Brazil unbound: How investors see Brazil and Brazil sees the world
-
Upload
the-economist-group -
Category
Business
-
view
2.518 -
download
4
Transcript of Brazil unbound: How investors see Brazil and Brazil sees the world
Brazil����������unboundHow investors see Brazil and Brazil sees the world
inco-operationwith
2
3
Contents
Foreword� 4
Executive�Summary� 5
Introduction� 6
Part�one:��Cornerstones�of�success� 9
Part�two:�Social�and�intellectual�capital� 15� I.Talentandeducation 15 II.Innovationinthinkingandaction 19 III.Braziliansabroad 22
Conclusion:�The�beginning�of�the�future�� 26
About�this�report
Brazil unbound: How investors see Brazil and Brazil sees the worldisanHSBCreportproducedinco-operationwiththeEconomistIntelligenceUnit.Thereportdrawsonin-depthinterviewswithcountryexpertsandanalysts,EconomistIntelligenceUnitforecasts,andasurveyofexecutivesin536companiesacross18industries,duringApril-May2010.AroundonethirdofsurveyrespondentswerebasedinBrazilandafurther11%inLatinAmerica;20%werebasedinAsia-Pacific,15%inNorthAmerica,and12%inWesternEurope.
Overtwo-fifths(41%)ofcompanieshadannualglobalrevenuesof$500morless,and22%hadannualrevenuesabove$10bn.Intermsofseniority,58%ofrespondentswereC-suiteorboardmembers.
4
Foreword
Brazil’s economic resilience over recent years has captured the world’s attention. All eyes have been on its growth, as it distanced itself from the political and economic uncertainty of the 1980s.
Withgrowthsettocontinue,ithasbeenforecastthatby2025Brazilwillbecometheworld’sfifthlargesteconomy,overtakingBritainandFrance,whileSãoPaulowillrankhigherthanParisandShanghaiastheworld’ssixthwealthiestcity.
In2010,HSBCcelebratesthevibrancyandexcitementofmodernBrazilwithaseriesofinternationaleventsandactivitiesacrosstenmarketsfromtheUKandBraziltoNorthAmerica,SouthAfrica,theMiddleEastandChina.ThisprogrammeofactivityiscentredaroundoursponsorshipofFestivalBrazil,afour-monthsummercelebrationofthecountry’sculturalofferingsatLondon’sSouthbankCentre.
Workingin88countries,weseetheunderstandingofdifferentculturesasanessentialpartofbuildinginternationalrelationshipsandbusinessexpertise.AspartofourglobalCulturalExchangeprogramme,FestivalBrazilprovidesinsightintooneoftheworld’smostprominenteconomies.
Bringingtogethertheviewsandopinionsoftheglobalbusinesscommunity,thisEconomistIntelligenceUnitreportidentifiesandexploresthechallengesthatnowfacethisdynamiccountry.Ihopethat,whetheryouarealreadyexperiencedinworkingwithBrazilorarejuststartingtoexploreitsopportunities,thisreportwillprovevaluabletoyourbusiness.
Zarir�J�Cama�GroupManager,GroupManagementOffice,HSBCHoldingsplc
5
Executivesummary
Brazilhasneverbeensopopularamonginvestorsasitisnow.Interesthasrisensteadilyoverthepast15yearsasthecountryhasmanagedtoovercomeonepolitical,macroeconomicandbusinesschallengeafteranother.Privatisation,liberalisation,anewstablecurrency,thesmoothhandoverofpoliticalpower,tonamebutafewachievements,coupledwithaboominglobaldemandforBrazil’scopioussuppliesofcommodities,haveboostedforeigncurrencyearningsandfiredupconsumerspending.Brazilhasbeentransformedfrom“countryoftomorrow”to“once-in-a-lifetimeopportunity”.Thetransitionis,ofcourse,farfromover:education,bureaucracy,corruption,infrastructureandfractiouspolitics,tolistjustafewdeep-seatedproblems,willtakeyearstoaddress.Butitsnew-foundeconomicandpoliticalstability–whichhelpedtheeconomywithstandrecentglobalfinancialshocks–allowspolicymakerstomakeaseriousstartonaddressingtheseissues.Moreover,thecountry’snaturalrichesinagricultureandmining–andpotentiallyoffshoreoiltoo–will,ifusedwisely,providethecashneededforvitalinvestmentsforyearstocome.
Thisreport,basedoninterviewsandasurveyof536seniorexecutivesworldwide,largelyendorsesthegeneraloptimismaboutBrazil’sprospects.PartoneofthereportsetsBrazil’srecenttransitionintoitspolitical,macroeconomicandindustrycontext.Parttwofocusesonthreeessentialareasofthebusinessoperatingenvironment:themarketfortalent;thestateofinnovation;andthedilemmasfacingBraziliancompaniesastheyexpandabroad.SomeofthekeyconclusionsofthisreportandthemainchallengesfacingBrazilincludethefollowing:
Poor�infrastructure�takes�a�heavy�toll�on�business.
Althoughsomethingofatruism,theparlousstateoftheinfrastructuretopsthelistofobstaclesfacedbyinvestorsinBrazil.Inoursurvey,nearlyonehalfofrespondents(49%)pointto“lowstandardorcostlyinfrastructure”asthemainoperatingobstacle.Inspiteofsomeimprovementinlogistics,freightdependsoncostlyroadhaulage;therearefewrailroads;thepotentialforwaterwaysremainslargelyunexplored;andportsandairportsarecongested.Theseconditionscanaddonequarterormoretothecostofgettinggoodstomarket,sayinvestors.Logisticsexpertscallforbetterco-ordinationbetweendifferentlayersofgovernmentandtheprivatesector.
Weaknesses�in�the�education�system�impair�the�supply�of��
relevant�workplace�skills.�
WhilemanyofthegraduatesofBrazil’suniversitiesareviewedastopclass,therearetoofewofthem.Poorteachingandresourcinginsecondaryeducationmeansthatschoolleaversareamongtheworld’sleasteducated.Companiesfindtheymustfilltheskillsgapsthemselveswiththeirowntraining.Atleastonethirdofinvestorssurveyedsayskillsshortagesrepresentoneofthebiggestoperatingproblems,withalmostonehalf(47%)ofUS-basedcompaniesreportingthisastheirgreatestchallenge.Educationalistscallforamorerelevantcurriculum,betterteachertraining,andashiftinstatefundingfromtertiarytosecondaryeducation.
Investors�praise�the�abilities�of�their�Brazilian�managers.
EducationstandardsmaybehigherinmostpartsofAsia,but,sayinvestors,thequalityofmanagementis“probablyworseinChinaandIndia”.Indeed,Brazilianmanagersaredeemedtobeonaparwiththeirpeersindevelopedmarkets,andsuperiortothosefromotheremergingmarkets,accordingto42%ofsurveyrespondents.Inparticular,investorslaudtheflexibilityandmaturityoftheirBrazilianstaff,afacetthatmayderivefromlearningtocopewitheconomicupheaval.However,thisflexibilitydoesnottranslateadequatelyintoinnovation.
Brazil�lags�in�innovation;�investors�could�help�more.�
Brazilscorespoorlyonmostinnovationrankings,anddeeperanalysissuggeststhateventhemeagreinvestmentsintoinnovationcould
producebetterresults.Some57%ofsurveyedexecutivesdonothaveadedicatedR&Dfacility,orevenplantohaveoneintheshortterminBrazil.Overonehalfofrespondents(51%)saythat,atpresent,lessthan10%ofproductsandservicessoldbytheircompanieshaveactuallybeendevelopedthere,andatleastonequarterofrespondentsexpectnoprogressonthatscoreoverthenextthreeyears.Yetalmosthalf(49%)ofsurveyrespondentsdescribethecapacityofBrazilian-basedbusinessestointegratethelatestinternationaltechnologyintotheiroperationsaseither“verygood”or“excellent”,andonly6%sayitis“poor”.Thisindicatesthatbettereducation,improvedinfrastructure,greaterinvestmentinR&Dandcloserrelationsbetweencompaniesanduniversitieswouldhaveadisproportionatelypositiveimpactoninnovation.Thatsaid,businesshasbrokennewgroundinenvironmentalandagriculturaltechnologies,whicharebeingexportedworldwide.
Co-operation�with�universities�works�well.�
Onewaytopromoteinnovationisthroughbusinessco-operationwithacademicinstitutions.Experienceseemsrelativelylimited,butpositive.OfsurveyrespondentswhoseBrazil-basedoperationsalreadyworkwithlocaluniversities,60%saytherelationshiphasbeen“positive”and12%“verypositive”,comparedwithlessthanonequarter(23%)whosaythatsuchco-operation“failedtoliveuptoexpectations”orwas“veryunsuccessful”(5%).Brazilian-basedcompanieswouldappeartogettheroughendofsuchdeals(orperhapsaretoooptimisticabouttheirpotential),asalmostonethird(32%)reportthatsuchco-operation“failedtoliveuptoexpectations”.
Brazil�focuses�on�“South-South”�trade�relations,�especially��
with�China.�
Aspartofageneralpolicyoftradediversification,oneofthebiggestchangesinBraziliantradepolicyunderPresidentLulahasbeentheexpansionoftradeandinvestmentwithChina.ChinahasbecomeBrazil’slargestexportandimportpartner,andprovidesinvestmentandfinancetosecuresuppliesofkeyminerals.BrazilhasalsoexpandeditsshareoftradewiththerestofLatinAmerica,otherAsiancountries,theMiddleEastandAfrica,especiallyinagriculture.
Brazilian�firms�still�suffer�from�poor�brand�recognition�abroad.�
Beyondthecharmedcircleofafewhigh-profilecompanies,BrazilianbrandsstilllacktheglobaldrawoftheirWesterncounterparts.Thisisreflectedinoursurvey,inwhich84%ofrespondentssaythatBrazilianbrandnamesarenotwellrecognisedornothighlyregardedabroad.Only3%ofUS-basedrespondentsbelievethatBrazilianbrandsarebothrecognisedandhighlyregarded.However,theperceptionofBrazilianbrandschangessomewhatamongChina-basedexecutives,withalmostonequarterofthoserespondents(24%)givingawarmreceptiontoBrazilianproducts.
6
Introduction
Brazilisinfashion.HostingthefootballWorldCupin2014andtheSummerOlympicsin2016wouldseemafittingcaptothemomentouseconomicchangeswitnessedovertheprevioustwodecades.Whilesuchmegaeventscanstrainacountry’sbudgetandtestitsinfrastructure,sendinglesserhostsintoaspiralofdebt,Brazil’sleaderswillseeitasglobalrecognitionofthecountry’simportanceintheworld;apowerfulsignalthatBrazil’sdomesticconcernsmatterbeyonditsborders;thatitscompaniesareaforcetoreckonwithabroad;andthatitstalentsaretheenvyoftheworld.
