Automotive. It is an emerging global automotive ancillary...
Transcript of Automotive. It is an emerging global automotive ancillary...
Mahindra CIE Kaizen thesis Mahindra CIE (MACA) is now part of the CIE Automotive Group, Spain and will be formed by a merger of M&M’s Mahindra Systech and CIE Automotive. It is an emerging global automotive ancillary player with a high probability of asymmetric revenue and earnings growth, which will be driven by new products, customers, and technology addition as part of group synergy, and the financial turnaround of Mahindra entities in Europe. MACA will be the growth engine for Asian market for the group and will be among the top three automotive forging companies of the world. MACA is a business improvement story with four broad levers of sales and earnings growth over the next 5 years. We expect the stock to rerate as the belief on the business combination gathers pace. We believe the story will be partly immune to business and economic cycles due to the complementary nature of the alliance, which is focusing on customer and product additions and the turning around of its low-profitability businesses. Key growth drivers are strengthening content market share in product platform, adding products using CIE’s R&D prowess, and leveraging the global footprint of clients.
1. Margin improvements: Focus on low-hanging fruits by turning around strong and stable businesses through process improvement, automation, best production techniques using CIE’s expertise, and a focus on high-yielding products using limited capex.
2. Growth acceleration: Focus on leveraging CIE products and clients to strengthen existing India business. Shifting production of low-yielding forging products from Europe to India. Global sourcing and supply chain advantage. Reduction in corporate overheads and incentives aligned to plant-level profitability.
3. Building new capabilities: Bringing CIE’s existing technologies (such as aluminium products, plastic products, and vehicle-roof systems) to India and Asia and focus on achieving or even bettering CIE financial standards and goals.
4. Inorganic opportunities: Consolidation of CIE’s Mexico and Brazil forging units with MACA and looking for an alliance in South East Asia to penetrate Japanese OEMs without breaching financial discipline.
As most of these drivers are internal (emerging out of group synergy and productivity improvement), we expect geometric progression in growth and earnings over the next 5-6 years. Although we are conservative in our growth assumption at the beginning, we forecast FY14-18 revenue and EBITDA CAGR of 15% and 34%, respectively, and an earnings CAGR of 51%.
Priya Ranjan | [email protected] | + 9122 6667 9965
Phillip Kaizen
Presenting stocks with sustainable growth prospects generated by internal drivers.
改
善 Kaizen in Japanese stands for “continuous improvement” or “philosophy of improvement” derived from the words Kai, which means “change”, and Zen which means good. It involves all employees from the CEO to the assembly line workers. Kaizen was first implemented in several Japanese businesses after the Second World War, influenced in part by American business and quality management teachers who visited the country. It has since spread throughout the world and is now being implemented in environments outside of business and productivity.
Novem
MahSimps• Mah
havin What w• The
suppforgi
• AlignMACprodbringcont
• EBIT1) tuunit)launcover
• Evenblenenha
• CIE’syearsof itsEBITnew
ValuatioAt CMPsignificaconsolidClarity otrigger
mber 10, 2014
hindra CIEson’s paradoindra CIE is on thng asymmetric gr
will change and hnew entity (abo
plier with € 1.7bn ing products acroning and accessCA’s topline by duct base will incg new growth avribute to >50% of
TDA margins shouurnaround of Mah, 2) focus on autch of value-addrheads, and 5) hign returning to eded margin by 3
ancement/automas strong track res) without compros covenants (free
T margin >11%, aleague/scale.
ons P, the stock tradeant discount to dated net debt toon consolidated fre-rating and mul
E ox e cusp of being aowth potential wi
ow it will changeout 53% owned
in sales) will be toss the globe. sing CIE’s customabout 69% by F
crease content pevenues. We expef MACA’s growth
uld improve 660bhindra Forging Etomation, plant eded products (C
gher operating levearlier margins o00bp — low-han
ation/outsourcingecord of acquisitomising profitabi cash flow at 50%
and ROI >20%) in
s at 7x FY17 EV/Eits peers such
o decline 50% by financials, earningtiple expansion.
a multi-product glth MNC ownersh
e after amalgamaby CIE, a leadinhe parent’s growt
mer and producFY18 (from FY14er vehicle, addingect additional clie by FY18. p to 14% in FY18
Europe (MFE) andefficiency, and fixCIE’s portfolio),verage at plants. of 12% at MFE ging fruit; can be at MFE plants. ion/turnaround (6lity is unmatched% of EBITDA, EBn 3-4 years could
EBITDA and 12xas Bharat Forg
FY18 due to its fogs visibility, and d
obal auto-parts pip.
ation… ng global compoth engine for Asia
ct base will ram4). While CIE’s wg CIE’s customersents and produc
8 from FY14 drived Metalcastello (gxed-cost reductio
4) lower corpo will expand MA
e achieved by pro
65 integrations iand the achieve
BITDA margin of d propel MACA in
FY17 earnings —ge. We expect ocus on free cash debt reduction, sh
player
onent a and
mp-up wider s will
cts to
n by: gears on, 3) orate
ACA’s ocess
n 20 ment 16%, nto a
— at a CIE’s flow.
hould
Key
CMP (
Targe
RECO
Bloom
Marke
Marke
Stock
O/S S
52 - W
Liquid
ValuRs mnNet SaEBIDTNet PrEPS, RPER, xEV/EBP/BV, ROE, %Debt/
Sourc
Data
(Rs) :
t (Rs) :
:
mberg :
et Cap (Rs bn) :
et Cap (USD bn) :
k Performance
hares (Mn) :
Wk Hi/Lo (Rs) :
dity 3m (USD mn) :
uation Summaryn ales TA rofit Rs x
BIDTA, x x
% Equity, %
ce: Company, PhillipC
209
340 (62%)
BUY
MACA IN
68
1.1
326
229 / 45
1.7
F5
(8
Capital India Research
Simpson’s Pa
Y
Shareholding Pat
Promoters :
FII / NRI :
FI / MF :
Non-Promoter Corp
Public & Others :
Price Performanc
Absolute
Rel to BSE
FY14P FY15E5,712 57,4044,151 5,628
-85 1,766(0.3) 5.4
800.5) 38.520.6 14.8
4.7 4.2(0.6) 10.9
137.0 109.7
Estimates
aradox | Mahindr
ttern (%)
p. Holdings :
ce (%)
1mth 3mth
4.4 34.4
-2.0 24.3
FY16E 66,781
8,003 3,585
11.0 19.0 10.0
3.4 18.2 77.1
ra CIE | 4
73.0
1.0
4.5
5.6
15.9
1yr
362.8
327.9
FY17E 80,217 10,836
5,568 17.1 12.2
7.3 2.8
22.7 58.9
Novem
StageAs paryield/pressentiadesired turnaroureductio MFE tuUsing Clooking consolidimproveGermanenergy pressesalso oncustomequalify f MFE: E
‐8‐6‐4‐202468
mber 10, 2014
e #1 Turnarot of its strategrofitability issues aally, low-hanging
CIE levels will taund in MFE (Euron. Early efforts ar
rnaround CIE’s expertise (CI
at turning aroudated margins aned 600bps due ton forging plant (costs after nuclea, and 4) lower die
n product pricingers, Daimler. We for power subsidy
BITDA margin tr
Q3'13 Q4'13
ound: Pluck y, CIE’s managat MACA’s plants
fruit. Wider groke a bit more timrope business) wre focused on:
E executives are nd its MFE busi
nd profitability. Sio: 1) process improas part of the gar power plant sh
e costs. Apart fromg — it recently believe that one
y — this will enhan
end
Q1'14 Q2'14
low-hangingement has bee, which will be the
owth and margin me and effort. It hawith better produ
now manning all ness, which has nce CIE’s takeoveovement, 2) € 5m
government’s effohutdown), 3) lowem plant-level imp
hiked the pricee more of its Germnce margins furth
Q3'14 Q4'14
g fruits n trying to adde fastest to addre
improvement toas partially achiev
uctivity and fixed
MFE plants), MACbeen a key dra
er, MFE margins mn power subsidy orts to lower indering down-time rovements, its focs for one of itsman forging planer.
