Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a...
Transcript of Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a...
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
1/16
MICROCREATIVITY:VOCAL RELEASESIN CAUDAAS STYLISTICMARKS IN SARDINIANA TENORE SINGING
PAOLO BRAVI
Introduction
The a tenore song is a genre of multipart vocal singing practiced in thecentral area of Sardinia, mostly in the sub-regions Barbagia and Baronia,
by singers with various degrees of specialization on various occasions,among which are the accompaniment of poetry contests and dancing. Athorough introduction to the a tenoresong has recently been published as
part of theEnciclopedia della musica sarda(Casu and Lutzu 2012-2013):
Pilosu 2012a and 2012b.The four male voices comprising an a tenorechoir are usually calledbassu, contra, boghe and mesu boghe (from the lowest to the highestvoice). Among them, the role of the bogheis distinct from that of the otherthree: he sings the verbal text (usually poetry in Sardinian language),whereas the other three parts provide a vocal accompaniment usingnonsense syllables. The two lower parts of the accompaniment choir, thebassuand the contra, use characteristic guttural voices, which are obtainedthrough a particular constriction of the laryngeal muscles. In the case of
the bassu, this entails the doubling of the period, i.e. the production of anote one octave below the one that would be produced in modal voice(Bailly, Henrich, Pelorson 2010).
The intervention of the three voices of accompaniment is realized insections called corfos(sing. corfu). In the corfosthe three accompanying
parts of the tenorebassu (plural: bassos), contra (plural: contras) andmesu boghe (plural: mesu boghes)sing together, though not always in ahomorhythmic way, sometimes along with the soloist part, the boghe.Their melodic profiles may vary, particularly as far as the mesu bogheand
the contraparts are concerned, but the most common disposition of thevoices, found at the end of each corfu, is represented in fig. 1.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
2/16
Paolo Bravi 195
Fig. 1. The usual disposition of the voices in the a tenoresongs at the end of thesections called corfos.
2. Materials and method
The topic of the analysis presented here is a stylistic feature that can beobserved in some singers at the end of the corfos, i. e. an emphasis of theclosure created by the pronunciation of a nasal (usually [m]- or [n]-like)sound, sometimes preceded by a glottal stop and/or a glottal frication afterthe last vowel of the corfu.
Io ci gioco con questo elemento [lenfatizzazione della chiusura del corfu]. un po come lasciare limpronta della tua voce. Ed molto udibile, gliascoltatori lo notano, e te lo chiedono: Ma che cos questa cosa che fatealla fine del canto? Si sente questo rilascio, come se fosse quasi il
rinculo proprio della pressione sonora. un effetto che nellascoltatore molto evidente. (Bandinu 2012)
I play with this element [the emphasis on corfuclosure]. It is like leavinga footprint of your own voice. And it is clearly audible, the listenersperceive it, and they ask you about it: What is that thing that you do at theend of the singing? One hears this release..., it is just like a recoil of thesound pressure. It is an effect that is clearly evident to the listener.
An analysis has been carried out on the three accompaniment voices of
three a tenorechoirs from different Sardinian villages, Orotelli, Orune andSiniscola (see fig. 2). The villages designations are written in the graphs
below as orot, orun and sini and the three parts of the choir arelabelled as bs (bassu), co (contra) and mb (mesu boghe). Thesingers voices were recorded in a recording studio as separate tracks.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
3/16
Microcreativity196
Fig. 2. On the left: map showing the distribution of a tenorechoirs in the villagesof Sardinia (the original map is taken from Pilosu 2012a: 29). On the right: thenine singers of the recordings, placed on the basis of their provenance and singingrole: bassu, contra, mesu boghe, referred to as BS, CO and MB. They areFrancesco Luigi Podda (BS), Pino Ortu (CO) and Massimiliano Pusceddu (MB),from Orotelli; Pietro Mula (BS), Peppinu Cidda (CO) and Piero Cidda (MB), fromOrune; Stefano Spanu (BS), Domenico Carta (CO) and Giovanni Mele (MB), from
Siniscola.
The analysis was carried out using the software Praat (Boersma andWeenink, 2011) on a corpus of 105 (35 closures x 3 voices) audiofragments identified and extracted on the basis of a two-step procedureconsisting firstly of a preliminary manual segmentation based on
perceptual criteria and secondly on the automatic detection of intensity fall(arbitrarily set at < 40 dB) as the end point of the extracted audio fragment(fig. 3).
