Border Patrol Rape and Attempted Murder Case

7/23/2019 Border Patrol Rape and Attempted Murder Case

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/border-patrol-rape-and-attempted-murder-case 1/37

"# $%& '#"$&( )$*$&) (")$+",$ ,-'+$

.-+ $%& )-'$%&+# (")$+",$ -. $&/*)

01*22&# ("3")"-#

"#$#%#&#' ()$(*($+,--. /

,)$ ,0 )123 45(1)$ 64 /

)#-#"#%#' , "789: /

,)$ /

$#1#&#' ,0 )123 45(1)$ /

64 ;#"#,#1#' , "789:' /

/ ,-042*"#$

<=>78?7@@A /

/BA# /

/

+)(31$ 03,310 64 ,"15(%,' /

/

$C@C8D>8?# /

42*"#$"..)5 -+"6"#*2 ,-042*"#$

*7 489:;<=

E# <=>78?7@@A >:C >=7C8A @:9F ?GC H9I8?:J 9@ K98DI:>A' HI::C8?=J >8D

=>L@I==J :CA7D78M 78 *7:M787># <=>78?7@@ "#$#%#&# 7A >8 >DI=? L9F>8# 0GC AICA

78D7B7DI>==J' >8D >A 8CN? @:7C8D @9: GC: F789: D>IMG?C: )#-#"#%# ":A# $#1#&# L>A

89? > O>:? 9@ ?GC 9:DC>= F>DC ?GC P>A7A 9@ ?G7A AI7?# 0GC G>A Q978CD ?GC AI7? >A 8CN?

@:7C8D @9: GC: F789: D>IMG?C:' ;#"#,#1# <=>78?7@@ "#$#%#&#' GC: D>IMG?C: )#-#"#%'

>8D ?GC 9?GC: M7:= ;#"#,#1# >== D7:CH?=J AI@@C:CD 78QI:7CA >8D D>F>MCA >? ?GC G>8DA

Case 7:15-cv-00552 Document 1 Filed in TXSD on 12/23/15 of 37



R

9@ +87?CD 0?>?CA S9:DC: <>?:9= 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA# E

R# $C@C8D>8? 7A ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H> VGC:C78>@?C: A9FC?7FCA

W+87?CD 0?>?CAX 9: W+#0#XY' LG9' >? >== ?7FCA :C=CB>8?' CFO=9JCD @9:FC: +#0#

S9:DC: <>?:9= ,MC8?T6@@7HC: 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA# ,? ?GC ?7FC 9@ ?GC CBC8?A F>DC

?GC P>A7A 9@ ?G7A AI7?' ">8U>8>:CA L>A >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC:'

>A ?G>? ?C:F 7A DC@78CD 78 RZ +#0#%# / R[Z\VGY' 9@ ?GC +# 0# %IA?9FA >8D S9:DC:

<:9?CH?798 VGC:C78>@?C: A9FC?7FCA W%<SX 9: WS9:DC: <>?:9=XY' >8DT9: 9?GC:

>MC8H7CA 9@ ?GC +#0# ]GC8 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA H9FF7??CD B>:79IA ?9:?A

>M>78A? ?GC O=>78?7@@A' 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\E^' GC L>A >H?78M L7?G78 ?GC AH9OC

9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC +#0#' >8D >H?78M I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L#

_# <=>78?7@@A PC=7CBC ?G>? >? >== ?7FCA :C=CB>8?' ?GC +# 0# %IA?9FA >8D

S9:DC: <:9?CH?798 >8D ?GC (FF7M:>?798 >8D %IA?9FA 18@9:HCFC8? 0C:B7HC LC:C

>8D :CF>78 >MC8H7CA 9@ 9: I8DC: ?GC +#0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J' >

+#0# 4CDC:>= &9BC:8FC8?>= DCO>:?FC8?' CA?>P=7AGFC8?' >8DT9: O>:C8? >MC8HJ'

H9FO:7ACD 9@ 8IFC:9IA DCO>:?FC8?A >8D >MC8H7CA L7?G GC>D`I>:?C:A 78

]>AG78M?98' $#%#' >8D B>:79IA P:>8HG 9@@7HCA ?G:9IMG9I? ?GC H9I8?:J' 78H=ID78M 78

E $C@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H> 7A >L>:C 9@ ?GC @I== =CM>= 8>FCA 9@ C>HG 9@ ?GCAC

3GC O=>78?7@@A L7== O:9B7DC ?9 ?GC M9BC:8FC8? LG>?CBC: >DD7?798>= 78@9:F>?798 7?

:C`ICA?A ?9 H98@7:F ?GC7: 7DC8?7?7CA' >8D >:C ACCa78M 98=J ?9 aCCO ?GC 8>FCA 9@ F789:A >8D

B7H?7FA 9@ 78?7F>?C >AA>I=? 9I? 9@ ?GC OIP=7H :CH9:D#




_

?G7A QID7H7>= D7A?:7H?# 1>HG 9@ AIHG >MC8H7CATCA?>P=7AGFC8?A ?GIA H98A?7?I?C >

W4CDC:>= >MC8HJX >A ?G>? ?C:F 7A DC@78CD 78 RZ +#0#%# / R[bE#

>7 ?@9;=A;1:;BC

^# 68 ">:HG ER' R\E^' %<S >MC8?T9@@7HC: 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA' LG7=C 78

?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8?' >8D 9OC:>?78M I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L' ?99a

78?9 HIA?9DJ O=>78?7@@A "#$#%#&#' GC: F789: D>IMG?C:' )#-#"#%#' >8D ?GC F789: M7:='

;#"#,#1#' 98 ?GC +#0# A7DC 9@ ?GC P9:DC: L7?G "CN7H9# 49: ?GC 8CN? ?LC8?Jc@9I:

G9I:A' GC D:9BC ?GCF >:9I8D ?9 B>:79IA =9H>?798A 78 09I?G 3CN>A# ">8U>8>:CA

OGJA7H>==J >AA>I=?CD' a87@CD' >8D P>??C:CD ?GC O=>78?7@@A >? B>:79IA =9H>?798A >8D

78?C:B>=A' @>=AC=J 7FO:7A98CD ?GCF' >8D OG9?9M:>OGCD ?GC F789:A 8IDC' >F98M

9?GC: ?9:?A# 3G7A +#0# $7A?:7H? %9I:? ?GC:C@9:C G>A 9:7M78>= >8D CNH=IA7BC QI:7AD7H?798

9BC: O=>78?7@@Ad H=>7FA' OI:AI>8? ?9 ?GC 4CDC:>= 39:? %=>7FA ,H? V43%,Y' RZ +#0# %# /

E^_[VPY >8D // R[bEcR[Z\#

e# ,A D7AHIAACD F9:C @I==J PC=9L 78 ACH?798 W$X' H98D7?798A O:CHCDC8?'

?G7A %9I:? @I:?GC: G>A QI:7AD7H?798 PCH>IAC C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A G>BC @I==J

H9FO=7CD L7?G ?GC 43%, >8D G>BC CNG>IA?CD ?GC7: >DF787A?:>?7BC :CFCD7CA# 3G7A

%9FO=>78? 7A O:9OC:=J PC@9:C ?G7A %9I:?' >8D >== QI:7AD7H?798>= O:C:C`I7A7?CA G>BC

PCC8 FC?#

,7 3<C@<




^

[# *C8IC 7A O:9OC: 78 ?GC 09I?GC:8 $7A?:7H? 9@ 3CN>A' "H,==C8 $7B7A798

I8DC: RZ +#0#%# /E^\RVPY# 3GC >H?A F>DC ?GC P>A7A 9@ ?G7A AI7? 9HHI::CD' 9: >?

=C>A? PCM>8' 78 K7D>=M9 %9I8?J' 3CN>A' 98 ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CAf A7DC 9@ ?GC 579 &:>8DC

57BC: V>=A9 a89L8 >A ?GC W579 S:>B9 DC= )9:?CXY# 3GC ?G:CC O=>78?7@@A' "#$#%#&# >8D

?L9 F789:A' GC: D>IMG?C: )#-#"#%' >8D ;#"#,#1#' LC:C A7??78M 98 ?GC +#0# A7DC 9@

?GC A9I?GC:8 P9:DC: 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' 98 ?GC A7DC 9@ > D7:? :9>D ?G>? :I8A

O>:>==C= ?9 ?GC 579 &:>8DC' 8C>: > PC8D 78 ?GC :7BC:# 3G7A 7A >8 I8O9OI=>?CD'

P:IAGJ' DCAC:?CD >:C>' L7?G @CL V7@ >8JY D7A?78H? >8D OC:F>8C8? F>:a78MA 9:

=>8DF>:aA >A ?9 =9H>?798# ]G7=C ?GC:C LC:C 89 D7:CH?798>= F>:aC:A' >8D ?GCJ G>D

89 &<0' ?GC O=>78?7@@A a89L ?G>? ?GCJ G>D QIA? H:9AACD ?GC P9:DC: >8D ?GC 579

&:>8DC 78?9 ?GC +#0# >8D LC:C >P>8D98CD PJ ?GC7: CAH9:? >? ?GC :7BC:dA CDMC 78

K7D>=M9 %9I8?J# <=>78?7@@A "#$#%#&#' GC: D>IMG?C: ;#"#,#1#' >8D )#-#"#%' LC:C

A7??78M 98 ?GC A7DC 9@ ?GC D7:? :9>D ?9 :CA?# 3GC ?G:CC O=>78?7@@A LC:C O7HaCD IO PJ

6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA >A GC L>A D:7B78M PJ#

b# $I:78M ?GC ?7FC ">8U>8>:CA L>A H9FF7??78M B>:79IA ?9:?A >M>78A?

?GC O=>78?7@@A' GC D:9BC ?GCF >:9I8D 78 G7A 4CDC:>= 9@@7H7>= BCG7H=C >8D A?9OOCD >?

B>:79IA =9H>?798A' >== 98 ?GC +#0# A7DC 9@ ?GC P9:DC:# (8 ?GC >PAC8HC 9@ F9:C

AOCH7@7H 78@9:F>?798' VLG7HG 7A =7aC=J 78 ?GC O9AACAA798 9@ ?GC +#0# @:9F ?GC 4S( >8D




e

(8?C:8>= ,@@>7:Ad 78BCA?7M>?7BC :CO9:?AY' 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA F>J G>BC D:7BC8

98C 9: F9:C O=>78?7@@A 9I? 9@ K7D>=M9 %9I8?J' 78?9 0?>:: %9I8?J' >8D =>?C: P>Ha 78?9

K7D>=M9 %9I8?J# 3GC O=>78?7@@A LC:C :CA?:>78CD 78 ?GC P>Ha 9@ G7A 9@@7H7>= BCG7H=C'

@:7MG?C8CD' A9FC?7FCA I8>P=C ?9 ACC LGC:C ?GCJ LC:C M978M# 3GCJ LC:C

I8@>F7=7>: L7?G ?GC >:C># 09 ?GCJ >:C 89? AI:C 9@ >== 9@ ?GC O=>HCA LGC:C ?GCJ

LC:C D:7BC8 PJ %<S 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA 9BC: > ACBC:>= G9I: OC:79D# 3GC

O=>78?7@@A H9I=D 98=J DCAH:7PC ?GC Q9I:8CJ' >A ?GCJ G>BC PC=9L >8D D7D 78 ?GC7:

H=>7FA# 3GCJ !" a89L ?GCJ LC:C >OO:CGC8DCD 78 K7D>=M9 %9I8?J' 3CN>A >? ?GC

PCM78878M 9@ ?GC7: 9:DC>=#

Z# <=>78?7@@ ;#"#,#1#' > E^cJC>: 9=D F789: >? ?GC ?7FC' L>A CBC8?I>==J

?>aC8 ACO>:>?C=J PJ 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA ?9 G7A >O>:?FC8? 78 "7AA798' K7D>=M9

%9I8?J' 3CN>A# 0GC L>A ?7CD D9L8' >AA>I=?CD' >8D P>??C:CD @9: G9I:A'

OG9?9M:>OGCD 78 ?GC 8IDC' CBC8?I>==J D7AH9BC:CD PJ 9?GC: =>L C8@9:HCFC8?

