CANADIAN CENTRE FOR ELDER LAW...CANADIAN CENTRE FOR ELDER LAW 1822 East Mall, University of British...
7
CANADIAN CENTRE FOR ELDER LAW 1822 East Mall, University of British Columbia Vancouver, British Columbia V6T 1Z1 Voice: (604) 822 0142 Fax: (604) 822 0144 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.bcli.org Revised March 8, 2017 Health Care Consent, Aging and Dementia: Mapping Law and Practice in British Columbia BACKGROUNDER Introduction The Canadian Centre for Elder Law (“CCEL”), in collaboration with the Alzheimer Society of British Co- lumbia (“The Society”), is embarking on a project which examines the law, policy and practice of consent to health care in the context of ageing and dementia. This 16-month project funded by the Law Founda- tion of British Columbia will involve extensive comparative legal research on informed consent and in- terrelated areas of the law, as well as community and key stakeholder consultation. The work will be in- formed by an expert interdisciplinary advisory committee and will culminate in a report identifying areas for law and practice reform and at least one plain language educational resource on health care consent rights. Objectives This project aims to: • Document the experiences of people with dementia, their substitute decision-makers and the people who support them, with respect to use of medication and consent in BC; • Summarize the law in BC with respect to health care consent; • Map knowledge, policy issues, and legal concerns related to the use of antipsychotics and anti - depressants for people with dementia; • Bridge a wide variety of social policy research with implications for legal practice; • Identify differing and innovative approaches taken in other jurisdictions in Canada and the United States as well as the United Kingdom and Australia vis-à-vis law and policy around health care consent, particularly with respect to older adults; • Suggest potential areas for law reform in BC; • Raise further awareness on the right to informed health care consent among British Columbians; • Produce a foundation of research that will support the key people engaged in this issue to ap- preciate the topic from a perspective that respects the rights of older adults, people with de- mentia, substitute decision-makers, family members and those who support people receiving treatment; and
Transcript of CANADIAN CENTRE FOR ELDER LAW...CANADIAN CENTRE FOR ELDER LAW 1822 East Mall, University of British...
CANADIANCENTREFORELDERLAW1822EastMall,UniversityofBritishColumbiaVancouver,BritishColumbiaV6T1Z1Voice:(604)8220142Fax:(604)8220144E-mail:[email protected]:www.bcli.org
RevisedMarch8,2017
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBritishColumbia
BACKGROUNDER
Introduction
TheCanadianCentreforElderLaw(“CCEL”),incollaborationwiththeAlzheimerSocietyofBritishCo-lumbia(“TheSociety”),isembarkingonaprojectwhichexaminesthelaw,policyandpracticeofconsenttohealthcareinthecontextofageinganddementia.This16-monthprojectfundedbytheLawFounda-tionofBritishColumbiawillinvolveextensivecomparativelegalresearchoninformedconsentandin-terrelatedareasofthelaw,aswellascommunityandkeystakeholderconsultation.Theworkwillbein-formedbyanexpertinterdisciplinaryadvisorycommitteeandwillculminateinareportidentifyingareasforlawandpracticereformandatleastoneplainlanguageeducationalresourceonhealthcareconsentrights.
Objectives
Thisprojectaimsto:
• Documenttheexperiencesofpeoplewithdementia,theirsubstitutedecision-makersandthepeoplewhosupportthem,withrespecttouseofmedicationandconsentinBC;
• SummarizethelawinBCwithrespecttohealthcareconsent;
• Mapknowledge,policyissues,andlegalconcernsrelatedtotheuseofantipsychoticsandanti-depressantsforpeoplewithdementia;
• Bridgeawidevarietyofsocialpolicyresearchwithimplicationsforlegalpractice;
• IdentifydifferingandinnovativeapproachestakeninotherjurisdictionsinCanadaandtheUnitedStatesaswellastheUnitedKingdomandAustraliavis-à-vislawandpolicyaroundhealthcareconsent,particularlywithrespecttoolderadults;
• SuggestpotentialareasforlawreforminBC;
• RaisefurtherawarenessontherighttoinformedhealthcareconsentamongBritishColumbians;
• Produceafoundationofresearchthatwillsupportthekeypeopleengagedinthisissuetoap-preciatethetopicfromaperspectivethatrespectstherightsofolderadults,peoplewithde-mentia,substitutedecision-makers,familymembersandthosewhosupportpeoplereceivingtreatment;and
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 2
• Publishatleastonepubliclegaleducationresourceforpeoplewithdementia,substitutedeci-sion-makersand/orlovedonesfocusedonhelpingpeopletounderstandtheirrights.