SINISCOLA
ORUNE
OROTELLI
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
4/16
Paolo Bravi 197
Fig. 3. The two phases of the segmentation and annotation of the corfosreleases.Each part of the accompaniment choir (bassu, contra, mesu boghe) was annotatedon a couple of tiers: in the upper one the segmentation was performed manually(the interval in this tier is labelled r); in the lower one the end boundary isreplaced via an automatic procedure based on the detection of the falling of theintensity curve below 40 dB (the interval in this tier is labelled r2). In thisexample, the part under observation is that of the contra.
3. AnalysisThe analysis took into consideration four acoustic features in the closureof the corfos, that is pitch, intensity, spectrum and duration, and thestatistics were obtained by means of the software R (RDCT 2012). Thetopic has also been discussed with some a tenoresingers. They are OmarBandinu, bassu of the tenore group Mialinu Pira from Bitti, DomenicoCarta and Luigi Carta, contrasfrom Siniscola, Stefano Frau, contraof thetenoregroup Osana from Orosei and the Cuncordu Vramentu of Fonni.The research, based on the integration of fieldwork and documents
analysis, shares the principles and method described and discussed inBravi, 2012.
3.1Pitch
In some singers, the pitch profile exhibits a characteristic high jump inthe voiced part of the corfu release. An analysis of this acoustic featurewas carried out by measuring the difference in semitones from the pitch
before the release and the maximum pitch in the release, as shown in fig.
4.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
5/16
Microcreativity198
Fig. 4. The measure of the high jump, a feature observable in many corfosreleases.
As figure 5 shows, the clearest difference in this case is regarding thebehavior of the bassosand those of the other two voices. The high-jumpis very strong in the bassos; particularly in two of them, and the pitch
jump usually exceeds the octave due to the release of the laryngealconstriction which causes the doubling of the period. As far as the voiceswhich do not exhibit period doubling are concerned, the contra ofSiniscola displays the highest pitch jumps, which correspond to a clear andstrong emphasis on the closure of the corfu, whereas no high-jump is
present in the mesu boghes.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
6/16
Paolo Bravi 199
Role of the singer
Semitones
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
bs co mb
orot
bs co mb
orun
bs co mb
sini
Fig. 5. Distribution of the pitch jumps in the releases, per village and part.
Generally speaking, the high-jump in the release therefore seems tobe a characteristic of guttural voices, particularly strong in the bassos,andweaker or absent in the higher voices, the contras and the mesu boghes.
A second feature of the pitch profile in the release is its descent in itsfinal part, which has been measured as the difference (in semitones) fromthe maximum pitch level and the pitch level at the end of the release (seefig. 6). In this case, no clear trend appears as far as the different kinds ofvoice are concerned, whereas a strong lowering of the pitch in the final
part of the release seems to be an individual characteristic of the mesubogheof Orune (see fig. 7).
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
7/16
Microcreativity200
Fig. 6. The measure of the pitch descent in the corfosreleases.
Role of the singer
Semitones
0
5
10
15
20
bs co mb
orot
bs co mb
orun
bs co mb
sini
Fig. 7. Distribution of the pitch descents in the corfosreleases, per village and part.
3.2 Intensity
As far as intensity is concerned, the presence or the absence of a hump inthe intensity curve1 of the releases is a feature which reveals either astrong or a smooth emphasis in the closure of the corfu(see fig. 8). In thiscase, the analysis shows that humps are common everywhere, but that theabsence of humps is less frequent in the bassos than in the other voices(fig. 9).
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
8/16
Paolo Bravi 201
Fig. 8. The intensity curve in the corfurelease may (or may not) show a hump,
i.e. may reach its maximum level after the release start point.
Fig. 9. Distribution of corfosreleases with and without humps in their intensity
curves, per part.
3.3 Spectrum
The emphasis on the closure of corfu sometimes occurs through theinsertion of a fricative section which precedes the final nasal release. Thisfriction is in some cases clearly visible in the spectrogram, whererelatively strong energy bands appear in the higher part of the spectrumabove 5 kHz (see fig. 10).
bs co mb
occ
orrences
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
presence of a hump
absence of a hump
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
9/16
Microcreativity202
Fig. 10. An example of a fricative section at the beginning of a corfurelease. Therounded rectangle displays the presence of energy bands in the upper part of thespectrogram.
The perceptual relevance of the friction is related to both its strengthand its duration. For this reason, the analysis has taken into account thespectral evolution over time and was carried out via the measure of the
band energy difference (low band: 0-5 kHz, high band: 5-24 kHz) in fivesuccessive spectral slices2.
