Bo-19 - kutaisiappeal.court.gov.gekutaisiappeal.court.gov.ge/files/upload-file/pdf/sakonkurso... ·...
Transcript of Bo-19 - kutaisiappeal.court.gov.gekutaisiappeal.court.gov.ge/files/upload-file/pdf/sakonkurso... ·...
domo3.)6 .)V8~<Y>o~o (b.)J(Y)5J~Mb(Y) J(Y)aoboob m.)38x~(Y)a.)<YJo) , .)M~o~ 0~~5~.)do
(b.)J(Y)5J~Mb(Y) J(Y)aoboob m.)3ax~(Y)a.)<YJob a(Y).)~0o~o) , ~oaoo<Ylo 03<Yloooo3o~o, 0o(Y)<Yl0o
't>.)M5.)do, 5.)mo.) ~(Y)~.)do (d~m.)obob \.).).)3o~.)(30(Y) b.)ba.)<YJm~(Y)b .)~.)ao.)5';:J<Ylo <Y>ob~<Y>bo~ob
8.)M(J)30b o<Y>mo~~ob V.)Ma(Y)a.)~oo5o~o) , 't>~M.)~ (3b3o~o.)5o
bb~(Y)a.)b .)M obv<Y>o~(Y)~5o5 \.).)J(Y)5J~Mb(Y) J(Y)aoboob ooa~ooo V03MO~O: domo3.)5 mbo~odo,
.3.).)0 .) ~boodo ~.) o<Yl.)J~o ao5oo~o.).
o';:J<n.)obob \.).).)3o~.)(30(Y) \.).)\.).)8.)M<n~(Y)b <n.)3aX~(Y)a.)~h 2018 v~ob 1 mo~o<YJ3~ob N1182
~Md.)5o~om 0.)8(Y)(3b.)~O~~~o J(Y)5J~<Ylbob.)m3ob (ooa~0(Y)aoo - ,J(Y)5J~<Ylbo") b.)J(Y)5J~Mb(Y)
.3<Yl(Y)0M.)8ob, .3o<YJ(Y)~o~ob, J.)5~o~.)oob ooczpbo~ob <B(Y)<Y>ao~ob ~.)86J0(30~.) ~.) ,J(Y)5J~<Ylbob"
~.)O.)MO~ob 0M.)<BOJOb 0.)5\.).)'t>~3M.) .
1. b.)J(Y)5J~Mb(Y) J(Y)aobo.)a, a(Y)obao5.) <Y>~ domrJ3~5 ~V8~<Y>o~ob a(Y)bbo5o~.), b~d~<Ylm30~(Y)b
8m~3M(Y)~ob 2017 v~ob 21 ~3<Ylo~ob N11204 ~~~oo6o~o~om ~~8~J0(30~';:J~O, b~X,~M(Y)
\.).)8\.)~b';:JMOO J(Y)6J';:JMbob ~~O~MO~ob vobob (oo8~0(Y)aCJo - ,vobo") Bo-19 ~b~ob b~<23';:Jd3o~<t>o, ,v0bob" a0-18 a~b~ob a0-3 3';:J5d~ob aob~~~aob~~. Jo5.Job8<Ylob ao~oo~~. 0<Y>mha~~ o~~~v830~~=
1
c;::'
~
Cl'
c;::'
;3
\"--
-'
9 ~
VJ
c;::'
u
Cl'
13 ~
3 3
\ c;
::'
3 Q
)l8
9 C
l' C
l' (3
3 V
J c;
::'
3\U
3
0"
O"d
0
13
cu
1'-
.J 0
" 0
&
~
0 u <:
13
9 13
0
0 c.
., c;
::'
g. Cl'
~18
Cl'
"'C
I'c..
L
OJQ
;3
\u
0
VJ
13
g. g.
&
3 ~oc;
1'-)1
8 8
0
18
(33
Cl'
c;::'
18
'5o
~
g. 0
1C
Y
0 C
l'
13
gJ
u C
l'
2:"
&
:;·
f3
c;::'
V
J C
l' 3
\ '&
0
3\
c;::'
9 Q
3 V
J u
u c;
::'
13
g.
3 u
c;::'
o;
OJ
c;::'
3
\ ~
Cl'
u .;)
' c..
L c;
::'
3\
'c}
Q)O
J..._
__
0
g. (j
~
<:13
0
" '0
C
l' 13
•
u 3
\ '"'
3\
01
,..
., '-
' C
l' G
.....
, c..
. o
o8
'5.3
c;
::'
0"
0 0
1
1'-
J;2
..C
(j
g '""
13
0 <:
13
0 <
:r3
u(j
f.l
c;::'
Q
) 'j
0 C
l' ,..
....
0 c;
::'
f3
c;::'
c;::'
13
c&
1'-
.J '-
1 0
3 'g
-13
3 cg
. c..
L g.
G
u
3 0
" Q
) :
~
3 c;
::'
....__
_
~
0" 3\ g. ~ """ 0\
0\
0" 3\
Q,
Cl'
Cl'
~
Q)
c;::'
'0
C
l' C
l' u
3\
3 0
" 9
13
(jl
3c..
L
j 3
? (Y
U
g. 83
Cl'
0 cs
8"18
0
" C
l' (j
Q
)
0' a
13 ~
u 0
O"Q
5-:
'5o
g.
~ oc;
01
0
u 9 g.
ctl8
Q
C
l' 0
9 <A
C
l' C
/' I
j Cf
l'l 3
0 C
l' 0
" 3
\ C
l' 0
&
c;::'
u
Q)
(j
c;::'
0
3
Cl'
Cl'
Cl'
VJ
c..
L3
G
Cl'
0"
3 3
\ 0
01
9
c;::'
3
VJ
Cl'
Q)
u 0
~18~
c;::'
C
l' 0
CY
c:'
c:'
Cl'
Cl'
Cl'
18
'& ~ ~
Cl'
3\
Q)
....__
_
<:13
9
Cl'
cc
3\
~ ~
9 C:
-0>1313~
0 3
3 C
l' 13
c;
::'
u 3
\ u
0"
9 0
" 0
3
VJ
5-:
0 0
u
CJ:.
Q)
13
G
3 ~
0 c..
L Q
C
l'
0 13
0
0 C
l' (j
c;
::' fr
c;
::'
c:'
<J
(j
9 0
Q)
Cl'
Q
Cl'
01
0
f.3
0 13
c.
., c;
::'
u 3
58
d
01
Q
) 0
Cl'
c;::'
c.
., f.3
C
l' C
l' f.
l 0
" Q
lj
Cfl'l
0 u
3 0
c;::'
c;
::'
c;::'
c;::'
c;
::'
1'-.J
G
c:r
0 C
l' ~
0 0
1
3 \0
18
c;
::'
Cl'
Cl'
<:13
3
\ 13
0>18
g.
'5o
Cl'
g. \0
c;
::'
18 ~
3 C
l' C
l'
c..
L8
3\
G
c...
9 3
0 ~
Q)
Q
f.l
0"
u 'j
3\
0"
3 0
g. c;
::'
c;::'
03
c;
::'
.....,.
u C
l' ~
c;::'
u
-C
l' 3
\ w
g
9 0
~
3
£ Cl'
OJ
;3\
"---'
9 VJ
~ u
c;::'
13
8 3
3\
c;::'
9
~
3 0
1
3 c;
::'
01
C
l' 0
c;::'
".
Cl' 9'
3\ 9 13 8 g'
c;::'
Q) ~
Cl'
Q)
Cl' 3\ 9 13
g 0" 9 Cl' 01
c.., 3 8 01
2 Cl'
Q 0 g. ~ g. 0
3
cg. g.
u 0"
3 ....___
c;
::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 V
J u 13
~ c.., Cl' 01
~
0 01 ~ Q
) C
l'
G
0 (j
13
0 ~
G
u 0" g. 03
cg
. ~
u ~
01
...._
__ c;
::'
Cl'
c..L
Cl' 3\ 9 V
J u 13
~ c;::'
~ 13 g. c;::'
C
l' Q
) C
l' 3\ 9 13 g. c;::'
C
l' O
J 3\ 3 Q
cg. 3 c.
., 3 18
g_
c;::'
?
~
c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~
c;::'
~ 13 g. c;::'
C
l' Q
) C
l' 3\ 9 13 g. c.
., 3 18 ~
?
13
....___
c;
::'
Cl'
c..L
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~
c.., Cl' 01
~
0 Cu
~
Cl' 3\
Q)
u 9 Cl' 03
cg
. g.
u o;
~
c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 V
J u 13
~
c;::'
C
l' Q
) d Cl' 13
Cl'
c..L 3 c;::'
~
3'- 6 cg. 3 c.
., ~ u 'i:'
?
0 ....___
c;::'
C
l' c..
L C
l' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~ c;::'
C
l' Q
) d Cl' 13 ~
3 c.., 3 18
u 'i:'
-~
9 ....___
c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~
Cl' 18
Q)
0 01
0 c;
::'
G 3'- CI'
Q 0 (j
13
c;::'
C
l' Q
) C
l' 3'- 9 Cl' 13
18
Cl' 3\
f3 ~
VJ Cl' 9 Cl'
c.., 3 18
u c..L
c;::'
?