Suchsentiments,ifnotnew,arecertainlymorerealistictodaythanatanypointinthecountry’srecenthistory.Onceknownforitsseverestop-goeconomiccycles,thememoryofhyperinflationinthelate1980sandthe2002IMFbail-outisrecedingfast.Investorqueasinessovertheelectionin2002oftheleft-wingPresidentLuizInácioLuladaSilva(“Lula”),whosetwotermsendthisyear,hasprovenmisplaced.Brazil’seconomyrodetheglobalfinancialcrisis,sufferingonlyabriefandshallowdip.Theeconomyispoisedtoexpandbynearly8%thisyear.Andtoday’spolicymakersangstlessaboutfinancialturmoilandmoreaboutwhoandhowtoaccessnewlydiscovereddeepwateroilreserves,developingaforeignpolicydoctrinethatreflectsglobalambitions,andturningdomesticenterprisesintoworldbeaters.
Forinvestors,Brazil’sglassisnow“halffull”.With192millionconsumers,itisLatinAmerica’slargestmarket,theworld’sfifth-mostpopulouscountryandtheeighth-largesteconomy.WhenaskedaboutBrazil’simageinthe
world,respondentstotheEconomistIntelligenceUnit’ssurveyprefertopointtothe“B”inBRICs(theoddballcategoryoffast-growingemerginggiantscomprisingBrazil,Russia,IndiaandChina)ratherthantothecountry’slong-standingstructuraldeficiencies.MoreexecutivesseeBrazilprimarilyas“ayoung,fast-growingmarketopportunityonaparwithChina,IndiaorRussia”(49%)–althoughChinesecompanieswerefarlessfavourablydisposedtosuchacomparison–andas“anemergingplayerontheinternationalstage”(40%),thanas“amarketwithhighpotentialbutheldbackitspoorbusinessenvironment”(31%)oreven“asupplierofkeycommodities”(20%).Despitethefactthatincomedistributionremainsamongthemostskewedintheworld–recentimprovementsaside–socialinequalitiesandtraditionalstereotypeslinkedtocultureandsportwerecitedrespectivelybyonly13%and9%ofrespondents.
Overall,�what�do�you�consider�to�be�the�main�image�today�of�Brazil�in�the�world?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
A young, fast-growing market opportunity on a par with China, India or Russia.
An emerging player on the international stage.
A market with high potential but held back its poor business environment.
A supplier of key commodities to the world.
Principally known for extremes of wealth and poverty.
Retains its stereotypical image associated with culture and sport.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
49%
40%
31%
20%
13%
9%
7
Insomerespects,thisnewprominenceshouldcomeasnosurprise.AlongwithSouthAfricaandIndia,BrazilhasbeenaleadinglightintheG20(groupof20leadingeconomies).Duringtheglobaleconomiccrisis,theG20supersededtheG8asthemainplatformforglobalgovernance,accordinglargedevelopingnationssuchasBrazilagreatervoiceatatimewhenthesettingofglobalrulesisdominatingheadlines.Andithasn’tescapedinvestorsthatemergingmarketshavegenerallycomethroughthefinancialcrisisinbettershapethanhavedevelopedmarkets.ThereisalsoplentyofcommercialsubstancebehindBrazil’snewpopularityamonginvestors.Theconsolidationofmacroeconomicstabilityinthepastdecadehasmeantthatthecountry’slargeinternalmarketpotentialisfinallybeingrealised.Brazil’syoungandsizeablepopulationanditsburgeoningmiddleclassarebothbyfarthemostattractivefeaturesofthecountry,accordingto58%ofexecutivessurveyed.Bycontrast,suchfactorsasitsabundantnaturalresources,politicalstabilityandcheaplabourforce–oftenfeaturesofprimarilyexport-driveneconomies–werefarlessregarded.
Judgedbyitshistory,therefore,Brazilhasdonewell;judgedbytoday’scompetition,however,thecountrystillhasmuchgroundtomakeup.AlthoughGDPgrowththisyearisexpectedtoapproachAsianrates,suchratesarefarfromsustainablegiveninfrastructuredeficiencies.SinceGDPperheadissignificantlyhigherthaninChina–andespeciallyIndia–comparisonstoAsianratesofgrowtharenotentirelyappropriate;evenso,Brazil’spotentialsustainablegrowthis
muchlowerthanitshouldbebecauseofafailuretoaddressstructuralreform.Swathesofitsworkforcearepoorlyeducated;innovationisstunted;infrastructureunfitforpurpose;anditscompanies’brands,havingfocussedonhomeadvantageare,withnotableexceptions,littleknownabroad.
Thisreportisdividedintotwoparts.Partonelooksatthepolitical,macroeconomic,industryandinfrastructurefoundationsthathaveenabledthecountrytosoarahead.ParttwodrawsontheviewsofbusinessexecutivesbothinthecountryandworldwideandidentifiesthreekeyaspectsofbusinessonwhichBrazil’sfuturedepends:itsdevelopmentofskills,itscapacitytoinnovate,andthecountry’sroleintheworld–andevaluateswhytheoptimismisjustified.
8
The�Brazilian�National�Congress��DesignedbytheworldfamousarchitectOscarNiemeyer
9
Partone:Cornerstonesofsuccess
Maintaining�political�consensus�
Brazil’snew-foundpoliticalstabilityhasprovidedasturdybaseforexpansion.Nationalelectionsnolongerposeanythreatofaradicalshiftinmacroeconomicpolicyorientation.Thecountry’svoterswillelectanewpresidentinOctober2010,afterthetwo-termlimitofLuizInácioLuladaSilva(knownas“Lula”)expires,aswellasvotinginstategovernorsandanewCongress.Fewcommentatorsharbourseriousworriesaboutthemaincandidatesandtheirpolicies.Powerhasalternatedsince1995betweentwomainparties:Lula’sPartidodosTrabalhadores(PT,orWorkers’Party);andthecentristPartidodaSocialDemocraciaBrasileira(PSDB–orsocialdemocrats).Bothbroadlyagreetocontinueordefendthesuccessfulpoliciesofthepastfifteenyears.
Lula’sshifttotheeconomicpolicycentregroundaheadofthe2002electionshasbroadenedcross-partyconsensusinfavourofdisciplinedmonetaryandfiscalpolicies.Thishasunderpinnedamorestablemacroeconomicenvironment,enablingdomesticandforeigninvestorstolengthentheirplanninghorizons.Theconsolidationofgreaterpoliticalstabilityalsocomesasawelcomereliefforapopulationwhichfollowingtheendofmilitaryrulein1985hasseenwildpoliticalswingsandahostofill-fatedeconomicplansaimedatpromotinggrowthandquashinghyperinflation.
ForallthecorruptioninBrazil’spoliticalsystem,especiallyintheparliament,thecountryhasdemonstrateditspoliticalmaturity.TheoutgoingPresidentLulatookoverthereinsfromFernandoHenriqueCardosoin2003relativelysmoothly,despitebeinginthemidstofafull-blowneconomiccrisisofconfidence.Heendshissecondtermwithunprecedentedpopularityratingsabove80%(thanksinlargeparttosuccessiveincreasesintheminimumwageandsocialpoliciesthathasliftedsome12millionfamiliesoutofpoverty).Yethehasresistedthetemptationtochangeaconstitutionthatforbidshimathirdterm.Instead,hehaspromotedarelativelyuncharismaticformercivilchiefofstaffandenergyandminesminister,DilmaRousseff,todefendhislegacy.
Thislegacyisnotsimplyoneofimplementingfree-marketideas.Thestateremainsfirmlyentrenchedintherunningoftheeconomy,despitemanyunhappyexperiencesof“economicmiracles”gonesourfromhyperinflationandforeigndebtdefault.MsRousseff,andthePSDBchallenger,JoséSerra,alsoadvocateastate-leddevelopmentstrategytoagreaterorlesserdegree.Thefailuresoffreemarketmodelsexposedbythe
globalfinancialcrisisvindicatedseveralofBrazil’sstatistpolicies.Thestatedevelopmentbank,BancoNacionaldeDesenvolvimentoEconômicoeSocial(BNDES),playedamajorroleinsupportingcreditatatimewhenprivatebanksaroundtheworldwereretrenchingsharply.
Thedifferenceseemstobethatadecadeofresponsibledebtmanagement,floatingexchangeratesandinflationtargeting–introducedatthebehestoftheIMFinthewakeoftheupheavalscausedbythe1997-98AsianandRussiancrisis–remainsacrosanct.ThesepolicyanchorswerevitalinenablingBrazilin2008towithstand(tothesurpriseofmany)aseriesofexternaleconomicshocksthatinthepastwouldhavetriggeredmajorinstability.Althoughsomelargecompanies,suchasAracruz,apulpandpapergroup,sufferedfrompoorderivativesdeals,thecountry’scon-servatively-managedbankswerenotexposedtotheriskyassetsthatfelledcounterpartsintheUSandEurope.A$30bnswapdealwiththeFederalReserveBoard(theUScentralbank)increasedtrustintheBrazilianbankingsectorandunderpinnedstronggrowthofdepositsinrecentyears.Indeed,duringtheglobalfinancialcrisis,manyBraziliansoverseasswitchedtheirassetsoutofUSbankstoBrazilianbanks,astheywereperceivedtobesafer.
Notwithstandingallthesepositivepoliticaldevelopments,Brazil’spoliticalenvironmentremainsadragonimplementingreformsneededtosustainmoredynamicGDPgrowth.Althoughfourpartiestypicallyaccountforaround70%ofseatsinthechamberofdeputiesandoverhalfthoseinthesenate,atotalof18politicalpartiesarerepresentedinCongressandgoverningcoalitionsaretypicallyunwieldyaffairs.Onaccountofthelaxrulesgoverningpartyallegiances,congressionalrepresentativestendtobeextremelyprovincial,showinggreaterloyaltytointerestgroupsthantoeitherpartyorpolicy.Moreover,thepresidentiscriticallydependentonthesupportofstategovernors,whotypicallyhaveconsiderableinfluenceovertheirstates’delegationsinCongress.Switchingpartyallegiancesinpursuitofcareeradvancementiscommonamongpoliticiansandcontributestothefractiousnatureofthepoliticalsystem.