ProjectMethodology:
TheProjectwillinvolvethefollowingactivities:
• EstablishingadiverseprojectadvisorycommitteethatwillmeetapproximatelysixtoeighttimestoguidetheworkoftheCCELandTheSocietyasneededonthisProject;
• Interviewingarangeofexpertsonthetopicofmedication,informedconsentandolderadultswithdementia;
• Holdingaseriesoffocusgroupsprovidingpeoplelivingwithdementia,familymembersandsub-stitutedecision-makerswithanopportunitytosharetheirexperiencesinrelationtoinformedconsent,medicationandtreatmentforadultslivingwithdementia;
• UndertakingacomprehensivereviewofrelevantlegislationandjurisprudenceinBC;
• CompletingcomparativeresearchconsideringkeyjurisdictionsinCanadaandabroad,suchasOntario,theUnitedKingdomandAustralia;
• Completingaliteraturereviewonthesubjectincludingsocialscienceacademicmaterialfromjournalsandreportsaswellaspublicationsfromthelegalcommunity;
• ProducingareportthatmakesrecommendationsforlawreformforBCfollowingasummaryof:
o Theviewsandconcernsofkeyprofessionalstakeholdersonthesubjectofmedication,useofchemicalrestraintsandtreatmentofolderadultswithdementia;
o Findingsfromourinterviewswithpeoplewithdementia(whohavecapacitytoconsenttoparticipate),substitutedecision-makers,familymembersandthosewhosupportthemregardingmedication,useofchemicalrestraintsandtreatmentofolderadultswithdementia;
o Relevantlegislation;and
o Legalmodelsandlegislativeprovisionsfromotherjurisdictionsofnote;
• Reviewingexistingpubliclegaleducationresourcesontherighttoinformedconsenttohealthcareanddevelopingastraight-forwardplainlanguageresourceforBC.
RationalefortheProject
ProvincialandterritorialdatafromStatisticsCanada2011CensusshowsthatBChasoneofthelargestgrowingpopulationsofseniorsinCanada.AsourpopulationcontinuestoagemanyBritishColumbianswillbeaffectedbydementia.Althoughdifficulttoestimate,researchsuggeststhatbetween60,000and70,000BritishColumbianshavedementia1,andmanymoreareaffectedbydementiaascaregivers,sup-portingfamilymembers,friendsandlovedones.
1MedicalServiceEconomicAnalysis,HealthSystemPlanningDivision,MinistryofHealth,Dementia(age45+yearsonly)January17,2011,project2010_372.CentreforAppliedResearchinMentalHealthandAddictions,SimonFraserUniversity,2006.
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 3
Inrecentyearsanumberofstudieshaveraisedconcernsregardingpotentialovermedicationofolderadults,especiallytheuseanti-psychoticsandanti-depressantstomanagebehavioursassociatedwithdementia.Forexample,a2011MinistryofHealthreportrevealedbothsignificantuseofantipsychoticsandconcernsregardinglackofappropriateconsenttotreatmentandengagementoffamilyindevelop-ingcareplans.2Thenin2015theBCSeniorsAdvocateidentifiedtheoveruseofbothantipsychoticsandantidepressantsinresidentialcareasanareaofgreatconcern,reportingthatonly4%ofseniorsinresi-dentialcarehaveadiagnosisofapsychiatricdisorder,yet34%ofthisclientgroupareprescribedanti-psychoticmedications.3Theuseofantipsychoticsinresidentialcareisprimarilyinresponsetothein-creasingnumberofresidentswithdementia.4Accordingtothe2015BCSeniorsAdvocate’sreport,itisestimatedthatupto51%ofresidentsinBCcarefacilitiesaretakingnineormoredifferentmedications.5
Chemicalrestraintsareanyformofpsychoactivemedicationusednottotreatillness,buttointention-allyinhibitaparticularundesirablebehaviourormovement.Antipsychoticsmaybeclassifiedasachemi-calrestraintiftheirprescriptionisnotintendedforthetreatmentofschizophreniaorarelateddisorder.