The difference is lower in the bassos than in the higher voices,particularly in the first spectra. This acoustic feature is related to a strongerfriction in the lowest voices (fig. 11, upper panel). At a keener level ofinvestigation, some differences appear between the three bass voices,
particularly between the bassuof Orotelli and that of Siniscola in the firstspectra (fig. 11, lower panel).
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
10/16
Paolo Bravi 203
Fig. 11. Distribution of energy bands (0-5 / 5-20 kHz) in five subsequent spectra
after the corfosreleases (time step = 0.02 s.). Upper panel: per poet; lower panel:
bassos, per village.
3.4Time
Some acoustic features of the release concern the time dimension. Two
factors have been evaluated in this regard: the overall duration of the
release and the delay of each voices release start in relation to the voice
which starts the release first. Release duration analysis partly provides
countertrend results compared to those observed so far. The bassos
release usually has a shorter duration than that of the other voices. As far
as the difference between choirs is concerned, durations are usually longer
in all three parts of the Siniscola choir than in the other choirs (see fig. 12,left panel). The delay of the release start shows different behaviors in the
three choirs. In the Orotelli choir, the voice which starts the closure first is
the mesu boghe; in the Orune choir it is the contra, and in the Siniscola
Role of the singer
Differenceofenergybands(0-5/
5-20kHz)
-50
-40
-30
-20
bs co mb
slice
bs co mb
slice
bs co mb
slice
bs co mb
slice
bs co mb
slice
Bassu
Difference
ofebergybands(0-5
/5-20
kHz)
-40
-35
-30
-25
-20
-15
orot orun sini
slice
orot orun sini
slice
orot orun sini
slice
orot orun sini
slice
orot orun sini
slice
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
11/16
Microcreativity204
choir no clear difference between the three parts is present (see fig. 12,
right panel).
In this respect, the Orotelli choir seems to reflect an idea expressed bysome a tenoresingers, like those of the Cuncordu Vramentu of Fonni, whosay:
Deve uscire un unico suono da bassu e contra, non si deve distinguere tra
il basso e la contra. In poche parole, il suono deve essere unico. Invece la
mezza voce pu sganciarsi un po di pi perch guida il tenore e aiuta la
voce al tono anche La mezza voce guida il tenore, una seconda voce,
diciamo.(Interview with the Cuncordu Vramentu of Fonni, in Lutzu 2003)
Bassu and contra should make up one sound; one should not distinguishbetween bassu and contra. In other words, there should be one sound.
Instead, the mesu boghemay get away a little more because he leads the
tenore and helps the boghein the pitch as well The mesu bogheleads the
tenore, it is like a second boghe, say.
Instead, the Orune choir seems to share the idea (and the singing
behavior) maintained by two contrasof different generations of Siniscola,
Luigi and Domenico Carta, according to whom: [DC] Sa chi cumandat
sonande est sempre sa contra [LC] Certu! Est sa contra che cumandat,
su bassu si depet ponnere afatu a sa contra, ca sa contra iscurtat sa oche.[[DC] The one who is in command is always the contra [LC] Of course!
The one who commands is the contra, the bassushould follow the contra,
as the contra listens to the boghe.] (Domenico and Luigi Carta 2011)
Lastly, the behavior of the Siniscola choir, at least in the recording
analyzed here, seems to obey a third principle on the topic advocated by
Omar Bandinu, i.e. that there is no fixed voice with a lead role within the
accompaniment choir.
In questi casi, c una voce che anticipa le altre e quindi le guida []? -Mah, secondo me no. Secondo me qua vige la totale libert dei cantori,
non c una voce che in qualche modo d, come dire, il La, che guida le
altre nella produzione di questo espediente della voce.(Bandinu 2012)
In these cases, is there a voice which anticipates the others, and therefore
guides them? In my opinion there is not. To me the singers are completely
free here, there is no voice which somehow guides the others in the
production of this vocal device.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
12/16
Paolo Bravi 205
orot_bs
orot_co
orot_mb
orun_bs
orun_co
orun_mb
sini_bs
sini_co
sini_mb
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.40
0.45
0.50
0.55
DURATION
Time(s)
orot_bs
orot_co
orot_mb
orun_bs
orun_co
orun_mb
sini_bs
sini_co
sini_mb
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
START DELAY
Time(s)
Fig. 12. Left panel: distribution of release durations; right panel: delay of the
release start with respect to the voice which starts the release first.
