Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09
-
Upload
tomthomas -
Category
Health & Medicine
-
view
606 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09
![Page 1: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Project Design
Community Based Monitoring Project
For:CBMP Consortium and Friends23 January 2009
![Page 2: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Monitoring framework for CSC
Quality control/ Triangulation
Government - CSO interface
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Overview
![Page 3: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Quality control/ Triangulation
Monitoring framework for CSC
Government - CSO interface
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Overview
![Page 4: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
ObjectivesBuild capacity of communities and CSOs to demand govt. accountability on public funds through:
promotion of citizen participation in national budget cycle
assess delivery of public services
Leading to a more informed and engaged civil society and a more accountable government
![Page 5: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Assessment of Services
Demand & Supply side
EducationHealthWatSan
Agriculture
CBMPPLAN, AA, CONGOMA
CBM&EGovt. of Malawi
CRCMEJN
CSC
CSC, CRC, CSD
CRC
OthersOthers
National Networks, CSOs
![Page 6: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Monitoring framework for CSC
Quality control/ Triangulation
Government - CSO interface
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Overview
![Page 7: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
•Units of Assessment and Assesses
•Tools - Community Score Card
•Other complimentary tools
•Dissemination/ Advocacy
•Sampling
![Page 8: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Units of Assessment and Assesses
SectorSector Sub-Sub-SectorSector
Unit of Unit of assessmentassessment
(service (service delivery delivery point)point)
Assesses Assesses (users whose (users whose experience/ experience/
perception is likely perception is likely to be different)to be different)
ToolsTools MethodMethod
EducationSchool
Education (rural)
Primary Schools Children - girls, boysParents - women, men
Teachers - male, female
CSC(on a
scale of 5)
Users Focus group discussions
Service ProvidersSelf assessment
Secondary Schools
HealthRural
Health Care
Health Clinic
ChildrenWomen
MenElderly
DisabledService Providers
WatSanWater supply (rural)
Village
ChildrenWomen
MenElderly
DisabledService Providers
WatSan Committee
Agriculture
Input Subsidy
Section
Agriculturist - Men and Women
LabourersService Providers
Ext. Services
SectorSector Sub-Sub-SectorSector
Unit of Unit of assessmentassessment
(service (service delivery delivery point)point)
Assesses Assesses (users whose (users whose experience/ experience/
perception is likely perception is likely to be different)to be different)
ToolsTools MethodMethod
![Page 9: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Community Score Card
Input Tracking
Sector
Entitlements (as per
plan, MGDS, MDG)
Actual
Education
Health
WatSan
Agriculture
Performance Scoring
IndicatorsScore
(scale of 1 - 5)
Generic
(5 to 8 indicators applicable across
all sectors)
Specific(specific to each
sector)
If data on entitlements is not available, just get the actual figures (and keep trying to get entitlement data)
Define each score with examples so that scoring is an informed process
![Page 10: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Performance ScoringPerformance Scoring
IndicatorsScale
Very Bad
BadAvera
geGood
Very Good
Generic
(5 to 8 indicators applicable across all sectors)
Importance of the service
Ability to access
Attitude of Service Provider
Promptness in delivery of service
Fairness
------
------
------
Specific(specific to
each sector)Define each score with examples so that scoring is an
informed process
![Page 11: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Other complimentary tools•Participatory Expenditure Tracking Survey (PETS)
•Citizen Charters
•Wall painting (for information dissemination)
•Community radio (for info dissemination)
•Ombudsman (for resolving govt. community disagreements, disputes)
![Page 12: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Dissemination/ Advocacy
LevelParticipants (representatives of
following groups)Lobbying
Unit Level(School, Health Clinic, Village,
Section)
•Users•Service Providers•Other community members
District
•Community members/ users•Service Providers•T.A Chiefs•M.Ps•DEC members
Prior lobbying with T.As, M.Ps, DEC members
State
•Community members/ users•MPED•M.Ps•National Monitoring Committee•xxx•xxx
•Publication and wide dissemination of findings through network, media•Networking with other National/ International networks•Lobbying with key stakeholders
![Page 13: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Sampling
![Page 14: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
MALAWI
North
District 1TA 1
U1
U2
U3
U4
U5
U6
U7
U8
U9
Un
TA n
District 2TA 1
TA n
District 3TA 1
TA n
District 4
District 5
District 6
Central
District 1
District 2
District 3
District 4
District 5
District 6
District 7
District 8
District 9
South
District 1
District 2
District 3
District 4
District 5
District 6
District 7
District 8
District 9
District 10
District 11
District 12
District 13
Stratified Random Sample
![Page 15: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Quality control/ Triangulation
Monitoring framework for CSC
Government - CSO interface
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Overview
![Page 16: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Quality Control
Key areasKey areas Control measuresControl measuresRecognising the perception of different sub groups of ‘community’ / ‘users’
•Capturing dis-aggregated information from different sub groups of ‘community’/ ‘users’ (children, women, men, disabled, elderly, etc.)
