BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro...

40
Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion BacteriO’Clock Create chassis for manufacturing of biomolecular machines that needs to be assembled in precise order

Transcript of BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro...

Page 1: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

BacteriO’Clock

Create chassis for manufacturing of biomolecular machines that needs to

be assembled in precise order

Page 2: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

The Flagella Machinery

Construction based on Multiple Output FFL network motif

E. coli flagella is a highly complex machine

Page 3: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

Page 4: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

1

Page 5: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

Page 6: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 7: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 8: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 9: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 10: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 11: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 12: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 13: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 14: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 15: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 16: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 17: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Multiple Output FFL yields FIFO behaviour

From a complex natural flagella system to a minimal synthetic gene circuit

1

2

3

Page 18: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Coordinate expression of genesin a repeated manner

the BacteriO'Clock

Page 19: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Final Design of Our Network

• Ensure the automatic switching ON and OFF by adding a negative feedback loop

Page 20: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Strain used and constructions built and characterized

-

Arabinose+

Glucose

Testing the Negative Feedback Loop

FlhDC

Page 21: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Testing Feedback Loop and Promoter Strength

Arabinose 0.2% Glucose 1%

As expected mRFP is less expressed in presence of arabinose

pfliL

Page 22: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Dynamical Analysis of the Switch

As expected, the fluorescence drops down !

Bacteria grown in a medium containing glucose are put in presence of Arabinose

pFliL « off » step

Page 23: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

This system should oscillate, wouldn’t it ?

Page 24: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Our Take on Modeling

• The goals of our approach• Obtain qualitative predictions by using experimentally

measured parameters• Help biologists by improving network design

• Principle of our model :• Linear effect & SUM functions for flagellar genes [1]• Using classical Hill functions otherwise• Time rescaling and normalization : reduce number of

unknown parameters

[1] S. KALIR et al. 2005

Page 25: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Optimizing Simplicity

• Do you think that’s too simple?

• Models and parameters extracted from literature

• Using Akaike criteria to discriminate between models

• We have all the information needed to develop simple experimentally-based models!

From literature 8

From normalization 2

Estimation (EnvZ*) 2

Total 12

Page 26: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

What About the FIFO?

FlhDC being the only regulator…

Hey, it’s a LIFO!

Page 27: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

What about the FIFO?

FlhDC and FliA : FFL-based control

Parameters and models from the publications : It worked as a FIFO !

Page 28: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

What About the Oscillations?

• With original parameters

• It does not oscillate(+ solved analytically !)

• Oriented parameter exploration(zoom on the key points)

• Damped oscillations• Three indications for biologists

Page 29: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Improvements with Quorum Sensing

Coupled Oscillators Final System

In addition, using a population model for cells in a chemostat, we show that we win the synchronization !!

Page 30: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

« Virtual Lab »Modeling for Fine Tuning

A modular and predictive model based on systematic parts

characterizations

Proposal of an assay for generic characterization

Page 31: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

A Bottom-Up Approach

Building of a modular and predictive model :

(1) Decomposition of the system

(2) Modeling of each part

(3) Experimental measurements

(4) Implementation in an integrated computationalenvironment

Page 32: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Decomposition of the System

Small and independent modules, treated as «Black Boxes» : outputs= functions of inputs

Page 33: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Modeling of Each Part

Analytical expressions for each black box

Model is a compromise between:

• Level of details considered for molecular reactions (favors predictibility)

• Available experimental data

Complex mathematical development:

• Can be simplified by the black box approach

• Simplification renders the model specific

Page 34: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Experimental Measurements

• Our black boxes =Input: Transcription Factor (TF) concentration

Output: Promoter Activity

construction of a generic plasmid that allows

– Controlling TF concentration with inducible promoters

– Measuring promoter activity with fluorescence

• Measurements in specific conditions for improved predictabilityBut: Bio-Brick Compatible !!

Also adapted to iGEM standards for measurement (SPU)

Page 35: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Integrated Modeling Environment

• Experimental data + Analytical Expressions

Least-square Optimization Program

Estimated Parameters

• Towards a Virtual Lab: Final modular program allowing in silico experiments :

Save time and money!

Page 36: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Parts Realized

Page 37: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Conclusion

• We designed a chassis that can be used to build complex genetically engineered machines

• We tested experimentally that our promoters and the negative feedback loop behaved as predicted

• Thanks to our models we tested and improved our system. In particular, the synchronization at population level was added to maintain the oscillations

• We developed a new standard tool for parallel characterization of complex BioBricks

• Perspectives

Page 38: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion

Perspectives

• Control of injectisome constructionInjectisome is a nanomachine that injects bacterial proteins into eucaryotic cells

Injectisome shares many similarities with flagellar system at gene level

• Optimization of biosynthetic pathwaysExample of an environmentally-friendly plastic: polyhydroxyalkanoate synthesis

sequential expression constitutive expression FIFO expression

competing pathways

PhaA

PhaB

PhaC

competing pathways

PhaA

PhaB

PhaC

competing pathways

PhaA

PhaB

PhaC

low throughput mixture of final and intermediate products high throughput and only final product

Page 39: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Have a look at our poster!

The Paris Team

Contact us: [email protected]

Page 40: BacteriO’Clockmichel/Documents/igem_08_Paris_presentation.pdf · 2009-01-15 · Intro Implementation Analysis Characterization Conclusion Conclusion • We designed a chassis that

Special Acknowledgement

Thank you for your attention!

Contact us: [email protected]