A�new�economic�era�
Brazil’sisadiversifiedeconomywithstrongcorporateandfinancialsectors,alowexternaldebtburdenandhighlydiversifiedexportindustriesandmarkets.ThesefactorsputBrazilinapositiontoemergerelativelyquicklyfromtheglobaldownturn.Thecountry’srecessionwasbriefandshallow:theeconomycontractedbyamere0.2%in2009–withthehelpofsomecreditexpansion,andsomesupportfromthegovernment’sflagshipinfrastructuredevelopmentprogramme,theProgramadeAceleraçãodoCrescimento(PAC),growthaccelerationprogrammelaunchedinearly2007.IncontrasttoRussia,seenbymanyasthe
10
morepromisingBRICeconomy,Brazilrespondedtothedownturnbylettingitscurrencydepreciate,conservingitsforexreserves.Moreover,Brazilhas,since2008,becomeanetforeigncreditorasforeigndebtshrankandinternationalreservessoared,promptingallthreemaincreditratingagenciestogivethecountryaninvestmentgraderating.
TheEconomistIntelligenceUnitexpectsBrazil’seconomytoshootahead,by7.8%,in2010–afittingendtoPresidentLula’ssecondfour-yeartermthathasseenannualaverageeconomicgrowthof4.7%(comparedtoaverageannualgrowthof2.5%intheprevious25years).Yet,themacroeconomicoutlookisfarfromrisk-free.Adouble-dipglobaldownturnmayyethitBrazilontherebound,andfiscalandcurrent-accountdeficitscouldalltooeasilyre-open.AlthoughthebudgetdeficitisrelativelysmallforaG20country,at3.3%ofGDPinthe12monthstoend-May2010,thismaynotlast.Indeed,arguably,creativeaccountinghasplayedapartinkeepingtheprimarybudgetontarget,andopacityinitselfcanjeopardiseconfidenceifthepositivemoodevershifts.
Moreover,highpublicspendingimposesahugeburdenonmonetarypolicytokeepinflationtamed.ThebenchmarkSelicinterestrateatover10%isoneofthehighestintheworld,andmarketratesarefarhigher.ByBrazilianstandards,interestratesarehistoricallylow,butgiventhestill-largepublic-debtfinancingrequirements,thelatterisalsocrowdingoutprivateborrowing.
Thecurrentaccountcouldalsodeterioraterapidly.Sixconsecutiveyearsofsurplusendedin2008.Lastyear,thedeficitamountedto1.5%ofGDP,andtheEconomistIntelligenceUnitforecastsadeficitof2.7%in2010.Officialshopethatthelocalcurrency,theReal,willdevalueaccordingly,butthisreadjustmentmaynotbesmooth,especiallyinadifficultexternalfinancingenvironment.
Forecast�summary�(%�unless�otherwise�indicated)�
� 2008a� 2009a� 2010b� 2011b
RealGDPgrowth 5.1 -0.2a 7.8 4.5
Consumerpriceinflation(av) 5.7 4.9 5.4 4.6
Moneymarketinterestrate(av)d 12.4 10.1c 10.3 11.5
Exportsofgoodsfob(US$bn) 197.9 153.0 178.2 194.3
Importsofgoodsfob(US$bn) -173.1 -127.7 -171.7 -200.9
Current-accountbalance(%ofGDP) -1.7 -1.5a -2.7 -3.3
Externaldebt(year-end;US$bn) 253.4c 279.8c 307.0 318.5
ExchangerateR:US$(av) 1.83 2.00 1.80 1.86
a–Actual.b–EconomistIntelligenceUnitforecasts.c–EconomistIntelligenceUnitestimates.d–Selicovernightrate.
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
11
Natural�advantages:�Land�and�energy�
Improvementsinthepolicymixhaveallowedpublicandprivateinvestorstofocusondevelopingthecountry’sindustrialandnaturalresourcebase.BrazilboaststhemostdiversifiedeconomyinLatinAmericawithexportindustriesrangingfrompetrochemicalstoaeronautics.Manufacturedexportshave,infact,declinedfromalmost60%oftotalexportearningsin2000to40%in2010,butoverallearningsvirtuallytripledinthisperiodthankstoextensiveandefficientexploitationofbountifulnaturalassetsandhighcommodityprices.
Brazilisfinallybeingrecognisedasanagriculturesuperpower.Thecommoditiesboomthatpeakedin2008,coupledwithseeminglyinsatiabledemandfromChina,haspoweredBrazil’scommoditiesexports,whichaccountforsome43%oftotalforeignsales.Itistheworld’slargestexporteroforangejuice,coffee,sugar,beefandpoultrymeat.Agronomistshavedevelopednewspeciestoboostproductivityinlessfertileareas,includingalmost100newspeciesofsoyabeansperyear.Itsgrainandleguminousharvestincreasedfrom100mtonnesin2003to134mtonnesin2009.
Theexplosionofdemandenabledpowerfullocalmultinationalstoemerge,althoughsmallerfamily-ownedfarmshavefoundithardtointegrateintothisboomingmarketeconomy.Meanwhile,globalcommoditytradinggroupssuchasCargillandBunge,longpresentinBrazil,havelinkedaproductiveagriculturalbaseintoasophisticatedfoodanddrinksindustry.UnileverandCocaCola,forexample,haveseensolidgrowthinBrazilanddrivenmuchofthesector’sconsolidation.Localgroupsinprocessedmeatproducts,suchasJBSS.AandMarfrig,havealsoprospered,whileothers,suchasSadiaandPerdigão,havemergedaftertheformergotburntbyderivativescontracts.
Deeperundergroundlieothersourcesofrichforeigncurrencyearnings,includinghugereservesofironoreintheminingprovinceofCarajásinthenorthernAmazonregionandthesouth-easternstateofMinasGerais.Althoughthesectorwasopeneduptoforeigncompetitionin1995,Brazil’sprivatisedmininggroup,Vale,theworld’slargestironoreexporter,continuestodominate.Itexpectstoboostitsironoreoutputby50%to450mtonnesby2014.ThecompanyalsoacquiredIncoofCanadain2006–withitslargereservesofnickel–diversifiedintocopper,expandedinAfrica,andisnowoperatinginfivecontinents.
ThelistofBrazil’sothermineralrichesisalsonotable:theworld’snumberthreebauxiteproducer;theworld’ssixth-largestreservesofuranium;thelargestproducerofniobium;andsignificantresourcesofmanganese,copper,tinandgold.
Likewise,Brazil’senergyprofile,inmanyrespects,leadstheworld.Around80%ofthecountry’selectricitycomesfromhydro-electricplants,accountingforsome45%ofenergyconsumptionin2009,andcontinuestoattractinvestorsinnewdamsintheAmazon.Petroleumderivativesaccountedfor39%oftotalenergyconsumption,naturalgasfor8%,coalfor5%,andnuclearfor1%.
Whilegreenenergysourceshavehelpedtoweantheeconomyoffimportedoil,andimprovedBrazil’senvironmentalcredentials(theadverseimpactofdam-buildingaside),thecountry’srecentdiscoveryofhugeoilreservesbelowthedeepwatersoffitssoutherncoastwilleventuallyshifttheenergybalance,makingBrazilamajoroilexporteroverthelongerterm.Thecountryalsoproducesindustrialquantitiesofbiofuelssuchassugarcaneethanolusedincars.In2008,domesticsalesofethanolexceeded,forthefirsttime,thesaleofpetrol.Petrobras,thestateoilgiant,isalsoinvestinginbiofuels(biodieselandsugarcaneethanolviaajointventurewithTereosInternational,asubsidiaryoftheFrenchco-operative.
Theintroductionin2003offlex-fuelcarengineshasencouragedapartialrenewalofthepassenger-carfleet;in2009,88%ofnewsaleswereflex-fuelvehicles.Flex-fuelcarscanrunbothonpetrolandsugarcaneethanol,allowingdriverstochoosethecheapestoption.Thesedevelopmentshavegonehandinhandwithalocalcarindustrythathasheldupwellintheglobalcrisis,thanksinlargeparttotaxbreaksandagoodsupplyofcredit,helpingtomakeBraziltheworld’sthesixth-largestmanufacturerandfourth-largestandfastest-growingmarketforlightvehicles.
Shaky�infrastructure�
Carmakersmayrejoice,butitisthemillionsofdriversthathavetonegotiatethedangerouslyunpavedroadsthatprevaileverywhereexceptthemainroutes–andevenmanyofthesearepotholedorneedresurfacing.PoorinfrastructureisonemajorreasonthatBrazilscoreslowintheEconomistIntelligenceUnit’sbusinessenvironmentrankings(basedon12keybusinessoperatingcriteria),whichplacesBrazil40thoutof82countriesdespitetheexpectationofsomemildimprovementsincomingyears.TheWorldBankDoingBusinessreportandotherinternationalrankingstellasimilarstory.Highandcomplextaxation,excessivebureaucracy,complexcustomsrules,corruption,asluggishjudiciary,andrigidlabourmarketsarefurtherlegitimateinvestorgrievances.
Butasklocalbusinessmenwithinternationalambitionsabouttheirgreatestconcern,andtheparlousstateoftheinfrastructurewillalmostcertainlytopthelist.Inoursurvey,nearlyonehalfofrespondents(49%)pointto“lowstandardorcostlyinfrastructureincludingtelephones,transportnetworksandutilities”asthemainoperational
12
obstacle,farmorethanselectedcorruption,poorgovernance(34%)orskillsshortages(32%),thestateoftransportinfrastructureisparticularlydire.Inspiteofsomeimprovementinlogistics,freightdependsoncostlyroadhaulage;therearefewrailroads;thepotentialforwaterwaysremainslargelyunexplored;andportsandairportsarecongested.Thiscanaddonequarterormoretothecostofgettinggoodstomarket,sayinvestors.
Which�of�the�following�operational�obstacles��present�the�greatest�challenges�to�your�business�operations�in�Brazil?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
InvestingininfrastructurehasbeenattheheartofPresidentLula’sgrowthprogramme(theso-calledPAC,launchedin2007),butprogresshasbeenlimited.Fewerthanhalfofthetargetsfor2010havebeenmet(withmuchoftheproposedfinancinggoingtofirst-timehomeowners,ratherthanintophysicalinfrastructure).Highpublicspendingcommitmentsarecrowdingoutthepaltry1%ofGDPthatisproposedforinvestmentininfrastructure,whilelimitedprivatesectorinvestmentintransportwillnotmakeuptheshortfall.
Littlemorethan10%ofBrazil’sroadnetworkispaved,andeventhesearepoorlymaintained.Theexceptionsarethemaintollroadsmanagedbyprivateoperatorssincethelate1990s,suchasthemainSãoPaulo-RiodeJaneiromotorway.Aswellasgrowingcarusage(with25mvehiclesnowontheroads)morethan60%ofcargotransportationisbytruck,eventhoughthismethodisslowandcostly.Manyfleetscompriseownerdriverswithageingvehicles,andthismakesithardforacompanytodevelopanoverarchingviewofitslogisticsneeds.AccordingtoAndrewMorgan,foundingchairmanofSupplyChainEurope,whichisinvolvedwithfreightlogisticsinBrazil’sfoodindustry,driversaremoreworriedabout“fiscalcompliance”–thatis,fillingouttherighttaxinvoice–thanwhetherthegoodsarriveontime.
