as derivative forms (amsam) from the
supreme lord Dhanvathari; the divine presider over healing and recuperation.
The period for recitation may extent from six months to one year.
This is a crucial period in each medical practitioner's (vaidya) life. In
this period, he cannot interact with other people. From morning to evening he
will be spending all his time in the shrine and recite Ashtangahridayam. In
addition, his daily intake of the food is limited to a single course and even in
taking this; the food even from his own home (illam) is strictly proscribed. The
trainee is only allowed to take the usual offerings from temples (prasadam) for
his minimum subsistence. So, this period of life brings several changes in the
attitude of the pupil, and after this, he will be starting medical practice with his
'father' or with his father's younger brothers (Aphan). Within the complex
familial structure and related customs of concubinage of Kerala Brahmins
(Namboothiris)6, the clans of Astavaidya practitioners regulated the
transmission of medical knowledge as an intra-sectarian affair. This is clearly
5 Ibid
6 K.R.Unni, 1956 "Visiting Husbands in Malabar," Journal of the Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda, Vol. 5, pp. 37-56. 1958, Joan P Mencher, "Namboothiri Brahmins an Analysis of Traditional Elite in Kerala", Journal of Asian and African Studies, vol. 1, no 3, 1996,pp 183-196
124
evident from the fact that the progenies of inter-caste alliance, mainly with
Nayars, were not permitted to be trained as Astavaidyas.
During the time of their training, the 'junior Mosses' are not entitled to
prescribe medicine or to consult patients. They just observe and understand
what their seniors are doing/officiating. Therefore, this period is similar to the
'house-surgency' under allopathy. However, during this period vaidya will be
getting a firsthand practical experience of the lessons which he learned from
the classical treatises 7• Each Ashtavaidya family has their own characteristical
peculiarities or specialties in the treatment. This is mainly because of the fact
they receive training in medicine from their respective ancestors. Depending on
their teaching methods, we can discern some differentiation in diagnosis and
prescription patterns. However, the basic methods of treatments are the same
and these are based on Ashtangahridayam in totality. Though the nonnative
presence of Ashtangahridayam as an unquestionable and authentic
phannacopeia is well evident, the five clans of practicing Astavaidyas in Kerala
show certain differences in the practice and execution of medicine. We will be
having a brief look at this matter in the section below.
The Systems of Medicine in Ashtavaidya families
Each Ashtavaidya family has their own methods of diagnosis and
healing practices. These are, at large, vary from one vaidya family to another.
In the existing Ashtavaidya families, almost all the senior Mooss's had their
7 Interview conducted with E.T. Narayanan Mooss, Eledath Thaikkattu, April 261h, 2006, 10 am
125
medical training from their own families. They consult people from all classes
and castes irrespective of the nomlative understandings on comparative purity
and pollution of human bodies. Their therapies involve nonnatively proscribed
ingredients and practices, such as the use of animal flesh as medicine.
Interestingly, some of the experts conduct surgical operations (sastra-kriya) on
the body (of patients) and hence cause themselves to be 'contaminated' by
contacting with human blood. Within the medicinal lexicon of these
practitioners, the therapies involving a contact with human blood are
understood as rakthamoksham or the technique of 'purifying' blood. Here the
'impurity' ascribed to the (patient's) blood is purely medical in its constitution
and hence in the realm of pragmatics these practitioners distance themselves
from the scriptural sanctions regarding purity and pollution. It is because of this
unfamiliar social/symbolic location of these groups of practitioners, they were
considered within the traditional social vocabulary of Kerala as clans without
Vedadhikaram and Yagadhikaram. 8 One of major Astavaidya clans of
Kerala- the grant lineage of physicians from Vaidyamadham-visibly disdain
therapies involving surgery though they possess a large collection of surgical
instruments (sastram) with them. This has to be read in connection with the
fact that the physicians ofVaidyamadham are the only Astavaidya clan with an
auth_ority for Vedic didactics and participation in sacrifices. The caste lore of
Kerala Brahmins locates the practitioners of Astavaidyam as 'degraded' within
the clusters ofNamboothiri castes. In the earlier times, these clans were strictly
endogamous by limiting their marriage alliances within them. As many of my
8 Vedadhikaram is generally understood in Kerala as the authority for Vedic didactics and the Yagadhikaram is the legitimate right to officiate sacrifices as per scriptural validation.
126
infonnants recount, 'pure' Namboothiri Brahmins of Kerala showed an utter
reluctance in having marital relations with Astavaidya clans9 owing primarily
to the stigma of impurity.
The therapeutic assemblage of a senior Maass does not include any
modem medical equipments like stethoscope, themlOmeters etc. Their method
of consultation and diagnosis is through an interaction with the patients. An in-
depth communication/deliberation between vaidya and patients is anticipated.
It takes around thirty to forty minutes. In this interaction, the vaidya will be
able know about whereabouts of the patients. An Ashtavaidya is not a
dependent on any of the instruments, or on test results. His therapy is fully
based on his intelligence (buddhi)-through an active interaction with the
patients. Constant and systematized propitiation (upasana) of a particular
guardian deity (maarthi) is conceived as the most important treasure from
where intelligence can be drawn. All the informants whom I met in the field
underscore this and consider upasana as the foundation of their treatment IO.
The process of diagnosis of an Astavaidya is not strictly limited to a mere
clinical diagnosis of the patient's body or disease. At times it attempt to
transcend the limitations of the patient's clinical body and to comprehend a
holistic socio-cultural milieu where the patient is embedded. The vaidya asks
detailed questions about the patient's food habits, daily routines and more
interestingly about his heredity (parampara) or the familial precedents of a
particular disease. This mode of interaction is very much helpful for the patient
9 Interview conducted with Sankaran Mooss, Pulamanthol Illam, 20 th January 2007. 10 Interview conducted with Brahmadattan Namboothiri, Ollannur Mana, Thrissur, April 25th
, 2006, 10 a.m.
127
to locate himself! herself on an elevated vantage from where he!she can
conceive the 'state of disease' (rogam) in continuity with the very familiar
ways of his own/her own living. In other words, the state of disease in
Astavaidya is not conceived as a 'break' within the nonnal or 'healthy' ways of
living.
