Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina...

36
Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents Carolina Vallejo Universitat de Val` encia St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val` encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 1 / 15

Transcript of Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina...

Page 1: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Certain Monomial Characters and Their

Subnormal Constituents

Carolina Vallejo

Universitat de Valencia

St. Andrews, August 2013

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 1 / 15

Page 2: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

This is a joint work with G. Navarro.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 2 / 15

Page 3: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Introduction

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 3 / 15

Page 4: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Let G be a group. A character � 2 Irr(G ) is said to be monomial if

there exist a subgroup U � G and a linear � 2 Irr(U), such that

� = �G :

A group G is said to be monomial if all its irreducible characters are

monomial.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 4 / 15

Page 5: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Let G be a group. A character � 2 Irr(G ) is said to be monomial if

there exist a subgroup U � G and a linear � 2 Irr(U), such that

� = �G :

A group G is said to be monomial if all its irreducible characters are

monomial.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 4 / 15

Page 6: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

There are few results guaranteeing that a given character of a group

is monomial. It is well-known the following

TheoremLet G be a supersolvable group. Then all irreducible characters of G

are monomial.

But this result depends more on the structure of the group than on

characters themselves.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 5 / 15

Page 7: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

There are few results guaranteeing that a given character of a group

is monomial. It is well-known the following

TheoremLet G be a supersolvable group. Then all irreducible characters of G

are monomial.

But this result depends more on the structure of the group than on

characters themselves.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 5 / 15

Page 8: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

There are few results guaranteeing that a given character of a group

is monomial. It is well-known the following

TheoremLet G be a supersolvable group. Then all irreducible characters of G

are monomial.

But this result depends more on the structure of the group than on

characters themselves.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 5 / 15

Page 9: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

An interesting result.

Theorem (Gow)

Let G be a solvable group. Suppose that � 2 Irr(G ) takes real

values and has odd degree. Then � is rational-valued and monomial.

We give a monomiality criterium which also deals with fields of values

and degrees of characters.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 6 / 15

Page 10: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

An interesting result.

Theorem (Gow)

Let G be a solvable group. Suppose that � 2 Irr(G ) takes real

values and has odd degree. Then � is rational-valued and monomial.

We give a monomiality criterium which also deals with fields of values

and degrees of characters.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 6 / 15

Page 11: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

An interesting result.

Theorem (Gow)

Let G be a solvable group. Suppose that � 2 Irr(G ) takes real

values and has odd degree. Then � is rational-valued and monomial.

We give a monomiality criterium which also deals with fields of values

and degrees of characters.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 6 / 15

Page 12: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Notation: For n an integer, we write

Qn = Q(�);

where � is a primitive nth root of unity.

Theorem ALet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and the values of � are contained in the cyclotomic extension

QjG jp , then � is monomial.

When p = 2, we can recover Gow’s result from Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 7 / 15

Page 13: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Notation: For n an integer, we write

Qn = Q(�);

where � is a primitive nth root of unity.

Theorem ALet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and the values of � are contained in the cyclotomic extension

QjG jp , then � is monomial.

When p = 2, we can recover Gow’s result from Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 7 / 15

Page 14: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

Notation: For n an integer, we write

Qn = Q(�);

where � is a primitive nth root of unity.

Theorem ALet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and the values of � are contained in the cyclotomic extension

QjG jp , then � is monomial.

When p = 2, we can recover Gow’s result from Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 7 / 15

Page 15: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

The hypothesis about the index jNG (P) : P j is necessary.

Consider

the group SL(2,3) and the prime p=3.

The solvability hypothesis is necessary in both Gow’s and Theorem A.

The alternating group A6 is a counterxample in the two cases.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 8 / 15

Page 16: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

The hypothesis about the index jNG (P) : P j is necessary. Consider

the group SL(2,3) and the prime p=3.

The solvability hypothesis is necessary in both Gow’s and Theorem A.

The alternating group A6 is a counterxample in the two cases.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 8 / 15

Page 17: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

The hypothesis about the index jNG (P) : P j is necessary. Consider

the group SL(2,3) and the prime p=3.

The solvability hypothesis is necessary in both Gow’s and Theorem A.

The alternating group A6 is a counterxample in the two cases.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 8 / 15

Page 18: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Introduction

The hypothesis about the index jNG (P) : P j is necessary. Consider

the group SL(2,3) and the prime p=3.

The solvability hypothesis is necessary in both Gow’s and Theorem A.

The alternating group A6 is a counterxample in the two cases.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 8 / 15

Page 19: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

B� Theory

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 9 / 15

Page 20: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

We say that � 2 Irr(G ) is a �-special character of G , if

(a) �(1) is a �-number.

(b) For every subnormal subgroup N / /G , the order of all the

irreducible constituents of �N is �-number.

A B� character of a group G may be thought as an irreducible

character of G induced from a �-special character of some subgroup

of G . (True in groups of odd order).

