Biomass Initiative for the State of California
Transcript of Biomass Initiative for the State of California
Changing World Technologies, IncBiomass Initiative
for the
State of California
“Anything into oil”
Eliminate WasteProduce Renewable Energy
Reduce Global WarmingImprove Quality of Life
…A new beginning; Thermal Conversion Process
A biomass bio-refinery which safely converts waste into clean fuels and industrial products
Thermal Conversion ProcessFeedstock Prep• Mixing and pulping
1st Stage Reactor• Aqueous depolymerization• 250°C and 50 atmospheres
2nd Stage Reactor• Organic oil reforming• Fuel-gas to power plant• Bio-derived hydrocarbon oil to separation
Product oilstorage
1st stage organic oil
Water, minerals, solubles
Pressurizing and Heating
Flash Tank• 1st stage product separation• Organic oil to 2nd stage• Water to evaporation• Minerals to drying
Oil Separation• Water and solubles to evaporation
Market Opportunities
Future Market Opportunities
Pulp & Paper
Heavy Oil & Coal
Hazardous Waste
Distribution of Solid Waste in the U.S.
6%
51%
3%
39%
1%Industrial
Agriculture
Municipal
Mining/Milling
Utility
12 Billion tons per year
Food & Agriculture Auto & Rubber Municipal Solid &Sewage Sludge
Disposed Waste Streams (~ 35 million tons) 1999
Statewide totalsCATEGORY POUNDS GALLONS TOTAL DAILY DAILY
OIL/TON OIL/TON TONS TONS GALLONS of OIL
__________ _________ ___________ _______ ______________
Paper 520 69 10,742,707 29,432 2,030,808
Plastics 1400 186 3,161,711 8,662 1,611,132
Organics (other) 520 69 12,490,171 34,220 2,361,180
Tires 880 117 145,899 400 46,800
Gallons per day 6,049,920
Gallons per year 2,208,220,800
Sub-category of statewide totals
•HDPE, PET Containers 1400 186 436,559 1,196 222,456
•Food 880 69 5,584,506 15,300 1,055,700
Source: California 1999 Statewide Waste Composition Study
144,045Barrels
(Every Day)
California Energy Conversions
Comparison of Available Technologies
High
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
CreatesAdditional
No
Yes (must be rendered first)
Incineration/Gasification
HighHighHighLowCost
YesYesYesNoCreates problem by-products
YesYesYesNoEmissions issues
YesYesYesNoGroundwater contamination
YesYesNoYesCreates “Green” Energy
NoNoNoYesDestroys Dioxins
NoYesNoYesDestroys Prions
NoYesNoYesHandle High Risk Material
DigestorsPyrolysisLandfillTCP
Multiple available sources of renewable
energy
Municipal solid wasteAgricultural waste
Utilization of Existing Infrastructures
Water is Utilized Under Pressure Energy Efficiencies Over 80%
Water available to utilize in arid or
water intense environments
No Incineration or Combustion Avoiding Pollution and Formation of BAD ACTORS
Industrial operating plant, processing
organic and inorganic waste
Fuels MeetD-975D-396
No special handling
of products
Thermal Conversion Process Products
Carbon Minerals Gasoline SplitsTDP 40
Diesel Split
RawProductOrganic
Liquor
TCP Typical Process Flow for Sewage Sludge
Bar grates &grit removal Aeration
Primaryclarifier
Concen-tration
Aerobictreatment
Secondary clarifier Disinfection
Water, debris, and ~300 ppm
organics
Grit/debris
Fuel - gas Oil
Water discharge
dissolved organics
~20% dry solids
Sludge
All scum
Concentrate Grease(optional)
Thermally treated water
Minerals Carbon CWT-TP
Dissolved organics + inorganics
Water with
Replace digestors
Food CompositionA mixed wet waste stream - provides opportunities
FatFat
CarbsCarbs
ProteinProtein
Hydrocarbon Fuels• Hydrocarbons contain hydrogen and carbon
MethaneMethane
H C
H
H
H
Cetane, a 16Cetane, a 16--carbon straight chain hydrocarboncarbon straight chain hydrocarbon
OctaneOctane
H CCCCCCCC
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
HH CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
Fatty Acids are Similar to Hydrocarbons
Palmitic AcidPalmitic AcidCarboxylicgroup-COOH
HCO
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
O
H
CetaneCetane
HH CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
Amino Acids – Protein
• Amino acids contain a carboxylic group• They also contain an amine group
CarboxylicCarboxylicgroupgroup--COOH O N
HC
H
HH
C
O
COOH HAmine group, Amine group, --NHNH22
GlycineGlycine
Carbohydrates• Carbs have the general formula C(H2O)
– Blood sugar is glucose, C6(H2O)6
– Sucrose is two sugars attached through an “O”
SucroseSucrose
GlucoseGlucose
Breakdown of Plastics
Vehicle Recycling PartnershipVehicle Recycling PartnershipAuto Shredder ResidueAuto Shredder Residue