&
....___
c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~
Cl' 18
Q)
0 01
g. G 3'- CI'
Q 0 (j
13
0 c;::'
C
l' O
J 3\ 3 ~
3 c.., ~ g_
c;
::'
?
VJ
....___
c;::'
C
l' c..
L C
l' 3'- 9 ~
13 ~
&
3 oc; 18
0 Cl' 18
Q)
0 01
g. G 3\
Cl'
Q 0 (j
13
0 c.., 3 18 ~
?
u ....___
c;::'
~
Cl' 3'- 9 VJ
u 13 ~
c.., Cl' 01
3 0
1
0 (:;:- ~ 3\ 3 c;::'
C
l' 82 g.
(j
3\ g. Q3 cg. g.
u ~
18
....___
c;::'
~
Cl' 3'- 9 VJ
u 13 ~
3 3' oc;
01
(j
13
0 c.., Cl' 01
3 0
1
0 (:;:
~
Cl' 3'- 9 VJ
u 13 ~
03
3
\ 3 Q) g. c.
., 3 18
u 'i:'
0~
e c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~ ~ oc; 01
(j
13
0 c.., Cl' 01
~
0 c- CI'
u 3\ 9 3 c;::'
~
Cl'
Q)
Cl' 3\ 9 13 8 0" g. Q3 cg. g ~
0"
....___
Cl' 18
Cl'
Q)
0 Cl' 01
g. (j
cs 13
u 0"
Cl' 9 Cl'
u VJ 3'- ~
(j
13
0 c.., ~ ~
01
Q
0 5-:
~
c;::'
~
Cl' 3\ 9 ~
13 ~
c.., ~
&
0 G
(j
Q 0 5-:
Q
c:'
CY
3 G
c:r
fc3
3'-
g. ~
01
(j
3
~0:~
dl3
tt
3'-u
9 (j
0
" C
l' f.
l 0
0 lj
c;::'
c;
::'
~
0 0
u Q
) c;
::'
3\
9 c;
::'
9 C
l' C
l' u
VJ
Cl'
(j
Cl'
OJ
13
3'-u
0 "&
c;::'
c.
., Q
0'
3 0
u gJ
3
1, (
j c;
::'
a.,
13
Cl'
f3
G ~
VJ
Cl'
Q)
Cl'
01
C
l' 0
1
r-_
3\
~ 'G.
-9
c;::'
13
~ Q
) 8 9 Q
) c;
::'
0" ~
Cl'
3 C
l' ~
~
9' f
c3 0
" 3'-
3\
~
9 3
'&13
18
fc3
g. C
l' u 00
c;::'
c;::'
9
Cl'
Cl'
Cl'
3 Q
) 0
1
3\
Cl'
Cl'
CY
3\
03
C
l' 9
u 0
1
13 ~ ~
u
c;::'
C
l' 0
" Q
3'-
0 0
I 3
VJ 0
Q) ~
Cl'
u c.
., c..
L 3
0 G
3
\ 9
u C
l' 0
' g'
18
9 c;
::'
0 C
l'
O'CJUQ0(300U 'Cla~~<!:?OU u~e,.}MU~ (Q~ U~d~(Y}ffi30<!:?MU u~o(Y)m(Y) u~u~a~(Y)m<!:?MQe,Oo 8Md~<!:?~doum~5
JM8'CJ5oa~ooou u0~5cg~(Y)00e,ou cg~a03o00e,ou a0u~boe," u~d~(Y)m3o<!:?Mu o'C.luooooou 'C.la~~<!:?ouo
u~e,.}Mu 2009 v<!:?ou 9 Md6M8e,(Y)ou Nl/310 o~CQ~V830oo<!:?oe,~.
1.2. U~J~(Q(Y)(Y) (Q~ U~(Y)(Y)o~5o'b~(30M u~aombm~ o~5~M<z30<!:?Qf>OU U3Q(30~<!:?ouou - 3o(Y)30<!:?0
a~oOoM(Y)oou 'CJ8G(Y)(Y)u u3ooo~<!:?ou0u 8MombM30e,~ aaacgo0o b8~(Y)m<!:?oe,(Y)o3o ~dooe,ou GMCQ5~:
'tl) ,u~o(Y)m(Y) u~u~a~(Y)m<!:?Moe,ou 8Mu~a~<'>m<!:?ooe,m~5 JM8'CJ5oa~ooou vouou aau~boe,"
u~d~<'>m30<!:?MU J~5M5o;
m) , 3MM<z3QUO'CJ<!:?O u~x~<'>M 8MbQ<!:?OU a(Y)e,O<!:?Me,ou vouou aou~bof>" U~d~Mffi3Q<!:?MU 8m~3MMe,ou
2017 V<!:?OU 20 ~3MO<!:?OU N2 199 (Q~(QQ050<!:?0e,~;
o) ,U~X,~MM CQ~VOUOe,'CJ<!:?Oe,~ao QffiOJOU~ CQ~ dG030U <t>M0~cgo vouoe,ou 0~6u~<t>~3<'>ou OQU~bof>"
U~d~Mffi3Q<!:?MU am~3MMe,ou 2017 V<!:?OU 20 ~3MO<!:?OU N2200 (Q~(QQ050<!:?0e,~ ;
J) ,bx~<'>M u~au~b'CJ<'>Clo 6~bo3~(Y) 0~5~J3om<t>o a'C.la~Me, u, ~~aou u~~moe,ao, cg~u3o6oe,ou~ cg~
'CJd8o CQ~Ooe,ao, X~68<'>m0<!:?Me,ou~m3ou (Y)ouaou ao8G30<!:? _l}~8'CJO~M 3o<'>Me,Qe,Clo u~d8o~5Me,ou
vouou cg~aoaoooe,ou O)~(Y)e,~<t>o" U~d~Mffi3Q<!:?MU am~3(Y)(Y)e,Ou 2017 V<!:?OU 21 ~3MO<!:?OU N2201
(Q~(QQ050<!:?0e,~;
<!:?) , 3MM<z3QUO'CJ<!:?O U~X ~MM 8Mb[J<!:?OU V~b~<!:?OUQe,ou VQUOU CQ~86J0(3Qe,ou O[JU~bQe,"
U~d~Mffi3Q<!:?MU am~3MMe,ou 2017 V<!:?OU 21 ~3(Y)o<!:?OU N2203 (Q~(QQ050<!:?0e,~;
8) ,u~x~<'>M u~au~b'CJMOO JM5J'CJMUOU R~o~<'>oe,ou vouou aou~boe," U~d~Mffi3Q<!:?MU am~3MMf>ou
2017 V<!:?OU 21 ~3MO<!:?OU N2204 (Q~(QQ050<!:?0e,~ ;
5) ,3(Y)M<z3QUO'CJ<!:?O bX,~MM 8MbQ<!:?OU m~5~8CQQe,Me,Qe,OU ffiOffiMQ'CJ<!:?O OQM~(Y)dO'CJ<!:?O
<'>~60ou~m3ou ~'CJGO<!:?Oe,o<!:?o ua00o~<!:?'CJ<'>o 8MmbM35of>ou 0~5u~<t>~3<'>ou a0u~boe," u~d~<'>m3o<!:?Mu am~3MMe,ou 2017 V<!:?OU 28 ~3(Y)o<!:?OU N2218 CQ~(QQ050<!:?0e,~ ;
M) ,3MM<z3QUO'CJ<!:?O bi{~M(Y) 8MbQ<!:?OU OQ<z3~uoe,ou vouou~ (Q~ 3o(Y)(Y)e,of>ou cg~aoaooof>ou
aou~boe," bd~Mffi3Q<!:?MU am~3MMe,ou 2017 V<!:?OU 28 ~3MO<!:?OU N2220 CQ~(QQ050<!:?0e,~;
3
17
!~;>QCg~;>p~Q l6N qoQ~~;>g 1 l
qo~~ 910Z: qo~~;>gwm'Xg~;>8~;>w qw~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q wo~k~Ce~;>~;>q qoqo~;>wC.p ,QCq~;>qCe qoqC~ qogC9~;>m~;><G
oe~CwC ~;>m ~;>qo~C~~;>~ womC.~;> '-wCmo8 '-wgof' 'qoQCw~;>m~;><GwQwS> oew~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q" (o
!~;>QC~oQC88~~;>m~;><G
01£/1!5N qo~<;JgwQpw 6 qo~~ 600l qwf<;J~;>q oqC~w~;>gC. qoo9oQqC'.o qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q
,<;lCQ~;>qCe qo<;JC9of'Qg~;>m qo<;JCQ~~;>mg~;>Qq qoo9~;>f'ogC.gwf' g~;>wqCp~;>~~;>pwg oe<;JCw~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q
ww~C~;>q qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q ~;>m ~;>qwf<;J~;>q oqC~w~;>gC'. qoo9oQqC.o qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q" ( w
!~;><;JC~oge<Gm~;>m OOZ:l5N qo~o~e~;> oz; qo~~ L10l qo<;Jw~8~;>wg qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q
,<;lCQ~;>qCe qo~8wq,~;>qg~;><G f!O<;JCqC~ om~;><Gwq, qo8C9p ~;>m ~;>qof'owC 081;'<;lC~C'.<;lCqC~~;>m W~~;>'X~;>q" (q,
!ogwg~;>f' qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q
,<;JCQ~;>qCe qoqC~ qoo9~;>f'ogC.gwf' g~;>w<;jCC~w~~;>g~;>qwg qo<;JCw~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q ww~C~;>q" (8
