Barren VolcanoBarren Volcano---- A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past ......
Transcript of Barren VolcanoBarren Volcano---- A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past ......
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
1
Barren VolcanoBarren VolcanoBarren VolcanoBarren Volcano---- A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past To A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past To A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past To A Pictorial Journey From Recorded Past To Observed Recent Observed Recent Observed Recent Observed Recent PartPartPartPart----IIII
Sanjeev Raghav
Within a week, we set out for another expedition to witness the fury of Barren Within a week, we set out for another expedition to witness the fury of Barren Within a week, we set out for another expedition to witness the fury of Barren Within a week, we set out for another expedition to witness the fury of Barren on 13on 13on 13on 13thththth June, 2005 on ‘INS Teresa’………………. Fortunately, the wind was south June, 2005 on ‘INS Teresa’………………. Fortunately, the wind was south June, 2005 on ‘INS Teresa’………………. Fortunately, the wind was south June, 2005 on ‘INS Teresa’………………. Fortunately, the wind was south wewewewesterly and we could negotiate our track till the base of secondary (parasite) sterly and we could negotiate our track till the base of secondary (parasite) sterly and we could negotiate our track till the base of secondary (parasite) sterly and we could negotiate our track till the base of secondary (parasite) vent on the southvent on the southvent on the southvent on the south----western slope of the main cinder cone to collect the fresh lava western slope of the main cinder cone to collect the fresh lava western slope of the main cinder cone to collect the fresh lava western slope of the main cinder cone to collect the fresh lava samples where temperature of the gas was recorded as high as ~200samples where temperature of the gas was recorded as high as ~200samples where temperature of the gas was recorded as high as ~200samples where temperature of the gas was recorded as high as ~2000000C. Red hot C. Red hot C. Red hot C. Red hot lava was seen peepilava was seen peepilava was seen peepilava was seen peeping through the Devil’s eye. This was my fourth visit to ng through the Devil’s eye. This was my fourth visit to ng through the Devil’s eye. This was my fourth visit to ng through the Devil’s eye. This was my fourth visit to Barren Island since 2001. Barren Island since 2001. Barren Island since 2001. Barren Island since 2001.
16
th February, 2005, I was right on the top of the northern edge of the main cinder cone of the
quiescent Barren Volcano (BV) and watching the gaseous fumes emanating from its south western
periphery. Suddenly a dreadful thought flashed in my mind- If Barren Erupts Now!! That day I had
returned to the base with minor injuries negotiating the steep outer slope of the pyroclastic cinder
cone laden with loose ash, lapilli, and boulders ejected from previous explosions. Barely 100 days
had passed, when I learned from the media on 28th May, 2005 that Barren has erupted again. I was
shaken and my hair stood on its end. Within a week, we set out for another expedition to witness the
fury of Barren on 13th June, 2005 on ‘INS Teresa’. Light shades of gas and vapour column emanating
from the BV was visible from as far as 20 km. As we approached nearer, the fury of BV became more
visible. Periodic eruptions at 2-3 minute interval with the sound of exploding cannon could be heard
from as far as 7 to 8 km. The vent of this eruption was situated on the southern face of the cinder
cone. Possibly this was the same location from which I have seen increased emanation of gas and
vapour on 16th February, 2005. Our team landed on the Barren from the lone landing site on the NW
face and was greeted by light tremors on the island caused by the periodic violent eruptions.
Fortunately, the wind was south westerly and we could negotiate our track till the base of secondary
(parasite) vent on the south-western slope of the main cinder cone to collect the fresh lava samples
where temperature of the gas was recorded as high as ~2000C. Red hot lava was seen peeping through
the Devil’s eye. This was my fourth visit to Barren Island since 2001.
