Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability...

35
Capability in Complexity SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Transcript of Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability...

Page 1: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

Capability in Complexity

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Page 2: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

From Aerospace Futures to Employed

(and back again)

Nikita Sardesai & John Furness

13 July 2017

Page 3: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Overview

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 3

Who is Shoal & what we do

Model-Based Systems Engineering

Modelling, Simulation and Analysis

Systems Engineering Life Advice

Introductions and our experience

Research and Development

Page 4: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Company Overview

Page 5: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Our people

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 5

Page 6: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Aerospace Futures alums

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 6

Page 7: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Our culture

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 7

Page 8: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

What we do

Shoal is a systems engineering firm, based in Australia and USA.

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 8

Systems Engineering

Training

Research & Development

Modelling Simulation &

Analysis

Model-Based Systems

Engineering

Capability Design

Conceptual Design

Page 9: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Systems Engineering Capability

Page 10: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Holistic system view

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 10

The ideal missile design from the viewpoint of various specialists

Source: Systems Engineering Principles and Practice, Kossiakoff et al. 2011

Page 11: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Concept development focus

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 11

Our area of focus

Page 12: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Conceptual design examples at Shoal

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 12

Ground Based Air and Missile Defence

Future Submarine & Frigate

Counter Improvised-Explosive Devices

Land Combat Vehicle System

Fire and Emergency Services

Defensive cyber operations

Future joint space/cyber concepts

Page 13: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 13

Projects Viewpoint

Integrated Systems Viewpoint

Capability Viewpoint

responsible for

shapes

guides

Fire & Emergency Events

shapes

Public Perception

influences

responds to

documents

documents

Mandate

guides

Fire Departmentguides

Fire Capability

Strategic Guidance

guides

guides

Legislation / Regulation

Enterprise Strategy

influences

Operational Viewpoint

performs

responsible for

results in

basis of

Scenario

Operational Activity

decomposed by Role

Organization

achieved by

People

Assets

Information Technology

Knowledge

Governance & Accountability

connected to

Requirement

Functionality

Interface

Capability Element

specified byspecified by

guides

performs

refines

refines

refines

refines

refines

guides

guides

guides

guides

refines

guides

People Plan

Capital Asset Plan

Capital Works Plan

IT Plan

Operating Procedures

Governance Plan

Project

accomplished by

Project Activity

Project Management

Module

Business Requirements

Database

generates

enabled by

definessupplied by

develops

defines

manages manages

Enterprise Strategy

refined by

Operational Item

Measure of Effectiveness

Critical Operational

Issue

Operational Interface

transfers

inputs / outputs

refinesrefines

Operational / End-user

Need

Limitation(Constraint)

results in

constrains

Page 14: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Modelling, Simulation and Analysis

Page 15: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Range Safety Template Toolkit

• ARAAM air-to-air missile

• JASSM cruise missile

• JAXA Hyabusa spacecraft return

• HIFiRE hypersonic test flights

• DT893 space launches

• FZ-90 70mm rocket

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 15

Page 16: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Model development

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 16

Engine performance - Thrust profile

- Mass profile

Mission concept - Event sequence & timing

- Launch azimuth, elevation & altitude

Geometry & mass properties - Masses

- Center of graviities

- Moments of Inertia

Aerodynamics - Aerodynamic coefficients

Failure modes - Reliability / Failure probabilities

- Vehicle response to failure

- Breakup characteristics

Page 17: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Monte Carlo simulation

Typical computational statistics:

• 16 million simulation runs

• 80 million debris impacts

• Three calendar days for computer runs, plus post-processing

Two-stage ballistic rocket

17

Page 18: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Weapon fly-out: no failure

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 18

Page 19: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Weapon fly-out: fin failure, mid-flight

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 19

Page 20: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Weapon fly-out: fin failure, end-flight

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 20

Page 21: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Ground impact points to PDF

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 21

Kernel Density Estimation

Page 22: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Safety Products

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 22

Page 23: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Flight vehicle modelling

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 23

Weapon / Air Vehicle

Autopilot Control

Surfaces

Force

Summer

Accelerometer

Rate

Gyroscopes

Inertial

Navigation

System

MotorAirframe

Characteristics

Vertical

Launch

Seeker and

FilterHoming Law

Roll Law

Trajectory

Shaping

Fuze

Wind

Thrust Vector

Control

Umbilical

Decoder

Uplink

Decoder

Dynamics

Warhead &

Lethality

Target(s)

Fire Control SystemLaunch

Rail/Tube Observers

Aerodynamics

Page 24: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Research & Development

Page 25: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 25

Page 26: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 26

Page 27: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Design Visualisation

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 27

Page 28: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Systems Engineering Life Advice

Page 29: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Practical systems engineering

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 29

Define the problem first

Develop your solution

Take a holistic approach

Page 30: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Practical systems engineering

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 30

Define the problem first

Develop your solution

Take a holistic approach

context

requirements

interfaces

continuous V&V

Page 31: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Practical systems engineering

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 31

Define the problem first

Develop your solution

Take a holistic approach

determine project scope

verification & validation

requirements

expected system behaviour

develop system architecture to

support behaviour

Page 32: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Practical systems engineering

Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 32

Define the problem first

Develop your solution

Take a holistic approach

Page 33: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590Shoal Engineering – Aerospace Futures 2017 33

Page 34: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590

Questions and Comments

Nikita Sardesai John Furness

Page 35: Capability in Complexity · 2017. 8. 11. · Technology Knowledge Governance & Accountability connected to Requirement Functionality Interface Capability Element specified by specified

309 Angas StreetAdelaide SA 5000

Tel: +61 2 6239 4288

[email protected] www.shoalgroup.com

Adelaide Canberra New York Sydney

SHOAL-REPORT-599-2017-J590