!ogwg~;>f' qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q "<;JCQ~;>qCe qow~;>~~;>o" (C
!o~qC.g C-£8 qoqpCmwf' wqC9w~e~;>q qo~w~~;>g~;>q qo~qqoq qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q
'o<;JC~qC.g C-nz; ~;>m C-uz; qoqpCmwf' wqC9w~e~;>q wp~;>~~;>pwg~;>q qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q (m
!o~qC.g 6-Cg qogwg~;>f' qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q ,QCQ~;>qCe qo<;JCo9~;>QqCS>og~;>g ~;>m ~;>qo<;JC<;JC~f'Ce" (<G
!ogwg~;>f' o~C'.g~;><G~w qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q ,<;JCQ~;>qCe qo<;JCw~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q ww~C~;>q" (<;J
!~;>o9C.QoQqgwf' qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q ( ~;>
:~;>gmw9 qoQCQP~;>
o8o~<;JC~w~~;>g~;>q o<GCmgCe <.O~;><;JC8wqwCwg qQqo~~;>o9Ceq qw~9gC. qoo~w<GCQ~;>f' o~C8~oe
-q~C'.Q~;>mg~;>g qo~C'.q~;>qg~;>q qo~C'.Q~;>mg~;>g-C8Cq~;> 'q~Cg~;>8wpg~Cq
qo~C.Cw~C o~C.~C.QPC.~Qq om~;>~wCg -qqw~R>C'. qo~C'.q~;>qg~;>q qo~C'.Q~;>mg~;>g "£"1
·~;><;JC~oQC88~~;>m~;><G
01£/1N qo~<;JgwQpw 6 qo~~ 600l qwf<;J~;>q oqC~w~;>gC. qoo9oQqC.o qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q
,<;lCQ~;>qCe qo<;JC9of'Qg~;>m qo<;JCQ~~;>mg~;>Qq qoo9~;>f'ogC.gwf' g~;>wqCp~;>~~;>pwg oe<;JCw~w~~;>g~;>q~;>q
ww~C~;>q qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q ~;>m ~;>qwf<;J~;>q qC~w~;>gC'. qoo9oQqC.o qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q" (G
!~;><;JC~C.<;JCg~;>p~<;J 99tl5N
qo~<;JgwQpw a qo~~ OOOZ: qoQgCmoq,C~e qw~C8w~~;>p~;>q Cq,~;><;Jw~;>w qo<;JC9of'Qg~;>m qo<;JC~C.<;JCm
,<;JCq~;>qCe qoqC~ qo<;JCwg~~;>~qogp~;>q ~;>m ~;>f!O<;JW~;>8C.g o~C'.o9~;>q,og~;><G~w oe<;JCW~<.O~~;>g~;>q~;>q qC~w~;>gC.
qo<;JCf'o~<;JC.eqC~ o~C'.ogwgwQ8~;> qo~~;>f~;> ~;>m qowCq,~;>qS>~;> 'wP~w~;>q '(wp~;>~~;>p~;>q) o~C'.gwo~;>~" (e
.3) , ,d'C.Jcn0obob b003:J<!?0(30M b0b080Mcn<!?MOO b0 <t>M~0<:QM:J~Mo3o ~:JbMo~ob 'C)<t>M'C)63:J<!?8M<z30b
~M5obdo:J~:J~ob a:Jb0b:J~" d'C.Jcn0obob U003:J<!?0(30M b0b080Mcn<!?Mb cn038'X,<.pM80Mob 2013 ~<!?ob 12
03<!?obob N97 ~Md05:J~0 .
2. U0JM6J'CJMU(Y) JM8obo08, 8Mob8o60 M0 d:Jcr>:J306 0~8'C.JM:J<!?Ob 8Mbb:J6:J~0, "~:Jbob" ao-19
8'C.Jb<!?ob b0<z3'C.Jd3:J<!?<t>:J <.p!> aa-18 8'C.Jb<!?ob 8:J-3 3'CJ6d~ob aab0~08ob0<.p, J:J6Job~(i)ob a:J<.p:J~0<.p,
:JMcnb80<.p ~0<.p0~~3o~0:
2.1.1. , JM5J'C.JMbob" ~0~0M:J~0bcn05 <.p0J0300M:J~'C.J<!?O bJocr>b:J~O, MM8<!?:J~0(3 0M 0Mob
8M~:JUMOW~'CJ<!?O 08 ~0<.p0~83:J~O<!?:J~ocn , M:J~'C.J<!?OM<:Q:J~0 ,~:Jbocn" .
2.1.2. U0JM5J'C.JMU(Y) JM8oboob bb<.pM80b 0~3:J3U <.p0 8ob w~ob ~:JUMO~b ~05b0<t>~3M03U JM8obo0,
06 - JM8oboob cn038X<.pM80M:J, (i)ob a:Jb0b:J~0(3 o5<z3MM80(300 d3:J~5<.p:J~0 d'C.Jcn0obob b003:J<!?0(30M
b0b080MO'><!?Mb M<z30(300<!?'CJM 3:J~~:JM<.p<t>:J (www.kutaisiappeal.gov.ge), JM8oboob bb<.pM808<.p:J
0M0'C.J~o05:Jb 7 <.p~ob0.
2.2.1. , JM5J'C.JMbo" 'C.J6<.p.:> ~08M(3b.:><.p<.p:Jb bbo3 b0X0(i)cv}- b08b0b'C.)Mob ~o'C.JMMb (a:J8<.p~M8ao -
,~O'C.JMM") 80:JM .:><.p8o6ob~(i)o(i):J~'C.J<!?O 3:J~~:JM<.pob (www.hr.gov.ge), .:>~M:J0'>3:J - d'C.Jcn0obob
b03:J<!?0(30M bb080MO'><!?Mb 3:J~~:JM<.pob (www.kutaisiappeal.gov.ge) 8:J03:JM~ocn .
2.2.2. ,JM5J'C.JMbob" ~08M(3b0<.p:J~Ob O:Jb0b:J~ O:J~~M~05:J~0ao 8ocnocn:J~'C.J<!? od5:Jb O:J8<.p:J~O
8M50(3:J8:J~O :
0) ~00 JM6J'C.)Mbao 8M50~0<!?:JM~ob 'C.J<z3<!?:J~0 0d3b bd0M0'>3:J<!?MU d8:J<.p'C)50Mo05 8Md0<!?0d:Jb,
MM8:J<!?OG 0J808M<z30<!?:J~b , b0X0M(Y) b08b0b'C.)Mob a:Jb0b:J~" b0d0Mcn3:J<!?Mb .306M6ob 27 -o w0 29-o
8'C.Jb<!?:J~Ocn ~00'>30<!?0U~05:J~'C.J<!? 8McnbM35:J~b;
5
9
·ogw~~om o~C<;~C~C.Qq<:m<:g<:m qo<;~C~w<:g<:~ oqC~w<:gC qww~o8Q<:
<:mgC. m<:~<;!C~o8C<: <:gQ<:momg<:P C~o~<:gwg OB()~C.PgwP ~C.~C.q<:m <:m <:OW "£"£"(;
·<;~Cq<:qCB qo<;~wqog<:<;!<:()CB g<:w<;~Cg8wqwwg wq~C.PgwP<:q o<;~CQgCgCPwm <:m <:o8<:g~wfbgo
O~<:C.fiQC qwmw~<:og ()<:<;!C~C.<;~CqC~<:m W~<:'X<:q -<:o~C.<;~Cm~<:8 oQ<:momg<:P "(';"£"(';
·Cmg<:8~C.~wg<: qom<:8 g<: qwg<:QoCB <:<;~C~o~88 oBm<:q8<:g<:~ -<:o~oqwg<:<;~C~S>C
oQ<:momg<:P ·wo<;~wC8BCg (a~L\o~bl["M.MM.) qom~C~<;~C8 o~C.<;!C~o~Qqogogm<: ~Cog
,qw~C.O<;!" 'wog~wfb o~C.gw~QPC~C mw~wqg 'OB<:m<:8 qowm W<:BC.g<:q 01 g<:mo<;~Cm<:q8wg<:~
,qoq~C.Pgwf'" qg~m<:~<:~ qm<:q8<:g<:~ oQ<:momg<:P 'qo8w<:qo<;~wC~o~<:gwg ,,OB()~CPgwP" ·1·£·z;
:<:g~m~<:~ qom~q8~g~~ wq~CE'gwE'~q ·£·z:
·qC8w l1 qg~m<:CB <:<;~w8o~p~~g<:q qo~gw~ 'wom<:8 o~Cm8<:qwg<:~
<:<;~Cwoog C~<:<;~w<;~Cmg<:g<:w ~C.Qg<:P<:8 o~o~ Cgwpg~<: qoqC.Q<:Qq qo~Cqwg 'm<:gq<:g~w qo<;~CQpgC.~
z; -Cg <:m o~-1 qo~qC.g C-£t qogwg<:P qw~C8w~<:P<:q ,<;!CQ<:()CB qo~C.q<:qg<:q w~<:'X<:q" ·£·z;·z;
·Cq,~<:QC C8o~w qoq~C.PgwP qCgpo <:mgC o~C.<;~Cgo~qo~<:8w 8<:~
'o<;~Cg8wqwwg wo8~Pofbo~<:8P<:q owo<;~CQ<:g<:m w~<:gog qo<;~CQ<:momg<:P C~o~<:gwg OB<;!Cq~C.PgwP
~C<;~C~<:Q~q<:~ Cq,<;~C<;~w<;~Cmg<:g<:w ~C.Qg<:P<:8 <:o~C.~8wq,<:qg<:~ wow~<:g<:m qo<;~Cg<:p~<;!
