BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

37
What’s the social impact of volunteering with Big Help Mob? Findings from the Big Help Mob Evaluation 2014 The Foundation for Young Australians July 2014 Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 1

Transcript of BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Page 1: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

What’s the social impact of volunteering with Big Help Mob?

Findings from the Big Help Mob Evaluation 2014

The Foundation for Young Australians

July 2014

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 1

Page 2: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 2

PROPOSAL HEADING

Prepared by Tessa Hillgrove, Olivia Killeen, and Naomi Berman

Contact [email protected] or 03 9670 5436

July 2014 Acknowlegement The authors would like to thank the staff and volunteers of Big Help Mob, who spent considerable time conducing interviews and surveys to gather the stories presented in this report, as well as the volunteers who generously shared their experiences. We would also like to thank Big Help Mob for the opportunity to complete this research. We thank Jeanette Pope and Rachel Mutch from FYA for their thoughtful comments on earlier drafts of this report. Copyright & Disclaimer The materials presented in this report are for information purposes only. The information is provided solely on the basis that readers will be responsible for making their own assessments of the matters discussed and are advised to verify all relevant representations, statements and information and obtain independent advice before acting on any information contained in or in connection with this report. While every effort has been made to ensure that the information is accurate the Foundation for Young Australians will not accept any liability for any loss or damage which may be incurred by any person acting in reliance upon the information.

Page 3: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 3

PROPOSAL HEADING

Executive Summary

Big Help Mob (BHM) arose from Useful’s idea that helping people to contribute to addressing bigger-

then-self issues could change the way people engage with their world. The program has a particular

focus on harnessing the efforts of young people through assembling a group of volunteers primarily

aged 18-30, mobilised to achieve a social purpose while creating positive experiences of volunteering.

Big Help Mob’s volunteers make a substantial contribution to their community through the missions

they undertake with local organisations. However, the experience is likely to have a personal impact

on many of those who take part. This evaluation aimed to measure the social impact of BHM’s

efforts for the individuals who volunteer through the organisation, with a focus on changes that

took place in volunteers’ lives, shifts in their worldviews, or new self-perceptions that resulted

from their volunteering.

This report has shown that the experience of volunteering with Big Help Mob has a highly beneficial

impact for the majority of volunteers, with most reporting positive life changes and increased pro-

social attitudes following on from their volunteer experience.

Those who volunteer for Big Help Mob experience:

1. personal benefits: feeling good about themselves, feeling useful, meeting new people,

feeling a part of their community, getting exposure to new activities and learning new skills,

and developing new perspectives and ideas as a result of their volunteering.

2. positive life changes: engaging in more volunteering; gaining new ideas and perspectives;

building new networks and feeling part of a community; changing jobs to something more

aligned with their interests; starting new courses to take them in a new direction; feeling

inspired and empowered; improving wellbeing; and developing personal.

The components particularly important for creating change are:

1. exposure to a network of like-minded, enthusiastic young volunteers provides a sense of

belonging for new volunteers, and sets a strong example, both in their life choices and in

their volunteering behaviour, which inspires new ideas and encourages further volunteering.

2. highly accessible and meaningful volunteer opportunities reduce many traditional

barriers to young people volunteering such as a lack of time, not having skills, or not knowing

people who already volunteer.

3. exposure to new populations provides opportunities to interact with groups in the

community volunteers might previously never had direct contact with.

Page 4: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 4

PROPOSAL HEADING

Background

Big Help Mob (BHM) arose through Useful Inc.’s passion and commitment to create a generation

actively working to solve bigger-than-self issues. The Western Australian-based organisation aims to

foster volunteer experiences that capture people’s energy, excitement and passion, by creating an

online platform that allows individuals to propose, organise and join short term, ad hoc volunteering

events known as missions.

BHM missions begin with a request from a community organisation for volunteers to assist with a

project. The mission is then organised by a captain, who takes responsibility for the logistical

arrangement of the mission and recruitment of volunteers (called sidekicks).

Upcoming missions are advertised on the digital platform and potential sidekicks can volunteer for

specific missions until the mission reaches its capacity. Missions are designed to be completed in one

day, and do not require any particular skills or experience from volunteers.

Examples of recent missions include painting a stairwell for a community organisation, preparing and

serving a National Aborigines and Islanders Day Observance Committee (NAIDOC) week breakfast for

200 people, and supporting activities in a school holiday program for children with autism.

A further component of Big Help Mob’s activities is the Unternship program, where 18-25 year olds

join BHM for a structured six-month development program, responsible for generating new missions

and recruiting volunteers while gaining valuable organisational and communication skills.

BHM has a particular focus on harnessing the efforts of the community through assembling an

'army' of volunteers mobilised to have great expereince in the helping the community and achieving

a social impact for community organisations.

In doing this, BHM connects people to bigger-than-self issues in their own local community and

causes increased pro-social behaviours and civic participation.

The stated objectives of Big Help Mob are:

1. Create happier and healthier communities by creating a cultural change that sees the

majority of people directly engaged in solving bigger-than-self issues.

2. Connect people who are looking for meaning and purpose with purpose-driven

organisations who are looking for people.

3. Increase the volunteering capacities of not-for-profit agencies/organisations notably in

next generation volunteering.

Page 5: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 5

PROPOSAL HEADING

4. Develop more engaged volunteers by enhancing the enjoyment of the volunteering

experience.

Big Help Mob’s volunteers make a substantial contribution to their community through the missions

they undertake with local organisations. However, in addition the experience of joining a mission and

working alongside other like-minded volunteers to help others is likely to have a personal impact on

many of those who take part.

This evaluation aimed to measure the social impact of BHM’s efforts for the individuals who

volunteer with Big Help Mob, with a focus on changes that took place in volunteers’ lives, shifts in

their worldviews, or new self-perceptions that resulted from their volunteering.

The key research question addressed in this evaluation is: Does the experience of Big Help Mob lead

to further action and if so, what components of Big Help Mob are most influential and why?

Page 6: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 6

PROPOSAL HEADING

What social impacts could be expected from volunteering with Big

Help Mob? A review of the literature

This section provides a context to the findings of this evaluation by providing a summary of selected

literature exploring the how and why young people volunteer, barriers to participation, benefits of

volunteering, the rise of episodic volunteering, and the impact of social participation on the

formation of a civic identity. The review focuses on the personal benefits and social impacts, such as

changes in behaviour and attitudes experienced by individuals when they engage in formal

volunteering, with a particular emphasis on young people.

The next generation of volunteers

Young people are frequently accused of being less willing to volunteer or engage in other forms of

civic action than older groups. This is part of a broader international political and social discourse that

describes young people as apathetic, cynical and disengaged, lacking important civic and political

knowledge and making a lesser contribution to society than older citizens (e.g. Campbell 2006; Crick

1998; Mellor et al. 2001; Muir et al. 2009; Torney-Purta et al. 2001).

However, these findings are contradicted by studies that show many young Australians volunteer.

According to Australian census data, in 2011 just over one in five young people (21%) aged between

12 and 25, volunteered (ABS 2011), which is somewhat but not substantially lower than the rate

amongst older Australians, which is remarkable given young people often have more constraints on

participation, such as cost or lack of transport. In 2008, Australia ranked fourth out of 28 countries for

the percentage of young people participating in voluntary activities (ARACY 2008).

