Autoradiographic evidence for receptor cell renewal in the olfactory epithelium of a snail

8
232 Brain Researc& 384 ( 19861232-239 Elsevier BRE 12046 Autoradiographic Evidence for Receptor Cell Renewal in the Olfactory Epithelium of a Snail RONALD CHASE and JANINE RIELING Department of Biology, McGill University; Montreal, Que. (Canada) (Accepted 4 March 1986) Key words: Olfaction - - Cell renewal - - Chemoreceptor cell - - [~H]Thymidine - - Autoradiography - - Gastrolx~d mollusc The tentacles of the terrestrial snail Achatinafulica contain an epithelium at their tips which is specialized for olfaction. The histolo- gy of the snail's olfactory organ bears a striking resemblance to that of the olfactory mucosa in the nose of vertebrates, where the re- ceptor cell population is known to undergo a continuous process of renewal. In the present experiments, [3H]thymidinewas delivered as a single pulse that was determined to have a maximum duration of about 1 h, Thirty minutes after an injection of [3H]thymidine, presumptive precursor ceils were found labeled within, or at the edges of, receptor cell lobules. At later survival times, label was seen over cells that were identified as receptors. The mean position of the labeled cells within the Iayer Of receptor cells became progres- sively more superficial with increasing survival times, indicating an upward migration of newly differentiated cells. The labeling index in the snail is ca. 0.7c/c, compared to 0.9% in the mouse. The turnover time is about 45 days, compared to 30-45 days in the mouse. INTRODUCTION The occurrence of receptor cell renewal in the ol- factory mucosa of vertebrate animals is well estab- lished 7's'ls-l°'2°. Although neurogenesis is otherwise rare within the nervous system of adult vertebrates. especially mammals, the dual processes of receptor cell death and replacement are a constant feature of the olfactory epithelium in every vertebrate species which has been examined. The precursors of the re- ceptors are the basal cells which lie beneath the re- ceptors at the base of the olfactory epithelium 71s21 . The basal cells divide by mitosis, and the daughter cells then migrate upward through the epithelium as they continue to differentiate and mature as sensory n e u r o n ss-~5.~6. An analogous phenomenon of renewal has not yet been described for any invertebrate chemosensory system. We tested its generality by examining the ol- factory organ of a snail, which is situated at the tip of the snaiFs tentacles, rather than in a nose 6. Despite the difference in gross structure, and in phylogeny. the histological appearance of the snail olfactory epi- thelium is remarkably similar to that of vertebrates. Like tts vertebrate counterpart, the olfactory epithe- lium in the snail is pseudostratified. It contains a pop- ulation of receptor cells, which are primary sensory neurons, and a unique population of gland celtss. The anatomical placement of the snail receptors, and their morphology, is very similar to that of the verte- brate receptors 4A°-22. In Achatina fulica, the species used in this study, each posterior tentacle contains ca. 100,000 receptor cells3. Recently, it has been found that some of the receptor axons terminate in synaptic glomeruli 21. as in the vertebrate olfactory bulb. The applicability of 2-deoxyglucose autoradio- graphic methods has also been demonstrated 3. These experimental results, together with the flatness of the olfactory epithelium, its ready accessibility and the morphological similarities to vertebrate systems. make the snail's olfactory system an attractive alter- native model for the study of olfaction. A mechanism for the renewal of olfactory receptor cells in the snail tentacle was suggested because these neurons, like their vertebrate counterparts, have dendrites which penetrate through a layer of epithe- Correspondence: R. Chase. Department of Biology, McGill University, 1205 Av. Docteur Penfield. Montr6at. Qud. H3A IB1. Ca- nada.

