Challenges in Performance Based Design -...
Transcript of Challenges in Performance Based Design -...
![Page 1: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Challenges in Performance Based Design
Patrick van Hees Lund Univeristiy, Sweden www.brand.lth.se [email protected]
![Page 2: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Overview
Trends in FSE – Background Focus on risks for fire development Discussion on the different steps
» New materials/new areas » Advanced modelling » Energy conservation
Conclusions=Challenges
![Page 3: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Background Fire Safety Engineering has been used
intensively in building applications within a fire performance based design
New areas such as marine applications (ships
with composite instead of steel, trains) New materials/products are introduced for which
new challenges appear e.g. products based on technical textiles
Picture:SP
Picture:Allianz
![Page 4: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Difference between fire prescriptive and performance based solution
Prescriptive solutions are based on well defined criteria e.g. : • A specific class for wall linings in evacuation routes e.g. Euroclass B • A specific fire resistance of the enclosure e.g. REI 120 • A specific width of doors/ corridors for the evacuation routes • A specific minimum path length to the nearest exit.
CE0123
AnyCo Ltd, P.O. Box 21, B - 1050
99
0123-CPD-0001EN 1234
80mm Mineral wool for use in buildingsReaction to fire - Class B
Thermal conductivity - 0.04 W/mKFlexural tensile strength - NPD
Picture:SP
![Page 5: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Fire performance based approach
Performance-based regulations design an objective, but do not say how it should be accomplished
Objectives can be e.g. safe
evacuation within a specified time, structure stability within a specified time.
This option allows more flexible
solutions (large public areas) and more cost-efficient designs
Picture: Tensinet
![Page 6: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
General approach (SFPE guide)
Choice of Design
Check with performance criteria
Run Trial Designs
Define Design Fire Scenario
Define Performance Criteria
Define Scope, Goals and Objectives
![Page 7: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Example Trial design for establishing safe evacuation - Deterministic
Choice of Fire Scenario and Design Fire
Calculation of smoke and fire spread by means of a zone model or CFD code
Calculation of the available evacuation time by means of evacuation models
![Page 8: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Developing Design fire scenarios - 1
Can include a wide range of scenarios which should be reduced to a selected group of scenarios which are considered as design fire scenarios.
A fire scenario represents one of a set of fire conditions that are thought to be threatening to a building.
So it should include state of the art of the building, its content and its occupants at time of ignition of resultant fire
![Page 9: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Developing Design Fire scenarios - 2
Factors that affect fire development Use of fire scenario characteristics
Defining components (gather pre-data) Making assumptions (lack of pre-data) Building characteristics Occupants characteristics Fire characteristics
Different tools are given to identify both failure modes and effect analysis, what-if, failure analysis, historical data, statistics. - Are they valid for all buildings?
![Page 10: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Developing Design Fire scenarios - Definition
Probabilistic approaches includes using probabilities coming from Statistics such as fire frequency, initiation frequency Hazard and failure analysis (see risk course) System availability and reliability Risk evaluation (overall assessment)
Deterministic approaches use calculation methods, test data for each scenario is needed
Quite often combinations are used!
![Page 11: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Developing Design Fire scenarios - Characterising
Process will lead to fire design curve and includes: Building characteristics (components, numbers, features,
structural components, fuel load, protections systems, egress components, services, operations, fire department, environmental factors)
Occupants characteristic (human behaviour, response, occupant loads, evacuation time, egress flows)
![Page 12: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Example of a design fire
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Time (s)
HR
R (k
W)
2.tRHR α=
Linear decay
Picture:Lund University
Constant HRR
![Page 13: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Methods to define design fire • Defined by the regulator ? • Real scale test of the fire scenario including items of
building products and content. • Combination of HRR data of items of building content
and building products obtained in full scale test data using so called open calorimeter techniques
• Modelling by means of empirical models using small scale test data such as given from the cone calorimeter test.
