BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare...

118
tenihan LLB. MusB & PUBLIC LAW BARRISTER 17 May2078 17 i', -. 2018 Envitonment Southland PB 90116 INVERCARGITT Attn: Rob Phillips Deat Rob, SOUTHI.AIYD REGIONAL COI,]NCIL PROPOSED WATER AI{D I-AI\D PLI\N: APPEALS Please find enclosed appeds on the above proposed plan ftom: 1. Stoney Cteek Sation Ltd 2. The Tettaces Ltd 3. Campbelfs Blockltd. and 4. Robert Gtant If you have any furthet quedes in dation this matter, please contact Clare Lenihan on (03) 2747674, [email protected], or Ieff Wdker on (03) 2140777. [email protected]. "ffwW Clare Lenihan Barister www.onvltonmcote I lrrryi:.co nz lO2 Jed Strcet, lnvercarglll 98lO P 03 214 1574 *t O27 577 5823 u [email protected]

Transcript of BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare...

Page 1: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

tenihan LLB. MusB

& PUBLIC LAW BARRISTER

17 May2078 17 i', -. 2018

Envitonment SouthlandPB 90116INVERCARGITT

Attn: Rob Phillips

Deat Rob,

SOUTHI.AIYD REGIONAL COI,]NCIL PROPOSED WATER AI{D I-AI\D PLI\N:APPEALS

Please find enclosed appeds on the above proposed plan ftom:

1. Stoney Cteek Sation Ltd2. The Tettaces Ltd3. Campbelfs Blockltd. and4. Robert Gtant

If you have any furthet quedes in dation this matter, please contact Clare Lenihan on (03)2747674, [email protected], or Ieff Wdker on (03) 2140777.

[email protected].

"ffwWClare LenihanBarister

www.onvltonmcote I lrrryi:.co nz

lO2 Jed Strcet, lnvercarglll 98lO P 03 214 1574 *t O27 577 5823 u [email protected]

Page 2: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

iill]lil

Li

i

i1I

tl

tl

j

l

1llr

liIil

rl

BEFORE TIIE EI\IVIROI\MENT COI]RT1 7 MAY 2018

IN TIIE MATTER Of,'the Resource Management Act 1991

IN THE MATTER OF of an Appeal pursuant to Clause 14 of the First

Schedule to the Act

BETWEEN CAMPBELL'S BLOCK LTD

Appellant

AI\D SOUTHLAI\ID REGIONAL COT]NCIL

Respondent

NOTICE OF APPEAL TO EI\IVIROI\MENT COURT AGAINST DECISION ON

PROPOSED PLAI\I ON BEHALI' OX' TIm APPELLAi\IT Dfie 17 May 2018

Instructing Counsel for Appellant:JeffWalker, Walker Murdoch Law LimitedPO Box 1188Invercargill 9840Tel:03 2140777

[email protected]

Counsel for Appellant:Clare LenihanBarrister102 Jed StreetInvercargill 9810Tel: (03) 2141674clare. lenihan@environmentallawyer. co. nz

15

Page 3: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I

Notice of appeal to Environment Court against decision on proposed plan

Clause I4(1) of Schedule l, Resource Management Act l99l

To the RegistrarEnvironment CourtChristchurchAtt: Christine McKeeEmail: [email protected]

Campbell's Block Limited (the Appellant) appeals against parts of a decision of the

Southland Regional Council on the Proposed Southland Water and Land Plan

(pSwLP).

2. The Appellant made a submission on the pSWLP.

The Appellant is not a trade competitor for the purposes of section 308D of the

Resource Management Act 1991.

4. The Appellant received notice of the decision on 4 April 2018.

The decision was made by the Southland Regional Council. The references below are

to the decisions version of the pSWLP,4 April 2018.

The parts of the decision the Appellant is appealing, the reasons for the appeal and the

relief sought are set out under relevant topic headings below.

A. Rule 20 Farmin

(i) Intensive Winter Grazing - size of area allowed to be grazed - Rule 20(a)(iii)(1)

.,

5

6.

25

Page 4: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

7

Decision appeoled:

The Council's decision to accept only in part the Appellant's submission I 17.1 f with

the result that the area of permissible intensive winter grazing is l5%o of a landholding

or 100 hectares, whichever is the lesser.

Reason-for appeal:

The proposal to allow intensive winter grazing on no more than l5Yo of a landholding

or 100 hectares, whichever is the lesser:

8.1 Is a one size fits all approach, which doesn't recognise the scale of different

properties;

Is not sustainable for larger properties if limited to 100ha - larger properties will

be unable to winter their own capital stock;

Penalises owners of properties at a higher altitude as there are generally lower

yields for these properties, resulting in lower stock units per hectare and the need

for larger areas to graze the stock. Conversely, with lower stock numbers per

hectare, there are also less adverse effects grazing the same stock numbers over

a greater area,'

Penalises the owners of larger properties without justifiable reason e.g. a 667

hectares property cap is 100 hectare and a 2000-hectare property cap is 100

hectares;

Does not allow for crop failure or lower yields due to climatic/pest issues;

Potentially devalues our (and other) property;

Will result in potentially more adverse environmental effects if there are more

smaller landholders, allowing for more intense winter grazing over a greater

collective area,

Does not give effect to the Southland RPS 2017, including Policy RURAL.1,

and

Is not in accordance with Part 2 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the

RMA), in particular section 7(b), the efficient use and development of natural

and physical resources.

8.2

8.3

8

8.4

8.5

8.6

8.7

8.8

8.9

l Recommended Decisions on Submissions 29 January 2018: page 91

35

Page 5: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

9

Reliqf sought.

Delete the words "or 100 hectares, whichever is the lesser" from the Rule.

(iD Intensive Winter Grazing - mob size - Rule 20(a)(iii)(3)(E)

Decision appealed.

10 The Council's decision to introduce a new additional practice to be required before

intensive winter grazing is permitted - i.e. if cattle or deer are being grazed, the mob

("herd" when referring to cattle) size must be no more 120 cattle or 250 deer.

11

Reason-for appeal:

Issues with the proposed new provision include:

1 1.1 It is unclear what sized area the provision applies to;

ll.2 It creates a meaningless split of mobs (herds) for the same environmental

impact;

1 1.3 Larger properties are penalised because of the larger scale, larger mobs (herds)

and more land per animal;

11.4 it will not give effect to the Southland RPS 2017, including Policy RURAL.l -Social, economic and cultural wellbeing; and

1 1.5 it is not in accordance with Part 2 of the RMA, in particular section 7(b), the

efficient use and development of natural and physical resources.

Relief sousht

12. Amend Rule 23(a)(iiD(3)(E) to increase the mob (herd) size of cattle from 120 to 200.

B. Cultivation - Rule 25(aXiv)

Decision appealed:

45

Page 6: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

The Council's decision to reject the Appellant's submissionllJ .22,requesting it lift the

slope on which cultivation could occur to 30 degrees, and instead requiring that

cultivation not occur on land with a slope greater than 20 degrees3.

Reason-for appeal:

Land sloping greater than 20 degrees is common on and forms a large part of many

properties in Southland.

15. The proposed rule is unduly onerous and

13.

t4.

t6.

15.1

ts.2

15.3

15.4

I 5.5

will prevent cultivation of traditionally cultivated blocks, over a large part of

Southland, unless a resource consent is obtained

results in a loss of productive land;

potentially devalues our (and other) property;

will not give effect to the Southland RPS 2017, including Policy RURAL.l -Social, economic and cultural wellbeing, and

is not in accordance with Part 2 of the RMA in particular section 7(b), the

efficient use and development of natural and physical resources.

Reliqf sought:

Amend Rule 25(a)(iv) so that the reference to "20 degrees" is replaced by "30 degrees"

(i) General

17. Campbell's Block Ltd. seeks:

17.l such further or altemative relief to like effect (including alternative wording to

address concerns expressed above) as the Court deems appropriate and any

consequential amendments which may be required as a result of allowing this

appeal;

17.2 costs.

2 Recommended Decisions on Submissions 29 January 2018 page 99

3 Slope is the average slope over any 20m distance, FN7 pWLP, page 54.

55

Page 7: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

18

19.

The Appellant agrees to participate in mediation or other alternative dispute resolution

ofthe proceedings.

The following documents are attached to this notice:

(a)

(b)

(c)

a copy of the Appellant's submission (Appendix A)

a copy of the relevant decision (Appendix B)

a list of names and addresses of persons to be served with a copy of this notice

(Appendix C).

(,(. V,M

Clare LenihanCounsel for Appellant

17 May 2018

Date

Address for service of Appellant:Jeff Walker, Walker Murdoch Law LimitedPO Box 1188

Invercargill 9840Tel:03 [email protected]

and copy to:Clare LenihanBarrister102 Jed StreetInvercargill 9810Tel: (03) 214 1674clare. lenihan@environmentallawyer. co.nz

65

Page 8: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Advice to recipients of copy of notice of appeal

How to become party to proceedings

You may be a party to the appeal if you made a submission or a further submission on thematter of this appeal and you lodge a notice of your wish to be a party to the proceedings (inform 33) with the Environment Court within 15 working days after the period for lodging a

notice ofappeal ends.

Your right to be a party to the proceedings in the court may be limited by the tradecompetition provisions in section 274(l) and Part l lA of the Resource Management Act199t.

You may apply to the Environment Court under section 281 of the Resource ManagementAct 1991 for a waiver of the above timing or service requirements (see form 38).

How to obtain copies of documents relating to appeal

The copy of this notice served on you does not attach a copy of the appellant's submissionor the parts of the decision appealed. These documents may be obtained, on request, from theappellant.

Advice

If you have any questions about this notice, contact the Environment Court in Auckland,Wellington, or Christchurch.

The Auckland address of the Environment Court is8th floor, District Court Building3 Kingston StreetAucklandTelephone: 09 9169091Fax: 09 9169090

Its postal address is:P OBox7l47Wellesley StreetAuckland

And its telephone and fax numbers are:Telephone: (09) 916 9091Fax: (09) 916 9090

The Wellington address of the Environment Court isThe District Court Building43 - 49 Balance StreetWellington

75

Its postal address is:

Page 9: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

P O Box 5027Lambton QuayWellington

And its telephone and fax numbers are:

Telephone: (04) 918 8300Fax: (04) 918 8303

The Christchurch address of the Environment Court is:83 Armagh Street (corner Durham Street)Christchurch

Its postal address isP O Box 2069Christchurch

And its telephone and fax numbers are

Telephone: (03)962 4170Fax: (03)962 4I7l

85

Page 10: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Apper,diY'A'& envlronmsnt

SOUTHLAND89-Cameron Grant-Campbells Block Ltd-Owner -DirectorTe |ai* Tr.la

89-CAMERON GRANT-Campbells Block Ltd-Owner -Director

Address 65 Otamita Valley Road,RD7, Gore, Postcode 9777

Email Address [email protected]

Phone N um ber 027 22O36Os

Public Hearing I DO NOT wish to be heard in support of my submission; or

Trade Competition I COULD NOT gain an advantage in Trade Competition through this submission; or

Gain

Joint Hearing

SWLP Topics-Select the topics that youwould like to provide feedback for:

CultivationCultivation Comments-Please comment on

the proposed rule for cultivation (Rule 25).lnclude any change or decision you wantcouncil to make.

FarmingFarming Comments-Please comment onthe proposed rule for farming (Rule 20).lnclude any change or decision you wantcouncil to make.!ntensive winterI ntensive winter grazing Comments-Pleasecomment on the proposed rule forintensive winter grazing (Rule 23). lncludeany change or decision you want council tomake.

CultivationFarminglntensive winter grazingTile drains

I oppose this because there is not enough clarity surrounding the 20

degree rule and what it applies to in a block of land to be worked i.e. doesit apply to the whole block if part of it is greater than 20 degrees or does itonly apply to the area of land within the block greater than 20 degrees.

I think the degree needs to be lifted to 30 because we would have toapply for permits to plant all our winter brasicas.ln conjunction with an

increase in the degree of the slope there also needs to be a buffer zonerequirement for the upper limit as much of our cultivation can be

contained to the flatter areas on top with extensive natural cover and alarge buffer zone to the nearest waterway/bottom of a gully already left in

lace

We are doing most of this already and review it annually.We have an

extensive Nutrient Budget Plan which is reviewed annually in conjunctionwith our Balance Rep.

I oppose this because I don't think farmers, farming in a traditionalmanner, wintering their own stock should have a set amount of winterfeed.The 20 hec and 50 hec maximums will not work within our farmingprogramme.They are not practical when you have a substaintiallandholding.l think the 15% that was in the original document is a

significant improvement rather than a setting a hectare limit and thisshould cover most people wintering their own stock and operating undera more sustainable farming practise whereby they are not farming moreintensively than their property allows by wintering stock off farm.

NB: High or intensive stocking rate is not defined in the plan and there isnot a rate.

Tile drains

Page 1 of 2

Page 11: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

&t envlronmentSOUTHLAND89-Cameron G rant-Cam pbells Block Ltd-Owner -Director

Tile drains Comments-Please comment onthe proposed rule for tile drains (Rule 13).lnclude any change or decision you wantcounci! to make.

7t Taiar 7,y

Not a time consuming task given advances in farm technology

Page2 of 2

Page 12: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Rule 20 - Farming

L4.3,24.86,26.9, 31_.4,31.5, 40,6, 47.!0, 49.34, 49.3,56.4, 57 .'.J", 58. 1, 59. 1", 62.9,63.3,64.12,7 4.2,7 9.2, g}.t7,81.20,83.2, 85.2,93.2,99.2, LOO.2, 10t.2, 103.5, tA7 3,108.78, 1,1,4.2, 1-L9.4, 119.1, 123.2, 135.2, l_50.3,

152.10, 1,57.2, 159.2, 159.3, 160.5, 161.3 , L62.3, 1,63.L,

L72.15, 173.2, 176.3, 199.31, !91".7, 192.1, 194.1,L96.2, L98.2, 200.2, 204.2, 205.24, 206.24, 209.30,210.82, 212.1,, 219.1-, 222.L, 223.L, 224.5, 23L.2, 233.6,237.7, 238.L, 239.1, 246.L, 247.9, 252.1., 257.2, 259.7,262.2, 264.5, 265.93, 269.L, 277.44, 2't9.67, 292.t4,296.4, 299.!4, 300.14, 310.1, 313.3, 314.3, 323.1",

33L.7, 336.2, 341,.8, 343.L, 349.5, 351.2, 352.3, 361,.9,

352.3, 355.3, 359.1, 370.2, 37L.4, 391.19, 396,9,387.1"1", 390.29, 39!.3, 392.L, 394.2, 401.',1., 41.1_.30,

425.2, 433.4, 434.2, 437.19, 45L.7, 461.2, 463.1, 469.2,469.3, 476.2, 47g.tg, 482.1"1, 492.12, 501.1, 502.2,506.2, 507.2, 510.1, 515.5, 5!7.2, 520.2, 521..2, 522.3,537.3, 538.3, 553.7, 554.9, 555.12, 556.4, 559.9, 555.2,5 58. 1, 57 2.2, 57 4.2, 57 8.L, 59L.2, 592.2, 5g3.tg, 595. 5,

590.8, 597.2,599.1, 503.3, 606.2,509.3, 613.2, 617.2,623.1, 616.6, 638.1, 640.35, 645.2, 652.4, 656.3,66L.37, 666.L3, 678.3, 679.3, 69L.1L, 692.7, 699.2,

692.2, 69 4.2, 695.2, 7 09.2, 7 11.6, 7 12.27, 7 t6.2, 7 2L.2,722.1,, 723.2, 723a.2, 737.L8, 739.L, 743.3, 747.5,748.3, 752.1,!2, 762.4, 766.4, 757.5, 77L.1.L, 774.4,7 7 5.2, 7 80.2, 7 82. L, 7 93.2, 7 96.4, 7 g7 .3, 7 90.6, 7 92.23,797.37, 798.5, 799.6, 902.23, 903.39, 907.2, 910.33,8L6.4, 817.20, 8\8.21, gLg.1g, 920.7, 924.2, 925.2,832.81, 843.4, 854.2, 961.19, 964.5, 965.4, 977.45,880.49, 892.2,893.2

Accept in part We have recommended merging Rules 20 to 23 into a new Rule 20. We have reviewed thesubmissions on Rule 20 as notified in light of all these requests with a view to accepting allthat would be most appropriate for achieving the objectives of the pSWLp and wouldcontribute to a coherent body of provisions that would assist the Southland Regionalcouncil to carry out its functions in attaining the purpose of the RMA, we havehad regard to the effectiveness and efficiency of the body of provisions andhave taken into accountthe benefits and costs of the environmental, economic, social andcultural effects anticipated from the implementation of the provisions and risks of actingor not acting. As a result, we have generally accepted the final amended version of Rule20 that was presented to us in the section 42A author's Reply Report. consequently, werecommend some of the amendments requested and do not recommend others. Withoutaddressing each in detail, we consider that those we do not recommend would notcontribute to making the pSWLP a coherent measure that would assist the SouthlandRegional Council as intended. The amendments to Rule 20 that we recommend arecontained in the marked-up version of the Plan in Appendix B1 to this Report. See alsoChapter 8 dealing with farming activities, Chapter 18 dealing with the content of FEMps(Appendix N of the pSWLP) and Chapter 19 dealing with IASM of the separate narrativeforming part of this Report where we discuss these matters in more detail.