Transcript of Autoradiographic evidence for receptor cell renewal in the olfactory epithelium of a snail

  • 232 Brain Researc& 384 ( 19861 232-239 Elsevier

    BRE 12046

    Autoradiographic Evidence for Receptor Cell Renewal in the Olfactory Epithelium of a Snail

    RONALD CHASE and JANINE RIELING

    Department of Biology, McGill University; Montreal, Que. (Canada)

    (Accepted 4 March 1986)

    Key words: Olfaction - - Cell renewal - - Chemoreceptor cell - - [~H]Thymidine - - Autoradiography - - Gastrolx~d mollusc

    The tentacles of the terrestrial snail Achatinafulica contain an epithelium at their tips which is specialized for olfaction. The histolo- gy of the snail's olfactory organ bears a striking resemblance to that of the olfactory mucosa in the nose of vertebrates, where the re- ceptor cell population is known to undergo a continuous process of renewal. In the present experiments, [3H]thymidine was delivered as a single pulse that was determined to have a maximum duration of about 1 h, Thirty minutes after an injection of [3H]thymidine, presumptive precursor ceils were found labeled within, or at the edges of, receptor cell lobules. At later survival times, label was seen over cells that were identified as receptors. The mean position of the labeled cells within the Iayer Of receptor cells became progres- sively more superficial with increasing survival times, indicating an upward migration of newly differentiated cells. The labeling index in the snail is ca. 0.7c/c, compared to 0.9% in the mouse. The turnover time is about 45 days, compared to 30-45 days in the mouse.

    INTRODUCTION

    The occurrence of receptor cell renewal in the ol-

    factory mucosa of vertebrate animals is well estab-

    lished 7's'ls-l'2. Although neurogenesis is otherwise

    rare within the nervous system of adult vertebrates.

    especially mammals, the dual processes of receptor

    cell death and replacement are a constant feature of

    the olfactory epithelium in every vertebrate species

    which has been examined. The precursors of the re-

    ceptors are the basal cells which lie beneath the re- ceptors at the base of the olfactory epithelium 71s21 .

    The basal cells divide by mitosis, and the daughter

    cells then migrate upward through the epithelium as

    they continue to differentiate and mature as sensory neurons s-~5.~6.

    An analogous phenomenon of renewal has not yet

    been described for any invertebrate chemosensory

    system. We tested its generality by examining the ol-

    factory organ of a snail, which is situated at the tip of

    the snaiFs tentacles, rather than in a nose 6. Despite

    the difference in gross structure, and in phylogeny.

    the histological appearance of the snail olfactory epi-

    thelium is remarkably similar to that of vertebrates.

    Like tts vertebrate counterpart, the olfactory epithe-

    lium in the snail is pseudostratified. It contains a pop-

    ulation of receptor cells, which are primary sensory

    neurons, and a unique population of gland celts s. The

    anatomical placement of the snail receptors, and

    their morphology, is very similar to that of the verte-

    brate receptors 4A-22. In Achatina fulica, the species used in this study, each posterior tentacle contains

    ca. 100,000 receptor cells 3. Recently, it has been

    found that some of the receptor axons terminate in

    synaptic glomeruli 21. as in the vertebrate olfactory

    bulb. The applicability of 2-deoxyglucose autoradio-

    graphic methods has also been demonstrated 3. These

    experimental results, together with the flatness of the

    olfactory epithelium, its ready accessibility and the

    morphological similarities to vertebrate systems. make the snail's olfactory system an attractive alter-

    native model for the study of olfaction.

    A mechanism for the renewal of olfactory receptor

    cells in the snail tentacle was suggested because these

    neurons, like their vertebrate counterparts, have

    dendrites which penetrate through a layer of epithe-

    Correspondence: R. Chase. Department of Biology, McGill University, 1205 Av. Docteur Penfield. Montr6at. Qud. H3A IB1. Ca- nada.

  • 233

    lial cells to an exposed surface. Although the snail's tentacle can be retracted inside the body for defense, or during rest, when it is operating as an olfactory sensor the receptor endings are vulnerable to irrita- tion from environmental sources, microbial infection and desiccation. The capability to generate new re- ceptor cells could provide for the continuity of olfac- tory function despite the loss of cells.