My journey to the Barren Volcano started from 18th
April, 2001, when I first stepped on
the Barren Island (being part of a multi-disciplinary scientific team of Geological Survey of India)
to study the Barren Volcano. Since then, I have visited Barren Island several times for various
scientific expeditions by GSI with the latest encounter being on 6th January, 2011 and have witnessed
its transformation from a sleeping giant to a roaring and fuming demon. So, when I received a request
for a popular article on geology for the e-journal of the Society of Earth Sciences, immediately I
thought of sharing my decade old association with Barren Volcano with everyone. In the following
chapters, I will take the readers on a pictorial journey of the Barren volcano which is divided into two
parts. Part- I deals with various heads like, location and approach, Tectonic and geomorphic set up,
Pre-historic and historical records of volcanic history of BI. Part– II deals with the various expeditions
carried out by the Geological survey of India during the eruptive 1991-1995 phase, quiescent 1996 to
February 2005 phase and the latest but most active phase from May 2005 to 2011, which has
superimposed all the earlier morphology of this lone active volcanic island of India.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
2
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig.1a,1b,1c: Quiescent Barren Volcano (BV) in the Andaman Sea: Observed on 18th
April
2001 (Top), Resurgent BV on 13th
June 2005 (Middle) and 11th
March 2006 BV (Lower)
with massive lava flow meeting the sea and superimposing all the previous deposits on the
western side.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
3
Fig.2: An aerial view of the top of the main cider cone probably taken in 2004 showing
remains of 1991 and 1994 - 95 vent. This was exactly the shape of the top of the cinder cone
which the author observed when he climbed atop in February, 2005. Brown arrow shows the
path of ascend from northern side and mark 2005 shows the location where he climbed on
16th
February, 2005. Note the dangerously steep slope of the cone top laden with white pasty
material which was overlying the loose pyroclastic cone and ground temperature was warmer
than air temperature of ~350C.
Fig. 3a & 3b: Author (standing on the left) at the top of main cinder cone of Barren Volcano
on 16th
February, 2005. (A: Inner slope of the 1994 - 1995 cinder cone; B: Outer slope of the
cinder cone; C: Inner side of southern prehistoric caldera wall; D: 1994 - 1995 eruption lava
flow towards the western valley, E: Inner slope of northern wall of prehistoric volcanics
covered by thick ash flow from successive historical eruptions till February, 2005. Photo on
the right, taken from the top of the cone, showing tracking path from the northern slope.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
4
Introducing Barren Volcano
How to approach Barren Volcano: Barren Island (Fig.4) can be approached through special tourist
cruises arranged by Andaman administration but tourists are not allowed to set their foot on the island.
Indian Navy and Coast Guard ships deployed for safeguarding the islands and Indian waters regularly
ferry around this island. A third category of visitors on these islands are geoscientists who visit these
islands occasionally for various scientific expeditions either on the Navy and Coast Guard ships or
with the help of institutional research vessels like R. V. Samudra Manthan (RVSM) of Geological
Survey of India. Some tour operators also provide fishing opportunity around the BI on small boats;
however, they can’t land on the BI. Hence, apart from scientists, administration and navy personnel,
Barren Island are not approachable by common man or tourists because of cost factor and
administrative restrictions due to security reasons.
Fig. 4: Location of Barren Island in the Andaman Sea. BI image not to the scale.
Location and Tectonic set up of Barren Volcano: Barren Island (12° 17’ N : 93° 51’ 30” E) is
located in the Andaman Sea within the exclusive economic zone (EEZ) of India as one of the most
easterly of the Andaman group of Islands. It is situated 135 Km north east of Port Blair (capital of the
Indian Union Territory of Andaman and Nicobar Islands). This volcanic island is the lone confirmed
active volcano of the Indian sub-continent on one of the most mobile zones of earth. Geologically,
this volcanic island stands in the midst of a volcanic belt on the edge of the Indian and Burmese
tectonic plates. Narcondum Island is another aerially exposed extinct volcano on the northern
extension of this volcanic belt, besides many under-water volcanoes like Alcock and Sewell sea
mounds in the Andaman Sea. Tectonically, Barren Island (BI) is a subduction - related volcanic island
lying in the Andaman Sea (north-eastern Indian Ocean). The Barren Island volcano represents an unit
of Indo-Indonesian volcanic chain, the origin of which is believed to be due to the east and north-
eastward oblique subduction of Indian ocean lithosphere below SE Asian plate with an easterly
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
5
dipping Benioff zone in the Burma–Java subduction complex (Fig.5). This Miocene-Recent volcanic
arc developed due to this subduction extends from the presently active volcano in Indonesia through
BI and Narcondam volcano in the Andaman sea to the late Tertiary extinct volcanoes of Myanmar
(Haldar and Luhr, 2003). The Andaman-Java Benioff zone dips eastward down to a depth of about
180 km below the Andaman Arc. Analysis of teleseismic data in this region suggest that an
intermediate seismic gap exists between depth range of 90 and 110 km in this Benioff zone. This
seismic gap is interpreted to indicate the partial melting zone. An east dipping benioff zone exists
below the BI (Dasgupta and Mukhopadhyaa, 1997). Deep crustal tectonism which is presently very
active in the region might have manifested itself in the form of BI volcanism.