l8N qo~8~C<;~Cw 1 qo~~ 810l qo~<:gwm'Xg8<:w qw~w~<:g<:q<:q wo8<:~C~<:<:q qoqo<:wCP ·v·z;·z;
·<:o~C~ 0£ oP<:q<: o~C.~8w~ qo~Cq<:qg<:q m<:~CQ<:mg<:g
qw~w~~g~q<:q '<:<;!WC~<:gw<Gmg qo<;~w~Cw~gg<:'X oqog<:<;!<:()CB qo8w<:qo<;~C~C.~qCB qo<;~C<;~wC~<:8wg
o8o~<;~C~C.q<:qg<:q q8p<: ~m q<:gC wfbo~g~Cq<:q q<;~w~S> o<Go Cw 'g<:moP<:q<: qo~~ z;z; CP<:~<:Pwg og<:o~<:gC.mCgp qw~C8w~<:P<:q qwgBogo<:m <:<;~C~poCB m<:Qqo~<:o8C~q qw~8gC. qoo~w<GCQ<:P
o~C8~o~-m~~C.Q<:mg<:g qo~C.q<:qg<:q qo~CQ<:mg<:g <:m m<:~Cg~<:8wpg~Cq qo~C.Cw~C
o~C.~C.Q~pc~Qq om<:~wCg-m<:qw~S>C. qo~C.q<:qg<:q qo~C.Q<:mg<:g 'm<:gq<:g<:w qoQpgC.~ t-Cg
qo~qC.g C-6£ qogwg<:P o~C.g<:<G~w qw~C8w~<:P<:q ,<;!CQ<:()CB qo<;~Cw~w~<:g~q<:q ww~C<:q" '£'(';"(';
'()<;!Cg8wqwwg ~C.<;~Cgo~qo~<:8w<:<G WO<;!C~qC.g C-6(; <:m C-a qogwg<:P qw~C8w~<:P<:q
,<;!CQ<:()CB qo~C.q<:qg<:q w~<:'X<:q" q<;~C~ofbwfi<:gf'<: <:m OB<:gCQqoq qo~Cq<:qg<:q w~<:'X<:q
()<;!W<:BC.g <:o~C~ 1 <;~C~P<:g<:~<: o<Go C.w 'q~o~ ~C.<;~Cgp~q~m wo<;~C~C.~PCB~Cq owogw~B (<G
806Q?0C~Mob b08b0b~(Y)ob ~<aM01bob 8:J01M0Q?O bc(Y)~dC~M~~o :JMm:J~~ob
'b:J~8di!2306:J~OU0 Q?0 8m030Mo J016b~~C06Co - 801b080Mm~ob m0600:J8V:J-8:J01M0Q?O
UCM~OC~M~~o :JMffi:J~~ob b:J~8di!2306:J~Ob 30J06C~M m0608Q?:J~01~:J~<t>a J06Q?OQ?0C80 0U:J38
Q?08008~om ~5Q?0 003oMm01b ua80o0~01~om 06/Q?0 aab~08ob ucaa(Y)01oo/Q?0M~ao 0M0603~a~
01MV~o06o b08~o001 ~0801(3Q?o~a~ob Q?080Q?0UC~M8~8~o Q?01J~8a6co. 08 ~J060bJ6a~80 30
0MU:J~01~ob oa8mb3:J30oo o~bcoeoob ~801!2~:Jb b,301~0oo b3:J(300~~(Y)o b0bV03~01 J~Mbob
~03~ob Q?080Q?0UC~MO~O~o Q?01J~8a6co 06/Q?0 801b080Mm~a01~ob b0J30~ocaoJ0(3001
~0801(3Q?Ob ~0~0M:J~ob Q?080Q?0UC~MO~a~o U:JMCO<aOJ0CO·
0) b0X,0M01 b08b0b~Moo 8~o001~ob Q?080Q?0UC~MO~a~o, b0m060Q?01Q? Q?0801V80~~~o e3601~0,
M018:J~OG ~0(3:J8~~o od6:J~0 ,J016J~Mbob" ~0801(3'b0Q?:J~Ob oa8Q?:J~, 06-
2.3.5. 003oMm~~ ~6Q?0 od5ab o0Mm~~ a60<t>a oaQ?w5o~o Q?01J~8a5C0Go0. ~Gb01:J601306o
b0~~ma~ob oa8m'b3:J30oo, 0~eo~a~a~o0 0oc3oMm01b 80mo d0Mm~~ a60<t>a 60100(Y)o~~0Q?
Q?0801v8a~~~o m0M~8068~o0 .
2.3.6. J05Q?OQ?0C80 b0ba~8voca01 a5ob G01Q?5ob Q?0Q?0bc~(Y)a~ob 8o<t>5om ~5Q?0 0c3oMm01b
,b0'b:J~8voca01 a6ob oab0b:J~" b0d0Mm30~01b J06016ob 33-a 8~b~om ~0m30~obvo6a~~~o
aab0~08obo Q?01J~8a5co/801V801~0 .
2.3.7. b0o0Mm30~01b <a0M~~a~b ~0M:Jm 8ol!2a~~~o ~060m~a~ob oa8m'b3:J30oo,
b30~Q?8~~~010 - 0oc3oMm01b bbo3 ~060m~a~ob 'b0Mobbob ~063om0M:J~ob :JM0136~~o
G05c(Y)ob 8oa(Y) ~0G:J8~~o Q?01J~8a5co ~Gb01amoo 8ol!2a~~~o ~060m~a~ob b0d0Mm30~01b
08Moc01Mo0<t>8 01!2o0M:J~ou m001~0<t>8 .
2.4.1. U0J016J~MU01 J018oboob V83MO 30~Q?8~~~00 - ,J016J~Mbob" OC03:J~Ob Q?0V!::J0~08Q?a
~060(3'b0Q?01b m3om0Go~a~0, m~ 0MU:J~01~b ~0M:J801:J~0 , M018:J~80G oaod~:J~0 80b ba~o
oa~o0~01b J06Q?OQ?0cob 01~oadC~M0Q? O:J<a0b:J~0oo . oab0~08ob0Q?, ob 38M 8ool!2a~b
80160vo~a01~0b o8030 30J05C~M m0608Q?0~01~0<t>a V0MQ?W5o~o bb30 J05Q?OQ?0C:J~ob
O:J<a0b:J~0b0 Q?0 80m 8o80Mm ~0Q?0V!::J38CO~:J~ob 8ol!2a~ob 3M01(3:Jboo.