Q1'15 Q2'15
dress ess — o the ved a
d-cost
CA is g on have to its
dustry at its cus is s key nt will
MFEreduarouMFE
MaxMACprodnearprod
It hahas nextforg
RedMosEurocomsheeimp
ProcprodAfteprocprocmainof bprodof a
E is looking atucing its manpowund 30% of salesE’s EBITDA margi
ximising throughCA is focused onducts to boost thrr-term growth optduct portfolio exp
as recently receiveapprovals to supt 6-12 months in ing sales in FY16- uced cost of deb
st of the combinopean businesses
mpany has taken aet) to reduce lonrove combined p cess improvemeductivity across a
er CIE’s takeovercess improvemencess automation untenance of presslanking sheets. Thduct margins whelready commissio
outsourcing mawer (has cut 110 s) to improve thens to about 12% b
put from existingn maximising itsroughput and yieltimisation strateg
pertise without inc
ed orders from Repply to most new India. We expect -17.
bt by around 200ed entities’ debts (MFE, Metalcasadvantage of theng-term debt cosrofitability and ca
ent, automation all plants r, all MACA entnts such as reduusing robots (thisses, and bringinghis will not only imen the efforts arened and upcomin
Simpson’s Pa
ny of its low-vaemployees in thee profitability. Mby the end of FY1
g customers in Inbusiness by offeld from its existing
gy is to introduce curring major cape
enault India to suPV models that wthis will significan
0bps t (about € 200mstello, and CIE F
e low rate in Eurost by about 200sh flow.
and fixed-cost
tities have been ucing wastage, ims improves produg CIE plant practimprove plant prode successfully impng efforts:
aradox | Mahindr
alue-added servie last 9 months, ACA intends to
16 from 5.5% in 1
ndia ring value-additiog customer base. new products usiex.
upply crankshafts will be launched ntly boost MACA
mn) is in the booForging Europe) ope (using group 0bps to 3.5% —
t reduction to
focusing on plmproving througctivity by 15-20%ces such as size oductivity but also
plemented. Few i
ra CIE | 5
ces and currently improve HFY15.
on to its Another
ing CIE’s
and also over the
A’s Indian
oks of its and the balance this will
improve
ant-level ghput by %), timely or shape improve nstances
Novem
• 20%• Com• To
acti• Incr• Ligh• Inst
auto• Low
ReductAnothercosts) aredundacorporamarginsmargins
ProductTo imprby CIE eproductmargin.profitabcomponprofitabfor forgIn the ethat hav
mber 10, 2014
% reduction in mammissioning of rodiminish frequenton was taken on treasing die life anht-weighting of crtallation and comomated process
wering product rej
ion in corporate r early benefit wias multiple entitant in a combine
ate costs ares/profitability leves by 100bps in the
t rationalisation rove productivity executives) are wts that have a lo Across its busine
bility discipline. Tnents of MFE plability can’t be enhing and product
early stages, the cve little ramp-up p
npower in MFE aobots at its Pune at breakdown of pthe number of died enhancing procrankshafts to redu
mmissioning of big
jection and wasta
overheads ll be a reduction ies with individued single entity. <1% of sales)
er in the mid-tere next 2-3 years.
and mix optimisaand plant-level p
orking on a revamow yield and incesses and plants, oThe managemennts to India (with
hanced in Germarelocation can im
company is willingpossibility and a d
nd Metalcastello and Nashik stamppresses, whereveres cess flow to loweruce machining allogger reduce roll
age
in corporate-leveual support-servic
Following CIE’s) MACA willrm. We think it
ation profitability, MACmp plan across bucrease products one of CIE’s key mnt is looking at out any business ny/Europe. India
mprove MFE’s mag to even discontdrag on overall pr
ping plants r load exceeded
r cycle time owances with manipulator
el expenditure (Sces functions wiphilosophy (in whave an additcan improve EB
CA’s managementusinesses/plants tthat have a sup
mantras is adherinshifting few fordisruption) if prois a low-cost loc
argin and profitabtinue certain prodofitability.
90%,
rs for
SG&A ll be
which tional ITDA
t (led o cut
perior ng to rging oduct ation bility. ducts
StaProdThe forglike constheswheminiconsgain A fe•
•
•
•
•
•
age #2: Focuducts cross-pollinmanagement’s sing and stampingEurope and Am
solidation and unse new product iere new products imum effort, at esolidation, which n penetration into
ew possible early pDiesel/gasoline eEurope and is threlationship with Cummins shouldsystem. Exhaust manifoldfrom Ford in IndiaOil pan systems topline ramp-up fLaunch of cross cnew business in sAdding turbo-boand Cummins. Launch of fuel inj
us on synergnation trategy of bringing that have produerica can improviversalisation is gintroductions arecan be introduce
existing locationsimproves supply OEMs/Tier-1 ven
product-cross-polengine-injection rahe key supplier tEuropean clients
d add significantly
d in casting businea. where CIE is a l
from this. car beam (used bstamping. ooster housing wi
ection system com
Simpson’s Pa
gy with CIE
ng CIE products iuct leadership in ve customer yieldgaining momentum likely in forginged without incurri. Another focus achain efficiency a
ndors due to glob
llination opportunail-forged producto Continental, Vin India along wi
y forging busines
ess as MACA has
eader; should se
below instrument
ith customer add
mpatible to powe
aradox | Mahindr
Automotive
nto India in areasthe existing CIE l
d significantly as m across OEMs. W
g, stamping, and ing major capex area for OEMs isnd is likely to hel
bal supply of CIE e
nities for MACA: ct where CIE is thVW, and PSA. Levth new customersss from the com
s recently receive
ee significant volu
t panels) in India
ditions such as Ho
ertrains used in Ind
ra CIE | 6
e
s such as locations platform We think
casting, and with s vendor p MACA entities.
he leader veraging s such as mon rail
d orders
ume and
can add
oneywell
dia.