Thefragmentednatureoftransportationisevenmoreapparentinrailtransport.Thecountry’s30,000-kmrailnetworkhasgrownby20%sinceitwasprivatisedandupgradedinthelate1990s.Butdespitegovernmenteffortstogetmorefreightontrains,itremainsunderused(withrareexceptionssuchaslinesoperatedbyironoreexporters)accountingforonly25%oftotalfreightmovement.
Meanwhile,Brazil’sgreatpotentialforrivertransportremainslargelyunexploited.Waterwayscurrentlyaccountforonly13%ofhaulage,eventhoughBrazilhasa48,000kmnetworkofnavigablerivers.
Thelogisticalnightmaredoesnotendwhengoodsfinallygettoportsforexport.AlthoughportssuchasatSantosnearSãoPaulo,whichhandlesaroundonequarterofthecountry’sforeigntrade,haveundergonesomemodernisationoverthepast15years,theyarecongestedandexpensive,especiallyatharvesttimeswhentrucksladenwithgrainarriveforloading.Itisasimilarstorywiththecountry’smainairports,theresultofsoaringdemand,andwillsurelybecomeanimportantissuetoberesolvedbeforethefloodofvisitorspoursinforthefootballWorldCupandOlympics.
Asidefromtheneedforcontinuinginvestment,MrMorganseesproblemsinthelackofabigpicture.Freightoperatorsallalongthesupplychaintendtosee“lowcost”asthekeyperformanceindicator.No-onetakesastrategicviewoftransportwhichwouldendupsavingmoney.Hebelievesthatiflogisticsoperatorsfocusedateachstageontimeratherthancost,thiswouldproducethegreatestefficiencies.Theproblemisthatno-onetakes“end-to-end”responsibilityforthewholelogisticsjourney.Andthisextendstothefinalexportdestination.Hecitesanexampleofonecompany’sgrainexportstoRussiathatranintotroublebecausetheBrazilianlogisticsmanagerwasunawareofthedifferentrailcontainersizesusedinRussia.
Ultimately,thesolutionliesinbettercollaborationbetweenprivatesectoroperatorsandthestateatvariouslevels.Wherethereisabigplayer,likeVale,itispossibletonegotiatewiththestateovertransportneedsandinvestment.Inafragmentedmarket,suchasthefoodindustry,substantialeffortisrequiredtogettherightpeoplearoundthetabletodiscusspriorities,investmentandresponsibilities.
Consume�now,�pay�later�
Onceseenas‘Americanswithoutcredit’,Braziliansarestartingtoenjoytherushofdebt-inducedpurchasingpower.Asaccesstocredithasimproved,andshopshavefacilitatedevenrelativelysmallpurchasessuchasshoeswithinstallment-payments,householdconsumptionhasboomed.Despitedifficultiesofgettinggoodsto
Low standard or costly infrastructure including, telephones, transport networks, utilities.
Failure to honour contracts, bribery, corruption, weak corporate governance.
Lack of key skills including management.
Poor quality control.
Rising wages/low productivity.
Underdeveloped retail and distribution systems.
Credit risk.
Availability of credit.
Difficult relations with organised labour.
Saturated markets.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
49%
34%
32%
24%
14%
15%
17%
20%
21%
9%
13
shops,Brazil’stantalisingmarketof192million,youthfulconsumersissimplytoomouth-wateringaprospecttobypass.Theeventualcontrolofinflationinthemid-1990sandthesuccessofthenewstablecurrency,theReal,setthestageforaconsumerboom.Fallingunemployment,nowat7.5%inmajorurbancentres,realincomegainsandcreditexpansionhavepushedupdisposableincomesandmadeordinaryBraziliansfeelalittlericher.
Some20millionBraziliansoverthepastsixyearshavebeenreclassifiedoutofpoverty,accordingtoMarceloNeri,asocialresearcherfromtheFundaçãoGetúlioVargas(FGV),aRiodeJaneirothinktankandbusinessschool.Overonehalfofallhouseholdsinlargeurbancentresaremiddleclass,upfrom42%in2004,accordingtotheFGV.Nevergreatsavers(giventhelegacyofhyperinflation),Braziliansarenowabletoborrowtofinancethegoodlife,withcreditrisingfrom25%ofGDPin2005to45%ofGDPtoday,pouringfurtherfuelonconsumerfires.
Thishasgeneratedrapaciousdemandforcars,personalcomputers,TVsetsandmobilephones.Followingthe1998privatisationofthetelecomsindustrythesaleofmobilephonesrosespectacularly,overtakingthenumberoffixedlinesin2003,andreaching184millioninmid-2010.
Largeretailinggroupshavealsothrived.ForeignchainssuchasCarrefour(France),andWal-Mart(US)havediversifiedintonon-foodandwholesaleactivities.PãodeAçucar(controlledbyCasino,aFrenchretailer)recentlyagreedtobuytwolocalnon-foodoutlets,PontoFrioandCasasBahia,inordertoincreaseitsexposuretoelectronicgoodsdemandandthelower-incomemarketsegment.
Withappetitesforconsumergoodsnowthoroughlywhetted,householdsaresettingtheirsightsonthebiggerprizeofhomeownership.Themortgagemarket,whichwasalmostnon-existentinthe1990s,hasstartedshowingsignsoflife,althoughitremainsinitsinfancy.Equivalenttoonly1.3%ofGDPatend-2005,itincreasedto2.1%ofGDPatend-2008,andwithpublicfinancingforsocialhousing,andagovernmentpledgetofinanceatleast1millionhomesforthepoorandthemiddleclass,themortgagestockhasriseninabsoluteterms,thoughisstillonlyaround3%ofGDP,indicatinghugescopeforgrowth.
TimeanddemographicsareonBrazil’sside,atleastoverthemediumterm.Theshareofthepopulationaged14orunderisaround28%,andthisagegroupwillstillcompriseatleastoneinfiveBraziliansforanother20years.Butageingwillsetinthereafter:thecountry’sbirthratehasdeclinedfrom2.39perwomanin2000toanexpected1.76in2010,accordingtoInstitutoBrasileirodeGeografiaeEstatística(IBGE).Itforecaststhattheratewillstabiliseataround1.5bythe2020s.Butforthenextdecade,atleast,thecountrycancountonarobustworking-agepopulationtopaytaxesandpensioncontributions(assuminggrowthintheformalsector),inmarkedcontrasttomanydevelopedeconomies.Itisthenurturingofthisyoungergeneration,itseducation,training,jobsandskills,thatholdsthekeytoBrazil’slong-termgrowthandprosperity,asPartTwoofthisreportexplores.
Brazil:�Population,�income�and�market�size
2005a� 2006a� 2007a� 2008a� 2009b� 2010c� 2011c� 2012c� 2013c� 2014c
Population(m) 184.2 186.8 189.3 191.9 194.4 196.8 199.3 201.6 204.0 206.6
GDP(US$bnat 881.8 1,088.9 1,366.3 1,637.9 1,573.4 1,927.6 2,021.7 2,088.9 2,198.2 2,317.9marketexchangerates)
Privateconsumption 531.5 656.6 818.4 988.0 987.4 1,194.0 1,253.1 1,299.8 1,370.5 1,442.3(US$bn)
Privateconsumption 2,890 3,520 4,320 5,150 5,080 6,070 6,290 6,450 6,720 6,980perhead(US$)
GDPperhead 8,610 9,110b 9,800b 10,390b 10,360 11,150 11,660 12,260 12,990 13,760(US$atPPP)
Personaldisposable 543.3 674.2b 841.7b 1,016.3b 1,127.6 1,270.8 1,252.8 1,240.3 1,240.5 1,256.9income(US$bn)
Growthofreal 2.5b 5.7b 6.2b 7.1b 15.5 -0.7 -1.8 0.2 -0.5 0.7disposableincome(%)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
14
The�Federal�University�of�Parana,�Curitiba.�TheoldestuniversityinBrazil,foundedin1912.
15
Parttwo:Socialandintellectualcapital
I.��Talent�and�education
The�learning�curve
Thirtyyearsago,BrazilandSouthKoreahadsimilarlevelsofGDPpercapita–todaytheAsiantigerisoverthreetimesricher(inPPPterms).Onemajorreasonforthisdivergencehasbeenalackofinvestmentineducation.InBrazil,thesystem’sfailingsarehavingdirectconsequencesforthequalityoftheworkforce.In2008,some20%oftheworking-agepopulationcouldnotread,writeorunderstandbasictext,aslightimprovementonthe25%leveloffunctionalilliteracyrecordedfiveyearsearlier.Thequalityofeducationforthemajorityofthecountry’schildrenandteenagers–thatis,thosewhocannotaffordaprivateeducation–remainsparticularlyinadequate,heldbackbypoorteachertraining,shortcomingsinphysicalinfrastructureincludingalackofnurseries,andstill-hightruancyrates.Onlyonehalfofthecountry’schildrencompletesecondaryeducation,thesecondworstdrop-outrateintheworld,aheadonlyofMozambique,accordingtoAlbertoRodriguez,aWorldBankeducationspecialist.
Thesystemcanboastafewsuccesses.Almostallchildrenagedbetween7and14attendedschoolin2008,accordingtoofficialfigures.Theaveragenumberofyearsofformaleducationintheworking-agepopulationhasalsorisenoverthepast20yearsfrom5.2yearsto7.1yearsin2008.Butthislevelisstillshortofthe10yearsrecommendedbyUnescoandachievedbyneighbouringChile,PeruandArgentina.Therearealsobigregionaldisparities.Themoredevelopedsouthandsouth-easthave7.5and7.7years,respectively;thepoorernorth-eastaverages5.9years.Althoughyoungerpeopletendtohavehadmoreyearsinschoolthantheirparents,theyarestillillpreparedforthemodernjobmarket.InOECD-runtestsacross57countriesin2006,Brazilian15-year-oldsranked53rdinmathematics,52ndinsciencesand48thinreading.
Partoftheproblemisthestructureoftheeducationsystem.Ahighlydecentralisedmish-mash,responsibilitiesarespreadovernumeroustiersofgovernment.Thefederalgovernmentspendssome3%ofitsbudgetoneducation,butitisthepublicsectorschoolsrunbystatesandmunicipalitiesthatmanagemuchofit.Thesysteminvolves200,000educationalunits,50millionpupils,and3million,oftenunderperforming,civilservantsandmanagers,accordingtoJoãoBatistaAraújoeOliveira,aformerWorldBankofficial.