    This study used the method of [3H]thymidine auto- radiography to establish cell proliferation and to identify the precursor population 11. Thymidine is in- corporated into newly synthesized DNA just prior to cell division. The interpretation of cell labeling with [3H]thymidine is greatly facilitated if it can be dem- onstrated that the [3H]thymidine is available for up- take during only a short interval following an injec- tion. A part of this report, therefore, concerns a de- termination of the [3H]thymidine availability time in the snail.

    MATERIALS AND METHODS

    Snails, Achatina fulica, were obtained from a labo- ratory culture 17. The animals weighed 25-35 g. Their sexual maturity was indicated by the reproductive ac- tivity of siblings. [3H]thymidine (spec. act. 60-90 Ci/mM) was injected into the haemocoel at the dorsal portion of the foot directly beneath the shell. A dos- age of 4/~Ci/g was mixed with ca. 1 ml of snail Ring- er's solution and a drop of blue food coloring. The food coloring allowed observations to determine the distribution of the injected solution and to check for leakage once the needle had been withdrawn. All in- jections were done in the morning in order to control for circadian variables.

    The radioactive haemolymph content was ana- lyzed by means of samples drawn from a cannula that was inserted into one of the tentacles ~. The cannula consisted of a length of polyethylene tubing (PE 90), ca. 70 mm long, which was inserted into the tentacle following an injection of 0.5% succinylcholine chlor- ide to immobilize the animal. The cannula was tied in place with surgical silk and further secured with a drop of cyanoacrylate glue. The free end was sealed with wax; this end was cut off to collect samples and then subsequently resealed.

    Samples of the haemolymph were placed in a boil- ing water bath for 3 min to precipitate proteins and to

    inactivate enzymes. They were then centrifuged for 15 min at 13,000 rpm and placed on ice. A 5~tl sample of the supernatant was analyzed by thin layer chro- matography to determine the thymidine and thymine content. The solvent system was the upper phase of ethyl acetate:water:formic acid in the ratio 65:35:10. Standards were located using ultraviolet light, and corresponding areas of the experimental samples were scraped off. Radioactivity was eluted from the silica gel by adding ca. 1 ml of water, mixing thor- oughly, and centrifuging the suspension for 1 rain at 13,000 rpm. The procedure was twice repeated, re- sulting in a total volume of 3 ml for scintillation counting. A 25 gl aliquot of haemolymph superna- tant was also counted to determine the total tritium content. The counts were corrected for efficiency by internal standardization.

    For autoradiography, the animals were sacrificed at various times following the injection of [3H]thymi- dine. The tentacles were excised, washed in 3 changes of snail Ringer's solution for 5 min each, then pinned flat in a solution of 1% glutaraldehyde and 1% paraformaldehyde for 1 h. They were em- bedded in Araldite resin and cut transversely as 1-/~m thick sections at intervals of 8 ~m. In pilot experi- ments, the entire tentacle tip was examined, but for the analytical work sections were taken only from the middle region of the olfactory epithelium, The slides were coated with NTB2 emulsion (Kodak) that was diluted 2:1 with distilled water at 40 C. Devel- opment was done with D-19 (Kodak) for 5 min at 16 C. The slides were counterstained with 0.5% to- luidine blue (pH 11).

    RESULTS

    Determination of the FH]thymidine availability time In order to establish the levels of radioactive com-

    ponents at various times after an injection, the theo- retical distribution of tritium at 'zero time' was esti- mated assuming complete and instantaneous mixing in the haemolymph. This assumption is supported by observations using the blue dye that was part of the injected solution. Within seconds of an injection, the entire snail, including the tentacles, acquired a bluish tint, indicating a rapid dispersion of the injected ma- terial. Since the isotope was injected in a dosage of 4 uCi (8.88 1() ~ dpm) per gram, and since there is ca.