Fig.5: Location and tectonic set up of Barren volcanic island with respect to convergence
boundary (white line) between Indian Plate and the Eurasian Plate. Labeled volcanoes are
Barren Island, Narcondam (N), Popa (P) and the Singu Plateau (SP) in the Myanmar. Other
abbreviations are the Burma Sub-Plate (BP) of the Eurasian Plate, Irrawaddy Delta (ID),
Andaman Island (AI), Grand Nicobar Island (GNI), Andaman Ridge (AR), Ninety East Ridge
(NER). The location of the 26 December 2004 Sumatran earthquake (Mw 9.3) is marked by a
white dot. The large white arrow shows the NNE relative-motion vector of ~60mm/yr for the
Indian Plate and the Eurasian Plate west of Sumatra. White triangles denote active volcanoes
along Indonesia-Sumatra subduction zone. (Image Source: Luhr and Haldar, 2006)
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
6
Barren Volcano with respect to other volcanoes on Earth: Presently there are about 500 active
volcanoes distributed over the surface of the earth of which about 50 show submarine eruptions.
Seventy-five percent of these lie on the ring of fire - a band running around the periphery of the
Pacific Ocean, along the coast of North and South America and down to the coast of Asia through
Kamchatka, Japan up to New Zealand. Another twenty five percent is located in southeast Asia,
mostly in the Philippines, Indonesia and Papua-New Guinea including the Barren Island volcano in
the Andaman Sea (Fig.6).
Fig. 6: Map showing the geographical location of the major active volcanoes on the Earth
with location of the Barren Island (BI) volcano and ‘Ring of Fire’ .
Flora and Fauna on the Barren Island: True to its name, it is a barren area uninhabited by humans,
though it has a small population of feral goats (Fig.7a). These animals were left in 1891 by the station
steamer from Port Blair (Kloss, 1902) and they are so free from fear and unsuspecting that when we
land on Barren Island, they stare at us as if we have come from another planet. Other mammals, apart
from goats, were variety of rats with range of colours, resembling various shades of volcanic dust and
lava flow, from brown to black. Amongst birds, Indian cuckoo (Koel), parrots and fruit bats are
common. Sea creatures like crabs are found roaming on the small beaches and rocky outcrops meeting
the sea water. Outer and inner slopes of the caldera wall are full of lush green vegetation with tall
trees and shrubs which are regularly destroyed during successive eruptions and thick ash fall (Fig.7b)
Geomorphology of Barren Island: Geologically, Barren volcano can be classified as startovolcano
with pyroclastic cone. All the historical and recent eruptions (1787 and after) are confined within and
around an active polygenetic cinder cone in a 2-km wide caldera that is formed by the collapse of a
primitive cone of a stratovolcano. The remnant of the primitive volcanic cone forms a precipitous
cliff around the island (commonly referred to as caldera wall), with a break towards the west (Fig.8).
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
7
Fig.7a & 7b: Feral goats encountered on Barren Island on 04-01-2011. Thick vegetation on
the outer slope of the northern caldera rim submerged during 2010 lava flow (white arrow).
The highest elevation on the island was that of the southern side of the caldera wall measuring 354
meters. The active cinder cone measured 265m when I climbed atop in 2005. Since then, it is
increasing in height with successive explosion and has reached almost 500m as observed in January,
2011. The island is 3 km in diameter with a total surface area of 10 km² and has a subaerial volume of
only ~1.3 km3.