Therearemanyconcernswiththeuseofchemicalrestraintsinresidentialcare,including:
• Antipsychoticmedicationsarenotintendedtotreatthesymptomsofdementiaandthereisnotrobustevidencetosupporttheiruse;6
• Seniorswhohavealargenumberofprescriptionmedicationsprescribedtothemareatanele-vatedriskofadverseevents,inpartbecausepotentialsideeffectsanddruginteractionsareof-tennotexplainedtothem7,ortheirsubstitutedecision-maker;and
• Sideeffectsofantipsychoticsrangefromunpleasanttodebilitatingandcanpotentiallyleadtomisdiagnosisofconditions,suchasParkinson’s,resultinginevenmoreincorrectlyprescribeddrugs.
Overall,despiteageneralknowledgethatallantipsychotics,whethertypicaloratypical,areassociatedwithincreasedmorbidityandmortalityinpersonswithdementiaandshouldbeusedwithcaution8,anti-psychoticscontinuetobeprescribed.
Inresponse,resourceshavebeendevelopedtosupportenhancedpractice.Inparticular,BCCareProvid-ersAssociationpublishedaBestPracticesGuideforReducingAnti-PsychoticDrugUseinResidentialCare
2BritishColumbiaMinistryofHealth,“AReviewoftheUseofAnti-psychoticDrugsinBCResidentialCare”,Decem-ber2011,online:http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/library/publications/year/2011/use-of-antipsychotic-drugs.pdf3OfficeoftheSeniorsAdvocate,“Placement,DrugsandTherapy:WeCanDoBetter”,Report#3,April2015,online:https://www.seniorsadvocatebc.ca/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2015/09/PlacementReport.pdf(“Place-ment,DrugsandTherapy”)4BritishColumbia,MinistryofHealth,BestPracticeGuidelineforAccommodatingandManagingBehaviouralandPsychologicalSymptomsofDementiainResidentialCare:APerson-CenteredInterdiscplinaryApproach(2012),online:http://www.health.gov.bc.ca/library/publications/year/2012/bpsd-guideline.pdf[BCMinistryofHealth].5SeniorsAdvocate,“Placement,DrugsandTherapy”.6HealthCanada,2005,http://healthycanadians.gc.ca/recall-alert-rappel-avis/hc-sc/2005/14307a-eng.php7Reason,B.,Terner,M.,McKeag,A.M.,Tipper,B.,&Webster,G.(2012).TheimpactofpolypharmacyonthehealthofCanadianseniors.Familypractice,29(4),427-432.8BCMinistryofHealth,supranote4.
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 4
in2013,9andtheBCMinistryofHealthpublishedBestPracticeGuidelineforAccommodatingandMan-agingBehaviouralandPsychologicalSymptomsofDementiainResidentialCarein2012.10However,thereremainsaneedtoadeveloparights-basedunderstandingofhealthcareconsenttosupplantthedominanthealthcareorientation.Thereisalsoaneedtodevelopresourcestoassisthealthcaredeci-sion-makers,healthcarestaff,olderadultsandtheirlovedonestounderstandthescopeoftherighttoinformedconsent.