2.4.2. m~ 08w0Mo m3om0eo~a~0 0M o060 ~06(3'b0Q?O~~~o Q?0 8omoma~~~o ~0M:J801a~ob
O:JU0'b:J~ ,J016J~Mbob" 8o8Q?060M:J01~0U0U ~0'bQ?:J~0 (3601~0~0, U0J016J~MU01 J018oboob 08 V83MOU
8oa(Y) ~05'b01MGoa~a~~~o oaca0b:J~0~o oab0~08ob 30J05C~M m0608Q?0~01~0<t>a 0M od5:J~0
7
8
qoro<;>q_8<;>g<;><6 ,()W<;YC.UCJ" ()W<D<;Y<'QOQ <DOCJCro<;>q_8g<;><G U<DOCJW~O<;YC~ oe<;>rod~ qowro W<'8C.Q<'()
z; g<;>rooQCwog qoQCgoQwliQCe o~C.QCwowog oeQpgC.e I ·9·z; -q8p<' <'QC~G,C, qQ<;>roorog<;>P ·z;·9·z;
·CqsCJW<'<D qo~8q<;>ro<;><G Cq,e<;>QC C<;YwCg ,qoq<;YC.Pgwf'" ()<'QCgoQwliQCe (CJ·<G
!<;>QCgoQwliQCe o~CQCwCQ<'q<'ro <'QCg8<'q, <GC<;><G
q<'g 'oe<;>8C8q_wgCe qog8wq_wwg qoQ<;>roorog<;>P !CJCQ<'rtCe qoQWQ<'CJ<'rtCCe g<'wQCg8wq_wwg
<;YC.~<'g<;YwG, ro<;><DO<;Yop qoro<;>q_8<;>g<;><G o~oge<Gro<;Y<'~ <;YCog qog ()<'QCgoQwliQCe (<'·<G
:qog8<;>q, <GC.
ro<;>~C.gw<;YQpC~C qQ<;>roorog<;>P 'C<;Yro<' wowro w<;>eCg<'q L Crog<'e<'QC C<;YwCg ,qoq<;YCPgwf'" (<G
!qQC<GCroCe WW~WCJ<'() ()OQCg~wgCe o~C<;Y8wq,<;>qg<;><G
ueQpgC.eC8p ,,<;>" qoQpgC.e g<' qgC<GroC.<;Y<'~ ro<;>~QC8of'Qg<;>q<;>ro ()<'O()OgwP W()<;YC.Pgwf'<;>q
'oe<;>ro<;-8 qowro w<;>eC.g<;>q 01 g<;>roo8<;YC.~wg<;> qoro<;-8 qo8<D<;Y08Q<;> ()OCJCro<;>q_8<;>g<;><G W()<;YCPgwf'<;>q (CJ
!<;>CJC8eo<'ro <;Y<'W<' Cq,e<'Qc
<GCrogCe ,qoq<;YC.Pgwf'" o<Go 'qq,C8l)<'Q qo<;Y8q_G,wgw<' <;Y<' oe<;>ro<;-8 g<' oQ<;>roorog<;>f' Cw "<'QC8eo<;>ro
<;Y<' <'CJC~Cp<;Y<G<'<G qoro<;-8 g<' ·ro<;>w~o89<'rt<' qoQgCgC.Pwro owoQCQ<'g<'ro •woQwgCrow qowro
£ q<;>ro<;-8 q8<'<;Y8wq,<'qC.g<;><G qQ<;>roorog<;>P •oq,C8<;Y<'Q Cgo<'<;Y <'QCgpo ~ogC~wgw<' C.w ·g<'wQCg8wq_wwg
<DoQCQ<;>g<;>ro <;>ro <;YC.~<;>o8Ceq 'ro<;><DO<;YOP ~oge<Gro<;>ro qo8w<;>qooqg<;>f'<;>8 o~CQCro<;>q_8wg<;><G
()<'CJW()OQ<'CJ<'rtCe qoQCQgCgC.Pwro o~C<D<;Y<;>rog<;>w <;>ro qoQCro<;>q_8<;>g<;><G o~C.<D<;Yo8Q<;>
qQCg~wg<' •oe<;>ro<;-8 qowro £ g<;>roo8<;YC.~wg<' qoro<;-8 qo8w<;Yo8Q<;> qoQCro<;>q_8<;>g<;><G wq<;YCPgwf'<'q (<'
:qQCQCroCgpwg
<GCrogCe rtCJC~Co8<;YWQ<' Cp<;>~w~ <;>ow<;>g 'wo~CQ<'() qooqogwP wq<;YC.Pgwf'<'q T9·z;
:o~<>QC o~C8<;Yoe ,qoq<;YCPgwf'" ·9·z;
"<'QCro<;>q_8wg<><G qoQC<GCroCe ,qoq<;YC.Pgwf'" -o~QC Cg<;>qCg (<G
!<;>QCq<;>G,Ce qoQ<;>roorog<;>P -oe<;>QC C<;YwCg ( CJ
!<;>ge<Gro<;>ro ()OCJW()OQ<'CJ<'()C8
g<'<DQCg8wq_wwg <;YC~<'g<;YwG, ro<;><DO<;Yop qoro<;>q_8<;>g<><G qoQ<;>roorog<;>f' -oe<;>QC o~C8<;Yoe (<'
:g<;><G<>qoQC~QC o<GCrogCe <'QC<GroCe ,oq<;YC.Pgwf'"
:otJCe<>QC ,qoq<;YCPgwf'" ·s·z;
·q<>qoQCwog
()OQC~oQC88~<;>ro<;><G WW~WCJ<'() <DOQC<;Yoe8<;>f'<;>ro 9<'<DQCQ<;>roorog<;>P o~C.QCgo~qo~<;>8w<;><G
c.re
u:
030"
Q)CrCue>~
~,a
at3
13
tv
c..3
oc..3~
Q)3
?0
3\
18
c;::' ~
<:j3
~
wc.r
g..
~-
& c
,. ~
en
3\
c;.,
18
c::
' c.r
Od
;>
~
c;::'
9 9
(j
3~
0 8
.18
c;:
:' ~en3\
c.r
o
~· ~
9 c;:
:' ~
~c..313
:f ~
3\
cf
13
3 "il
l ~
~
0 13
~
18
v; 3
\/@
~8~
~
en ~ ~ ~
<:j3
(J'
I ~
Q)
c.r
c.r
(j
Cu
c;:
:'Q
)
§18'g,~~~
9 3
\3
o Q
)en
c.r
3
2'1
8
3 c.r9
18
1
0
c.r
Q
~_......_oc,.l8
o ~·
c.r
en
3 c.r
~3\c.rc::'
13
18 ~
J' 0
' cs
3
c.r
c.r
-c.r
(j
U) Vl
~ c"@
3
\1
~'&~g8&
9 3
Cl
13
't
o9
wg
g2
cg
0
(j
18
1
0
c.r
3\
: c.r
0
~~~~(§~
~9
c..
3g
:c
g..
eu
c
en
O'
en
c.r
3
C::
o
c.r
c.r
':-"
§'
·"
c;::'
18
9 c;:
:' Q
) c.r
8-
0J
o 3
\o
g
c.r
0 3
c;::'
,.~
~
en
c
0'-
' I~
c;::'
Q)
Q)
c.r
13
c;::'
~
cfO
' 0
gg
c.r~,a
c;:
:'cg
.9
8'3
\.2
5Jc.r
'5=
.8
c8~§ ~g
..~
3\
0 c,
. g.
<:j3
<:j3
9 0
c;::
'~
cc
g-18ag~~
a ?
8'1
&~
g:g..~@
g..
g..
c;:
:'()
J
c.r
c.r
03
en
IV
(j
c;::'
. c.r
c.r
0
0
~
cf
i-v
I~
.Y3
• ~c.:><:j3
g 3
\ ~
0" (j
3\
g..
13
0 Q3
0
9 ~
0 c,
. 3
18
~ 1
8 c.r
c.r
~
<:.:)
I en
c.r
~ ~ 1
3 Q
) 0 ~
3 9
0"
§ ..
g.
. en
Q
) ~
c.r
3 ?'
9 9
~
g. Cu
0
3
3\
0 a.
. c.r
13
't
~
en
0"1
8
c.r
0 9
18
Q)
c.r
3 c,
. 0"~
0 0"
13
0
(j
Q3
3\~
0 18
0
c,.
c.r
~
en
13
c;::'
~
c.r
cs
Cu
3 ~
OlC
u
0 (j
c;::'
3\
c.r
c;::'
en
3 c;
::'C
u g
3 c.r
Q
)
c,.
g..
~
0 u.
.. 0
~
c;::'
Cu
Q)
(j
0 3\~
0 3
\
01
(j
cs
3 cs
c.r
3\~u...IV
Q)
I~
c,.
. c.r~~
00
c,
. 0"
0"
;....
.. 0
c.r
0 .
(j
c.r
9 13
u.
.. c.r
<:
j3 ocg.g~
c.r
0"
0 u
_.
I (j
9 ~
<:j3
13
0 0"
~
0 ?
3\t
.rl8
Q
) 0
Q)
c.r
c.r
9 3
c.:>
9
0 Q
c.r
0
~ 1
3 Cu
18
0 ~
3 c.r
c;:
:' 0"
Q
) <:.
:) ,....
.._ 0
~
c.r
03
c;:
:' en
13
~
o-~t3Q)
~
0"0
' 0
~
0 3
Q
,.....,
c;::'
~
....,.
Q)
Q)
0 0
3
Q3
c.r
c.r ~
0 C
Jlc
;::'
I()
J
fc3
3\
=
(j
c.r
c..
3't
13
c;:
:' 13
cf
0
c.r ~
(j
c;::'
g 0
" c;:
:' CJ
' ~
0 0
Q)
I~
c;::'
" 3
Q)
c.r
..._;;
a..
9 c.r
0
" .Y3
<:.
:) Q
) c;:
:' <:.
:) 0
3 c.r
c;:
:' c;:
:' Cu
en
c.r
c.r
~
9 CT
en
13
c.r
g;
18
3
01
~
0 ~
~
18
0
" 0
I~
c.r
0 u.
.. c.r
,....
._ .
3 1
8
'"5
01
0
' c;:
:' 0
c.r
c.r
3 1
8
9 c;:
:' c.r
<:.