Novem
CIE pro
Source: C
mber 10, 2014
oduct capabilities
Company, PhillipCapita
s – cross-pollinat
al India Research, oran
tion opportunitie
nge bubble points lea
es in India
adership product
SupBeinadvamatescatoversuppdire MarApaconsimpprodoutfacil LikewhicThe to mimpheadunlikexparedustamimpa
ply-chain efficienng part of the antages with imperial and supply-tered standaloner the next 2-3 yeaply-chain benefitct/indirect means
rgin accretion in rt from strengtsultation with CIErovement in stamduct-offering expawith detailed p
ities to achieve m
wise, gear produch will improve tcompany manag
meaningfully imprrovement and dcount). Althoughkely due to lack oansion in the neuction. Ramp-up mping facility at Zact on revenues a
ncy from global sCIE automotive
proved economie-chain costs for te operations. Thisars. Although the ts, we think a s is achievable.
non-forging opethening forging E’s team) is draw
mping/gears/castiansions. CIE’s tealant-level produc
margin accretion b
cts will see a lot the margins apargement has drawnove margin accreemployee ratio
h earlier peak maof high-margin deext 2-3 years th
of its Chakan Zaheerabad for Mand margins.
Simpson’s Pa
sourcing/value ce group brings es of scale. This he combined ents is likely to help
company has no20-25bps additi
eration: Stampingoperations, MA
wing up a blueprngs plants by proam and local prodctivity roadmapsby 2HFY16.
of value additionrt from generatinn a four-year businetion from <10% onalisation (arouargins of around efence orders, wehrough productiv
gear facility (Ta&M’s tractors/pic
aradox | Mahindr
hain MACA global will help rationatity compared toimprove EBITDA
ot quantified the eion to margins
g/Gears/CastingsACA’s managemrint for plant prooduct value addiduction teams are
by visiting each
(machined compg plant-level effiness plan at Metacurrently through
und 20% reduc20% at Metalcase expect a 400bpvity gains and fiata Motors/expock-ups will have a
ra CIE | 7
sourcing lise raw-
o its past A margin extent of through
s ment (in oductivity tion and
e coming h other’s
ponents), ciencies.
alcastello h process ction in stello are p margin xed-cost
orts) and positive
Novem
Stage New cliNew cliup betwclients Ford/GMvolumesOEMs additioncustomedependcustomeramp-up CIE+Sy
Source: C
New teBeing awith an
mber 10, 2014
e #3: Access
ient additions wient addition is anween FY16-18, b
in Europe/AmM/Renault/Fiat/VWs) provides a non-are focused on n requires a leaders to start accr
ding on the new er addition of Rep in FY16.
ystech client/prod
Company, PhillipCapita
chnology additioa vehicle of growtn intention to b
sing CIE cust
th CIE’s help nother area wherebased on CIE’s lerica. Existing W/BMW (accoun-linear growth oplocalisation to b
time of about 1ruing towards thlaunches from th
enault (forging) an
duct synergy
al India Research
on in India using th in Asia, MACAuild new capabi
tomers/tech
e we will see signong-standing relrelationship wi
nting for aroundportunity in the mbecome compet8 months, we ex
he end of FY16he European/US Ond Ford (casting)
CIE’s portfolioA will have access
ilities (plastic pa
hnologies
nificant revenue raationships with tth OEMs such
d 20% of Indianmedium-term, as titive. Since custoxpect benefits of
or fully from FOEMs. However, will provide bus
to CIE’s technoloarts, aluminium p
amp-these h as n PV these omer f new FY17,
new siness
ogies parts,
painand alumtrenbusideve Gro
Sourc
We of Clightreasplasadddrive
‐
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
nting and roof syAsia. As globall
minium and plastd to improve eminess to start contelops these capab
wth from new pr
ce: Company, PhillipC
think plastics will CIE Automotive satweight. MACA insonable valuation)stic-parts businessition and paintiners for India starti
5
0
5
0
5
0
5
0
5
ystem) for the exiy OEMs are focu
tics in the vehiclemission standardstributing topline mbilities and appro
roduct technolog
Capital India Research
be one of the keales) in the field antends to acquire) or use Mahindras, which has marg. We expect thng FY17-18.
FY17E
Simpson’s Pa
isting Systech anusing on light wee, we expect Inds and fuel mileameaningfully fromaches the OEMs w
gy in sales additi
ey growth areas gand incremental fe a plastic facilitya Composite’s facrgins of >14-15%is business to be
aradox | Mahindr
d CIE customers eight with greatedian OEMs to foge. We expect t
m FY17-18 as the cwith products.
on
given CIE’s expertfocus of OEMs foy in India (if availacility (plan B) to e
% if combined wie one of the key
FY18E
ra CIE | 8
in India er use of llow this this new company
tise (20% or vehicle able at a enter the ith value y growth
Novem
Althougwe thinkare aggthis trencurrentlbetwee• Prod
be a• Oil
be i• Alu
with• Com• Loo
numnea
FY14 co
Source: C
mber 10, 2014
gh it has gone slok it can be anothe
gressively using and can gather pacy unavailable withn FY15-18 and arducts like brake ba growth area. pans across multintroduced. minium stampingh few OEMs like Mmmon rail system oking at setting umber of OEMs arar client plant loca
onsolidated MAC
Company, PhillipCapita
Gears10%
Stamping13%
CastiMa9
ow in aluminium cer growth driver fluminium parts toce in India as welh MACA to contriound 40% of the booster and gear
tiple technology l
g products like doM&M
forging ramp up p a greenfield stre setting up plaations.