Studies suggest that young people are most attracted to volunteering opportunities that:

• engage their interests and values and enable them to put these into action in meaningful

ways

• meet a real and objective need and enable them to see the impact of their volunteering on

this need

• are intended to benefit other young people e.g. youth programs and camps

• offer them the opportunity to meet or work with high profile groups or individuals (Ferrier et

al 2004).

Page 7: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 7

PROPOSAL HEADING

These studies are part of a wider body of research that suggests young Australians are eager to

influence a range of social, political and economic issues (Arvanitakis & Marren 2009; Ferrier et al

2004; Horsley & Costley 2008; Manning & Ryan 2004; Mission Australia 2011). This research indicates

that young people in Australia are increasingly seeking alternate modes of participation and active

citizenship, eschewing traditional or formal modes such as voting or membership of political parties

(Arvanitakis & Sidoti 2011; Harris et al. 2010; Schulz et al. 2010; Vromen & Collin 2010; Walsh & Black

2011). These alternate modes of participation are understood to include volunteering.

The benefits of volunteering and community participation

A significant body of research illustrates the social benefits of volunteerism. Boessler and Ding (2010)

examined an Australian St Johns Ambulance volunteer program, with a view to understanding the

motivations, benefits and barriers to young people volunteering. Their research found that the

motivations for young people volunteering are to connect with people; use existing skills and develop

new ones; personal fulfilment and personal values; and expectations of others, including family and

Barriers to the next generation volunteering

While many young people contribute to their community, overall, this age group is less likely to

volunteer than older age groups (ABS 2011). Lower rates of volunteering by young people have

been found in a range of Australian studies over time (Baum et al. 1999, Ironmonger &

Soupourmas 2002; Ferrier et al. 2004; Pope 2005b; ABS 2006; ABS 2011).

A population survey in Victoria found a lack of interest is not a reason for low rates of

volunteering in any population group, including young people (Pope 2005b). Lower rates were

more likely to be the result of other barriers such as time or cost (Pope 2005b). This study also

showed around 22% of people think about volunteering, but don’t do it.

The biggest barriers to volunteering reported in the general population (all age groups) have been

(in order):

• being too busy

• not knowing about opportunities or routes into volunteering, and

• cost/access issues, such as transport (Ferrier et al. 2004; Ellis 2004; Pope 2005b; ACFID

2012).

Excerpt from FYA (Foundation for Young Australians) (2014 forthcoming) Unlimited Potential:

a data and information resource on young Australians. Foundation for Young Australians:

Melbourne.

Page 8: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 8

PROPOSAL HEADING

compulsory school programs. The benefits included both personal and professional outcomes. Young

people reported enjoying the experience, feeling valued, meeting new people and feeling a sense of

accomplishment. The authors concluded that volunteering might also provide young people with the

opportunity to utilise and improve skills they already have, develop new skills and increase their job

opportunities. However, a significant barrier existed in feelings of not being valued. For example, not

being involved in decisions that affect them, not being trusted, listened to or acknowledged, lack of

support and being given jobs that no one else wants to do.

A recent systematic review (Jenkinsen et al. 2013) explored the impact of formal volunteering on

physical and mental health. Volunteering was associated with a number of benefits, including greater

wellbeing, reduced stress, and more physical activity (all demonstrated in experimental studies) and

increased longevity, improved mental health, greater quality life, and higher satisfaction with life (all

demonstrated in other types of studies). It is worth noting that review primarily included research on

populations aged over 50, which reflects the limited research conducted on the benefits of

volunteering for younger populations, and that most, though not all, groups studied were regular

rather than episodic volunteers.

There were, however, two studies included in the review that featured a younger population and

therefore have relevance for BHM. The first study featured a broad age range (19-60) of volunteers

engaged in a variety of volunteering activities through a social welfare program, and found that

relative to those in the program who were not volunteering, volunteers experienced a greater sense

of empowerment (Cohen 2010). The second study demonstrates that the positive effects of

volunteering at a young age can have lasting impact (Bowman 2010). University students who

volunteered during their student years were found to have greater levels of well-being (specifically

personal growth, environmental mastery, life purpose and life satisfaction). Volunteering as a young

person influenced later well-being in two ways: by increasing the likelihood of volunteering as adults;

and by influencing attitudes and values collectively known as a “pro-social orientation”.

Page 9: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 9

PROPOSAL HEADING

The benefits of community participation for young people

Community participation has been shown to generate benefits in young people including:

Higher self-esteem, a sense of belonging and meaning and purpose (Johnston et al.

2004; Volunteering Australia 2011; UNV 2011; Oaktree Foundation 2012; Mundle et

al. 2012).

An increased sense of wellbeing and better physical and mental health (Young &

Glasgow 1998; Berkman & Glass 2000; Pope 2005a; Giles et al. 2005; Egan et al.

2008; Mundle et al. 2012).

Higher rates of healthy behaviours and lower rates of risk behaviours including:

o Improved: relationships with parents/teachers/friends; self-confidence;

control and awareness of the need to take responsibility; involvement

in/enjoyment of school; homework; positive risk-taking; and understanding

the transferability of skills and knowledge in different contexts (Harrison &

Narayan 2002; Davis Smith 2000, Wikeley et al. 2009), and

o Decreased: truancy, smoking, drug use, vandalism, fights, sexual activity and

sad or suicidal thoughts (Harrison & Narayan 2002; Alperstein & Raman

2003; Mundle et al. 2012).

Success in learning (Wikeley et al. 2009). Young people’s connections with adults in

clubs and activities outside of family and school have been shown to provide role

models, specialist expertise/skills, and opportunities to develop fresh and broader

perspectives on issues (Wikeley et al. 2009). This has been shown to give young

people a more positive appreciation of school and an increased ability to negotiate

their schooling with teachers (Wikeley et al. 2009).

Connection to better career paths. Networks developed through volunteering have

been shown to be important for connecting people to career paths and to labour

markets that are better paid and more stable (Granovetter 1983; Menchik &

Weisbrod 1987; Davis Smith 2000; Chapple 2002; Sacerdote & Marmos 2006).

Networks provide more opportunity, compensate for less experience and

qualifications, and attach people to jobs with longer tenure (Granovetter 1983;

Chapple 2002; Finneran & Kelly 2003; Ioannides & Loury 2004; Oaktree Foundation

2012).

Excerpt from Pope J (2011) Indicators of Community Strength: framework and evidence.

Department of Planning and Community Development: Melbourne.

Page 10: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 10

PROPOSAL HEADING

New forms of volunteering- episodic volunteering

Literature surrounding volunteering in recent decades has shown the rise of ‘episodic volunteering’, a

term coined by Nancy Macduff in 1991 (cited in Bryen & Madden 2006). Macduff suggested that

people increasingly preferred to volunteer on a short-term basis, rather than in traditional, long term

roles. The development of episodic volunteering has been further discussed in the literature, and is

claimed to be increasing in popularity (Macduff 2005; Smith et al. 2010; Cnaan & Handy 2005; Handy,

Brodeur & Cnaan 2006; Hustinx & Lammertyn 2003; Haski-Leventhal et al. 2008; Bryen & Madden

2006).

