8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 1/6

CASE 1 : A DELIMA (SOURCE: ANSWERS FROM ALL GROUP PRESENTATION AC2208EMARCH-JULY 2012)

PROBLEM SOLUTION- TIMESHEET ARE MANUALLY PREPAREDBY EMPLOYEES

• Em !"#$$% &$'"& *$+& +m$ +, ".*$m%$!/$% )

• U%$ .,'* ' &

•

U%$ $#$% &$'" ,+ +",• U%$ +m$ '!"'3 m '*+,$ 4 *.m5 &+,

• S. $&/+%$ +m$ +, ". "6 *$$m !"#$$%

• S*".! *+&$ , + +", ! $m !"#$$ 7*" ' , m",+ "& *$ $, ,'$ ,

+m$%*$$

-DOCUMENTS ARE NOT PROPERLY PRE-NUMBERED RECORDED DOCUMENTED

• S !$% +,/"+'$ &$ m ,. !!# &" .'$% ," &$-,.m5$&$

• M", *!# % $m$, "6 ''"., ,"$&+" +' !!# &$ &$ 9 ",!# &$ &$ %$, " '.% "m$& 7*$, #m$,

* 5$$, !", ". % , +,

-D"'.m$, % (+,/"+'$ P O D O $ ') %*".!5$ &" $&!# &$-,.m5$&$

-U%$ ! $% $ + +", "6 % , & 6+, ,'+ !%"6 7 &$ (MYOB UBS SAP $ ')-P$&+" +' !!# &$ &$ . $ '", &"!

''"., %

-LAC OF AUTHORISATION OF BUSINESSTRANSACTION

• N" SOP 9 !! $'+%+", 7$&$ m $ . *"&+%$ 5# $+ *$& E, ; #$ "& P,

H %*+m *

• P$&%", ! /$*+'!$ $< $,%$% 7$&$'* & $ " '"m ,#

• A!! $'+%+", %*".! 6"!!"7 SOP• E< $,%$% %*".! 5$ . *"&+%$ 5#

!$ % 7" $&%",%• P$&%", ! $< $,%$ ' , 5$ '* & $

% '"m ,#=% $< $,%$• S$ &$ +", "6 . +$% 5 7 $&%",% 7*" &"/$ % m +, *$

"'.m$, %• S*".! 5$ %$ & $ " $,$& ! ,

% $'+6+' . *"&+> +",

LAC OF TRAININGI, $?. $ @"5 & +,+,

T*$ '"m ,#=% %$'&$ &# +% +, *$" +,+", * C+3 Am# +% 6&$%*

& . $ 6&"m !"' ! .,+/$&%+ # 7+ *," &$!$/ , 7"&3+, $< $&+$,'$ "* , !$ *$& @"5 $%'&+ +",$66$' +/$!# % F+, ,'$ E<$'. +/$ A%+m !$ *+, % ''"., +,

&$ m$, 7 % ., 5!$ " 5$ %"!/$5# C+3 Am#

C+3 Am# %*".! 5$ %$, 6"& 6.& *$&& +,+, 5# *$ '"m ,#=% "

m , $m$, " 6.& *$& $,* ,'$*$& ., $&% , +, +, &$! +", " *$&

@"5 $%'&+ +", , '"m $ $,'# "$&6"&m *$& @"5 T*$ m , $m$,

%*".! $,&"! *$& " %*"& '".&%$$%+ , $ " +m &"/$ 7"&3

$66+'+$,'# , $66$' +/$,$%% +, ,#!"' ! +,% + . +",% %.'* % U+TMS.,7 # U,+/$&%+ # , " *$&%

IMPROPER ORGANI;ATION CHART I %*".! 5$ &" $&!# & 7, 7+ *

8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 2/6

Im &" $& O& ,+% +", ! C* &T*$ "& ,+% +", ! '* & 7 %+m &" $&!# & 7, , "" 6$7

"%+ +",% * 5$$, $ " *$'* & T*$ '* & "$% ," +,'!. $

+% +,' $ & m$, % " %*"7 *$"& ,+% +", 5# $ & m$, !6.,' +",%

+% +,' 6.,' +", ! $ & m$, % "%*"7 +% +,' @"5 $%'&+ +", 6"&$ '* $ & m$, , %$/$& !+m "& , "%+ +",% %*".! 5$

$ " $,%.&$ $66$' +/$ ,$66+'+$, '", &"!