Theuseofprescriptionofmedicationtomanagesymptomsofdementiaraiseslegalissuesrelatedtohealthlaw,substitutedecision-makinglegislation,workplacesafetyandhumanrights.Decisionsregard-ingmedicationhaveasignificantimpactonqualityoflifeandlifeexpectancy,andolderpeopleandsub-stitutedecision-makersoftendonotappreciatetherighttoaskquestions,explorealternativesandpro-videconsent.Olderpeoplelivingwithdementiaareavulnerable,growingsubsetofBC’spopulation;however,ultimatelytheissueofconsenttohealthtreatmentmatterstoeveryone,andtheresearchofthisprojectwillsupportarobustunderstandingoftherighttoinformedconsentinBCwhichwillbenefitanyonereceivingtreatmentorconsentingtotreatmentonbehalfofanother.Inparticular,projectfind-ingswillbeofbenefittopeoplelivingwithdisabilitiesotherthandementia,aspeopleinothercommu-nities,suchasthecommunitylivingsector,sufferfromexclusionfromhealthcaredecision-makingduetoassumptionsaroundmentalcapacityandlackofrespectfortherighttoinformedconsent.
LegalBackground
HealthCareConsentLaw
InBritishColumbia,thelawofhealthcareconsentforadultsisgovernedprimarilybytheHealthCare(Consent)andCareFacility(Admission)Act(“HCCA”).11PursuanttothisAct,everyadultispresumedca-pableofgiving,refusingandrevokingconsenttohealthcare12andahealthcareprovidercannotprovidehealthcarewithoutfirstobtainingtheadult’sconsent.13Healthcareisdefinedas“anythingthatisdoneforatherapeutic,preventive,palliative,diagnostic,cosmeticorotherpurposerelatedtohealth…”.14Thelegislationsetsouttheelementsandscopeofconsent15andthethreelimitedexceptionstotherequire-menttoobtaintheconsentoftheadult:incapacity16,emergency17andpreliminaryexamination.18Im-portantly,thelegislationalsosetsoutindescendingorderofhierarchywhomayactasatemporarysub-stitutedecision-makerincasesofincapacity.TheActissaidtobeacodificationofthecommon-lawdoc-trineof“informedconsent”.
9BCCareProvidersAssociation,BestPracticesGuideforReducingAnti-PsychoticDrugUseinResidentialCare:En-suringResidentialCareHomesareSafePlacestoLiveandWork(2013),online:http://www.bccare.ca/wp-con-tent/uploads/Anti-Psychotics-Guide-hr-06-05-13.pdf.10BCMinistryofHealth,supranote4.11R.S.B.C.1996,c.181(“HCCA”).12HCCA,s.3.SeealsoRepresentationAgreementAct,s.3.13HCCA,s.5.14HCCA,s.1.15HCCA,ss.6-9.16Ifpatientfoundincapable,mayobtainconsentfromSDM:s.11(personalguardianorrepresentative)ands16(TSDM)HCCA.17Urgentoremergencyhealthcare:“inordertopreservetheadult'slife,topreventseriousphysicalormentalharmortoalleviateseverepain”,s.12HCCA.18To“undertaketriageoranotherkindofpreliminaryexamination,treatmentordiagnosis”,s.13HCCA.