Most of the primitive volcano is underwater. Rising from a depth of ~2300 m on the
Andaman Sea floor, BI has a submarine volume estimated at ~400 km3. At present, the main cinder
cone of the erupting Barren volcano can only be approached from the western flank of the Barren
Island because all other sides are occupied by thickly vegetated high (> 200m) caldera wall which
gives the conical shape to this island and reaches a maximum elevation of 355 m on its southern
flank. The main cinder cone which was recorded to be ~ 235m in height in 2005 has gained height
post- 2005 eruptions and was estimated to be around ~500m in January, 2011. Lava flows and
pyroclasts fill much of the caldera floor and have reached the sea along the western coast during
eruptions in the 19th century, 20th century and 21st century and also on the northern side during 2010.
The diameter of the base of the volcano on the sea floor is 16-19 km. The slope of the underwater part
of the volcanic mount varies from 1 in 3 to 1 in 23 in different directions. In general, northern and
eastern slope is steeper and smoother as compared to the western and southern slopes. Signatures of
subsidiary cone and under water lava flow have also been recorded on the south-western slope of the
underwater Barren Island mound
Eruption history of Barren Volcano: After the first recorded eruption in 1787, further eruptions
were recorded in 1789, 1795, 1803–04 and 1852. After nearly one and half century of dormancy, the
island had another eruption in 1991 that lasted six months and caused considerable damage. There
were eruptions in 1994–95 and 2005–07, the latter being considered to be linked to the 2004 Indian
Ocean earthquake.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
8
Fig.8: Aerial view from the NW side (left image) of the active Barren volcano and front view
from the west side (right) of the quiescent Barren volcano depicting the geomorphology of
volcanic island. Present main pyroclastic cinder cone is occupying the centre of caldera
formed due to the collapse of prehistoric volcano, exposed aerially during late Pleistocene
(?). The caldera rim is breached on the western side through which lava flow from successive
eruption flows down (black colour) to the water front.
The most recent eruption started in May 2008 and still continues with episodes of increased eruption.
This Pictorial journey, showing various faces of Barren Volcano has been compiled from Kloss,
1902, Ravi Shanker et al. (2001) and references therein like Hobday and Mallet (1885), Ball (1893),
Mallet (1895), Washington (1924), Raina (1987) and Haldar et al. (1992a,b, 1999), Haldar and Luhr
(2003), Luhr and Haldar (2006), Shrivastava (2002), Raghav (2005), Bandyopadhyaya et al. (2006),
Pal et al. (2006, 2010), various reports from the Bulletin of the Global Volcanism Network
(Smithsonian Institution, 1991, 1992, 1993,1995, 2011), various web sites, aerial photographs
courtesy Indian Navy’s Coast Guard station at Port Blair and personal collection of photographs by
the author collected during various expeditions from 2001 to 2011.
Pre-Historic Eruption Records
The present Barren Island came into existence through a submarine volcanic eruption during
Pliocene-Pleistocene (assumed, not exactly dated). A reconstruction of the most of the caldera rim
which has an average slope of 30-350 and a diameter of 3.5 km suggests that the height of the
primitive cone was about 1100 m. It is assumed that some time during late Pleistocene or early
Holocene (?), upper part of this volcanic cone was blown off by some high intensity paroxysmal
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
9
eruption leaving behind a big relict cauldron (Shankar et al., 2001). This submarine eruption produced
major landform of Barren Volcano with an estimated submarine volume of 390 sq km and the sub
aerial volume of 1.3 sq km (Luhr and Haldar, 2006). The culmination of this eruption was marked by
a sub-aerial eruption producing a caldera (Fig.8) 2km diameter in the central part (Shanker et al.,
2001). The interstratified beds of the pyroclastics of basaltic to andesitic composition are now
preserved as the caldera wall. Agglomerate, massive beds, current bedding, graded bedding and
penecontemporaneous structures from this bedded sequence suggest that the bedded sequence was the
product of subaqueous pyroclastic flow deposit. These deposits have recently also been described as
the products of waves, pyroclastic fall and surge deposits (Sheth et al., 2009).