1,7.3, 25.25, 67 .2, 17 5.2, 195.4, 195.3, 319.1.!, 369. 1 1,

420.2, 424. 1,, 464.1,4, 57 6.3, 5 gg. 1, 60 4.3, 615.2, 7 3 4.1",

827.2, 851.2, 952.3, 953.2, ggg.g

Reject

z€

lra3*x

2Ft

87

Page 13: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Lz.L, 29.1, 33.3, 42.L, 46.L, 84.L, 88. 1, 89. 28, 90. 1,

92.7, 94.3, L44.2, 164.1, 183. 1, 184.L, 220.!3, 221.13,225.L, 243.1-, 29L.1", 298.3, 3 06. 1, 3 12.L, 402.9, 407 .t,428.1, 435.1,, 474.1-, 49L.L, 492.L, 493.1,503.1, 505.1,

527 .t, 539. 1, 542.2, 548. 1, 557 .3, 563. L, 57 0.14, 57 L.t,595.1, 630.1, 535.1, 539.1, 669.1-, 677.1, 593.3, 699.L,

7 00.2, 7 14.L, 7 88.1-, 7 91-.1", 7 96.L, 812.1,, 835.1, 836. 1,

866.2, 867 .7, 87 3.1, 884.1, 890.1_

Accept in part While we have recommended removing reference to the physiographic zones from thepSWLP's rules we recommend that Policies 4-11 retain reference to these zones for thereasons outlined by the section 42A authors and as further discussed in Chapter 6 of theseparate narrative forming part of this Report.

1".1, tog.!, 156.6, 207 .4, 253.2, 258.L2, 261,.3, 297 .9,

334.2, 415.L, 429.2, 438.1-, 477 .5, 483.16, 496.L,519.4,525.1, 559. 1, 550.4, 580. 2, 642.3, 643.3, 646.2, 67 0.3,

690.3, 69L.3, 7 28.3, 7 30.2, 7 33.L4, 7 57 .5, 7 59.9, 7 58.9,

776.',J.,800.2,808.3, 813.5, 840.5, 842.5, 868.15, 869.5

Reject A general request which does not give precise details of amendments requested. See alsoChapter 5 in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

23.L, 7 0.2, 86.3, 91-.2, 240.!, 244.1,, 266.4, 3L5.2, 3 18. 1,

320.L, 3 58. 13, 413.1, 6L6.6, 61,8.1,, 632.1, 648.1., 649.1.,

655.6, 726.4, 793.3, 834.3

Reject The submission is outside the scope of the pSWLP. See also Chapter 5 in the separatenarrative forming part of this Report.

88

Page 14: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

L2.3,29.3, 42.3, 46.3,84.3, 88.3, 89.30, 90.3, 135.3,183. 3, t84.3, L92.8, 205.26, 206.26,225.3, 243.3, 29L.3,3t23,331.8, 407 .3,428.3,435.3, 474.3, 487 .3, 491.3,492.3, 493.3,503.3, 505.3, 527 .3,539.3, 548.3, 563.3,571-.3, 595.3, 530.3, 635.3, 639.3, 693.5, 599.3, 7L4.3,7 88.3, 7 91.3, 7 96.3, 802.25,8L2.3, 835.3, 836.3, 867 .3,

873.3,884.3, 890.3

Accept in part While we have recommended removing reference to the physiographic zones from thepSWLP's rules we recommend that Policies 4-1L retain reference to these zones for thereasons outlined by the section 42A authors and as further discussed in Chapter 5 of theseparate narrative forming part of this Report.

23.3,7 0.4, 17 8.2, 244.3, 3 18. 3, 3 20. 3, 389.6,413.3,61"8.3, 622.23, 632.3,648.3, 649.3, 814.5

Reject The submission is outside the scope of the pSWLP. See also Chapter 5 in the separatenarrative forming part of this Report.

642.4,643.4 Accept in part See Section 32 Report. We address the section 32AA matters raised in this submissionpoint in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

Rule 23 - lntensive winter grazing

7.2,3.6,5.12,5.13,6.1,7 .4,8.1, 11.6, 13.3, 14.4, L9.4,

19.5, 22.2, 23.4, 24.89, 25.28, 26.1,1,, 27 .2, 28.3, 30.2,37.6, 32.7, 33.5, 34.2, 37 .3, 38.3, 39.3, 40.8, 47.1, 43.5,

44.2, 47.13, 51.1, 53.1, 54.10, 55.2, 56.5, 57.2, 58.2,

59.2, 60.L, 62.10, 62.25, 66.2, 67 .3, 69.L, 7 0.5, 7 3.!3,7 4.4, 7 9.3, 8L.21-, 82.5, 83.5, 87 .2, 89.31, 9L.3, 92.9,

93.5, 94.4, 96.1, 97 .3, 99.3, 101-.3, 102.4, tO3.7, 105. L,

107 .4, 108. 8 1, 111.1-, 1-L4.3,',J"17 .1", LL8.7, 1L9.2, 120.3,

121.7, !24.2, 126.3, !32.1_, 133.4, 13 4.1., 136.2, 13 9. 5,

1,4L.3, 1-44.5, 1"46.L, 147 .5, 1,48.3, 150.4, 152.13, 154.3,

155.5, 156.8 , 160.J, 163,3, 164.2, 165.1, 1,68.2, L75.4,

17 7 .3, 17 8.3, 17 9.6, 181. 13, 182. 1, 186.5, 188.2,

189.34, L90.13, L9L.10, 195.4, 198.3, 200.5, 20L,2,

202.1-, 203.1_, 20 4.5, 2O8.L, 209.32, 2 10. 85, 21L.3,

274. L4, 2L5.3, 217 .2, 218.2, 2L9.5, 220.14, 22L. 14,222.2, 224.9, 233.8, 235.2, 23 6.2, 237 .2, 238.2, 239.2,

240.2, 244.4, 245.3, 247 .t0, 248.1, 249.25, 250.4,

25L.2, 252.4, 253.4, 254.3, 257 .3, 258.L3, 259.1O,

Accept in part We recommend that Rule 23 as notified is included in amended Rule 20 as part (a)(iii) ofthat rule. We have considered the content of new Rule 2O(a)(iii) in the light of all thesubmissions on Rule 23 as notified with a view to accepting all that would be mostappropriate for achieving the objectives of the pSWLP and would contribute to a coherentbody of provisions that would assist the Southland Regional Council to carry out itsfunctions in attaining the purpose of the RMA. We have had regard to the effectivenessand efficiency of the body of provisions and have taken into account the benefits andcosts of the environmental, economic, social and cultural effects anticipated from theimplementation of the provisions and risks of acting or not acting. As a result, werecommend some of the amendments requested and do not recommend others. Withoutaddressing each in detail, we consider that those we do not recommend would notcontribute to making new Rule 2O(a)(iii) a coherent measure that would assist theSouthland Regional Council as intended. The amendments we recommend are containedin the marked-up version of the Plan in Appendix 81 to this Report. See Chapters 8 and 10of the separate narrative forming part of this Report that respectively deal with farminggenerally and intensive winter grazing in particular. See also Chapters 17 , L8 and 19 of theseparate narrative forming part of this Report dealing with definitions, FEMPs and IASMrespectively.

91

Page 15: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

260.L, 262.3, 262.4, 263.1,, 264.7, 265.86, 266.5, 259.1,27 4.2, 27 5.2, 27 7 .47, 27 9.69, 281.1, 284.2, 286.3,287 .3,290.2, 292.L5, 29 4.3, 29 6.6,297 .tO,299. L5,300. 15, 301.2, 302.L, 303. 1, 305. 1, 308. 1, 310.2, 3 13.5,

3 15. 1, 3 L7 .1,, 318.4, 319.14, 320.4, 322.9, 323.2,324.1,,325.1, 33 L. 9, 332.2, 333.2, 334.3, 335.4, 339. 10, 34L.9,344.5, 345.5, 350. 1, 351.3, 352.4, 358.t4, 360. 1,

36L.LL, 362.6, 3 65. 5, 369.L4, 37 0.3, 37 1,.6, 37 3.L,37 4.L, 377 .3, 37 8.3, 384.3, 389.7, 392.2, 393. 1, 396.2,399.2, 40L.2,405.1, 4L3.4, 415.2, 416.2, 417 .1, 4!8.2,4L9.2, 421_.3, 423.1_, 423.2,425.4, 425.5, 429.4, 431.3,433.5, 437.22, 438.4, 439.2, 440.3, 443.2, 444.3, 447.3,

448.3, 45A.4, 456.L, 46L.3,463.2, 464.L7 , 465.3, 469.6,

47 0.2, 47 6.3, 483.t9, 487 .4, 488.2, 49 4.2, 496.3, 498.4,

500.1, 50L.3, 502.3, 504.4,506.5, 507.3, 508.1, 509.3,5 L0.4, 5LL.2, 515.7, 520.5, 52L.4, 524.2, 525.4, 53 1.3,

532.2,533.3, 534.3, 535.5, 536.L2,538.5, 540.1,, 54L.2,545.6, 552.2, 553.9, 554.10, 555.L3, 556.5, 557.5,558.9, 560.7, 564.LL, 565.3, 568.2, 569.8, 57 2.5, 57 6.4,

586.9, 587.1", 590.9, 592.4, 598.4, 603.6, 604.4, 605.L,606.3, 607.1,, 6L3.4, 6L6.7 ,617 .3,6!8.4, 523.4, 624.4,

625.2,632.4, 634.3,536.1, 638.4, 640.37 , 64L.3,642.5,643.5,545.5, 645.3 , 648.4,649.4,651.2, 652.6, 553.1,

654.2, 655.8, 661.40, 663.1, 556.16, 671-.1-, 672.5,67 3.2, 67 6.2, 67 7 .2, 67 8.4, 67 9.4, 680. 1, 68 1, 13, 682.9,

594.3, 588.1, 689.5, 690.5, 691.5, 692.5,694.4,695.4,7 01.3, 7 02.3, 7 03 .1", 70 5. 3, 7 06. 12, 7 08.2, 7 t1.9,7 t2.30, 7 16.4, 7 L8.1,1", 7 20.2, 7 22.2, 7 26.6, 7 27 .2,

7 29 .2, 7 3 1".7, 7 32.4, 7 33 . 15, 7 35.2, 7 38.3, 7 39.2, 7 44.2,

7 45.1, 7 47 .7, 7 52.11-6, 7 59.12, 7 50.5, 7 6L.Lt, 7 62.7,7 65.3, 7 66.6, 7 69.2, 7 7 0.2, 7 7 1,.13, 7 7 ta.LO, 7 7 4.6,

7 7 5.5, 7 7 7 .7, 7 7 8.L, 7 7 9.4, 7 80.4, 7 82.2, 7 83.3, 7 86.6,7 87 .4, 7 90.9, 7 92.25, 7 93.4, 7 94.1, 7 97 .40, 800.5,

801.3, 802.26, 803.41, 804.L, 807 .5, 8 10.35, 8 15.5,

817 .23, 8!8.24, 8L9 .22, 820.9, 822. 4, 824.5, 8 25. 5,

828.3, 828.4, 829.L, 832.84, 83 2. 85, 833. 5, 83 4.4,837 .2, 840.7, 843.5, 845.3, 846.2, 847 .1, 849.2, 854.3,

92

Page 16: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

855. 1, 856. 5, 857 .5, 858. 1, 859.4, 850.3, 863.2, 864.6,855.5, 868.18, 871.4, 875.5, 876.2, 877.48, 878.3,

880.52, 881.3, 882.2,883.2, 885.3, 887 .1,, 892.4,893.4,894.2

20.2, 49.37, 49.4, 63.5,7L.L, 80.L8,85.3, 109.2, L3O.2,

L3L.L, 135.4, L42.3, 157.5, 161.5, L62.5, L92.9, 194.4,

207.7, 227.2, 228.L, 229.4, 261.4, 276.1,, 278.1, 316.3,

326.L, 336.4, 337.L4, 340.2, 343.2, 349.L,354.3, 368.3,

381_.21, 424.4, 426.4, 434.4, 446.L, 453.3,458.3, 460.3,467.8, 471.3, 472.3, 473.4, 478.20, 486.4, 495.L,518.9,522.5, 526.4, 529.2, 530.2, 561.1, 574.4, 593.1, 609.4,

615.3, 626.2, 644.L,656.6, 665.1, 686.1, 685.2,748.6,7 95.2, 7 98.7, 81L.20, 81,4.6, 821.4, 87 9.3

Reject A general request which does not give precise details of amendments requested. See alsoChapter 5 in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

64.15, L00.3, 123.4, LZS.t, L53.2,158.5, 159.4, 172.16,17 3.3, L7 6.4, 196.3, 205.27, 206.27, 212.2, 2!6.3,246.4, 27 3.L, 282.L,283.4, 3 14.4, 3 53. 1, 366.L, 367 .L,

375.3, 380.L, 385.9, 387 .1,4,394.3, 402.11., 407 .4,

420.3, 446.2, 45 1.8, 452.1, 454.2, 455. 1, 459.3, 47 7 .7,

480. 5, 482.14, 499,3, 516.3, 517 .4, 537 .6, 542.5,

570.15, 577.2, 58L,3, 582.3, 583,2L, 596.2, 599.2,

619.4, 62L.t, 527.5,628.6,629.1, 637 .L, 647 .7, 650.3,

559.3, 660.2, 667 .7 ,558.5, 669.4, 670.4, 696.2, 697 .4,

700. 3, 7 04.5, 7 17 .4, 7 L9.3, 7 2L.3, 7 23.3, 7 23a.3, 7 24. 4,

728.4,730.5, 737 .20,7 40.3, 7 43.4, 7 67 .7 , 7 68.!2,77 2.3, 773.6, 7 84.L, 7 99.8, 813.7, 8 15.3, 826.3, 827 .5,

930. 5, 83 1.3, 842.7, 844.3, 861.21,, 862.3, 869.6, 87 4.2,

888.9,889.4

Reject The amendments requested would unjustifiably weaken the pSWLP and reduce itseffectiveness in achieving its objectives, and for giving effect to the superior instruments.

12.4, 29.4, 42.4, 46.4, 84.4, 88.4, 90.4, 183.4, 1,84.4,

225.4, 243.4, 29L.4, 298.5, 3L2.4, 428.4, 435.4, 47 4.4,

49L.4, 492.4, 493.4, 503.4, 505.4, 527 .4, 539.4, 548.4,

563.4, 57 1,4, 595.4, 630.4, 635.4, 639.4, 693.6, 699.4,

7 14.4, 7 88.4, 7 91.4, 7 9 6.4, 8L2.4, 83 5.4, 83 6.4, 86'1 . 4,

873.4,884.4, 890.4

Accept in part While we have recommended removing reference to the physiographic zones from thepSWLP's rules we recommend that Policies 4-lL retain reference to these zones for thereasons outlined by the section 42A authors and as further discussed in Chapter 6 of theseparate narrative forming part of this Report.

355.10 Accept in part We address the issues raised by this submission point elsewhere in this Report.

93

Page 17: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Reject406.L,578.4,775.4 The submission is outside the scope of the pSWLP. See also Chapter 5 in the separatenarrative forming part of this Report.