Episodic volunteering is seen to occur on a continuum, and includes a broad scope of activities (Bryen

& Madden 2006). Episodic volunteering is not entirely replacing traditional volunteering; however, it

is becoming a more popular form, as people have the ability to select appropriate opportunities that

fit into their lives, and do not require a large time committment (Macduff 2005). This is becoming

increasingly common amongst young people (Smith et al. 2010), and the shift is unsurprising given

the new ways that young people take action in their communities, which includes responding to

needs as they arise, being project oriented, and finding opportunties through their networks rather

than traditional ways such as joining groups or political afiliations (Loader, 2014).

While there is an extensive literature on the motivations of regular volunteers, as well as the benefits

experienced through undertaking the activity, it is unclear whether episodic volunteers have different

motivations to participate. Handy, Brodeur and Cnaan explored this question through a study of

volunteers at summer festival events in Canada, which found three distinct groups of volunteers

(2006). These were:

1) Long-term Committed Volunteers (LTVs) – engaged in long-term, regular, committed

volunteering

2) Habitual Episodic Volunteers (HEVs) – volunteer for multiple episodic opportunities (three or

more) within a year

3) Genuine Episodic Volunteers (GEVs) – volunteer for two for fewer volunteer episodes in a

year

Page 11: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 11

PROPOSAL HEADING

By these definitions, the majority of participants in Big Help Mob missions can be seen as HEVs or

GEVs, depending on their individual

involvement, and those engaged in the

Unternship program (highly-engaged

volunteers undertaking a 6-month

program with the organisation) could be

seen as LTVs. One hypothesis of Handy

and colleagues’ study was that the LTVs

would report being more motivated by

altruistic motives than utilitarian, self-

serving motives than the HEVs, followed

by the GEVs (Handy, Brodeur & Cnaan

2006). However, this was not proven, as

there were no significant differences

between the three groups in terms of

reporting self-serving motives.

Additionally, when altruistic motives were

the dependent variable; any differences

being reported also disappeared (Handy,

Brodeur & Cnaan 2006). This suggests that

episodic volunteers experience similar

motivations as those engaged in more

traditional, committed forms of

volunteering.

Many organisations rely on episodic

volunteers to achieve their aims. Therefore, it is necessary to ensure that episodic volunteers return

to the organisation and continue their involvement for such organisations to be successful. This was

explored in an Australian study of an environmental group by Bryen and Madden (2006). Volunteers

identified a number of factors as important for retention:

• feeling rewarded by the nature of the work

• feeling appreciated for their efforts by the organisation

• ensuring volunteers felt welcomed and valued

However, the two most important reasons in this study were:

• being personally asked to return

Motivation for volunteering

Generally, people volunteer for four main reasons:

• wanting to help/give back or connecting with

a cause – the main reason for all age groups

• maintaining a service a member of the family

is consuming, for example, where a child plays

sport and volunteers are needed to run it

• personal reasons: satisfaction, making friends

or feeling useful – a reason more common in

older people, and

• improving skills for career development

(maintaining/ developing work habits, skills,

contacts/ networks, paid work opportunities)

– a reason increasing for young people

(Bussell & Forbes 2002; Eley 2003; Ellis 2004;

Pope 2005b).

Excerpt from FYA (Foundation for Young Australians)

(2014 forthcoming) Unlimited Potential: a data and

information resource on young Australians.

Foundation for Young Australians: Melbourne.

Page 12: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 12

PROPOSAL HEADING

• the perception that they made a tangible difference to the physical area in which they

worked.

Ultimately, the amount of satisfaction this group of volunteers received in their perceived protection

of the environment appeared to have the greatest influence on ‘bounce-back’ of volunteers (Bryen &

Madden 2006). This then suggests that feelings of making a difference are extremely important in

retaining episodic volunteers, and more research is needed in this area involving other types of

community groups to support these findings.

Developing a civic identity through volunteering

The work of Youniss, McLellan and Yates (1997) explored the development of civic mindedness in

young people by examining the link between civic participation and the development of a civic

identity. They argued that through their involvement in youth programs, young people are exposed

to a broad range of worldviews and communitarian beliefs which assimilate with their own process of

identity construction. In a second study, Youniss and Yates (1997) examine the pathways of young

people who completed a year of service learning as part of school-based social justice studies. They

found that service learning programs deliver three key outcomes; a sense of agency, that one can

make a difference or effect change; social responsibility or having a concern for other individuals or

general societal well-being; and political-moral awareness, which refers to having a capacity to

identify problems within the existing social and political order, and to then question or challenge that

order. For Youniss and Yates, these three outcomes help explain the relationship between

participation in civic activities as a young person and future participation as an adult. The mechanism

for this change was through the exposure to ‘explicit ideological orientations or worldviews’ that

young people gained through involvement in civic organisations (Youniss & Yates 1997, 3).

Youniss and Yates conclude that involvement in civic activities not only structures the shape and form

of a young person’s civic identity but also has a long lasting effect:

By offering youth meaningful participatory experiences, we allow them to discover

their potency, asses their responsibility, acquire a sense of political processes, and

commit to moral-ethical ideology (Youniss and Yates 1997, 5).

This interest in the social, cognitive and civic development of young people who participate in civic

activities is also reflected in research by Waldstein and Reiher (2001) who found that for young

people engaging in both community and service learning activities, their appreciation of these

activities transcended the nature of the activity itself. Rather, it was in the actual participation in the

activities that produced a sense of meaning or achievement.

Page 13: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 13

PROPOSAL HEADING

Furthermore, Larson (1994) contends that these activities perform the dual functions of acting as

vehicles for both social and psychological integration. Participation in some activities provides a

unique opportunity for development of intrinsic motivation and personal agency (Larson 1994, 47).

While his analysis refers to school-related and extracurricular activities such as sports, hobbies and

organisation based activities, the principles can equally be applied to volunteering. It follows that

social integration is encouraged when such activities provide an opportunity for contact with other

participants, which often comes with support, mentoring and role modelling. Specifically,

participation in youth activities encourages/promotes/denotes membership into a:

subcultural enclave which provides a reference group and set of mores that

one carries (or that carries one) through the transition into adulthood

(Larson 1994, 50).

In summary, this literature suggests that participating in voluntary activities as a young person

contributes to the development of a civic identity, which in turn influences future pro-social

behaviour. This civic identity is formed through exposure to new worldviews and beliefs; exposure to

others who encourage and model pro-social behaviours, and provide the individual with a sense of

belonging to a caring and helpful volunteer community; as well as first-hand experience of being able

to make a difference to an issue that they care about. These findings highlight some of the factors

which may contribute to the decision to pursue future civic pursuits (such as more volunteering) after

a Big Help Mob experience.

Page 14: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 14

PROPOSAL HEADING

Methods

This evaluation report draws on four data sources, which were all collected by BHM staff and

volunteers based on surveys and interview guidelines developed by the Foundation for Young

Australians (FYA) research team. The data sources were:

8 semi-structured interviews undertaken with individuals who had participated in missions

with BHM, and one who was yet to undertake a mission

80 survey respondents, made up of 63 people who had previously undertaken a mission with

BHM, and for comparison purposes, 17 people who had registered with BHM but were yet to

undertake a mission

5 interviews with stakeholders working for organisations who have benefited from a BHM

mission

One Most Significant Change (adapted) group session conducted with 8 “Unterns”. These

were a group of highly-engaged volunteers currently undertaking a 6-month program with

the organisation, in which they were responsible for generating new missions and recruiting

new volunteers, all the while building employability skills (such as leadership and

communication skills).