:) Q
0
18
'&
c;:
:' c.r
c.r
c;:
:' ""
" .
0 0
' Cu
c.r
c.r
Q
) 0
1
3 18
0
0 §
18
0
1
c.r
3 c,
. c;:
:' c;:
:'
UJ § ~ 8 3\
0
IV
?o
83
3\
0 9 0 18
&
c.r
13
~
0"
g..
Q)
0 Q ~
Q)
g.. ~
:::!
cf
~
UJ
0"
0 .._
..,
~18
18 ~
c.r
c.r
<:.:)
3\
c.r ~
13 ~
~
en
0"<:
.:)
0 c.r
c;
::'C
u c.r
Q)
01
0
c:"'
Q
0 ~ ~
Q)
0"
0 cf
c;::'~
Q3<
:j3
~
c.r
18
3\
~
Q)
g 3
0"1
8
g..
g
0'
en
c.r
0 9
13
'€
0 13
Cu
0
c.r
c en
<
:j318
0
0 0
11
8
~
c.r
8'c
,.
9 ~
. 0
" 0 Q3
~
cs ~
18
~
0"
0 c.r
en
~
cJ 0" 3\ ~
0"
g..
c.r
18
c.r
0'
03
c;:
:'()
J
c.r ~
c,.
c.r
9C
S
3\(
l'c.r
'€~c..33.._..,
13~0;-~u...
~~~a§
OJ
01
(j
8'
0 ~
<:j3
13
c;::'
5 0"
~
'"' c;:
:' 0
3\
'"' 9
90 ~
c;::'
3\
c.r
0 9
Q)
c.r
18~
98
' c.r
(j
&
13
cf
13
c.r
c.r
~
0 3
\ Q
U
J c;:
:' 0
0 0
3 3
\ CT
0 ~
c;::'
18
13
Cu ~
c.r
Q)
3 c.r
c.:>
a.
. en
Q
) c.r
.Y3
c;:
:' c.r
13
'€
(j
3\
~
en ~
9 0
" ~
I~ ~
~
13
c,.
I~
8'
0 c.r
3
ccc?
;c
Q)
<:.:)
0 c;:
:' 0
c.r
c;::'
c.r
Q
W
I W
~
c.r
Q)
c.r
Q)
en
3 18
0
c;::'
c;::'
3\
p 8.
&
3
c.r
cf
c.r
0'
,.~
3\
3\
'-'
9 18
~ <:j3~
c.r
9 c.r
I~
<:.:)
3\
g..
c;::'
~
Q)
c.r
3 3
0'
18
3\
c.r
0'
0'
c::'
D
9 c.r
c.r
en
en
(j
0 c.r
0
0"
13
en
cf
3\
0 &
c.r
~
~
Q
8'eu~o
c;::'
c.r
0 3
en
c 03
18
I c;:
:' ~
0 Q
) c.r
18
18
~
Cu
~
c.r
3 0
gc,.3
\9
0
" ~
c.r
CJ'
0 0
" 18
9
c;::'
0 0
c.r
IV
'-l
IV
c;., 3 ~ 3\
c;::'
g.. ~
Q)
~ 3 3\
~
~
c,. ~ Cu
c.r
01
18
0 18
c.r
~
0" g..
03
~
cs ~
18
~
0"
0 c.r
01
0
3
~
Q)
18
~
~ ~
0 ~
18
0'
0'
..:l
c.r
c.r
c.r
1
0
9 Q
) c.r
~
<:.:)
3 9:'
tv
c.r~e>c,.'--l
13
I~
18 ~
;......
0 0
0 0"
~~a
~c;.,
eu
en
O"'
"'
3 ~~
o cO
l '"
'O"c::
'c.r
Cu
tc
..3
t.
rc..
.,(j
c;:
:' 13
<:.
:) 3
\ ~
18
Ji
5 0
1 ~
c.r
0 c;:
:' 0
3Q
)
cs
~
'€=-~
Q> 2
.... ~
c.r
c.r
'"'
c.r
'-'
e"3
5
'5
3 Q
) c.r
3
3\
0 13
~
c;::'
<:j3
UJ
3 ~
3\
0"
3\
3 0
0 cs
c;:
:' 13
~
18
3 c;:
:' c.r
0
" c]
18
c.r
13
g 9
0
Q)~
3 c,
. 9
c.r
CJ'
UJ
3 &
<:.:
) ~
en
~
CT
8'1
8
c;::'~
01
c.r
~
9l
Q)
• c;:
:' Q
0
e' U
J 3
Q)C
u
~
18
c.r
c.r
Q
en
3\e
n
0 0
9 ..
:l
c.r
c;::'
-1
0
13
3\
,§ (j
<:.:)
c.r
c.r
3\c
.re>
c,.
..
:l 't
~
0 10
en
Q)
c c.r
c,
. <f
18
(j
3\
g c.r
3
\ ~
cs
Q)o
O
'er
c.r
c.r
c;::'
c,.
Cu ~
~
9 c.r
0
" 0"
en
c.r
0
c.r
..:l
9
en
10
c c.r
0
UJ
Q)
Q)
18 ~
3 1
8
c.r
Q
9~c,.o
CJ' ~
0 c.r
3
0"
c1
3
<:.:)
0 c;:
:' (j
en
c c.r
3
\ ~
c.r
Q)
'"'
0"9
c..
3'"
' 9
<:.:)
Q3
..:l
c.r
0
c.r
10
en
c
3 c.r
IV
~
~ ~ ~
g.. :
g 3 J'
~ ~ :::!
18
0'
<:.:)
a..
c.r
c.r
c.r
0 Q3
18
13
3
\ ~
c.r
18
0 18
~ ~
9 ~
<:.:)
0"
c.r
g ~
(j
18
0"~1
3cs
0 13
0
3 18
~
c.r
3\
c.r
0"
Q)
(j
(.r
I (.
r
cc
0'
13
3 Cr
r<
: c.:>
en
eu
u
g ~ ~
3\
0"
CJ'
18
Q)
13
c.r
0 3
0 ~
18
9 c.:>
c::
' c.r
CT
c.r
c,
. 3
Q
a..
0 <:.
:) en
o
c 0
1
3 3
\ ~
0"
0 0"
3
9 Q
) 9
c;::'
c.r
0 ~
c;::'
..:l
Q
) c.r
1
0
c.r
03
Cu
cs 3\~
3 3
9 c;:
:' en
c.:>
c.r
Cu
3
\0
e' (j
Q)
18
Q)
3\
c.r
c.r
0 c
13
en
c 3
(j
~
eu
3\I
VO
~
Q)
c;::'
0 3
c;::'
0'
c;::'
9 c.r
c.r
8.
CJ
' Q
) 18
c;:
:' 3
(j
&
c.r
<:.:)
03
3
18
en
c.r
<:j3
c.r
'5:.
3 Q
)
Cu
9 '5:
. ~
c.r
18
0 18
en
13
c
0 Q3
0
Q)
18
'€=-
c;::'
3 c.r
c.r
9
C,.
e' c.:>
CT
~
Q)
c.r
3 0
18
<:.:)
c;::'
c.r
01
3
03
0
0"
0 9
0 .