  • 234

    100 - -- Tota l t r i t ium

    E ~% ~% Thymine T Bo

    0 70 i

    N60 i

    U , - . 40 1

    n t . . .30 - Ti ~

    ;20 i 10 L ~ I I

    i i i i ~ ) ) i - , i i

    1 12 3 4 5 10 20 30 60 120

    Minutes a f te r In iec t ion

    Fig. 1. Levels of radioactive substances in the haemolymph at various times after a single injection of [3H]thymidine. The points are means _+ S.D. The sample size is 5 animals at all times except at 60 min and 120 min, where the sample sizes are 4 animals and 3 animals, respectively.

    0.40 ml of haemolymph per gram in Achatinafutcia ~=. the theoretical total radioactivity circulating at zero time is 2.22 x 107 dpm/ml.

    The levels of total tritium, thymidine and thymine in the circulation at various times after an injection are shown in Fig. 1, relative to the amount of total tri- tium at zero time. It is assumed that all initial activity is present as [3H]thymidine, with little or no decom- position or product impurity. The thymidine concen- tration falls to 66.2% of its initial value after 30 s. 3.2% after 5 min and 1.6% after I h. From these data, a conservative estimate of the pulse duration for a single injection of [3H]thymidine is l h. It is un- likely that the small amount of [3H]thymidine still re- maining in the circulation at this time would make a significant contribution to the number of labeled cells '~.

    Epithelium Muscle Receptor cell Iobules

    Digits (neuropil) Gland cells 100/Jm

    Fig. 2. The olfactory epithelium of Achatina fulica. Transverse histological section through the tip of a posterior tentacle. The olfacto- ry receptor cells are aggregated in lobules beneath the outlying epithelial and muscle layers. Protein secreting glands lie between the receptors and the digits, which are branched extensions of the tentacle ganglion.

  • 235

    ~ ~ i~ fill ~ ~i ~ ~ ~i!~ii ~#~ ~i i~ i~ ~

    ~!!~ii~ ~, i~i ii!!!!~il ~ ~ ~

    Fig. 3. Examples of cells labeled with [3H]thymidine (arrowheads) following a single pulse injection. A: 30-rain survival: the line marks the border between the muscle layer and the lobules containing receptor cell bodies (see Fig. 2). B: 30-rain survival; the labeled cells lie bctween thc receptor cells above and the protein-secreting gland cells (PG) below. C: l-day survival; the labeled cell lies su- perficially in a receptor cell lobule, D: 14-day survival; the labeled cell lies among receptor cells near the middle of a lobule.

  • 236

    Apart from [3H]thymidine, the radioactive com- pounds in the circulation after zero time consist of thymine and other catabolic products 2J9. None of

    these substances is taken up by the cell nuclei, and therefore they do not affect the pulse duration. After about 5 min, most of the tritium activity is probably contained in tritiated water.

    Autoradiography When the snail olfactory organ is viewed in cross-

    section (Fig. 2), several types of cells are evident, each having a characteristic morphology and loca- tion. The cellular composition of the tentacular olfac- tory organ is thoroughly described elsewhere 4-~'1~'22. The autoradiographs that were examined in this inves- tigation contained labels over several types of cells, namely, epithelial cells, glial cells, protein glands and receptor cells ~s. Interneurons were never labeled. Cells belonging to each of the aforementioned types could be positively identified and unambiguously dis- tinguished from cells of the other types. There were, in addition, other labeled ceils whose appearance conformed to none of the previously described cell types in the snail tentacle. These latter cells are thought to be the undifferentiated precursors of the receptor cells. Only the receptors and their precur- sors are considered in this report. A cell was re- garded as labeled if there were 6 or more silver grains

    overlying the nucleus. Labeled cells were seen at all survival times (Figs.

    3 and 4). They were frequently observed as pairs

    5

    03

    ~3

    d 2

    "3

    E 1

    Z

    g

    I , \

    i 1

    12 24 5 10 15 20 Hours Days

    T ime a f te r In jec t ion

    060 r'-

    o-

    045 ~-

    E 030 ,

    Fig. 4. Time-course of cell labeling following a single injection of [3H]thymidine. One tentacle was examined from each ani- mal sacrificed at the times shown. The points are means +_ SD. for 2 animals (25 sections each) at 3 days and at 14 days; 3 ani- mals (25 sections each) at all other times.