304.2,622,24 Reject The requested amendment is uncertain and would be disproportionately onerous. ltwould foreclose reasonable opportunities for economic growth and employment.

Rule 24 - lncidental discharges from farming

Accept24.9A, 108.82, 152.!4, 185.6, 189.35, 233.9, 250.5,

313.5, 368.4, 402.12, 570.L6, 81L.2L,832.85, 877.49,880.s3

Except to the extent that, in response to other submissions, we are recommendingomissions or amendments to the notified provisions, we recommend, including for thereasons set out in the submissions and the Section 42A Reports, that they are retained as

notified.

Reject265.87,355.11, 581.4 The amendments requested would unjustifiably weaken the pSWLP and reduce itseffectiveness in achieving its objectives, and for giving effect to the superior instruments.

224.9,582.4 Reject A general request which does not give precise details of amendments requested. See alsoChapter 5 in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

Reject We adopt the recommendations and reasons set out in the section 42A Reports.Additionally, we are not persuaded that the amendment requested would be a moreeffective and reasonably practicable option for achieving the objectives of the pSWLP, andfor giving effect to the superior instruments.

27 9.7 O, 3 49.2, 640.38, 7 52.LL7, 7 92.26, 8 10. 3 6

Accept Provisions in the pSWLP already adequately address these matters510.5, 598.5

94

Page 18: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Rule 25 - Cultivation on sloping ground

Sub lD & Sub Point 'i ' Recommendation

5.1-4, 8.2, 14.5, 19.6, 22.3, 24.9L, 27.3, 34.3, 43.6,

47.14, 56.6, 62.11,, 79.4, 87.3, 92.10, 99.4, !01.4,108.83, LL6.4, !33.5, !47.7, 155.6, 1,56.9, 173.4,

185.3, 189.36, 190j,4, 191,.11,, 210.86, 237.3, 238.3,

239.3, 249.26, 257.4, 259.1,1,, 268.3, 275.3, 277.48,279;tL, 286.4, 28't.4, 290.3, 297.L1,, 313.'/, 340.3,

365.6, 368.5, 374.2, 390.30a, 394.4, 432.2, 452.2,453.4, 461,.4, 464.18, 470.3, 472.4, 473.5, 5O2.4, 5O7.4,

512.1_, 5L7.5, 525.5, 532.3, 544.2, 565.4, 569.9,

570.L7, 586.10, 598.5, 504.5, 622.25, 646.4, 654.3,

655.9, 662.3, 677,3, 696.3, 700.4,'l 10.8, 721..4, 730.6,

733.1_6, 735.3, 744.3, 748.7, 752.1"18, 758.1, 759.13,7 62.8, 7 92,27, 7 93.5, 845.4, 854.4, 860.4, 866.3, 885.4

Accept in part We recommend that Rule 25 as notified is retained in the pSWLP subject to theamendments we discuss below. We have considered the content of Rule 25 in the light ofall the submissions on it with a view to accepting all that would be most appropriate forachieving the objectives of the pSWLP and would contribute to a coherent body ofprovisions that would assist the Southland Regional Council to carry out its functions in

attaining the purpose of the RMA. We have had regard to the effectiveness and efficiencyof the body of provisions and have taken into account the benefits and costs of theenvironmental, economic, social and cultural effects anticipated from the implementationof the provisions and risks of acting or not acting. As a result, we recommend some of theamendments requested and do not recommend others. Without addressing each indetail, we considerthat those we do not recommend would not contribute to making Rule25 a coherent measure that would assist the Southland Regional Council as intended. Theamendments we recommend are contained in the marked-up version of the Plan inAppendix Bl to this Report. See Chapters 8 and 11of the separate narrative forming partof this Report that respectively deal with farming generally and cultivation in particular.See also Chapters 17,18 and 19 of the separate narrative forming part of this Reportdealing with definitions, FEMPs and IASM respectively.

L.3, 9.L, LL.7, 25.29, 26.12, 3L.7, 33.6, 39.4, 40.9, 53.2,

54.!1,, 51.3, 58.3, 59.3, 60.2, 55.2, 74.5, 80.19,

81,.22,81.23,82.6, 83.6, 86.5, 89.32, 9L.4, 93.6, 100.4,

102.5, 103.8, 105.2, 107.5, t\2.2, L13.2, L15.1., L17.2,

118.8, 119.3, t20.4, 12L.2, !22.1,, 124.3, L25.2, 127.1,

130.3, 131'2, 136.3, L39.6, 140.3, L4r.4, 145.3, 1.46.2,

148.4, 150.5, 152.15, 153.3, 158.6, 160.8, 163.4,

164.3, 1-67 .2, 168.3, 1,69.2, 1'1 2.t7, L7 5.5, 17 9.7, 195.5,

L96.4, 198.4, 199.2, 200.6, 202.2, 203.2, 204.6, 205.28,206.28, 208.2, 209.33, 21-1.4, 21,2.3, 2r3.L, 21.4.15,

215.4, 220.15, 22L.!5, 222.3, 223.2, 230.L, 233.10,234.L, 240.3, 245.4, 248.2, 255.2, 260.2, 262.5, 264.8,

265.88, 266.6, 267.1, 28r.2, 282.2, 292.1,6, 294.4,

295.4, 296.7, 298.6, 299.17, 300.17, 301.3, 304.3,

305.2,309.1, 310.3, 31-1-.2, 31,4.5, 3L6.4, 317 .2,319,15,321-.1,, 322.10, 323.3, 324.2, 327 .1,, 332.3, 334.4, 335.5,

339.11, 341".10, 344.6, 345.6, 349.3, 35'1.1,, 360.2,

Reject We adopt the recommendations and reasons set out in the section 42A Reports. See alsothe separate narrative on this matter in Chapter 11 forming part of this Report.Additionally we consider that the amendments requested would unjustifiably weaken thepSWLP and reduce its effectiveness in achieving its objectives, and for giving effect to thesuperior instruments.

95

Page 19: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

36!.L2, 362.7, 369.15, 385.1, 385.10, 39L.4, 392.3,

402.13, 403.1, 404.L, 42L.4, 424.5, 429.5, 432.1,,

437.23,438.5, 441.1, 444.4, 445.3,450.5, 454.3, 459.4,

462.L, 463.3, 469.7, 47 7 .8, 482.L5, 485.L, 485. 5, 494.3,

495.2,498.5, 506.6, 508.2, 509.4, 510.6, 511.3, 518.10,

52L.5, 524.3, 526.5, 535.13, 537.7, 540.2, 543.1,

547.\2, 550.1, 551.2, 552.3, 553.10, 554.11, 555.14,

556.7, 557.6, 558.10, 561,.2, 564.!2, 567.1, 583.22,

599.3, 568.3, 574.5, 575.L,576.5, 578.5, 581.5, 582.5,

584.2, 587.2,590.10, 597.3, 6A2.L, 603.7, 603.8, 605.2,

606.4, 608.1, 516.8, 625.3, 626.3, 627.6, 628.7, 633.t,638.5, 642.6, 643.6,645.6,650.4, 656.1, 659.4, 660.3,

666.L7 , 667.8,558.6, 676.3, 678.5, 679.5, 686.2, 687 .1,

688.2, 689.5, 690.6, 69!.5, 694.5, 695.5, 697.5, 704.3,

7 7L.!0, 7 20.3, 7 26.7, 7 27 .3, 7 28.5, 7 3L.8, 7 32.5, 7 34.2,

737.2L, 738.4, 739.3, 755.7, 756.1-, 76L.12, 763.3,

766.7, -769.3, 773.7, 775.6, 78L.L, 782.3, 784.2, 786;l ,

787.5, 790.L0, 802.27, 807.6, 8L0.37, 813.8, 8L4.7,

816.6, 8L7.24,818.25, 8L9.23, 822.5, 824.6, 825.5,

826.4, 827.6, 828.5, 833.6, 834.5, 840.8, 842.8, 847.2,

851.3, 853.3, 855.2, 861-.22, 864.7, 865.6, 868.19,

875.6, 881.4, 883.3, 887 .2, 893.5, 894.3

Reject A general request which does not give precise details of amendments requested. See also

Chapter 5 in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.20.3, 48.38, 64.16, 66.3, 67.4, 68.L, 7L.2, 96.2, 98.L,

109.3, L14.4, 135.5, 177.4, !92.10, 194.5, 2L9.6,

224.L0, 227.3, 253.5, 26!.5, 326.2, 336.5, 337.15,353.2, 358.15, 387.15, 388.2, 405.2, 4L5.3, 4L7.2,

417.3, 425.6, 426.5, 434.5, 445.2, 466.L, 47!.4,479.2L, 480.6, 488.3, 496.4, 528.3, 529.3, 533.4,

538.5, 559.3, 560.8, 592.5,609.5, 5L3.5, 615.4, 637.2,

641.4, 652.7, 67L.2, 68L.14, 682.L0, 683.2, 684.4,

692.6, 707.1, 722.3, 736.1, 767.8, 774.7 , 776,2, 7-19.5,

7 83.4, 7 95.3, 80L.4, 808.4, 821.5, 832.87, 845.3, 856.6,

857.6, 863.3, 877 .50, 879.4, 880.54

95

Page 20: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

42.5, 84.5, 88, 5, 183.5, L84.5, 225.5, 243.5, 29L.5,312.5, 4O7.5, 474.5,492.5,493.5, 503.5, 505.5, 527.5,539.5, 548.5, 563.5, 571.5,595.5, 530.5, 693.7, 599.5,7L4.5,791,.5,796.5, 912.5,935.5, 936.5, 957.5 , 973.5,884.5, 890,5

Accept in paft While we have recommended removing reference to the physiographic zones from thepSWLP's rules we recommend that Policies 4-11 retain reference to these zones for thereasons outlined by the section 42A authors and as further discussed in Chapter 6 of theseparate narrative forming part of this Report.

Rule 25 - Discharges from on-site wastewater systems

Rule 27 - Discharges from pit toilets

24.92, 387 .L6, 640.39, 556. 18, 7 25.5, 910.39, g32. gg Accept in part Except to the extent that, in response to other submissions, we are recommendingomissions or amendments to the notified provisions, we recommend, including for thereasons set out in the submissions and the Section 42A Reports, that they are retained asnotified.

1.52.76, 330.!4, 558. l-, 7 50.1,5, 7 52.t]-g Accept in part We adopt the recommendations and reasons set out in the section 42A Reports. See alsothe separate narrative on this matter in chapter 12 forming part of this Report.

L56. 10, 197 .8, 337 .!6, 349.4, 5LO.7, 598.7, 7 93.6 Reject A general request which does not give precise details of amendments requested. See alsoChapter 5 in the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

192.LL,265.89, 797 .4! Reject The amendments requested would unjustifiably weaken the pSWLP and reduce itseffectiveness in achieving its objectives, and for giving effect to the superior instruments.

279.72 Reject See Chapter 20 of the separate narrative forming part of this Report

24.93, 510.8, 598.8, 832.89 Accept in part Except to the extent that, in response to other submissions, we are recommendingomissions or amendments to the notified provisions, we recommend, including for thereasons set out in the submissions and the Section 42A Reports, that they are retained asnotified.

279.13 Reject See Chapter 20 of the separate narrative forming part of this Report.

750.16,752.124 Accept in part we adopt the recommendations and reasons set out in the section 42A Reports.

97

Page 21: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ir1---li I -.-i '.* l

AJ&SRCurrieLtd Andrew Currie 220 Chamberlain Road

RD2

Gore9772

ascu rrie @vrless.co.nz

AP&SMVerhaeghLtd Sue Verhaegh 1934 Riverton WallacetownHighway

RD3

Riverton 9883

a ndva [email protected]. nz

ADAMSAJ&PG Pauline Adams 437 River Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

ADAMSJuIeS l Chartlea Park Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

AdBest Partnership Jan Kingma 1654 Gorge Road lnvercargillHighway RD5

lnvercargill 9875

[email protected]

AFFLECK Christopher 192 Robertson Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]. nz

Agribusiness Consultants Ltd Deane Carson PO Box 1739

lnvercargill 9840

[email protected]

Agricentre South Ltd Simon Frisby PO Box 5213

Waikiwi

simon @asrice ntre.co.nz

-o*2

(\

-

IAddress list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Iand Plan

Page 22: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

r-i_l-r,-_r- Ir- l

lnvercargill 9843

Allln Ltd Peter Hughes &Maree Crowley

557 Carmichael Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

ALIAN Frazer & Karen 135 Glenurehill Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

frazer. ka ren @ netsoeed.net.nz

ALLAN Peter & Dianne 71 Ben-Callum Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

[email protected]

ALLENRS&KF Robert Allen zl47 Collinson Road

RD6

lnvercargil! 9876

No email

Allison Family Farms Ltd Bruce & Susan

Allison1359 Otautau Drummond Road

RD3

otautau 9683

bruce.a I lison @xtra.co.nz

ANDERSON Robert 989 Pourakino Valley Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

rla nderson@h rmside.co.nz

2Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutlland !7ater and Land Plan

Page 23: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I i-l i-i'li i r_l

Aparima Bridge Farm BrendonShearing

9 Riverton Otautau Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

bre nd o n. iacq u i @xtra.co. nz

Apolima Farms Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha un @fortunaeroup. net.nz

Aratiatia Livestock Ltd Paul & JuanitaMarshall

983 Lillburn Monowai Road

RD1

Tuatapere 9691

oa ul.marshall@fa rmside.co. nz

ArdelDairies Ltd Lyndon & AntheaDuff

458 Longridge Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

Ardoyne Farm Dairys Ewen Mathieson 612 Ward Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

math ieso n6 @fa rmside.co. nz

Arkley Farm Ltd Peter Gardyne 169 Collins road

RD3

Gore9773

arklevfarm@emai!.com

Aurum Farming Ltd Chris Deroles 5 McKinnon Road

RD1

Winton 9781

[email protected]

Austin Brothers PO Box 48

Riversdale 9744

[email protected]. nz

3Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan

Page 24: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I

il

Avon Downs Ltd Grant McKenzie 203 A6 Mclvor Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9876

[email protected]

AYERS Warren 413 Waiarikiki-Mimihau Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

wa [email protected]

B D Farm Trust Leon Black 357 Mitchell Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

BACON V M 811Weir Road

RD1

Te Anau 9679

sinnv [email protected]

BAIRDAJ&LS Allen Baird 166 Bixter Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

No emai!

