Brock v. Carrion
of 36
Transcript of Brock v. Carrion
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
1/36
Dfn
ff
f9f
-@ff
-I9-
fnffff
fffffnfn
ffff
ffffn%fff
ffffff
fff
f9fnffnf
@nf
f
%n
nn
fffffn
%ff
#ffn
f
f
%fff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
2/36
ffff
fffn
9ffff
ff
ff
ff
OJff
O%,Jff
9f
O%ffn
f
nf
n
,f
ffnn
n
nffff
fffff
ffnff
fffff
fffffff
n%D%
%f
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
3/36
ff
ff
OJff
O%,Jff
9f
O%n
fff
n
f
,f
ffnf
nnnnf
f#ff
nff
fff
ffffff
fffffff
n%D%
ff%
ff
OJff
O%,Jff
9f
O%n
fff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
4/36
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
n
fff
%9f
@Jf,f
Dfffffff
fffnffff
fff
ffnf
ffff
fffn
ff
ffffnfffff
ffnffnf
fff
&@ffn@
ffnf9f
Jffnn
f
,,-D,-
,n
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
5/36
9ffn%#n
fnffff%#f
f,nfff%nn
#fnffff
ffn%Dff
fffff
9fnnf
ffff
ffff
ffffffff
ffn
@fnnn
ffnfff
f-f&
ffff
nffnffff
fff
fffnf
fffff
-nfff
ffffnn
ff
nf%
fnf
ffnf-@f
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
6/36
ffnn-
@DD--
-Dfnn
f
fffffff
f$fffffn
-ff%9
Dnfn
%#D-
ffff
ffffffff
ffnnfIf
f%#If%-
9D,fffn
%#D,-f
f
ffffn%#fff
fff-
n-%D,
-f
fnn
nfnffff
%D,-
ffff
nfnf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
7/36
%D-D,-D
f,ff
%#f
fff
fffffff
ffff
fff%D,-nnf
f#@
fff
ffffnnf
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
nn%D,-f
fffffn
%D,-@
nnffffff
nfff
ff%D,-
9fffnf
fffffffn
%fn99
,9ff
D,-@f
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
8/36
ffff
fffIffn
fff#
9f
fffnfnf
fff#f
%
D-nf
ffffffn
f
ffff
nff%
,99
,nf%#
Df
fffffn
#fnfnn
fnfnn
ffnn
nfff&ffn
nff
nffffff
%D,-ff
fnffn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
9/36
nf
nnfnfffff
f%D,-nnfff
fnn
fffnff
%D,-
9fnfnf
nffffff
ffffn
%D,-fnf
ffnf
fff
fff%D,-
fff#
fffnnfnf
nfffn
nfff
ff%D,-f
f#fnn
$fffff
%D,-f
fnfffn
fnffn
ffff%D,-
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
10/36
ffn
ffnf
fnfnff
f%D,-
D,-
@-
ffnfffnf
ffnf
9%f%#fn
fnffff
fffff
ff,ff
%f@ff
ffffnf
ffffff
9%f%n,f
@nn
%f@ffnfff
fff
fffffn
ffffff
9%nn
D
%
Jfn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
11/36
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
fnn
fnnfn
fnff
nn
@%@
nffnn
fffD
fnD
%
@f#ffff
nn
ff
fff
ffff
fnf
fnffffn
fD
%
ff
ffff
fffffnfnf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
12/36
,ffn
fD
%&-f
fD
%
fnff#nf
ffnnff
ffff
nD
%
nff
fnfnf
nnn@Jn
n9fnnnfn
%%n,ff
nf
D
%@nf
f9%n
nfffff
nffn
fffff
fn-ffff
%@9n@
%
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
13/36
-
@nnffnf
ffff
fffff
fIffffff
fnffff
fnffnfn
ffffff
fff
fn#ffn
ff
fnD%
%@ffff
nfffff
ff%f
fnffffn
fffffff
fnfff
nfff
fffff
ffff%f
ffffn
nfffnffn
n
9fnfff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
14/36
ffffnnf
fffff
fn
ffff
ff
fn
%f%%fff
ffffJf
-%#Jf-fff
fnnf
nffffnf
nf
nffff
fffffff
Jf-
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
fJffJ
9nf
%
ff
D#Jfff
nffn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
15/36
nf
fnD%@n
fnff
ffnff
n%ff#n
fff-&f-
fn%
@ff
#ffnf#ffnfn
ffn
%f%Jfnf
nnfff
ffffffn
%n#ffnnf
fff
%
-Dff
ffnf
fn@
fnffn
%#nf
fff%fnn
ff
%f
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
16/36
ff
%
fff
fff#
nf
fffff
fffnn
ff
fnffffnn
%9,9ff
%#9
fD,-
,ff
n
nffnnn
ff,
9n
%ff%
fff
f
f
fnf
%9fnf
nffff
nnff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
17/36
f
fn
fffnf
ff
fnf
ffnf#fff
ffnff
ffff@f
fnfff
fffnnfff
fffnfff
ff ffff
nffnfn@f
ffnff
ffffff
fnfnffnn
fff
fnnnfff
fnfnnn
fffnf
ffn
@fnnfff
fnff
nfJfnf
%-
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
18/36
ff%@
nff
nnfn
n
fffn
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
f#fn
ff
fnffffn
ffnfnnf
fn%f@nfn