    (e.g. Fig. 3B). At 30 min, the majority of the labeled cells were situated at or near the borders of the lo- bules containing receptor cell bodies (Fig. 3A and

    B). Usually, these cells had a size and a shape that was different from any of the previously described cell types in the snail olfactory epithelium (Fig. 3B), but other cells were similar in appearance to receptor cells (Fig. 3A).

    At survival times after 30 min, all the labeled cells were situated within the receptor cell lobules (Fig. 3C and D). The receptor cells in Achatina are gener- ally ovoid in shape and measure approximately 6 8 l~m. The nucleus is highly chromatic and can vary in appearance from light to dark (Fig. 3). The darker cells seemed to be preferentially labeled at early sur- vival times and the lighter cells at longer survival times. However, this impression could not be quanti- fied because of the obscuring effect of the silver grains and the non-categorical variation in nuclear density.

    The labeling index was estimated to be 0.7% at 30 min and it remained at about the same level until day 10, after which it fell to 0.3% on day 30 (Fig. 4). The gross distribution of the labeled cells appeared to be uniform in all regions of the olfactory organ at all times.

    The labeled cells shown in Fig. 3 illustrate the gen- eral finding that cells were heavily labeled at short survival times, but more lightly labeled at long sur-

    I It 35

    ~r

    .$

    "3

    z

    30 min 12 hrs 24 hrs 3 days days t0 days 14 days 30 (lays

    T ime a f te r In jec t ion

    Fig. 5. The number of silver grains over individual cells as a function of time after an injection of [3H]thymidine. Each bar represents a single tentacle, with each tentacle coming from a different snail. Standard deviations are shown. The line is the least squares regression; P < 0XX)I.

  • vival times (compare Fig. 3A and B with Fig. 3D).

    The densities of autoradiographic labels were

    measured by counting the number of silver grains over each labeled cell (Fig. 5). At 30 min the mean

    number of grains was ca. 22. By day 30, the mean

    number of grains had fallen to ca. i2. The coefficient

    for the least squares regression for the data shown in

    Fig. 5 is -0.23; P < 0.001. A measure of labeling that

    is more sensitive to the dynamics of a dividing cell

    population is the number of cells labeled at either ex-

    treme of the grain density range. The cells were

    therefore sorted into a lightly labeled class (6-12

    grains) and a heavily labeled class (>20 grains). The

    number of lightly labeled cells and the number of

    heavily labeled cells are shown as a percentage of all

    labeled cells in Fig. 6. It can be seen that the number of heavily labeled cells decreases with survival time,

    whereas the number of lightly labeled cells increases.

    The two curves cross at 16 h, which represents the

    theoretical mean time for the division of those cells which incorporated [3H]thymidine at, or near, zero

    time.

    Although labeled cells were seen at all positions

    within the lobules at all survival times, the mean

    depth of the labeled cells, as measured from the epi-

    thelial surface, progressively declined with increas-

    ing survival times (Fig. 7). At 30 min, the mean depth

    was 145 Hm, which corresponds to a position deep in

    the Iobules. By day 30, the mean depth was 108 #m,

    which is superficial in the lobules. The coefficient for

    7o l co L ight ly labe led ce l l s

    60

    ~ 50

    3o

    t t"-"----I c~ i l l / ~o .~ /_ c

    Heav i ly labe led ce l l s

    12 24 5 10 15 20 25 3Q

    Hours Days

    T ime a f te r In jec t ion

    Fig. 6. Time-dcpendent changcs in the number of lightly la- beled cells (6 12 grains: solid line) and heavily labeled cells (>20 grains: dashed line). The points are means _+ S.D.