4. Conclusion
Upon closer inspection of the emphasis of the closure of the corfos,
what is seemingly a minor characteristic of singing and is usually
neglected as a specific musical or expressive element in the vocal
accompaniment turned out to be an interesting trait of the performative
styles in a tenoresongs. A first ethnographic survey devoted to the topic
and the results of the analysis carried out on some of its acoustic features
allow some preliminary hypotheses on the whole matter.
First, there is a consistency, at least to a certain degree, in the
performances of each singer and sometimes of the choirs. The release
technique may be considered a part of the individual or collective style of
the accompaniment voices. As a feature shared within the choirs, anemphasised release may be considered a characteristic which can
distinguish different groups and different singing styles:
La /m/ noi la usiamo fra un corfue l'altro per non chiudere direttamente in
[a]. Invece di fare [a], fai [am] [] Noi indirizziamo dalla /a/ alla /m/,
quella una particolarit del modo di cantare nostro, del nostro tenore, per
indirizzare verso la chiusura (Frau 2011)
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
13/16
Microcreativity206
We use /m/ between one corfuand another in order not to close directly in
[a]. Instead of doing [a], you do [am][]. We go from /a/ to /m/, this is a
peculiarity of our way of singing, of our tenore, for approaching the
closure
As an individual feature, the presence of the emphasis can be
unintentional, just a physiological side-effect of the release of the
laryngeal muscles, as Domenico Carta says:
Quello [lenfasi della chiusura del corfu] ti viene cos, non lu aches
apposta. Ti enet gai, dae su sfortzu chi aches, poi comente [finisce]: [m].
Ma no este unu difetu sicuramente cussu, este una cosa chi ti enit comente
finis de cantare che sa gula si serrat, e s'intendet, in su microfono Ma tudici che involontario? S, este involontariu. Poi, calincunu bi l'achet a
lu mantenere e no lu achet. Jeo mi essit a me, per esempiu, no est che lu
acu aposta, Bi nd'at chi l'achene a serrare bene, lu mantenene e no
s'intendet nudda.(Carta, Domenico 2011).
This [the emphasis on the corfuclosure] comes naturally, you dont do it
on purpose. It comes from the effort that you make, and when it [ends]:
[m]. But it certainly isnt a mistake, it is something that happens when you
finish singing and your throat seals, and you can hear it through the
microphone But are you saying that it is not done deliberately? Yes, itis involuntary. Then somebody manages to hold it back and doesnt do it.
I it happens to me, for example, its not that I do it on purpose. There are
people who manage to close well, who keep it closed, and one cannot hear
anything.
In other cases, self-assertion may play an important role in choosing
whether to emphasize the corfu closure or not, or how to do it, as there are
different ways to do it in terms of their acoustic features. Vocal releases
show performers individuality as other melodic, timbral or rhythmic traits
do. As Omar Bandinu says: ha un peso rilevante anche la propria auto-affermazione [che si realizza] attraverso questa caratterizzazione finale
[self-assertion [which can be obtained] by means of this characterization in
the final part has significant weight too]. (Bandinu 2012).
Second, the lower voices usually exhibit a more pronounced emphasis on
the closure. The release of laryngeal tension can be emphasised in a
stronger way in these kinds of voice than in modal ones.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
14/16
Paolo Bravi 207
Third, the emphasis on the closure may be a way to stress the rhythmicdimension of the song, to bring attention to the strength of the choir
accompaniment, to enhance the compactness of the ensemble and, aspointed out by Omar Bandinu, to make a contribution to the emotional
efficacy of the song. [lenfasi nella chiusura del corfu] serve anche
per caricare proprio emotivamente il canto, anche per spingere di pi il
solista a dare una maggiore, come dire, carica emotiva al canto. [
[emphasis on corfuclosure] also serves to charge the singing emotionally,
and to give the soloist a lift to provide a stronger emotional charge to the
song.] (Bandinu 2012)In oral and traditional musical genres like the a tenore song, where
many primary stylistic features are (pre-)defined by specific and well-
known village fashions, the customization of the song is often carried by
the singers by means of low-level variations of their village model. Thesingers creativity is usually expressed not in terms of the creation of
completely new melodies or the invention of rhythmic and harmonic
innovative structures, but as small and progressive changes of what each
singer has learned by listening to and practicing with others, normally in
the first years of his life. Existing repertories are subjected to a moderateelaboration as far as individual experiences are concerned and to a slow
evolution as far as diachronic change is concerned.