nff$ffn
,
fnf%
fnfnfff
fn
nfffnff
fffnf
ffn
f
%f
fn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
19/36
fIffn
n%@
f&nn
nnf
fnfnffn
ff-f
f
fnfn
f
fnffn
-ff#
fffn
ffn
nf
ffffn
Jfff
ffn
f
fffn
Jfnf
%,ffJ
%ffff
@ffnn
-%
nfff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
20/36
#nfff
ffnfnf
f,n#nnf
fnfnf
f%fnfn
f@ffn
fff
%nfnn
@nf
@nnnf
nff
nn
nfn
ffnfff
nfff
%n%fff
nf#f9fnf
ffn
fnfn
fn%
f@fff
n%n
nn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
21/36
f%nn
f%n
fffnffnf
f%n@f
nffffnf
ffff
ffff
ffffff
nf@nf@
fnfff
ffnff%D,-
@nf
nfffn
n
fff
nffnfnfn
fnnnfn
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
nfnf%D,-
ff
ffnnff
fnfnf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
22/36
fIf%D,-f
fnnffnnf
-&%
D,-fnff
nnff
nn%#fff
f%
@
nf%f
ffff
ffnfnf
nn%ff
nffff@
nff#fff
fnfnnf
nnf-f
ffff
fnfnfff
@fffffff
ffff
nfffff
ffff
-fff
nf%
9,-
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
23/36
ff
fn
fffn
ffnnf
ff
fnfn
Jfnfnn
nn,ff@f
fnJfnf
f@fn
ffnfnn
fnfffnf
fnnfnf
fffffnn
,ff@f
%
fffff
fffnnfnf
ffnff
nffff
nffn
nfnff
fnfnffffn
fffnn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
24/36
,ffnfff
nnf#nf
fffnn
ffff
ffn
@fffnf
ffnnfff
f
nfnn
fnfffn
nffffff
fnfnfffnff
ff
fffnfnf
ffnfnfn
nff
fnfnfff
nnnfn
fff
f
nfff
fff
#ffn
%D,-ffff
fnfnff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
25/36
fnfnffnfn
nfffff
@fff
fffnf
fffffnf
f
ff
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
ff
fff&nf
ffnf
f%fffn
f%Jf-
fffn
fJf-
fffn
f
-fff
ffnff
Jffnnf
nffff
ffffff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
26/36
ffff
ffffn
ff
ffff
ff%f@
nffnff
ffffff
ffff%f
fff%n
fff
ff
Jf-ff
Jfn
ff
,ffnff
fff
ff
Jnf
fff
fnf
f%$f
fffff
f
%n,fn
fff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
27/36
%nffff
f
%%fJf-
fnfn
ffff
ffn%
fnnffnf
nff
fJf-ff
fnnnn
#ffnffJf
fnnf
nfff
fff%ffnn
fff
@nffn
fJf-
nnf
fffn
fnnff
nfff
nfnffnf
f#nff
ff
ff%ffJf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
28/36
-nfnnfn
nffn
fff@
nf
nffffJf
-ff
nfn
fn
ffff
n#nn
fffff
nfnf
nff&ff
ffffJf-
nf
fnff
nJf-
ffnfnn
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
nffffn
fnf
9fnfff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
29/36
fnfff#nff
ffnnf
fffffn
ffnffff
ffff
fnfff
fffffnff
ff
fnfffnf
fnff
fn
Jf-
fnnfnn
fnfnff
#nfn
ffffff
n%#ffnnf
nfffffn
9nff,ff
ffnf
fff@
,ffnf
#ffffff
fff
ffffnff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
30/36
ffDf
n9nff
,fff$$
nf$$,ff$nff
@fJff,ff
ff#n
nff
ffffff
ffffnf
ffnfnf
Jff,ffff
%n%
ffff
nfn
ffnf
nfff
9nn%#9@f
,ffnfff
f9%
@fffnn
fnfff
ffnff
ffnnfn9n
ffff
f9fn
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
31/36
ffnf
nnfffnn
nfnf,
f9fnf
f9%
%#fnffnn
ffnfff
ff
nf
ff
f%%#
nnf
fnfn
fnnff
ffn
fnn
,fffnn
fnnf
fffff
&Dff
ffnf
fffffnnf
ffffff
ffnnfnf
n#nff
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
32/36
fffffff@
nnfnf
ffffn
ffnff
fffnff#ffn
#%nn
@f9,
nff
ffnf
9f
%f
'f-fDJ
fnfffff
If%D,-@
fffnfffnf
fffff
fff
fnnn
Jf--
-9fnfIf
ff
fffffff
nf
%D9
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
33/36
fD,%#
D,-,
fffff
fff
nffnfn%
D,-
fnffff
fnnf
n
nfnfJf
-%ffnf
fnfnf
f
nfnff
fff
%9
f
nfJf-fn
f
9fffffJf
-ffnff
fffnff
ffnnff
#fffnf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
34/36
Jf-%f@
fffnfnf
fnnf
n
fnf
Jf-f
f
nfnf
ff
,fnfffff
fffff
%f
%%
nffn
nffff
Jf-nn
nfnnfnfff
n%n
f%
f
,fffff
ffff#f
ff
ffff
#nnfnnf
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
35/36
ffff
-Dfn
9nff,fff
fnnf
fJf&-
#fffn
fff%
f%ff@f
nf
nff
nfff%D,-
@fnfffff
ffff
%Jf--
-ffnf
fffn
fffnf
f@ff
f
f%
-%fff
ffnff
nf
%f
9f
-
8/3/2019 Brock v. Carrion
36/36
%f
'f-fDJ
%
nfffJf-
nfff
fffffnf
nffn
fffff
-D-
ff
ffnfff
f$n-@f
ffnff
ffnn-
@
f
nf
-D,-@
9f