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 5
TheResidentialCareRegulationdealswithconsentinthecontextoftheuseofchemicalrestraints.19OnlyafewCanadianprovinceshaveenactedhealthcareconsentlegislation,theremainderpreferringtorelyonthecommonlawdoctrine.20
AfullexaminationofhealthcareconsentlawsinBritishColumbiarequiresareview,notonlyofthecommonlawdoctrineofinformedconsentandstatutoryconsentlaws,butofthebroaderlegalframe-work.Thisprojectendeavourstocontextualizeconsentlawswithinthisbroaderlegalframeworkbyalsoconsideringthefollowinginterrelatedareasoflaw:
CapacityandSubstituteDecision-Making
Whereadultsarefoundincapable,healthcareprovidersmustobtainconsentforhealthcaredecisionsfromtheirsubstitutedecision-makersormakedecisionsinaccordancewithanyadvancedirective.Ad-vancedirectivesprovidelegallybindinginstructionstohealthcareprovidersregardingwhichhealthcareapersonconsentstointhefutureshouldtheybecomeincapableandtheyaregovernedbytheHCCA.Substitutedecision-makersmaybe:
o RepresentativesundertheRepresentationAgreementsAct
o Temporarysubstitutedecision-makersundertheHealthCare(Consent)andCareFacility(Admission)Act
o CommitteesofthepersonunderthePatientsPropertyAct
MentalHealthandInvoluntaryCommittalLaws
InBritishColumbia,apatientinneedofpsychiatriccarecanbeinvoluntarilycommittedtoadesignatedpsychiatricfacilityandtreatedwithouttheirconsent:pursuanttos.31(1)oftheMentalHealthAct,treatmentofaninvoluntarypatientwhichisauthorizedbythedirectorofthefacilityis"deemedtobegivenwiththeconsentofthepatient".21Thisprovisioneffectivelyenablesadultswithdementiatobeadmittedtoresidentialcarefacilitiesandtobeprescribedantipsychoticmedicationswithoutthecon-sentoftheadultortheirsubstitutedecision-maker.This“deemedconsent”provisionisatoddswithleg-islationinotherprovinces,suchasOntario,wherebyconsentmustbegivenbytheadult,orbytheadult’ssubstitutedecision-maker.22TheabilitytousechemicalrestraintsunderOntarioisverylimited.The“deemedconsent”andrelatedprovisionsarecurrentlysubjecttoaCharterchallengeintheSu-premeCourtofBC.23
HealthCareRegulationandProfessionalResponsibility
Inadditiontoprovincialhealthcareconsentlaws,regulatedhealthcareprofessionsarerequiredtocomplywiththeirgoverningbodies’codesandstandards,andareguidedbyinternalguidelinespro-ducedbythem.Somesuchgoverningbodieshavestandardsand/orguidelinesspecificallyaddressing
19ResidentialCareRegulation,ss.73-75.20Ontario,BritishColumbia,NewBrunswick,PrinceEdwardIslandandYukonhavehealthcareconsentstatutes.21MentalHealthAct,R.S.B.C1996,c.288,s.31(1).22HealthCareConsentAct,SO1996,c2;SeealsoVerdun-Jones,S.&Lawrence,M.“TheCharterRighttoRefusePsychiatricTreatment:AComparativeAnalysisoftheLawsofOntarioandBritishColumbiaConcerningtheRightofMental-HealthPatientstoRefusePsychiatricTreatment”(2013)46UBCLRev489–527.23MaryLouiseMacLaren,D.C.&CouncilofCanadianswithDisabilitiesv.AttorneyGeneralofBC,SupremeCourtofBritishColumbia;Seealso<http://www.clasbc.net/charter_challenge_forced_psychiatric_treatment>
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 6
consenttohealthcare,suchastheCollegeofCollegeofRegisteredNursesofBritishColumbia.Others,suchastheCollegeofPhysiciansandSurgeonsofBC,donot.
InternationalandDomesticHumanRightsandDiscriminationLaw
CanadaisasignatorytotheInternationalConventionontheRightsofPersonswithDisabilities,whichbroadlyspeakingpromotesindividualautonomy,thefreedomtomakeone’sownchoices,fullparticipa-tion,equalityandnon-discrimination,andinparticular,underarticle12,enshrinestherightofpeoplewithdisabilitiestoparticipateindecisionsabouttheirownlives.24Further,BritishColumbianhumanrightslawprohibitsdiscriminationonthebasisofage,disabilityandgender,amongstothergrounds.25Inthecontextofavulnerablepopulationofolderadultslivingwithdementia,theinterplayofdisability,discriminationlawandhealthcarelawisevident.Consequently,applyingahumanrightslenstoare-viewofhealthcareconsentlawasitaffectsolderadultsmayprovideanimportantperspectiveonthisissueandhelpilluminateareaswherepeoplelivingwithdementiaaretreateddifferentlyfrompeoplelivingwithotherformsofdisabilityorotherhealthconditions.