Guided by the project brief, this evaluation focused on two aspects of the volunteer experience:

1. Impacts experienced by individuals that resulted from volunteering with BHM

2. The mechanism that contributed to the impact.

Social impacts were broadly defined in the project scope, with potential impacts including further

volunteering, changes to identity, and increased happiness. However, the evaluation team

considered all benefits and changes reported by respondents as impacts. The interview transcripts

were systematically coded, as well as the open-ended survey response questions, to explore the

range of impacts experienced by BHM volunteers. Where available, we also explored volunteers’

explanations of what caused the change. Data was grouped into themes and explored for patterns.

Survey data was analysed using SPSS v21.

Page 15: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 15

PROPOSAL HEADING

Results

Summary of survey participants

Table 1 summarises the demographic characteristics of survey participants, divided into those who

had joined a BHM mission vs. those who had yet to take part. Respondents were predominantly

female, aged between 18-29, and most likely to be full time students. This respondents matched the

age profile of all those registered with Big Help Mob (45.8% aged 18-29 in the BHM database) but

females were more likely to participate (with males making up 72.2% of the BHM database).

Table 1: Demographic characteristics of survey respondents*, **

Previous BHM

volunteer

(n=63)

Not yet

volunteered BHM

(n=17)

Gender

% male 20.6% 11.8%

% female 66.7% 82.4%

Age

% aged <18 7.9% 17.6%

% aged 18-29 71.4% 47.1%

% aged >=30 7.9% 29.4%

Employment status

% full time student (with any employment) 36.5% 64.7%

% employed (full time) 23.8% 23.5%

% employed (part time or casual) 25.4% 0.0%

% unemployed 1.6% 5.9%

Page 16: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 16

PROPOSAL HEADING

Table 2 shows the volunteering backgrounds of participants from each group. Of those who had

volunteered with BHM, most had undertaken at least two missions, and at least half had been on a

mission within the previous three months (the survey did not allow us to break down the number of

missions completed beyond this distinction).

The frequency of previous volunteering efforts was explored for each group. Survey respondents in

both groups were, in general, highly engaged volunteers. Both groups had high levels of volunteering,

with just over three quarters of BHM volunteers having volunteered elsewhere before their BHM

mission, compared to approximately 9 out of 10 of those not yet joining a mission. When asked about

their volunteer activities during the last 12 months, the most common response for both groups

indicated a sporadic, ad hoc volunteering style (multiple organisations, with a less frequent

commitment).

Table 2: Volunteering backgrounds of survey respondents*, **

Previous BHM

volunteer

(n=63)

Not yet

volunteered

BHM

(n=17)

Volunteering with BHM

Yet to complete a mission - 100%

1 missions 28.6% -

2 or more missions 61.9% -

When was last BHM mission?

<3 months ago 50.8% -

3-6 months ago 22.2%

-

6-12 months ago 7.9% -

>12 months ago 11.1% -

Volunteered previously (before BHM)?

Page 17: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 17

PROPOSAL HEADING

Yes, has volunteered elsewhere 77.8% 88.2%

Has not volunteered elsewhere 22.2% 11.8%

How many organisations (last 12 months)?

None 6.3% 17.6%

One 20.6% 23.5%

Two 31.7% 23.5%

Three or more 41.3% 35.3%

How often do you volunteer (last 12 months)

Once per week 20.6% 23.5%

Once per fortnight 25.4% 17.6%

Less often than once per month 50.8% 41.2%

Never 3.2% 17.6%

Hours spent volunteering in previous 4 weeks

< One hour 27.0% 58.8%

1-5 hours 31.7% 17.6%

6+ hours 41.3% 23.5%

*Note: a high proportion of categories have <5 respondents in any given category (insufficient cell size), so statistics were not able to be computed for demographics or volunteering history. ** numbers will not add up to 100% for each category, as missing responses were not removed from analysis (up to 10% for any given question

Page 18: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 18

PROPOSAL HEADING

Changes experienced by Big Help Mob volunteers

Survey respondents were asked about changes that occurred in their life since volunteering with

BHM “What important actions or decisions have you taken/made since participating in BHM?”, and in

a follow up question, whether they attributed the changes to their BHM experience. In a later

question, they were asked “In what way (if any) has your experience with BHM caused you to think or

feel differently about yourself or your world views?” Given the considerable cross-over in the

responses given, responses for these questions were considered together.

Overall, the large majority of BHM volunteers participating in this evaluation experienced some

kind of positive change that they directly attributed to their BHM volunteering experience. A large

proportion reported new activities or directions since they began volunteering with BHM, such as

changing job, going back to study, or more volunteering (51 survey respondents, or 81%), and three

quarters of those experiencing changes (38 survey respondents) attributed some or all of those

changes to their BHM experience.

When asked specifically about any changes to the way volunteers saw themselves or the world

around them, a total of 39 respondents described changes (62% of BHM survey respondents).

Responses from interviews and group discussion participants followed similar patterns: of the 16

participants who had undertaken missions, 13 spoke of changes that had occurred subsequently.

When responses were considered together, a total of 61 BHM volunteers (76%) reported at least

one positive impact occurring for them as a result of their volunteer experience.

The positive impacts experienced are presented in order of those most commonly reported

(volunteers could nominate more than one area of change). Proportions presented here are for

survey respondents only, however quotes from interview participants are included where they help

provide context. Only quotes from those attributing their reported changes to their engagement with

BHM have been presented.

More volunteering

For many, joining a BHM mission ignited a stronger interest in and commitment to volunteering. Just

over half (n=32) of all surveyed BHM volunteers had increased their volunteering since their first

BHM experience, or were considering how to do so, with a sizeable majority (80%) of volunteers

attributing this change to the BHM experience. New volunteering opportunities ranged from doing

more BHM missions, signing up for regular volunteering with organisations they first met through

BHM, through to branching out and taking committed volunteer roles with external organisations.

I make more effort to be more involved in volunteering with BHM or with other

organizations (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 19: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 19

PROPOSAL HEADING

To volunteer for Save the Children on one of their local programmes (BHM

volunteer, survey)

Since first volunteering with BHM (over a year ago now), I signed up to volunteer

regularly with two volunteering organisations. (BHM volunteer, survey)

For one survey respondent, volunteering became a full-time commitment when he left a paid

position to take up a voluntary position in a not-for profit agency.

Left full-time paid employment to pursue a full-time volunteer role with an

incredible organisation in a different city to the one I was currently living. I cannot

ascribe all of this decision to BHM, but I am sure it was an influence. (Or perhaps

more accurately Useful was an influence). (BHM volunteer, survey)

Gaining new ideas and perspectives

Seventeen volunteers described developing new ideas and perspectives through volunteering with

BHM. New ideas included different ways they could combine work and volunteering, new attitudes

to consumption, new views on issues and not-for profit organisations, and changed attitudes to

others. All but two believed BHM helped them develop these new ideas (with the remainder unsure).