BA]RD J J Jeremy Baird 8 Murphy Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

BAIRDMG&RJ Murray & Ruby

Baird1332 Lumsden Riversdale Highway

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

BAIRDNJ&SA Neil& SharrylBaird

1403 Otama Valley Road

RD7

oatlevhill @vrless.co. nz

4Address list of submitters on the proposed SoutNand lWater and Land Plan

Page 25: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Il- L- --lI i . -i t_i

Gore9777

BAKER David 545 Tomogalak Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

BAKER lsles 190 Pollock Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

BAKER Rory 122 Aicken Road

RD9

lnvercargil! 9879

[email protected]

BAKER Shane & SHAW Wendy 501 Tuatapere Orepuki Highway

RD1

Riverton 9881

[email protected]

BAKER Wendy 3 Lyne Street

Nightcaps 9630

wendviovba ker-ooet@ hotma il.com

Balfour Engineering Ltd CarlGutshlag PO Box 95

Balfour 9779

ba [email protected]

Balfour, Wendonside & WaikaiaGroup

Blair Drysdale 137 Pringle Road

RD6

Gore9776

d rvla [email protected]. nz

Balfour, Wendonside & WaikaiaGroup

Rob Dingle 245 Wendonside Church Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

5Address Iist of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and r.^nd Plafl

Page 26: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

_ili i1 i

l

BARCLAYTodd

(Member of Parliament - CluthaSouthland)

Office 2.087

Parliament House

Parliament Buildings

Wellington 5011

rebecca. rva n @ oa rlia ment.sovt.nz

Barkman Farming Ltd Murray & Lisa

Barkman140 Flynn Road

Gladfield

RD3

Otautau 9583

[email protected]

BAVIN Jono 1 Pullar Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9876

ionokellv@fa rmside.co. nz

Bayswater Dairy Ltd 388 Bayswater Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

[email protected]

BEATON G J & V R FamilyTrust Greg Beaton 1800 Waimea Valley Road

RD6

Gore 9776

[email protected]

BEATTIE Michael & Lynley Braxton Hill Station

56 Endowment Road

RD2

la mb. beattie @fa rmside.co.nz

6Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan

Page 27: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

_))

Lumsden 9792

Beaumont Station Glen Minty l Main Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

Beaumont Station Lynn Minty l Main Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

Beaumont Station Struan Minty l Main Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

BEE Carole 189 Leonard Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

oicabee@ netsoeed.net.nz

BEE Peter 189 Leonard Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected]

BEGGSNW&CE 154 Centennial Avenue

RD1

Queenstown9STL

[email protected]

BELGARD Family Trust (GA & JM

Rauber)

Janine Rauber 150 Hedgehope Block Road

RD2

[email protected]

7Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan

Page 28: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

al L_ i_i ,__t r:_f t- t f . i_l ai i t L--- i_i L_l - r r_r i_t a_t i--li:-rl---l

lnvercargill 9872

Ben Callum Station Ltd Justin & Shane

Roy2129 Waimea Valley Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

Benmore Downs Ltd Jared & PrueCollins

246 Matthews Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

benmoredowns@fa rmside.co. nz

BENNETT Raymond 190 Brydone Glencoe Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]. nz

Best AG Ltd Graham, Avril&Josh Best

26 Terrace Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

Betapahu Farms Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha u n @fo rtu naqro u p. net.nz

Beulah Organics NZ (BONZ) Alison Kingsbury 588 Crawford Road

RD2

Gore9772

ea [email protected]

BIACK Family Trust J Black, K Black &H Gallop

474 Longwood Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

[email protected]. nz

BIACKGL&RR Graeme BIack 1181 Riverton Otautau Highway

Gropers Bush

[email protected]

8Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan

Page 29: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

-l--r-^l--li rl

RD3

Riverton 9883

BLAIR Phillipa Mary 215 Waipapa Otara Road

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

[email protected]

BLAKELY Barney & Stephanie 567 Tomogalak Road

RD6

Gore9776

tomosa lakrun @fq rmside.co.nz

BLAKELY Hamish & Hannah 568 Tomogalak Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

BLOMFIELDMJ&KGTrust Michael& Karen

Blomfield14 Heenan Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

BOKSER Greg 1075 Waimea Highway

RD6

Gore9776

bo kse r.fa m i [email protected]. nz

BOLE WiII 288 Ellis Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

wairima @wilkinsfarmins.co.nz

BOWMAR Lindsay & Joanne 46 Wilson Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

I i.io.bowma [email protected]. nz

9Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland rVater and Land Plan

Page 30: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i-, l- - i i-_l IL. l i,---ll-r '- -'t

L___l

Braemore Farms Ltd Hamish MacKay 229 Kemp Road

RD7

Gore9777

mackavotama @sma il.com

BRAITHWA]TE Nathan 7 Mitre Street

Gore 9710

[email protected]

BRENTLEIGH Family Trust Brian Dillon 20 York Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

Brian Mahon Engineering Brian Mahon PO Box 140

Riversdale 9744

[email protected]

James Dillon 949 Riversdale-Ardlussa Road

RD6

Gore9776

Bridesdale Farming iimshoe@ netsoeed.net. nz

Patrick & MaryHanning

182 Tussock Creek-Grove Bush

Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

Bristol Grove Dairies [email protected]

Maurice &Suzanne Hanning

336 Hanning Road

Grove Bush

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

BristolGrove Dairies [email protected]

1077 Waimea Highway

RD6

Broadacres Ltd bret@tu llocheroup.co.nz

Address list of submitters oo the proposed Southland Water afld Land Plafl l0

Page 31: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i_l

)!

Gore9776

Brooklea Farm Ltd Rob & Rachael

Dingle248 Wendonside Church Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

BROWNING Stuart 235 Waituna Lagoon Road Kapuka

South

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

srazi ne4d a i rv@ gma i l.co m

Brunel Peaks Ltd Neil& Ben

Robertson4056 Blackmount Redcliff Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

[email protected]

BUCKINGHAM GTeta 1085 Niagara Tokanui Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

g.buckineha [email protected]

BUCKINGHAM Janette Waikawa Valley

RD1

Tokanui 9884

No email

BUCKINGHAM Thomas 905 Niagara Tokanui Highway

RD1

Tokanui 9884

[email protected]

Bunlrood Station Ltd Hamish McClean 2905 State Highway 94

RD2

Te Anau 9572

ha m ish mcclea n @farmside.co.nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod Plan ll

Page 32: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i1 ._l tlii, l li

BYARS Digby 99 Gardyne Road

Waikaka

RD5

Gore9775

[email protected]

BYARS Jeremy 294 Greenvale Road

RD5

Gore9775

[email protected]

BYARS Richard 1237 Waikaka Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

BYTHELL Jesse 131 Main Street

RD1

Otautau 9689

iesse. bvthell @orcon. net. nz

CFLFarmsLtd Andrew Muir Cattle Flat

RD5

Gore9'176

CFLfa rmsltd @em a i l.co m

C S Wilson Farming Ltd CampbellWilson 897 Longridge North Road

RD6

Gore 9776

ca mmv.wilson @ hotmail.com

CADE Andrew 272 Orawia-Pukemaori Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

kel.a ndv@fa rmside.co. nz

CADE Errol 50 Sim Road acade @pgewrightson.co. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Iaod PIan t2

Page 33: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ltirl i

RD2

Otautau 9582

CALLAHAN Pamela 251Quarry Hills Fortification Road

MaranuiValley

RD1

Tokanui 9884

ca llahan @fa rmside.co. nz

CAMPBELLJenny PO Box 71

Mossburn 9747

[email protected]

Campbells Block Ltd Cameron Grant 65 Otamita Valley Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Carmyllie Farm Blair McKenzie 64 Gold Creek Road

RD3

Gore9773

bla ir-mckenzie@ hotma il.com

Carnie Farms Brian & MarieCarnie

177 Oakland Road

Mataura lsland

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

CARTERDG&BJ David Carter 428 Waimea Valley Road

Mandeville

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

CARTER W J zl45 Kakapo Road ca rtercha ntal @hotmail.com

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan t3

Page 34: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i,l i I i I i . i r I l_ _l i_ i :_, _lrli_rl ll li_-l

Te Anau 9672

Caughey Ltd Grant Caughey 422Trotters Road

Longbush

RD1

!nvercargill 9871

[email protected]

CHAMBERLAIN Terry 355 Otahu Eastern Bush Rd

RD2

Otautau 9682

terrv. [email protected]

CHARTRES PeteT Te Anau Downs Station

Private Bag 50050

Te Anau 9640

[email protected]. nz

Cheviot Downs Ltd Craig & AilsaSpeight

1049 Blackmount Redcliff Road

RD1

Te Anau 9679

cheviotdowns@fa rmside.co.nz

CHRISTEY Anthony 75 Rouse Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

CHRISTIE William 587 Piano Flat Road

RD1

Waikaia 9778

inve rlochvfa rm sltd @qma il.co m

CHURCH David 4l Township Road

RD2

[email protected]. nz

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan t4

Page 35: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

llii -lr l- i

Otautau 9582

CivilTech Ltd Murray Gardyne 61 Rimu Street

lnvercargill 9812

[email protected]. nz

CTARKBD&NJTrust Bryson Clark 245 Terrace Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

CLARKE A W & T M Partnership Tania Clarke 94 Cowie Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

CLARKE Alanna 899 Wyndham Letterbox Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

CLARKE David 899 Wyndham Letterbox Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

CLARKE Julie Ann 87 McMillan Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

iulessthld @ hotmail.com

CLARKE Julie Ann & TUCK Roger 87 McMillan Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

iulessthld @ hotmail.com

CLEARWATERGS&MA GregoryClearwater

360 Waimumu Road

RD4

gclea ruvater@ osgwriEhtson.co. nz

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Soutlrland rWater and Land Plao l5

Page 36: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

- -l t-- i-- I :- a--. 1 , .r ,- I i-- I 1-

-r--l

Gore9774

2208 Lumsden-Riversdale Highway

RD6

Gore9776

CLEARWATER SuE suecleanrater@ hotmail.com

PaulClement 437 Glenkenich Road

RD5

Gore 9775

[email protected] Ltd

CLEMENT Karina 3 MemorialDrive

RD!

Wyndham

9891

peteka [email protected]

1232 Pyramid Waiparu Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected] Paul& Linda

4l Nicholson Road

RD3

Gore 9773

triffcl iffo rd @xtra.co. nzCLIFFORD Mervyn & Judy Ann

Andrew Gunn 186 Fleming Road

RD1

lnvercargill 9871

cloverbel l1 @outlook.co mClover Bell Ltd

Stephen Dennis 328 Clinkerhill Road

Wendon Valley

RD3

coa l. broo kfa rm @em a il.co mCoalbrook Partnership

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan t6

Page 37: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i_- l i

Gore9773

Coastal Plains Ltd Peter Hughes &Maree Crowley

557 Carmichael Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

oeter.ma ree07 @xtra.co.nz

Coasthaven Farms Ltd & PatersonGavara Trust

Gavin, Barbara &ChristopherPaterson

39 Ruahine Road East

RD1

Riverton 9881

sboaterson @fa rmside.co.nz

COCKBURN Grant & Rachel 1338 Kakapo Road

RD2

Te Anau 9672

g ra nt. rache I @xtra.co. nz

COGHIAN K P &WA GoodallRoad

Hamilton Burn

RD2

Mossburn 9792

wcoehla n@ nsc.school. nz

Colin Woodrow Ltd Cotin Woodrow 58 Tinker Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

pa m.colin @farmside.co.nz

COLLING Leigh 88 Traill Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]. nz

COLLING Megan 788 Ward Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land PIan t7

Page 38: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ill ir.ill il l i

COLLINS Gary 19 Steffan Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

screcollins@)Cra.co. nz

COLLINS Rachael 19 Steffan Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

CONLAN Eddie & Judy Family Trust Edward Conlan 943 Waikaka Valley

RD5

Gore9775

[email protected]

Conlan Farming CarlConlan 943 Waikaka Valley Highway

RD5

Gore 9775

[email protected]

Cook Farming Co Ltd Brendon Cook 177 Tyneholm Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

COPLANDMC&S Mark & Sallyann 360 Rosemarkie Road

Ferndale

Mataura9772

ma rksa I lva n n @xtra.co. nz

COPTAND R D & N J FamilyTrust Ross Copland 30 Mclntyre Road

RD1

Gore977L

[email protected]. nz

CORCORAN Martin Peter 212 Wendon Valley Road

RD3

oetercorcoran @xtra.co.nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan t8

Page 39: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

-lI

I li

Gore 9773

COWAN Les & Christine 5ll Waimatuku Flat Road

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

cowa nota huti@ema il.com

COWIE Martin 1377 Niagara-Tokanui Highway

Quarry Hills

RD1

Tokanui 9884

rmcowie@fa rmside.co.nz

CRACK Glenys 228 Rimu South Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

[email protected]

lll Clifden Highway

RD1

Tuatapere 9591

crackco ntracti ng@xtra. co.nzCRACK Stephen

456 Graham Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

[email protected] Farm Trust Martin & ValerieRabbidge

431Selbie Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

crome lva I levstatio n @xtra. co. nzCromel Valley Station Ltd Craig Drummond

15 Wendon Creek Road West

RD7

Gore9777

crooksclem @xtra.co.nzCrooks Dairy Ltd Morgan & Gen

Crooks

Address list of submitters oo the proposed Soutlland Water and Land Plao t9

Page 40: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Il I r I r -- , - l i i I I __r i:_i ' _l

CROOKS Jonathan Ross & Sarah Jane 52 Rob Roy Road

RD7

Gore9777

ionatha n.sa ra [email protected]

CRUICKSHANK Peter & Liz Rosedale

200 Wilton Street

lnvercargill 9810

No email

Currie Farm Ltd Andrew Currie 1150 Mossburn Lumsden Highway

RD2

Lumsden 9792

[email protected]

CUTHBERTSON John 18 Helena Street

Lumsden 9730

No email

Cuthbertson Shane 12 Farm Street

Lumsden

9730

No email

DJ&DAAndersonLtd James & DeniseAnderson

770 Winding Creek Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

DR&JAEPullarLtd David Pullar 86 Speden Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

Dairy Farms NZ Ltd Craig McBeth PO Box 1917

Shortland Street

Auckland 1140

cra ir@da irvfa rmsnz.co m

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan20

Page 41: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

r,_t___l li ', 1

DALEJM&KB John & KimberlyDale

170 Ardlussa Cattleflat Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

DALEPT&SBTrust Susan Dale 730 Mandeville Kingston CrossingRoad

RD6

Gore9776

dalefa [email protected]'

DAVIE Justin 99 Omutu Road

Gropers Bush

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

DAVIE Stuart 210 Turnbull Road

RD5

Gore9775

sas.davie@clea r.net.nz

DE BOER Frido 409 Lowther Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Sout}land lWater and Land Plan 2t

Page 42: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

,* l i- -_, i , i _ - ) -l -l i-- ,--i :-. l- - - ---l r---j

DIACK Hugh 29 Diack Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

diack@ netsoeed.net. nz

DICKIE Alan & Valerie 919 Old Coach Road

RD2

Gore9772

ala [email protected]. nz

DICKIE Alton Brent 1115 Old Coach Road

Ferndale

RD2

Gore9772

No email

DICKSON Andrew 155 Blaikie Road

Waikaia 9745

scairn @farmside.co.nz

DICKSON Brent Gordon 406 Byars Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

DICKSON Bruce John 480 Clinker Hill Road

RD3

Gore9773

No email

DICKSON Grant 1216 Waimumu Road

RD4

Gore9774

No email

Dillon Ag Ltd Chris Dillon 1032 Ardlussa Road

RD6

dillonaeltd @email.com

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Soutlland Water and Land Plan22

Page 43: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I i- l rl

Gore 9776

Dillon Ag Ltd Rochelle Dillon 1032 Ardlussa Road

RD6

Gore9776

dillonaeltd @smail.com

Dillon Grain Ltd Earl & ScottDillon

918 Riversdale Ardlussa Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

DILLONMJ&SE Mark & Sonia

Dillon850 Nine Mile Road

RD6

Kaweku

Gore9776

No email

DIPROSE Dave 794 Omutu Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

DITCHFIELD Dylan 510 Glenlapa Toad

RD7

Wendonside

Gore9777

dvlan @ditchfi elderoup.co. nz

DODDNR&JL 1096 Wyndham Letterbox Road natha [email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland \Water and Land Plan 23

Page 44: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lt-ll

RD1

Wyndham 9891

DODDS Geoffrey 232 CampbellRoad

RD2

Wyndham 9892

Geoff.kate232 @email.com

Donald Farms Murray Donald Spar Bush School Road

RD4

Waianiwa 9874

murravandca rolvnn@qma il.com

Douglas Monymusk Farms Ltd ChristopherDouglas

508 Gillespie Rod

RD1

Te Anau 9579

[email protected]

DRISCOLL Timothy & Jocelyn 265 Thomsons Crossing Road East

RD1

Winton 9781

driscolldairv@cma il.com

Drumderg Farm & Melgan Ltd Logan McKenzie zl40 Seaward Downs Gorge Road

RD3

Wyndham 9893

[email protected]

DRUMMONDRG&JM Russell & Janeen

Drummond

180 Tiromaunga Rd

Avondale

RD3

Winton 9783

d rum mond @netsoeed.net.nz

Drylands Farming Ltd Blair & JodyDrysdale

137 Pringle Road

RD6

d rvla nds @fa rmside.co. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plao24

Page 45: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I IiiiI,-l iiIiir i

Gore9775

DRYSDALE Family Trust William & Fiona

DrysdalePahiwiRoad

RD6

Gore9776

d [email protected]

DUFF Bradon 889 Clinker Hill Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

DUFF Farms Ronald Duff 820 Wyndham Valley Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

d [email protected]

DUFFY Pau] 998 Fortrose Otara Road

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

Paul [email protected]

DUGDALE Peter 83 Oakland Street

Mataura 9712

No email

DUNBAR M Craig Road

RD4

Gore9774

No email

DUNCAN Murray & Andrea 119 Terrace Road

RD4

Gore9774

a nd rea m u rrav6060@sma il.com

DUNNAGE Tony 162 Lang Road

RD1

[email protected]. nz

Address list of submitters oa the proposed Southland Water and Land Plao25

Page 46: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I I , __ __l i i i , 1 i l i : i I _i _ l a )

Dipton 9791

DYER Stephen 224 Wyndham Letterbox Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