SEGREGATION OF DUTIESS$ &$ +", "6 D. +$%

E,'+3 ; #$ "$% ," $<$&'+%$ *+%. +$% &" $&!# % " %$ &$ $

m , $m$, . +$% $?. !!# m",*$ $m !"#$$% "6 *$ '"m ,# *

*$ m # *+,3% 6+ % " $&6"&m %.'*. +$%

S$ &$ +", "6 . +$% +% +m "& , +, '"m ,#=% m , $m$, % "/"+ ,# %3 &$ ., ,'# 6& .

,$ !+ $,'$ "7$& 5.%$+,$66+'+$,'# , 7"&3 $! #M"&$"/$& + +% " $,%.&$ *$m , $m$, 7"&3% $66+'+$, !# ,$66$' +/$!# C+3 Am# +% * % 5$$,

%%+ ,$ " ,.m$&".% 7"&3!" %, %"m$ "6 *$ 7"&3% &$ ,"

7+ *+, *$& @"5 $%'&+ +", % F+, ,'$ E<$'. +/$ E,'+3 ; #$%*".! %$ &$ $ C+3 Am#=%

7"&3!" % " " *$& $&%",,$!''"& +, " *$ &$!$/ , @"5$%'&+ +",% F"& $< m !$ A''".,

P # 5!$% , R$'$+/ 5!$% %*".! 5$%%+ ,$ " +66$&$, $&%",,$!

REMO AL OF AUDITOR• R$m"/ ! "6 A. + "& 5$6"&$ *$

$< +& +", "6 *+% $&m% "6 "66+'$

• U, $& S$' +", 1 2 ( ) ( ) ( ) CA1 ",!# *$ %* &$*"! $&% ' ,&$m"/$ *$ . + "& 5$6"&$ *$$< +& +", "6 *+% $&m%

• R$?.+&$ *$ %%+, "6 "& +, &#&$%"!. +", $,$& ! m$$ +, 7+ *% $'+ ! ," +'$ "6 28 #% +/$, "

*$ . + "&

ISSION AND MISSION• T*$ C"m ,# ",!# * % m+%%+",

7*+'* +% %*"& $&m " ! " '*+$/$• C"m ,# " ," '!$ &!# % $ *$+&

/+%+", % 7$!! % *$ "5@$' +/$ "6 *$C"m ,#

• I 66$' % *$ $&6"&m ,'$ "6 *$+&$m !"#$$ % *$# ",= 3,"7 7*

" '*+$/$

• T*$ m+%%+", /+%%+", , "5@$' +/$"6 *$ C"m ,# m.% 5$ '!$ &!#% $

• I m.% 5$ +,6"&m$ " $m !"#$$% %"* *$# 3,"7 *$ C"m ,#=% " !

LAC OF CONTROL• D"'.m$, % 9 ,"

&$,.m5$&$ m+%%+,

• D"'.m$, % 9 %$&+ !!# ,.m5$&$ 3$ &" $&!#

• A%%$ % 9 &" $&!# &$'"& $ 3$ +,

8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 3/6

• A%%$ % 9 ," &$'"& $• N" %. $&/+%+",

!"'3$ &""m• S. $&/+%+", 9 ",$ +, &$ .! & ,

'", +,.+, 5 %+%• A!! &$'"& $ "'.m$, % %*".! 5$

m &3$ "% $• M , $m$, %*".! &$/+$7 *$

$?. '# "6 +, $&, ! '", &"! ",&$ .! & 5 %+%

NO BUDGET PLANNING• N" 5. $ ! ,,+, 7 % &$ &$

• U%$ " ! , ", *$ '"% * 7+!! 5$+,'.&&$

• T" '"m &$ *$ 5. $ '"% ,' . ! '"% " %$$ ,# / &+ ,'$

• T" *$! m , $& " m 3$ $66+'+$,$'+%+", m 3+,

DIRECTOR=S DUTIES• D+&$' "&% " ," ., $&% , 5".