Teachersarealsooftenpartoftheproblemratherthanthesolution.Reportsofwasteinschoolsarerife–computersleftintheirboxesbecauseteachersdon’tknowhowtouse
themforexample.“Theycantalkabout[childdevelopmentpsychologist]Piagetbuttheycannotorganiseaclassroom.Theyjustdon’tknowthepractice,”saysMrRodriguez.Heestimatestheannualcosttotheeducationsystemandthewidereconomyofsucheducationalshortcomingsataround$600m.AsPauloRenatoSouza,aformereducationminister,notes:“Weneedpupilsactuallytolearnsomething.”
Average�years�of�formal�education�by�gender,�age�groups,�2008(inyears)
20-24 25-29 30-39 40-49 50-59 >60
Men 9.1 8.8 7.7 7.3 6.2 4.3
Women 9.8 9.5 8.5 7.7 6.3 3.9
Total 9.4 9.2 8.1 7.5 6.3 4.1
Source: IBGE.
Educational�level�achieved�in�working-age�population�(25-64�age�group):
Basiceducation:63%
Secondaryeducation:27%
Highereducation:10%
Source: IBGE.
Companies�step�in
CompaniesinBraziloftenfindthatiftheywanttheskillstheyneed,theyhavetofilltheyawninggapleftbythecountry’sscrappyeducationsystemthemselves.Muchofthetrainingtakesplaceafterrecruitsarehired,butsomeinitiativestrytogetinearlier.FollowinghisretirementaspresidentofPhilipsLatinAmerica,MarcosMagalhães,forexample,launchedtheInstitutodeCo-ResponsabilidadepelaEducação,aninitiativetoraiseeducationstandardsinhishomestateofPernambuco,inthenorth-east.Suchprivateeffortsarespreading,andcarrythesimpleobjective:tomaketheclassroomwork,andtrytocatchupwithcompetitors,especiallyinAsia.
Theideafollowssimilar,successfulinitiativesinSouthKoreaandEurope.ButinBrazil,theymerelyscratchthesurface.Meanwhile,governmenteducationbodiesinsist,rightlyinmanyinstances,thatmoneyforeducationbespentonteachertrainingandpartnershipswithstate-runschools.
Thesedilemmasexistatpost-secondaryeducationtoo.AnEconomistIntelligenceUnitreportonpost-secondaryeducationinBrazilconcluded:“Ratherthanoperatingeducationalinstitutions,theprivatesectorshouldworkinpublic-privatepartnershipsrelatedtoeducation,sharebestpracticesofchangemanagement,providefinancialsupportforprogrammestoenhanceteacherqualification,andsharenewtechnologysolutions.”
16
Everybithelps,itseems.“Youcannotlosetheopportunitytosetupalinkbetweenthecorporateworldandtheuniversity,”saysMrGutierrez,CEOofIntrabase,alocalmarketingcompany.Headdsthatcompaniescanspurpost-secondaryinstitutionstoexplorereal-worldsituationsbyencouragingemployeeparticipationineducationalprogrammesandofferingstudentshands-onexperiencethroughinternshipsandwork-studyprogrammes.
Creaming�off�
Whilethemassofunder-educatedBrazilianslanguish,thestoryatthetopofthepyramidisofintensifyingcompetitionformanagerialskills.Muchofthequalitytalentthatenterstheworkforcecomesfromseveralwell-respecteduniversitiesandbusinessschoolsinBrazil,manyofwhicharerankedasthebestinLatinAmerica,accordingtoa2009comparativesurveybyHeidrick&Struggles,arecruitmentfirm.Studentsfromleading(usuallystate-run)universitiesinBrazilareratedhighlybyforeignmultinationals.
Inaddition,businessschoolsarecateringforanewcropofprofessionalmanagers.Someofthemorepromisingstudentsattendleadingforeignbusinessschools,butincreasinglyhome-growninstitutionssuchasthehighlyregardedInsperandIBMEChaveemergedandbeensuccessful.Othersthoughhaveattractedcriticismsforlackingrelevant“people-related”trainingthatisincreasinglyrequiredbyinternationalmanagement.
Althoughdeemedhighlycreative,Brazilianstaffareoftenseenaslackinginitiative.AccordingtoSergioAverbach,presidentoftheSouthAmericadivisionofKornFerry,anexecutivesearchcompany,thesuccessofBrazilianmanagersinternationallyismore“duetotheiroutstandinginfluenceandleadershipskills,thantotheabilitytocreatethenewandthedifferent.”
Withrapideconomicexpansionandrisingforeigninvestment,demandfortherightskillshassimplyintensified.“BoardmembersoftentellmetheyarehavingtroublehiringpeoplefromCEOtofactorystaff,”saysMrAverbach.“Irecentlyreceived10presidentsofconstructioncompanies.ThereissimplynotenoughlabourforcetomeettheneedsatalllevelsinBrazil.”
Companieshavefewproblemswiththosewhoarequalified–therejustaren’tenoughofthem.AES,aUSelectricitycompanythathasinvestedsome$6bninBrazilsince1997andplanstodoubleinsizewithinfiveyears,typicallysuffersashortageofelectriciansandmechanics.“Qualityisnotaconstrainingfactor,butthevolumesarenotthere,”notesAndrewVesey,AESpresidentforLatinAmericaandAfrica.Thecompanyhastoinvestintrainingitsownworkforcetomeetitsneeds.
Gettingforeignerstofillthegapcanalsobefrustrating.AlistairCox,CEOofHayGroup,aconsultancy,saysthatIndiaprovidesavaluableexampletofollow:BrazilneedstoinvestininformationtechnologyandattractthetalentcurrentlyworkingoutsideBrazil.
AlltheseissuesbecomestarklyapparentfromtheEconomistIntelligenceUnit’sownsurvey.Thelackofkeyskillsisthebiggestoperatingchallengefacedbynearlyonethirdofsurveyrespondents–andasmuchas47%ofUS-basedcompanies–onaparwithcorruptionandnotfarbehindtheproblemsofpoorinfrastructure.Notabledeficienciesamongstaffincludelanguageskills(43%reportshortfallsthere)andscienceknowledge(34%).
Still,overonehalfofrespondentsalsosaythattheBrazilianworkforcematchestheirneeds,withengineeringcompaniesbeingamongthemoresatisfied(althoughitisworthnotingtoothattheUSChamberofCommerceinSãoPaulorecentlyfoundthat41%ofitsmemberswereunhappywiththequalityofengineers,describingtheirtrainingas“totallyinadequate”).
In�which�of�the�following�areas�of�education�or�skills�relevant�to�your�business�do�you�believe�the�Brazilian�labour�market�satisfies�your�needs�or�falls�short?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
Brazilianmanagersalsoappeartolackinternationalexperienceandmulticulturalawareness,whencomparedwiththeirpeersindevelopedmarkets.Butlocalmanagersdoexcelincreativityandinnovation.Managementexperience,financeandmarketingarealsohighlyrated.
Basic literacy or numeracy
Secondary education
Tertiary education
Languages
IT
Science
Engineering
Mobility
Work ethic
Soft skills (ie, problem solving, cultural sensitivity, etc)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
13% 17%70%
68%11% 21%
11% 54% 35%
9% 48% 43%
16% 61% 23%
20% 59% 21%
18% 61% 20%
10% 56% 34%
23%16% 62%
23% 58% 19%
Exceeds needs Matched needs Falls short
17
How�would�you�rate,�relative�to�management�in�developed�markets,�the�skills�and�knowledge�of�Brazilian�managers�in�the�following�areas?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
Overall,Brazilianmanagersaredeemedtobeonaparwithdevelopedmarketpeers,andsuperiortothosefromotheremergingmarkets,accordingto42%ofrespondents.EducationstandardsmaybehigherinmostpartsofAsiathaninBrazil,butthequalityofmanagementis“probablyworseinChinaandIndia”,saysEduardoWanick,presidentofDuPontLatinAmerica.
How�would�you�rate�the�quality�of�Brazilian�managers�compared�with�those�in:�
a)� other�emerging�markets?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
b)�developed�markets?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
The�sky’s�the�limit
Attheverytop,thereseemstobenoshortageofrolemodelstoinspirethemostambitiousBrazilianexecutives.SeveralBrazilian-bornbusinessleadershaverisentoglobalprominenceinrecentyears.CarlosBrito,theCEOofABInbev,startedhiscareerwiththeBrazilianbrewerAmbev(whichlatermergedwithInterbrewandAnheuserBusch).AlainBeldaandBrazilian-bornCarlosGhosnhaveenjoyedhigh-flyingcareersatAlcoaandRenault-Nissan,respectively.AndréEstevesnowheadsBTG,anaggressiveemergingmarketinvestmentbank.What,someargue,maybeholdingbackthenextgenerationofbusinessleadersistheabilitytothinkinnovatively.
Management experience.
International experience
People management.
Relevant technical skills
Multicultural awareness (languages, knowledge of foreign cultures, etc).
Strategic thinking.
Finance.
Marketing.
Creativity/Innovation.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
39% 13% 1%35%
24%5% 40% 26% 5%
9% 32% 42% 14% 3%
7% 36% 41% 13% 2%
21% 32% 31% 13% 3%
10% 36% 38% 13% 3%
16% 30% 38% 14% 2%
8% 30% 43% 16% 3%
34% 23% 5%10% 28%
Very high 1 2 3 4 Very low 5
12%
Generally superior.
About the same.
Generally inferior.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
42%
50%
8%
Generally superior.
About the same.
Generally inferior.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
19%
51%
31%
18
Business�education�–�not�just�for�the�boardroom�
ThesizeofBrazil’smarketforbusinesseducationisaround$1bn,accordingtoVanDyckSilveira,directorofbusinessdevelopmentatDukeCorporateEducation.Petrobras,thestateoilgroup,forexample,isspendinganestimated$150mperyearontraining.Companiesareincreasinglytakingontheburdenofimprovingemployeeskillsthatshouldhavebeencoveredwithintheeducationsystem.
MrSilveira,oneofseveralexecutiveswhotookoverandrestructuredthebusinessschoolIBMECin1998,seesaparticularneedforthesoftskillsofmanagement–communication,givingfeedback,“co-creating”andsoon.ButhealsobelievesthatthehighlyflexibleapproachofhisBrazilianstudentsmakesthemwellplacedtobenefit.Unlikemanyothernationalities,“theydon’tfreezewhentheirmistakesarepointedout”.Feedbackistakenconstructivelyandatfacevalue,hesays.