DYSON Valerie &Glyn 795 Lillburn Monowai Road

RD1

Tuatapere 9691

[email protected]

EADEGT&FA Geordie Eade 1058 Pourakino Valley Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]. nz

East Dome Farms Ltd David Nind 142 East Dome Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

d o. n i nd @ eastd o mefa rms. co. nz

Eaton Willow Lodge Brent Eaton 94 Balfour Ardlussa Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

Eaton Willow Lodge Derek Eaton 94 Balfour Ardlussa Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

Eaton Willow Lodge Pauland Elaine

Eaton94 Balfour Ardlussa Road

RD1

[email protected]. nz

Address list of submitters on t}re proposed Southland Water and Land Plan26

Page 47: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I r i l i,_ l___ t i .-_l ' __ : I,t il

Balfour 9779

EDIE Partnership Dean Blair-Eade 567 OhaiClifden Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

deanoedie@va hoo.co. nz

ELDER Hamish PO Box 73

Mossburn 9747

[email protected]

ELS Luren 1018 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore9776

No email

Elya Holdings Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 576

lnvercargill 9840

sha u n @fo rtu nasro u p. net. nz

Enfield Ltd Lynn Wi[s 256 McRorie Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

ENGLISH Hamish 160 Break Neck Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

[email protected]

Environment Southland Vin Smith Private Bag 90116

lnvercargill 9840

[email protected]

Erne HillLtd lan Smith 93 Jacks Hill Road

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

[email protected]

Ernslaw One Ltd Peter Weir PO Box 35 [email protected]

Address list of submitters on t}le proposed Southland Water and Land Plan27

Page 48: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I i--li--l,-l'--lL-.-1,---. I -t i--l -- r .-- ii___

Tapanui 9542

ESLER Lloyd 15 Mahuri Rod

RD9

lnvercargill 9879

[email protected]

Euan Crump Farming Co Ltd Euan Crump 1408 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected]

EVANS Blair 562 Collinson Road

RD5

lnvercargill 9876

bla i ra nd ra che I @xtra.co. n z

EVANS Frederick & BROCKMAN

Carla

479 Waikawa Curio Bay Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

onwa rdfonra rd @va hoo.com

EVANS Harold 153 Pourakino Valley Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

No email

EVANSOR&TD Owen Evans 575 Biggar Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

Eyre Creek Ltd Steve Wilkins PO Box 4

Athol 9749

steve @wilkinsfarmine.co.nz

F D Enterprises Ltd Simon Anderson 171 Ruahine Road

RD1

fdenterorisesltd @ema il.com

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plao28

Page 49: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I II l

Riverton 9881

Fairlight Station Ltd Simon Wright PO Box 20

Garston 9750

simon@fa irliqht.co. nz

Fairmount Perendale Stud Farm KS & SF Harvey 152 Beaumont Station Road

RD1

Otautau 9589

sa ndkharvev@ hotma il.co. nz

Fairview Eastern Bush Ltd Tim Blair-Edie 131 Begley Road

RD2

Otautau 9582

timedie58@ hotma il.com

Fallow Valley Ltd Hamish Thomson 774 Kakapo Road

RD2

Te Anau 9572

fa llowva I [email protected]

FarmRight Ltd Shaun Davis Private Bag 201

Lumsden 9742

sdavis@fa rm rieht.co.nz

Fenham Downs Ltd Tyson & ChristinaJamieson

1424 Otautau Tuatapere Road

Merrivale

RD2

Otautau 9682

christina.Wson @netspeed.net.nz

Fermoy Holsteins Ltd Stewart & Julia

Eden

33 McDonald Road

RD6

Gore9776

stewiu [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod Plan29

Page 50: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ll

Fernview Family Trust Steven Kennedy 13588 Dipton-Winton Highway

RD2

Winton 9782

[email protected]

Flaxwood South Kent & Denise

Pease

227 Josephville St Patricks Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

fl [email protected]

FLECKWS&KM Wayne Fleck OtaitaiBush

RD3

Riverton 9883

grassvfl [email protected]

FLETT AIan Hillcrest

Fairfax

RD3

otautau 9683

No email

FLETT Robert 48 Lower Scotts Gap Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

[email protected]

FORDYCE Gary 53 Elizabeth Street

Gore977t

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southlaod Water aad I-and Plan30

Page 51: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

,l I | -i --'

Fonrvard Holdings Ltd William &JulieSmellie

549 Omaui Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

No email

Four Legged Farming Ltd Christopher Giles 78 Waimumu Road

RD4

Gore 9774

4legsedfa rms@ema il.com

Foveaux lnvestments (2008) Ltd Craig Williams 380 Waituna Lagoon Road

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

craie.heidi@fa rmside.co.nz

Foveaux lnvestments Ltd Gary Townshend 4938 Orchard East Road

RD1

Ngatea 3597

ga Mownshend @xtra.co.nz

FRASER Alan 123 Fraser Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

FRASER Doug 624 Gropers Bush Thornbury Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

Frew Farming Ltd Dan Frew 738 OtapiriGorge Road

RD2

Winton 9782

fa rmerda [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water dnd Land Plan 3l

Page 52: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

rl t -1 I l-- I r- -, --. :- I I i- I l . l- I .--

FREW Mervyn 247 Otapiri Gorge Road

RD2

Winton 9782

ma nd mfrew@fa rmside.co. nz

G A Young & Co Ltd Geoffrey Young Cattle Flat Station

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

G J Gardner Simon Culhane PO Box 5180

lnvercargill 98t10

[email protected]

GS&MACleanraterLtd HaydenCleanrvater

582 Davidson Road

RD4

Gore9774

havde nclea mrate r@ hotma il. co m

GAMBLESW&JM 29l Waterhouse Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

stevehelioa [email protected]

Gardyne Agriculture Ltd Duncan Gardyne 999 Waikaka Road

RD3

Gore9773

ga [email protected]

Gardyne Agriculture Ltd Aaron (Fred)

Gardyne999 Waikaka Road

RD3

Gore9773

sa rdvne b rothe rs @ema i l. com

GARDYNEGW&ELTTust&CKGardyne Ltd

Graeme Gardyne 758 East Chatton Road

RD3

Gore9773

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan32

Page 53: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l--- l--.r i i I ,i liiL I

GARDYNE Hugh & Kathie 213 Gardyne Road

RD5

Gore 9775

[email protected]. nz

GARDYNE Joanne 113 North Chatton Road

RD3

Gore9773

[email protected]

GARDYNE John 113 North Chatton Road

RD3

Gore9773

ieardvnefa m [email protected]

GARDYNE Jonathan 29 North Chatton Road

Gore9773

[email protected]

GARDYNE Lois 999 Waikaka Road

RD3

Gore9773

No email

GARDYNE NeiI 438 Otama Hill Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Garfield Farm Ltd Lindsay Gardyne 1345 Waikaka Road

RD3

Gore 9773

lindsavqa rdvne @va hoo.co. nz

Gavenwood Farm Peter McDonald 50 McLeod Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

teammcdona ld @fa rmside.co.nz

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan33

Page 54: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

- l :__l I lll i- _-_-lirl-li

GERRARD LJ &J A Lindsay & JudithGerrard

46 Smith Rod

RD3

Winton 9783

No email

GIBSON Alister Riversdale

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

GIBSON-SMITH G A 384 Winton Lorneville Highway

RD1

Winton 9781

[email protected]

GILKISON Nigel 544A Mossburn Lumsden Hwy

Castlerock

RD2

Lumsden 9792

[email protected]

GILL Aaron 97 BellRoad

RD2

Winton 9782

[email protected]

399 Lora Gorge Road

RD2

Winton 9782

GILL Greg & Liz [email protected]

482 Freshford Plains Station Road

RD7

Gore9777

GILLESPIE David No email

GlLLESPIE Maria 847 Old Dunedin Road marie.eillesoie@emai!.com

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 34

Page 55: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I i iiL )L

RD3

Wyndham 9893

Gladvale Farms Ltd Geoff Lindsay Gladvale Farms

381 Boundary Road

Drummond

RD3

Otautau 9583

seoff @qladvalefr rms.co.nz

Glen Echo Station Partnership Stephen Brown PO Box 844

lnvercargill 9840

steohen.brown @ mco.co.nz

Glenaffric Partnership Mark Heslip 387 Ben Callum Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

elenaffric@ netspeed.net. nz

Glenaray Station (W Pinckney Ltd) David Pinckney Shands Road

RD6

Christchurch 7676

[email protected]

Glenarlea Farms Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha u n @fo rtunasro u p. net. nz

Glendhu Dairies Ltd Jason & Ronald

Duff499 Crooked Road

RD6

Gore9776

gle nd h uda i [email protected]. nz

Shaun Neeley PO Box 675

lnvercargill 9840

Gleneden Dairies Ltd sha u n @fo rtu n apro u p. net. nz

Glenlapa Station Charles Smaill 594 Glenlapa Road cesma [email protected]. nz

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 35

Page 56: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I.l.l.lI, ll i-lli-li lil

RD7

Gore9777

Glenshe Trust Trevor Stark 530 Landslip Valley Rod

RD1

Gore977t

[email protected]

Glentui Farms Ltd Howard Boyd 15 Dunrobin Valley Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

[email protected]

GLOVER A F & C M Family Trust Alexander Glover 7O Marairua Road

RD4

Gore9774

No email

GLYNN Chris & Dawn 2254 Ohai Clifde n H ighway

RD2

otautau 9682

[email protected]

GRANTJJ &J L Jeff Grant 64 Pahiwi Balfour Road

RD6

Gore9776

ieff.iulia@$ra.co.nz

GRANT Robert Alexander 759 Otapiri Mandeville Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Greenbush Farms Ltd Scott McKenzie 298 Fortrose Otara Road

RD5

Invercargill 9875

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed South-land Water and Laod Plan 36

Page 57: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i l--, t i r r. -t

. r -i --- i I r I i- i- ; i-] --f

Greenvale Station Ltd Murray Pike PO Box 42

Garston 9750

greenvalestation @xtra.co.nz

GREER Robin 65l Wyndham Road

RD4

Gore9774

robin @ retroorsa nics.co. nz

GRIMM Hamish PO Box 67

Riversdale 9744

gwenma @fa rmside.co.nz

Growplan Ltd NigelCowburn PO Box 337

Dunedin Metro

Dunedin 9054

[email protected]

GUNN Graeme 589 Gillespie Road

RD1

Te Anau 9579

[email protected]

GUNN Olivia 42 Brooklands Road

RD3

Winton 9783

greenstone@ netspeed.net. nz

Gunton Farms Ltd Mark Gunton 56 Piano Flat Road

RD1

Waikaia 9778

[email protected]

Gunton Farms Ltd Jeremy Gunton 55 Argyle Road

RD1

Waikaia 9778

gu ntonfa [email protected]

Halder Oreti Graeme Halder 402 Spar Bush Winton Road va lleyfi eld [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laad Plan37

Page 58: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

il_ ,. i___, _.- i_ _ I . _l _l i i i , _ I . i l

RD3

Winton 9783

HallAg Ltd Glenda Hall 437 Turnbull Road

RD5

Gore 9775

elendaeardvne@hotma il.com

HallAg Ltd John Hall 437 Turnbull Road

RD5

Gore 9775

[email protected]

HAMILTON N J & R H & ManapouriStation

Ralph Hamilton 5 Murray Road

RD1

Winton 9781

[email protected]

HAMILTON Nick 1217 Mossburn - Five Rivers Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

nickha m ilton @fa rmside.co.nz

HAMILTON Rosemary Stranger farm

East Winton

RD1

Winton 9781

Ham iltonfa rms202 @cma il.com

HAMMOND Emma & Peter 145 Campbell Road

RD3

Winton 9783

me rrvfi e ldfa rm @xtra.co. nz

Hardwick Farm Harvey Perkins 330 Galt Road

Tuturau

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan38

Page 59: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l r i--: l-------r---,---- _l -- i - i --l i- -, r - r

I

RD4

Gore9774

HARPUR George Sl Orawia Road

Tuatapere 9620

[email protected]

HARRIS David 30 Baxter Street

lnvercargill 9810

[email protected]. nz

HASTIE Stephen 33 Bryant Road

Mt Wendon Station

RD3

Gore9773

stepha niehastie@va hoo.co.nz

Hazeldean Downs Ltd Gillian Watson 11 Riverbank Road

RD2

Wanaka 9382

No email

HBG AgriLimited Hadleigh &Jolene Germann

647 Otautau Nightcaps Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

Hedgehope Grazing Ltd Simon &MoniqueTopham

1021 Rakahouka Hedgehope Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

[email protected]. nz

HEENANMDandDW Denis Heenan 188 Hillas Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

denis@ ma hoefarms.co. nz

HEGANMJ&JM 1522 Blackmount Redcliff Road mikeheean @fa rmside.co.nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan39

Page 60: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I I i- I L_:_ \__ . =, - , I

-_l L- i,____ l_ t __i ._-- _ _ i____r l___ _-

RD1

Te Anau 9679

HEISS Raphael 557 Avondale Road

RD3

Winton 9783

[email protected]

HENDERSON Chris (Mrs) 59 Walker Road

Lumsden 9794

he nde rso n.fa rm @ gma il.com

HENDERSON Michael 2138 Seaward Downs Gorege Road

RD3

Wyndham 9893

[email protected]

HENDERSON Stephen 167 Colyer Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

Steve [email protected]

HENDERSON Tracy 167 Colyer Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

steve [email protected]

HICKMAN J J & T A Family Trust John Hickman 112 Drummond OretiRoad

RD3

Winton 9783

[email protected]

High Country Farms Ltd Andrew Gunton 64 Newcastle Street

Riversdale 9776

[email protected]

Hillview Trust Peter & YvonnePhiskie

160 Hills Road

RD1

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water 21d I rnd plal40

Page 61: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

1i ii !l ir l I

lnvercargill 9871

HODGE Lynda PO Box 26

Balfour 9746

No email

HODGE Murray PO Box 25

Balfour 9746

No email

HODSELL Sam 45 McEwing Road

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

[email protected]

HOLDER Wendy & Tom 83 Young Road

RD4

Invercargill 9874

newriverfa rm @ hotma i l. com

HOPCROFT Bevan & Wendy 486 Main Wendonside Road

RD7

Gore9777

b.w.hoocroft @ema il.com

Hopcroft Farms Ltd Simon Hopcroft 605 Riverton Otautau Road

Gummies Bush

RD3

Riverton 9883

ia [email protected]. nz

HORRELL Andrew Russell 84 Hazlett Road West

Thornbury

RD3

Otautau 9683

arhorrell @slingshot.co.nz

HORRELLPJ&JM Peter Horrell 920 Clifden Highway [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutbland Water and Land Plan 4t

Page 62: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I: i--i 1..-

I _)

RD1

Tuatapere 9691

HOWEMA&BJ Murray Howe 101South Wyndham School Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

howef -a m ifu @ netsoeed. net. nz

HOWE PeterJames 318 MitchellRoad

RD1

Wyndham9891

[email protected]

HSV Dairy Ltd Simon Vallely 86 Charlton Siding Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

HUDSONOF&SM 8l HallRoad

RD2

Winton 9782

[email protected]

HUGHES Chrlstopher 7 Black Lane

RD2

Te Anau 9672

[email protected]

Hughes-Crowley Company Ltd Peter Hughes &Maree Crowley

557 CarmichaelRoad

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laad Plan42

Page 63: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

j

HUMPHRIES Marie 173 Lowther Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

[email protected]

HUMPHRIES Trevor & Karen 1238 Mossburn Five Rivers Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

Ka re na ndtrevor9 @gma il.com

HUNT Alistair & Bernadette 79 Okapua Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

Huntly Farm Partnership Clarke Horrell 1887 Riversdale Waikaia Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

HUTTON Sue 215 Leonard Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected]

HYLAND Maureen 7 Preston Street

Gore 9710

[email protected]

lron Bridge Farms Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha u n @fo rtu n a gro u p. net. nz

IRWIN Doug 2Sl Glencoe Highway No email

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water aod Laod Plan43

Page 64: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l ) I i _, L. i I _)

RD4

Gore9774

IRWIN Robyn 26l Glencoe Highway

RD4

Gore9774

No email

J & K Stone Farming Ltd Jonathon Stone 1032 Pyramid Waiparu Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

J Mclean Farming Ltd John McLean 500 Dryridge Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

mclea ns@ rivernet.co.nz

JR&DMSmithLtd John Smith 248 Plains Station Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