78D7B7DI>=A' >8D CAH9:?CD ?9 > G9AO7?>= 78 "H,==C8#

(7 ,BCA;:;BC= 49<1<A<C:

g# 1>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A ?7FC=J FC? ?GC >DF787A?:>?7BC O:CcAI7? @7=78M

:C`I7:CFC8?A @9: AI78M ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA# ,== H98D7?798A O:CHCDC8? G>BC PCC8

A>?7A@7CD O:79: ?9 ?GC @7=78M 9@ ?G7A =>LAI7?' 78H=ID78M >A @9==9LA#




[

E\# 1>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A O:9OC:=J @7=CD >8D O:CAC8?CD ?GC7:

>DF787A?:>?7BC H=>7FA ?9 ?GC >OO:9O:7>?C @CDC:>= >MC8H7CA LC== L7?G78 ?L9 JC>:A 9@

>HH:I>=# RZ +#0#%# / R^\EVPY# 0OCH7@7H>==J' C>HG H=>7F 9@ C>HG O=>78?7@@ L>A

O:9B7DCD ?9 >8D :CHC7BCD PJ' C>HG 9@ ?GC ?GC >OO:9O:7>?C @CDC:>= >MC8H7CA =7A?CD

PC=9L 98 9: >P9I? ,O:7= RR' R\Ee' L7?G78 ?L9 JC>:A >@?C: A>7D H=>7FA G>D 9HHI::CD

V98 ">:HG ER' R\E^Y# ,? ?GC ?7FC 9@ @7=78M >8D O:CAC8?FC8?' C>HG H=>7F>8?

O:9B7DCD 89?7HC 78 ?GC >OO:9O:7>?C +#0#c>OO:9BCD 49:F 04cge' >=98M L7?G

>??>HGFC8?A' OI:AI>8? ?9 RZ %45 / E^#RVPYVEY' ?9 C>HG 9@ ?GC @9==9L78M >MC8H7CA 9@

?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' LG9AC H98DIH? M>BC :7AC ?9 ?GC H=>7Fh

• +#0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?Ji

• +#0# %IA?9FA j S9:DC: <:9?CH?798i

•

+#0# (FF7M:>?798 %IA?9FA 18@9:HCFC8?i >8D

• +#0# 4CDC:>= SI:C>I 9@ (8BCA?7M>?798#

EE# 3GC:C>@?C: !"##$%&%'()$ D9HIFC8?A LC:C O:9B7DCD ?9 ?GC DC@C8D>8?

>A > H9I:?CAJ' ?9 L7? IOD>?CD FCD7H>= :CH9:DA' >8D AIOO=CFC8?>= =>L C8@9:HCFC8?

:CH9:DA LG7HG ?GC O=>78?7@@A D7D 89? G>BC >? @7=78M#

ER# %I::C8?=J' >== 9@ ?GC @9:CM978M >MC8H7CA G>BC @>7=CD ?9 F>aC >8J @78>=

D7AO9A7?798 9@ >8J H=>7F 9@ >8J 9@ ?GC H=>7F>8?A' 9: >8J D7AO9A7?798 ?G>? ?GC

O=>78?7@@A >:C >L>:C 9@# "9:C ?G>8 A7N F98?GA G>A O>AACD A78HC C>HG 9@ ?GC




b

O=>78?7@@Ad H=>7FA LC:C C@@CH?7BC=J @7=CDTO:CAC8?CD' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC @9:CM978M

>MC8H7CA G>BC @>7=CD ?9 :CA9=BC >8J 9@ ?G9AC H=>7FA# RZ +#0#%# / R[beV>Y# 3GC

H=>7FA >:C ?GC:C@9:C DCCFCD DC87CD *+, 3G7A AI7? 7A PC78M P:9IMG? L7?G78 ?L9

JC>:A 9@ ?GC ?7FC C>HG H=>7F @7:A? >HH:ICD 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\E^' LG7HG 7A

LC== L7?G78 ?GC O:CAH:7PCD A?>?I?9:J ?7FC# RZ +#0#%# / R^\EV>Y# ,HH9:D78M=J' C>HG

O=>78?7@@ G>A H9FO=7CD L7?G >== QI:7AD7H?798>= O:C:C`I7A7?CA >8D H98D7?798A

O:CHCDC8? ?9 H9FFC8HCFC8? >8D O:9ACHI?798 9@ ?G7A =7?7M>?798#

&7 )<9D;1< BC (<E<CA8C: 'C;:<A ):8:<=

E_# $C@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA F>J PC AC:BCD OI:AI>8? ?9 41$# 5# %(*# <# ^V7Y'

PJ AC:B78M ?G7A %9FO=>78? >8D > AIFF98A ?9 C>HG 9@ ?GC @9==9L78M' PJ HC:?7@7CD

F>7=' :C?I:8 :CHC7O? :C`ICA?CDh




Z

># ":# kC88C?G ">M7DA98 >F ,0+++

+#0# ,??9:8CJ

09I?GC:8 $7A?:7H? 9@ 3CN>A

,??8h %7B7= <:9HCAA %=C:a

E\\\ -9I7A7>8>' 0?C# R_\\K9IA?98' 32 bb\\R

P# ":# kC88C?G ">M7DA98 >F ,0+++

+#0# ,??9:8CJ

09I?GC:8 $7A?:7H? 9@ 3CN>A

,??8h %7B7= <:9HCAA %=C:a

"H,==C8 6@@7HC

SC8?AC8 39LC:

Eb\E ]# K7MGL>J Z_' l[\\"H,==C8' 32 bZe\EceE[\

H# &C8C:>= -9:C??> 1# -J8HG >F ,0+++

,??9:8CJ &C8C:>= 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA

+# 0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ ;IA?7HC

ge\ <C88AJ=B>87> ,BC8IC' )#]#

]>AG78M?98' $#%# R\e_\

D# 0CH:C?>:J ;CG ;9G8A98 >F ,0+++ 0CH:C?>:J 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J

,??8h %7B7= <:9HCAA %=C:a

$CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J

R^e "I::>J ->8C 0]

]>AG78M?98' $#$# R\eRZc\\be

C# 6@@7HC 9@ ?GC &C8C:>= %9I8AC= >F ,0+++

+#0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J

]>AG78M?98' $% R\eRZ

@# +#0# %IA?9FA j S9:DC: <>?:9= >F ,0+++

6@@7HC 9@ ?GC %G7C@ %9I8AC=

E_\\ <C88AJ=B>87> ,BC# )]

]>AG78M?98' $% R\RRg




g

M# 6@@7HC 9@ ?GC <:78H7O>= -CM>= ,DB7A9: >F ,0+++

+# 0# (FF7M:>?798 j %IA?9FA 18@9:HCFC8?

+#0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J

e\ ER

?G

0?:CC? 0]]>AG78M?98' $% R\\R^

.7 .81:=

E^# 4:9F 98 9: >P9I? R\\Z I8?7= G7A DC>?G' 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA L>A

CFO=9JCD PJ ?GC DC@C8D>8?' ?G:9IMG 7?A >MC8HJ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA %IA?9FA j

S9:DC: <:9?CH?798' LG7HG L>A >8D 7A > AIPc>MC8HJ 9: D7B7A798 9@ ?GC +#0#

$CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J# ">8U>8>:CA L>A > AL9:8 >8D =7HC8ACD +#0#

S9:DC: <>?:9= 6@@7HC: DI:78M >== ?7FCA :C=CB>8? ?9 ?GCAC H=>7FA#

Ee# (8 ">:HG 9@ R\E^' %S< 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA L>A >AA7M8CD ?9 >

O9A? >=98M ?GC 579 &:>8DC 57BC: 0CH?9:' 78 LG>? 7A PC=7CBCD ?9 PC 8C>: ?GC

?9L8T%$< VHC8AIA DCA7M8>?CD O=>HCY 9@ ,P:>F' 78 K7D>=M9 %9I8?J' 3CN>A#

<=>78?7@@A PC=7CBC ?G>? ">8U>8>:CA L>A >@@7=7>?CD L7?G ?GC 579 &:>8DC *>==CJ 0CH?9:

V3CN>AY' %S< "H,==C8 0?>?798' DI:78M ?GC :C=CB>8? ?7FC#

E[# ,A FC8?798CD >P9BC' 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\E^' ?GC ?G:CC

O=>78?7@@A' "#$#%#&#' GC: D>IMG?C:' )#-#"#% V?GC8 Ee JC>:A 9=DY' >8D ;#"#,#1# V?GC8

E^ JC>:A 9=DY' LG9 G>D PCC8 ?:>BC=78M ?9MC?GC:' LC:C A7??78M 98 ?GC A7DC 9@ > D7:?

:9>D 78 K7D>=M9 %9I8?J# 3GC D7:? :9>D :I8A O>:>==C= ?9 ?GC 579 &:>8DC' >8D @9==9LA




E\

> PC8D 78 ?GC :7BC:# 3GC O=>78?7@@A G>D QIA? :CHC8?=J H:9AACD ?GC 579 &:>8DC >8D ?GC

P9:DC: L7?G9I? >I?G9:7U>?798' >8D LC:C A7??78M 98 ?GC A7DC 9@ ?GC D7:? :9>D 98 ?GC

+#0# A7DC' :CA?78M# 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA L>A D:7B78M PJ 78 G7A 9@@7H7>= +#0#

&9BC:8FC8? BCG7H=C LGC8 GC AO9??CD ?GC O=>78?7@@A# KC A?9OOCD' >AaCD LGC?GC:

?GCJ LC:C >=98C' >8D LGC8 ?GCJ A>7D ?GCJ LC:C' ">8U>8>:CA ?9=D ?GC O=>78?7@@A ?9

H9FC L7?G G7F# KC ?9=D ?GC O=>78?7@@A ?G>? ?GCJ LC:C 78 G7A H98?:9= >8D HIA?9DJ'

>8D LC:C ?9 @9==9L G7A 78A?:IH?798A#

Eb# 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA L>A 78 I87@9:F' >:FCD' 9OC:>?78M > @CDC:>=

BCG7H=C' >8D 78 O9AACAA798 9@ FI=?7O=C H9FFI87H>?798 DCB7HCA# 3GC %S< C7?GC:

7AAICD ?G7A C`I7OFC8?' 9: G>D >H?I>= a89L=CDMC GC L>A 78 O9AACAA798 9@ ?G7A

C`I7OFC8?# <=>78?7@@A "#$#%#&#' GC: D>IMG?C: )#-#"#%' >8D ?GC M7:= ;#"#,#1#' C>HG

AI::C8DC:CD L7?G9I? 78H7DC8? ?9 ">8U>8>:CA' L7?G ?GC I8DC:A?>8D78M GC L>A

>:FCD >8D L>A > @CDC:>= =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC:#

EZ# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA >DB7ACD ?GC >DI=? O=>78?7@@ "#$#%#&# ?G>? AGC

>8D ?GC ?L9 F789: M7:=A L9I=D PC ?:>8AO9:?CD ?9 > @>H7=7?J @9: F9?GC:A >8D ?GC7:

HG7=D:C8# KC ?GC8 D:9BC >:9I8D F>a78M ACBC:>= A?9OA# 68 9: >P9I? ?GC ACH98D

A?9O GC O=>HCD P=>Ha :CA?:>78? P>8DA 98 ?GC L:7A?A 9@ "#$#%#&#' GC: D>IMG?C:

)#-#"#%#' >8D ;#"#,#1#' >8D OI? ?GCF 78 ?GC P>Ha 9@ G7A 9@@7H7>= BCG7H=C#

">8U>8>:CA CBC8?I>==J F>DC > A?9O >? LG>? >OOC>:CD ?9 PC > M9BC:8FC8?