*$ C"m ,+$% A' 1

• A!! # $% "6 +,'"& "& $ '"m ,+$%• E,* ,'$ '"& "& $ "/$&, ,'$• M $&% &$ & +, "7$&% "6 *$:

&$ +% & & "6 *$ '"m ,#m , $m$, ,

m+,+% & +", "6 *$'"m ,#O66+'$&% "6 *$ '"m ,#A''"., +, , . + +, "6

*$ '"m ,#

APPOINTMENT OF AUDITOR• D+&$' "&% %+m !# "+, . + "&

7+ *". ,# &" $& &"'$ .&$

• G$,$& ! &.!$%A "+, , . + "& $ '*

A,,. ! G$,$& ! M$$ +, (%$'1 2(1))T*$ . + "& "+, $ *"! %"66+'$ ., +! *$ '",'!.%+", "6

*$ ,$< AGM

CORPORATE GO ERNANCE• C+3 Am# " ," * /$ $,". *

3,"7!$ $ , $< $&+$,'$ +, *$&6+$! "6 7"&3

• C"m ,# %*".! &"/+ $ .+ ,'$, & +,+, " ,$7 $m !"#$$%

• M , $m$, %*".! *+&$ %"m$",$* +% ' 5!$ +, "+, *+% 7"&3

NO STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE

(SOP)• W+ * & 7 ! "6 '"m ,#=% m",$#

m $ 7+ *". &" $& "'.m$, +",• D$'+%+", , . *"&+> +", m $ 5#

*$ +&$' "&% ", + % "7, 7+ *".&" $& "'.m$, +",

• I 7+!! +,'&$ %$ *$ &+%3 "6 6& . ,+,'",%+% $,'# +, $&6"&m+, %3

D$!+m %*".! +m !$m$, % , &

" $& +, &"'$ .&$ (SOP) :• I,'&$ %$ $66+'+$,'# , '",%+% $,'$+, $&6"&m+, %3

• I, +' $ '"m !+ ,'$ +, *$ $, + #&$?.+&$m$, % , ' , 5$ .%$ "

& +, " *$&%

8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 4/6

• G+/$ *$ . + "& * & +m$ " 3$$& '3 "6 *$ & ,% ' +", ,

m"/$m$, "6 %%$

LAC OF COMPETENCY• H$ "6 $ & m$, !$ $ 5#

.,?. !+6+$ % 66• D"$% ," % $, ", & +,+, "6 % 66• D$'&$ %$ '"m ,# $&6"&m ,'$ %

7*"!$• D+%'&$ + *$ '"m ,# &$ . +",

• S $, m"&$ ", & +,+, " $?.+$m !"#$$ 7+ * &" $& 3,"7!$ $

• S*".! *+&$ ?. !+6+$ % 66 * * /$$< $&+$,'$

• Em !"#$$% m ,. !!# &$ &$ *$+&+m$%*$$ %

• N" % 66 +, '* & $ , m",+ "&$m !"#$$ $, ,'$

• S 66 3$ / , $ "/$& *$%! '3,$%%

• D$'&$ %$ +, '"m ,#$&6"&m ,'$

•

• I,% !! . "m $ +m$ $, ,'$

C=S CREDITWORTHINESS T*$ 3$# $!$m$, % 5"&&"7$& %*".! * /$+, "& $& " "5 +, '&$ + :

1 C* & ' $& I, $ &+ # 5"&&"7$&=%&$ . +",

2 C '+ # '"m ,#=% 5"&&"7+,*+% "&#C + ! N$ 7"& *C"!! $& ! A%%$ % " %$'.&$ *$$5

C", + +",% O6 *$ 5"&&"7$& ,*$ "/$& !! $'","m#

E +, $&$% & $ , m"., "6 &+,'+ !

