Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

24
1

description

Case study showing how Universal Music has automated its weekly media analysis using Artificial Intelligence and is getting better results and lowering costs

Transcript of Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Page 1: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

1

Page 2: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

About Universal Music

♫ Global music market leader:

♯ 6 of the global 10 best selling tracks in 2009

♯ market share 27% in 2008

♫ Market leader in four of the five largest music markets

♫ UK market leader in 2009:

♯ 2 of the 5 best selling albums in the UK in 2009

♯ 33% market share for all albums

♫ Labels Polydor, Mercury, Island, Motown, Decca etc.

♫ Artists include U2, Lady GaGa, Elton John, Metallica

and Amy Winehouse

2

Page 3: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

About Media Buying at Universal Music

♫ TV advertising is a key sales driver:

♯ over 1/3 total marketing budget on TV

♫ Marketing mix differs widely from album to album

♫ Each label responsible for managing its own budgets

♫ TV advertising budget is set on a project by project basis

♫ Budgets and spot allocation modified on a weekly basis

♫ Weekly Albums Chart gives immediate gauge of response

♫ How to separate TV response from other drivers?

3

Page 4: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Media Buying is a Source of Worry for Clients

Of the 50 largest advertisers in the world:

91 percent consider the media buying process

insufficiently transparent

85 percent are convinced their media agency

has deals outside the client agreement

74 percent said these deals cause bias in the

choice of media and recommendations

Source: CMO Council 2009

Page 5: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

AdNav

Agency / Client

Ad Nav our Robotic Media Advisor

Brief Plan/Cost Buy Execute

What-If Reconciliation

Billing

ResultsLearnings

Our “Robotic” Media Advisor uses Artificial Intelligence

to produce over 1000 models annually

Page 6: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Comparison of Approaches

Media Agency + Audit/Model + AdNav

Timing 9-6 x 5 x 52 1 x 1 x 1 24 x 7 x 52

Media effectiveness Gut feel High level patterns Detail of every spot

Media invoice

reconciliationTrust As and when audited 24 x 7 x 52

Media plan

assessmentTrust

As and when audited

& contract24 x 7 x 52

Learning and

improvementLimited

As and when audited

& delayed24 x 7 x 52

Costs (function of

“spec”)As per contract £50k - £100k p/a

£100k build

£50k p/a

Benefits Function of deal book [say] 2-10% 10-30%

Page 7: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Illustrative Results

0

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

6,000

7,000

8,000

9,000

25 N

ov

26 N

ov

27 N

ov

28 N

ov

29 N

ov

30 N

ov

1 D

ec

2 D

ec

3 D

ec

4 D

ec

5 D

ec

6 D

ec

7 D

ec

8 D

ec

9 D

ec

10 D

ec

11 D

ec

12 D

ec

13 D

ec

14 D

ec

15 D

ec

16 D

ec

17 D

ec

18 D

ec

19 D

ec

20 D

ec

21 D

ec

22 D

ec

23 D

ec

24 D

ec

25 D

ec

26 D

ec

27 D

ec

28 D

ec

29 D

ec

30 D

ec

31 D

ec

1 J

an

2 J

an

3 J

an

4 J

an

5 J

an

6 J

an

7 J

an

8 J

an

9 J

an

10 J

an

11 J

an

12 J

an

13 J

an

14 J

an

15 J

an

16 J

an

17 J

an

Date

Sa

les

by

co

ntr

ibu

tio

n (

un

its

)

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

Ad

ve

rtis

ing

sp

en

d (

£/d

ay

)

Ads

Launch

Base

Sales

Spend

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

25 N

ov

26 N

ov

27 N

ov

28 N

ov

29 N

ov

30 N

ov

1 D

ec

2 D

ec

3 D

ec

4 D

ec

5 D

ec

6 D

ec

7 D

ec

8 D

ec

9 D

ec

10 D

ec

11 D

ec

12 D

ec

13 D

ec

14 D

ec

15 D

ec

16 D

ec

17 D

ec

18 D

ec

19 D

ec

20 D

ec

21 D

ec

22 D

ec

23 D

ec

24 D

ec

25 D

ec

26 D

ec

27 D

ec

28 D

ec

29 D

ec

30 D

ec

31 D

ec

1 J

an

2 J

an

3 J

an

4 J

an

5 J

an

6 J

an

7 J

an

8 J

an

9 J

an

10 J

an

11 J

an

12 J

an

13 J

an

14 J

an

15 J

an

16 J

an

17 J

an

Date

Co

st

Pe

r U

nit

)