EE

PI7=D78M' LG7HG L>A 9HHIO7CD PJ 9?GC: 78D7B7DI>=A' 78H=ID78M OC:A988C= ?G>?

>OOC>:CD ?9 PC I87@9:FCD %S< CFO=9JCCA# KC =C@? ?GC :CA?:>78CD O=>78?7@@A 78 ?GC

P>Ha 9@ ?GC BCG7H=C#

Eg# ,@?C: D:7B78M @I:?GC: @9: >8 I8a89L8 D7A?>8HC' ">8U>8>:CA A?9OOCD

78 >8 I8O9OI=>?CD >:C># KC ?99a ?GC ?G:CC O=>78?7@@A 9I? 9@ ?GC BCG7H=C# KC ?>OCD

?GC7: F9I?GA >8D L:7A?A' >8D ?9=D ?GCF GC L>A D978M A9 DIC ?9 > ACH98D>:J 9:DC:

GC G>D :CHC7BCD#

R\# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA LC8? ?G:9IMG ACBC:>= M>?CA DI:78M ?GC

ACBC:>= G9I:A GC L>A ?:>8AO9:?78M ?GC O=>78?7@@A @:9F O=>HC ?9 O=>HC# KC IACD aCJA

?G>? >:C PC=7CBCD ?9 G>BC PCC8 M7BC8 G7F PJ %S< ?9 9OC:>?C ?GC M>?CA# 3GC

O=>78?7@@A A>L >? =C>A? 98C 9?GC: %S< I87@9:FCD CFO=9JCC >=98M ?GC :9>DL>J'

DI:78M ?GC ?7FC ?GCJ LC:C PC78M ?:>8AO9:?CD ?G:9IMG M>?CA#

RE# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA CBC8?I>==J A?9OOCD ?GC BCG7H=C 78 > 8CL

>:C># KC @9:H7P=J :CF9BCD ?L9 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A' "#$#%#&# >8D GC: D>IMG?C:

)#-#"#%#' LG9 LC:C A?7== :CA?:>78CD' 98C >? > ?7FC @:9F ?GC ?:IHa#

.81:= )G<1;E;1 :B :H< *A@I: 4I8;C:;EEJ 07(7,767

RR# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA D:>MMCD "#$#%#&# 9I? 9@ ?GC ?:IHa' >8D

@9:HCD GC: ?9 ?GC M:9I8D# KC C8M>MCD 78 L:98M@I= >8D CNHCAA7BC @9:HC @9: ACBC:>=

F78I?CA' >8D A?:IHa "A# & >P9I? ?GC @>HC >8D P9DJ# +8?7= ?G7A O978?' AGC G>D 89?




ER

:CA7A?CD' PI? >? ?G7A O978? AGC PCM>8 ?9 A?:IMM=C# KC ?GC8 D:>MMCD GC: IO > G7=='

>8D C8M>MCD 78 @I:?GC: CNHCAA7BC @9:HC# KC A?:IHa GC:' a7HaCD GC:' >8D A?:>8M=CD

>8D HG9aCD GC:' >8D ?L7A?CD GC: 8CHa# <=>78?7@@ "#$#%#&# PC=7CBCD AGC L>A M978M

?9 PC a7==CD PJ %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA' >8D @C>:CD @9: GC: =7@C# ,? A9FC O978?

DI:78M ?GC >AA>I=? >8D P>??C:J' AGC PCH>FC ?CFO9:>:7=J I8H98AH79IA 9:

A7M87@7H>8?=J D7A9:7C8?CD PJ ">8U>8>:CAd A?:>8M=78M >8D HG9a78M GC:# ]GC8 AGC

L>A >L>:C >M>78' ">8U>8>:CA G>D "#$#%#&# 78 > G9=D A9 ?G>? AGC H9I=D 89? :CA7A?#

(8 >DD7?798' GC: D7A9:7C8?>?798 F>DC 7? D7@@7HI=? @9: GC: ?9 :CA7A?' LG7=C GC

78?C:F7??C8?=J >AA>I=?CD GC:' PC>? GC:' >8D ?9IHGCD GC: 78 >8 9@@C8A7BC F>88C:#

R_# ,? A9FC O978?' ">8U>8>:CA OI==CD 9I? > a87@C' >8D PCM>8 ?9 HI?

"#$#%#&#dA >:FA >8D L:7A?A# 0GC L>A H9FO=C?C=J >L>aC DI:78M ?GC ?7FC GC L>A

A=7H78M GC: >:FA >8D L:7A?A' >8D PC=7CBCD GC L>A ?9:?I:78M GC:' ?:J78M ?9 a7== GC:

A=9L=J' 9: O9AA7P=J F>aC 7? =99a >A 7@ AGC G>D a7==CD GC:AC=@# ,? A9FC O978?' "#$#%#&

=9A? H98AH79IA8CAA @9: > LG7=C#

R^# ]GC8 "#$#%#&# H>FC ?9' ">8U>8>:CA G>D =C@? GC: @9: >LG7=C >8D AGC

H9I=D GC>: ">8U>8>:CA PC>?78M >8D >AA>I=?78M GC: D>IMG?C: )#-#"#%# "A# & L>A

>L>:C AGC L>A P=CCD78M' >8D ?:7CD ?9 D9 A9FC?G78M ?9 H98?:9= 7?# 5C>=7U78M ?G>?

%S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA G>D LC>O98A' ?G>? AGC >8D ?GC M7:=A LC:C :CA?:>78CD' ?G>?

GC G>D PCC8 9BC:O9LC:78M ?GCF' >8D ?G>? ?GC7: 98=J HG>8HC L>A ?9 MC?




E_

>AA7A?>8HC' "#$#%#&# ?GC8 F>DC ?GC D7@@7HI=? DCH7A798 ?9 =C>BC ?GC AHC8C >8D :I8

@9: GC=O#

Re# ,? A9FC O978? FIHG =>?C: m GC: 78QI:7CA >8D D7A9:7C8?>?798 F>aC GC:

I8AI:C G9L FIHG ?7FC C=>OACD m "#$#%#&# CBC8?I>==J H>FC IO98 %S< 6@@7HC:A#

0GC D9CA8d? a89L G9L AGC M9? ?GC7: >??C8?798' LGC?GC: PJ H>FC:> AI:BC7==>8HC 9:

9?GC:L7AC# SI? CBC8?I>==J AGC C8H9I8?C:CD > %S< 9@@7HC:' LG9 D:CL G7A MI8 98

GC: >8D ÌCA?798CD "#$#%#&# >? MI8O978?# 0GC ?9=D ?GC 9@@7HC: LG>? G>D

G>OOC8CD' LGJ AGC L>A D7AGCBC=CD' GC: H=9?GCA ?9:8' >8D LGJ AGC L>A H9BC:CD 78

P=99D# 0GC >8ALC:CD >== G7A ÌCA?798A' >8D ?9=D G7F ?G>? ?GC OC:A98 LG9 G>D

D98C ?G7A ?9 GC:' L>A A?7== D978M 7? ?9 GC: D>IMG?C: >8D ?9 >89?GC: M7:=# ]GC8 >AaCD

LG9 L>A D978M ?G7A' "#$#%#&# ?9=D ?GC 9@@7HC: ?GC OC:OC?:>?9: L>A WD:CAACD QIA?

=7aC J9IX V?GC %S< 9@@7HC: ÌCA?79878M GC:Y# 3GC %S< 6@@7HC: PCM>8 ?9

H9FFI87H>?C PJ :>D79 >8D H>== @9: >AA7A?>8HC# 6?GC: %S<cD:CAACD 78D7B7DI>=A

PCM>8 ?9 >::7BC' @9==9LCD PJ CFC:MC8HJ FCD7H>= OC:A988C=#

R[# <=>78?7@@ "#$#%#&# L>A O=>HCD 78 >8 >FPI=>8HC >8D ?:>8AO9:?CD ?9 >

G9AO7?>= 78 "H,==C8# 0GC L>A O=>HCD I8DC: MI>:D >? ?GC G9AO7?>=' 78 ?GC HIA?9DJ 9@

%S<# (? L>A A9FC ?7FC PC@9:C "#$#%#&# =C>:8CD LG>? G>OOC8CD ?9 GC: D>IMG?C:'

)#-#"#%# 0GC L>A 89? OC:F7??CD ?9 ACC GC: D>IMG?C: I8?7= LG>? AGC PC=7CBCA L>A

?GC ?G7:D D>J#




E^

.81:= )G<1;E;1 :B :H< 0;CB9 4I8;C:;EE #72707,#

Rb# )#-#"#%# L>?HGCD LG7=C GC: F9?GC: @9:H7P=J >8D :9IMG=J :CF9BCD

@:9F ?GC 9@@7H7>= BCG7H=C# EecJC>:c9=D )#-#"#%# L>?HGCD' :CA?:>78CD' LG7=C %S<

6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA IACD CNHCAA7BC @9:HC 98 GC: F9?GC:' "#$#%#&#' >8D L>?HGCD

?GC 78QI:7CA GC: F9?GC: L>A AIA?>7878M# ,? A9FC O978?' ">8U>8>:CA D:>MMCD GC:

F9?GC: >L>J @:9F ?GC ?:IHa# )#-#"#%# GC>:D ?GC PC>?78MA >8D ?GC A9I8DA 9@

D7A?:CAA @:9F GC: F9?GC: LG7=C ?GCJ LC:C >L>J#

RZ# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA ?GC8 :C?I:8CD ?9 ?GC ?:IHa' >8D @9:H7P=J >8D

:9IMG=J :CF9BCD )#-#"#%# 0GC A?:IMM=CD LG7=C GC A?:>8M=CD GC:' HG9aCD GC:' >8D

?L7A?CD GC: 8CHa 78 > F>88C: ?G>? =CD GC: ?9 PC=7CBC GC L>A ?:J78M ?9 P:C>a GC:

8CHa# )#-#"#%# PC=7CBCD AGC L>A M978M ?9 PC AC:79IA=J 78QI:CD' >8D O9AA7P=J D7C' >?