According to this system of medicine, 'disease' is not restricted to the
state of bodily illness. Rather the conceptions of disease, treatment and cure are
deeply impregnated with a vernacular cosmological understanding (of a
physician). A simple causation is been established between state of bodily
illness (rogam) and the transcendent realm of action (karma) in which the body
(shariram) is continuously involved. Diseases are understood as an engrafted
extensions or a results of the sin (papa) committed by a particular body. A
vaidya recognizes an illness as a state or an embodiment of accumulated sins
(papas) either in this or in previous births (poorva janma). The notion of
poorva janma papa or sins of previous births own a central position within the
therapeutic assemblage of Ashtavaidyam. According to the Ashtavaidyas when
they are treating patients, vadiyan himself became a part in the 'chain of sins'
which has actualized as disease in the body (of a patient) they are treating.
Therapeutic intervention into a 'sinned body' and the alleviation of suffering is,
in a closer look, goes against the universal nonns of karma-sidhantha. The
vaidyas are considered as sharing the sin (papa) of a patient by treating the
'sinned body' and helping it to come out of the state of illness. The acceptance
of prestations in the form of money, gift and grants by the vaidya, entangle
128
himself with the contaminated domain of sinsIl. The strict adherence to the
principle and practice of upasana by almost all of the Ashtavaidyas can directly
be connected to this dimension. Moreover, 'this contaminated domain of sins'
reappears as a crucial philosophical disqualifier for the Ashtavaidyas in their
interface with other 'purer' sections of Kerala Brahmins.
Tridosa and Panchabootha are the basis of ashtavaidya treatment.
Medicine and food is not very different things for them. According to
Ashtavaidyas if aharam and viharam (food and dwelling) controlled there is
less chance for the diseases. Vaidya first examines the basic constituent
characters (gunam) of a body (of patient) as per the pathological conceptions of
Ayurveda. Within the Ethno-Iogic of Ayurveda, human body is conceptualized
as a site of three basic constituent characters or qualities such as vata, pita and
kapha. According to the body type of the· patient, the medicines to be
prescribed have some variations. Thus the senior Mooss prescribes the
medicine in a manner that the patient could make it at his home. But because
of the spread of A yurvedic retailing shops in recent times, the need for making
medicine at patient's home is rare. However, one point which can be noticed in
the Pulamantol Illam is worth mentioning. The patients are willing to make the
medicine at their home, and some of them have a very good idea about herbs,
method of making Asavam, kashayam etc.
Each medicine has its own 'yoga' (nature of the medicine), it is varies
according to the quality and quantity of the ingredients in that medicine. Yoga
II For a similar case, see, Gloria Godwin Raheja, The Poison in the Gift: Ritual, Pres/ation and the Dominant Caste in a north Indian Village, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1988.
129
generally means ingredients of the medicines, each of them has a special
quality (guna) attached to it. It should be adjusted in the medical recipe as per
the rationale (Yukti) of vaidya. In Astangahrdaya, Vagbhta says about the
importance of the Yukti to a vaidya. Yukti comes from the mind of a vaidya.
The observation of the patients is the main source of the Yllkti and central to
their treatment. From the observation one must get the idea of the state of
disease. Take the example of Dhanwantharam Kashayam, the most common
medicinal component in almost all the therapies. It is not possible to prescribe
one particular bottle of Dhanwantharam Kashayam to all the patients. The
ingredients of this Kashayam have been different according to the nature and
condition of the patients and diseases. So vaidya should have through
knowledge of each ingredient (dravyam) of the kashayam as well as the nature
of the disease and patient under treatment. With the proper combination of the
two or three ingredients, disease will come under the control of vaidya.
Ashtavaidyas are thought to be endowed with a special skill, which is
recognized as rishtam or death prediction. It is, as my infonnants say,
mentioned in the Kasi-Ghattaa portion of Sootha Samhita12 which deals with
the prediction of the death of an individual. Many vaidyas are claimed to be
well versed in dictating the signs of de-partition of cells in advance. There were
instances of predicting death even a decade in advance. Physicians from
Pulamanthol Illam are known for their technique of identifying
Mirthulakshnam (signs of death)
12 Interview conducted with Brahmadattan Namboothiri, Ollannur Mana, Thrissur, April 25th , 2006, 10 am
130
Each Ashtavaidya families demonstrate differences in their prescription
methods. For the same medicine, there are differences in their prescriptions, the
way in which they write their clinical notes and suggest. Here also, we could
find one peculiarity between Vaidyamadham and Aalathiyoor Nambi. Both
these families insist on making Kashayam in five liters of water while, all other
Ashtavaidyas make it in four liters of waterI3. Legendary belief is that the
ancestors of the Vaidyamadham family belong to Nambi Illam l4. Pulamantol
Illam is very famous for Ayurvedic treatment based on Ashtangahridayam.
Pulamantol is acclaimed as 'the curable place for incurables 15., Pulamantol
Mooss was the court physician to the Samoothri Rajas of Kozhikode. Nobody
knows about exact the origins of Pulamantol Illam. But it is certain, as my
infonnants recount, that, 'here vadiyam is practiced from very ancient time'.
There is a belief that Vagbhata spend his last days in this Illam and disappeared
(Anthardhanam) on an Ekadashi day. Therefore, on every month on the
Ekadashi day, Ashtagagridhyam is not taught and some special poojas are
perfonned. Almost all the Ashtavaidya families do not teach the
Ashtangahridayam on that specific day as a mark of respect to Vagbhata. The
medical practices of this Illam have some peculiarities, for the medicines used
by them may not be found in any ayurvedic text. The vaidyas are sometimes
using their medicines not based on text but based on their rationale. In addition,
13 Interview conducted with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, Vaidyamadham, May 5th, 2006.
14 Ibid.
15 Interview conducted with Brahmadattan Namboothiri, Ollannur Mana, Thrissur, April 24th, 2006, 10
a.m.
131
if that medicine has shown the positive signs it would be noted in their medical
records (tha/iota grathangal) so it is a kind of pattern medicine system 16.