WorkplaceSafetyLawsandStaffingRegulations
Employershaveastatutoryobligationunderoccupationalhealthandsafetylawstoensurethesafetyofallemployees.26Employershaveanobligationtoundertakeaviolenceriskassessment27andarerespon-sibleforeducatingandtrainingworkersinviolencepreventionstrategiesandinformingworkersofwhattheyneedtodoifaresidentbecomesviolent.28Inaddition,theResidentialCareRegulationsetsmini-mumstandardsforstaffingcoverageandtraining—whichmustbeappropriatetomeettheneedsofpersonsincare—aswellasrequiresdesignatedprogrammingforthephysical,socialandrecreationalactivitiesforpersonsincare.29Therelationshipbetweenstaffsafety,staffingcoverageandtrainingishighlyrelevantinthecontextofevidencewhichsuggeststhatbestpracticefortreatmentofbehaviouralsymptomsofdementiais“comprehensive,individualizedassessmentinordertoprovideperson-centredcare,withfamilyandprofessionalcaregivereducationandsupport”.30
ProjectCommitteeMembers
AswithmanyCCELprojects,anadvisorycommitteewillprovideongoingprojectguidanceregardingre-searchandconsultationmethodology,keystakeholdersandrecommendationstoflowfromresearch.Theadvisorycommitteemembersare:
TaraFitzgerald,QualityLeader,SeniorsCare,BCPatientSafety&QualityCouncil
24ConventionontheRightsofPersonswithDisabilities,Arts.3and12.25HumanRightsCode,R.S.B.C1996,c.210.26WorkersCompensationAct,R.S.B.C1996,c.492,s.11527OccupationalHealthandSafetyRegulation,B.C.Reg.296/97,s.4.27tos.4.31.28WorkSafeBC,“Dementia:UnderstandingRisksandPreventingViolence”,online:<https://www.worksafebc.com/en/resources/health-safety/books-guides/dementia-understanding-risks-and-preventing-violence?lang=en>29ResidentialCareRegulation,ss.45&55.30Alzheimer’sAustralia,“TheUseofRestraintsandPsychotropicMedicationsinPeopleWithDementia”,PaperNo38,March2014,online:<https://www.fightdementia.org.au/files/NATIONAL/documents/Alzheimers-Australia-Numbered-Publication-38.pdf>,p.8.
HealthCareConsent,AgingandDementia:MappingLawandPracticeinBC,ProjectBackgrounder 7
IsabelGrant,Professor,PeterAllardSchoolofLaw,UniversityofBritishColumbia
LauraJohnston,Lawyer,CommunityLegalAssistanceSociety
MichaelKary,DirectorofPolicyandResearch,BCCareProvidersAssociation
AlisonLeaney,ProvincialCoordinator,VulnerableAdultsCommunityResponse,PublicGuardianandTrustee
MarthaJaneLewis,ExecutiveDirector,BCCentreforElderAdvocacyandSupport
BarbaraLindsay,Director,Advocacy&Education,AlzheimerSocietyofBC
IsobelMackenzie,BCSeniorsAdvocate
JimMann,Personlivingwithdementia
Dr.DeborahO’Connor,Professor,SchoolofSocialWork,andCo-director,CentreforResearchonPer-sonhoodandDementia,UniversityofBritishColumbia
LisaA.Peters,Partner,LawsonLundellLLPandChair,BCLawInstitute
MichaelVonn,PolicyDirector,BCCivilLibertiesAssociation
PennyA.Washington,Partner,DisputeResolution&Litigation,BullHousser
AbouttheCCEL
TheCCELcarriesoutscholarlyresearch,writing,analysisandcommunityengagementrelatingtolegalandpolicyissuesthatimpactolderadults.AspartofitsworktheCCELconsultswithstakeholders,col-laborateswithnumerouscommunityagenciesandpublisheslegal,policyandpracticeresourcesinclud-ingrecommendationsforlawreformandpublicinformationmaterials.TheCCELisadivisionoftheBrit-ishColumbiaLawInstitute,BC’snon-profitindependentlawreformagency.
Contacts
KristaJamesExecutiveDirectorCanadianCentreforElderLawkjames@bcli.orgBarbaraLindsayDirector,Advocacy&EducationAlzheimer’[email protected]