0

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

Ad

ve

rtis

ing

sp

en

d (

£)

CPU

CPU

CPU

Spend

Day Time Station Programme Adspend IncSales Cost of Sale

SUN 21:00 C4TV BIG BROTHER 10 HOUSE ACTION 5,000 500 10.00

MON 21:00 E4 DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES YR 2 500 100 5.00

MON 21:00 E4 DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES YR 3 600 120 5.00

TUE 21:00 LIVING GHOST WHISPERER S04 80 40 2.00

TUE 21:00 MORE4 WEST WING YR 7 US O5/06 700 350 2.00

WED 21:00 E4 YOUNG SEXY AND...RICH 100 40 2.50

WED 21:00 E4 DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES 400 160 2.50

WED 21:00 E4 ONE TREE HILL YR 6 1,000 400 2.50

THU 21:00 C4TV BIG BROTHER'S LITTLE BROTHER 4,000 500 8.00

FRI 21:00 C4TV UGLY BETTY YR 3 - CRIMES OF FASHION 2,500 250 10.00

FRI 21:00 LIVING FOUR WEDDINGS 200 20 10.00

SAT 21:00 C4TV BIG BROTHER 10 HOUSE ACTION 10,000 500 20.00

Page 8: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign A

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

S 5

-Ap

r

M 6

-Ap

r

T 7

-Ap

r

W 8

-Ap

r

T 9

-Ap

r

F 1

0-A

pr

S 1

1-A

pr

S 1

2-A

pr

M 1

3-A

pr

T 1

4-A

pr

W 1

5-A

pr

T 1

6-A

pr

F 1

7-A

pr

S 1

8-A

pr

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Sales

Spend

What explains this peak?