Fig.9: Pre–historic volcanics (pyroclastic and lava flow) exposed on the NW side of the
caldera wall is gently dipping towards NE. The lone landing site from historic time till 2005
is seen on the NW corner of the image. Lava flow during historical times (?) is seen exposed
directly against the sea water along the entire western face of the breached caldera wall. The
1991-1995 flow (dark flow towards the sea but not reaching the water front) and 1995 vent is
also shown. The pre- historic caldera wall is also covered with shrubs and long grass. Semi-
consolidated and southerly dipping pyroclasts (ash + boulders) deposited aerially during the
historic times is unconfirmably overlying the NE dipping Pre-historic caldera rim.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
10
Fig. 10a & 10b: Inter-bedded agglomerate bed, finely laminated tuff and lava flow of
varying thickness and colour suggesting episodic nature of pyroclastic and lava flow
deposited under water and sub - aerial conditions during the Plio-Piestocene (?) evolution of
Barren Volcano, now exposed above water as volcanic island. Left image is from inner side
of southern caldera wall and right image is from the inner side of northern caldera wall. Also
seen is the recent ash flow abutting against the vertical scarp face of the collapsed caldera.
The Pre-historic thick massive lava flow interbedded with agglomeratic flows (Fig. 10a, 10b)
of different thickness ranging from 50 cm to 5 m are result of both Hawaiian type and
Strombolian eruptions in succession. Nine such eruptive pulses were identified by Shankar et
al. (2001) during 1991–1995 expeditions.
Historical Eruption Records
On the basis of tephrochronology, it is suggested that Barren volcano became active during 8010 ±
100 BC. The first historical record indicate that BI erupted on 12th May 1787 with Volcanic
Explosivity Index (VEI) of magnitude ~2 with an explosive eruption
(http://dsc.nrsc.gov.in/DSC/Others/ODEventsTable.jsp#) from the central cone in the middle of the
pre-historic caldera. The historical records of explosive eruption from central vent with an VEI
magnitude of ~ 2 were recorded on 24th March 1789, 20-21
st December 1795 and with eruption and
lava flow from November 1803 – 1804 (Colebrook (1787) give the earliest report of columns of
smoke, gas and steam rising from the crater.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
11
Fig. 11a & 11b: Moderately dipping caldera wall of finely laminated tuff beds (left) and
thick inter-bedded pyroclasts and lava flow (right) suggests underwater/sub aerial deposition
through successive eruption during Pleistocene (?). The very thin to thickly-laminated ash
bed, overlying the pre-historic flow indicate aeolian deposition during historical times which
continues till date.
Fig.12: About 100 m thick section of pyroclasts exposed on the inner side of prehistoric
northern caldera wall.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
12
Fig.13: Pre-historical pyroclastic and lava flow showing guarded bedding and
penecontemporaneous deformation developed due to gravity collapse of ejected pyroclastic
bombs from the explosive cinder cone.
Fig. 14: Pyroclast flow showing cross bedding structure in the pre – historic volcanics
exposed on the inner side of the southern crater wall.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
13
Fig.15: Flow and slump structures of the pre – historic volcanic deposits suggestive of under-
water deposition of pyroclasts and lava flow.
Followed by Capt. Blair (after whom the capital of Andaman and Nicobar Island is named as ‘Port
Blair’) in 1789 and 1795 when he passed near the island and found enormous volumes of smoke
with frequent showers of red-hot stones as big as three to four tons and which had been thrown some
hundred yards past the foot of the cone and also recorded two or three such eruptions while grazing
through the BI. The distant parts of the island were thinly covered with withered shrubs and blasted
trees. A few years letter Horsburgh recorded an explosion every ten minutes and a fire of considerable
extent burning on the eastern side of the crater. Records of eruption have been also recorded by Von
Buch (1825), Capt. Miller (1834).