JACK Wallace 144 Evans Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

[email protected]

JAMES S T & K A Family Trust Steve & KerriJames

56 Lakefront Drive

Te Anau 9600

i nfo @ radfordso nthe la ke.co. nz

JANSSEN Mark & Martha 258 Counsell Road

lnvercargill 9875

ianssen [email protected]

JARVIS Ben 799 Kaka point Road

RD1

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod PIan44

Page 65: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

. r L t i ll--_. ._ -l -__ i Il: _-, l_l ___.1 :_ r __ ' ,--,=, - -t .-----i i----i --- -,

Balclutha 9271

Timothy Story 248 Venlaw Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected] Station Ltd

57 Dolamore Park Road

RD7

Gore9777

No emailJOHNSTON Allan & Robina

Jones & Cooper Builders Peter Cooper 21 Lyne Street

Gore 9710

oeter@ ionescoooerbuilders.co. nz

JOYCE Nathan J & Julie L 235 Kee Road

RD3

Gore9773

nathan [email protected]

Kaikaha Farms Ltd Peter Hughes &Maree Crowley

557 Carmichael Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

Deter.ma [email protected]. nz

Kapuka Dairies Ltd Nadine Paterson 314 Miller Road

Kapuka South

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

noaterson [email protected]

Kauana Dairy Ltd & Taffy Ltd Todd Anderson 316 Calder Road

RD2

Winton 9782

[email protected]

KAY Gilbert PO Box 126 [email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water ard Iand Plao 45

Page 66: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

-- I i I

rl i___,r__r i-1,-r,-'-ll-- i.:l '-': -- I I -rrl-l L---l

Riversdale 9744

KEMPTHORNE RobeTt 240 Mavora Lakes Road

RD2

Te Anau 9572

rob.a nna @farmside.co.nz

KENNEDYJohn 93 Drummond Oreti Road

RD3

Winton 9783

[email protected]

KENNEDY Murray 934 Venlaw Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

m uzke n nedv @ xtra.co. nz

KENT Rita 169 Hamilton Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

[email protected]

KING Farming Partnership NigelKing 135 King Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9876

cvninqs5 @fa rmside.co.nz

KING Henry 65 Dean Forest Road

RD1

Tuatapere 9671

[email protected]

KINGSBURY Grant 588 Crawford Road

RD2

Gore9772

sakinesbu [email protected]

Kiwi Dutch Dairies Ltd John van Vliet 197 Longridge Road vliet!)[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plao 46

Page 67: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ii _l li it_ i L

lri

Longridge North

Riversdale 9776

Kiwi Dutch Dairies Ltd Lucy van Vliet PO Box 54

Balfour 9746

[email protected]

KiwiRail Holdings Ltd (KiwiRail) Rebecca Beals PO Box 593

Wellington 6140

rebecca. beals@ kiwirail.co.nz

Kmore Farming Ltd Thomas EdwardKerr

53 Wicks Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Knockinnon Farm Trust RW&DMMcKenzie

267 Longwood Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

[email protected]

KNOWLERJohn & Wendy 1116 Clifden Highway

RD1

Tuatapere 9691

[email protected]

KNOWLER Rohan 1024 Clifden Highway

RD1

Tuatapere 9691

rknowler@fa rmside.co. nz

Kyler Pastorals Braden Kyle 1899 Lorne Dacre Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

[email protected]

Kyler Pastorals Nicole Kyle 1899 Lorne Dacre Road

RD2

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water aad I-and Plao 47

Page 68: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l

lnvercargill 9872

Kynlallan Farming Company Ltd Chris Cairns 8 McBride Road

OtapiriGorge

RD2

Winton 9782

c.o.ca irns@fa rmside.co. nz

LR&SJHammondLtd Sally Hammond 57 Barber Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

lrsihammond @netsoeed.net.nz

Lagore Enterprises Trust 890 Argyle Otahuti Road

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

[email protected]

LAIDLAW Graham 2351 Bluff Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

[email protected]

LAMB Bruce & Gaye 747 Tokanui Niagara Highway

RD1

Tokanui 9884

save.bruce @fa rmside.co.nz

LAMB Greg 499 Wendon Valley Road

RD3

Gore9773

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan48

Page 69: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

_.- .: l r -- '- l | -- l i -l

! --l t--.t i- --.1r--l

ll

Lankirk Trust Robert Allan Charlton

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

Lawrence Farms Ltd Gavin Lawrence 898 Riversdale Waikaia Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Lawrence Farms Ltd Charles Lawrence 898 Riversdale Waikaia Road

BD7

Gore 9745

[email protected]

LEGG Rob & Nessa 1937 Clifden Blackmount Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

No email

LEITZE Janet & David 672Mt Hamilton Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

No email

LINDSAY Chris 385 Feldwick Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

No email

LINDSAYJiII 39 Lindsay Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

No emailgiven

Ad&ess list of submitters oo the proposed Southland Water and Iand Plan49

Page 70: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I

LINDSAY Ray 39 Lindsay Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

No emailgiven

LITTLE Robert Edsall 147 Pasture Street

Lumsden

9730

[email protected]

36 Clifden Highway

Tuatapere 9620

LIfiLE Trevor No email

John Titter 456 Josephville-St Patricks Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

Lochhead Holdings Ltd [email protected]

Mark Townshend C/- Townshend Office

4938 Orchard East Road

RD1

Ngatea 3597

[email protected] Properties Ltd

615 Centre Road

Riverton

9883

[email protected] David

Birgit Pemberton 507 Pioneer Highway

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected] Ag Ltd

Lowburn Ag Ltd JonathanPemberton

507 Pioneer Highway

RD4

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 50

Page 71: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lr -l ir il r__i f i-- f i -t -- -i r l ' ---r r --i 1 ,1

Gore9774

Lower Aparima Catchment Group John White 2064 Riverton WallacetownHighway

RD3

Riverton 9883

ioh ncooela ndwhite@ hotma il.com

Ludell Ltd Chris & Sharna

Ludi

236 Walker Road

RD4

Lumsden 9794

[email protected]

M B Dillon Richard & JustineWilliams

1538 Waimea Valley Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

MichaelGardyne 126 Otamita Road

RD3

Gore9773

M Gardyne Ltd m ichael @Ea rdvnes.co. nz

ChristopherHorrell

588 Freshford Plain Station Road

RD7

Gore9777

MKHFarmingLtd m o rea n ka re n horrel I @ema i l.co m

299 Howe Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

No emailMACDONALD Brian

Davaar Station

89 Princhester Road

The Key

Lrmacdona ld @xtra.co. nzMACDONALDJameS

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 5l

Page 72: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l,iili i-l

RD2

Te Anau 9672

MacGregor Motors (Balfour) Ltd AlisterMacGregor

1703 Lumsden Riversdale Highway

RD1

Balfour 9779

macEregorga raqe @xtra.co.nz

MACKAY Alexander PO Box 183

Riversdale 9744

No email

MACKENZIE Toni PO Box 51

Waikaia 9745

[email protected]

MACKINTOSH Alistair 85 Fox Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

mackintoshcla n @ netsoeed. net.nz

MACLEOD NeiI 179 Mill Road

RD4

Gore9774

No email

MACPHERSON Chanelle 1012 Tokanui Haldane road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

[email protected]

MANN AlistairJohn 857 Wendonside Road

RD7

Gore9777

alistairtina @gmail.com

MANN Jeffery 203 Glenlapa Road

Wendonside

m a n n. ieffe rvwi I I ia m @Ema il. co m

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Phn52

Page 73: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

'rl ,---l i-- l i---r i---l rr11 li_ri__1.-ll-lr--rr)

RD7

Gore9777

Mararoa Downs Hayden Slee 104 Mararoa Road

RD2

Te Anau 9672

kateslee.fa rm business@sma il.com

Marlow Farms Gary Marlow 28 Kingsbury Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

MARSHALL Allan & Kathryn 120 Crosbie Road

Waikawa Valley

RD1

Tokanui 9884

slenfern @outlook.co. nz

MARSHALL Logan 57 Berwick Street

Riversdale 9775

No emai!

MARSHALL Lynette 101Kemp Road

RD3

Wyndham 9893

[email protected]

MARSHALL Norman PO Box 94

Riversdale 9477

[email protected]

MARSHALL R C 34 Scott St

Mataura 9712

No email

MARSHALL Spencer 359 Fortification Waikawa Valleyroad

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutlrland \UTater and Land Plan53

Page 74: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

iii-,i-li- -_ir--- _i I__i ,---t l- .l

RD1

Tokanui 9884

Martyn Farming Ltd Dary!Martyn 203 Copland Road

RD4

Gore9774

marWnfarmins@ netsoeed.net.nz

Matai Farms Ltd Bathan Muir 174 Tramway Road East

RD3

Wyndham 9893

batha nm uir@xtra. co. nz

Mataura Butcher Shop Ltd Trevor Newton 19 Frazer Road

RD4

Gore9774

newtons @fa rmside.co. nz

MCCALL Ashley John 183 Cunningham Road

RD1

Gore9771

[email protected]

MCCROSTIE Ray 273 Clearwater Road

RD 11

Mokotua

lnvercargill 9877

ir.mccrostie@gmai!.com

MCDONALD Cameron J 258 Hillside Road

RD1

Te Anau 9679

ca mmc@ paradise.net.nz

MCDONALD Co]in & Dot 206 Pope Road

RD1

mcdona lds@fa rmside.co. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water aad Land Plan 54

Page 75: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

L

i r_l-.1

Tokanui 9884

MCDONALD Stuart & HALDER Robyn 394 Kaiwera Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

MCELLIGOTTJW&TL Tracey McElligott 178 Hedgehope Block Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

ti mcel I iqott@fa rmside. co. nz

MCEWAN Trevor & Anthea 1542 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

ta mcewa n @fa rmside.co. nz

McFarm Trust - Pahia Christine Alty 98 Mclntosh Road

RD3

Otautau 9583

[email protected]

MCINTYRE Craig & Rebecca 752 Donald Road

RD5

Gore9775

mcinWre @fa rmside.co. nz

MCINTYRE Hayden 270 Clinker Hill Road

Wendon Valley

RD3

Gore9773

[email protected]

MCINTYRE Peter Lindsay 225 Mclntyre Road

RD1

Gore977L

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland lWater and Land Plan55

Page 76: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

tl :] lili ill l r_l

MCKAIN Belinda 10 Dacia Street

Lumsden 9730

emoolo@!ive.com

MCKAY Alistair 507 Maher Road

RD7

Gore9777

No email

MCKAY lan &Jodi 1059 Riversdale Waikaia Road

Wendonside

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

McKee Highview Ltd Maybin McKee 146 Pyramid Creek Road

RD7

Gore9777

mabiniocelvn@fa rmside.co. nz

MCKEE M & C Family Partnership Malcolm McKee 8l McDonald Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

MCKEE Rebecca 318 Pyramid Waiparu Road

RD7

Gore9777

m ikmckee@fa rmside.co. nz

MCKEE Scott 364 Freshford Plains Station Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

MCKEE Tyler 8l McDonald Road

RD7

Wlermckee @hotma il.co.nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan56

Page 77: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I

I

iI

! 1

Gore9777

Mckelvie Ltd MatthewMcKelvie

128 Lawrence Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

mckelviematt@qma il.com

MCKENZTE G & T Partnership Grant & TaniaMcKenzie

1652 Argyle-Otah uti Road

lsla Bank

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

[email protected]

MCKENZIE Hayden 76 Taylor Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

farme rmckenzie @sma il.com

MCKENZIE Matthew 50 Queen Street

Balfour 9779

[email protected]

MCKERCHAR Farm Partnership MalcolmMcKerchar

331 Cooper Road

RD1

Winton 9781

mckercha r.foresthill @hotma il.com

MCLEAN Campbell 602 Steffan Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

No email

MCLEAN David 2208 Lumsden-Riversdale Highway

RD6

Gore9776

mclear@ netspeed. net. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed $suthland \f/21er and Lard Plan57

Page 78: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

I I.l L _l i,ii ,__t

MCLEOD Emma 1394 Pyramid Waiparu Road

RD7

Gore9777

Emma field@hotmai!.com

MCMULLEN Leith 288 Longridge Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

MCPHAIL G|en 190 McPhail Road

RD1

Gore9771

[email protected]

MCPHAIL Neil l Aranui Place

Gore 9710

No email

MCPHELZO Trust Craig & MaryPullar

718 Kaiwera Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

MCPHELZO Trust ZN, EJ & PE Pullar 718 Kaiwera Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

MCRAE Daryl& Ruth 225 Whare Range Road

RD2

Gore9772

d [email protected]

MCRAE Joe 2Sl Klondyke Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

ioe.mcrae92 @email.com

Address list of submitters on the proposed SoutNand Water and Land Plan58

Page 79: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

.--l ,-_ __l l__- t__l il --l l----l ili l---r a - ' a--r l-----r :- -.-

rCI Matheson Road

RD2

WVndham 9892

MCRAE Matt [email protected]

40 Matheson Road

Redan

Wyndham 9892

MCRAE Natalie [email protected]

MCRAE Neroli 15 Robertson Court

Cromwell9310

[email protected]

MCRAE Tim & Justine 625 Edendale Seaward DownsRoad

RD3

Wyndham 9893

noodle.mcrae@ hotina il.com

MENLOVE William 299 Five Rivers Lumsden Highway

RD3

Lumsden 9793

[email protected]

MEYER Timothy 2363 Waimea Highway

RD5

Gore 9776

No email

Addrcss list of submitters oo the proposed Southland Water aod T and Plan 59

Page 80: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

t_ r I ir- I l i ---- - i l -, '!--

MIDDLETON Lindsay 395 HallRoad

RD2

Winton 9782

[email protected]

MTLLER N & tJ Family Trust Neil& Linda

Miller315 Clinker Hill Road

RD3

Gore9773

neiland linda @hotmail.com

MILLER,RJ TTust Roger & TraceyMiller

208 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

MILTERRL&SJFarmTrust Robert Miller 225 McBain Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

MILLER Susan 225 McBain Road

Otama

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

MINTYJ R 40 Minty Road

Feldwick

RD2

Otautau 9682

[email protected]

Glen Mitchell 824 Lumsden Dipton Highway No emailMTTCHELLGB&MD

Address list of submitters oa the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 60

Page 81: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

1iI

l

RD4

Lumsden 9784

MITCHELL Keith 388 Oughton Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

MOIR Joseph 747 Ardlussa Cattle Flat Road

RD5

Gore9776

io. moir@fa rmside.co.nz

MOODY Luke 1085 Crawford Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

Basil Paterson Moonlight

RD7

Gore9777

Moonlight Trust basilca [email protected]

50O Waterloo Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

MOORE James [email protected]

Grant Morris 796 Clement Road

RD2

Gore9772

MORRIS G G & R M FamilyTrust [email protected]. nz

MORRIS Lenore PO Box 52

Otautau 9641

Le no re. m i ntv@ema i l.com

MORRIS Peter & Norina 119 Scotts Gap [email protected]. nz

Addrcss list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 6t

Page 82: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

t__ i -r i- l i ii

Fieldwick Road

RD2

Otautau 9582

MOSEBY.Ryan James lll Crawford Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

MOUAT Family Trust Richard Mouat 57 Craig Road

RD4

Gore9774

richa [email protected]

MOUATJameS 104 Bushy Park Road

RD3

Gore 9773

ia [email protected]. nz

MOUAT Laurence 712 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

la [email protected]

Mt Linton Station Ceri Lewis 309 Mount Linton Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

Mt Nicholas Station Kate & Jack Cocks PO Box 225

Queenstown 9348

[email protected]

Mt Peel Ltd Logan & NicoleEvans

957 Otapiri-Mandeville Road

RD7

Gore9777

loga [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southlaod Water and Land Plan62

Page 83: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l ii

MUIR Malcolm 752 Winton Lorneville Highway

RD1

Winton 9781

ma lcol [email protected]

MURRAY Rex 1018 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore9776

No email

NAPPER Mary & FlNDLAYAllan 358 Wether Hill Road

RD1

Otautau 9589

[email protected]

Newton Slink Skins Ltd Trevor Newton 19 Frazer Road

RD4

Gore9774

newto ns@fa rmside.co. n z

NEWTONTW&LM Trevor Newton 19 Frazer Road

RD4

Gore9774

newtons@fa rmside.co. nz

NICHOLSON Peter 484 Knapdale Road

RD3

Gore9773

pete.fee @farmside.co. nz

Nightcaps Contracting Ltd Hamish Wilson 12 Benson Road

Nightcaps 9630

[email protected]

Nithdale Station Andrew Tripp 338 Nithdale Rod [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Sout}Iand rVater and Land Plan63

Page 84: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

RD2

Gore 9772

NokomaiStation Ltd Brian Hore 1242 Nokomai Road

RD3

Lumsden 9793

[email protected]

Noremac Ag Ltd Stuart Cameron 318 Wyndham Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

stua rtcame ro n @xtra.co. nz

Norham Farm Ltd Mark & Leanne

Heaps

764Old Coach Road

RD2

Ferndale

Gore 9772

lea nne.ma [email protected]. nz

North Range Partnership lan Grant 199 Dunrobin Valley Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

a i lesca stl e (@ netspeed. net. nz

NORTON Emily 41 Kingsbury Road

Riversdale 9744

[email protected]

NZ Deer Farmers Association -Southland Branch

Richard Cook 75 Hamilton Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9875

richa [email protected]

NZ Deer Farmers Association -Southland Branch

Graham Murdoch 234Te Tipua School Road

RD4

Gore 9774

era hamandlorna @farmside.co.nz

Address list of submitters on the proposcd Southland Water and Land Plan 64

Page 85: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

NZ Groundspread FertilisersAssociation lnc.