?GC G>8DA 9@ ">8U>8>:CA# ,? A9FC O978?' )#-#"#% L>A C7?GC: ?CFO9:>:7=J

I8H98AH79IA 9: A7M87@7H>8?=J D7A9:7C8?CD >@?C: AGC L>A A?:>8M=CD' HG9aCD' >8D GC:

8CHa L>A ?L7A?CD >A 7@ ?9 P:C>a 7?# ]GC8 AGC :CM>78CD H98AH79IA8CAA' )#-#"#%# D7D

89? =C? G7F a89L# 0GC >H?CD >A 7@ AGC LC:C DC>D ?9 >??CFO? ?9 =7F7? 6@@7HC:

">8U>8>:CAd >H?798A#

Rg# 1BC8 LG7=C AGC >H?CD I8H98AH79IA 9: DC>D' ">8U>8>:CA H98?78ICD

L7?G ?GC IAC 9@ L:98M@I= >8D CNHCAA7BC @9:HC >M>78A? )#-#"#%# KC H98?78ICD ?9

?9IHG >8D >AA>I=? GC: 78 >8 9@@C8A7BC >8D O:9B9H>?7BC F>88C:#




Ee

_\# 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA F>87OI=>?CD EecJC>:c9=D )#-#"#%#dA H=9?G78M ?9

M>78 >HHCAA ?9 GC: P:C>A? >8D B>M78>= >:C>' >8D ?9IHGCD GC: O:9B9H>?7BC=J# 0GC

L>A :CA?:>78CD' A9 ?GC:C L>A 89?G78M AGC H9I=D D9 >P9I? 7?# ">8U>8>:CA

F>87OI=>?CD >8D ?9IHGCD GC: P:C>A? >8D B>M78>= >:C>A L7?G G7A G>8DA >8D 9?GC:

P9DJ O>:?A# ,? A9FC O978?' ">8U>8>:CA L>=aCD >:9I8D )#-#"#%#' ?>a78M O7H?I:CA

9@ GC: ACF7cI8H=9?GCD >8D CNO9ACD P9DJ# 0GC L>A I8>P=C ?9 O:9?CH? GC:AC=@ @:9F

?G7A D9HIFC8?>?798 PCH>IAC AGC L>A A?7== :CA?:>78CD' >8D PCH>IAC AGC L>A A?7==

H98?78I78M ?9 =99a =7@C=CAA' >8D O:C?C8D ?G>? AGC L>A I8H98AH79IA 9: DC>D' G9O78M

?9 A>BC GC: 9L8 =7@C#

_E# KC ?GC8 IACD G7A a87@C >8D HI? GC: =C@? >:F# )#-#"#%# L>A >L>aC >8D

H98AH79IA LG7=C GC: >:F L>A PC78M HI?' PI? H98?78ICD ?9 >H? I8:CAO98A7BC 78 >8

>??CFO? ?9 A>BC GC: =7@C# ,OO>:C8?=J ?7:78M 9@ )#-#"#%#' %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA

H9BC:CD )#-#"#% L7?G D7:?' DCP:7A' >8D P:IAG' >8D =C@? ?GC >:C># 09FC?7FC >@?C:

?GC 9@@7HC: G>D 89? :C?I:8CD' >8D AGC G>D GC>:D G7F D:7BC >L>J' )#-#"#%# DIM

GC:AC=@ 9I? @:9F I8DC: ?GC P:IAG >8D D7:? ?G>? ">8U>8>:CA G>D IACD ?9 H9BC: GC:#

0GC PCM>8 ?9 =99a @9: GC: F9?GC:# KC: 78QI:7CA >8D D7A9:7C8?>?798 F>aC GC:

I8AI:C G9L FIHG ?7FC C=>OACDi PI? )#-#"#%# CBC8?I>==J @9I8D >89?GC: 78D7B7DI>=

D:CAACD >A > %S< 9@@7HC:# 0GC L>A O=>HCD 78 >8 >FPI=>8HC' >8D ?:>8AO9:?CD ?9 ?GC

G9AO7?>=#




E[

_R# )#-#"#%# L>A O=>HCD I8DC: MI>:D >? ?GC G9AO7?>=' 78 ?GC HIA?9DJ 9@

%S<' >8D L>A 89? OC:F7??CD ?9 ACC GC: F9?GC: I8?7= LG>? AGC PC=7CBCA L>A ?GC

?G7:D D>J#

.81:= )G<1;E;1 :B :H< 0;CB9 4I8;C:;EE ?707*7&7

__# ">8U>8>:CA CBC8?I>==J :C?I:8CD ?9 ?GC BCG7H=C L7?G9I? ?GC F789:

)#-#"#%# 9: GC: F9?GC: "#$#%#&# KC :C@IACD ?9 ?C== ?GC8cE^cJC>:c9=D ;#"#,#1# LG>?

GC G>D D98C L7?G ?GCF DCAO7?C GC: O=C>A' >8D L9I=D 89? ?C== GC: LG>? GC

78?C8DCD ?9 D9 ?9 GC:# SI? ;#"#,#1# L>A 89L 78 @C>: @9: GC: =7@C PCH>IAC AGC G>D

L7?8CAACD G9L :9IMG GC G>D PCC8 L7?G GC: @:7C8DA# 0GC G>D ACC8 G7A IAC 9@

L:98M@I= >8D CNHCAA7BC @9:HC' >8D H9I=D ?C== ?GCJ LC:C PC78M 78QI:CD 78 ?GC

O:9HCAA# 0GC PC=7CBCD ?G>? PJ :C?I:878M ?9 ?GC BCG7H=C L7?G9I? ?GCF' ">8U>8>:CA

G>D O:9P>P=J a7==CD' 9: >? =C>A? AC:79IA=J 78QI:CD' GC: ?L9 @:7C8DA#

_^# %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA D:9BC ;#",#1# >:9I8D @9: > LG7=C# KC

CBC8?I>==J ?99a GC: ?9 > DCAC:?CD >:C>' ?7CD GC: IO ?9 > ?:CC' >8D =C@? GC: @9: > @CL

G9I:A# ;#",#1# 7A 89? AI:C @9: G9L =98M# ">8U>8>:CA CBC8?I>==J :C?I:8CD ?9 MC?

GC:# KC ?99a GC: ?9 >8 >O>:?FC8?' LG7HG AGC =>?C: =C>:8CD L>A G7A 9L8

>O>:?FC8? 78 "7AA798' 3CN>A# ">8U>8>:CA HI? >L>J ;#"#,#1#dA H=9?G78M' @9:H7P=J

P>?GCD GC:' >8D ?7CD GC: ?9 > PCD#




Eb

_e# ">8U>8>:CA OG9?9M:>OGCD ?GC E^cJC>:c9=D ;#"#,#1# 78 ?GC 8IDC#

,=?G9IMG AGC A?:IMM=CD ?9 A?9O 7?' PCH>IAC 9@ ?GC :CA?:>78?A AGC L>A I8>P=C ?9

H9BC: 9: O:9?CH? GC:AC=@ @:9F ?G7A D9HIFC8?>?798#

_[# 68 F9:C ?G>8 98C 9HH>A798' >8D 9BC: ?GC H9I:AC 9@ ACBC:>= G9I:A'

>8D DCAO7?C GC: O=C>A' 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA ?99a OGJA7H>= =7PC:?7CA L7?G ;#"#,#1'

78H=ID78M ?9IHG78M GC: O:9B9H>?7BC=J >8D 9@@C8A7BC=J' @98D=78M GC:' OC8C?:>?78M GC:

B>M78>==J' >8D 9?GC: >AA>I=?A LG7=C ;#"#,#1# L>A :CA?:>78CD#

_b# ;#"#,#1# :CH>==A ?G>? >? =C>A? 98 98C 9HH>A798' %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA

=C@? ?GC >O>:?FC8? >8D :C?I:8CD# 0GC D9CA8d? a89L @9: G9L =98M >A GC: 9:DC>=

G>D PCC8 M978M 98 PI? PC=7CBCA 7? L>A ACBC:>= G9I:A# 0GC :CF>78CD :CA?:>78CD ?9

?GC PCD ?GC C8?7:C ?7FC >@?C: AGC L>A @9:H7P=J P>?GCD#

_Z# K9I:A =>?C:' ;#"#,#1# GC>:D > =9ID O9I8D78M 98 ?GC D99:# 0GC

PC=7CBCD ?G>? 9?GC: 78D7B7DI>=A G>D >::7BCD ?9 H>IAC GC: CBC8 F9:C G>:F# 0G9:?=J

>@?C: ?GC =9ID a89Ha78M 98 ?GC D99: >8D =9ID B97HCA' AGC GC>:D MI8@7:C >8D

CNO=9A798A 9@ M>AC9IA HGCF7H>=A 78 ?GC >O>:?FC8?# 0GC L>A =>?C: ?9=D ?G>? 6@@7HC

">8U>8>:CA L>A @>?>==J 78QI:CD LGC8 GC a7==CD G7FAC=@ L7?G G7A 9L8 LC>O98#

_g# ]GC8 9?GC: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 78D7B7DI>=A C8?C:CD ?GC >O>:?FC8?'

?GCJ @9I8D ;#"#,#1# A?7== ?7CD >8D :CA?:>78CD ?9 ?GC PCD# 0GC L>A ?:>8AO9:?CD ?9

?GC G9AO7?>=# 0GC L>A O=>HCD I8DC: MI>:D >? ?GC G9AO7?>=' >8D L>A 89? OC:F7??CD




EZ

?9 ACC GC: @>F7=J @9: > F98?G# 0GC L>A 78 ?GC HIA?9DJ 9@ @CDC:>=

>MC8H7CAT>I?G9:7?7CA @9: > O:9=98MCD OC:79D 9@ ?7FC#

^\# 3GC O=>78?7@@A >:C M7BC8 ?9 I8DC:A?>8D >8D PC=7CBC' P>ACD 98

78@9:F>?798 :C=C>ACD ?9 ?GCF >8D 78 O:CAA :CO9:?A @:9F I8a89L8 A9I:HCA' ?G>?

98C 9: F9:C 4CDC:>= >MC8H7CA 9@ DC@C8D>8? +#0# VPC=7CBCD ?9 PC ?GC +# 0#

(FF7M:>?798 >8D %IA?9FA 18@9:HCFC8? 0C:B7HC V(%1Y >8DT9: ?GC +#0 4CDC:>=

SI:C>I 9@ (8BCA?7M>?798 V4S(YY a8CL 9@ %S< 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA G>B78M >PIACD

OC:A98A 78 G7A HIA?9DJ >8D H98?:9=' >8D ?G>? ?GC:C G>D PCC8 78BCA?7M>?798A 78?9

>PIAC >8D G7A L:98M@I= IAC 9@ CNHCAA7BC @9:HC# 3GC O:79: >==CM>?798A 78H=IDCD

H9FO=>78?A 9@ >??>HaA 98 L9FC8 78 > OGJA7H>=' FC8?>=' >8DT9: ACNI>= F>88C:#

S>ACD 98 ?GC @9:CM978M' 78H=ID78M ?GC H98DIH? 9@ ">8U>8>:CA' ?G7A >F9I8?CD ?9

8CM=7MC8? :C?C8?798 9@ 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA# (8 B7CL 9@ ?GC O:79:

H7:HIFA?>8HCA' >8D L:98M@I= >8D >PIA7BC H98DIH?' ?GC DC@C8D>8? +#0#' 78H=ID78M

?G:9IMG 7?A 4CDC:>= >MC8H7CA (%1 >8D ?GC 4S(' @>7=CD ?9 AIOC:B7AC 7?A CFO=9JCC'

9@@7HC:' >8D >MC8?' LG7HG >F9I8?CD ?9 8CM=7MC8HC I8DC: ?GC H7:HIFA?>8HCA#

^E# (? G>A @I:?GC: PCC8 :CO9:?CD ?G>? ?GC %S< 0CH?9:T0?>?798 78

`ICA?798 G>A PCC8 O=>HCD 98 89?7HC PJ 9?GC: M9BC:8FC8?>= >MC8H7CA >8D

898cM9BC:8FC8?>= >MC8H7CA >P9I? > D7:CH? @>7=I:C 9@ F>8>MC:7>= =CBC=

CFO=9JCCA ?9 C8@9:HC O9=7HCA' :CMI=>?798A' A?>?I?CA' >8DT9: 78?C:8>=




Eg

O:9?9H9= :CM>:D78M ?GC CNHCAA7BC IAC 9@ @9:HC' ?GC G>8D=78M 9@

I8>HH9FO>87CD F7 89:A' >8D L9FC8# 0OCH7@7H>==J' ?G7A 89?7HC M9CA D7:CH?=J ?9

?GC H=>7FA 9I?=78CD PJ ?G7A O=>78?7@@ V>8D >8J 78BCA?7M>?798' H98?:9='

C8@9:HCFC8? >8DT9: >H?798T78>H?798 PJ (%1 >8DT9: ?GC 4S(Y >8D >:C @I==J

78H9:O9:>?CD 78?9 GC: 43%, H=>7F GC:C78#

67 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 .<A<98I $B9: ,I8;L= *1: M.$,*N

^R# ,? >== ?7FCA :C=CB>8? GC:C?9' DC@C8D>8?' ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H>'

7A > A9BC:C7M8 M9BC:8FC8?>= C8?7?J' LG7HG G>A PCC8 C8M>MCD 78' >F98M 9?GC:

?G78MA' H98?:9==78M >HHCAA 78?9 7?A A9BC:C7M8 ?C::7?9:J' >8D O:CBC8?78M C8?:J'

O:CAC8HC' >8D :CA7DC8HC 9@ I8D9HIFC8?CD 78D7B7DI>=A L7?G78 7?A P9:DC:A# ,F98M

9?GC: >MC8H7CA' ?GC DC@C8D>8? OC:@9:FA ?GCAC >H?7B7?7CA PJ >8D ?G:9IMG 7?A

>MC8H7CATD7B7A798A cc ?GC +#0# S9:DC: <>?:9=' ?GC +#0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D

0CHI:7?J' ?GC +#0# SI:C>I 9@ %IA?9FA >8D S9:DC: <:9?CH?798' >8DT9: ?GC +#0#

$CO>:?FC8? 9@ ;IA?7HC' >H?78M L7?G78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ ?GC7:

>MC8HJT>@@7=7>?798 L7?G ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA#

^_# ,? >== ?7FCA :C=CB>8?' 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA L>A >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC

9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC: >A DC@78CD 78 RZ +#0#%# / R[Z\VGY 9@ DC@C8D>8?dA

4CDC:>= >MC8HJ' ?GC %<S' LG7HG L>A 78 ?I:8 >8 >MC8HJ 9: AIPD7B7A798VAY 9@ ?GC +#0#

$CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?J' > DCO>:?FC8? 9@ ?GC +#0#i ?GIA' ">8U>8>:CA




R\

L>A >H?78M L7?G78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC DC@C8D>8? >?