Hence, it can be safely assumed that the second cycle of eruption was sub-aerial explosive with
Strombolian style during 1787-1832 period. In the central part of the relict cauldron, a cinder cone of
305 m height with a 60m diameter crater was produced. From the crater and vents, initially a huge
amount of blocks, and scoria (cinder and ash) of basaltic composition had been ejected and deposited
as lava debris at initial stage. Subsequently, during the 1803-1832 period, the ‘aa’ basaltic lava was
pouring out from the vents.
Thereafter, for thirty years the volcanic activity seems to have decreased, when only volumes of white
smoke and no flames were seen. Dr. Mount and Dr. Leibig, who visited the island within a few
months of each other in 1857, write respectively of volumes of dark smoke and clouds of hot , watery
vapour. In 1866, a whitish vapour was emitted from several deep fissures (Boscowitz, 1866). Around
1890, steam was seen to be issuing at the top from a sulphur- bed, which was liquid and pasty and a
new jet was coming from a lump on the sloping side of the cone. While recounting all the above
observations in his memoir in 1902, Capt. Kloss mentions that in the 2nd
week of January 1901, when
he landed on the island, the sole evidence of activity observed was deposition of sulphur and escape
of steam which often condensed on the surface rocks.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
14
Fig.16: Alternate bands of pyroclast and lava flow in the pre– historic crater wall with tree
root penetrating through cracks. Section from the inner slope of the southern caldera wall.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
15
Fig.17: Earliest drawing of BI volcano from the west showing the start of the 1787–1832
activity, after Colebrooke (1787). Fig. 1.16 from Shanker et al. (2001).
Fig.18: Capt. Blair’s view of Barren Volcano, 1789 Fig. 1.17 from Shanker et al. (2001). The
ash flow direction suggest that ship observations were taken during summer and rainy
seasons (March to September) when south westerly winds blow over the Andaman Sea.
Kloss (1902) in his memoir further writes that “ a rough wall of lava about a dozen feet high stretches
across the landing site, among the stones and boulders of the shore, was found, below high water
mark, a little stream of fresh water trickling to the sea; it is the only water on the island and at that
time was at a temperature of 97.50F*” (and also mentions with an asterix* from earlier records that the
temperature in 1891 was 103.50F, 1400F in 1873, 158-1630F in 1806 and recounts that Dr. Adam’s in
1831 found that 100 yards from shore water was nearly boiling, the stones and rocks on shore exposed
at low tide were smoking and hissing and the water was boiling all around them. Dr. Mount who
landed on BI in 1857 found ‘a natural boiling spring, the waters so extremely hot that they rendered
the sea in the immediate neighbourhood warm enough to roast crabs in their shells’. All these records
suggest that there was an active phase of volcanism between 1787 to 1857. The explosive activity
stared diminishing after 1860 with pyroclast and lava flow being replaced by an increase in fumerolic
activity till 1890.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
16
Fig.19: Sketch of Barren Volcano, 1886 (Arnold Boscowitz) Fig. 1.19 from Shanker et al.
(2001). The sketch suggest the wind direction was north to south indicating that ship
observations were taken during winter season (November-February) when north easterly
wind blows over the Andaman Sea.
When Capt. Kloss landed on the island in January 1901, he found a cessation in all these activities
and writes “From the landing place (the lone landing site in the NW corner of the island till June 2005
which was destroyed by the 2005-06 eruption) the ground slopes gently upward to the floor of the
crater, which is about 50 feet above sea level (observed by the author till June, 2005). In the centre of
this rises the little cone of slightly truncated form. Symmetrical in outline, 1000 feet high and perhaps
2000 feet in diameter at the base, there is nothing to remind one of more closely than a huge heap of
purplish – black coal – dust, with patches and streaks of brown on the top. To the right and left of the
base , and thence towards the sea, flows a broad black steam of clinker lava, the masses of which it is
composed varying in dimension from rugged block of scoriae a ton or more in weight to pieces the
size of one’s fist”.