Brent Scully

Address:for Se ice ,:tttttt,ttttt,,,,,,l . 1 1.,,1irr..111

1811 Dipton Winton Highway

RD2

Winton 9782

bre nt@scul lvstra nsoort.co. nz

NZ Transport Agency Luke McSoriley C/- Opus lnternational Consultants

PO Box 547

lnvercargill 9840

[email protected]

O'CONNELL Dennis 1341Winding Creek Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

O'CONNELL Elizabeth 1341Winding Creek Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

O'NEIL Craig & Colleen 178 Wyndham Valley Road

RD2

Wyndham

9892

Colleen.craiq@ rura linzone.net

Onepu Farms Ltd Shaun Neeley PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha un @fo rtu naRroup. net. nz

Opio Milk Ltd Frank vanMiltenburg

60 Sinclair Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

Otara Dairies Ltd Antony Perriam Thomas Road

RD1

Tony.d ia n ne @xtra.co. nz

Address list of submittcrs on thc proposed Southland Water and Land Plan65

Page 86: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l ii il ,] lli

Tokanui 9884

P F Olsen Ltd Kit Richards PO Box-LL27

Rotorua 3040

kit. richards@ PFOlsen.com

P H Bennett Ltd Paul Bennett 162 Terrace Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

Paraemara Ltd Tony Waller 308 Blue Road

Sandstone

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

Parawa Ltd Rosie Hore 531Athol Five Rivers Highway

RD3

Lumsden 9793

[email protected]

PATERSONLJ&SM Laurie Paterson 137 Greenvale School Road

RD5

Gore 9775

oate rson @fa rmside.co. nz

PATERSON Ross 162 Greenvale Road

RD5

Gore 9775

steoha ndross@ hotmail.com

PATERSON Stephanie 152 Greenvale Road

RD5

Gore 9775

steohandross@ hotmail.com

Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutbland rWater and Land PIan 66

Page 87: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ll l1i

li

PATERSON Tony 40 Timbertop Road

RD4

Lumsden 9794

[email protected]

PATTULLO Pauline 1018 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore9776

livestockeenetics@wilkinsfarm ine.co.nz

Peat View Dairies Ltd Shaun Neely PO Box 575

lnvercargill 9840

sha un @fo rtu n asro u o. net. nz

PERKINS Aron Glyn 80 Perkins Road

RD2

Gore9772

aronoerkins@ isonz.co.nz

PETER Hayden Trust Hayden Peter 988 Waimahaka Fortification Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

No email

PGG Wrightsons Roger Collins 118 Robertson Street

Gore 9710

[email protected]

PIKE Jonathan 984 Knapdale Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

PINCKN EY Edward, MACGILLIVRAY

Craig & STIRLING Paul

C/- E Pinckney

364 Beaumont Station Road

RD1

edpincknev@ icloud.com

Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutlrland \U7ater and Land Plan 67

Page 88: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l! -li-rii,i -ri l,-

Otautau 9689

Pinnacle Farming Company Ltd Shane Walker 559 Pinnacle Road

RD5

Gore 9775

oinnacleoad @email.com

PITCHER Brian 41 Aotea Crescent

Gore 9710

[email protected]

Pourakino Catchment Group Luke McSoriley C/- Opus lnternationat ConsultantsLtd

PO Box 647

lnvercargill 9840

lu [email protected]

POYNTZ-ROBERTS David 548 MitchellRoad

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

PREBBLE Lynden 48 Watson Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

[email protected]

PREBBLE SandTa 48 Watson Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

sa nd rajorebble@ema il.com

Premier Dairies Ltd Peter Clinton 151 Pullar Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9876

[email protected]

20 Broughton Street No emailPRICE William

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod Plan 68

Page 89: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ll11 rl-i r11

I i r,

Gore 9710

Progress Valley Farms Ltd BR & SJ Mclean 414 Progress Valley Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

sb m clea n @fa rmside.co. nz

Progressive Engineering SouthlandLtd

Luke McSoriley C/- Opus lnternational ConsultantsLtd

PO Box 647

Invercargill 9840

[email protected]

Puke Rua Dairies Ltd Shaun Neely PO Box 576

!nvercargill 9840

sha u n @fo rtu nagrou o. net. nz

Puke Tahi Dairies Ltd Shaun Neely PO Box 676

lnvercargill 9840

sha un@fortunagrouo. net.nz

PULLARIJ&KM lan Pullar 611 Kaiwera Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

PULLAR Logan Trust Logan Pullar 643 Kakapo Road

RD2

Te Anau 9672

losan [email protected]

PULLAR Mary 718 Kaiwera Road

RD2

Gore9772

ma rv. ou I [email protected]. n z

QUERTIER Stewart & Jan 304 Knapdale Road stewvq @fa rmside.co.nz

Address Iist of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan69

Page 90: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

RD3

Gore 9773

RD&JDStewartLtd John Stewart 820 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected]

RABBIDGE Dean 34 Rabbidge Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

RABBIDGE Stephen 1501 Wyndham Letterbox Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

Rathfriland Ltd James McKee 571 Block Road

RD ].

Waikaia 9778

rathfrila nd ltd (osma il.com

2237 Winton Hedgehope Highway

RD2

lnvercargill98T2

RAUBER Kass No email

Ravensdown Ltd Carmen Taylor C/- Planz Consultants

8 Stafford Street

Dunedin 9016

Rayonier NZ Ltd Chris Fowler Cl- Adderley Head

PO Box 16

Christchurch 8140

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and L,and Plan70

Page 91: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lt_ ii i

RDAgritech Ltd Karen Ladbrook PO Box 1711

lnvercargill 9840

ka renl@ rdaeritech.co.nz

Ribbonwood Farm Neil Sutherland 449 Waltz Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

Rimu Grasslands Ltd & LeicesterDowns Ltd

Clarke McKenzie 1522 Argyle Otahuti Road

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

Clarkefi ona03 @email.com

Riverfield farms Ltd Peter & Paula

TurnerHamilton Burn

RD2

Lumsden 9792

[email protected]. nz

Rivervale Dairies Ltd William Egan 1487 Otautau Wreys Bush Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

ROBB Alfred PO Box 26

Lumsden 9714

ro bbs.fa m [email protected]. nz

ROBB Tony & Jill Family Trust Jasmin Robb 98 Lintley Rod

RD4

Lumsden 9794

[email protected]

ROBERTS Andrew 218 Broughton Street

Gore 9710

[email protected]

ROBERTSON Antony PO Box 868

lnvercargill 9840

tonv@thesenesisgrou p.co. nz

Addrcss list of submitters on the proposed Southland rtrTater and Laod Plao 7t

Page 92: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ll .-I l ! 11

ROBERTSON CoIin 315 McDonald Road

RD7

Gore9777

No emai!

ROBINS SAm 1148 Blackmount-Redcliff Road

RD1

Te Anau 9679

k.s.robi ns@fa rmside.co.nz

ROBINSON Brent 133 Robinson Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

Robinson Dairies Ltd Hamish Robinson 403 Woods Road

Oware

Wyndham 9892

hwrobinson @outlook.co. nz

ROBINSON Jeffrey 133 Robinson Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

robinsonieffl33 @ema il.com

151 Stout Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

ROBINSON Michael [email protected]

196 Old Coach Road

RD2

Gore9772

ROBINSON Samantha sirobinson @outlook.co.nz

Haydn Blatch 559 Ardlussa Cattleflat Road

RD5

Rockytommy Farming Ltd roclMommv@ hotma il.com

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water ard Laod Plan 72

Page 93: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

.! ---] iL

I-l I t-_ -_l

Gore9776

Rokenwai Farming Ltd Kenneth Blatch 1156 Riversdale Waikaia Rod

RD7

Gore9777

ko.blatch @fa rmside.co.nz

RonJStewart&Co Ron Stewart 112A Glenure Hill Road

RD1

Balfour 9079

No email

ROSE David 1210 Oporo Flat Road

Northope

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

[email protected]

Rosebrae Farm Ltd Steven Clarke 506 Pioneer Highway

RD4

Gore9774

lstevenclarke@qma il.com

605 Waddle Road

RD2

Gore9772

RosehillSouth Ltd Peter & NikCurrie

petera nd nik@ema il.com

671 lsland Edendale Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

Roseneath Dairies Kerry & GeorginaCampbell

seorgina conlan@ hotmail.com

13 William Street

Gore9770

shonava I @farmside.co.nzROSS Garry

ROSS Keith 201 Paterson Road No email

Address list of submitters on ttre proposed Southland Water and Laod Plao73

Page 94: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

.._l - L -r i .-- a I -_ r- i L-l ---. a , - r ,-__f i,- lI i-

iL]

RD4

Gore9774

ROSS Warren 1550 Waimumu Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

Rossland Farming Ltd Todd Copland 134 Kaiwera Downs Road

RD2

Gore9772

rossland @vrless.co. nz

ROWE Emma 635 Pyramid Waiparu

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

ROY Bevan PO Box 116

Balfour 9746

[email protected]. nz

ROY Bruce 29 Hazeldale Road

RD1

Clinton 9583

bruce.helen@ rovfamilv.co.nz

ROYJames 741Waimea Valley Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

RUDDENKLAU I & J lan Ruddenklau Fortrose

RD5

lnvercargil! 9875

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters oa the proposed Southland Water and Land Plaa74

Page 95: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Rural Livestock Ltd Craig North 10 Durham Street

PO Box 60

Riversdale 9776

[email protected]

RuralSolutions Ltd Graham Butcher PO Box 14

Gore 9710

[email protected]

RUYGROKNC&N Nicholas Ruygrok 192 Aka Aka Church Road

Aka Aka

Waiuku 2682

[email protected]

RUYGROKNC&N NicolazinaRuygrok

192 Aka Aka Church Road

Aka Aka

Waiuku 2682

[email protected]

Ryan Dairies Ltd Christopher Ryan 434 Bayswater Road

RD3

otautau 9683

ch ris.a ngela. rva n @ live.com

Hamish RyanRyan Farms 2006 Ltd 2130 Dipton Mossburn Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

[email protected]. nz

SALLIS Robin 131Main Street

Wairio

RD1

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed $suthland Wafsr and Land PIan75

Page 96: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lli lr i_ ri.-l

Otautau 9610

Sandy Creek Trust Trevor Brown 418 Round HillWakapatu Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

brownees@fa rmside.co. nz

6 Riversdale Waikaia Road

Riversdale 9775

SANSON Mark [email protected]

John Scandrett PO Box 5003

Waikiwi

Invercargill 9843

Scandrett Rural Ltd sca nd rettru ra I @xtra.co. nz

82 Fleming Road

RD1

tnvercargill 9871

SCHMIDT D No email

Schrader Mains Ltd Hank & Sandra

Schrader514 Rimu Seaward Downs Road

RD1

lnvercargill 9871

Bridset. irvinE@ea !lawavcookallan.co.nz

SCOTTGD&MM Grant Scott 45l Crawford Road

RD2

Gore9772

grant.di.scott@gma il.com

Seaview Trust & Oraka Farms Ltd GraemeMcKenzie

32 Bungalow HillRoad

RD1

Riverton 9881

grae me @ora kafa rms.co. n z

Selbie Farm Partnership John Selby Private Bag2O2

Lumsden 9742

sel bies@netsoeed. net. nz

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan76

Page 97: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i- tt_l L- i.i

SELLWOOD LuKe 989 Freshford Plains Station Road

Wendonside 9777

[email protected]

SHALLARD David & KiM 909 Nine Mile Road

RD6

Gore 9776

[email protected]

SHALLARD Mark & Tania 12 Burgess Road

RD6

Gore9776

ma rka ndta niashallard @xtra.co.nz

SHALIARD Murray & Jo 582 Pyramid Waiparu Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Shallow Croft Ltd Blair & SharonShallard

68 Burgess Road

RD6

Gore9776

bla i ra ndsha ron @xtra.co. nz

Sharp Trust Graham Sharp 907 Waimumu Road

RD4

Gore9774

No email

SHAW Robert Brett 516 Davidson Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

SHEARING Dean tt49 North Makarewa-Grove Bush

Road

RD6

[email protected]

Add:ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and I aod Plan 77

Page 98: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

--l i

l

i

lnvercargill 9875

SHEARING Gordon 1975 Riverton Otautau Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

No email

SHEARING Raymond 182 The Narrows Rd

Waipango

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

SHEARING Euan & Lisa 327 Orepuki Riverton Highway

RD1

Riverton 9881

eua n.shea [email protected]. nz

SHIRLEY Wayne & Gaye 485 Nine Mile Road

Kaweku

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

Paul & Lee

Slattery7 Blue Road

RD5

Gore9776

Slattery Trust oa nd lslatterv@fa rmside.co. nz

Philip Sloan 315 Owen Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

SLOAN PJ &J M Sloan [email protected]

Andrew Wilson &Justine Parker

164 Slope Point Road

RD1

Slope Point Farms Ltd slooeoointfa [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan78

Page 99: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

ll, l I

Tokanui 9884

Charles Smaill 68 Pyramid Creek Road

RD7

Gore9777

c.a. iaccka @slineshot.co.nzSMAILLCF&ASTrust

1130 Dipton Winton Highway

RD2

Winton 9782

sma I levfamilv@clea r.net.nzSMALLEYTimothy

173 Grant Road

RD9

lnvercargill 9879

bisrdms@smai!.comSMITH Barry

122 Mimihau SchoolRoad

RD2

Wyndham 9892

tAmlet@ ruralinzone.netSMITH George & Kathryn

115 Mimihau School Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

[email protected] Hamish & Karen

247 Scotto Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

No emailSMITH Warren

559 Waipahi Highway

RD1

Gore977L

[email protected] William

[email protected] Allan Currie 87 Mataura Wyndham Road

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and I-^.d Plan 79

Page 100: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

_l ,,] tl I---,--|.,--l -r

-l, - - t-i

RD4

Gore9774

SmithillLtd Peter & MargaretSmith

252 Hamilton Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

massie. pete.smith @smail.com

Snowdon Downs Steve & KerriJames and Kane

& Shelley Walsh

324a Sinclair Road

RD1

Te Anau 9679

slia [email protected]

SOMERVILLE John 95 Titiroa Pine Bush Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

io h na nd melsome rville @cma i l.co m

South Coast Dairy Ltd Robert Craig 430 Whangaehu Beach Road

RD 11

Wanganui4581

[email protected]

South lsland Eel lndustryAssociation

BillChisholm Chisholm Associates

67 Selwyn Street

Leeston

Canterbury 7532

[email protected]

Southern Farms NZ Ltd Brendon Phillips 154 Myross Road

RD6

lnvercargill 9875

[email protected]

Southern Farms NZ Ltd Gene Bryce PO Box 93

Kingston 9748

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed SouttrIand Water and Land Plan 80

Page 101: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

;l-l lliii ir.j

Southern Farms NZ Ltd Brendon Duthie 98 Cemetery Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

nickandbrendon @email.com

Joanne & DarrinCrack

Southern Star Farms Ltd Mokotua

RD5

lnvercargill 9875

[email protected]

Karen Duthie 361Bainfield Road

RD1

lnvercargill 9871

Southern View Ltd [email protected]

Southland Conservation Board K Roberts PO Box 743

lnvercargill 9840

[email protected]

Southland District Cou ncil Janan Dunning C/- MWH Global

PO Box 13052

Christchurch 8141

[email protected]

Southland District Council lan Evans PO Box 903

lnvercargill 9840

ia n.eva ns @ so uth la ndd c.eovt. n z

Southland Fish & Game Council Jacob Smyth PO Box 159

lnvercargill 9840

iaco b@south la ndfi shga me.co. nz

Southview Farm Brent Perkins 48 Perkins Road

RD2

Gore9772

[email protected]

Southview Ltd Dean

McNaughton471 Waiarikiki-Mimihau Road

RD2

dea n.iod [email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 8t

Page 102: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

t l :- . l ----l - i L---: i-= ----l --r - l ; -. i-.-i i -l

Wyndham 9892

Mark Townshend C/- Townshend Office

4938 Orchard East Road

RD1

Ngatea 3597

[email protected] Properties Ltd

Katie Robinson C/- AWS Legal

PO Box 1207

lnvercargil! 9840

katie. [email protected] Export Ltd, Kodansha

Tree Farm Ltd & SouthlandPlantation Forest Co. of NZ

Springlands Group Ltd Gavin Tayles 57 Watt Road

Ardlussa

Riversdale 9775

etavles@o utlook.co.nz

St Patricks Farms Ltd David & MelissaBullmore

11 St Patricks Road

RD1

Baltour9779

d m bul lmo re @fa rm side.co. n z

STALKER Hanna & Callum 303 Wbicola Road

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

STANLEY Karen 3/32 Jackson Street

Richmond

lnvercargill9810

ra nd ksta nlev@fa rmside.co.nz

STARK W & S Wayne Stark Benio

RD1

Gore977L

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod Plan 82

Page 103: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

-lrltf

I __l -?