>== :C=CB>8? ?7FCA#

^^# <=>78?7@@A O=C>D H=>7FA I8DC: ?GC 43%, @9: n78QI:J' =9AA 9@ O:9OC:?J' 9:

OC:A98>= 78QI:J 9: DC>?G' H>IACD PJ ?GC L:98M@I= >H? 9: 9F7AA798 9@ >8J CFO=9JCC

9@ ?GC +#0# &9BC:8FC8?' LG7=C >H?78M L7?G78 ?GC AH9OC 9@ G7A 9@@7HC 9:

CFO=9JFC8?' I8DC: H7:HIFA?>8HCA LGC:C ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' 7@ > O:7B>?C OC:A98'

L9I=D PC =7>P=C ?9 ?GC O=>78?7@@A 78 >HH9:D>8HC L7?G ?GC =>L 9@ ?GC O=>HC LGC:C ?GC

>H? 9: 9F7AA798 9HHI::CD#n RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPYVEY

^e# $C@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA G>A L>7BCD 7?A A9BC:C7M8 7FFI87?J >8D G>A

H98AC8?CD ?9 PC AICD OI:AI>8? ?9 ?GC 43%,# RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPY' R[bEcR[Z\#

^[# ]G7=C >H?78M L7?G78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A >MC8HJ >8D

CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA F>=7H79IA=J'

>8DT9: L:98M@I==J' >8DT9: 9?GC:L7AC ?9:?I9IA=J DC?>78CD' :CA?:>78CD' P>??C:CD'

>AA>I=?CD' BC:P>==J >PIACD' >8D B79=>?CD 78 9?GC: FC8?>= >8D OGJA7H>= FC?G9DA'

78H=ID78M' PI? 89? =7F7?CD ?9' @9:HC ?G>? L>A 78?C8DCD ?9 PC DC>D=J @9:HC 98 ?GC

O=>78?7@@A' CBC8 ?G9IMG ?GCJ AG9LCD 89 :CA7A?>8HC ?9 ,MC8? ">8U>8>:CAf

DCF>8DA# 3GCAC >H?A H>IACD =7@Cc>=?C:78M OGJA7H>= >8D FC8?>= ?:>IF> >8D 78QI:7CA

?9 ?GC O=>78?7@@A#




RE

^b# ,=?G9IMG ?GC 43%, MC8C:>==J CNCFO?A @:9F =7>P7=7?J 78?C8?798>= ?9:?A

PJ 7? CFO=9JCCA' 78H=ID78M >AA>I=? >8D P>??C:J' ?G>? CNCFO?798 D9CA 89? >OO=J ?9

?GC 78?C8?798>= ?9:?A >==CMCD 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78?' LG7HG >:7AC 9I? 9@ ?GC H9FF7AA798

9@ AIHG ?9:?A PJ n78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC:A 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA

&9BC:8FC8?#n RZ +#0#%# / R[Z\VGY# ">8U>8>:CA L>A >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L

C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC: LG9 L>A CFO9LC:CD ?9 CNCHI?C AC>:HGCA' ?9 AC7UC CB7DC8HC'

>8DT9: ?9 F>aC >::CA?A @9: B79=>?798A 9@ 4CDC:>= =>Li >8D' GC L>A L9:a78M @9: ?GC

+# 0# S9:DC: <>?:9=' 9OC:>?78M I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L' >? ?GC ?7FC 9@ AIHG 78?C8?798>=

?9:?A# 3GC:C@9:C' ?GC 43%, >OO=7CA ?9 O:9B7DC =7>P7=7?J @9: G7A ?9:?A' CBC8 ?G9AC

LG7HG LC:C 78?C8?798>=' -+,. >8D L7?G9I? :CM>:D ?9 LGC?GC: ">8U>8>:CAd >H?7B7?7CA

LC:C :C=>?CD ?9 AC>:HGVCAY' AC7UI:CVAY 9: >::CA?VAY# /-$$01223 5, 6,7,. oooo +#0#

ooooo' E__ 0# %?# E^^E' E^^ec^[ VR\E_Y#

^Z# (8 ?GC >=?C:8>?7BC' O=>78?7@@A O=C>D I8DC: ?GC 43%, ?G>? 6@@7HC:T,MC8?

">8U>8>:CA 8CM=7MC8?=J 78QI:CD O=>78?7@@A CBC8 ?G9IMG ?GCJ AG9LCD 89 :CA7A?>8HC

?9 G7A DCF>8DA' ?GC:CPJ H>IA78M ?GCF =7@Cc>=?C:78M OGJA7H>= >8D FC8?>= 78QI:7CA#

">8U>8>:CA 8CM=7MC8?=J' L:98M@I==J' >8D ?9:?I9IA=J H>IACD ?GC 78QI:7CA ?9 ?GC

O=>78?7@@A# 09 ?G7A H=>7F 7A >=A9 @9: >== @9:FA 9@ 8CM=7MC8HC >8D L:98M@I= H98DIH? 78

?GC P:9>DCA? ?C:FA >==9LCD @9: ?9:?A 9@ >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8?

9@@7HC: 9@ > +87?CD 0?>?CA >MC8HJ 78 H>IA78M 78QI:J 9@ >89?GC:#




RR

^g# <=>78?7@@A >=A9 P:78M ?G7A 43%, H=>7F >M>78A? DC@C8D>8?' ?GC +87?CD

0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H>' @9: ?GC 8CM=7MC8HC 9@ 7?A CFO=9JCCA L7?G78 ?GC @9==9L78M

,MC8H7CAh %<S' +# 0# $CO>:?FC8? 9@ K9FC=>8D 0CHI:7?Ji (%1' >8D ?GC 4S(i >8D >8J

>8D >== 9@ 7?A CFO=9JCCA @9: 8CM=7MC8?=J AIOC:B7A78M' ?:>7878M' 78BCA?7M>?798' >8DT9:

:C?>7878M 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA#

e\# 3GCAC >H?A PJ 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA IO98 ?GC O=>78?7@@A LC:C

78?C8?798>=' L:98M@I=' >8D 8CM=7MC8?# 0OCH7@7H>==J' ">8U>8>:CA L>A >8 CFO=9JCC 9@

?GC DC@C8D>8? >8D >H?78M L7?G ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A 9@@7HC 9: CFO=9JFC8?'

>8D G>D > DI?J ?9 CNC:H7AC 9:D78>:J H>:C >8D >H? :C>A98>P=J >8D O:IDC8?=J LGC8

DC?>7878M OC:A98A# +8DC: ?GC =>LA 9@ ?GC 0?>?C 9@ 3CN>A' LGC:C ?GC >H?A 9HHI::CD'

> O:7B>?C OC:A98 L9I=D PC =7>P=C ?9 ?GC O=>78?7@@ @9: ?GCAC >H?A 9: 9F7AA798A# +8DC:

RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPY' ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C ?9 O=>78?7@@A @9: ?GC7: D>F>MCA

PC=9L @9: ?GC OC:A98>= 78QI:7CA >8D D>F>MCA DCAH:7PCD PC=9L# RZ +#0#%# / R[b^#

,B@C: O P 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 :H< .$,* EB9 *==8@I: 8CA >8::<9F

eE# , OC:A98 H9FF7?A >8 >AA>I=?R I8DC: 3CN>A =>L 7@ GCh

VEY 78?C8?798>==J' a89L78M=J' 9: :CHa=CAA=J H>IACA P9D7=J 78QI:J ?9 >89?GC:i

R K7A?9:7H>==J' >AA>I=? >8D P>??C:J LC:C ?L9 ACO>:>?C ?9:?A' PI? ?9D>J ?GC ?C:FA >:C IACD

?9MC?GC: 9: 78?C:HG>8MC>P=J 78 3CN>A =>L ?9 :C@C: ?9 H98DIH? DC@78CD >A n>AA>I=?n 78 ?GC 312,0

<1),- %6$1# 3GC <C8>= %9DC DC@787?798 ?>aC8 @:9F 0CH?798 RR#\E >P9BC G>A PCC8 GC=D ?9 >OO=J

78 H7B7= >A LC== >A H:7F78>= H>ACA#




R_

VRY 78?C8?798>==J 9: a89L78M=J ?G:C>?C8A >89?GC: L7?G 7FF78C8? P9D7=J

78QI:Ji 9:

V_Y 78?C8?798>==J 9: a89L78M=J H>IACA OGJA7H>= H98?>H? L7?G >89?GC: LGC8

GC 9: AGC a89LA 9: AG9I=D :C>A98>P=J PC=7CBC ?G>? ?GC 9?GC: L7==

:CM>:D ?GC H98?>H? >A 9@@C8A7BC 9: O:9B9H>?7BC#

7%% 8)$9/)1( 7(21%!. *':, 5, ;+%&. gRg 0#]#RD eE_' eRR V3CN# ,OO#cc0>8 ,8?9879

Egg[' L:7? DC87CDYi <=-$+%1! 5, >,7,. g\g 0#]#RD RZR' RgR V3CN# ,OO#cc49:? ]9:?G

Egge' L:7? DC87CDY# S>ACD 98 ?GC @>H?A 9@ ?G7A H>AC' C>HG 9@ ?GCAC DC@787?798A L>A

FC? PJ ">8U>8>:CAd >H?798A' CBC8 ?G9IMG ?9 O:9BC >AA>I=? ?GC O=>78?7@@A 8CCD 98=J

AG9L 98C#

eR# ,A ?9 ?GC @7:A? C=CFC8?' >A D7AHIAACD 78 DC?>7= >P9BC 78 0CH?798 4'

O>:>M:>OGA E^c^R' ">8U>8>:CA 78?C8?798>==J' a89L78M=J' >8D :CHa=CAA=J H>IACD

P9D7=J 78QI:J ?9 C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A# KC D:>MMCD ?GCF 9I? 9@ G7A ?:IHa @9:H7P=J'

CBC8 ?G9IMG ?GCJ LC:C 89? 9@@C:78M :CA7A?>8HC' D:>MMCD "#$#%#&# IO > G7==# KC

:9IMGCD ?GCF IO' a87@CD "#$#%#&# >8D GC: D>IMG?C:' )#-#"#%#' A?:>8M=CD >8D

HG9aCD ?GCF' ?L7A?CD C>HG 9@ ?GC7: 8CHaA >A 7@ >??CFO?78M ?9 a7== ?GCF' >8D

:C8DC:CD ?GCF I8H98AH79IA @9: P:7C@ OC:79DA# KC D7D8d? A?9O H>IA78M P9D7=J 78QI:J

?9 "#$#%#&# I8?7= AGC >OOC>:CD I8H98AH79IA 9: DC>D' >8D ?GC8 LC8? 98 ?9 G7A 8CN?