While describing vegetation inside the crater, Capt. Kloss (1902), observed that the ground at the base
of the cone widest on the southern side was covered with tall bamboo grass and various kinds of low
bushes. On the inner slope of the crater, the south and east side (which are of rocky formation
composed of pre- historic volcanic), support certain amount of small forest. In 1789, only withered
shrubs and blasted trees were to be seen on parts remote from the cone (Blair); while as late as 1866
there were no trees of any height, but on the slopes and ridges abundance of bushes, some rising 20
feet was found (Report of the Andaman Committee). Thus, records of vegetation also confirms that as
late as 1860, the Barren Volcano witnessed an intensified explosive activity which slowly ceased by
1901 when Capt. Kloss visited the Island.
Not much published data on Barren Volcano is found between 1903 to 1959.
Karunakaran and Raina (1960, Unpublished GSI reports) records that western and northern slopes of
the crater rim was traversed by a number of cracks, an inch to one-foot wide and up to 20-feet long,
through which steam and sulphurous gases were issuing out spasmodically. Inside the crater, steam
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
17
was issuing out from an area of 100 square feet on the slope of the crater, as well as through several
cracks in the floor of the crater. The top section of the cone from the rim down to about 50 feet,
showed thick encrustation of sulphur.
Powde and Raina (1961, Unpublished GSI report) observed super-heated steam and gas oozing out
from the north face of the crater. Ground temperature at the crater varied between 450
C to 850 C
with
deposition of sulphur, plastic clay, gypsum and anhydrite. NE subsidiary vent showed similar
deposition with ground temperature of 650 C. (Author observed no such activity at the base of the
cone but observed issuing of vapour from the southern and eastern periphery of the rim and sulphur
encrustation down to 25 feet on both sides of the cone, when he climbed on the top of the main cinder
cone in 2005).
Fig.20: Fumerolic activity observed on the inner wall of the main cinder cone down to 25m
inside the cone on 16th
February 2005. Northern, eastern and southern sides of both outer and
inner wall of the rim of the pyroclastic cone (at a height of 235m) was covered with white to
light brown coloured pasty material (plastic clay, gypsum and anhydrite ) making the surface
very slippery. White vapour was emanating from NSE of rim with ground temperature higher
than air temp of ~350C. However, no smell was observed suggesting a sulphuric emission as
observed by Powde and Raina (1961).
No records are available about the activity of the volcanoes for another 25 years.
Haldar (1988) paid two visits to the island in April, 1986 and March, 1987 and observed deposition of
sulphur and red plastic clay and emission of superheated steam at the northern part of the crater.
Ground temperature in the western and northern valley-face was comparatively higher than normal.
Interestingly, they observed high population of rats near the landing site.
In 1989, Banerjee et al., while studying the magnetic signatures across the island detected presence
of heated mass at shallow depth with 10 to 12 times higher heat flow as compared to the adjacent
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
18
terrain. The calculated Curie Isotherm surface was located about one km below the sea bed near the
island and did not rule out the resurgence of volcanism.
Haldar et al. (1990) noted continuous emission of super heated steam through cracks at the northern
floor of the crater with deposition of sulphur, Kaolinite and Natroalunite. Ground temperature at the
outer flank of the existing cone and also at the northern valley was abnormally high compared to that
recorded by them during 1986 and 1987 investigations. Surprisingly, they noted the absence of rats at
the landing site which were found to be abundant in April, 1986. Possibly these were the pre-
cursors of a new eruption which was confirmed on 29-30th
March, 1991 when Commander Coast
Guard, Port Bair confirmed that “thick jet of gas spewing off the top of the existing cone” has been
observed by a mercantile ship and also by a team from the Directorate of Light House and Light
Ship, Port Bair ( Shankar et al, 2001).
Thus began the most active phase of Barren Volcano which is well
documented and published. The Recent Eruptive record from 1991 till 2011
will be compiled in Part-II of the Pictorial Journey of Barren Volcano.
Fig.21: Thick column of the Pre-historic caldera wall (PH) exposed on the northern side of
the rim is dipping NE. The pyroclasts deposited during the historical (H) times (1787-1990)
is dipping southerly and lies unconfirmably over the PH. The Recent (R) deposits (1991-
2011) are mainly volcanic ash with some boulders and covers both PH and H increasing the
height of caldera rim. In the foreground is also seen the latest (2010) lava flowing westerly
towards the sea and filling the valley between main cinder cone and caldera rim consisting
PH, H and R.