Religious practices in Ashtavaidya Therapy
Sankaran Mooss is the senior Mooss of the Pulamantol Illam. He did his
Sanskrit education from Kanchipuram. After coming back to his homeland,
he started studying medicine form his uncle (ValiyaAchan) under his guidance,
Sankaran Moss learned the basic text of the Ashtavaidyas, Ashtangahridayam 17
And after that he gone to another teacher known in the name of Povalli
AramThampuram ,who also known .as Arivinte Thampuran(lord of knowledge)
from his supervIsIOn he learned Charka Samhita, Mathangaleela,
Kalarippayattu 18. Sankaran Moss is the only Astavaidyan who learned Charka
Samhita through infonnal learning. According to Sankaran Mooss, 'Ayurveda
system is very much related with religious beliefs' 19. His medical practices
have some peculiarities; he is very strict in observing some restrictions
(pathyam), as a part of the healthy eating and being. Sankaran Mooss also says
same things regarding the treatment of illness. According to him, in some cases
of the disease, it is very difficult to cure. At such a point, he will suggest some
16 Ibid.
17 Interview conducted with Sankaran Moss, Pulamanthol IlIam, 20th January, 2007 18 Ibid. The late Poomully Neelakkandan Nampoothrippadu popularly known as Aram Thampuran was born in 1921. His expertise in all fornls of arts and literature, Ayurveda, Kalari, Yoga and other performing arts and his knowledge in all facets of life gave him the name "Arivinte Thampuran" (living legend of knowledge). The heritage of Poomully Mana, which the Aram Thampuran fastidiously carried forward, is even today nurtured by his many disciples. Today Poomully Mana is being used as a heritage centre for Ayurveda, Kalari, Yoga and other traditional art forms with all facilities to suit modem life styles, but without losing slight on traditional values and principles. 19 Interview dated 21st January 2007 with Sankaran Mooss, Pulamantollllam
132
pujas or will insist to look at their astrology. Sankaran Mooss says: "Disease
means some doshas. So at the time I am treating the patient, the doshas will
come into my family so I will do proper pujas and rituals (pariharakriyakal) to
get rid of all these bad ailments,,2o. Sankaran Mooss is not that much stick to
the norm of Pathyam. His version is that it will discourage the preventive
powers of the patients. He says, "Pathyam is not for the patient; it is for the
disease. Now the patients are not averse to follow the Pathyam. Patients from
all over the country come here for consultation". In addition, Mooss is not
interested in advertisements. Moreover, he is not that much keen to in-patient
treatment. At the need stage only he prefers in-patient treatment. Also, he is
very strict in the preparation of medicines. They have their own phannacy and
processing unit under their IUam. Mooss is not interested in taking fees from
the patients, but he wants to remove the illness from patient's body. Another
point to be noted is that, now patients more interested to make medicine in
home itself.21 Sankaran Mooss insists on patients to be aware of their medicine.
He said that a patient should know what they were taking as medicine.
Chirattamann Illam22 one of the Ashtavaidya families, used to be at
Agandipuram in Malapuram district. The family temples-one for Dhanvantari
and one for Sivan- exist there even now. As much as in Ashtanga Chikitsa, the
20 Ibid. 21 Interview dated 22 nd January 2007 with Sankaran Mooss, Pulamantol IIIam. 22 It is said that the Ashtavaidyan family, "Chirattamann", literally meaning "coconut shell-soil", got that name as a result of the successful treatment of an elephant. Once, the handsome elephant belong to a local chieftain was afflicted with a serious swelling which could have turned out fatal. None of the local physicians were successful in treating it. And them Moss was sent for and brought. He suggested surgery and they made the necessary preparations. Moss asked his disciple to make the medicines needed to be applied after the surgery. But when the time came, he was not to be seen, and Moss was in a fix. He filled some soil in a coconut shell, prayed to his family god, Dhanvantari, and applied it on the open wound where the elephant was operated upon. To everyone's surprise, the wound healed and the elephant got well.
133
family members were adept equally in the treatment of elephants (Gaga
Chikitsa). During Tippu Sultan's invasion of erstwhile Malabar (1788 AD), the
family moved out like many others and sought asylum under the Maharaja of
Thiruvithaamkoor (Travanocre), who obliged and made him the court
physician. After a few years at Maruthorvattam near Cherthala, an Illam was
built and land given to them at Olassa near Kottayam, and thereafter the family
came to be known as Olassa Moss. They looked after the health aspects of the
Namboothiri participants in the six-yearly Murajapam until the last one held in
1954.
The known family tree dates back to one Ravi Moss (1789 AD), son of
the Paramesvaran Moss. Ravi moss had nine boys and nine girls and later, the
family was connected through marriage to most other Ashtavaidyan families.
The fifth son, Naryanan married from Nagaru Illam in 1860 at the age of 38,
when all his brothers died. Since all the later first-born sons were named
Naryanan, they are sequentially numbered one, two and so on. Naryanan Moss
II (1861-1912) had expeliise in identifying signs of approaching death
(Maranalakshanam). The then Maharaja of Thiruvithaamkoor have given him
a "Veera Srimkhala" (a kind of Medal of Honor). Naryanan Moss III (1860-
1961) served as an honorary Ayurveda Director of the Government of
Thiruvithaamkoor during 1938-44, and has a large number of discipies. His
third child, Parvathy Devi was the first lady doctor who studied and practiced
Ayurveda. Naryanan Moss IV (1936- ) studied Ayurveda under his father.
While Naryanan Moss V (1964- ) took his BAMS degree from Vaidyaratnam
Ayurveda College, OHur.
134
The senior Naryanan Mooss and his one son are practicing Ayurvedic
medicine. (The other two sons are Allopathy doctors).23 The Junior Narayanan
Mooss is formally educated from Ollur Ayurvedic College. They have a
pharmacy set up in their Illam and also in Kottayam town. Patients from
different parts of Kerala come here for consultations. Senior Mooss is
consulting the patient in the Illam, and in the pharmacy, their daughter-in law is
also working. At the time of fieldwork, I noticed several cases of Chikungunya.
People come here for meditation as well. In Olassa Mooss Illam, I noticed
several kalarichikitsa centers, providing people with different medicinal oils,
thailms?4 Francis Zimmerman had done his fieldwork in this Illam with
Vayaskara Mooss.25 Olassa Mooss was considered the court physician of the
Thiruvithaamkoor Rajas. At the time of Murajapam Olassa Mooss has the
position of a dignitary.26 In Olassa Illam, at present, the medical training is not
restricted to Brahmin pupils. It is imparted to all from different walks of
society. Interestingly some of the Christian disciples can also be attested.