CA sales break-u
al India Research
ing and agnet9%
PlasCompo
1%
components (aroufor MACA in the loo reduce vehicle l. We expect newibute about 10% annual growth byhousing where C
ike stamping, pla
oors where the c
from clients like Camping plant in Gnts due to the n
p (by business)
Forgi67%
tic osites%
und 10% of CIE song-term as PV Oweight/emissions
w products/technoof incremental to
y FY18. CIE has leadership
astic and aluminiu
company is unde
Cummins Gujarat where a
nature of the bus
ng%
ales), OEMs s and ology pline
p can
um to
r talk
large siness
FY1
Sourc CIE MACrate trackcomdiscRuss
8 consolidated M
ce: Company, PhillipC
philosophy of mCA is confident oin India, organica
k record in achiemfort on the strat
ipline (capital expsia aluminium plan
Gear10%
Stamping19%
Casting/Ma9%
Compot3
MACA sales brea
Capital India Research
market plus growtof achieving a groally, through prodeving this (partly tegy and growth penditure only aftnt, about 75% pre
rs%
agnet
osite/Plastics3%
Aluminium3%
Simpson’s Pa
ak-up (by busines
Estimates
th – track-recordowth rate that is duct, technology a
through small aprospects. Its tra
ter sizable confirme-order) is also co
m Paintings1%
aradox | Mahindr
ss)
is consistent well ahead of theand client additioacquisitions too) ack record of inv
med orders like Momforting.
Forging55%
ra CIE | 9
e market ons. CIE’s provides vestment
Mexico or
g
Novem
CIE glo
Source: C CIE glo
Source: C
mber 10, 2014
obal sales growth
Company, PhillipCapita
obal sales break-u
Company, Phillip Capit
Machining16%
Plastic20%
h – track-record i
al India Research
up (by business,
tal Research
casting4%
Roof syste4%
mpressive
Ex-MACA) Aluminium
10%
Stam28
em
Forging18%
mping8%
StaCIE 100%the brinyearentitdebfinansignmod Givearoufurthpresram Thro
Sourc
age #4: Inorhas kept its Brazi% subsidiary Autolatter’s current leg these units unrs given their statty — they will mt level improves.ncials improving —s of financial im
del).
en that these (Braund 16%, we expher increase groussure from OEMsping-up productio
oughput of Mexi
ce: Company, PhillipC
ganic growtl, Mexico and Chometal, with topleverage/financial nder MACA onceted objective of
merge few entitiesAdditional busin
— we see this as provements (tho
zil, Mexico, Chinapect the eventuaup synergies — Ms to start operatioon.
co capex (Forgin
Capital India Research
Simpson’s Para
th – Within/oina forging units ine of € 110-120strength. Howev
e its financials imforging and Asias which have bee
ness combinationa very likely evenugh combination
a) forging units enl merger to be m
MACA’s forging uons in Mexico an
ng units to be me
adox | Mahindra
outside gro(currently owned mn) out of MACA
ver, the group inmprove over the
business under en kept out of Mis contingent to
nt in FY17-18 given not yet factore
njoying EBTIDA mmargin accretive units in Europe arnd Brazil, where
erged with MACA
a CIE | 10
up by CIE’s
A due to tends to next 2-3 this new
MACA as MACA’s
en visible d in our
margin of and will
re facing they are
A)
Novem
EBITDA
Source: C
‐
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
mber 10, 2014
A margin of Auto
Company, PhillipCapita
2009
ometal group (for
al India Research Estim
2010
Autometal EBITDA
rging units to me
mates
2011 201
A margin (Ex MACA
erge with MACA)
12 2013
)
)
InoGiveJapato pJapastratthe MAC CIE
Sourc
organic oppoen the limited panese OEMs, MApursue inorganic anese OEMs. Althtegy to penetrateIndia business givCA’s managemen
sales by geogra
ce: Company, PhillipC
ortunity in Spenetration of boACA’s manageme
opportunities inhough nothing hae Japanese OEMsven the OEM’s w
nt has hinted at th
phy before Mahi
Capital India Research
Simpson’s Para
South East Aoth CIE group ant in consultation
n South East Asis been yet finalise
s may bring additiwell-entrenched pr
is in various medi
indra CIE and sta
Estimates
adox | Mahindra
Asia nd Mahindra Sy
n with CIE group a, an emerging ed on this front soional non-linear gresence in India aia interaction.
ated goals by 20
a CIE | 11
stech to is willing hub for
o far, the growth to and Asia.
017
Novem
FinanWe expdriven bWe havforging at a CAassumpadditionand bra While tadditionramp-uplaunchebusineswill be while dutilisatio We expto contnew bubusines We estiFY18 (loutperfowill impexpertiseach plWe thinleverage
mber 10, 2014
ncials pect a revenue CAby a 50% growthe assumed modeunits). We expec
AGR of 33% andtion is based onn like forged/macke booster.
the domestic fornal vehicle platforp from existing
ed from CIE’s pses to grow at Cled by the new
domestic gear/traon of the Chakan
pect future busineribute about 10%
usiness/customer/s by FY18.
imate EBITDA mower than the ormance here as prove blended Ese) has already dant level and to nk our margin ase (15% additiona
AGR of 15% overh addition from nerate 5% CAGR foct India forging and 49% respectivn new client adchined common
rging business wrms, composite/pcustomers and t
portfolio. We estCAGRs of 26% an
facility and prodansmission businfacility and a stro
sses such as plast% of additional replatform to contr
argin to improveCIE target of 1only its MFE bus
EBITDA by 300brawn a clear roadbring overall marssumption is not al volume) at do
r FY14-18 to toucnew customers anor European entitind composite/plavely between FY1dition like Renaurail injection, cro
will be driven byplastic segment gthe new plastic ptimate stamping d 22%, respectiv
ducts (such as oilness growth willng order book.
tics parts, aluminievenue by FY18. ribute around 50
by a conservativ6%) — howeversiness returning tbps. MACA’s madmap for producrgin to CIE’s expeaggressive at al
omestic forging b
ch to Rs 96bn in nd products/platfes (both MFE andstics business to 14-FY18. Our grult/Ford and pro
oss-car beam, oil
y new customers rowth will be led products that wi
and domestic vely. Stamping gr pan, brake boo be led by gr
um parts and paiIn totality, we ex
0% of the increm
ve 660bps to 14%r, there is scopeo its earlier 12% anagement (withctivity improvemeected levels (15-1l since just operbusiness can imp
FY18 form. d CIE grow rowth oduct pans
and by a ll be gear
rowth oster), eater
nting xpect ental
% by e for level CIE
ent at 16%). ating
prove
margstamdue mac Rev
Sour
2
4
6
8
10
12
gin by >300bp. mping/gear segm
to fixed-cost achining can improv
enue break-up –
rce: Company, PhillipC
‐
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
00,000
20,000
FY14
ForgCastPain
Similarly, sales ments will improve
addition. Similarve margins (aka C
– product catego
Capital India Research
P FY15E
gingting/Magnetntings
Simpson’s Para
ramp-up from e margins of therly, product valuCIE/Bharat Forge)
ry wise
h Estimates
FY16E
GearsComposite/Plastic
adox | Mahindra
new plants in dese businesses bue engineering .