It has been a positive reinforcement of my world outlook. I have been more aware

of making more sustainable choices and choices in regards to how I spent some of

my spare time. I try to be more open minded about people in general after getting

to meet a range of volunteers and not for profit staff (BHM volunteer, survey)

I've become more aware of my impact of society (BHM volunteer, survey)

Learnt that kids with autism aren’t so scary after all (BHM volunteer, survey)

I am more optimistic about the future of humanity (BHM volunteer, survey)

Change of job

Nine respondents reported changing their work since they commenced volunteering with BHM, with

six attributing the change to their experience. Volunteers commonly moved to jobs that more closely

aligned with their passions and often with reduced hours, allowing time for them to engage with

other meaningful activities

Thinking more deeply about the work I do and the impact I have - has driven me to

change jobs (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 20: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 20

PROPOSAL HEADING

Applied for a job with less hours and closer to my personal passions (BHM

volunteer, survey)

Additionally, one of the interviewees spoke about his decision to cut back to part-time work, leaving

them more time to volunteer amongst other activities.

I’ve quit my full-time job and started doing stuff- doing part-time instead which I

guess is partially related to the volunteering experiences, because I figured I want

a bit more time to be able to do other things and potentially do some more

volunteering stuff (BHM volunteer, interview)

New areas of study

Seven respondents had engaged in new study (either starting a new course, or choosing particular

subjects), with five of the seven reporting that volunteering with BHM influenced their decision.

Started a diploma in child care…I found out I love volunteering and helping people

(BHM volunteer, survey)

I have decided to study occupational therapy…BHM made me realise that I wanted

to help people for the rest of my life (BHM volunteer, survey)

Changes to the way they see themselves and the world

Changes to the way BHM volunteers see themselves and the world around them fell into five main

themes: realising volunteering is possible within the context of their lives; feeling inspired for further

action; changes to identity and sense of self; empowerment; and improved wellbeing.

Volunteering is possible for me

Eight survey respondents described how the BHM experience had shifted their views on volunteering

itself- that the activity was more accessible, required less commitment, and there was a wider range

of ways to help than previously thought. Commonly, volunteers noted that BHM caused them to

rethink the time and effort required to make a positive impact.

My perspective on life in general and work-life balance has really been shaped by

the idea of being able to 'do good' in small ways. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Yes it made me realise volunteering is accessible and doesn't require a big

commitment. (BHM volunteer, survey)

It is a lot easier to volunteer than one might think especially with short term

opportunities. And there are various ways to do so which I was less aware of prior

to BHM. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 21: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 21

PROPOSAL HEADING

Changes to identity/ sense of self

Seven respondents reported changing their sense of self or identity, with all but one attributing their change to their BHM experience. Seven volunteers additionally mentioned that they had experienced personal development since undertaking their first mission.

I became more confident and tried new things, I put myself out there more and

just became a better person (BHM volunteer, survey)

Less cynical/fearful/resigned about 'the world' and my role/potential. (BHM

volunteer, survey)

I feel more confident within myself and think about the bigger picture a lot more

(BHM volunteer, survey)

Two survey respondents described how they left unhappy relationships after a period of reflection,

which for both was attributed to meeting like-minded people who encouraged them to reflect on

their lives and the impact they wanted to have.

Breaking a long term relationship because of seeking more in a partner - who

considers their actions and the impact in the world in a deeper way

Additionally, two of the interviewees spoke about how the experience of volunteering positively impacted on their communication skills, empathy and ability to confidently express themselves.

I used to be really worried to talk to kids in front of adults in case the adults, (as in)

you’re doing it wrong or you’re being patronising or overprotective, but then from

doing that I’ve grown more confident to talk to kids around other people…. I feel

like I’ve learnt…to put myself in other peoples’ shoes more than I did before I went

there [to the mission]. (BHM volunteer, 2 missions, interview)

I feel more at ease to express opinions, share ideas and tell others what I think. So

the main change is more open to people’s views and ideas and a new way of doing

business. (BHM volunteer, Untern group discussion)

Feeling empowered

Twelve volunteers spoke of having a greater sense of their own capacity to make a difference after

volunteering with BHM. They reported feeling more useful, more accomplished, and had a greater

sense that their contribution was important.

I feel more accomplished (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 22: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 22

PROPOSAL HEADING

That you can be of use in different fields, regardless of your educational

background or experience (BHM volunteer, survey)

I feel that by getting involved in the community, I am able to make a true

difference (BHM volunteer, survey)

Improved wellbeing

Eight volunteers described how volunteering had increased their wellbeing, improved their mood and

made them feel better about themselves. Two described a substantial improvement in their mental

health following their engagement with BHM.

I'm a nicer person, less judgmental, less angry, less depressed, and more confident

(BHM volunteer, survey)

A significant way. On a slightly serious note, I've struggled with mental health due

to feeling different to the world, like I was alone. BHM has helped reduce my

thoughts of suicide by making me feel part of a group who wants to better the

world (BHM volunteer, survey)

I feel better about myself because I have been volunteering more and this makes

me feel more selfless and helpful (BHM volunteer, survey)

Feeling inspired

Eight volunteers described how they felt inspired by their volunteering experience.

Since planting trees with BHM I realise there’s a world outside of me that needs

help (BHM volunteer, survey)

I met people from France, Germany and other exotic places in the few times I've

volunteered with BMH and what I learn is that people come from anywhere, and

we could come together just to clean up the beach or plant trees ...No matter

where you are from, people want to do something about the society we live in,

even if they don't live here long term (BHM volunteer, survey)

New networks

One of the strongest messages from BHM volunteers was the importance of the new networks of

passionate, like-minded people they met through missions. Many were inspired by the examples set

by other volunteers, both in terms of helping others, and the way they live their everyday lives:

Page 23: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 23

PROPOSAL HEADING

Volunteering with BHM made me feel better about people and more motivated to

help others when I saw other people being so enthusiastic and passionate (BHM

volunteer, survey)

Getting to meet other people who think deeply about the impact of their daily

actions is inspiring and makes me reflect on my own decisions. (BHM volunteer,

survey)

Being involved in core team means being influenced by a range of incredibly

diverse and intelligent individuals who challenge me to think more deeply about

the choices I make and the impact it can have.

Volunteering alongside others also allowed people to challenge their perceptions of others, or

reinforce their good opinions of those around them.

It has opened me up to many more opportunities and opinions and people which

has allowed me to be more accepting and understanding of different people.

(BHM volunteer, survey)

I think the positive experience has perhaps just reinforced my views that people

can be nice and doing good things is enjoyable.

Meeting other volunteers helped some respondents feel more a part of the community.

As an international student, I feel out of place in Perth, but BHM has given me the

opportunity to integrate myself more and make me feel comfortable being in a

foreign country on my own. In a way, I now feel less insecure about myself and

what differences I might have compared to others. (BHM volunteer, survey)

For highly engaged BHM volunteers, who had taken on roles in the in the core groups or joined the

Unternship program, the support network they were able to access through their work appeared to

be the strongest influence any subsequent changes.

Lots of things have changed since I started here and I think they were related. I

went back to uni, I got a job in a not-for-profit, I made a tonne of new friends and

that kind of thing but one of the things that I think this did more than anything

else was like give me a support network which allowed me to feel comfortable to

actually try things that I might not have done before. (BHM volunteer, Untern

group)

Page 24: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 24

PROPOSAL HEADING

Who does not experience positive impacts from Big Help Mob

Volunteering?

