Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(...

18
Balancing processes, resolu0on and ensembles in Earth System Models JeanFrançois Lamarque CESM Chief Scien0st Na0onal Center for Atmospheric Research

Transcript of Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(...

Page 1: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Balancing  processes,  resolu0on  and  ensembles  in  Earth  System  Models  

 Jean-­‐François  Lamarque  CESM  Chief  Scien0st  

Na0onal  Center  for  Atmospheric  Research  

Page 2: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

CESM  CMIP5  models  

The  deeper  blue  the  beIer  

IPCC  AR5  Ch.  9  

Page 3: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Components  of  CESM  

3  

Coupler  

Atm.  

Land  

Sea-­‐ice  Ocean  

Land-­‐ice  

Chemistry  (CAM-­‐Chem)  WACCM  

Forcings:  •   Greenhouse  gases  •   Manmade  aerosols  •   Volcanic  erup0ons  •   Solar  variability  •   Land-­‐use  change  

Biogeochemistry  

Biogeochemistry  Wave  model  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque  

Page 4: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Complexity  

Resolu0on  

Resources  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   4  

Page 5: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

ENSEMBLES  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   5  

Page 6: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Internal  variability  and  ensemble  

Slide  from  C.  Deser   MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   6  

Page 7: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Slide  from  C.  Deser   7  MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque  

Internal  variability  and  ensemble  

Page 8: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

PROCESSES  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   8  

Page 9: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Climate  impacts  of  SLCFs  

9  

Summer0me  precipita0on  (mm.day-­‐1)  as  simulated  by  GFDL  CM3,  averaged  over  East  Asia.    The  red  dots  indicate  the  simula0on  in  which  the  RCP4.5  aerosol  emissions  are  kept  at  their  2005  level  throughout  the  21st  century.    Shading  indicates  the  3-­‐member  ensemble  envelope.  From  Levy  et  al.  (JGR,  2013).  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque  

Page 10: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Modeling  SLCFs  in  CMIP3  and  CMIP5  

Emissions  (anthropogenic  &  biomass  burning)  

10  

Shindell  et  al.,  JGR,  2008  

2000  1850   2100  

Emission    Database  

Integrated    Assessment  Models  

Emissions  from  SRES  A1B  scenario  

Lamarque  et  al.,  2010  

RCPs  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque  

Page 11: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

CMIP3  -­‐>  CMIP5:  aerosols  conc.  -­‐>  emissions  

IPCC  AR5,  Ch.  7  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   11  

Page 12: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Kiehl,  2007  

CMIP3  

Forster  et  al.,  2013  -­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐-­‐>  

IPCC  AR5,  Ch.  7  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   12  

CMIP3  -­‐>  CMIP5:  aerosols  conc.  -­‐>  emissions  

Page 13: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

IPCC  AR5  SPM  MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   13  

CMIP3  -­‐>  CMIP5:  aerosols  conc.  -­‐>  emissions  

Page 14: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

ESM

Chemistry

Atmosphere

Land-Ice

Hydrology

Land use & land cover

change

Ecology

Cryosphere

Biogeo- Chemistry Land Ocean

Sea-ice

Using  all  research  communi0es  to  improve  process  representa0on  and  evalua0on:  the  case  of  the  Land  Model    

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   14  

Page 15: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Biogeochemistry  feedbacks  

Arneth  et  al.,  2010  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   15  

Page 16: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

How  do  we  factor  in  evolu0on?  

16  MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque  

Page 17: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Summary  •  Bringing  new  processes  allows  for  a  more  physically/chemically/biologically  observable  Earth  System  Model  (requires  link  to  external  communi0es)  

•  Ensembles  are  a  key  component  to  our  understanding  of  the  Earth  System  and  how  it  might  respond  to  forcing  

•  Significantly  impacts  the  balance  of  resolu0on  with  exis0ng  resources  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   17  

Page 18: Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and( …cpo.noaa.gov/sites/cpo/MAPP/Webinars/2016/01-29-16/Lamar...2016/01/29  · Balancing(processes,(resolu0on(and(ensembles(in(Earth(System(Models((Jean;François(Lamarque(CESMChief(Scien0st

Summary  •  Bringing  new  processes  allows  for  a  more  physically/chemically/biologically  observable  Earth  System  Model  (requires  link  to  external  communi0es)  

•  Ensembles  are  a  key  component  to  our  understanding  of  the  Earth  System  and  how  it  might  respond  to  forcing  

•  Significantly  impacts  the  balance  of  resolu0on  with  exis0ng  resources  

MAPP  Webinar  J.-­‐F.  Lamarque   18  

Bauer  et  al.,  2015