Page 9: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign A

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

S 5

-Ap

r

M 6

-Ap

r

T 7

-Ap

r

W 8

-Ap

r

T 9

-Ap

r

F 1

0-A

pr

S 1

1-A

pr

S 1

2-A

pr

M 1

3-A

pr

T 1

4-A

pr

W 1

5-A

pr

T 1

6-A

pr

F 1

7-A

pr

S 1

8-A

pr

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Ads

Launch

Base

Sales

Spend

Carryover

Page 10: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign B

T 1

0-F

eb

W 1

1-F

eb

T 1

2-F

eb

F 1

3-F

eb

S 1

4-F

eb

S 1

5-F

eb

M 1

6-F

eb

T 1

7-F

eb

W 1

8-F

eb

T 1

9-F

eb

F 2

0-F

eb

S 2

1-F

eb

S 2

2-F

eb

M 2

3-F

eb

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Sales

Spend

Page 11: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign B

T 1

0-F

eb

W 1

1-F

eb

T 1

2-F

eb

F 1

3-F

eb

S 1

4-F

eb

S 1

5-F

eb

M 1

6-F

eb

T 1

7-F

eb

W 1

8-F

eb

T 1

9-F

eb

F 2

0-F

eb

S 2

1-F

eb

S 2

2-F

eb

M 2

3-F

eb

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Ads

Launch

Base

Sales

Spend

Page 12: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign C

T 1

0-F

eb

W 1

1-F

eb

T 1

2-F

eb

F 1

3-F

eb

S 1

4-F

eb

S 1

5-F

eb

M 1

6-F

eb

T 1

7-F

eb

W 1

8-F

eb

T 1

9-F

eb

F 2

0-F

eb

S 2

1-F

eb

S 2

2-F

eb

M 2

3-F

eb

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Sales

Spend

Page 13: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign C

T 1

0-F

eb

W 1

1-F

eb

T 1

2-F

eb

F 1

3-F

eb

S 1

4-F

eb

S 1

5-F

eb

M 1

6-F

eb

T 1

7-F

eb

W 1

8-F

eb

T 1

9-F

eb

F 2

0-F

eb

S 2

1-F

eb

S 2

2-F

eb

M 2

3-F

eb

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Ads

Launch

Base

Sales

Spend

Page 14: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign D

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

S 5

-Ap

r

M 6

-Ap

r

T 7

-Ap

r

W 8

-Ap

r

T 9

-Ap

r

F 1

0-A

pr

S 1

1-A

pr

S 1

2-A

pr

M 1

3-A

pr

T 1

4-A

pr

W 1

5-A

pr

T 1

6-A

pr

F 1

7-A

pr

S 1

8-A

pr

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Sales

Spend

Page 15: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Campaign D

T 2

4-F

eb

W 2

5-F

eb

T 2

6-F

eb

F 2

7-F

eb

S 2

8-F

eb

S 1

-Mar

M 2

-Mar

T 3

-Mar

W 4

-Mar

T 5

-Mar

F 6

-Mar

S 7

-Mar

S 8

-Mar

M 9

-Mar

T 1

0-M

ar

W 1

1-M

ar

T 1

2-M

ar

F 1

3-M

ar

S 1

4-M

ar

S 1

5-M

ar

M 1

6-M

ar

T 1

7-M

ar

W 1

8-M

ar

T 1

9-M

ar

F 2

0-M

ar

S 2

1-M

ar

S 2

2-M

ar

M 2

3-M

ar

T 2

4-M

ar

W 2

5-M

ar

T 2

6-M

ar

F 2

7-M

ar

S 2

8-M

ar

S 2

9-M

ar

M 3

0-M

ar

T 3

1-M

ar

W 1

-Ap

r

T 2

-Ap

r

F 3

-Ap

r

S 4

-Ap

r

S 5

-Ap

r

M 6

-Ap

r

T 7

-Ap

r

W 8

-Ap

r

T 9

-Ap

r

F 1

0-A

pr

S 1

1-A

pr

S 1

2-A

pr

M 1

3-A

pr

T 1

4-A

pr

W 1

5-A

pr

T 1

6-A

pr

F 1

7-A

pr

S 1

8-A

pr

Ad

vert

isin

g s

pen

d (

£/d

ay)

Sale

s b

y c

on

trib

uti

on

(u

nit

s)

Date

Ads

Launch

Base

Sales

Spend

Page 16: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Before

Business Unit

Contribution

gained

Contribution

lost

Net

contribution

A 200,000 (150,000) 50,000

B 400,000 (200,000) 200,000

C 500,000 (250,000) 250,000

D 300,000 (500,000) (200,000)

E 200,000 (100,000) 100,000

Total 1,600,000 (1,200,000) 400,000

Eight week period

Page 17: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

After

Business Unit

Contribution

gained

Contribution

lost

Net

contribution

A 150,000 (50,000) 100,000

B 350,000 (50,000) 300,000

C 450,000 (100,000) 350,000

D 250,000 (150,000) 100,000

E 150,000 (50,000) 100,000

Total 1,350,000 (400,000) 950,000

An improvement of

£550kA reduction of

£250k

An improvement of

£800kEight week period

Page 18: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Is this approach for you?

18

Page 19: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

AdNav – Good client “fit”

Heavy media user

Sales responses are at least as important

as brand building

Sales data is available daily and by region

Media plans are reviewed and adjusted to

fit changing market conditions

Page 20: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Data accuracy

Feasibility Study

Data variation

Data availability

Page 21: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Check Inter-Correlations

Feasibility Study

Build One-Day Model

Find Correlations

Page 22: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

Feasibility Score Card

Issue Score

Data Availability

Data Accuracy

Data Variability

Correlations and Inter-correlations

One Day Model

Total marks out of 100

Page 23: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

About VBMF

VBMF

£ Consultancy established in 1989

£ Combining analytical and systems expertise

£ Academic input maintains us at leading edge

Cass Business School

The business school for the City of London

High in the research league tables globally

International mix of students from 60 countries

23

Page 24: Case study - improving marketing ROI at Universal Music through Artificial Intelligence

24