Nearly one in four (22%) survey respondents did not experience any personal changes or shifts in

their attitudes, or reported changes that they did not attribute to their experience with BHM. The

evaluation team ran analysis to explore whether any volunteer characteristics were associated with

experiencing changes. Only one attribute was found to be associated with experiencing changes: that

the most recent BHM mission was within the previous 12 months (p<0.05). Other characteristics of

volunteers, such as being satisfied with most recent BHM experience, having undertaken more than

one BHM mission, having regular volunteering patterns in the last 12 months, having volunteered

elsewhere prior to BHM, reporting meaningful volunteer experience in the past, being female, or

belonging to any particular age group, were not associated with experiencing changes. However, it is

worth noting that the numbers are small, meaning statistics cannot be reliably calculated for all

comparisons.

A small number of volunteers went on to describe why they did not attribute the changes in their

lives to their BHM experience. Commonly, respondents said major life decisions would have

happened regardless of their volunteering experience. However, a small group of BHM volunteers

noted that BHM was just one of a range of volunteering activities they were engaged in, and their

other activities were likely to have a larger influence on them.

These opportunities did not come out of BHM. Unfortunately, I need reminders to

even go onto BHM because I am so busy with other volunteer events! (BHM

volunteer, survey)

I have done a lot of volunteering before, so it is not a new experience for me.

However, it is really affirming to see lots of people out and about just helping out

others. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 25: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 25

PROPOSAL HEADING

What is it about Big Help Mob volunteering that creates change?

The BHM model allows potential volunteers to become engaged in a range of ways:

1) joining missions, which enables a sporadic approach to helping, as the volunteer can join

missions when they have time and interest without ongoing commitment;

2) taking on more responsibility by organising missions within a core team (still without an

ongoing commitment); and,

3) in a highly engaged way, through the formal Unternship program.

It is worth noting that volunteers at all levels of engagement reported positive and substantial

impacts from volunteering with the program.

Respondents who reported that changes had taken place in their lives were asked to reflect on what

it was about the experience that led to the decision to make changes. This section outlines the ways

in which BHM volunteering experience impacted on participants.

A facilitated, easy and convenient volunteer experience

By far, the most common response (20 survey respondents) was that the BHM approach to

volunteering worked extremely well for the volunteers. BHM provided a way for individuals to help

others in a way that did not require an ongoing commitment, and could easily fit around their other

activities.

Enjoying the volunteer experience, particularly the BHM version which doesn't

require set, ongoing commitments has made me want to do more. (BHM

volunteer, survey)

Before volunteering with BHM, I was a bit hesitant about what volunteering would

be like, but volunteering for just a one-day mission (where there's no ongoing

obligation and the people are friendly) helped me overcome that. (BHM volunteer,

survey)

I want to be able to be volunteer my time in some way and I find it’s a really good

way to be able to do that but it’s flexible, which I find’s really important. (BHM

volunteer, 4 missions, interview)

Joining a mission was a very low barrier activity, with participants noting that the sign up process was

straight forward and required no pre-existing skills or experience.

Page 26: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 26

PROPOSAL HEADING

Knowing how one can help the community, without the need of specific skills (or

training). (BHM volunteer, survey)

BHM introduced me to things I could do, (whereas previously I had made

assumptions about what might be required). (BHM volunteer, survey)

Volunteer opportunities were facilitated, meaning people could access opportunities that they

otherwise would not have sought or felt comfortable engaging in.

BHM gives me the chance to volunteer in places I would have never gone to due to

safety, time or distance reasons. I know that I could participate safely and it gives

me more confidence to step out of my comfort zone.

Missions presented a fun, warm and encouraging environment in which to help others.

After being welcomed into a volunteering position so warmly by BHM, I feel more

motivated and more confident to take on more volunteering positions. (BHM

volunteer, survey)

It made me realise that there are opportunities out there for young people that

are like, fun and stuff but you know, also meaningful which was really cool. (BHM

volunteer, Untern group discussion)

Experience of new activities and exposure to new populations

Volunteering with BHM exposed young people to new tasks, new community organisations, and new

population groups within the community.

Volunteering provides me with that hands on experience and allows me to

interface with people when I work, which reminds me how much I enjoy that kind

of work. (BHM volunteer, survey)

I used to just do simple volunteering such as ushering at a production or helping

supervise and teach little kids. Since the mission I attended helping the elderly and

disabled with their gardens, I have tried to help people who benefit more from my

help such as giving a performance at an elderly care home and helping children at

a school for the autistic. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Awareness of [international NGO] through BHM, (and the) realisation that I wasn’t

happy in my old job based on the experiences I had through volunteering with

BHM. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Page 27: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 27

PROPOSAL HEADING

An Untern in the group discussions highlighted how her decision to enrol in a new course the

following year was influenced by her exposure to working directly with young people.

I’d always liked the idea of maybe becoming a teacher, but I was a bit of a fence

sitter, I wasn’t entirely sure if that was something I wanted to do…I want to be

helping these kids to grow and find something they really enjoy…so that’s where I

sort of got that idea from, so that was sort of how that mission changed me….I am

going to do a Diploma of Education next year, and continue to try and work with

youth. (BHM volunteer, Untern group)

Exposure to other volunteers

As described previously, other volunteers proved to be an exceptionally strong influence on BHM

volunteers. For some, particularly those who became highly engaged in the BHM organisation (as

Unterns or members of core teams), the BHM volunteer network provided a strong sense of

belonging, and the opinions and examples given by other group members proved highly influential on

volunteers’ worldviews and subsequent life decisions.

Getting to meet other people who think deeply about the impact of their daily

actions is inspiring and makes me reflect on my own decisions. (BHM volunteer,

survey)

Being involved in core team means being influenced by a range of incredibly

diverse and intelligent individuals who challenge me to think more deeply about

the choices I make and the impact it can have.

Experiencing the benefits of volunteering

Some volunteers noted that experiencing the benefits of volunteering was what contributed to

changes in their lives.

Doing a mission reminded me of some of the benefits of volunteering (particularly

with BHM!) and I guess made me keener to find a way to have more time available

to volunteer or even just work on things that I am passionate about. (BHM

volunteer, survey)

The benefits experienced by volunteers was measured in a survey questions: “What benefits do you

feel you get from volunteering?”, with all respondents asked to describe benefits gained from any

volunteering (not only their contributions through BHM). Responses outlining a broad range of

individual benefits were common, such as:

Page 28: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 28

PROPOSAL HEADING

I feel that I belong to the volunteering community and am part of something

bigger than just a group or a club. I get opportunities to engage with really

passionate people in their fields of interest. I am also able to do work that I see the

tangible benefits of. (BHM volunteer, survey)

Personally, I feel happy to simply know I've made a difference. It's always good to

know that you are helping others. You also, usually, get to be with like-minded

people, and so you can make friends that you can set up more voluntary work at

later times (Yet to volunteer with BHM, survey)

Figure 1 shows a word cloud of responses to this question, with the size of the word indicating the

frequency of response.

Figure 1: What benefits do volunteers experience?

The responses are summarised here. While there is considerable overlap with the changes resulting

from BHM volunteering, the benefits described do not directly corresponded with the changes and

impacts described previously. The evaluation team explored differences between the benefits

reported by BHM volunteers and those who had yet to undertake a mission, as well as differences

between volunteers with a regular commitment to those with a more sporadic recent volunteering

Page 29: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 29

PROPOSAL HEADING

pattern, however in both analysis, there was no differences between groups. Summaries of the

proportion of all survey respondents reporting different benefits are presented here:

Feeling helpful and useful (39 respondents, 49%)

Feeling good about themselves (39 respondents, 49%)

Meeting new people (32 respondents, 40%)

Building and contributing to the community, a sense of belonging (24 respondents, 30%)

Learning new skills (14 respondents, 18%)

New activities (13 respondents, 16%)

A sense of purpose (11 respondents, 14%)

Gaining new ideas and perspectives (9 respondents, 11%)

A summary of the inputs of BHM volunteering – that is, what BHM provides to individuals through

the volunteer experience- and the outcomes experienced by volunteers, is presented in Figure 2.