Some of the Ayurvedic institutions and manufacturing units situated in the
southern parts of Kerala have relation with this Illam.27Thus, the Olassa Mooss
is practicing vaidyam in the traditional methods. Mostly Ashtavaidyas do not
take fees from patients; here also, it is the same. The medicine process is
mostly done in the phannacy itself. At the time of fieldwork, some of the
patients especially those who are going through massage therapy (Pizhichil)
23 Interview conducted with Olassa Naryanan Mooss (senior), May loth, 2006. 2~ Interview conducted with one therapist of Kalarichikitsa centre, May 11 th, 206. 2) Interview conducted with Olassa Naryanan Mooss (senior), May 10th
, 2006 26 Ibid. 27 Ibid.
135
had very good opmIOn about their oils (thailm).28 In addition, this Olassa
Mooss Illam was famous for elephant treatment (gaga Chikitsa).29 Nowadays
they are not doing this treatment. In the Illam, I also observed that, their
daughter-in-law is working in the phannacy. In addition, they are well educated
and modem in their thinking patterns and attitudes. However, the senior Moss's
wife (veli) is a typical Namboothiri woman (antharjanam). At the time of
fieldwork, I met with lots of Chikungunya patients who were taking medicines.
The patients already took allopathic medicine at the time of initial fever.
However, the body pain and other problems continued though the allopathic
doctors gave painkillers. So they shifted to Ayurveda, and in some cases
allopathic doctors themselves suggested to take some Ayurvedic medicines in
order to get rid of the pains in muscle and other problems.
OUur Thaikkattu (Elayidath Thaikkattu) IS another important
Ashtavaidya family situated in the Thrissur district. According to the ancient
accounts about Kerala's origin (division of 18 Gral11mas), Ollur Thaikkattu is
under Peruvanal11 graml11. From this village, the senior priest of Kerala's
famous Guruvayoor temple is selected. The territory of this gramm is from
Elamkunnapuzha of Ernakulam district to Pattamabi of Palakakkad district. 30
Ollur, Mooss is considered the court physicians of Cochin Rajas. The famous
physician of this Illam was E.T Neelakandhan Mooss. He has made many
changes especially for changing the orthodox nature. They have their own 150
bedded nursing home facility, and out patient's facility. In addition, for the
28 Interview conducted with one therapist of Kalarichikitsa Centre, May II'h, 2006. 29Interview conducted with OIassa Naryanan Mooss Uunior), May 10'h, 2006 30 Parasurama divided Kerala into 18 villages; peruvanam is one of that villages. Interview conducted with Vasudevan Chakiar, P.R.O, Ollur Nursing Home, May S'h ,lOAM
136
poor patients, there is another clinic. Ollur Thaikkattu is situated in the Olluf.
Moreover, this family has their own Ayurveda Collage; it is accredited to
Calicut University. In addition, this Illam has primary educational institutions
as well. Ourga is their family deity; family members are saying Ourga (Durga
in Dhanvantari foml) worshipping here. The senior Mooss in this Illam is E. T
Naryanan Mooss. He did his medical education through Gurukula method.
After Upanayana ceremony from the age of 10 to 16, he studied Sanskrit and
grammar. At the age of 16, he started learning Ashtagagridhya and
Asthangasamhitha; it took five years to complete the course. After learning
Ashtagagridhya, it should be recited in front of the family deity, Ourga. This
has been known in the name of Bhajanam. Naryanan Mooss takes one year for
this. At his Bhajanam period, he would read five lessons of Ashtagagridhya.
This enables him to by-heart the chapters of Ashtagagridhya. After, he started
practicing the medicine under the guidance of his father and other senior
members of the family, especially ValiyaAchan. This is a kind apprenticeship
period; it took three to four years. Naryanan Mooss started independent
practices only after completing all these studies and training .. 31
E.T. Narayanan Mooss is not at all satisfied with the present practicing
methods. In his opinion, patients get the treatment according to their wishes.
Now patients are leading a-speedy life, so they need this speed in their
treatment also. Naryanan Mooss cautions against this trend by observing,
"Patients must have patience, especially in Ayurveda".32Naryanan Mooss is not
interested in rasa and sindooras in his treatment. Even it should be that much
31 Interview conducted with E.T Naryanan Mooss May 5 th 2006,11 A. M S32 Ibid
137
needy condition; he will give these medicines in his presence only (in-patient
treatment).33
Vaidyamadham is one of ~he Ashtavaidya clans to Bharadwajeeya
group. This family was brought over here by the renowned Mezhatole
Agnihothri who is credited with conducting about 100 Somayaga34. In
Somayaga, the Vaidyamadham family is honored as Sala Vaidya. Sala Vaidya
is a highly honored status whose responsibility is mainly to maintain the health
of yaga participants apart from performing tantric rites in the sacrifice. Their
family-name Vaidyamadham, itself is born out ofvadiyam (treatment) madham
denotes centre or abode. Lord Dakshinamoorthy (a form of Siva in meditation)
is the family deity (Kuladevta) of the Vaidyamadham. Vaidyamadham has the
surname of Namboothiri instead of Mooss. They have the lineage of
Bharadwajeeya Gotra, (all the other Ashtavaidyas are the lineage of
Dhanwantariya Gotra)35 Vaidyamadham is not salya-vaidyas or the physicians
doing surgeries. The physicians from Vaidyamadham do not touch blood36.
Though authentic proof is not available, incidents illustrating the
legendary skills of the physicians of the family have come through generations.
33 Kerala Ayurvedic medicine uses more herbal medicine compared to northern Indian ayurvedic medicine; almost all Ashtavaidyas are in more interested to give herbal medicines in the form of kasayam, arishtam and capsules to patients. 34 Soma yaga is a spiritual and Vedic ritual participated by scores of Thantries and prolonging to several days non-stop ceremonies conducted for the welfare of mankind. Only highly learned Thantries (priest - scholars) are eligible to participate, interview conducted with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiris May 12th
, 2006, 5 P.M 35 Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, Deerghayussam Ayurvedavum (Malayalam language) D.C. Books, Kottayam, 2004, pp. 95 Two groups in Ayurveda, Bharadwajeeya are vaidyas who are medicine practicing vadiyas (Kaya Chikitsa Group), coming under Charaka School of Thought, Dhanwantaris are able to do surgeries(Salya Chikitsa), Susruta School of Thought, (like M.D, M.S in Allopathy) 36 One contrary thing here is they are expert people who conducted the Siraveda (rakthamoksham), interview conducted with Brahmadattan Namboothiri, April 24th
, 2006, 10 a.m.