c;::'
-Q3
Q
) (y
~
0 0
c;::'
0 (j
g. .Y3
3
\ ~
3 3
0"
c;::'
~
0"[
·qCp<>~W~ <'OC.0<'9
<>gC8C<;>ru<;>Q o<;~C~8~C,S> qo<;~Cq<>S>CB o~o~C~wg~Cq ~Cog qo~8C~ qooqogwf' wq~Cf'9wf'<>q '£'6'Z:
·oQpC~CQ9o qoQ<;>mom9<-f' ( <;~
!0~<'9c, {)O<;JW<'BC,g OBWgC~<;>Q ~C,qC~Qq-qo~WB c.o<;>g 'o<;~C8C8~-~<'9c, om<;>Qw~ qoQ<;>ruOm9<-f' (<'
:c.oo8mCqog qo<;~CgCo~CQo~P oQCmgCB Cf'~<-8-~<-8 'c.oo~Cp Cmg-01 9<-m-o '~Cog qo~8C~
o~CCwc.ooc.o qooqogwf' wq~Cf'9wf'<>q <><;~Cmq<>S>CB 'm<;>QCmCB qo<;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q 'oQ<;>mom9<-f' ·v·6·z:
'C.OO<;JWgQ9<'C.0 qoQ<;>ruOm9<-f' mw~wqg
<>o~C<;~C~p<>qCB c.oo<;~C~Co8~wq9<-Q qo<;~C~C~<-9<'~-womC<-<>m -wCmo8 <>o8<-qpoS> qo<;~wC~<-9omgog
qo<;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q ·C8~8oq qoq<>c.ow qo<;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q <>8C~po q<><;~w~<;~C~p<>qCB qog<> Cc.o 'o~o~
o~C<;~CqC~CQ9o<>m o~Cogqo<;~C9 qw~~qC<>m <><;~C~poCB q<>g <>m <>w~<>'X<>q <><;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q '£'6'Z:
'<'<;1C9CRwg<>Q qo<;~C<;~C~<>CB<'<l o~Cf'o9pCQ <>8qq 9<' womC<> 'qo9wS>C~CQ
o~C~o<;~wg 'qo~<>q<>g o~CoQw~<-9<' <>8qq 9<' qo<;~C~<>Q9Cgwf' oc.o<;>g 'qo<;~CQp<> o~CoQ<;>g~w9
C.O<;><;JC~<;>p~rc c.o<;>g !mW<;>C.OOC.O<;'{) 9<-0mCB o<;~CQ<;>mom9<-f' OBQ<'C.OW qo<;~C~<;~C<>q<;>Q 'Z:'6'Z:
·oQpC~CQ9o <>m o<;~C8C8~-~<>9C om<;>QwQ:, qoQ<;>mom9<-f' qCmg~wgCB <>W<'~ 'q<-9Cgqwg qo<;~CqCq<>~
C~c.o<>g <>m q<>gq<>m qo<;~C8qc.oof'CB qo8c.o<>qoQ<>mom9<-f' q<;~wgqqo~CQ <><;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q T 6 ·z:
:oqC~ qo<;~C~<;~C<>q<>Q · 6 ·z:
·qCp<;>~W~ <;>OC.0<-9
<>gC8C<;>ru<;>Q o<;~C~8~C,S> qo<;~Cq<>S>CB o~o~C~wg~Cq ~Cog qo~8C~ qooqogwf' wq~Cf'9wf'<>q '£'8'Z:
·o~<-9C qo~C~ m<>~w~q m<>~CPoQ<>g<>~Q ( m
!o~<-9C qogC8wgm<;>Q m<;>~C.0<'9 c:m ru<;>~C9wf'<>~ qo~Q:,<' (Q
!o~<-9C qo<;~C9CRwg<;>Q OBC:f'oQp<>~~ qo9mw8 o~Co~wCc.o ( <;~
!<>9mw8 o~Co~wCc.o ( <>
:c.oo8mCqog qo<;~CgCo~CQo~r
oQCmgCB CP~c:8-~c:8 'c.oo~Cp Cmg-01 9<-m-o '~Cog qo~8C~ o~CCwc.ooc.o qooqogwf' wq~Cf'9wf'<>q
<><;~Cmq<>S>CB 'c.oo8mCqog qo9wm qo<;~C~C~qCB qo<;~C~c:8c:m oc.oo~C~ 'oQ<;>mom9<-f' ·v·8·z:
·c.oo~Cp o c:<;~Cmqc:S>CB mc:~CQ<>gwQ8c: oQ<;>mom9<-f'
'oB<-8C8qc.ogCB QCmgw<>c:9o~ !q~C8~CS> wm8wg<>Qc:q q<;~C~c:<;~c: qCpc:~w~ c:oc.oc:9 oQ<;>mom9<-f'
'C8<>9<-c.oqo8~C~wg<> qow~m o~C~8w~c:q9<-Q ·<;~Cq<>qCB qow~m o~o9C~~<>m qQ<>mom9<-f'
2.10.1. 'bo3o(i)o Q?~3~~o~ob Soeocb 0~~ohbSC'l~U J~5Q?OQ?~6ob~013ob OOJ001b3o~ob Q?~ba~b Q?~ S~01'b0 3~b~bo~ob SC'lbSo5~b , M~01~ Cl[JSC'l\)SQ?[JU J~5Q?OQ?~6ob 01[)C'lMO'CJ~O (S~01 OC'lMOU
JC'lS3o'CJ60M~~o 3MC'l0M~So~ob) GC'lQ?5~ Q?~ Sobo 3(Y)~d6oa~ao 0~SC'l~::J05o~ob 'CJ5~Mo .
2.10.2. 'bo3o(i)o Q?~3~~o~ob Soeoa~ o\)l:JO~~ 0~b'CJ~MO~ob Q?~UM'CJ~O~ob01~5~30· oS~30 C'l01~bao
Q?~ R~6~MQ?O~~ 'b[JSC'l01, 2.9.2-2.9.3 3~5d6o~ao 0~5b~'b<;.?3M~~o \)obo01.
2.10.3. a~5Q?OQ?~6o, 0~b~~~MO~ob OOQ?Oo~Q? , Cl[Jez3~UQ?O~~ b~JC'l5J~MUC'l JC'lSoboob 01o01C'l0~~o
V03MOU SO[JM, O-Q?~5 10-SQ?o d~~001, G~~-G~~ao aoa<!?ooo JM06[JMO~ao~ob aoboQ?3001:
2.10.4. J~5Q?OQ?~6o, 'bo3o(i)o Q?~3~~o~ob aob(Y)~~o~ob Q?C'l5ob SoboQ?3001, Cl[Jez3~UQ?O~~
U~JC'l5J~MUC'l JC'lSoboob 01001C'l[)~~o V03MOU SO[JM, O-Q?~5 10-SQ?o d~~001, G~~-G~~ao aoSQ?ooo
JM06[)MO'CJSo~ob SobOQ?3001:
2.10.5. U~JC'l5J~MUC'l JC'lSoboob V03MOU aoo(i) bo~SC'l\)[JMO~O O[Jez3~bo~ob ez3'CJMG~O~O
o~<!?~oeoa~ 6~010~ ~(Y}~~a0u .
830~~ a~5Q?OQ?~6ob 01~6~~~(') SQ?0C'lS~M[)C'l~~ao R~b~l:J050~~~Q? , b~JC'l5J~MUC'l JC'lSoboob
V03MO~O a~01 ~U3~ao5 (~SC'lbbb5o~~Q? o~Q?~beoao5) 01~5~~~MO UOM01~~ob Q?~ .
aod~o~obQ?~Q3~M~Q?, [JM01Q3~MC'l3~5 Cl[JJ001b3o~b (,J~'b~bo~b") .
2.12.1. 01001C'l[)~~o J~5Q?OQ?~6ob SoS~M01 ~MU[J~~~ O[Jez3~bo~ob ez3'CJMG~O~Cio ~b~b'CJ~O
Cl[Jez3~bo~o~ob 0~013~~ob\)o6o~o01, 6~010~ ~C'l~~do 0~SC'lo~50~Moao~b b~Cl'CJ~~C'l ~Mo01S060J'CJ~U,
M~G \)~MSC'l~Q?Q05b J~5Q?OQ?~6ob b~~C'l~C'lC'l O[Jez3~bo~ob d~~~b.
2.12.2. ,JC'l5J~Mbao" 0~S~MX30~'CJ~, b~~J001[JUC'l J~5Q?OQ?~6~<!? R~o013~0~~ ob J~5Q?OQ?~6o,
MC'lS~ob b~~(Y}~(Y}(Y} aoez3~bo~ob d~~~ 830~~'bo a~<;.?~~o ~<;.?aC'lR5Q?o~~.
2.12.4. 01~ C'lMO ~5 M~SQ?o5oSo J~5Q?OQ?~6ob b~C'l~C'lC'l O[Jez3~bo~ob d'CJ~O~O ~<;,?SC'lR5Q?O~~
OQ?056~MO, U~JC'l5J~MUC'l JC'lSobo~ a~01 OC'lMOU b~~J001[JUC'l a~5Q?OQ?~6b o~aC'l~3~o5b
11
J:J6Job8MOb 0 'born. rn~ J:J6Job8MOb O:J(g:J0.)(g J.)6cgocg.)o:Je:,a.) aoo~:Jb rn.)6.)e:,.)MO ba:Je:,O,
0.)<;:g.)8V83:JOO od6:Je:,.) b.)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) J(Y)Boboob rn.)3axcg(Y)8.)(Y)ob b8.).
2.13.1. b.)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) a(Y)aobo.) 3.).3.)6o~(Y) rn.)6.)8cg:Je:,(Y)e:,.)'b:J cg.)b6oo6.)cg V.)M.)<;:gQ:J6b b.)~J:Jrn:Jb(Y)
J.)6cgocg.)ob .)6 <;:g.)b.)e:,~rn:Je:,~~ ~.)(Y)b .)Gb.)cg:Je:,b a.)6cgocg.)oob V.)M<;:gQ:J6.)'b:J. .)~6oo6~~o
\.).)e:,(Y)~(Y)(Y) o.)(g.)V83:JOO~:Je:,.) ao~:Je:,~~ ~6<;:g.) od6:Jb \.).)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) o.)6.)(3b.)cg:Je:,Ob V.)M<;:gO:J60b
3.)cgob .)a(Y)v~M3ocg.)6 .)M.)~03o.)6:Jb 3 rn3ob.
2.13.2. b.)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) J(Y)8obo.) oobe:,.)aobo 0.)<;:g.)V83:JOO~:Je:,ob ao~ne:,ocg.)6 .)M.)~Q3o.)6:Jb 5
ba~o.)(Y) cg~ob.) rnorn(Y):J~~ J.)6cgocg.)ob :J~:JdOM(Y)6~~.)cg .)(36(Y)e:,:Je:,b Bob 8o8.)Mrn ao~:Je:,~~o
0.)<;:g.)v8380o~8e:,ob O:Jb.)b:Je:,.