•• Oxygen/chlorine bondsOxygen/chlorine bondsIncluding Dioxins
PVCPVCPETPET
•• CarbonCarbon--carbon bondscarbon bonds
PolypropylenePolypropylene
PolystyrenePolystyrene
The biomass produced oil can be utilized in the refined oil markets of California. The refined oil markets in the United States can be categorized into two broad uses…
Fixed energy production market
6,576
Residential/CommercialResidential/Commercial
Distillate fuel 657Kerosene 36LPG 505Gasoline 20Residual fuel 30
1,248
IndustrialIndustrial
Distillate fuel 603Kerosene 7LPG 1,648Gasoline 159Residual fuel 87Petroleum coke 398Other petroleum1,435Lubricants 78Asphalt 513
4,926
Electrical power
Electrical power
Distillate fuel 51Petroleum coke 61Residual fuel oil 291
402
(000’s barrels per day)2002 statistics
Total: 19,665 barrels which is equivalent to 2.9MM tons a day
Transportation fuel market
13,089
Motor gasoline 88,355Fuel additives* 310Distillate fuel 1,800LPG 10
Distillate fuel 665Kerosene 1,608Aviation gasoline 18 Residual fuel oil 250Lubricants 73
10,475
2,614
On RoadOn Road
Off RoadOff Road
*Ethanol production between 170 and 200 of total fuel additive production
…petroleum use involves a complex and well developed supply chain.
Blend and deliver hydrocarbons to the end users. Various uses of petroleum are very specific in quality standards so precise blending is necessary. Often managepipeline distribution systems.
Crude oil Gatherers
Source crude oil from oil fields and manageinbound logistics for oilrefineries. Often own ormanage pipelines.
Guard DogsRemove water and saltSeparate various fractionsRemove sulfur and other
impurities
Can be either wholesale/retail customers or both.
Imports-60%Domestic-40%
End users
Blenders/distributorsRefiners
Enter product as a crude oil into supply system by using the gatherers.
Why use them?-Logistics-Security blanket torefiner
Enter product asa crude oil directly tothe refiner.
Why do this?-Bypass gatherer-Get recognition ofattributes of AFcrude
Enter product as fuel additive which is blended by refiner, blender or end user with other refined oils.
Why do this?-Increase value as AF is a fully refined product whichwould only need blending
Enter product as an intermediate feed stock in the refinery.
Why do this?-Increase value of AFproduct as it would reducerefinery operating costs
Enter product as refined finished product capable of being used by end user straight or blended.
Why do this?-Maximize value
… governments have altered the value proposition for both fixed energy production and transportation fuel markets.
Renewable fuel requirementsRestrictions on air emissions (including KYOTO) Mandatory government purchasing guidelines
Renewable fuel requirementsRestrictions on air emissions (including KYOTO) Mandatory government purchasing guidelines
Fixed energy production marketFixed energy production market
Policies requiring/restricting use
Subsidies
Transportation fuelmarketTransportation fuelmarket
Mandatory sulfur reduction in diesel fuelsMandatory government purchasing guidelinesKYOTO?
Mandatory sulfur reduction in diesel fuelsMandatory government purchasing guidelinesKYOTO?
Environmental restrictionson production of productEnvironmental restrictionson production of product
Emissions standards Permitting processesEmissions standards Permitting processes
Financial incentives for environmentally friendly production processes
Financial incentives for environmentally friendly production processes
Fixed energy production marketFixed energy production market
Loan guaranteesDirect capital supportLoan guaranteesDirect capital support
Production credits for manufacturers of products based upon environmental value of product in its final usageBlenders credits for users of the productLoan guaranteesDirect capital support
Production credits for manufacturers of products based upon environmental value of product in its final usageBlenders credits for users of the productLoan guaranteesDirect capital support
Transportation fuelmarketTransportation fuelmarket
Carbon credits for clean production of fuelCarbon credits for clean production of fuel
…it has been the belief of lawmakers that alternative fuels offer an opportunity to provide energy independence and petroleum reduction, however we have actually limited competition by enacting “exclusive definitions” at the federal government for incentive to stimulate change.