Figure 2: A summary of the impact of volunteering with Big Help Mob on individual volunteers

What volunteering

with BHM provides Intermediate change Impact

Page 30: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 30

PROPOSAL HEADING

Summary and Discussion

This evaluation has found that those who volunteer with Big Help Mob experience a number of

personal benefits. They described feeling good about themselves, feeling useful, meeting new

people, feeling a part of their community, getting exposure to new activities and learning new skills,

and developing new perspectives and ideas as a result of their volunteering.

The focus of this evaluation was the question “Does the experience of Big Help Mob lead to further

action and if so, what components of Big Help Mob are most influential and why?”

This report has shown that the experience of volunteering with Big Help Mob has a highly beneficial

impact for the majority of volunteers, with many reporting positive life changes and increased pro-

social attitudes following on from their volunteer experience.

Some of the changes experienced include: engaging in more volunteering, both with BHM and with

other organisations; gaining new ideas and perspectives, especially around the impact their choices

and actions can make; building new networks and feeling part of a community; changing their job to

something more aligned with their interests, or cutting back work commitments to free up time for

other passions; starting new courses or taking on subjects to take them in a new direction; feeling

inspired and empowered; improving wellbeing; and developing personal skills to be better

communicators and feel more confident.

There are a number of components of the Big Help Mob experience that seem particularly important

for creating these changes. First, BHM provides opportunities that are highly accessible, meaningful

volunteer roles that overcomes many traditional barriers to volunteering for young people, such as

lack of time for a regular commitment or knowledge around finding suitable opportunities. BHM’s

activities do not depend on having a particular skill set, or knowing people who already volunteer.

This allows individuals to help out when they have time, and when a cause resonates with them,

without having to seek the opportunity themselves or make long-term commitments they may not be

able to fulfil. In this way, BHM shifts perceptions of volunteering, as it demonstrates that helping the

community can be easily fit into young people’s lives.

Perhaps most importantly, BHM provides exposure to a network of like-minded, enthusiastic young

volunteers. This supportive community provides a sense of belonging for new volunteers, and sets a

strong example, both in their life choices and in their volunteering behaviour, which inspires new

ideas and encourages further volunteering.

Finally, BHM volunteering activities provide exposure to new populations (such working directly with

children), activities and community organisations, which provides volunteers with new experiences

and chances to interact with groups in the community they might previously never had direct contact

Page 31: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 31

PROPOSAL HEADING

with. This exposure appears to inspire volunteers to consider new direction for work, study and

further volunteering opportunities.

Given the short-duration of exposure to volunteer activities, the wide-ranging and, in some cases,

substantial impacts described in this evaluation are noteworthy, as they have previously been found

in research on regular volunteering. For example, many BHM volunteers report feeling empowered,

which was also found by Cohen (2010), and volunteers were more likely to take up more

volunteering after their initial contact with the organisation, in line with Bowman’s findings of

university-aged volunteers (2010). The reported changes to volunteer’s sense of self was in line the

literature on the development of civic identity (for example, Youniss and Yates, 1997). A number of

young people report a greater sense of wellbeing and improved mental health, which has also been

widely found in the literature (Jenkinsen et al. 2013).

The design of this evaluation does not allow us to attribute all of the reported changes to

volunteering with BHM, to determine direct causality between Big Help Mob’s activities and

subsequent impacts, or to fully understand the mechanism for any change. This evaluation does,

however, indicate that episodic volunteers engaged with Big Help Mob can also experience the wide-

ranging benefits associated with more regular, sustained volunteering commitments, and that the

organisation creates a substantial social impact for those who voluntarily contribute to its missions.

Page 32: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 32

PROPOSAL HEADING

References

ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) (2006) Census of Population and Housing, 2006. Commonwealth

of Australia: Canberra.

ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) (2011) Census of Population and Housing, 2011. Commonwealth

of Australia: Canberra.

Alperstein G & Raman S (2003) Promoting Mental Health and Emotional Wellbeing Among Children

and Youth: A Role for Community Child Health?. Child: Care, Health and Development. 29(4): 269-274.

Australian Council for International Development (2012) Youth Engagement in the Australian Aid and

Development Sector Discussion Paper. ACFID: Canberra.

ARACY (2008) Report card on the wellbeing of young Australians: Technical report, Canberra:

Australian Research Alliance for Children and Youth.

Arvanitakis J & Marren S (2009) Putting the politics back into politics: Young people and democracy in

Australia, Discussion paper. Sydney: The Whitlam Institute.

Arvanitakis J & Sidoti E (2011) ‘The politics of change: where to for young people and politics’ in L

Walsh & R Black (eds.), In Their Own Hands: Can young people change Australia? Melbourne: ACER

Press, 11-20.

Baum F, Modra C, Bush R, Cox E, Cook R & Potter R (1999) Volunteering and social capital: an

Adelaide study. Australian Journal of Volunteering. February: 13-22.

Berkman LF & Glass TG (2000) Social interaction, social networks, social support, and health. In

Berkman LF & Kawachi I (eds) Social Epidemiology. Oxford University Press: Oxford.

Boessler J & Ding B (2010) Gen Y and flexible volunteering, National Emergency Response.

Bowman N, Brandenberger J, Lapsley D, Hill P & Quaranto J (2010) Serving in College, Flourishing

in Adulthood: Does Community Engagement During the College Years Predict Adult Well-Being?.

Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being. 2(1): 14-34.

Bussell H & Forbes D (2002) Understanding the Volunteer Market: The What, Where, Who and Why

of Volunteering. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing. 7(3): 244-257.

Page 33: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 33

PROPOSAL HEADING

Bryen L & Madden K (2006) Bounce-Back of Episodic Volunteers: What makes episodic volunteers

return? CPNS Working Paper No. 32. Brisbane: The Centre of Philanthropy and Nonprofit Studies.

Campbell DE (2006) What is education’s impact on civic and social engagement? Paris: OECD. Chapple K (2002) “I

Chapple K (2002) “I Name it and Claim it – in the Name of Jesus, This Job is Mine”: Job Search,

Networks, and Careers for Low Income Women. Economic Development Quarterly. 16(4): 294-313.

Cnaan, R & Handy, F (2005) Towards understanding episodic volunteering. Vrijwillige Inzet

Onderzocht. 2(1): 29–35.

Cohen A (2009) Welfare Clients' Volunteering as a Means of Empowerment. Nonprofit and Voluntary

Sector Quarterly. 38(3): 522-534.

Crick B (1998) Education for citizenship and the teaching of democracy in schools: Final report of the

advisory group on citizenship and the teaching of democracy in schools, London: Qualifications and

Curriculum Authority.

Davis Smith J (2000) Volunteering and Social Development. Voluntary Action. 3(1): 9-23.

Egan M, Tannahill C, Petticrew M & Thomas S (2008) Psychosocial risk factors in home and

community settings and their associations with population health and health inequalities: a

systematic review. BCM Public Health. 8: 239-251.