    237

    3

    E

    ~z

    _ LU CZ , . o

    o

    2t] T, 20o

    30 min 12 hrs 24 hrs 3 days 7 days 10 days 14days 30 days

    T ime a f te r In jec t ion

    Fig. 7. The location of labeled cells at various times following an injection of [3H]thymidine. Each bar represents a single ten- tacle, with each tentacle coming from a different snail. Stan- dard deviations are shown. The line is the least squares regres- sion; P < 0.006.

    the least squares regression for the data shown in Fig. 7 is -0.88; P < 0.006.

    DISCUSSION

    It is generally assumed that when [3H]thymidine is

    delivered as a pulse, the cells labeled at short survival

    times are those that are in the process of duplicat- ing DNA prior to mitosis ~1. At longer survival times

    (ca. 20 h or more), a labeled cell is understood to be

    the product of division by a cell which initially incor-

    porated the isotope. The application of these as-

    sumptions to the observations of cell labels in the

    present experiments (Fig. 3) leads to the conclusion

    that proliferation occurs within the receptor cell pop-

    ulation of the snail olfactory epithelium. Further evi-

    dence for cell replication is contained in the finding

    that the density of the labels over individual cells de-

    creases with time (Figs. 5 and 6), as would be ex-

    pected if the radioactive DNA were distributed to

    daughter cells. The replication of receptor cells ap-

    pears to be part of a renewal process within the re-

    ceptor population, rather than an expansion of the

    population, because the number of labeled cells

    eventually decreases (Fig. 4), indicating that cell rep- lication is accompanied by cell death.

    In contrast to the situation in the vertebrate olfac- tory epithelium 7J5,2, the snail tentacle does not seem

    to contain a readily identifiable and anatomically seg-

    regated population of precursors for the receptor cell population. Our results indicate that the precursors

  • 238

    are scattered among the mature receptors within and around the iobules. In vertebrates, the precursors are generally believed to be the basal cells which lie beneath the receptors, but it should be noted that 20 min after an injection in a mouse, about 10% of the labeled cells are found above the region of basal cells 15. In the snail, there is an upward migration of newly formed receptors (Fig. 7) similar to that de- scribed in vertebrates s'~5"~6. The difference between the segregated arrangement for the precursors in

    vertebrates and their distribution among the recep- tors in Achatina may be related to the size of the area occupied by the receptors. In vertebrates, the recep- tors form a layer ca. 20-50 f~m thick. Since the basal cells lie directly beneath the receptor layer, their pro- geny need only migrate a maximum of 50/~m. In Achatina, the lobules may be as thick as 160 urn. Were it not for the fact that the precursor cells are vertically distributed within the lobules, the required migration distance would be much greater than it is in vertebrates.

    In two species of slugs, both closely related to Achatina, the tentacular receptor cell population can be differentiated into two types, using ultrastructural criteria t'22. The alpha neuron is described as smaller than the beta neuron; it has a slightly irregular and chromatic nucleus with a small nucleolus. The beta neuron has a larger, more spherical nucleus than the alpha cell; the nucleus is also less chromatic, and the nucleolus is larger. This distinction in receptor cell morphology is relevant to the present results because the alpha receptor type is found predominately near the base of the lobules, whilst the beta receptors are found at superficial positions 1'22. It is possible, therefore, that the alpha cells are immature recep- tors and the beta cells are mature receptors that have migrated upwards. A confirmation of this hypothesis will require electron microscopic autoradiography. An intriguing finding that relates to the proposed vertical migration is the fact that only superficial re- ceptor cells become labeled with [14C]2-deoxyglu- cose after exposure to odors 3, suggesting that matu- ration is accompanied by an increase in metabolism. or an increase in sensitivity to stimuli, or both.

    The number of labeled cells decreases with time af- ter an injection, suggesting that cells die and disap- pear, as would be expected in a population which is continuously renewed, tf one extrapolates the de-

    cline in the number of labeled cells from day 10 (Fig. 4), a turnover time of about 45 days can be estimated. This compares with estimates of ca. 30-45 days for the turnover time in mice ~>14.