Oral creativity may be seen best, in cases like this, through a
microscope, be it a careful listening or a fine-grained analysis. There is
no genius, no chosen soul, no revolutionary eccentric or hypersensitive
talent at work here, only honest, gifted, pernickety craftsmen of their ownvoices. Their vocal creations have no grandeur, no vanity, no vulgarity, no
blatant appearance. I think that we may refer to them as microcreativity:
something which can be discovered and, if present, appreciated through
work, experience and practice.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
15/16
Microcreativity208
In particular, the treatment of the closure of the corfosin the a tenore
song is, in terms of its effect, no more than an acoustic device: a modest
epithetic levis immutatioof the standard corfu. In a way, it is close to thezero-degree of microcreativity. And, of course, it is easy to fail torecognize any creativity in it altogether, as we are the sons and daughters
of a writing-based culture and we are proneconsciously or inadvertently
to disregard or at least underestimate aspects of the performative style
which do not fit into our familiar staff notation.
I am aware of the potential damage that the (mis-)use of the word
microcreativity may cause. The concept of microcreativity is logically
opposed to that of macrocreativity. Based on that, the concept of
microcreativity might be considered as the weak side of creativity, as a
sort of poor or diminished form of it, according to the common view. In
recent times, the virtues and miracles of microbiology, minimalist art and
nanotechnologies might have changed the usual understanding of theimplications of the two prefixes micro and macro which equate them
with low- and high value. Perhaps they have even set a new benchmark in
this regard, and have started to form a different sensibility. But, to be sure
not to be misunderstood, I prefer to state explicitly that in my view
creativity is also present in this case, and that we have to think of it as
creativity in its own right.
References
Bandinu, Omar. 2012. Interview with Paolo Bravi. Cagliari, Sardinia,
Italy. 17 April.
Bailly, Lucie and Natalie Henrich, Xavier Pelorson. 2010. Vocal fold and
ventricular fold vibration in period-doubling phonation: Physiological
description and aerodynamic modeling. Journal of the Acoustical
Society of America. Vol. 127(5).3212-3222.
http://asadl.org/jasa/search?sortby=newestdate&q=j+acoust+soc+am.+vol+127+%285%29&faceted=faceted&searchzone=1&alias=/jasa&dis
playid=ASA&key=JASMAN&conditions=j+acoust+soc+am.+vol+127+%285%29article&page=8.
Boersma, Paul, and David Weenink. 2011. Praat: doing phonetics by
computer.http://www.fon.hum.uva.nl/praat/.
Bravi, Paolo. 2012. "The practice of ornamentation in the multipart vocal
music of Southern Sardinia. A bifocal perspective in ethnomusicological
analysis." In Multipart music: a specific mode of musical thinking,
expressive behaviour and sound, a cura di Ignazio Macchiarella, 467-490. Udine: Nota, 2012.
-
7/25/2019 Bravi, Paolo (2013) "Microcreativity. Vocal releases in cauda as stylistic marks in the Sardinian a tenore singing"
16/16
Paolo Bravi 209
Carta, Domenico and Luigi Carta. 2011. Interview with Paolo Bravi.
Siniscola, Sardinia, Italy. 22 July.
Casu, Francesco and Marco Lutzu. 2012-[c.s.].Enciclopedia della musicasarda. Voll. 1-16.Cagliari: Unione Sarda.Frau, Stefano. 2011. Interview with Paolo Bravi. Orosei, Sardinia, Italy.
24 September.
Lutzu, Marco. 2003. Tenores. Vol. Suoni di un'isola, vol. 1. CD-Rom.
Cagliari: Live Studio.
Pilosu, Sebastiano. 2012a.Enciclopedia della musica sarda. Vol. 1: Canto
a tenore.Casu, Francesco and Marco Lutzu, eds. Cagliari: L'Unione
Sarda.
. 2012b.Enciclopedia della musica sarda. Vol. 2: Canto a tenore.Casu,
Francesco and Marco Lutzu, eds. Cagliari: L'Unione Sarda.
RDCT (R Development Core Team). 2012. R: A Language and
Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation forStatistical Computing. URL: http://www.R-project.org.
Notes
1Parameters used for the intensity measure in Praat are the following: pitch floor =
40 Hz; time step = 0.01 sec.2Spectral analyses were carried out by means of the relevant Praat functions, with
the following parameters: window length = 0.005; maxfreq = 24000; time step =
0.02; window shape: Gaussian.