138
One such incident was the birth of Pareekshith Thampuran who went on to
become a noted scholar and one of the famous rulers of a Kerala principality.
The delivery process was so complicated that the chances of saving both the
mother and the child became almost negligible. Then physician of this family,
who fortunately arrived at the scene, decided to turn his hands on the case.
After obtaining the consent from the king, it is said that he selected some herbs
from the palace courtyard, ground it in to make two types of medicines in paste
form and applied one of them on one side of a wooden board and second on the
other side. The attending midwife was specifically instructed to expose one of
side of the board to the vagina of the queen until the delivery was over and the
reverse the board immediately as otherwise the internal parts would come out
resulting in the death of the queen. The child was named Pareekshith owing to
these extraordinary incidents related to his birth (here Pareeksha means a risky
experiment). It must be noted that no medicines were applied externally nor
taken internally. This incident clearly illustrates the extraordinary powers of
Ayurveda and the brilliant diagnosing skills of its practitioners.
Astavaidyan Vaidyamadham Valiya Naryanan Namboodiri-I (1882-
1952), was well known physician from this family, who is remembered by
many, for his astonishing diagnosing skill and simple and effective treatments.
He was also an expert in detecting Maranalakshana (the sign of immediate
death). He was a confident daring physician of his time, for he brought many
complicated treatments back in to practice. One such treatment was
Kutipraveshikam- a treatment to arrest the ageing process. It may be noted that
at a time when extensive research is being done in various medical disciplines
139
all over the world to arrest the ageing process, India has the rich tradition of a
medical system which evolved a successful approach to it and physicians who
practiced those concepts in actual situations. Nowadays people do not show
much interest in this treatment because of its duration. Siraveda (cutting of vein
to let out impure blood) was another treatment process that was practiced at
times. The present chief physician of Ashtavaidyan Vaidyamadham Cheriya
Naryanan Namboodiri is his grandson and studied Ayurveda in the Gurukula
style under the tutelage of his grandfather. His grandfather started the
Vaidyamadham Vaidya Sala and nursing home in 1912.
Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri is thl.~ senior vaidya of this Illam.
According to him, Ashtavaidyas means those vaidyas who are doing medicinal
treatment based on Ashtangahridayam. In his opinion, Vagbhata wrote
Ashtangahridayam and Ashtangasangraham. He opines, "We could find
interesting of similarities between these two in the description and slogans
(stanzas)37. Vagbhata considered to as a Jainist, from Dhanvantari lineage
which is the basic factor for the Ayurvedic traditions in Kerala. "Vagbhata", for
Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, "was very much modern in his thoughts; that
he combined Kaya Chikitsa and Salya Chikitsa".38
Astavaidyan Vaidyamadham Valiya Naryanan Namboodiri-II (1912-
1988), the father of the chief physician was a legendary figure in his lifetime
itself. He was a tall figure in the Ayurveda tradition and sometimes referred to
as the most efficient ayurvedic physician in a century. Unlike his father, he
37 Interview with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri May I t h 2006, 5 p.m 38 Ibid.
140
traveled extensively through the length and breadth of the country to treat
patients of chronic and complicated diseases, to deliver lectures on Ayurveda
and to partaking in discussions and seminars pertaining to the propagation of
various treatment modalities cited in the Ayurveda texts. Due to his extensive
knowledge on various subjects like Sanskrit, Vedas, mythoiogy, ancient Indian
culture and classical arts he was considered as a living encyclopedia. Being a
versatile genius, he commanded high respect from every walk of like.
The last Kutipraveshikam in the history of Ayurveda was performed by
him some five years ago. Supervised by his father and assisted by his son, he
performed Kutipraveshikam for his friend and close companion, the late
Poomully Vasudevan Namboodiripad. He took up many a complicated case,
which other physicians will not, dared not and he displayed an intense passion
while dealing with various cases. The honorary title of V AIDY ASHASTRA
MAHODADHI was conferred on him by Kanchi Kamakoti Matathipathi Sree
Sree Jayendra saraswathi Swamikal, for his outstanding contribution to
Ayurveda.
According to Cheriya Narayanan Namboothiri, Indu and Jarjada were
the two prominent disciples of Vagbhata in Kerala. Indu was considered as a
vaidya from the Kaarathol IlIam (one of the Ashtavaidya families, now
extinct)39. He wrote a commentary (Vyakhanam) to Ashtangahridayam known
as Sasilekhavyakyanam. In 1957, N. S. Mooss (Vayaskara Mooss, Vayaskara
Illam) published this book with limited copies.40 The original version of this
39 Interview dated 24th January 2007, with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, Vaidyamadham. 40 Ibid.
141
book is kept with Vaidyamadham famil/ l. Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri
opines that this work was a very well arranged and descriptive book. It has
been used as a reference book for the practicing physicians.
We can find two Ashtavaidya families associated with Thrissur
Thaikkattu Illam: the family of Aalathiyoor Nambi and the household of
Pazhanellipurathu Thaikkattu42. The present semor member of the
Pazhanellippurathu Thaikkattu is P.T. Vasudevan Mooss. He was adopted
(Dattu)43 to the Pazhanellippurathu Thaikkattu from Nambi Illam around two
decades back.44 Aalathiyoor Nambi originally from Aalathiyoor in Kozhikode
district, but Narayanan Nambi (senior vaidya ofNambi Illam) and his two sons
are settled in Choondal, in Thrissur district.
Choondal Mooss one of the major Ashtavaidya families In Kerala,
family lineage was cut out because of the non-birth of a male child. Eventually
all their family properties and temple prope11ies came under Aalathiyoor
Nambi family.45 So Choondal Mooss's Illam is known in the name of Nambi
Illam. The name of the place is also Choondal itself. In original, Aalathiyoor ~
Illam is situated in Kozhikode district. Nowadays nobody is practicing
medicine there. The famous temple dedicated to Aswini Devatas is located in
this place. Aswini Devatas are considered the vaidyas of Deva Loka. In Nambi
III am, there is a story that Aswini devatas come here for learning the
Ashtangahridayam, and after their learning, they blessed the Nambi family with
41 Ibid.
42 Interview dated May 2nd 2006, with P.T. Vasudevan Mooss, SNA Oushadhasala, Thrissur. 43 Ashtavaidya families are partrilineal in n;ture, so if there is no male member in one family they will have the right to adopt from other Ashtavaidya family, this is known in the name "Datthu" 44Interview dated May 2nd 2006, with P.T. Vasudevan Mooss, SNA Oushadhasala, Thrissur. 45 Interview dated 30th April, 2006, with Naryanan Nambi, Nambi II1am, Choondal, Thrissur.