RECORDING• S$/$& ! %%$ % .&'* %$ 5# *$

'"m ,# 7$&$ ," &$'"& $

• E/$&# %%$ .&'* %$ m.% 5$&$'"& $ m ,. !!# ,'"m . $&+>$

• A%%+ , $&%",(%) " 5$ &$% ",%+5!$6"& *$ '"m ,# %%$ %

• C&$ $ , A%%$ M , $m$,D+/+%+",

• P&" "%$ *$ A%%$ T +, S#% $mLEAN ORGANI;ATION

• L$ , "& ,+> +", 7+ * 5 %+'6.,' +", ! "%+ +",

• P"%+ +", 6.,' +", %*".! 5$'! &+6+$ '!$ &!#

ACADEMIC KUALIFICATION• D+ ," m$$ ' $m+' ?. !+6+' +",

"& &$!$/ , $< $&+$,'$ * &$?.+&$

• H+&$ $" !$ * * /$ ""' $m+' ?. !+6+' +",% &$!$/ ,

$< $&+$,'$%

8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 5/6

5# *$ '"m ,#

STATUTORY AUDIT• C"m ,# + ," $&6"&m *$

S . "&# A. +

• O,!# !$ ! " P.5!+' L+% $C"m ,# N" '"m .!%"&# 6"&P&+/ $ C"m ,# " $&6"&m S A

• P&+/ $ C"m ,+$% m # ,$$ " "%" 7*$, !#+, 6"& !" ,% , $ '6&"m F+, ,'+ ! I,% + . +",%

AUDITOR=S DUTIES ANDRESPONSIBILITIES

• E,'+3 ; #$ &+$ " ,$ " + $. + "& " m 3$ .,?. !+6# &$ "&

• S$' 1 (2)E< &$%% " +,+", +, &$ "& ( . # "&$ "& $6$' % +&&$ .! &+ +$% +,

''"., )• S$' 1 ( )

R$ "& & +'.! &% "6 $6+'+$,'#6 +!.&$ , %*"& '"m+,

PROBLEM IN FINANCE DI ISION• I,/"+'$ ," &$-,.m5$&$• C"m ,# + ," %$, S $m$, "6

A''"., (SOA) " '!+$,• N" &$ &$ m", *!# &$'",'+!+ +",• U%$ '"m ,#=% m",$# 6"& $&%", !

.%$• N" %$ &$ +", "6 . +$%

• A "+, ,$7 6+, ,'$ m , $& ". *"&+>$ , %. $&/+%$ 6+, ,'$$ & m$,

• S$ & $ . +$% ''"& +, " 7"&3"%+ +",

• Em * %+>$ *$ %$ & $ !$ ! $, + #'",'$

ACCOUNTING SYSTEM• MYOB S"6 7 &$ ," +, $ & $

• P.&'* %$ ,$7 %"6 7 &$• E : UBS SAP S"6 7 &$ R m'",

E, +,$$&+, A. "'"., $ 'PROBLEM IN HUMAN RESOURCEDI ISION

• P # 7 $% 7$$3!# 7+ *".$m !"#$$% 5$,$6+

• U,?. !+6+$ % 66 (! '3 "6 3,"7!$ $, $< $&+$,'$)

• L '3 "6 $m !"#$$% , .,5 ! ,'$% 66 !!"' +",

• P # 7 $% +, m", *!# 5 %+%+,'!. +, EPF , S"'%"

• P&"/+ $ & +,+, , %$m+, & 6"&% 66

• A%%+ , m"&$ % 66% 7+ * ?. !+6+' +",• A, &$-"& ,+%$ '* &

W$&$ *$&$ ,# 5.%$% "6 "7$& 5#m , $m$, , 5&$ '* "6 6+ .'+ &# ",

*$ & "6 *$ +&$' "&%

YES

W*" %*".! 5$ *$! &$% ",%+5!$ ,''"., 5!$

NOT ONLY DIRECTOR ALLMANAGEMENT LE EL SHOULD BERESPONSIBLE ANDACCOUNTABLE

C".! *$ A. + 5$ '"m !$ $ %"", 7+ *".,# ?. !+6+' +",

• Y$% *$ . + &$ "& ' , 5$'! %%+6+$ % ?. !+6+$ " +,+", &$ "&

.$ " %$/$& ! .,&$%"!/$ +%%.$% I6*$ . + "& . + $ *$ &$% "6 *$

6+, ,'+ ! % $m$, % , +%&$ %", 5!# %.&$ * *$# '",6+&m

7+ * G$,$& !!# A''$ $ A''"., +,

8/12/2019 Case 1 Solution and Answers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-1-solution-and-answers 6/6

P&+'+ !$% (GAAP) *$, *$ . + "&%+m !# % $% * *$ 6+, ,'+ !% $m$, % &$ 6 +&!# &$%$, $ 7+ *

*$ $<'$ +", "6 *$ +%%.$% 7*+'*'".! ," 5$ . + $

W* %*".! 5$ ",$ " +m &"/$ *$!$ $&%*+ , m , $m$, "6 D$!+mE, $& &+%$ S , B*

SUME JAWAPAN DIATAS