Peter Hughes &Maree Crowley

557 Carmichael Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]!! Farms Ltd

412 Pahiwi Balfour Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected] Brendon

451 Glenure Balfour Road

RD5

Gore9776

nethe rda le @xtra.co. nzSTEVENS David

STEVENSON Audrey 91 MataiStreet

Te Anau 9600

[email protected]

STEVENSONGV&BP GeorgeStevenson

690 Cross Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

[email protected]

STEWART Family Trust David Stewart 1192 Tapanui Raes JunctionHighway

RD2

Tapanui 9587

[email protected]

STEWART Family Trust Trevor & VirginiaStewart

zl48 Wyndham Station Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

tsvrstewa [email protected]

STEWARTGrahame 420 Wyndham Station Road

RD2

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and I-and Plan83

Page 104: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

1l rii!_ itii i

Wyndham 9892

STEWART Ronald 418 Blue Road

RD6

Gore9776

Ssstewsue8l @email.com

STEWART Rory 418 Blue Road

RD6

Gore 9776

sarahthia n@ hotmail.cqm

STEWARTVanessa 1192 Tapanui Raes JunctionHighway

RD2

Tapanui 9587

[email protected]

Stoney Creek Station Ltd 1077 Waimea Highway

RD6

Gore9776

bret@tullochsrou p.co.nz

STRANG Matthew 1049 Wallacetown-RivertonHighway

RD3

Riverton 9883

matt [email protected]

STRATFORD Chris & Lynsey 530 Haldane Curio Bay Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

cmstratford @vahoo.com

Strathallan Farms Ltd RussellJack PO Box 78

winton 9720

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 84

Page 105: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Strathallan Trust Murray Peter 96 Colto Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

No email

Strathfair Farms ChristopherBrown

558 Chewings Road

RD2

Lumsden 9792

brownieT2 @outlook.co.nz

STRINGER Dougal Wendon Valley

RD3

Gore9773

bulls@kowa i-aneus.co.nz

STRINGER Gay 459 Clinker Hill Road

Wendon Valley

RD3

Gore9773

bu lls@ kowai-aneus.co. nz

STRINGER Joe 11 Park St

Gore 9710

[email protected]

Sunnyside Station Richard Greer 357 Sunnyside Station Road

RD2

Otautau 9582

ka n d rs ree r@fa rm side.co. nz

SUTHERLAND Kevin & Ann 247 5 Ohai Clifden H ighway

RD2

Otautau 9682

[email protected]

SUTHERLAND Richard 812 Blackhill Road

RD3

fred iill @vrless.co. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water ad Irod Plafl85

Page 106: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

llL-' r --l

r-iri li

Gore9773

Switze/s Valley Transport Andrew Sharp 29 Main Wendonside

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

SWNEY Garry & Beverley 694 Mill Road North

RD6

lnvercargill 9875

eobiswnev@fa rmside.co.nz

475 Waikawa Valley Road

RD1

Tokanui 9884

TAIT G R & J E & Waikawa ValleyTrust

Joy & GraemeTait

[email protected]

42 Saleyard Road

RD2

Gore9772

No emailTALBOT Jeanette

Lorne Peak Station Ltd

PO Box 19

Garston 9750

[email protected] Matthew

(Lorne Peak Station Ltd)

TAYLER Phillip PO Box 19

Garston 9750

No email

TAYLORCB&SI Colin & Sonya 1263 Mossburn Lumsden Highway

RD2

Lumsden 9792

brucea ndsonva @xtra.co. nz

TAYLOR George 1850 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

ga nd [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southlaod Water and Iand Plao 86

Page 107: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

-l -l : I - i i l I i I L

- ) -- l

Wyndham 9892

TAYLOR Marcy 7A Vogel Street

Gore 9710

m a ror @wil ki nsfa rm i ns.co. nz

TEMPLETON LuKe 15l Templeton Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

TEMPLETON PeteT 124 Otaitai Bush Road

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

TEMPLETON Vaughan OtaitaiBush

RD3

Riverton 9883

vauehan.temoleton @outlook.com

Terrace Farm Trust & Johnrey Trust JonathanFerguson

30 Compton Rod

RD3

Wyndham 9893

[email protected]

The 254 Partnership & GerkenFamily Trust

Mark & JaniceGerken

218 Sandstone Kingston Crossing

Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

The Fertiliser Assoc. of NZ Claire Kelly Boffa Miskell

PO Box 110

Christchurch 8023

[email protected]

The Mahoe Trust Craig Hodsell 45 McEwing Road No email

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan87

Page 108: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

iL- I

tt,il l-- l i = r . I l r i- l "--1, 1 t l --'

RD4

lnvercargill 9874

The Terraces Ltd 1077 Waimea Highway

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]. nz

Three Rivers Catchment Group(rRcG)

Luke McSoriley C/- Opus lnternational Consultants

PO Box 647

lnvercargill 9840

[email protected]. nz

255 Colyer Road

lnvercargill 9877

THYS Herman & STAUTTinneke fa [email protected]

TIDEY AIIan 42 Meadow Street

Lumsden 9730

No email

Tihaka Farms Scott Townshend C/- Eltorito & Associates Ltd

2l River Road

Ngatea 3597

[email protected]

Timothy Farms Ltd Adele Richards 888 OId Balfour Road

RD4

Lumsden 9794

adelerichards@ hotmail.com

Timpany lnvestments Ltd Gary Townshend C/- Townshend Office

4938 Orchard East Road

RD1

Ngatea 3597

[email protected]

TIPPETT Christie 22 Banks Street [email protected]

Addrcss list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plao88

Page 109: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lllr ,11 i --)1---1i--, I ,-. r i 1 -r , --;

Richmond

lnvercargill 9810

Tomogalak Gorge Trust Jeffery Keen 664 Biggar Road

RD6

Gore9776

tommvs@netsDeed. net. nz

Tomogalak Gorge Trust John Keen 63 Meadow Street

Lumsden 9730

No email

Tomogalak Gorge Trust LinziKeen 654 Biggar Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

TOPHAM Jeanette 1021 Rakahouka Hedgehope Road

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

Krazv. [email protected]

TOSH David 372 Riverside School Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

No email

Tremaine Farming Partnership Victoria Tremaine 537 Mandeville Kingston Crossing

Road RD5

Gore 9776

tremainefarm ine@ hotmail.co. nz

VAN ROSSUM Winy 346 Waituna Morton Mains Road

RD1

lnvercargill 9871

[email protected]

195 Main StreetTulloch Farm Glendhu Ltd [email protected]. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 89

Page 110: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

1liri l I f r i.l ,l ,i i-irl

Mataura 9712

Tulloch McNab Transport Ltd 195 Main Street

Mataura 9712

bret@tul lochErou o.co.nz

TURNER Jonny 33 Butler Road

RD6

Gore9775

No email

TURNER Paul& Kayleen 1769 Wreys Bush Mossburn Road

RD1

Otautau 9589

oa uland kavleen @fa rmside.co. nz

Twin Farm Ltd Welsh Family 808 Waimea Valley Road

RD7

Gore9777

snowwelsh @ hotmail.com

twinfa rm @vrless.co.nz

Unity Farm Ltd Jan Verkaik 1560 Hundred Line Road East

RD3

Winton 9783

[email protected]

Upper Aparima Catchment group Paul Turner 1133 Wreys Bush Mossburn Road

RD1

otautau 9689

oaulandkavleen@fa rmside.co.nz

VAN DER BIJL WiIIem 2361 Wreys Bush - MossburnRoad

RD1

Otautau 9689

[email protected]

VAN GOOL Raewyn 90 Smiths Way [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 90

Page 111: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

l I r1 1jL L '--^, I r

itl

RD3

Cromwell9383

902A Avondale Road

RD3

Winton 9783

[email protected] ROOIJEN Marcel

346 Waituna Morton Mains Road

RD1

Morton Mains

Invercargill 9871

winwa n rossum @email.com

[email protected]

VAN ROSSUM Winy & Maarten

580 Main Wendonside Road

RD7

Gore9777

VAN ZYL Hendrik

580 Main Wendonside Road

RD7

Gore9777

VAN ZYL Michelle

David Story 267 Venlaw Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

d i-davesto rv@fa rmside. co. nzVenlaw Ltd

Lindsay & LoraleeClarke

725 Feldwick Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

lusser.lou @xtra.co.nzW&BClarke&SonLtd

Mark Townshend C/- Townshend Office

4938 Orchard East Road

[email protected] Holdings Ltd

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southlaod Water aod Lafld Plan 9l

Page 112: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

rl-li ll

RD1

Ngatea 3597

Waikaia Plains Ltd Andrew Bowmar 375 Plains Station Road

RD6

Gore9776

[email protected]

Waitea Dairies Ltd Hamish de Pass &DarrellDuncan

1147 Glendhu Road

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

WALLACE Bruce & Maree 307 Okapua Road

RD3

Gore 9773

bmwa ! lace @vrless.co. nz

WALSH Brian 1000 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

No email

WALSH Kerri 1000 Wyndham Mokoreta Road

RD2

Wyndham 9892

No email

WARD Patrick 1581Te Anau Manapouri Highway

RD1

Te Anau 9679

[email protected]

WARNOCK Barry 53 Mokotua Road

RD 11

Invercargill 9877

bswa [email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Sout}laf,d Water and Land Plan 92

Page 113: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

Ll

1

54 McMillan Road

RD5

Gore9775

vic-da rrenl @ hotmail.co.nzWEIR Darren

249 Turnbull Road

RD5

Gore 9775

[email protected] Pauline & Andrew

54 McMillan Road

RD5

Gore 9775

Vic-darren [email protected] Victoria

2014 Waimea Valley Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected] Grant & Bernie

Alan & JanineWells

68 Sim Road

RD 11

lnvercargill 9877

thewellsrdll @smail.comWELIS A R & J R FamilyTrust

BronwynChamberlain

548 Otahu Eastern Bush Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

westra n ge. stn @fa rmside.co. nzWest Range Farms Ltd

DerekChamberlain

548 Otahu Eastern Bush Road

RD2

Otautau 9682

westra nee.stn @farmside.co.nzWest Range Farms Ltd

[email protected] Station MichaelO'Brien 383 Lake MonowaiRoad

Address list of submittets on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 93

Page 114: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

,_ii

RD2

otautau 9682

WHITE FamilyTrust Kenneth White 519 Gladfield Road

RD3

Otautau 9683

whites4 @fa rmsid e.co. nz

WHTTE John (Richard) 31 Rob Roy Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

WHITE John Copeland 2054 Riverton WallacetownHighway

RD3

Riverton 9883

[email protected]

WHITE Malcolm & Pauline 915 Longridge North Road

RD5

Gore9776

[email protected]

Whiterig Dairy Farm Tristan & GraceMercer

300 Whiterig Road

RD3

Gore 9773

whiterieda irvfa rm @xtra.co.nz

WHYTE S G, Linhope Trust, BerryFarm Trust & BERRY Ltd

Lyn Berry 798 Caroline Valley Road

RD1

Dipton 9791

[email protected]

WILKINS Brendan 83 Maher Road

RD7

Brenda n @wilkinsfa rm ine.co. nz

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and l,and Plan 94

Page 115: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

lt trl . . . - l . , i r

Gore9777

860 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore9776

d loff h aqe n @xtra.co. nzWILKINS Donna

1018 Waipounamu Road

RD6

Gore 9776

[email protected] Farming Ltd

226 Maher Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected] Pam

1945 State Highway 94

RD1

Te Anau 9579

[email protected] Murray & Tarn

333 Maher Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected] James

whitecom be@ netspeed. net.nz1349 Waikaia Piano Flat Road

RD1

Waikaia 9778

WILLIAMSON Rodney

[email protected] & VickiMiles

558 Avondale Road

RD3

Winton 9783

Willowbank Farms 2015 Ltd &Avondale Dairies

trent [email protected] Wilson 170 Cross RoadWilriskit Ltd

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 95

Page 116: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

, t t-r a-r I -, l--= , -l - l -

RD2

lnvercargill 9872

WILSON Aaron 170 Glenure Hill Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

slenelebalfou [email protected]

WILSON Douglas 180 Wilson Road

RD5

Gore9776

No email

WILSON Kerry 252 Hishon Road

RD3

Winton 9783

kerrv.sharvnwilson@qma il.com

WILSON Shannon 170 Glenure Hill Road

RD1

Balfour 9779

nutrimeticssouthla nd @ icloud.com

Windyridge (Fleming) Ltd Farm MalcolmMclntosh

Tl Milne Road

RD3

Gore 9773

[email protected]

WINGDR&HM Douglas Wing 1335 Otama Valley Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

WING Darren & Jenny 1198 Otama Valley Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Land Plan 96

Page 117: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

i-l..r i_ r i L__- , -l i _j

WINTER Amy 110 Wilton Street

Windsor

Invercargill 9810

i r [email protected]

WINTER Graham & Robin 589 Pioneer Highway

Brydone

RD4

Gore9774

[email protected]

WOODROW A B & L M Family Trust Allan & Leeann

Woodrow148 Knowsley Park Road

Waikana

RD2

Gore9772

sreen ridses@ve lociWnet.co. nz

Woodslea Downs Farm Ltd Peter Dodds 948 Woodslea Downs Road

RD1

Wyndham 9891

[email protected]

WOOLHOUSEKA&JA Kevin Woolhouse 102 Talbot Road

RD2

Te Anau 9672

[email protected]

WRIGHT David 934 Kakapo Road

RD2

Te Anau 9672

No email

WRIGHT Lindsay Family Trust Lindsay Wright 110 Wendonside Church Road

RD7

Gore9777

[email protected]

Address list of submitters on the proposed Soutlland Water and Land Plan 97

Page 118: BARRISTER - Southland Regional Council26gi9ayo517q9stt81sd... · (Appendix C). (,(. V,M Clare Lenihan Counsel for Appellant 17 May 2018 Date Address for service of Appellant: Jeff

t--r i f--r t, -,r i-- i-'.] i-l L.l l'-l a--l a--l l l i -] rl lj l- I i---l i .-r L-l ---l '*-l

YOUNG A R & R B Partnership Andrew Young 175 Mt Victoria Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

mtvictoria @o utloo k.co. nz

YOUNG A R & R B Partnership Rosanne Young 175 Mt Victoria Road

RD1

Riverton 9881

[email protected]

Ad&ess list of submitters on the proposed Southland Water and Laod Plan 98