142
some sacred Ayurvedic book.46 A senior Nambi of that Illam with his left hand
received the book. Because of this reason, even now, the Nambi family vaidyas
start their treatment with left hand only.47
Narayanan Nambi is the first person in the Ashtavaidya who studied
Ayurveda in a formal way. He did his medical educatioILfrom Kottakkal Arya
Vaidya College, 1955-59 (Arya Vaidyan Diploma). According to Narayanan
Nambi Ashtagangahridyam is the foundation of the Kerala Ayurveda. In this
treatment method Bhasma, Sindooras (rasa, sindooras) are less, mostly using
herbs and herbal varieties. Hence, side effects are very less compared to Rasa
Sindooras. Moreover, Panchakarma therapy is also gaining more practice in
Kerala. It is again one of the specialties of the Kerala Ayurveda. A process
involving steps that call for expertise and experience, "Panchakanna"
comprIses five steps- 'Vamanam' (Vomiting), 'Virechanam' (purgation),
'Vasti' (Enema), 'Nasyam' (Nasal cleaning) and 'Rakta-moksham' (the
removal of impure blood)
Thrissur Thaikkattu moss family is one of the reputed Ashtavaidya
families, practicing Ayurveda for many decades. They have migrated to the
Ancient Cochin Province, and were patronized by Sakthan Thampuran, the
king of Cochin. Soon they were named after the place Thrissur and came to be
called as Thrissur Thaikkattu Moos. In course of time; they emerged and
prevailed with talismanic quality. Among them, the name of Ashtavaidyan
Thrissur Thaikkattu Naryanan Moss left a huge legacy. The fame of the family
46 Interview dated 30th April, 2006, with layakrishanan Nambi, Nambi IIIam, Choondal, Thrissur. 47 Ibid.
143
shot up at the time of Ashtavaidyan Thrissur Thaikkattu Unni Moss. He was
very much accepted as physician at a very young age itself. In 1920, he
established the ayurvedic manufacturing unit in Kizhakkumpattukara, Thrissur
viz. SNA Oushadhasala 48as a memorial of his father Ashtavaidyan Thaikkattu
Naryanan Moss. Ashtavaidyan Thaikkattu Naryanan Moss was an experienced
physician, a poet in his own right and a scholar in Sanskrit. He wrote more than
ten books in Sanskrit, and text Sindooramanjari in Ayurveda. Sindooramanjari
is the book describing the preparation, method and the use of sindooras and
shuddhi kannas of various drugs.
In the Pazhanellipurathu Thaikkkatu Illam, treatment IS m an
institutionalized environment. Narayanan Nambi notes that patients with all
kinds of illnesses visit there. However, most patients visit there in an advanced
stage of their medical condition for consultation. Chronic diseases are
increasing in number. There are several cases rejected from allopathy which are
referred there for treatment. In these cases, they should need an in-patient
treatment. A good number of foreigners are also coming there for consultation;
this is mainly through tour operators, Indian friends, web sites etc. Nambi
opmes that most patients are from the middle, upper-middle class families.
OtherWise, the rejected cases are from the high-class private allopathic
hospitals.
OHur Thaikkattu Moss's (Elayidath Thaikkattu Moss) family tradition
dates back 0 the legendary days of Parasurama. The long and celebrated
lineage has produced many gems, who have harnessed their individual talents
48 It is local tenninology for pharmacy and nursing home
144
with the immaculate excellence of Ayurveda. Becoming legends in their own
lifetime, Naryanan Moss and Ittiravi Moss of the 19the century, for instance
were sought after by the kings and nobles of the day. It is believed that the
younger Moss-Ittiravi Moss- had the uncanny ability to foresee death years in
advance. An uncompromising commitment to Ayurveda and the ability to
adapt to changing conditions have helped the family to continue with the trail
blazing tradition in all excellence. In the year 1924, the Viceroy of India, Lord
Reading, bestowed the title of 'Vaidyaratnam" on the then doyen of the family
Ashtavaidyan Naryanan Moss. His son, Neelakandhan Moss, founded the
Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala in 1941. The aim was to provide the healing
blessing of Ayurveda to all, in the most effective manner. Something the family
has stood for, since its association with Ayurveda. He was an exceptionally
talented physician and scholar with foresight. The Oushadhasala established by
him at Thaikkattsery prepared and provided quality medicines as prescribed by
the masters of Ayurveda. To continue with his efforts, he founded the
Vaidyaratnam Nursing Home. The Vaidyaratnam Ayurveda College and the
Ayurveda Research Centre.
The main medicines used by Ashtavaidya families
Asavam and Arishtam
Decoction/aqueous extract or fresh juice is made from the crude herb to
which nutrients/sweeteners such as sugars like jaggery, honey or sugar, singly
or wholly were added. To the resulting solution, certain fennenting aids like
145
Dhataki Puspha etc and Prakshepa Choorna are mixed and kept it in a
fennentation vat for 30-60 days. In this condition, alcohol is self-generated and
the alcoholic extracts from Prakshepa Choorna are obtained. It is then filtered
and kept for settling. Such preparation is called Arishtam.49
In the case of Asavam, the initial step of the preparation of the aqueous
extract from the medicines is not carried out. In this case, the extractions of the
medicines are taking place as from the second step of preparation of Arishtam.
The Asava-Arishtas have therapeutically higher potency, clear liquid with
pleasant odour. As these preparations mature over a period, the efficacy also
mcreases.
Medicated Thailm ICoconut Oil/Kuzhambu
The base of these preparations is either sesame oil or coconut oil. The
process consists of addition of water extracts (Kasayam), juice (Swarasa) and
paste (Kalka) subjecting the mixture prepared in a regulated temperature. The
Thailms are prepared as per the stipulations in the reference texts. Therefore,
the medicated thailmlcoconut oil is having the property and efficacy almost in
the same manner since it contains the potent ingredients. It is used generally for
inunctions and massage. 50 Kuzhambu is ~ special preparation of Kerala
Ayurveda. In this preparation the base is special combination of sesame oil,
49 Interview with pharmacy people of Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, Ollur, Thrissur district, April 29th
2006 50 Ibid.