    It might be expected that the number of labeled cells would increase during the initial period after an injection, when the labeled DNA is presumably be- ing distributed to the progeny of dividing cells. Cu- riously, this result was obtained neither in the present work nor in the investigations of the mouse olfactory mucosa carried out by Moulton and co-workers is The absence of an initial increase in the labeling index may be explained, in part. by the assumption of a non-synchronous division of cellsl ,,)wing to variable times of [3H]thymidine uptake in relation to the dura- tion of the S-phase of the cell cycle A second factor contributing to the absence of a net increase in the la- beling index is the occurrence of cell death concur- rently with cell proliferation. Whereas the influence of cell death is only apparent in "d~e labeling index from day 10 onward, the death rate prior to that time may be just sufficient to offset gains in the population due to proliferation. It is interesting to note that in the mouse 15, as in the snail, the decline in the labeling index also begins at about day 1().

    Because the precursor cell population cannot be readily identified, and therefore quantified, the la- beling index in this study is expressed as a percentage of the number of receptor cells (Fig. 4). During the first 24 h, the labeling index is ca. (1.7%. This value can be compared with a labeling index of 0.9% in the mouse, where the percentage is based on the total number of cells of all types in the olfactory epitheli- um j''. Because the labeling index reflects both the probability of DNA synthesis in a given cell at a given time and the availability time of [~Hlthymidine, the interpretation of the similarity between snail and mouse depends on an appreciation of the pulse dura- tion times in the two species. We have no information on the pulse duration in mice, but remarkably, the time course of [3H]thymidine availability m the rat corresponds closely to that seen in the snail, when similar methods are used for its determination. The comparison is shown in Table 1. If one assumes that the clearance rate in mice is close to that in rats, then evidently the proliferation of receptor cells proceeds at about the same rate in mice as it does in snails,

    Taken together, the results ~f ~his investigation

  • 239

    TABLE I

    Comparison of [~ H]thymidine clearance times in ,snail and rat folio wing a single injection

    The data t;or rat are taken from ref. 2.

    Time after injection Percentage of initial FH]thymidine remaining in the circulation

    Rat Snail

    5 rain 3.6 3.2 30 min 2.4 2.0 60 min I).4 1.6

    demonst ra te a process of renewal in the o l factory ep-

    i thel ium of a snail which is s imi lar to that which exists

    in ver tebrates . P resumably , the common basis for the

    renewal in both cases is the exposure of the receptors

    to a harmfu l externa l env i ronment . Neurob io log is ts

    now have avai lable two a l ternat ive mode l systems in

    which to study the processes of death and renewal in

    a nerve cell popu lat ion , and the prob lem of how the

    new receptor cells are able to establ ish correct ana-

    tomical connect ions w i thout d isrupt ing sensory func- t ion 13.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    We thank Joan Marsden and Rober t Lev ine for

    advice and crit icism. This work was suppor ted f inan-

    cially by a grant f rom the Natura l Sciences and Engi-

    neer ing Research Counci l of Canada.

    REFERENCES

    l Burton, R.F., A method of narcotizing snails (Helix poma- tia) and cannulating the haemocoel and its application to a study of the role of calcium in the regulation of acid-base balance, Comp. Biochem. Physiol., 52A (1975) 483-485.

    2 Chang, L.O. and Looney, W.B., A biochemical and auto- radiographic study of the in vivo utilization of tritiated thy- midine in regenerating rat liver, Cancer Res., 25 (1965) 1817-1822.

    3 Chase, R., Responses to odors mapped in snail tentacle and brain by [14C]2-deoxyglucose autoradiography, J. Neuro- sci., 5 11985) 2930-2939.

    4 Chase, R. and Kamil, R., Neuronal elements in snail tenta- cles as revealed bv HRP backfilling, J. Neurobiol., 14 (1983) 29-42.