B7H?7F# ,@?C: 78@=7H?78M P9D7=J 78QI:J 98 GC: @9: A9FC ?7FC' ">8U>8>:CA CBC8?I>==J

=C@? )#-#"#%# @9: I8H98AH79IA 9: DC>D' >8D H9BC:CD IO GC: P9DJ L7?G D7:?' =C>BCA'

>8D DCP:7A' 89 D9IP? G9O78M AGC L9I=D8d? PC @9I8D @9: A9FC ?7FC#




R^

e_# ,A ?9 ?GC ACH98D C=CFC8?' 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA 78?C8?798>==J

>8D a89L78M=J P9?G H>IACD >8D ?G:C>?C8CD C>HG O=>78?7@@ L7?G P9D7=J G>:F'

>=?G9IMG 898C G>D :CA7A?CD PC78M ?>aC8 78?9 HIA?9DJ 9: L>A @7MG?78M G7F# SJ ?GC

A?:>8M=78M >8D HG9a78M 9@ "#$#%#&# >8D GC: F789: D>IMG?C:' )#-#"#%#' ?9 ?GC O978?

?G>? ?GCJ L9I=D ?CFO9:>:7=J =9AC H98AH79IA8CAA' >8D ?L7A?78M ?GC7: 8CHaA >A 7@ ?9

P:C>a ?GCF' ?GCJ ?G9IMG? ?GC7: P9D7=J G>:F L9I=D PC ?G>? C>HG L9I=D D7C# KC

A?>PPCD >8D a87@CD "#$#%#&# >8D )#-#"#%#' >8D A?9OOCD 98=J >@?C: C>HG >OOC>:CD

?9 G>BC =9A? H98AH79IA8CAA 9: PC DC>D# ]GC8 ">8U>8>:CA :C?I:8CD ?9 ?GC ?:IHa'

G>B78M =C@? ?GC 9?GC: ?L9 L9FC8 78 > DCAC:?CD >:C>' >8D >@?C: ;#"#,#1# GC>:D

LG>? G>D PCC8 G>OOC878M' AGC >AAIFCD ?GCJ LC:C DC>D >8D ?G>? AGC L>A 8CN?#

0GC @C>:CD @9: GC: =7@C#

e^# 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA @I:?GC: 78?C8?798>==J >8D a89L78M=J

C8M>MCD 78 OGJA7H>= H98?>H? L7?G C>HG O=>78?7@@ LGC8 GC a8CL 9: AG9I=D

:C>A98>P=J PC=7CBC ?G>? ?GC O=>78?7@@A L9I=D :CM>:D ?GC H98?>H? >A 9@@C8A7BC 9:

O:9B9H>?7BC# KC L>A :9IMG >8D 9@@C8A7BC L7?G C>HG O=>78?7@@' >8D C8M>MCD 78

O:9B9H>?7BC OGJA7H>= H98?>H? L7?G ?GC ?L9 F789:A# (8DCCD' GC G>D ?9 :CA?:>78 C>HG

O=>78?7@@ LGC8 GC C8M>MCD 78 H98?>H? L7?G ?GCF A9 ?GCJ H9I=D 89? :CA7A? 9: :I8

>L>J#




Re

ee# 49: ?GCAC :C>A98A' ">8U>8>:CA >AA>I=?CD C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A' >A

?G>? ?C:F 7A a89L8 I8DC: 3CN>A =>L# KC D7D A9 >A >8 CFO=9JCC 9@ ?GC +87?CD

0?>?CA' 78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8?' >8D I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L# KC

L>A >=A9 >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC: 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA# RZ

+#0#%# / R[Z\VGY# 3GC:C@9:C' I8DC: ?GC 43%,' ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C @9: G7A

>H?798A' RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPY' R[bEcR[Z\' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A 78QI:7CA >8D

D>F>MCA >A =>?C: AC? 9I? 78 ACH?798 WKX 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78? 98 D>F>MCA#

,B@C: Q P 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 :H< .$,* EB9 .8I=< "LG9;=BCL<C:R.8I=< *99<=:

e[# +8DC: 3CN>A =>L' ?GC C=CFC8?A 9@ @>=AC 7FO:7A98FC8? >:Ch

VEY L7==@I= DC?C8?798'

VRY L7?G9I? H98AC8?' >8D

V_Y L7?G9I? >DC`I>?C QIA?7@7H>?798 9: >I?G9:7?J 9@ =>L#

7%% ?)'+)$$@! A22+ /)13%(!. *':, 5, B2='!2'. ZgE 0#]#RD [^\' [^^ V3CN# EggeY# 7%%

)$!2 8)$9/)1( 7(21%!. *':, 5, ?2+1-C"%D. gR 0#]#_D e\R' e\[ V3CN# R\\RYi /)1(-'%D

5, E'C$-!=' R[b 0#]#_D eRE' eRg V3CN# ,OO# cc ,IA?78 R\\Z' OC? DC87CDY#

eb# , OC:A98 7A @>=AC=J 7FO:7A98CDX I8DC: 3CN>A =>L LGC8 AGC 7A L7==@I==J

DC?>78CD' L7?G9I? =CM>= QIA?7@7H>?798' >M>78A? GC: H98AC8?' LGC?GC: AIHG DC?C8?798

PC C@@CH?CD PJ B79=C8HC' PJ ?G:C>?' 9: PJ >8J 9?GC: FC>8A ?G>? :CA?:>78A > OC:A98

@:9F F9B78M @:9F 98C O=>HC ?9 >89?GC:# E 312,0 <#;#%# / [#E#




R[

eZ# 68C FC>8A 9@ H9FF7??78M > @>=AC 7FO:7A98FC8? 7A PJ E8I=< 899<=:#

312,0 <1),- %6$1 / R\#\E# , @>=AC >::CA? 9HHI:A LGC8 > OC:A98 F>aCA >8 >::CA?

L7?G9I? QIA?7@7H>?798 9: >I?G9:7?J 9@ =>L# <$)13 5, F%)1+. e_Z 4# 0IOO# Z\\' Z\[

V0#$# 3CN>A EgZRY# , @>=AC >::CA? >=L>JA :CAI=?A 78 @>=AC 7FO:7A98FC8?# 8=-1$ 5,

G%1'' ^\b 4#RD bZE' bg_ Ve?G %7:# Eg[ZY#

eg# 1BC8 ?G9IMG =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC:A >:C >I?G9:7UCD ?9 DC?>78 9:

C@@CH? CBC8 L>::>8?=CAA >::CA?A 9@ OC:A98A I8DC: HC:?>78 H7:HIFA?>8HCA' ?GC

O:7B7=CMC H>8 PC =9A? 7@ ?GC F>88C: 9@ DC?C8?798 7A I8:C>A98>P=C' >A GC:C# H-$$)1+

H%#@( 7(21%!. *':, 5, 7-$5). E^Z 0#]#_D _b\' _bR V3CN# R\\^Y# (? 8CCD 98=J PC AG9L8

?G>? ?GC DC?C8?798 7?AC=@ L>A I8=>L@I=#

[\# (8 ?G7A H>AC' 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA L7==@I==J DC?>78CD C>HG 9@ ?GC

O=>78?7@@A' L7?G9I? ?GC7: H98AC8?' >8D L7?G9I? >DC`I>?C QIA?7@7H>?798 9: >I?G9:7?J

9@ =>L# ]GC8 %S< 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA DC?>78CD ?GC O=>78?7@@A' >8D D7D 89?

?>aC ?GCF D7:CH?=J ?9 > %S< 9: 9?GC: M9BC:8FC8?>= @>H7=7?J' G7A DC?C8?798 PCH>FC

I8=>L@I=# KC G>D ?GC7: 787?7>= H98AC8? ?9 DC?>78 ?GCF >8D ?>aC ?GCF ?9 > %S<

@>H7=7?J m 89? ?9 >AA>I=? >8D OGJA7H>==J >PIAC ?GCF' 89? ?9 IAC DC>D=J @9:HC' >8D

HC:?>78=J 89? ?9 OG9?9M:>OG ?GC F789:A L7?G9I? H=9?G78M 9: O>:?7>==J H=9?GCD# 3GC

@>H? ?G>? ">8U>8>:CA G>D ?9 aCCO ?GCF 78 :CA?:>78?A DI:78M ?GC C8?7:C ?7FC ?GCJ

LC:C L7?G G7F 7A @I:?GC: CB7DC8HC ?GCJ LC:C @>=AC=J 7FO:7A98CD# 3GC:C 7A 89




Rb

>DC`I>?C QIA?7@7H>?798 9: >I?G9:7?J 9@ =>L @9: ">8U>8>:CAd DC?C8?798 9@ ?GC

O=>78?7@@A A9 GC H9I=D >AA>I=? >8D P>??C: ?GCF' ?9:?I:C ?GCF' >8D 8C>:=J a7== ?GCF#

[E# 3GC O=>78?7@@Ad @>=AC 7FO:7A98FC8? 9:DC>= D7D8d? C8D LGC8 ?GCJ LC:C

:CAHICD @:9F ">8U>8>:CA# 49: LG>? ?GCJ PC=7CBC L>A ?G:CC D>JA' CBC8 >@?C: ?GC7:

G>::9L78M 9:DC>=' "#$#%#&# >8D )#-#"#%# LC:C ACO>:>?CD' >8D 89? OC:F7??CD ?9

ACC C>HG 9?GC:# 3GCJ LC:C M7BC8 =7F7?CD 78@9:F>?798 >P9I? C>HG 9?GC:# ,M>78'

CBC8 >@?C: ?GC 9:DC>= AGCdD CNOC:7C8HCD >? ?GC G>8DA 9@ ?GC7: @C==9L @CDC:>= >MC8?'

?GC F789: O=>78?7@@ ;#"#,#1# L>A aCO? I8DC: MI>:D >8D 89? OC:F7??CD ?9 PC L7?G

GC: @>F7=J @9: 8C>:=J > F98?G#

[R# 49: ?GCAC :C>A98A' ">8U>8>:CA @>=AC=J 7FO:7A98CD C>HG 9@ ?GC

O=>78?7@@A' >A ?G>? ?C:F 7A a89L8 I8DC: 3CN>A =>L# KC >=A9 @>=AC=J >::CA?CD ?GCF'

>A ?G>? ?C:F 7A I8DC:A?99D I8DC: 3CN>A =>L' PCH>IAC GC >OO>:C8?=J 8CBC: G>D >8J

78?C8?798 9@ DC?>7878M ?GCF =>L@I==J ?9 ?>aC ?GCF D7:CH?=J ?9 > %S< DC?C8?798

HC8?C: 9: 9@@7HCi :>?GC: GC DC?>78CD ?GCF @9: G7A 9L8 OC:A98>= OI:O9ACA' ?9

>AA>I=? >8D ?9:?I:C ?GCF# ">8U>8>:CA D7D A9 >A >8 CFO=9JCC 9@ ?GC +87?CD

0?>?CA' 78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8?' >8D I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L# KC

L>A >=A9 >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC: 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA# RZ

+#0#%# / R[Z\VGY# 3GC:C@9:C' I8DC: ?GC 43%,' ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C @9: G7A




RZ

>H?798A' RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPY' R[bEcR[Z\' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A 78QI:7CA >8D

D>F>MCA >A =>?C: AC? 9I? 78 ACH?798 WKX 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78? 98 D>F>MCA#

,B@C: S P 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 :H< .$,* EB9 "C:<C:;BC8I 8CA#<TI;T<C: "CEI;1:;BC BE &LB:;BC8I (;=:9<==

