Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The...

46
Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar February 14, 2019 10:30 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. (Eastern) www.florida-stormwater.org

Transcript of Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The...

Page 1: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar

February 14, 2019 10:30 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. (Eastern)

www.florida-stormwater.org

Page 2: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

Community Based | Regionally Skilled

Page 3: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

Today’s Presenters

Thomas Frick, Director Division of Environmental Assessment and Restoration, FDEP Email: [email protected]

Brett Cunningham, PE, Managing Director / Sr. Vice President Jones Edmunds & Associates Email: [email protected]

Stephanie Gudeman, Manager Division of Water Resource Management, FDEP Email: [email protected]

Maurice Barker, Engineer Domestic Wastewater Program, FDEP Email: [email protected]

Page 4: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

SLIDE TITLE

Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns

February 14, 2019

Page 5: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

2

Presentation Elements

Blue Cypress Lake

Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee

Page 6: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

3

Acknowledgements

SJRWMD

Indian River County Utilities

Janicki Environmental

Page 7: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

4

Blue Cypress Lake Watershed

Page 8: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

5

Blue Cypress Lake Watershed

Page 9: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

6

Blue Cypress Lake Nutrient Trends

Page 10: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

7

Blue Cypress Lake TP Annual Geometric Means

Page 11: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

8

Annual Biosolids Applications in Blue Cypress Lake Watershed

Page 12: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

9

Biosolids Moratoria and Resolutions

Indian River County (July 2018)

Treasure Coast Regional Planning Council

Fellsmere

St. Lucie County

Others

Page 13: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

10

SJRWMD Analyses

Page 14: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

11

Blue Cypress Lake Water Quality

Page 15: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

12

No Trend in Blue Cypress Creek TP

Page 16: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

13

No Trend in Padgett Branch TP

Page 17: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

14

No trend in Blue Cypress Marsh TP

Page 18: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

15

Upward Trend in Blue Cypress Lake TP

Page 19: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

16

Upward Trend in Blue Cypress Lake Outflow TP

Page 20: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

17

Water Quality Assessment

Waterbody TN TP Chlorophyll a Dissolved Oxygen

Blue Cypress Lake Not Impaired Impaired Not Impaired Not Impaired

Padgett Branch Not Impaired Study List Study List

Blue Cypress Lake Drain Not Impaired Study List Study List

Blue Cypress Marsh Not Impaired Study List

Blue Cypress Creek Not Impaired Study List Study List

Currently Blue Cypress Marsh impaired for macrophytes

Anticipated impairment status of each of the WBIDs

Page 21: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

18

Nutrient Budget

Page 22: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

19

Nutrient Budget

Page 23: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

20

Nutrient Budget

Page 24: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

21

Nutrient Budget

Page 25: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

22

Nutrient Budget

Page 26: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

23

Lake Nutrient Recycling Unlikely

Page 27: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

24

SJRWMD Sampling

Page 28: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

25

Source is Primarily Dissolved Phosphate

Page 29: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

26

High P in soils

Page 30: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

27

No Correlation with Potassium

Page 31: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

28

Other Considerations

Hauler generally in compliance with permit

Land owner cooperative

Caution in extrapolating results

Page 32: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

Biosolids in Florida Maurice Barker and Stephanie Gudeman

Division of Water Resource Management

February 14, 2019

Page 33: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

2

• Biosolids Overview

• Biosolids Management in Florida

• Septage Management Facilities

• Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee

Overview

Page 34: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

3

Biosolids Overview The treatment of domestic wastewater produces two principal end products: effluent and biosolids

Page 35: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

4

Classes of Biosolids

•Two primary uses:

Land application

• Typically Class B biosolids – minimum quality for beneficial use

Distribution and marketing as fertilizer

• Class AA biosolids – highest quality for beneficial use

Page 36: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

5

Biosolids Management in Florida

• Estimated Total Production 340,000 dry tons/year.

• Approximately two-thirds are beneficially used and one third is landfilled.

Landfill Land

Application

(Class B)

Distribution and

Marketing (Class

AA)

Page 37: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

6

Class AA Biosolids-

Distribution and Marketing

• Distributed and marketed as a fertilizer

• Approximately 39 Florida facilities produce Class AA

192,879 dry tons distributed and marketed in Florida

26,717 dry tons distributed and marketed outside of Florida

Page 38: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

7

Class B Land Application

• Approximately 140 permitted land application sites in Florida

• Haulers are the most common site permittees

• Utilities commonly contract with haulers/appliers instead of applying the biosolids themselves

Page 39: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

8

Septage Management Facilities

• The land application of septage under Florida Department of Health (DOH) regulations was prohibited after June 30, 2016, affecting 80-90 entities regulated by DOH

• Under DEP rules, septage is regulated as “biosolids”

• Since 2016, DEP has issued 42 septage management facility permits

Page 40: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

9

State Regulations Ch 62-640,

F.A.C.

Land application permits include:

• Nutrient management plan

• Setback provisions

• Ground water depth provision

• Signage Requirements

• Storage requirements

• Public access, grazing, harvesting restrictions

• Runoff provisions

• Record keeping/reporting requirements

Page 41: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

10

Example Application Site

• Site in Osceola and Brevard Counties, shows the application zones, setbacks, etc.

• This site has 30 application zones covering 5,736 acres

• The odd shapes of the application zones, or fields, primarily result from setback buffers (i.e., wetlands, surface waters, residences, etc.)

Page 42: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

11

Biosolids Technical

Advisory Committee

• The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids management and explore opportunities to better protect Florida’s water resources.

• The TAC members represented stakeholders from environmental and agricultural industry experts, large and small utilities, waste haulers, consultants and academics.

• Each public meeting included an open public comment period, as well as discussion with experts among the TAC members, the audience and the Department

Page 43: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

12

TAC Recommendations

• Permit biosolids in a manner that minimizes migration of nutrients, specifically phosphorus, to prevent impairment to waterbodies.

• Establish the rate of phosphorus application based on site specifics, such as soil characteristics/phosphorus adsorption capacity, water table, hydrogeology, site use, distance to surface water;

Page 44: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

13

TAC Recommendations,

continued

• Increase DEP inspection rate of land application sites;

•Develop monitoring protocols to detect nutrient migration;

•Develop and conduct biosolid and nutrient management research on nutrient run-off through surface and groundwater flow; and

•Promote innovative technology pilot projects for biosolids processing that could provide a wider range of beneficial end products.

Page 45: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids

14

Contact Information

Maurice Barker

Division of Water Resource Management

[email protected]

850-245-8614

Stephanie Gudeman

Division of Water Resource Management

[email protected]

850-245-8814

QUESTIONS?

Page 46: Biosolids and Water Quality Concerns Webinar...Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee •The Biosolids Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) convened in September 2018 to evaluate biosolids