Demand U.S. 2002 annual: 25MM gallons, which is less than 600,000 barrels in entire year.Europe 2003: 341MM gallons, which is only 8.2MM barrels a year.
Environmental: EPA reducing sulfur in diesel fuel which will create lubricity problem.Biodiesel is supposed to be able to solve this problem. Farm policy: Theory is that biodiesel will create demand for vegetable oil which will increasesoybean demand and therefore keep prices of soybeans above marketing support level.Soybean processing industry driven: Need demand for soybean oil as soybean meal is whatdrives crushing capacity. Follow European lead and mandate use of renewable energy into fuel supply.
Change drivers
The Problems
U.S. is not Europe, where 50% of the transportation vehicles run on diesel.Biodiesel fuel has variety of functional use limitations including lack of solubility in cold temperatures.Biodiesel may create variety of environmental hazards associated with emissions from dieselengines.Biodiesel has been expensive to produce.
BIODIESEL FACTS
THE SOLUTION: Treat all fuels equally, if produced from biomass. If we are successful these efforts will help expand alternative fuel use and fossil fuel extraction. A level playing field should stimulate competition and result in lower prices.
Alternative fuel suppliers benefit from a variety of non-subsidy programs being enacted by both federal/state governments as well as companies using green power…
Mandates 20% reduction in federal motor vehicle fleets by end of calendar 2005.Executive Order 13149Executive Order 13149
Requires all diesel fuel sold in State of Minnesota contain 2% biodiesel by June 30, 2005.
-Creates demand for 16MM gallons of biodiesel annually.
Minnesota Consumption RequirementsMinnesota Consumption RequirementsLAWS CREATING DEMAND
State renewable fuel use standardsState renewable fuel use standards 13 states have legislation that requires a certain percentage of power fuel to be from renewable sources by various times in future. “RPS”
Variety of power companiesare exploring whether sociallyconscious consumer will pay
premium for green fuel
Variety of power companiesare exploring whether sociallyconscious consumer will pay
premium for green fuel
If these programs can generate revenue for power generators then producers will receive a portion of that premium.
THE PRIVATE GREEN CARD
These efforts will result in the offset of traditional petroleum extraction, negatively impacting major industries (both power and petroleum). We must build a bridge between these established industries and alternative energy producers. We collectively can embrace change by working together.
…next steps to develop a biomass and biofuels program and achieve petroleum reduction
•Understand the driving force and how to enter the market
•Identify problems and recommend solutions or incentives
•Expand excise tax reduction incentives to include income tax deduction
•Embrace power markets during a transitional period
•Easier maintenance, more forgiving, and a central location
•Typically dirtier fuels and most have grandfather status
End users
Blenders/distributors
Crude oil RefinersGatherers
Enter product as a crude oil into supply system by using the gatherers.
Enter product asa crude oil directly tothe refiner.
Enter product as fuel additive which is blended by refiner, blender or end user with other refined oils.
Enter product as an intermediate feed stock in the refinery.
Enter product as refined finished product capable of being used by end user straight or blended.
…There is a desire to use biomass waste and eliminate landfills. There are energy shortages, quality control and special handling issues on existing alternative fuels. What can a public/private partnership do?
Biodiesel is complicated due to alcohols and glycerin…Help the
industry find a solution. Power is an obvious one
Alternative fuels need a refiner. They convert
CRUDE to useful products. Forward contracts with refineries mean 975 and 396 specifications can be
achieved
Refiners
Work with an infrastructure that has figured out how to keep equipment within the specification of engine manufacturers. Work with legislators that understand the balance of the tax system and production incentives needed for promotion of biomass and alternative fuels
We need alternative energy produced from waste biomass – Bridge the gap and engage big industry to accelerate noble changes. Market and demand is enormous.
Minimize complications of different blends. Avoid boutique
approach
Definition of ALTERNATIVE FUELS should
be inclusive, not exclusive