146
castor oil and ghee in a uniquely blended manner.51 This proves more effective
than some medicated Thai/m. The continuous use of Kuzhambu is more
effective in the diseases, which affect the bones.52
Lehyam I Rasayanam
The new herbs are collected, identified properly, then cleaned and dried.
Each of the ingredients for powdering is pulverized separately and
homogenously mixed together as per the fonnula. Prepare the kashayam
(decoction) or Swarasam (juice) or with water, mix it with jaggery/sugar or
sugar candy and concentrate to the required consistency. The powdered raw
herb is added as Prakshepa choomam, weII mixed and laced with ghee, honey
-3 etc. as per Text.)
Kashayam (Kwatha)
As per the fonnula, the drugs are collected, identified properly, cleaned
and the raw herbs for drying are to be dried. Weighed quantity of ingredients as
per formula is made in to coarse powder, mixed with sufficient quantity of
water well boiled and reduced to attain the proper specifications. 541n
Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, they are conducting the microbiological analysis
as per WHO norms. This helps to market a pathogen free kasayam and increase
51 ET, Naryanan Mooss, interview dated 25 th April 52 Ibid
53 Interview dated April 29th Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, Ollur, Thrissur. 541nterview dated April 29th Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, Ollur, Thrissur.
147
the shelf life of the product. 55 The dosage can be fixed according to condition
of the patient and disease, normal dosage is 15 ml mixed with two time of
boiled and cooled water. 56 Here we can see the similarities of making kasayam
between Aalathiyoor Nambi Ashtavaidyan family and Vaidyamadham family.
Both these families prescribe preparing kashayam in five liters of water, unlike
the other Ashtavaidya families (they make it in four liters ofwater).57
Choornam
The ingredients are collected, identified properly then cleaned and died.
Each of the ingredients is pulverized separately and homogeneously mixed
together as per the fonnula. These powders are used directly or with additives
or used for making decoction (Thoyam) according to the condition of patients
and diseases. 58
Gulika/Varti/Vattu
The medicines from plant origin, animal origin and mineral origin are
collected, identified properly and cleaned. The ingredients for making powders
are to be dried and pulverized separately and then homogeneously mixed
together and ground into the base as per the formula up to the proper
55 Interview dated 30th April, Pharmacist, Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, OIlur, Thrissur. 56 E.T. Narayanan Mooss, interview dated 25th April 57 Interview dated January 15th 2007, with Cheriya Naryanan Namboothiri, Vaidyamadham, Palakakkad district. 58 Interview dated 30th April, Pharmacist, Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala, OHur, Thrissur.
148
consistency for making Gulika/Varti/Vattul Tablets.59 The medicines, which
require purification, are identified and purified as per the textual references and
the purity analytically checked to ensure the medicine is devoid of side
effects.6o
Treatments in Astavaidyam
In Astavaidyam, treatments of diseases are classified into "shodhana"
(purification) and "shamana" (pacification).
Shodhana Chikitsa
Shodhana Chikitsa61 in Astavaidyam is tenned as Panchakarma. It is a
curative line of treatment for all diseases, which are not amenable to Shamana
Chikitsa. Panchakarma procedures are purifacatory one. The word
Panchakarma comprises of two words namely pancha and karma. Pancha
means five and karma means therapy.
The five methods or procedures are the elimination of vitiated doshas
from the body. They are:
• Vamana Karma (Emesis therapy).
59 Ibid.
60 E.T. Narayanan Mooss, interview dated 25th April, the idea of making tablets in Ayurveda was first introduced by P.K. Varier of Kottakkal Arya Vaidya Sala, he is the disciple of Kuttencheri Ashtavaidya Mooss( this Ashtavaidya family was famous for teaching the Ashtangahridayam than the practicing medicine) 61 Treatment methods
149
• VirechanaKarma (Purgation therapy).
• Anuvasana Vasti Karma (Unctuous enema therapy).
• Nirooha Vasti Karma (Decoction enema therapy).
• Nasya Karma (Errhine therapy).
Shamana Chikitsa
It is mainly the oral medication system. The medicines used are Asavas,
Kashayas, Lehyas, Ghees, Bhasmas and Sindooras. This method also includes
external application of medicines such as oils and rasakriyas.
Special Treatments of Astavaidyas
Dhara is a method of Kerala special treatment evolved from the genius
of the medical tradition here. Kerala physicians conduct many such distinctive
and excellent fonns of treatments, not practiced in the other parts of India. A
continuous stream of medicated wann oil/herbal decoctions/medicated
milklbuttennilk is poured onto the forehead for 45 to 90 minutes. This
procedure often induces a mental state similar to a trance, which creates
profound relaxation of the mind and body; it deeply relaxes and revitalizes the
central nervous system. Shirodhara gives the best results when taken after an
Abhyanga. Dhara is good for all ailments. Changing the liquid as per the
Dosha, condition, with necessary alteration in the procedure, is useful to
150
alleviate any Dosha. The above treatments are prescribed for the medical
problems like epilepsy, diabetic neuropathy, paralysis etc.
Pizhichil is a procedure developed in Kerala, which gives the effects ,
both Snehana and Swedana. It is considered as one of the Keraleeya
Panchakarma Techniques. Medicated oil pour onto the body in continuous
streams while being gently massaged by four therapists for 45 to 90 minutes. It
is extremely soothing and relaxing. It acts as a free radical scavenger, toning,
strengthening and deeply rejuvenating the whole body. It is giver after
Abhyanga. Pizhichil is prescribing for the deceases like paraplegic, hemiplegia
and other vata dominant ailments.
Abhyangam is a whole body massage with special herbal oils to nourish
and revitalize the body tissues (Dhatus) and to allow the toxins to be removed
from the cells. Abhyanga has much deeper and more far-reaching effects than
the ordinary massage using mineral oils and lotions. Abhyanga achieves
deepest healing effects by naturally harmonizing Body Mind and Spirit. This
massage is performed symmetrically two therapists for one hour and is usually
followed by a medicated steam bath (Sweda). Kativasthi: In this process,
specially prepared warm medicated oil is kept over the lower back with herbal
paste boundary. This treatment lasts for 45 to 60 minutes. Kizhi: Herbal
leaves/powders are applied to the whole body in boluses with hot medicated
oils for 45 minutes per day for a period of7 to 14 days.