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
19
Fig.22: Underwater/sub- aerially deposited NE dipping ~ 100 m thick pre-historic pyroclastic
caldera wall (light yellow colour) is unconfirmably overlain by ~20m thick loosely packed
and unasserted southerly sloping pyroclasts (light gray and covered by shrubs) ejected
during historical time (H).
Fig.23: Light gray, thick and loosely consolidated pyroclasts deposited aerially during
historical times is partially covered with shrubs. Recent clinkery lava flow with thinly-
covered ash is seen in the foreground.
Suggested Readings:
Open Access e-Journal
Earth Science India- www.earthscienceindia.info
Popular Issue, IV (III), July, 2011
20
Ball, V., 1893, The volcanoes of Barren and Narcondum islands in the Bay of Bengal, Geol. Mag., P. 289.
Hodbay, J. R. And Mallet, F. R., 1885. The volcanoes of Barren and Narcondum islands in the Bay of Bengal,
Mem. GSI, v..21(4), pp. 252-286.
Karunakaran, C. and Raina, V. K., 1961. Report on the Preliminary investigations of the Barren Island,
Unpublished GSI Report, FS, 1959-60.
Kloss, C. K., 1902. Barren Island and the Archipelago, In Andaman and Nicobar. Unknown Publisher, pp. 9-17.
Luhr, J. F. and Halder, D., 2006, Barren Island Volcano (NE Indian Ocean): Island- arc high-alumina basalts
produced by troctolite contamination. Jour. of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, v.149, pp. 177-
212.
Mallet, P. R., 1895. Some early allusions to Barren island: with a few remarks thereon, Rec. GSI, v. 28(1), pp.
23-34.
Powde, M. B. And raina, V. K., 1962. Investigation for sulphur, in Barren and Narcondum Islands, Unpub. GSI
Report FS 1960-61.
Raina, V. K., 1987. A note on the sulphur occurrences in the volcanoes of Bay of Bengal, Indian Mineral, v.
41(3), pp. 110-125.
Raghav, S., 2005. Barren Erupts Again, Samudrika, v.12, pp. 59-60.
Shankar, R., Haldar, D., Absar, A. Chakraborty, 2001; Pictorial Monograph of the Barren Island Volcano-The
lone active volcano in the Indian Subcontinent. Spl. Publ. No.67, GSI Published by Director General,
GSI, 27, J L N Road, Kolkata-16. (References of earlier records from this book has been quoted in the
text which are otherwise not mentioned here)
http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/NaturalHazards/view.php?id=46047
http://www.indianetzone.com/40/barren_islands.htm
http://www.volcanolive.com/barrenisland.html
http://volcano.oregonstate.edu/barren-island
http://dsc.nrsc.gov.in/DSC/Others/ODEventsTable.jsp#
http://visibleearth.nasa.gov/view_rec.php?id=20825
http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/NaturalHazards/view.php?id=16388
About the author
Mr. Sanjeev Raghav is Senior Geologist, Paleontology Laboratory, Marine Wing, Geological Survey of India,
Kolkata and has participated in over 25 cruises on board coastal and deep sea survey vessel of GSI namely R. V.
Samudra Kaustubh and R. V. Samudra Manthan and has graduated from the youngest participant in 1988 to the
Chief Scientist in 2010. During his 24 years of profession as marine geologist Mr. Raghav has worked in various
spheres of marine studies like near shore and deep sea survey of the Bay of Bengal and Andaman Sea, Placer
mineral investigation along the east coast of India, Construction sand investigation off Andaman group of
Islands, Mud Volcano studies of Andaman Islands and Barren Volcano expedition since 2001. However, his
thrust area had been the foraminifer study of sea bed sediments collected during various cruise. He has co-
authored over 25 articles in national and international journals. He was the editor of Hindi Journal on Marine
Studies “SAMUDRIKA” published by the GSI. He is principal investigator of the projects on “high resolution
late Quaternary climate changes and monsoonal evolution of the Bay of Bengal with the help of palnktonic
forminifera”. Email: [email protected]