[_# 3GC C=CFC8?A 9@ 78?C8?798>= 78@=7H?798 9@ CF9?798>= D7A?:CAA V((1$Y 78

3CN>A >:Ch

VEY ?GC DC@C8D>8? >H?CD 78?C8?798>==J 9: :CHa=CAA=Ji

VRY G7A H98DIH? L>A CN?:CFC >8D 9I?:>MC9IAi

V_Y ?GC >H?798A 9@ ?GC DC@C8D>8? H>IACD ?GC O=>78?7@@ CF9?798>= D7A?:CAAi

>8D

V^Y ?GC CF9?798>= D7A?:CAA AI@@C:CD PJ ?GC O=>78?7@@ L>A ACBC:C# 7%%

IJK&)' 5, IJK&)'' Zee 0#]#RD [Eg' [RE V3CN# Egg_Y#

[^# ]G7=C ?GC O=>78?7@@A G>BC > H>IAC 9@ >H?798 @9: >AA>I=?' >8D @9: ?GC7:

D>F>MCA @9: FC8?>= >8MI7AG @9: ?GC7: 78QI:7CA >8D ?GC >AA>I=?' ?GCJ >=A9 G>BC >

H>IAC 9@ >H?798 @9: 78?C8?798>= 78@=7H?798 9@ CF9?798>= D7A?:CAA# ">8J 9@ ?GC

78QI:7CA 78?C8?798>==J >8D DC=7PC:>?C=J 78@=7H?CD PJ ">8U>8>:CA DI:78M G7A P:I?>=

>8D D:>L8 9I? ?9:?I:C 9@ C>HG O=>78?7@@ L7== :CF>78 FC8?>= AH>:A JC>:A >@?C:

OGJA7H>= 78QI:7CA D7F787AG# 1>HG 9@ ?GC <=>78?7@@Ad CF9?798>= D7A?:CAA >A > :CAI=? 9@

?GC7: 9:DC>= 7A ACBC:C# 3G7A 7A 78 O>:? PCH>IAC '2'% 2L (=% -'M"1-%! (=%K !"!()-'%+

J%1% )::-+%'()$ # ">8U>8>:CA FC?G9D7H>==J >8D DC=7PC:>?C=J >AA>I=?CD' A?:>8M=CD'




Rg

HG9aCD' @98D=CD' O:9B9H>?7BC=J ?9IHGCD' >8D ?9:?I:CD C>HG L9F>8 9: M7:=' 98C PJ

98C' 9BC: ACBC:>= G9I:A' 78 ACBC:>= =9H>?798A' >8D 78 ACBC:>= L>JA# ,? F9A? ?7FCA'

C>HG O=>78?7@@ GC>:D >8DT9: L7?8CAACD ">8U>8>:CA >AA>I=?78M >8D ?9:?I:78M GC:

@:7C8DA# 49: >? =C>A? 98C F789: O=>78?7@@' ;#"#,#1#' ">8U>8>:CA >AA>I=?CD >8D

?9:?I:CD GC: @9: 8C>:=J > R^cG9I: OC:79D# 49: ?GC >DI=? O=>78?7@@' "#$#%#&#' AGC G>D

?9 L>?HG >8D =7A?C8 LG7=C GC >AA>I=?CD' >PIACD' O:9B9H>?7BC=J ?9IHGCD' >8D

OG9?9M:>OGCD I8H=9?GCD' GC: F789: D>IMG?C:# 3GC F789: O=>78?7@@ )#-#"#%# G>D ?9

=7A?C8 ?9 ">8U>8>:CA >PIAC' PC>?' >8D ?9:?I:C GC: F9?GC:#

[e# 3GCAC a78DA 9@ >AA>I=?A' LG7HG 78H=IDC O:9B9H>?7BC >8D 9@@C8A7BC

?9IHG78M LG7=C ?GC 9?GC: OC:A98 7A :CA?:>78CD >8D GC=O=CAA' >:C >P9I? 98C OC:A98

DCF98A?:>?78M G7A O9LC: >8D D9F78798 9BC: >89?GC:i > DC=7PC:>?C >??CFO? ?9

GIF7=7>?C >8D DCM:>DC >89?GC: OC:A98 cc C>HG O=>78?7@@# 3GC O=>78?7@@Ad 78QI:7CA

D7D8d? G>OOC8 PJ >HH7DC8?# ,8D ?GC7: ?:>IF> D7D 89? C8D LGC8 ?GCJ LC:C :CAHICD

@:9F ">8U>8>:CA# "#$#%#&# >8D GC: F789: D>IMG?C:' )#-#"#%' LC:C ACO>:>?CD @9:

?G:CC D>JA LG7=C ?GC 9?GC: H9I=D 98=J 7F>M78C ?GC A?>?C ?GC 9?GC: L>A 78 >@?C:

?GC7: 9:DC>=# 1BC8 >@?C: ?GC 87MG?F>:C AGCdD CNOC:7C8HCD' ?GC F789: ?GC8cE^c

JC>:c9=D O=>78?7@@ ;#"#,#1#' LG9dD PCC8 ?9:?I:CD @9: 8C>:=J R^ G9I:A' L>A 89?

OC:F7??CD ?9 PC L7?G GC: @>F7=J @9: > F98?G# 1>HG O=>78?7@@ G>A ACBC:C O9A?c




_\

?:>IF>?7H A?:CAA D7A9:DC: V<30$Y >A > :CAI=? 9@ GC: G>::9L78M 9:DC>= L7?G

">8U>8>:CA#

[[# 3GC +#0# 7A >=A9 =7>P=C @9: ?GC 78?C8?798>= 78@=7H?798 9@ CF9?798>=

D7A?:CAA PJ 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA 98 ?GC O=>78?7@@A PCH>IAC 7? 7A > WH=>7F >:7A78M 9I?

9@ >AA>I=?' P>??C:J' @>=AC 7FO:7A98FC8?' >8D @>=AC >::CA?#X RZ +#0# %# / R[Z\VGY#

[b# ">8U>8>:CA 78?C8?798>==J 78@=7H?CD CF9?798>= D7A?:CAA 98 ?GC O=>78?7@@A

LG7=C >8D >A >8 CFO=9JCC 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' 78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7A

CFO=9JFC8?' >8D I8DC: H9=9: 9@ =>L# KC L>A >=A9 >8 78BCA?7M>?7BC 9: =>L

C8@9:HCFC8? 9@@7HC: 9@ ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA# RZ +#0#%# / R[Z\VGY# 3GC:C@9:C' I8DC:

?GC 43%,' ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C @9: G7A >H?798A' RZ +#0#%# / E_^[VPY' R[bEc

R[Z\' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A 78QI:7CA >8D D>F>MCA >A =>?C: AC? 9I? 78 ACH?798

WKX 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78? 98 D>F>MCA#

,B@C: U P 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 :H< .$,* EB9 #<TI;T<C1< BE *T<C: 08CV8C89<=

[Z# ,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA G>D > DI?J' LG7=C >H?78M 78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC

9@ G7A CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC +#0# &9BC:8FC8?' ?9 CNC:H7AC :C>A98>P=J O:IDC8? >8D

9:D78>:J H>:C 9@ > %S< 9@@7HC: 78 ?GC CNC:H7AC 9@ G7A DI?7CA 78 DC?>7878M' :CA?:>7878M'

?:>8AO9:?78M' >8D 78 G7A ?:C>?FC8? 9@ 9?GC:A' 78H=ID78M ?GC O=>78?7@@A# KC >=A9 G>D >

DI?J ?9 :C@:>78 @:9F O:9N7F>?C=J H>IA78M OC:A98>= 78QI:7CA >8D D>F>MCA ?9 9?GC:A'

>8D ?9 :C@:>78 @:9F L:98M@I=' 8CM=7MC8?' 9: :CHa=CAA >H?A 9: 9F7AA798A# KC @I:?GC:




_E

G>D > DI?J ?9 >H? L7?G H>:C ?9 @9==9L >OO:9O:7>?C O9=7H7CA >8D O:9HCDI:CA' >8D 89?

?9 >==9L > A7?I>?798 ?9 DCBC=9O 78 LG7HG GC L9I=D' ?G:9IMG =>Ha 9@ DIC H>:C' 78QI:C

>89?GC: GIF>8 PC78M#

[g# ">8U>8>:CA D7D 89? CNC:H7AC :C>A98>P=C H>:C' 89: D7D GC PCG>BC >A

>8 9:D78>:J O:IDC8? %S< 9@@7HC:# ">8U>8>:CA L>A 8CM=7MC8?' L:98M@I=' >8D

:CHa=CAA' >8D P:C>HGCD G7A DI?J 9@ H>:C 98 ">:HG ER' R\E^' LGC8 GC DC?>78CD ?GC

?G:CC O=>78?7@@A L7?G9I? ?>a78M ?GCF D7:CH?=J ?9 > %S< 9: 9?GC: >OO:9O:7>?C

M9BC:8FC8? A?>?798i LGC8 GC IACD CNHCAA7BC @9:HC >M>78A? ?GC O=>78?7@@Ai LGC8 GC

:9IMG=J ?:C>?CD ?GCF >8D H>IACD ?GCF 78QI:J CBC8 ?G9IMG ?GCJ D7D 89? :CA7A? G7A

787?7>= DC?C8?798i LGC8 GC L:98M@I==J' 9@@C8A7BC=J' >8D O:9B9H>?7BC=J ?9IHGCD

?GCF LG7=C ?GCJ LC:C :CA?:>78CDi LGC8 GC HG9aCD' A?:>8M=CD' 9: ?L7A?CD ?GC7:

8CHaAi LGC8 GC HI? ?GCF L7?G > a87@Ci >8D LGC8 GC O=>HCD G7FAC=@ 78 > O9A7?798

?9 L:98M@I==J >8D I8QIA?7@7>P=J IAC CNHCAA7BC 9: 9@@C8A7BC @9:HC L7?G ?GC O=>78?7@@A'

LG7HG :CAI=?CD 78 ?GC7: 78QI:7CA# , DCAH:7O?798 9@ ?GCAC CBC8?A 7A >P9BC 78 ACH?798

4' O>:>M:>OGA E^c^R# 3GC P:C>HG 9@ ">8U>8>:CAd DI?7CA' >8D G7A L:98M@I= >8D

:CHa=CAA H98DIH? >M>78A? ?GC O=>78?7@@A' O:9N7F>?C=J H>IACD 78QI:7CA >8D D>F>MCA

?9 ?GC O=>78?7@@A' 78 ?GC O>A? >8D @I?I:C' >A AC? 9I? 78 ACH?798 WKX 9@ ?G7A %9FO=>78?

98 D>F>MCA#




_R

b\# 3GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C @9: G7A H98DIH? I8DC: ?GC 4CDC:>= 39:?