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 10 / 15

Page 21: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

We say that � 2 Irr(G ) is a �-special character of G , if

(a) �(1) is a �-number.

(b) For every subnormal subgroup N / /G , the order of all the

irreducible constituents of �N is �-number.

A B� character of a group G may be thought as an irreducible

character of G induced from a �-special character of some subgroup

of G . (True in groups of odd order).

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 10 / 15

Page 22: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

We say that � 2 Irr(G ) is a �-special character of G , if

(a) �(1) is a �-number.

(b) For every subnormal subgroup N / /G , the order of all the

irreducible constituents of �N is �-number.

A B� character of a group G may be thought as an irreducible

character of G induced from a �-special character of some subgroup

of G . (True in groups of odd order).

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 10 / 15

Page 23: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

We say that � 2 Irr(G ) is a �-special character of G , if

(a) �(1) is a �-number.

(b) For every subnormal subgroup N / /G , the order of all the

irreducible constituents of �N is �-number.

A B� character of a group G may be thought as an irreducible

character of G induced from a �-special character of some subgroup

of G .

(True in groups of odd order).

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 10 / 15

Page 24: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

B� Theory

We say that � 2 Irr(G ) is a �-special character of G , if

(a) �(1) is a �-number.

(b) For every subnormal subgroup N / /G , the order of all the

irreducible constituents of �N is �-number.

A B� character of a group G may be thought as an irreducible

character of G induced from a �-special character of some subgroup

of G . (True in groups of odd order).

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 10 / 15

Page 25: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Main results

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 11 / 15

Page 26: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Now, I can state the main result.

Theorem BLet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and its values are contained in the cyclotomic extension QjG jp ,

then � is a Bp character of G .

We notice that Bp characters with degree not divisible by p are

monomial.Thus Theorem B implies Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 12 / 15

Page 27: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Now, I can state the main result.

Theorem BLet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and its values are contained in the cyclotomic extension QjG jp ,

then � is a Bp character of G .

We notice that Bp characters with degree not divisible by p are

monomial.Thus Theorem B implies Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 12 / 15

Page 28: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Now, I can state the main result.

Theorem BLet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and its values are contained in the cyclotomic extension QjG jp ,

then � is a Bp character of G .

We notice that Bp characters with degree not divisible by p are

monomial.

Thus Theorem B implies Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 12 / 15

Page 29: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Now, I can state the main result.

Theorem BLet G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not divisible

by p and its values are contained in the cyclotomic extension QjG jp ,

then � is a Bp character of G .

We notice that Bp characters with degree not divisible by p are

monomial.Thus Theorem B implies Theorem A.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 12 / 15

Page 30: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Subnormal constituents of B� characters are B� characters.

Then, as

a Corollary of Theorem B we get.

Corollary C

Let G be a p-solvable group. Suppose that jNG (P) : P j is odd,

where P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not

divisible by p and its field of values is contained in QjG jp , then every

subnormal constituent of � is monomial.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 13 / 15

Page 31: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Subnormal constituents of B� characters are B� characters. Then, as

a Corollary of Theorem B we get.

Corollary C

Let G be a p-solvable group. Suppose that jNG (P) : P j is odd,

where P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not

divisible by p and its field of values is contained in QjG jp , then every

subnormal constituent of � is monomial.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 13 / 15

Page 32: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Subnormal constituents of B� characters are B� characters. Then, as

a Corollary of Theorem B we get.

Corollary C

Let G be a p-solvable group. Suppose that jNG (P) : P j is odd,

where P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. If � 2 Irr(G ) has degree not

divisible by p and its field of values is contained in QjG jp , then every

subnormal constituent of � is monomial.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 13 / 15

Page 33: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

We also obtain the following consequence.

The number of such

characters can be computed locally.

Corollary D

Let G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. The number of irreducible characters

which have degree not divisible by p and field of values contained in

QjG jp equals the number of orbits under the natural action of NG (P)

on P=P 0.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 14 / 15

Page 34: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

We also obtain the following consequence. The number of such

characters can be computed locally.

Corollary D

Let G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. The number of irreducible characters

which have degree not divisible by p and field of values contained in

QjG jp equals the number of orbits under the natural action of NG (P)

on P=P 0.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 14 / 15

Page 35: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

We also obtain the following consequence. The number of such

characters can be computed locally.

Corollary D

Let G be a p-solvable group. Assume that jNG (P) : P j is odd, where

P 2 Sylp(G ) for some prime p. The number of irreducible characters

which have degree not divisible by p and field of values contained in

QjG jp equals the number of orbits under the natural action of NG (P)

on P=P 0.

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 14 / 15

Page 36: Certain Monomial Characters and Their Subnormal Constituents · St. Andrews, August 2013 Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Val encia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August

Main results

Thanks for your attention!

Carolina Vallejo (Universitat de Valencia) Certain Monomial Characters St. Andrews, August 2013 15 / 15