DukeCE’scoursesarerareinacountrywhereMBAsarefocusedonacademicresearchratherthantheneedsofcompanies.ButwhiledealingwithsomeofthemostmotivatedandemployabletalentheseesmuchdeeperproblemsinBrazil’seducationsystem-namelythefailureofsecondaryschoolstopreparestudentsfortheworldofwork.
Theelitearealreadywellcateredfor,hebelieves,havingattendedexpensivesecondaryschoolswhereteachingisrigorousandincludesastrongdoseofscienceandmathematics.Thesestudentsareatabigadvantagewhengettingintothehighlycompetitiveandhigh-qualitystateuniversities.
Theresthaveapoorgroundinginscience,mathematicsandcomputerscience.Theymayhavehadclassesin15thcenturyPortugueseliterature,buttheyhavenotbeentrainedtothinkrigorouslyoranalysedata,remarksMrSilveira.Thisdeprivespotentialemployersofacorpsofcompetentmiddlemanagementandtechnicalstaff.“Thereisabigdisconnectbetweenhighschoolanduniversity,”henotes.Manyoftheprivatecollegestheygoontoaremerely“diplomamills”.
MrSilveirahasseentheproblemfirsthand,andhasevenhadtoalterthesyllabusatIBMECtogetweakerstateschoolcandidatesuptoscratch.Positivediscriminationcanhelp,butittendstolowertheoverallqualityofgraduates,andrequireshighereducationinstitutestoteachbasic,grade1skillsorelseseestudentsfallbehind.
Theproblemstemsfromthequalityofteachinginwhatamountsto“apactofmediocrity”.ToparaphraseanoldSoviet-erajokeaboutbossesandworkers:“theypretendtoteachus,andwepretendtolearn.”Secondaryschoolteachersdonothavetobeaccreditedwithaformalqualification.Theymaybeabletorunaclassroom,buttheybarelyknowthesubjectstheyaresupposedtobeteaching.
A�question�of�class
MrSilveiraarguesforreforminthreeareastomeetBrazil’sfuturebusinessneeds.First,addressthemismatchbetweenwhatbusinessneedsfromschoolleaversandwhatthebureaucratsintheeducationministriesputonthesyllabuses.Hewantsofficialsto“createalearningarchitecture”thateducatesforlife,fromtopmanagementtotheshopfloor.
Second,shiftfundingawayfromthetopuniversitiestowardsprimaryandsecondaryeducation.Thismeansensuringpropertrainingandqualificationsforteachers,andgreatertransparencyaboutwhicharethehigh-andlow-performingschools.Whilearound7%ofthegovernmentbudgetgoestoeducationgenerally,thevastmajorityofthisisspentonhighereducation.
Relatedtothisisathirdissue–theneedtobemoreequitable,sothatthosewhoaremostabletopay,andwhodominatehighereducation(andwhowillearnmostintheirfuturecareers),arenotfundedbypoorertaxpayerswhobenefitleastfromtheeducationsystem.Withonlyaround1in5schoolleaversgoingtocollege,thisseemsnotonlyunfairbutalsogrosslyinefficient.
Businessshouldbelessworriedaboutthequalitycomingoutofthetopoftheeducationsystemandfocusonthemid-rankingschoolleavers,whoareneededtoprovidethenation’smiddlemanagement,techniciansandengineers,butfindthemselvesstrugglingthrough,andtoooftendroppingoutof,secondaryeducation.
19
II.��Innovation�in�thinking�and�action�
A�certain�mindset
WhileBrazilianindustrycanboastseveralcentresofexcellence—notablyenergy,aerospaceandagribusiness—educationdeficienciesholdbackinnovationinthewidereconomy.DavidNeeleman,theSãoPaulo-bornCEOofAzulairlines(andfounderofthelow-costJetBlueairlineintheUS),observesacultureofdeferenceamonghisBrazilianstaff.Flightattendantsarehappytoreadthecompanymanual,butfewactuallyraiseissuesduringmeetingsortrytoimproveprocesses.“Innovationstartswhenpeopleareabletospeaktheirmind,”hesays.Heisnottheonlyinvestortodrawsuchconclusions.
Butotherswoulddisagreewiththisassessment.ManyinvestorsregardtheirBrazilianstafftobe“flexibleandadaptable”,quiteprobablybecausetheyhavehadtodealwithasuccessionofeconomiccrisesthattaughtthemhowtosucceedinthemidstofinstability,sayinvestors.“ThereisatoleranceforambiguitythatismuchstrongerinBrazilthaninothercountries,”saysKornFerry’sMrAverbach.TheBrazilianexecutive“hasinhisDNAtheabilitytochangedirectionwithgreatereasethaninanyotherregionintheworld”.ButresearchconductedwithInseadbusinessschoolsuggeststhatBrazilianmanagersarelessablewhenitcomesto“creatingthenewandthedifferent”.
Whicheverviewonetakes,Brazilcannotdenyitspoorrecordofinnovation.“Everybodyagreesthatinnovationisimportantbutpeopledonotnecessarilybehavethatway,”saysMrWanickfromDuPont.Brazilaccountsforsome3.5%ofworldGDPatpurchasingpowerparity(PPP),butonly0.2%ofworldpatentsoriginatefromthismarket.Bycontrast,28%ofpatentsareregisteredintheUS.
AnEconomistIntelligenceUnitinnovationmodelthatmeasurescountriesaccordingtoboththeirreadinessandsuccessininnovationranksBrazil52ndoutof82countries,andnotesthatthecountryislikelytoslipfurtherdowntherankingsincomingyears.Moreinterestingly,themodelshowsthatitsrankingofthefactorsthatcontributetoinnovation(forexample,thenumberofsciencegraduates,educationlevels,thebusinessenvironment,R&Dspending,broadbandpenetration,etc),althoughinitselflow,isstillhigherthanthemeasureforinnovationsuccesses(measuredbythenumberofpatentsfiledglobally).ThissuggeststhatnotonlyisBrazilinsufficientlyinnovativecomparedwithitspeers,butthatitisalsoinefficientwithitsresources,byfailingtotranslateinvestmentsintopracticalinnovation.
Which�of�the�following�technological�factors�most�impact�your�firm’s�ability�to�innovate�in�Brazil?�
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
Whetherthisistheresultofalackofinventivenessorsystemicfailuresinthebusinessenvironmentishardtogauge,butBrazil’sweedyperformancecomesthroughintheviewsandexperiencesofcompaniessurveyed.“Innovationsthataredevelopedlocallyarenotfrequent,”lamentsMrWanick.Some57%ofsurveyedexecutivessaythattheydonothaveadedicatedR&Dfacility,orevenplantohaveoneintheshortterminBrazil,althoughthelikesofIBMandGeneralElectrichaverecentlyannounceddecisionstoestablishtheirownresearchcentresinBrazil.
Overonehalfofrespondents(51%)saythat,atpresent,lessthan10%ofproductsandservicessoldbytheircompanieshaveactuallybeendevelopedinBrazil,andatleastonequarterofrespondentsexpectnoprogressoverthethreeyears.Moreover,only29%expecttodevelophalfoftheirproductsandservicesinBrazil,andthatfigurerisesto38%inthreeyears’time.
Yetconditionsforinnovationontheshop-flooraremorepromising;whenfocusingmoreonthehumanfactors,Brazilian-basedcompaniesareseenaswellabletointegratethelatestinternationaltechnologyintotheiroperations,withalmostonehalf(49%)ofsurveyrespondentsdescribingthiscapacityas“verygood”or“excellent”,andonly6%sayingitis“poor”.
Technical skills of the workforce.
Availability of scientists and engineers.
Total spending on R&D in the country.
Availability of university graduates.
Spending on R&D by the private sector.
Quality of IT and communications infrastructure.
Spending on R&D by the public sector (government).
Broadband penetration.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
46%
41%
23%
28%
28%
30%
33%
13%
20
What�proportion�of�the�products�and�services�sold�by�your�company�in�Brazil�was�developed��in�Brazil?
a)� in�the�past�three�years�
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
b)�in�the�next�three�years?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
�Case�study��DuPont:�Middle�class�army
DuPonthasrecentlylauncheditsversionof‘thepeople’s’bullet-proofvehicleinBrazilbasedonalightandaffordablearmouringconcept.Thenewproduct,namedArmura,offersprotectionagainst97%offirearmsincirculationinBrazil,accordingtoDuPont,atamuchreducedcost($10,000insteadof$30,000ormore).Thearmourisalsomuchlighter(lessthan100kgagainstmorethan200kgforregulararmour).
TheprojectwasdevelopedentirelyinLatinAmerica,mostlyinBrazil,saysEduardoWanick,presidentofDuPontLatinAmerica.Theconceptisappealingtoagrowingmiddle-classpopulationthatlivesinastateofconstantinsecurity,especiallyinurbancentres(“40,000murdersayearislikeasmallwar,”saysMrWanick–nottomentioncarjackingsandotherformsofattack).
Inordertoputitsproductonthemarket,DuPontprovidescompleteprefabkits(itsownproductsarecalledSentryGlasandDevlar)toauthorisedcardealers.Five
modelsarecurrentlyavailable,fromGeneralMotors,Toyota,Mitsubishi,HondaandHyundai.“Thepotentialishuge,”saysMrWanick,althoughhedeclinestoprovidehardnumbers.Brazilisthelargestmarketintheregionforarmouredvehicles;butthereisplentymoredemandforArmuraintherestofLatinAmericaandfurtherafield.
Greenfield�thinking
OnevitalareaofinnovationwhereBrazilexcelsisinthedevelopmentofgreentechnologies.DespiteinternationalcriticismoverAmazondeforestation(andworriesoverpotentialnewoilwealth),Brazilboastssomeimpressivegreencredentials.Electricityneedsarelargelymetthroughhydropower,andthecountryhasexperimentedsuccessfullyinbiofuelssuchassugarcaneethanol.LocalmanufacturersandsupplierssuchasMagnetiMarellidevelopeda“flex-fuel”engineinthe1990s,allowingcarstorunoneitherpetrolorethanol,oracombinationofthetwo.Suchmodelsnowaccountformorethan90%ofnewvehiclesinthefast-growingautomotivemarket(seePartone).Brazil-basedcompaniesarealsoinvolvedinresearchonasecondgenerationofbiofuels(suchascellulose),althoughtheperformanceofbiodieselhasprovedlessconvincing.Localfirms,suchasBraskem,arealsobreakingnewgroundingreenplastics(seecasestudybelow).
�Case�studyBraskem:�A�future�in�green�plastics
Braskem,thepetrochemicalunitofOdebrecht,amajorindustrialconglomerate,hitheadlineswhenitannouncedthedevelopmentofso-called“greenplastics”.Brazil’sPresidentLulapromotedthecompany’stechnologyonavisittoEurope,unveilingaprototypeofthe“greencarofthefuture”whichincludedBraskem’sinnovativematerial.