    5 Chase, R. and Tolloczko, B., Secretory glands of the snail tentacle and their relation to the olfactory organ, Zoomor- phology, 1115 (1985) 60-67.

    6 Croll, R., Gastropod chemoreception, Biol. Rev., 58 (1983) 293-319.

    7 Graziadei, P.P.C. and Metcalf, J.F., Autoradiographic and ultrastructural observations on the frog's olfactory mucosa, Z. Zel![orsch. Mikrosk. , 116 (1971) 305-318.

    8 Graziadei, P.P.C. and Monti-Graziadei, G.A., Continuous nerve cell renewal in the olfactory system. In M. Jacobson fed. ), Handbook of Sensory Physiology, Vol. IX, Springer. New York, 1978, pp. 55-83.

    9 Hickey, T.L., Whikehart, D.R., Jackson, C.A., Hitch- cock, P.F. and Peduzzi, J.D., Tritiated thymidine experi- ments in the cat: a description of techniques and experi- ments to define the time-course of radioactive thymidine availability, J. Neurosci. Meth., 8 ( 19831 139-147.

    10 Kataoka. S., Fine structure of the epidermis of the optic tentacle in a slug, Limax flavus L.. Tissue Cell, 8 (1976) 47-60.

    11 Leblond, C.P., Messier, B. and Kopriwa, B.. Thymidine- 3H as a tool for the investigation of the renewal of cell pop- ulations, Lab. Invest., 8 (1959) 296-3116.

    12 Martin, A.W., Harrison, F.M., Huston, M.J. and Stewart, D.M., The blood volume of some representative molluscs, J. Exp. Biol., 35 (1958) 260-279.

    13 Monti-Graziadei, G.A. and Graziadei, P.P.C., Studies on neuronal plasticity and regeneration in the olfactory sys- tem: morphologic and functional characteristics of the ol- factory neuron. In E. Meisami and M.A.B. Brazier (Eds.), Neural Growth and Differentiation, Raven Press, New York, 1979, pp. 373-396.

    14 Moulton, D.G., Dynamics of cell populations in~khe olfac- tory epithelium, Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci., 237 (1974) 52-67.

    15 Moulton, D.G., Celebi, G. and Fink, R.P., Olfaction in mammals - - two aspects: proliferation of cells in the olfac- tory epithelium and sensitivity to odours. In G.EW. Wolstenholme and J. Knight (Eds.), Taste and Smell in Ver- tebrates, J. and A. Churchill, London, 1970, pp. 227-246.

    16 Moulton, D.G. and Fink, R.R., Cell proliferation and mi- gration in the olfactory epithelium. In D. Schneider (Ed.), Olfaction and Taste, IV, Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesell- schaft, Stuttgart, 1972, pp. 20-26.

    17 Pawson. P.A. and Chase, R., The life-cycle and reproduc- tive activity of Achatinafulica (Bowditch) in laboratory cul- ture,,/. Moll. Stud., 50 (1984)85-91.

    18 Rieling. J., Sensory Receptor Neuron Turnover in the Olfac- tory Epithelium of the Snail, Achatina fulica: A n A utoradio- graphic Study, M.Sc. Thesis, McGill University, 1985.

    19 Rubini, J.R., Cronkite, E.P., Bond, V.P. and Fliedner, T.M., The metabolism and fate of tritiated thymidine in man, J. Clin. Invest., 39 (1961/) 909-918.

    21/ Thornhill, R.A., Cell division in the olfactory epithelium of the lamprey, Lampetra fluviatilis, Z. Zellforsch. Mikrosk., 109 (1970) 147-157.

    21 Tolloczko, B. and Chase, R., Gtomerular terminations of olfactory receptor axons in a snail tentacle, Soc. Neurosci. Abstr., 11 11985) 1221.

    22 Wright, B.R., Sensory structure of the tentacles of the slug, Arion ater. 1. Ultrastructure of the distal epithelium, recep- tor cells and tentacular ganglion, Cell Tissue Res., 151 (1974) 229-244.