Conflict resolution Capturing consensus and disagreements
Reducing investigator bias
•Detailed facilitator training•Supportive supervision•Defining each indicator •Defining scale (1 to 5) clearly in for each indicator•Sample re-check by Supervisors
Transparency of data•Making data available at all levels from ‘community’/ ‘user’ group to national level•Capturing remarks/ reasons for specific scoring
Traceability of data •Capturing full details of ‘assessors’/ ‘respondents’, time and place for each focus group/ self assessment
External checksTriangulating with other assessments and investigating outliers
![Page 17: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Government - CSO interface
Monitoring framework for CSC
Quality control/ Triangulation
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Overview
![Page 18: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
VILLAGE Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
REGIONAL North Central South
NATIONAL
Consortium
CBMP Team
![Page 19: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 20: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 21: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 22: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Capacity Building
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
REGIONAL TRAINING
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
Investigators
Volunteer
s
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 23: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
POLITICAL
District Committee
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 24: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
District Committee
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 25: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
District Committee
Community
Networks+
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 26: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
District Committee
+
TargetTargetDEC, M.Ps, DEC, M.Ps,
T.AsT.As
NATIONAL
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
Consortium
CBMP Team
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
MASTER TRAINERS
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
Community
Networks
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 27: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
NATIONAL
Consortium
CBMP Team
MASTER TRAINERS
TECHNICAL POLITICAL
+
National Committee
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
District Committee
Community
Networks
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 28: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Implementation Structure for CBMP
+
National Committee
POLITICAL
NATIONAL
Consortium
CBMP Team
MASTER TRAINERS
TECHNICAL
+
TargetTargetGovt. of Govt. of MalawiMalawi National
Networks
REGIONAL
VILLAGE
North Central South
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Lead NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
Implementi
ng NGO
DISTRICT
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
Implementing NGO
District Committee
Community
Networks
TECHNICAL SUPERVISOR
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
Investigators
Volunteers
![Page 29: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Framework for monitoring progress of the CBMP
Government - CSO interface
Monitoring framework for CSC
Quality control/ Triangulation
Overview
![Page 30: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
![Page 31: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
![Page 32: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
![Page 33: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Checklist Checklist for Visitsfor Visits
![Page 34: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
![Page 35: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
Tasks for Tasks for Lead Lead NGONGO
![Page 36: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
Tasks for Tasks for Lead Lead NGONGO
Tasks for Tasks for ImplemeImpleme
nting nting NGONGO
![Page 37: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
Tasks for Tasks for Lead Lead NGONGO
Tasks for Tasks for ImplemeImpleme
nting nting NGONGO
Quarterly Quarterly ReportinReporting Tableg Table
![Page 38: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
Tasks for Tasks for Lead Lead NGONGO
Tasks for Tasks for ImplemeImpleme
nting nting NGONGO
Quarterly Quarterly ReportinReporting Tableg Table
MonthlyMonthlyReportinReporting Tableg Table
![Page 39: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Monitoring and Evaluation of CBMP
Area of monitoring
IndicatorsMeans of
verificationsFrequency
Responsibility
Process
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Lead NGO
Visit Observations Annually Implementing NGOMeetings Monthly Lead NGO
Institutional
Meetings Quarterly Implementing NGOVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateVisit Observations Quarterly Lead NGOProgress Report Annually Lead NGO
Policy
Meetings Quarterly SecretariateVisit Observations Monthly SecretariateProgress Report Monthly Implementing NGO
Visit Observations Annually
Empowerment
Capacity
Checklist Checklist for for
meetings meetings
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Format Format for for
ReportReport
Tasks for Tasks for SecretariSecretari
atat
Tasks for Tasks for Lead Lead NGONGO
Tasks for Tasks for ImplemeImpleme
nting nting NGONGO
Quarterly Quarterly ReportinReporting Tableg Table
MonthlyMonthlyReportinReporting Tableg Table
Annual Annual ReportinReporting Tableg Table
![Page 40: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Master Gantt Chart
Area of monitoring
ActivityWk 1
Wk 2
Wk 3
Wk 4
Wk 5
... ... ... ... ... ...Wk n
Process
Training
Collection of Info
Review Meeting
Roll out of CSC
Institutional
Dissemination
Policy
Empowerment
Capacity
![Page 41: Cbm&E Malawi 23 Jan09](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042521/5483f37ab4af9fdd328b4595/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Very Critical Gantt Chart
Area of monitoring
ActivityWk 1
Wk 2
Wk 3
Wk 4
Wk 5
... ... ... ... ... ...Wk n
Institutional Support to CBMP
team
Technical SupportPLAN
ACTIONAID
Political Support
PLAN
ACTIONAID
CONGOMA
Successful Roll out