%=>7FA ,H?' RZ +#0# %# / R[bE' C? AC`#' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC <=>78?7@@A 78QI:7CA >8D

D>F>MCA >A =>?C: AC? 9I? 78 ACH?798 WKX 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78? 98 D>F>MCA7

,B@C: W P 2;8K;I;:F 'CA<9 :H< .$,* EB9 #<TI;T<C1< BE -EE;1<9=

X *T<C:= -:H<9 :H8C 08CV8C89<=

bE# <=>78?7@@A >==CMC ?G>? ?GC +87?CD 0?>?CA' PJ >8D ?G9IMG 9?GC: >MC8?A 9:

CFO=9JCCA' L>A 8CM=7MC8?' >8D ?G>? 8CM=7MC8HC L>A > D7:CH? >8D O:9N7F>?C H>IAC

9@ C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@dA 78QI:7CA# 3GC O=>78?7@@A @I:?GC: O=C>D ?G>? ?GC +87?CD

0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H> L>A 8CM=7MC8? 78 98C 9: F9:C 9@ ?GC @9==9L78M F>88C:A ?G>? L>A

> O:9N7F>?C H>IAC >8DT9: A7M87@7H>8? H98?:7PI?78M @>H?9: ?GC ?9 ?GC O=>78?7@@Ad

78QI:7CAh

># )CM=7MC8? K7:78M 9@ 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA O:79: ?9 ">:HG ER'

R\Eî

P# )CM=7MC8HC 9@ %S< ACH?9:ATA?>?798A >8D 9@@7HC:A' 78H=ID78M 9@

1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA' O:79: ?9 >8D 78H=ID78M 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\Eî

H# )CM=7MC8? :C?C8?798 9@ %S< 9@@7HC:A' 78H=ID78M 9@ 1A?CP>8

">8U>8>:CA' O:79: ?9 >8D 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\Eî

D# )CM=7MC8? @>7=I:C' 78H=ID78M PJ ?GC 4S(T(%1' ?9 OC:@9:F

>OO:9O:7>?C 78BCA?7M>?798 9@ %S< 6@@7HC: 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA O:79: ?9 ">:HG ER'




__

R\E^' O>:?7HI=>:=J 78 B7CL 9@ O:79: H9FO=>78?ATCB7DC8HC 9@ G7A >PIAC' >AA>I=?VAY'

>8DT9: CNHCAA7BC IAC 9@ @9:HC PJ 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA L7?G :CM>:D ?9 @CF>=CA LG7=C

O:CB79IA=J OC:@9:F78M >I?G9:7UCD DI?7CA 9: 9?GC:L7AC 98cDI?Ji

C# )CM=7MC8? @>7=I:C ?9 G>BC >HHI:>?C=J >8DT9: >DCÌ>?C=J

:CO9:?CD :CAI=?A 9@ 78BCA?7M>?798 H98HC:878M' >8DT9: ?>aC8 >OO:9O:7>?C

O:9AOCH?7BCT:CFCD7>= >H?798 L7?G :CM>:D ?9' %S< 6@@7HC: 1A?CP>8 ">8U>8>:CA

O:79: ?9 ">:HG ER' R\E^' 78H=ID78M PJ ?GC 4S(T(%1i

@# )CM=7MC8HC 78 ?GC C8@9:HCFC8? 9@ O9=7H7CA' O:9HCDI:CA'

:CMI=>?798A' >8DT 9: 9?GC: D7:CH?7BCA O:79: ?9 >8D 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\Eî

M# )CM=7MC8? IAC 9@ 78DCOC8DC8? H98?:>H?9:A 9: 9I?A7DC >MC8H7CA

?9 H98DIH? 9?GC:L7AC @I8D>FC8?>= O:9HCAACA :C=>?78M ?9 G7:78M' AIOC:B7A798'

>8DT9: :C?C8?798 9@ %S< CFO=9JCCA O:79: ?9 >8D 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER' R\Eî

G# )CM=7MC8? @>7=I:C ?9 G>BC C8AI:CD ?G>? %S< 9@@7HC: 1A?CP>8

">8U>8>:CA L>A 89? >=98C' >8DT9: D7D 89? G>BC 7A9=>?CD >HHCAA ?9' @CF>=CA'

78H=ID78M F7M:>8?AT7FF7M:>8?A' LG7=C OC:@9:F78M G7A Q9P 98 9: >P9I? ">:HG ER'

R\E^' O>:?7HI=>:=J 78 B7CL 9@ O:79: H9FO=>78?ATCB7DC8HC 9@ >PIAC' >AA>I=?VAY'

>8DT9: CNHCAA7BC IAC 9@ @9:HC PJ 6@@7HC: ">8U>8>:CA L7?G :CM>:D ?9 9?GC: @CF>=CA

LG7=C O:CB79IA=J OC:@9:F78M >I?G9:7UCD DI?7CA 9: 9?GC:L7AC 98cDI?Ji >8D




_^

7# ,== 9?GC: @CDC:>= >8D A?>?C =CM>= >:MIFC8?A' ?GC9:7CA'

D9H?:78CA' :CMI=>?798A' A?>?I?CA >8DT9: =>LTH9FF98 =>L ?G>? 7A 9: F>J PCH9FC

>OO=7H>P=C ?9 ?G7A H>AC 9: ?GC @>H?A GC:C78 >@?C: ?GC O=>78?7@@A G>BC G>D > @I==

9OO9:?I87?J ?9 H98DIH? D7AH9BC:J >HH9:D78M ?9 ?GC 5I=CA 9@ 4CDC:>= %7B7=

<:9HCDI:C#

bR# 3GC +87?CD 0?>?CA 7A =7>P=C @9: G7A H98DIH? I8DC: ?GC 4CDC:>= 39:?

%=>7FA ,H?' RZ +#0# %# / R[bE' C? AC`' >8D C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A 78QI:7CA >8D

D>F>MCA >A AC? 9I? PC=9L 78 ACH?798 WKX 78 ?G7A %9FO=>78? 98 D>F>MCA#

%7 (8L8T<=

b_# ,A > D7:CH? >8D O:9N7F>?C H>IAC 9@ ?GC 78?C8?798>= ?9:?A >8DT9:

8CM=7MC8HC 9@ 6@@7HC:T,MC8? ">8U>8>:CA' >8DT9: ?GC 8CM=7MC8HC 9@ 9@@7HC:AT>MC8?A

9?GC: ?G>8 ">8U>8>:CA' >== >A AC? @9:?G >P9BC 78 ?GC H9I:AC >8D AH9OC 9@ G7AT?GC7:

CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC $C@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA' O=>78?7@@' "#$#%#&' (8D7B7DI>==J'

AI@@C:CD 78 ?GC O>A? >8D L7==' L7?G :C>A98>P=C FCD7H>= O:9P>P7=7?J' H98?78IC ?9

AI@@C:' ACBC:C 78QI:7CA' 78H=ID78M PI? 89? =7F7?CD ?9h O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= O>78i

O>A? >8D @I?I:C FC8?>= >8MI7AG >8D AI@@C:78Mi O>A? >8D @I?I:C FCD7H>=' G9AO7?>='

>8D GC>=?G H>:C CNOC8ACAi O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= D7A@7MI:CFC8?i O>A? >8D @I?I:C

OGJA7H>= 7FO>7:FC8?i O>A? =9A? L>MCA >8D =9AA 9@ @I?I:C C>:878M H>O>H7?Ji O>A? >8D




_e

@I?I:C =9AA 9@ H98A9:?7IFi O:9OC:?J D>F>MCi >8D' >== 9?GC: D>F>MCA OC:F7??CD

I8DC: ?GC 43%, >8D 3CN>A =>L#

b^# ,A > D7:CH? >8D O:9N7F>?C H>IAC 9@ ?GC 78?C8?798>= ?9:?A >8DT9:



CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC DC@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA' O=>78?7@@' "#$#%#&' ,A )CN? 4:7C8D

9@ )#-#"#%#' > "789:' AI@@C:CD 78 ?GC O>A? >8D L7==' L7?G :C>A98>P=C FCD7H>=

O:9P>P7=7?J' H98?78IC ?9 AI@@C:' ACBC:C 78QI:7CA' 78H=ID78M PI? 89? =7F7?CD ?9h O>A?

>8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= O>78i O>A? >8D @I?I:C FC8?>= >8MI7AG >8D AI@@C:78Mi O>A? >8D

@I?I:C FCD7H>=' G9AO7?>=' >8D GC>=?G H>:C CNOC8ACAi O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>=

D7A@7MI:CFC8?i O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= 7FO>7:FC8?i O>A? =9A? L>MCA >8D =9AA 9@

@I?I:C C>:878M H>O>H7?Ji O>A? >8D @I?I:C =9AA 9@ H98A9:?7IFi O:9OC:?J D>F>MCi

>8D' >== 9?GC: D>F>MCA OC:F7??CD I8DC: ?GC 43%, >8D 3CN>A =>L#

be# ,A > D7:CH? >8D O:9N7F>?C H>IAC 9@ ?GC 78?C8?798>= ?9:?A >8DT9:



CFO=9JFC8? L7?G ?GC $C@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA' O=>78?7@@' $#1#&#' ,A )CN? 4:7C8D 9@

;#"#,#1#' > "789:' AI@@C:CD 78 ?GC O>A? >8D L7==' L7?G :C>A98>P=C FCD7H>=

O:9P>P7=7?J' H98?78IC ?9 AI@@C:' ACBC:C 78QI:7CA' 78H=ID78M PI? 89? =7F7?CD ?9h O>A?




_[

>8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= O>78i O>A? >8D @I?I:C FC8?>= >8MI7AG >8D AI@@C:78Mi O>A? >8D

@I?I:C FCD7H>=' G9AO7?>=' >8D GC>=?G H>:C CNOC8ACAi O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>=

D7A@7MI:CFC8?i O>A? >8D @I?I:C OGJA7H>= 7FO>7:FC8?i O>A? =9A? L>MCA >8D =9AA 9@

@I?I:C C>:878M H>O>H7?Ji O>A? >8D @I?I:C =9AA 9@ H98A9:?7IFi O:9OC:?J D>F>MCi

>8D' >== 9?GC: D>F>MCA OC:F7??CD I8DC: ?GC 43%, >8D 3CN>A =>L#

b[# 3GC D>F>MCA A9IMG? PJ C>HG O=>78?7@@ >:C L7?G78 ?GC QI:7AD7H?798>=

=7F7?A 9@ ?G7A %9I:? >8D' ?9 ?GC CN?C8? :C`I7:CD ?9 PC O=C>DCD PJ 3CN>A ->L' C>HG

O=>78?7@@ GC:CPJ ACCaA F98C?>:J :C=7C@ 9BC: pE'\\\'\\\' PI? 89? 78 CNHCAA 9@ ?GC

>F9I8?A H=>7FCD PJ C>HG 9@ ?GCF' :CAOCH?7BC=J' 78 ?GC7: @9:FA 04cge#

"7 498F<9

49: ?GCAC :C>A98A' C>HG 9@ ?GC O=>78?7@@A DCF>8D QIDMFC8? >M>78A?

DC@C8D>8? +87?CD 0?>?CA 9@ ,FC:7H> @9: ?GC @9==9L78Mh

># ,H?I>= D>F>MCA 78 >8 >F9I8? LG7HG CNHCCDA ?GC ?G:CAG9=D 8CHCAA>:J

@9: ?G7A %9I:?dA QI:7AD7H?798' PI? LG7HG D9CA 89? CNHCCD ?GC >F9I8? H=>7FCD 78

C>HG 9@ ?GC7: @9:FA 04cge#

P# %9A?A 9@ AI7?#

H# <9A?cQIDMFC8? 78?C:CA?#

D# ,== 9?GC: :C=7C@ ?9 LG7HG ?GC O=>78?7@@A DCCF ?GCFAC=BCA C8?7?=CD' >8D

?G>? ?GC H9I:? DCCFA QIA? >8D >OO:9O:7>?C#




5CAOCH?@I==J AIPF7??CD'

SJ h TAT ">:a $# %=9:C

">:a $# %=9:C0?>?C S>: )9# \^^\eE\\

0#$# 3CN# 4CDC:>= ($ )9# RbeRRee

%=9:C ->L &:9IO --%

^g (FF7M:>?798 0?:CC?'

%G>:=CA?98' 0% Rg^ER

3C=COG98Ch VZ^_Y bRRcZ\b\

4>HA7F7=Ch VZ^_Y bRRcgZZE

1F>7=h">:aqH=9:C=>L#H9F

*$$-+#&Y "# ,%*+6& .-+

*22 42*"#$"..)

Christine Lockhart PoarchTexas Bar No. 24013052

Virginia Bar No. 47106POARCH LAW FIRM, PC

203 S. College Avenue

Salem, VA 24153(540) 387-1005FAX: (540) 444-0323


Border Patrol Rape and Attempted Murder Case

Documents

Transcript of Border Patrol Rape and Attempted Murder Case