• Modelling by means of flame spread models within advanced CFD codes.
• Probabilistic approaches • ….. Magic numbers?...
![Page 14: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Methods for real scale data - 1 Room test e.g. using ISO 9705 either with
linings or even completely furnished (in place)
Picture:SP
![Page 15: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Methods for real scale data - 2 Establishing the HRR from a full sized item in a
open calorimeter (in place) ISO 24473
Picture:SP
![Page 16: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Type of models 1 – Semi empirical models Semi Empirical models as cone tools (link
between the cone and a specific scenario e.g. room corner)
Picture:SP
![Page 17: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Type of models 2 CFD models for more flexible solutions
Picture:SP
![Page 18: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Test Methods for modelling Cone calorimeter using small items of building
materials or components of products (furniture, composites)
Pictures: SP
![Page 19: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Use for new materials: What to consider?
Many of the FSE techniques are possible to use for these materials BUT!! Consider the following!!
When using models: Are the models thoroughly being validated for the materials ? Check the applicability of the model by running some different products at different scale levels Are the small scale tests applicable for the materials i.e. can they be mounted in a realistic way? Can you obtain the input data for the CFD models for your new material
![Page 20: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Input-data Which product can be tested ?
?
Picture SP
![Page 21: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
New energy demands challenges in fire safety design
Higher thermal insulation means more use of new insulation materials and often also combustible insulation (thickness effectiveness) How does complex systems perform?
Reduced natural ventilation can lead to
underventilated fires How well perform the models? How deal we with this in PBD?
![Page 22: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Energy Demands – cont. - Knowledge is available on traditional room
fires but many fire developments spread inside a construction.
- Need for more knowledge on constructions fires.
- Need to learn from real fires by cases studies – new project at Lund University
![Page 23: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Which fire scenario are covered ?
?
Picture SP Picture VTT
þ
![Page 24: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Reaction to fire - Challenges Fire development becomes more
and more a question of the a whole system and no longer of single products or materials. e.g. Sandwich panels, façades, roofs, etc.
How do we tackle this?
Picture SP
![Page 25: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Haeundae Highrise - Busan Marine City Korea – 2010
Foto: Koreabridge.net
![Page 26: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Fire in schools – Attic fires
Foto Police Gotland
![Page 27: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Conclusions – Challenges - Procedure • Introduce harmonisation between different
areas (transport, buildings) for PBD • Develop more guidance for PBD else it will
become prescriptive PBD J • More Quality control. • More knowledge for PBD with other objectives
e.g. continuation of operation, functional performance of safety systems.
![Page 28: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Conclusions – Challenges - Input • Appropriate tests to cover all fire scenarios
for PBD codes as input to design fires • Good statistics to define probabilities for
probabilistic designs and how to use them • More feedback from real accidents – case
studies • Develop procedures to obtain reaction to fire/
fire resistance for other exposures then the traditional one.
• Ensure link between risk analysis and design fire
![Page 29: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Conclusions – Challenges - Tools • Appropriate tests for input in sub-models for fire
and smoke spread (pyrolysis models etc.) in CFD for PBD
• Standardised ways to inform user of fire models on verification and validation in order to determine uncertainties.
• More knowledge on ALL uncertainties in the process.
• Establish procedures for safety margins, minimum safety levels
![Page 30: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Conclusions Educational challenges: Deep knowledge as well
as practical experience by “performing” a PBD The list is long and certainly not complete!! These challenges should be tackled on
international level! Forums for this can be IAFSS, ISO, SFPE etc.
![Page 31: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Ok -- Go for it!
Risk for too large extrapolations J.
![Page 32: Challenges in Performance Based Design - FireSeatfireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/sites/fireseat.eng.ed.ac.uk/files/images/40Fire_103_PatrickvanHe... · Challenges in Performance Based Design](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022041204/5d54a6e288c9931c6b8b9a77/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Links to our department
www.brand.lth.se
Tack så mycket