FY17E FY1
Stampingcs Aluminium
a CIE | 12
domestic y 200bp such as
8E
Novem
Revenu
EBITDA
Source: C
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
‐
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,00
12,00
14,00
16,00
mber 10, 2014
e and revenue g
A margins to imp
Company, PhillipCapita
0
00
00
00
00
00
00
FY14P
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
FY14P
growth
prove 660bp by F
al India Research Estim
FY15E FY1
Revenue
FY15E FY16
EBITDA EBIT
FY18
mates
16E FY17E
Growth (%) (rhs)
6E FY17E
TDA Margin (%) (rh
0
5
10
15
20
25
FY18E
‐
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
FY18E
hs)
Con
Earn
Sourc
0
5
0
5
0
0
0
0
(1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
ntribution to 660
nings CAGR of ~
ce: Company, PhillipC
Metalcastello5%
Stamping3%
India Gears5%
Global Sourcing3%
India 1
1,000)
‐
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
FY14P
bp EBITDA marg
51% over FY15-
Capital India Research
Forging12%
FY15E
Ad
Simpson’s Para
gin expansion
18
Estimates
MFE45%
Corporate Overhead
15%
Im
FY16E FY
justed PAT
adox | Mahindra
mprovement from Rest
12%
Y17E FY18E
a CIE | 13
Novem
Marginssuch ascompouto Rs7.3 LeveragWith a significanet deb Net deb
Source: C
FinanciIf MACA16%, EB>20%) assump
0
4,000
8,000
12,000
16,000
20,000
mber 10, 2014
s in new value-adds plastic productsund businesses. O3bn between FY15
ge to come downsignificant impro
ant fall in leveragebt going down 50%
bt to come down
Company, PhillipCapita
al goals set by CA achieves CIE coBIT margin >11%over 3-4 years, ttions. Financial g
0
0
0
0
0
0
FY14P
N
ded products in es are typically hi
Overall, we expec5-18 from a loss i
n sharply ovement in profe and debt servic% from current lev
n by 50%
al India Research Estim
CIE provides upsiovenants (Asia bus%, net debt <1.5xthere will be ups
goals are very imp
FY15E FY1
Net Debt N
existing operationigher than plain ct profits to increan the combined e
fitability and case coverage ratio vel by FY18.
mates
ide risk siness size at € 1bx, FCF at 50% ofside risk to our gportant for CIE’s m
16E FY17E
Net Debt/EBITDA (x)
ns and new businevanilla stamping
ase at a CAGR of entity in FY14.
h flow, we expeover FY15-18. We
bn), EBITDA margf EBITDA, and ROgrowth/margins/remanagement bec
0
1
2
3
4
5
FY18E
) (rhs)
esses and
f 51%
ect a e see
gin of OI of eturn cause
theydece
VaBacksignconsbalavalu At iassigat aassusubsassuwith ValuRs mnNet SaEBIDTNet PrEPS, RPER, xEV/EBP/BV, ROE, %
Sourc
0
1
2
3
4
5
y don’t want to sentralised with em
luations ked by CIE’s techificant scalabilitysolidation and gance sheet, MNC ations.
ts current markegned a FY17 PER price target of R
umptions are cosidiary. However,umptions as businh a BUY rating.
uation Summaryn ales TA rofit Rs x
BIDTA, x x
%
ce: Company, PhillipC
stretch the balancmphasis on plant p
hnology, product y to MACA’s bglobal vehicle p
parentage, and
t price, the stocR of 20x (based oRs 340. Given tha
onservative vs. C, we expect MAC
ness and strategy
F5
(8
Capital India Research
Simpson’s Para
ce sheet of any profitability and in
portfolio, and gbusiness in theplatform. Attractiv
a scalable mode
ck trades at 12x on 10% discount tat this is a busineCIE Automotive’sCA’s financial pestart delivering. W
FY14P FY15E5,712 57,4044,151 5,628
-85 1,766(0.3) 5.4
800.5) 38.520.6 14.8
4.7 4.2(0.6) 10.9
Estimates
adox | Mahindra
entity as their woncentives.
lobal client base,current age of
ve return ratiosl will help the co
our FY17 EPS. Wto peer average) ess turnaround sts expectation frerformance to beWe are initiating c
FY16E 66,781
8,003 3,585
11.0 19.0 10.0
3.4 18.2
a CIE | 14
orking is
, there is vendor
, strong ompany’s
We have to arrive tory, our rom this etter our coverage
FY17E 80,217 10,836
5,568 17.1 12.2
7.3 2.8
22.7
Novem
Compa BHFC MSS IN WIL IN BOS IN SKF IN Indian AveGlobal parCIE SM WBC US SKFB SS Multiples SKF IN WIL IN
Source: B
Key ITurnaroCurrentFY16-17cultural As a recompan IntegraPotentiaentities,reflecterecur w
mber 10, 2014
rable Valuation S____FY1
129
192215
rage 16rent of India subsidiarie
610
7premium/discount of M
10082
loomberg, PhillipCap
nvestment Round time and quly, MACA expects7. However, this differences. Also
esult, financials mny’s own.
tion issues relateal roadblocks in , which may creatd in the financiaith the new CIE m
Sheet __EV/EBITDA____ 16E FY17E 2.4 10.5 9.1 7.4 9.5 13.9 2.6 18.8 5.6 13.2 6.1 13.3 es 6.0 5.5 0.7 9.6 7.8 7.1
MNC listed subsidiaries0.0 85.1 2.2 44.8
ital India Research
Risks uantum may not s a meaningful tumay take longer , the productivitymay fail to achi
ed to cultural valintegration couldte hurdles — this l deterioration o
management. How
______PER______FY16E FY17E
22.4 17.921.8 16.329.9 20.733.4 29.524.2 20.227.3 22.4
12.6 10.715.5 13.211.5 10.1
s in India 110.4 100.0
92.9 56.8
meet internal bernaround of low-ythan that due to
y improvement maeve our expecta
ues d be the different
in turn can impaf MFE after M&Mwever, given that
_ ____EV/SalesE FY16E9 2.43 1.07 3.75 3.92 2.14 2.6
7 0.82 1.9
1.2
0 76.58 97.9
enchmark yielding businesse internal resistancay fall short of tarations as well as
t work cultures inct productivity. TM’s takeover anda year of trouble
s____FY17E
2.10.92.83.41.82.2
0.71.71.1
57.961.8
es by ce or rgets. s the
n the This is d can e-free
coopissue ShaManfinanentitIndiageo RegOnebusiJapacomgove ManCIE’domIndiabusiHowof thexec
perative integraties cropping up is
rp slowdown in Eny of the problemncial crisis as theties. We are buila over our forgraphies may imp
ulation related re of the key reinesses was a shuanese tsunami of
mpanies significanernment directive
nagement attritio’s strategy of lig
mestic managers aa or Mahindra Syiness plans given
wever, from what his happening as cutives through ad
ion has already pvery low.