Thenewsugarcane-derivedpolyethylene,whichavoidstheuseofnaphta,willbeproducedonanindustrialscalebythebeginningof2011.Theproductwillcostaround20%morethananequivalentnon-greenproduct,saysthecompany,buttheinnovationisviewedasabreakthroughinthesearchforrenewablealternativestooil-derivedplastics.
TheplasticwasdevelopedfromsugarcaneethanolbyBraskem’sresearchanddevelopmentcentreinsouthernBrazilinpartnershipwithJapan-basedToyotaTsusho.Inaddition,BraskemisworkingwithNovozymes,aDanish-basedbiotechnologycompany,inaresearchprojecttoproduceasugarcane-derivedpolypropylene.
ThecompanyhascapitalisedonBrazil’sexperienceinethanol,whichisalreadywidelyusedasbiofuelinthecarindustry.Braskem’sethanolissuppliedbyETHBio-Energia,alsoaunitofOdebrecht.ThenewR500mgreenplasticsplant,whichisbeingsetupinTriunfo,southernBrazil,willhaveanannualcapacityof200,000tonnes,accordingtoBraskem.
0-10%
11-50%
51-90%
91-100%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
21%
51%
13%
16%
9%
0-10%
11-50%
51-90%
91-100%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
36%
26%
23%
15%
9%
21
Greenplasticresinsareexpectedtofindaneagermarketamongmanufacturersofpackaging,automotive,cosmeticsandpersonalhygieneproducts.BraskemhasalreadysecuredcontractswithTetraPakandtheJapaneseShiseidocosmeticsfirm.OnequarterofitsinitialproductionwillbeexportedtoAsia.Meanwhile,Natura,aleadingBraziliancosmeticscompany,isalreadyadvertisingthatitwilluseBraskem’sgreenplasticsaspartofitssustainabilitypolicy.
Braskemcurrentlyemploysaround200researchers,andhasfiled250patentsinBrazil,EuropeandtheUS.LuizdeMendonça,Braskem’svice-president,saysthat20%ofthecompany’ssalescomefromproductslaunchedinthepastthreeyears.
BothitsindustrialsitesinTriunfoandinCamaçari,nearthenorth-easterncityofSalvador,hostinnovationcentres(pilotplantsandlaboratories).BraskemalsohasaPVCresearchcentreinSãoPauloandpartnershipswithacademicinstitutesanduniversitiesathomeandabroad,suchaswithGainesville’sUniversityofFlorida,theUniversityofMassachusettsandtheDutchPolymerinstitutes.Itsinvestmentssofarsuggestthatthecompanymaywellfulfilalong-statedaspirationtobeaworldleaderinbiopolymers.
Back�to�school
Onewaytopromoteinnovationisthroughbusinessco-operationwithuniversitiesandacademicinstitutes.Theevidencetodateseemsreasonablypositive.OfsurveyrespondentswhoseBrazil-basedoperationsalreadyworkwithlocaluniversities,60%saytherelationshiphasbeen
“positive”and12%“verypositive”,comparedwithlessthanonequarter(23%)whosaythatsuchco-operation“failedtoliveupwiththeirexpectations”orwas“veryunsuccessful”(5%).Brazilian-basedcompanieswouldappeartogettheroughendofthedeal(orareperhapstoooptimistic),asalmostonethird(32%)reportthatsuchco-operation“failedtoliveuptoexpectations”.
How�would�you�characterise�co-operation�between�your�Brazilian�operations�and�local�universities/academic�institutes?
(%�of�respondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
ExamplesofsuccessincludethelocalsubsidiaryofGeneralMotorswhichhostsaresearchanddevelopmentcentrethatworkscloselywithSãoPauloUniversity’sengineeringschool.Vale,theminingcompany,hasalsoinvestedtimeandenergytoinfluencethecurriculumofuniversitiessotheytrainengineersinmining,railwayandportlogistics.
Very positive
Positive
Failed to live up to expectations
Very unsuccessful
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
60%
12%
23%
5%
9%
�Case�study��SAP�Labs:�Software�in�Brazil�
SAP,aglobalsoftwaregiant,launchedanewprogrammein2009thatinvolvesuniversitiesinitsinnovationprocessfromitsBrazilianbase,inSãoLeopoldoinsouthernBrazil.ItsetupitsresearchlaboratorywithinthelocalUnisinosUniversity,whichrecentlylaunchednewcourses(ITandEnglish,andrenewableenergysources)asaresultofSAP’sengagement.Groupsofbetween10to20selectedstudentsfromvariousuniversitiesfollowatwo-yearprogrammeatSAP,whichfocusedontopicsrelevanttoBrazil’sfutureneeds.Theseinclude:
E e-health(suchaselectronicdatamanagementofhealthrecordstoeasetheexchangeofinformationalongthehealthchain,fromlocaldoctorstohospitalsandchemists,aswellasintegrationamonghospitals);
E e-energy(efficientresourcemanagement);
E infrastructureandmobility(Brazilhasaseriesofchallengesaheadofthe2014footballWorldCupandthe2016SummerOlympicsinRiodeJaneiro);
E riskmanagementandsafety(sharinginformationamongvariousagenciesandvictimsofaccidentsandnaturaldisasters);and
E supportingsmallandmicrobusinessesthroughthedevelopmentofdedicatedsoftware.
Localissues“willinfluencethesoftwarethatwewillbedeveloping,”saysErwinRezelman,presidentofSAPLabs.TheindustrialstandardmaystillcomefromtheUSorChina,but“re-engineeringmaycomeoutofBrazil,”hesays.Moreover,insomeITsectorswhereBrazilismostadvanced,suchase-banking,“maybethestandardshouldcomeoutofBrazil”.MrRezelmansaysresearchmodellingisduetostartattheendof2010andthewholeprocessisexpectedtotakeuptofiveyears.
22
III.�Brazilians�abroad�
Making�a�name�for�themselves
Brazil’svoiceontheworldstageisbeingheardmoreloudlyandmoreoftennowadays.WhilerelationswiththeUSremainstrong,BrazilisshiftingfocustootherLatinAmericancountries,ChinaandAfrica.Ithasraiseditsprofilewithmoremilitaryspending(albeitfromaminisculebase),astrategicdefenceagreementwithFrance,followingmilitaryprocurementcontracts,anddiplomaticforaysintotheMiddleEast.
ButitisBrazil’sappealtoforeigninvestorsandtherecentboldnessofitsowncompaniesabroadthatisgivingsubstancetoitsglobalambitions.Mostoftheworld’s100largestmultinationalcompaniesareoperatinginthecountry:annualforeigndirectinvestment(FDI)inflowsgrewfromamere$10bnin1996topeakat$45bnin2008,
beforefallingbackto$26bnin2009,pushingtotalFDIstockto$320bn,andmakingBrazilthesecond-largestemergingmarketrecipientofFDI,afterChina.WhiletraditionallyFDIhascomefromtheUSandEurope,especiallySpain,newplayersfromMexico,ColombiaandChile,areshowinginteresttoo.
PerhapsmoreremarkablethantheinrushofFDI,aretheinternationalacquisitionsandinvestmentbeingmadebyBrazilianmultinationals–somethingthatwasnotalwaysencouragedbypastgovernments.ThepurchasebyValeofIncoin2006,forexample,sentoutbounddirectinvestmentthatyearsoaringtoover$28bn(althoughithassubsequentlyfallenbacksubstantially).Suchventureshavebeenpropelledinpartbycheapfinancingfromthestate-owneddevelopmentbankBNDES,whichinvestedover$5bninthepastfiveyearstohelpBraziliancompaniesexpandabroad.Arelativelystrongcurrencyhasalsohelped.
Foreign�direct�investment
�� 2005a� 2006a� 2007a� 2008a� 2009a� 2010b� 2011b� 2012b� 2013b� 2014b
Foreign�direct�investment�(US$�bn)
Inwarddirect 15.1 18.8 34.6 45.1 25.9 30.0 35.0 40.0 42.0 45.0investment
Inwarddirect 1.7 1.7 2.5 2.8 1.6 1.6 1.7 1.9 1.9 1.9investment(%ofGDP)
Inwarddirect 10.7 10.5 14.5 14.7 9.9 8.5 8.9 9.5 9.0 8.8investment(%ofgrossfixedinvestment)
Outwarddirect -2.5 -28.2 -7.1 -20.5 10.1 -6.0 -5.0 -5.5 -6.1 -6.7investment
Netforeigndirect 12.6 -9.4 27.5 24.6 36.0 24.0 30.0 34.5 36.0 38.3investment
Stockofforeigndirect 195.6 214.3 248.9 294.0 319.9 349.9 384.9 424.9 466.9 511.9investment
Stockofforeigndirect 1,062 1,148 1,315 1,532 1,646 1,778 1,932 2,108 2,289 2,478investmentperhead(US$)
Stockofforeigndirect 22.2 19.7 18.2 17.9 20.3 18.2 19.0 20.3 21.2 22.1investment(%ofGDP)
Shareofworldinward 1.59 1.51 1.79 3.00 2.89 2.77 2.89 2.94 2.77 2.92directinvestmentflows(%)
Shareofworldinward 2.04 1.82c 1.69c 2.04c 2.08c 2.12 2.18 2.23 2.27 2.32directinvestmentstock(%)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
23
Afocuson“South-South”relations,aspartofageneralpolicyoftradediversification,isperhapsoneofthebiggestchangesinBraziliantradepolicyunderPresidentLula.Chinahasbecomeitslargestexportandimportpartner,andtheshareoftradewiththerestofLatinAmerica,otherAsiancountries,theMiddleEastandAfricahasalsoincreased.
Butcompetingeffectivelyabroadalsorequireswiderbrandrecognition.AnelitegroupofBrazil’sinternationalplayershavealreadyachievedthisrecognition.AswellasVale,bignamesrangefromthefashionablesandalsofHavaianastoaircraftsofEmbraer.State-ownedoilgroup,Petrobras,andmeatpackersJBSandMarfrighavelaunchedaggressiveacquisitionsintheUS.AccordingtoFundaçãoDomCabralbusinessschool,JBSisnowthemostinternationalBraziliancompany,withfour-fifthsofitssalesabroad.