2.13.3. d~rn.)obob \.).).)o:J~.)(30(Y) \.).)\.).)8.)(Y)rn~(Y) ,J(Y)6J~Mbob" O:J(g:JO:Je:,ob O:Jbb:Je:, o6<z3(Y)M8.)(3mb
.)b.)b.)3b ,e:,o~M(Y)b" 8o:JM .)<;:g8o6obo(Y)o(Y):Je:,~~o 3:Je:,Q3:JM<;:gob O:Jb.)e:,.)aob a(Y)cg~~oo.
2.14.1. b.)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) J(Y)8oboob J(Y)8~60J.)(30.) J.)6cgo<;:g.)O:Je:,rn.)6 b(Y)M(30:J~<;:g:Je:,.) ab(Y)~(Y)cg
:J~:JdOM(Y)6~~o aoa(Y)V:JMob 0 'born, 6.)rno.) ~(Y)~.)dob 8:J03:J(Y)e:,orn.
2.14.2. 6.)rnO.) ~(Y)~.)d:J ~'t>(Y)~63:J~8(Y)<z3b vo6.)8<;:g:Je:,.)(Y):J (Y)d8ob o.)8(Y)d3:J86:Je:,.)\.) d~rn.)obob
\.).).)o:J~.)GO(Y) b.)b.)8.)(Y)rn~(Y)b 3:Je:,-Q3:JM<;:g'b:J, .)b:J3:J - aobo :J~:JdOM(Y)6~~o 3:JMboob 0.)<;:g.)0'\J.)36.)b
,J(Y)6J~Mbob" 8:J(Y)M:J :J0.)3'b:J 0.)<;:g.)b~~o 83:J~.) J.)6cgocg.)oobrn3ob.
3. b.)J(Y)6J~Mb(Y) J(Y)8obo.)a, a(Y)ob8o6.) (Y).) d:Jrn:J3.)6 .)V8~M:J~ob a(Y)bb:J6:Je:,.), .. v:Jbob" Bo-19
8~b~ob b.)<z3~d3:J~'t>:J <;:g.) 8:J-18 ~b~ob 8:J-3 3~6doob O:Jb.)e:,.)aob.)cg, J:J6Job8Mob O:J(g:Jo~·
:JMrnb8.)cg o.)(g.)V83oo.):
12
N~~ J05cpocp0~ob bba~o, 2>30Mo cp0 o5caf'lM80(300 J05cpocp0~ob
3oM0cpo 5f'l8[)MO 2>08f'lG b0cpa~ob Q').)(Y}~.) <t>a
13
J~5(20(2~QOU ffiQMMO~<!!'O ffiQMMO~<!!'O ~'b(Y)ou oM~a~ooa~<!!'~C2
u~bo<!!'o, (3M(250U (3M(250U <!!'~ JM5~M~(2 U\)MM~(2 \)QMOU
Q3~Mo (2~ ao<a~uoe,~ 3(Y)~dooa~ao (2~ 5~m<!!'~C2 ~5~(Y)ou
3oM~(20 (0-(2~5 10
0~a(Y)~050e,ou o~(28M(3Q8ou ao<a~uoe,~
5M8QMO ~5~(Y)ou ~5~(i)ou d~<!!'~8(2Q)
ao<a~uoe,~ ao<a~uoe,~ (0-(2~5 10
d~<!!'~8(2Q)
(0-(2~5 10 (0-(2~5 10
d~<!!'~ae2o) d~<!!'~8(2Q)
......
VI
,--.
.. 0 13 Cl
" 0
1 .... 0 u.
... C3
13
Cl"
Q.)
fc3
u '-'
fc3
Cl"
OJ
0 3\
Cl"
fc3
0 01
3 Q
) u 3
\ 0
Cv Cl"
01
fc3
0 fc3
Cl
"
Go g. c::' g.
u 13
? ~
Cl" 3\
0
Q) ~ ~
<:&
3\
0'
Cl"
g. ,a
5, I
0 0
c::'
(j
c::'
Go
01
C3
3
\ Cl
" 0
1
u 3
\ C/
" c;
:' I
3\
C3 ~
0 ~
cu
c::'
'd
8 '-
'O'U
03
Cl
" 0
" u
3\
g. cs
u g
..Q
)Q)
u ~
Cl"
e"
0 9
,--.
.. 0 I fc3
Cl
" 0
1 .... 0 u..
.. C3
13
Cl
" Q
)
fc3
u '-'
03
u cs g 0"
Cl"
0 01
Go
u 13
u u..
.. Go
g.
a'
u 13
Q) ~ 3\ ~
c::' ct 3 01
C
v C3 3\
c::' 3 C
v 3 Q) g. 0 g. 83
cu 3\
~
a3
u cs g 0" g. ~ 3\
g 13
0
Cv Cl"
01
fc3
0 fc3
Cl"
Go g. Q
.)
0 u 3\ ~
(§
0" J'
0" g. ~ g.
cs ~ Q)
Cl" ~ ~
~
Cl"
C3 g. 0" g. a3
u cs g g; cs ~
g 13 ~
J.)6Q?OQ?.)oob mo(Y)MO'CJ~O mo(Y)MO'CJ~O .)<tJ(Y)ob J(Y)a3o'C.JoO<">'CJ~o
bbo~o, Q3.)Mo (3(Y)Q?60b (3(Y)Q?60b ~.)J(Y)6'C.)M.)Q? Q?.) 3<">(Y)0M.)ao~ob
Q?.) 3oM.)Q?O 00£PUO~.) 3M.)JOOJ.)OO 6.)m~.)Q? (3(Y)Q?60b
6(Y)ao<">o (0-Q?.)6 10
o.)a(Y)8o6o~ou 0.)Q?a(Y)80aou 00£PUO~.)
'CJ6.)(Y}ob Clo£pbo~.) 'CJ6.)<">ou aoca.)uo~.) d'CJ~.)aQ?o) (0-Q?.)6 10
(0-Q?.)6 10 (0-Q?.)6 10 d'CJ~.)aQ?o)
d'CJ~.)aQ?o) d'CJ~.)aQ?o)
H Si~~, CpoBC~C.~ Cqogw
:ogd~od:>e qooqogwE'
. "::)f'~¥1 a og<oirJCEqO QO<,>Cq,
J :J Cp~~w~ ~ow~g
Cp~g~~Q, o~~wo~
., ~IAij~· -~ o~o8BoQo~8<a o~Qogod:>
•C Cp~~gC'.~~ ~o~~~
o~C~C.R~~ g~8CwCf!
:ocaC~8C~ qooqogwE'
·CQ,<O<;>~q L 1 <;>d:>~8<;>wg<;>d:> <;>gwd:>qq
·~caC~oe qocaC~oQC8R~~d:>~~ caCq<;>qCB
qog8Bog<;>d:> ~w~d:>od:>g~E' ~og~d:>~<;>~ ~Cog qooqogwE' wq~C'.E'gwE'~q :oqo~e Sl qo~~ 8l0l
~~9B09~q~d:>
~g~d:>~~~ qocaCQ~d:>od:>g~r wqCwCrc.~q ~Cog qooqogwE' wq~C.E'gwE'~q :oqo~e 11 qo~~ 8l0l
~~eCOoe
qocaC~~8~d:> o~~Q, ~d:> ~caC~caC.~q~~ g~wcaCQ<;>d:>od:>g~E' :oqo~e v-o~o~~ 9l qo~~ 8l0l
~~eCOoe qocaC~~8~d:> owo~C~ qo8w~qocaCQ~d:>od:>g~E' :o~o~~~ Sl qo~~ 8l0l
~o~QC o~C8~o~ ,qoq~C.E'gwE'" :o~o~~ l1 -oQ~~e 8l qo~~ 8l0l
~~g~d:>we~~~ qocaCd:>~q_O<;>~~ ~Cog qocaCQ<;>d:>od:>g~E' :oQ~~e a-vi qo~~ 8l0l
~wocawC8BCe qod:>~CW-caC8 o~C.caC~o~Qqogoed:>~ ~Coe ,qw~C.oca"
~caCgRC8f!we~~ qocaCoqg~E'~8 ~d:> ~caCd:><;>q_Owg<;>~ ,qoq~C.E'gwE'" :oQ~~e £1-L qo~~ 8l0l
:oE'oS>~~~ o~Cd:>eCB qocaC~~Q~~ ,qoq~C'.E'gwE'" qw~8~Q,~qog~~
:~Qo8R~<;>d:>~~ d:>~eqw~C
·d:>~~Cd:>CB qo~RqofgCE' ·d:>~qoe~ca~qCB qoQf!gC.~ £-Ce qo~qC'.e 81-Ce ~d:> CQ,~C8pC'.S>~q qo~qC.e
61-Ce ,qoqC~" ·~caCgCqqwe qo~C~c.R~~ g~8CwCf! ~~ ~gogqowe ·e~oqogwE' wq~C.E'gwE'~q ·v