Eley D (2003) Perceptions of and reflections on volunteering: the impact of community service on

citizenship in students. Voluntary Action 5(3): 27-45.

Ellis A (2004) Research Bulletin: Generation V: Young people speak out on volunteering, Institute for

Volunteering Research, London.

Ferrier F, Roos I & Long M (2004) Passions, people and appreciation: Making volunteering work for

young people, Canberra: National Youth Affairs Research Scheme.

Finneran L & Kelly M (2003) Social networks and inequality. Journal of Urban Economics. 53(2): 282-

299.

Page 34: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 34

PROPOSAL HEADING

Giles LC, Glonek GFV, Luszcz MA & Andrews GR (2005) Effects of social networks on ten year survival

in very old Australians: the Australian longitudinal study of aging. Journal of Epidemiology and

Community Health. 59(7): 574-579.

Granovetter M (1983) The strength of weak ties: a network theory revisited. Sociological Theory. 1:

201-233.

Handy F, Brodeur N & Cnaan, RA (2006) Summer on the Island: Episodic volunteering in Victoria,

British Columbia. Voluntary Action 7(2), 31-46.

Harris A, Wyn J & Younes S (2010) Beyond apathetic or activist youth: ‘Ordinary’ young people and

contemporary forms of participation, Young, 18(1): 9-32

Harrison PA & Narayan G (2002) Benefits Associated with Participation in School Sports and other

Extracurricular Activities in Adolescence. Minneapolis Department of Health and Family Support

Research Division: Minneapolis.

Haski-Leventhal D, Meijs L & Hustinx L (2010) The Third-party Model: Enhancing Volunteering

through Governments, Corporations and Educational Institutes. Journal of Social Policy. 39(1):139-

158.

Horsley M and Costley D (2008) Young people imagining a new democracy: Young people’s voices.

Focus Groups Report, Sydney: Whitlam Institute.

Hustinx L & Lammertyn F (2003) Collective and reflexive styles of volunteering: A sociological

modernization perspective. Voluntas 14(2):167-187.

Ioannides YM & Loury LD (2004) Job Information Networks, Neighbourhood Effects and Inequality.

Journal of Economic Literature. 42(4): 1056-1093.

Ironmonger D & Soupourmas F (2002) Calculating Australia’s Gross Household Product: Measuring

the Economic Value of the Household Economy 1970-2000. Research Paper Number 833. Department

of Economics: The University of Melbourne.

Jenkinsen CE, Dickens AP, Jones K, Thompson-Coon J, Taylor RS, Rogers M, Bambra CL, Lang I &

Richards SH (2013) Is volunteering a public health intervention? A systematic review and meta-

analysis of the health and survival of volunteers. BMC Public Health. 13: 773-783.

Page 35: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 35

PROPOSAL HEADING

Johnston F, Gogan K & Savelsberg H (2004) Young People & Volunteering. The Office for Volunteers.

University of South Australia: Adelaide.

Larson R (1994) ‘Youth organizations, hobbies, and sports as developmental contexts’

in RK Silbereisen & E Todt (eds.) Adolescence in context: The interplay of family, school, peers, and

work in adjustment, NY: Springer-Verlag, 46-65.

Loader BD, Vromen A & Xenos MA (2014) The networked young citizen: social media, political

participation and civic engagement, Information, Communication & Society. 17(2): 143-150.

Macduff N (2005). ‘Societal changes and the rise of the episodic volunteer’ in JL Brudney (ed.),

Emerging areas of volunteering: ARNOVA Occasional Paper Series, 1(2): 49-61.

Manning B & Ryan R (2004) Youth and citizenship: A report for NYARS, Canberra: National Youth

Affairs Research Scheme.

Markus A (2011) Mapping social cohesion: The Scanlon Foundation Surveys, Summary Report,

Caulfield: Monash University.

Mellor S, Kennedy KJ & Greenwood L (2001) Citizenship and democracy: Australian students’

knowledge and beliefs, The IEA Civic Education Study of Fourteen Year Olds. Canberra:

Commonwealth of Australia.

Menchik PL & Weisbrod BA (1987) Volunteer Labour Supply. Journal of Public Economics. 32(2): 159-

183.

Mission Australia (2011) National survey of young Australians 2011: key and emerging issues, Sydney:

Mission Australia.

Muir K, Mullan K, Powell A, Flaxman S, Thompson D & Griffiths M (2009) State of Australia's young

people: A report on the social, economic, health and family lives of young people, Canberra: Australian

Government.

Mundle C, Naylor C & Buck D (2012) Volunteering in health and care in England: a summary of key

literature. The King’s Fund, London.

Oaktree Foundation (2012) Oaktree Foundation: volunteer experience. SROI Findings Presentation. 6

June 2013.

Page 36: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 36

PROPOSAL HEADING

Pope J (2005a) Volunteering in Victoria over 2004. Australian Journal on Volunteering. 10(2): 29-34.

Pope J (2005b) Indicators of Community Strength in Victoria. Department for Victorian Communities:

Melbourne.

Pope J (2011) Indicators of Community Strength: framework and evidence. Department of Planning

and Community Development: Melbourne.

Sacerdote B & Mararmos D (2006) How do friendships form?. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.

121(1): 79- 119.

Schulz W, Ainley J, Fraillon, J, Kerr, D & Losito B (2010) ICCS 2009 International Report: Civic

knowledge, attitudes, and engagement among lower secondary school students in 38 countries,

Amsterdam: International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement

Smith KA, Holmes K, Haski-Leventhal D, Cnaan R, Handy F, & Brudney JL (2010) Motivations and

Benefits of Student Volunteering: Comparing Regular, Occasional, and Non-Volunteers in Five

Countries. Canadian Journal of Nonprofit and Social Economy Research. 1(1):65-81.

Torney-Purta J, Lehmann R, Oswald H & Schulz W (2001) Citizenship and education in twenty-eight

countries: Knowledge and engagement at age fourteen, Amsterdam: International Association for the

Evaluation of Educational Achievement.

United Nations Volunteers (2011) Youth Volunteering, social integration and decent work: inspiring

leadership discussion paper prepared for the 48th session of the commission for social development.

Volunteering Australia (2011) 2011 National Survey on Volunteering. Volunteering Australia:

Melbourne.

Vromen A & Collin P (2010) Everyday youth participation? Contrasting views from Australian

policymakers and young people, Young, 18(1): 97-112.

Waldstein FA & Reiher TC (2001) Service-learning and students' personal and civic development, The

Journal of Experiential Education, 24(1):7-13.

Walsh L & Black R (2011) In their own hands: Can young people change Australia? Melbourne: ACER

Press.

Page 37: BHM Social Impact Report - incorporating BHM 2nd review

Commercial in confidence © Foundation for Young Australians 2014 37

PROPOSAL HEADING

Wikeley F, Bullock K, Muschamp Y & Ridge T (2009) Educational Relationships and their Impact on

Poverty. International Journal of Inclusive Education. 13(4): 377-393.

Young FW & Glasgow N (1998) Voluntary social participation and health. Research on Aging. 20(3):

339-362.

Youniss J, McLellan JA & Yates M (1997) What we know about engendering civic identity American

Behavioral Scientist, 40(5): 620-632.

Youniss J & Yates M (1997) Community service and social responsibility in youth, Chicago: The

University of Chicago Press.