Other,lesser-knowngroupsarealsomakingheadway,suchasGerdau,asteelmaker,andNatura,acosmeticsmanufacturer.Theworld’sbankingsectorwillsoonhearmoreofstate-ownedBancodoBrasilandItaúUnibanco,bothofwhichareplanningsignificantinternationalexpansion.AtypicaljourneyofcorporateexpansionbynewcompaniesisbeingtakenbyTotus,asoftwarecompanythattargetssmallandmedium-sizedbusinesses.Havingemergedstrongerfromfierceconsolidationinitsdomesticmarket,whereithadbuiltastrongbrand,itisnowlookingtoexpandelsewhereinLatinAmerica,andwillgofurtherafieldintime.Theglobalfinancialcrisismayhavedelayedsomeforeignventures,butstrongdomesticgrowth,healthyprofits,andlowerassetspricesabroadmeanthatforeignmarketsarebeckoning.
ThedevelopmentofBrazil’sagriculturesectorinparticularhasprovidedfertilegroundfortwo-wayinternationalexpansion.Whiletheworld’sleadingfoodgroupsareplantingrootsinthecountryinanticipationof40%growthinthesectoroverthecomingdecade,accordingtoajointUNandOECDreport,innovationsinagronomyhavebeenapassportforBrazilianstoenternewmarkets,particularlyinAfrica.
“WhathasbeenachievedintheBraziliancerradoisapplicabletotheAfricansavannah,”saysEliseuAlves,aformerpresidentofEmbrapa,astateagronomyagency.Thesolutiontoglobalfoodsecurityis“creatingtechnologyandinvestinginresearch”,hesays.BrazilianscientistsfromthestateofMinasGeraisarealsovisitingAngolaandMozambique,twoPortuguese-speakingcountries,tosupporttechnologydevelopment.EmbrapaopenedaregionalbaseinGhanain2008,andBNDESisfinancingBrazil-basedcompaniestoexporttractorsandothermachinerytoAfrica.
Brand�new
Butbeyondthecharmedcircleandthedynamicnewcomers,BrazilianbrandsstilllacktheinternationaldrawoftheirWesterncounterparts,thoughitssizeabledomesticmarketmitigatessomeoftheurgencyofoverseasexpansion.Thisisreflectedinoursurvey,inwhich84%ofrespondentssaythatBrazilianbrandnamesareeithernotwellrecognisedornothighlyregardedabroad.
Only3%ofUS-basedrespondentsthinkthatBrazilianbrandsarebothrecognisedandhighlyregarded.However,theperceptionofBrazilianbrandsisdifferentamongChina-basedexecutives,withalmostonequarterofthoserespondents(24%)declaringawarmattitudetoBrazilianproducts.
ThismightbewhyBraziliancompaniesfeeltheyhavemoreofanadvantage(oratleastlessofadisadvantage)whenoperatinginotheremergingmarketssuchasChina.Andexecutivesareclearlyalerttothistrend.Chinaisexpectedtobecomea“primarytradingpartnerwithBrazilinthenextthreeyears”,accordingto63%ofrespondents,comparedwith51%whopointtotheUSand49%toLatinAmerica.Similarly,Braziliancompaniesseeopportunitiesforacquisitionsinotheremergingmarkets,with66%pointingtointerestinfirmselsewhereonthecontinent,comparedwith43%focusingonUScompanies,and31%lookingtoChina.
24
China-Brazil�trade:�A�raw�deal
ThespectaculargrowthofSino-BraziliantradeinrecentyearsisoneoftheclearestindicatorsofBrazil’ssuccessintappingintothedynamisimofemergingAsia.Itisnothardtoseewhy.China’sinsatiabledemandforrawmaterialsismatchedbyBrazil’swillingnessandabilitytosupplythem.
CommoditiesdominatesalestoChina,ofwhichironoreandsoyabeanscomprisedtwothirdsofthetotal.AstheglobalcommoditiesboominthelatterpartofthedecadesentpricesofBrazil’smainexportproductsrocketing,bilateraltradewithChinahasleaptbymorethan50%since2007,topping$36bninboth2008and2009,andprotectingBrazil’stradefromtheworstoftheglobalfinancialturmoil.ChinabecameBrazil’smaintradingpartner,overtakingtheUS(importsofwhichfromBrazilplummetedby43%in2009)andArgentina.Allthewhile,importsofChinesemanufacturedgoodsdeclinedby20%,resultinginabilateraltradesurplusforBrazilof$4.3bn.
Sowhat’snottolikeabouttherelationship,fromBrazil’sperspective?ForsomeBrazilianmanufacturerswithglobalambitions,thestoryisaboutmorethanthecommoditytrade–andforthemitisnotalwaysahappyone.Brazilhasfoundithardtoexportvalue-addedproductstoChina.Embraer,anaircraftmanufacturer,setupitsjointventurewithaChinesestate-ownedcompanysevenyearsago–arequirementforaccessingthemarket–openingaplantinHarbin,inChina’sNorthEast.Sofar,70aircrafthavebeenproducedforChineseclientsand30morearetobedeliveredshortly(including25modelsimportedfromBrazil).
TheChineseauthorities,however,announcedthattheChineseaircraftindustrywouldstartmanufacturingitsownregionaljetswithoutthehelpofEmbraer.ItwasadifficultsituationfortheBrazilianfirm,whicharguesthatitsChineseplantonlyhasenoughworktolastuntilthestartof2011.IthasaskedtheauthoritiesforalicencetomanufactureitslargerEmbraer190locally,andannouncedthatitwassettingupamaintenancecentreinBeijing.“ThecreationofEmbraerChinaTechnicalServicesshowsourlong-termcommitmentandconfidenceinthegrowingChineseaviationmarket,”saysGuanDongyuan,presidentofEmbraer’sChinesesubsidiary.Nevertheless,thefutureofEmbraer’smanufacturingactivitiesinChinamaynowdependonpoliticalanddiplomaticarrangementstosmooththewayforhighervalueinvestments.
The�other�side�of�the�coin
WhileEmbraerpondersitsfutureinChina,thelatterhasunveiledsomeofitsownambitiousplansforBrazil:
E ChinaPetroleumCorporation(Sinopec)hassignalleditsintentiontograntnewloanstoPetrobras,theBrazilianoilcompany,towhichitlent$10bnlastyearinreturnforaguaranteedoilsupply.SinopecmayalsobuystakesintwoPetrobrasoilfieldsinnorthernBrazilandarefineryinRiodeJaneiro(Comperj).Co-operationintransportandfertilisersarealsobeingconsidered.
E WuhanIronandSteelCorporation(Wisco)intendstosetupa$5bnsteelplantnearRiodeJaneirointhenewAçuport,currentlybeingbuiltbyEBX,aholdingcompanyownedbyEikeBatista,alocalbillionaire.Thenewportandplantarescheduledtoopenby2013.Wiscowilltakea70%stakeinthenewplant,whichwillhaveannualcapacityof5mtonnesofsteel.TheChinesegovernmentsaysitwilleventuallyimportsteel(ratherthanironore)fromBrazil.
E Wiscoinvested$354minMMX,aRiodeJaneiromininggroupownedbyMrBatista,earlierthisyear.TwoothermineshavealsobeensoldbyVotorantimandItaminastoChinesecompanies.
E TheChineseDevelopmentBankintendstogranta$1bnloantoOi,theBraziliantelecommunicationscompany,tobuyChineseequipment.
25
Which�markets�will�become�the�primary�trading�partners�with�Brazil�in�the�next�three�years?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
Where�do�you�envision�an�increase�in�acquisitions�by�Brazilian�companies�in�the�next�three�years?
(%ofrespondents)
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit.
Other Latin America.
The US.
Western Europe.
Central/Eastern Europe.
China.
India.
Rest of Asia.
Middle-East.
Africa.
Other, please specify.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
49%
51%
22%
10%
12%
11%
12%
25%
63%
1%
Other Latin America.
The US.
Western Europe.
Central/Eastern Europe.
China.
India.
Rest of Asia.
Middle-East.
Africa.
Other, please specify.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
66%
43%
23%
14%
21%
9%
16%
15%
31%
3%
ThatBraziliancompaniesareeyeingtheChinesemarketis,inonesense,onlytobeexpected.Companiesgowherethereisgrowth.Butonanotherlevel,thisrepresentsamajorshiftinthebalanceofeconomicpower.Emergingmarketcompanies,products,managersandinnovationsmayfindmoreincommonwithoneanotherthanmerelyadoptingthebusinessnormsandideasthatemanatefromtheUS,EuropeorJapan.
Ofcourseotheremergingmarketsdonotalwaysmakeperfectallies:companieslikeEmbraerhaveexperiencedtheclassicdilemmaofWesterninvestorsinChina,forcedintoalocaljointventurethatputsatrisktheirintellectualproperty.Yet,asglobalisationresumesitsonwardmarchfollowingtheupheavalsoftheeconomicdownturn,aneweraofglobalrelationshipsmaybecharacterisedmorebyabattleforscarceresources,state-ledinvestmentstrategies,andaflairfordealinginopaquebusinessenvironments,thanthroughthemarket-ledorthodoxiesofthepast.AndthesetrendswouldappeartoplaytoBrazil’sownstrengthsandtraditions.
26
Conclusion:Thebeginningofthefuture
Braziltodayseemsbetterplacedthanevertodisposeofitsfrustrating,ifclichéd,moniker“thecountryofthefuture”.Adecadeofmacroeconomicprudencehasgiventheeconomyasturdyplatformforinvestment,growthandforeignexpansion,andbusinesseshavefactoredthischangeintotheirlong-termstrategies.Importantly,executivesaresanguineaboutthe2010presidentialelectionandtheendoftheLulaera,assuming,astheydo,thatadecadeofmacroeconomicstabilitywillsimplybemaintained.ButBrazilisnotquitethereyet.Insomerespects,enlightenedeconomicpolicyistheeasypartoftransition.
Asthisreporthasshown,apooreducationsystemwillleavethecountryshortofskillsformanyyearstocome;andfillingpotholedroads,buildingraillinksandlayingbroadbandcablecantakeadecadeormore.Italsotakes
alongtimeforcompaniestobuildupabrandthatissufficientlywellknowntoopenforeigndoors.SalestoChinamaybebooming,butBrazilhasyettomovebeyondtherelativelyeasytaskofsupplyingcommoditiestoacustomerthatisdesperatetobuy.
Nevertheless,avirtuouscircleisturning.Soundpoliciesandagrowingdomesticmarkethaveattractedforeignmoney,know-how,newskillsandtechnologies,andunleashedtheconsiderablepent-upenergyoflocalbusinessbothathomeandabroad.This,inturn,willhelptofundinvestmentintoeducationandinfrastructure,whichwillattractmoreinvestmentandsustainablegrowth.That,atleast,isthetheory,andonBrazil’scurrenttrajectorythereisnoreasontothinkitcannotbeachieved.Itwilltakemanyyears,butifrecentsuccessesareanyguide,theprizewillbeworththeeffort.
27
28