Europe and Indiams in the MFE bus
prolonged downding in a mild rerecast period. pact the financials
isks easons for finanutdown of the nuf 2011. This has tly (heavy power-
es in other geogra
on after consolidght corporate oand senior executystech entities. Tlong-term customwe know of CIE’smanagement ha
dequate compen
Simpson’s Para
passed, the poss
a may impact tursiness have emergnturn impacted thecovery in EuropeEconomic deters of new entities.
cial deteriorationuclear power plaincreased power-consuming indusaphies may impac
ation may impacoverheads may ctives — this may
This in turn may imer relationshipss turnaround trackas anticipated thissation such as sto
adox | Mahindra
sibility of new int
rnaround ged after the 200he financials of Ee and decent recrioration in bot
n of Germany’s nts in Germany a
r costs if Germanstry). Similar reguct the business ma
ct Indian businescause discontentlead to higher atimpact short to mof the existing mk record, we see s and tried to rewock options.
a CIE | 15
tegration
08 global European covery in h these
forging after the
n forging ulation or aterially.
s t among ttrition in mid-term anagers. little risk
ward key
Novem
CompMahindcomponSpain-b(formalitbe amobe formCIE’s EuCIE bupresenccastings
MACA Automoits globcustomeFY18.
Sales: 5
Capac
MahindC
Sales: E1
Capaci
mber 10, 2014
pany Backgrra CIE Automonent player, whic
based automotive ties pending), MA
ong the top three med by merging uropean forging bsinesses in Asia
ce in India, Spain,s, gears, and stam
will emerge as a otive group with abal forging operater accretion shou
MFEEUR252mnPlantscity: 185k T
S
dra Hinoday ‐CastingEUR46.3mnPlantsity: 70k TPA
M
S
C
round otive (MACA) isch will be formed
component majoACA (which will bautomotive forgiMahindra Systec
business. The newand for its glo
, Germany, UK, Itmpings.
large global autoa focus on Asia ations. The likely ld drive MACA’s
India ForgingSales: EUR55mn
1 PlantsCapacity: 85k T
ahindra Hinoday ‐Magnetics
ales: EUR13.8mn1 Plants
Capacity: 7.2k TPA
Mahind
s an emergingd by the alliance or), and M&M Systbe a subsidiary ofng companies of
ch’s listed/non-listw entity will be thebal forging opetaly, and Lithuani
omotive ancillary across all of CIE’ssynergy in terms topline by around
CIE Forging ‐EuropeSales: EUR150mn
3 PlantsCapacity: 110k T
Mahindra Composites Sales: EUR6.3mn
2 PlantsCapacity: 1k SMC & 4k
DMC
ra CIE
g global automof CIE Automotitech. After the mef CIE Automotivethe world. MACA
ted auto entities e growth engine fration. It will haa, supplying forg
player within theproduct verticalsof new business
d 69% (15% CAG
MUSCO StampSales: EUR100
5 PlantsCapacity: 100
Metal castelSales: EUR49m
1 PlantsCapacity: 3mgears/annum
otive ve (a erger e) will A will
with for all ave a gings,
e CIE s and s and R) by
Key compain
Sourc
ping 0mn
0k T
lomn
m m
product lines of mposites; 5) castinnting (to be launch
ce: Company
MUSCO MahiCompo
Mahindra GeTransmission Indi
Mahindra Forgi(Europe)
M&M
‐20%
the new entity wng and magnets; hed from CIE’s po
Mahindra CIE A
ndra osites
Mahindra Investments
(India)
ears & a Ltd (India)
ings
Mahindra CIE AuLimited*
2
53%
Simpson’s Para
will be 1) forging; and 5) plastic, alu
ortfolio in India).
utomotive is create
s MahindraGears
International
Metalcastello(Italy)
*Erstwhi
PIA 2(Spain)
utomotive *
MERGER
12.1%
28%
72%
adox | Mahindra
2) stamping; 3) guminium sheet m
ed
Mahindra Hinoday P
CIE Forgin
ile Mahindra Forgings Lim
CIE Automotiv
Autometel
99.9%
a CIE | 16
gears; 4) metal and
PIA 3
ngs
mited
ve
%
Novem
Source: C
Merger
Company
Mahindra
Mahindra
Mahindra
Mahindra
MUSCO
CIE Forgin
Source: C
Forgi
Ca
mber 10, 2014
Company
r and share swapy
a Hinoday
a Composites
a Gears Europe
a Gears India
ngs
Company
ngs Composites
Stamstings + MPD
Mahindra CAutomotive Lim
M&M
Mahindra Systec
Indicates transaction
Indicates merger
Listed company
ratio
I
Gears
mpings
IE mited
ch
12.1% ‐ 2nd largest s
*CSp
CIE Au
Forgings
Machining
Stampings
Aluminium
Plastics
Bio‐fuels
nf. & Comm. Tech
A
shareholder
>50%
CIE forgings plants in pain & Lithuania
Swap
utomotive
Brazil
Mexico
USA
China
Autometal
Forgings, macasting, stamplastics, pain
Aluminium, fomachining, splastics, pain
Plastics
Forgings
p ratio
1.10
0.90
0.17
0.20
2.84
1.05
Mah
CIE CIE comAutoMorand in thcom Throsectsust
chining, mpings, nting
orgings, tampings, nting
hindra CIE globa
Automotive: BacAutomotive is a
mponents and subomotive group, rocco, Czech RepMexico. CIE Aut
he auto componemponent manufact
ough its subsidiartor, providing tainability, transpo
l footprint
ckground a Spain-incorpora
b-assemblies for thwhich operates
ublic, Romania, Btomotive has emeent space and raturers by sales.
ies, it is present intechnological soort, and communi
Simpson’s Para
ated company, whe auto industry. in Spain, Port
Brazil, Argentina, Cerged as one of tnks among the t
n bio-fuels and tholutions to the cations sectors.
adox | Mahindra
which makes autIt is the parent of
tugal, France, LChina, Russia, Guhe leading globatop-75 global aut
he information techealthcare, ed
a CIE | 17
tomotive f the CIE
Lithuania, atemala,
al players tomotive
chnology ducation,
Novem
CIE Aut
mber 10, 2014
tomotive: Busineess/operational s
tructure
Simpson’s Paraadox | Mahindraa CIE | 18
Novem
CIE pro
Source: C
mber 10, 2014
oduct portfolio in
Company, PhillipCapita
n functional area
al India Research
picture
Tec
Proce
Stamp
Forgin
Gears
Plasti
Alum
Castin
Painti
Roof S
Comp
Magn
Sourc
hnology integrat
ess
pings
ngs
s / Machining
cs
inium
ngs
ing
Sys.