151
Tabulation and analysis of the data from the patients
Table No: 1. Personal profile
Sex Female lVIale
49 51
Age Below 25 25-50 Above 50
07 33 60
Education Below Graduation Post
Graduation Graduation
54 33 13
The first table depicts about the age and education of the patients. Here
we can see that people above fifty years are coming more. In the older
152
generation, we can see more health problems, like orthopedic problems and
living style diseases. The educational qualification of the patients shows that
the below graduation level people are coming more. So education is not an
influential factor in the selection of the medium of medicine.
Table No: 2. Occupation
Professional Business Service Skilled/ House wife Student
Unskilled
09 10 34 17 22 08
This table shows that more patients are coming from the service sector,
(retired teachers are more in number). Another category is housewives. Skilled
and unskilled persons working in the gulf countries constitute the third
category.
153
Table No: 3. Nativity
Keralities Non Resident NRI's Foreigners
Keralites
39 40 10 II
The above table shows that, 40% of the non- resident Keralites are using
the indigenous medicine. Most of these people are using the Ayurvedic
medicine as an alternative medicine for the allopathic medicine because of the
reason that the allopathic medicine has failed to cure their medical problems.
Eleven patients are foreigners. It not only proves the interest of the local people
but also the interest of the western people in the traditional Ayurvedic
medicine.
154
Table No: 4. Religion and Caste of patients
Religion Hindu Christian Muslim
55 31 14
-
Caste Upper Caste Ezhavas Nairs
Hindus
11 29 15
This table shows a drastic change in the Kerala society. Ashtavaidyas
are Nambuthiri Brahmins, but here we are able to see, the patients are mostly
non-brahmanic category. In addition, a good number of Christian patients we
could tabulate here. In the Hindu category, itself we can see the emerging
number of Ezhava patients compared to Nair's and upper caste Hindus. E.T
Neelakanadan Mooss of Eledath Thaikkattu Mooss already depicted about this
phenomena. He observes "after the land reforms we could see the socio
political and economic upliftment of the lower caste people in Kerala." 62
62 The interview with E.T. Narayanan Mooss, dated may 3rd 2006
155
Table No: 5
Disease No. of patients
l. Arthritics related, Orthopedic 56
2. Infertility 05
3. Delivery purpose 03
4. Asthma 04
5. Skin Problem 06
6. Chicken Guinea 06
7. Diabetic, cardiovascular problems 20
Most of the patients whom I interviewed were either arthritis related
patients or orthopedic patients. The above table shows that 56% of the patients
belong to this category. The 21 % of them belong to life style diseases like
diabetics and cardiovascular problems. According to E.T Narayanan Mooss,
"the numbers of patients with infertility problems are increasing year by year.
Around twenty years back, the numbers of patients were maximum one or two
156
in a year, but now days it is at least two per day,,63. Here the percentage of
infertility patients is 8%.
Table No: 6
Particulars Yes No
Allopathic medicine 76 24
Table No: 7
Particulars Yes No
Done Lab test, scanning 74 26
The above table shows that 76 patients are ex- allopathic patients, due to
the failure of the allopathic medicine to cure their diseases; they depend on
Ayurvedic medicine as an alternative medicine. The rest 24 patients are going
for Ayurvedic treatment as their first choice. Among these patients, 74 have
already done their lab tests and scanning for the diagnosis. However, the
63 The interview with E.To Narayanan Mooss, dated may 3rd 2006
157
Ayurveda is neither describing nor supporting these tests. The newly
institutionalized Ashtavaidyas like Thrissur Thaikkattu and Elyedath
Thaikkattu prefer to diagnosis the patients with the modem technologies.
According to Pulamanthol Mooss, "still we are following the traditional
methods for the diagnosis, if we will depend on the modem technologies; it
may lead to for a wrong diagnosis." The above table shows that out of 100
patients, 74 (including some foreigners) are well aware about Ayurvedic
medicine and Ashtavaidyas. The rest 24 do not have any idea about
Ashtavaidyas, even though they have some knowledge about Ayurveda.
Table No:8
Particulars
Through Friends, Relatives
Media and Formal
Is there any difficulty to follow path yam
158
No. of patients
94
06
Yes No
20 80
This study shows that, 94% of the patients going to the Ashtavaidyas not
due to advertisements, but because of the ideas, which spreads through
interactions. The rest are there because of the advertisement. 80 people are
ready to follow the pathyam64, even though it is very difficult to follow, which
is directed by Ashtavaidyas. In most of the cases, allopathic doctors are not
giving any restrictions or control on diet or the life style, but Ayurvedic
patients are bound to follow these restrictions.
Table No: 9
Particular's Yes No
Have you Visited any other Ayurvedic institutions? 44 56
The above table shows that, 44 patients have treated with other
ayurvedic vaidyas, but they could not cure their problems because this reason
they came for Ashtavaidyas. The rest 56 are giving first preference for
ashtavaidya treatment. The most of the patients prefer the senior Moosses,
because of their faith in Moosses' s competence to cure their problems.
Thus this chapter has a detailed depiction about the Ashtavaidya system
of medicine. The first part discusses the senior Mooss' from this system of
64 The control and restrictions on diet and life style for a particular period, which is directed by an Ayurvedic vaidyan
159
therapy. The Ashtavaidyam itself has lots of peculiarities. Though these
vaidyas are practicing within the framework of Ayurvedic medicine; they have
lots of specialties assembled within the vernacular cosmology of Kerala. These . ~
vaidyas are following the Ashtangahridayam for their treatment, but at the
same time, their treatment (vadiyam) is mainly based on yukthi and upasana.
Because of this reason this system of medicine became a distinguished figure
within the conventional Ayurveda practice in Kerala .. At the same time, these
vaidyas are claiming that the Ashtavaidyam is the base of the Kerala Ayurveda.
The second part of the chapter discussed the data collected from the
Ashtavaidya patients and the interesting findings emerging from the survey.
But, it must be recognized that this study is not intended to have the inclusive
interpretations of the data above mentioned. These data shed lights on whole
Kerala society and its medical practices. This study basically deals with the
Ashtavaidyas of Kerala so I did elementary level of interpretation of data in the
second section of this chapter.
160