posites
nets
ce: Company, PhillipC
ted worldwide
EU NAF
Capital India Research
Simpson’s Para
FTA Brazil R
adox | Mahindra
Russia India
a CIE | 19
China
Novem
CIE ACIE’s Rautomofocus ovehicle Focus a
Source: C
mber 10, 2014
Automotive:&D is focused o
otive industry. Its an emerging powcomfort.
areas for R&D on
Company: PhillipCapita
Products alon providing soluannual R&D expe
wertrain/gearbox,
n emerging indus
al India Research
ligned with utions for the emenditure is aroundlight-weights, em
stry trends
sector drivemerging trends od 2.2% of its salesmission reduction,
ers f the
s with , and
CIE
Sourc
product portfoli
ce: Company: PhillipC
o
Capital India Research;
Simpson’s Para
; orange bubble point
adox | Mahindra
ts leadership product
a CIE | 20
Novem
R&D foGloballyshort prpace wconsolidwith thegroup, old MAR&D inv Techno
Source: C
aads
ThasseindehaGRin
mber 10, 2014
cus of CIE to hely, the automotivroduct lifecycles. T
with OEMs to redation in the Inde OEMs investmeMACA will benefCA entities may nvestments to rema
ologies focus on w
Company: PhillipCapita
he product ssociated with the ector drivers are creasingly emanded thereforeave HIGHER ROWTH than the dustry average
lp MACA in longe industry is seeTherefore, auto cmain relevant —ustry (size and bnts on new technfit from its parentnot have had theain relevant.
winning product
al India Research
e
sfsdf
Particulartrends affPOWERTR(ENGINE AGREABOXpart wherAutometasignificanand therecommitmfuture
g-term eing rapid technoomponent manuf
— this is the mabalance sheet is nologies). Being a t’s technological financial strength
s
rly these fect the RAIN AND X), a vehicle re al has a very t presence, e is a clear ment to the
asfsd
ological changesfacturers need to in reason for veneeded to keep part of the globaprowess; many oh to sustain long-
These trends are global but largelydriven by EUROPas a PIONEER tre
s and keep
endor pace
al CIE of the -term
CIE To specprod
Sourc
y PE, nds
CoemCO•Fumsy
•EnTusy
•Adu
•WCoalcost
focus on winninggrow faster thancialised in differeducts with fastest
ce: PhillipCapital India
onsumption and mission reduction oO2/NOxuil engine and oil management: fuel injectiystem and oil panngines reduction: urbuchargers and EGR ystems (gas recirculationutomatic transmission: ual clutch, 8/9/10 speed
Weight reduction: omponents based on uminium, plastics and omposites. Electric poweteering components
g technology/pron its peers, CIE ent products withgrowth in the sec
a Research, Industry
of
on
n)CVT, ds
er
Greater s•Active andImpact absnew gener
Simpson’s Para
oducts has positioned ih an aim at gettctor.
sscurityd Passive Safety: sorption and airbags rations
adox | Mahindra
itself in such a wting a pie of the
Greater comfort•Refueling systems: C•Thermal and acoustmanagement: EncapEngine and Underbo(aerodynamic syste
•Interior work: Persothrough new materprocesses
a CIE | 21
way and e winner
Caplesstic psulation ody m)onalization ials and
Novem
MahinMahindthroughpresencof the MahindItaly, anand com Mahind
mber 10, 2014
ndra Systecra Systech foraye
h a series of locace across the autolargest Indian aura Systech scaled
nd the UK. Its keymposites. It emplo
dra Systech: Corp
h ed into the auto cl and internationa
o-industry value chuto component d up with manufy product areas aoys around 9,000
porate Structure
components indusal acquisitions wihain. Over the yeagroup. After a sfacturing units acre forgings, castipeople across va
stry in the early 2th an aim to buiars, it emerged asseries of acquisitcross India, Germngs, gears, stamp
arious companies.
2000s ld its s one tions, many, pings
Simpson’s Paraadox | Mahindraa CIE | 22
Novem
Finan Profit &As at 31st
Net sales
Growth, %
Other incom
Total incom
Raw mater
Employee e
Other Oper
EBITDA (Co
Growth, %
Margin, %
Depreciatio
EBIT
Growth, %
Margin, %
Interest pa
Other Non-
Non-recurr
Pre-tax pro
Tax provide
Profit afte
Net Profit
Growth, %
Net Profit
Unadj. sha
Wtd avg sh
Source: P
mber 10, 2014
ncials
& Loss Mar, Rs mn
me
me
ial expenses
expenses
rating expenses
ore)
on
id
-Operating Income
ing Items
ofit
ed
r tax
(adjusted)
res (m)
hares (m)
hillipCapital India Ressearch, Company
FY14 FY15E
55,712 57,404
3
137 156
55,848 57,559
-28,293 -29,329
-10,791 -10,335
-12,614 -12,267
4,151 5,628
35.6
7.5 9.8
-2,684 -2,853
1,467 2,774
89.1
2.6 4.8
-1,322 -855
395 435
1,750 0
2,290 2,354
-1,010 -589
1,280 1,766
1,280 1,766
(2,177.4)
(85) 1,766
326 326
326 326
FY16E
66,781 8
16
168
66,949 8
-34,401 -4
-11,102 -1
-13,443 -1
8,003 1
42.2
12.0
-3,005
4,998
80.1
7.5
-696
478
0
4,780
-1,195
3,585
3,585
103.1
3,585
326
326
FY17E
80,217
20
182
80,399
41,857
12,377
15,328
0,836
35.4
13.5
-3,309
7,527
50.6
9.4
-629
526
0
7,424
-1,856
5,568
5,568
55.3
5,568
326
326
Cas
Y/E M
Pre-ta
Depre
Chg in
Total t
Cash
Capita
Chg in
Cash
Free c
Equity
Debt r
Cash
Net ch
Sourc
h Flow
Mar, Rs mn
ax profit
eciation
n working capital
tax paid
flow from operating ac
al expenditure
n investments
flow from investing act
cash flow
y raised/(repaid)
raised/(repaid)
flow from financing act
hg in cash
ce: PhillipCapital India
ctivities
tivities
tivities
a Research, Company
Simpson’s Para
FY14 FY
2,290 2
2,684 2
6,213
-1,759
9,427 5,
-33,822 -3
-712
-34,534 -3,
-25,107 2
14,374 1
14,115 -2
28,488 -
3,382 1
adox | Mahindra
Y15E FY16E
,354 4,780
,853 3,005
491 87
-589 -1,195
,110 6,678
3,000 -4,000
0 0
,000 -4,000
,110 2,678
,766 3,585
,000 -2,000
-234 1,585
,876 4,263
a CIE | 23
FY17E
7,424
3,309
1,134
-1,856
10,012
-8,000
0
-8,000
2,012
4,806
-1,000
3,044
5,056
Novem
BalanceAs at 31st
Cash & ban
Debtors
Inventory
Loans & ad
Other curre
Total curren
Investment
Gross fixed
Less: Depre
Add: Capita
Net fixed a
Total asset
Current lia
Provisions
Total curren
Non-curren
Total liabili
Paid-up cap
Reserves &
Shareholde
Total equit
Source: P
mber 10, 2014
e Sheet Mar, Rs mn
nk
vances
ent assets
nt assets
ts
d assets
eciation
al WIP
ssets
ts
bilities
nt liabilities
nt liabilities
ities
pital
& surplus
ers’ equity
ty & liabilities
hillipCapital India Ressearch, Company
FY14 FY15E
2,102 2,212
6,160 6,150
7,885 8,035
2,340 2,134
580 598
19,068 19,130
712 712
72,090 75,090
-41,499 -44,352
547 547
31,138 31,285
52,422 52,630
20,146 20,575
2,995 3,009
23,141 23,584
14,907 12,907
38,048 36,491
326 326
14,048 15,814
14,374 16,140
52,422 52,630
E FY16E
2,890
6,787
9,425 1
2,422
695
22,219 2
712
79,090 8
-47,357 -5
547
32,279 3
56,714 6
22,667 2
3,415
26,082 3
10,907
36,989 4
326
19,399 2
19,725 2
56,714 6
FY17E
3,140
7,709
11,468
2,859
835
26,010
712
87,090
50,667
547
36,970
65,196
26,728
4,030
30,758
9,907
40,665
326
24,205
24,531
65,196
ProfY/E MPer SEPS (IGrowtBook FDEPSCEPSCFPS ReturReturReturReturTurnoAsset Sales/Sales/WorkiReceivWorkiLiquidCurreQuickIntereTotal dNet deValuaPER (xPEG (xPrice/EV/NeEV/EBEV/EB
Sourc
fitability, ProductMar, Rs mn
hare data NR) th, % NAV/share (INR) S (INR) (INR) (INR)
rn ratios n on assets (%) n on equity (%) n on capital employed (%over ratios turnover (x) /Total assets (x) /Net FA (x) ing capital/Sales (x) vable days ing capital days dity ratios nt ratio (x)
k ratio (x) est cover (x) debt/Equity (%) ebt/Equity (%) ation x) x) - y-o-y growth Book (x)
et sales (x) BITDA (x) BIT (x)
ce: PhillipCapital India
tivity, Liquidity a
%)
a Research, Company
Simpson’s Para
and Valuation RatFY14 F
(0.3)
(2,17 44.2
(0.3) 2.6 10.6
8.1 (0.6) 13.2
3.3 2.1 3.6 (0.1) 40.4
(20.8) (2
0.9 0.6 1.1 137.0 1 122.4
(800.5)
n/a 4.7 1.5 20.6 58.4
adox | Mahindra
tios FY15E FY16E
5.4 11.0 77.4) 103.1 49.6 60.6 5.4 11.0 14.2 20.2 14.4 20.6
4.4 7.4 10.9 18.2 7.2 12.2
1.7 2.0 1.1 1.2 1.8 2.1 (0.1) (0.0) 39.1 37.1
23.3) (18.2)
0.9 1.0 0.5 0.6 3.2 7.2 09.7 77.1 96.0 62.4
38.5 19.0 (0.0) 0.2 4.2 3.4 1.5 1.2 14.8 10.0 30.1 16.1
a CIE | 24
FY17E
17.1 55.3 75.4 17.1 27.3 28.4
9.8 22.7 16.4
2.2 1.3 2.3 (0.0) 35.1
(17.6)
1.0 0.5 12.0 58.9 46.1
12.2 0.2 2.8 1.0 7.3 10.5
Novem
RegionaSINGAPO PhillipCaNo. 1, 18
Manage
Kinshuk B
Researc
Dhawal DPriya Ran
Manish APradeep AParesh Ja
ConsumeNaveen KManish P
CementVaibhav A
Sales &Ashvin PaShubhangKishor BinSidharth Bhavin Sh
Vineet Bh
Jignesh S
Automob
Banking,
mber 10, 2014
al Member CompanORE | MALAYSIA | H
apital (India) Privat8th Floor, Urmi Esta
ement
Bharti Tiwari (Head – In
ch
Doshinjan
AgarwallaAgrawalain
er, Media, TelecomKulkarni, CFA, FRMPushkar, CFA
Agarwal
& Distribution atilgi AgrawalnwalAgrawalhah
hatnagar (Managing Dir
hah (Head – Equity Der
biles
NBFCs
nies HONG KONG | JAP
te Limited ate, 95 Ganpatrao K
stitutional Equity)
(9122) 6667 9769(9122) 6667 9965
(9122) 6667 9962(9122) 6667 9953(9122) 6667 9948
(9122) 6667 9947(9122) 6667 9764
(9122) 6667 9967
(9122) 6667 9991(9122) 6667 9964(9122) 6667 9989(9122) 6667 9934(9122) 6667 9974
rector)
rivatives)
PAN | INDONESIA |
Kadam Marg, Lower
EconomicsAnjali Verma
Engineering, Capital GAnkur SharmaHrishikesh Bhagat
Infrastructure & IT SeVibhor SinghalVarun Vijayan
MidcapVikram Suryavanshi
Dipesh Sohani
| CHINA | THAILAN
r Parel West, Mumb
(91 22) 2300 (91 22) 6667 (91 22) 6667
(9122) 6667 9
Goods(9122) 6667 9(9122) 6667 9
ervices(9122) 6667 9(9122) 6667 9
(9122) 6667 9
(9122) 6667 9
D | FRANCE | UNIT
bai 400013. Tel: (91
299999469735
Metals9969 Dhawal Dosh
Ankit Gor
9759 Oil&Gas, Ag9986 Gauri Anand
Deepak Pare
9949 Pharma9992 Surya Patra
Retail, Real E9951 Abhishek Ran
Neha Garg
9756 Sales TraderDilesh DoshiSuniil PanditExecutionMayur Shah
TED KINGDOM | UN
22) 2300 2999 Fax:
hi (9(9
gri Inputs(9
ek (9
(9
Estatenganathan, CFA (9
(9
(9(9
(9
NITED STATES | AU
: (9122) 6667 9955 w
Te9122) 6667 9769 Su9122) 6667 9987
PG
9122) 6667 99439122) 6667 9950 D
V
9122) 6667 9768 SrR
9122) 6667 99529122) 6667 9996
Za9122) 6667 9747 9122) 6667 9745
9122) 6667 9945
C
Simpson’s Para
USTRALIA | SRI LAN
www.phillipcapital.i
echnicalsubodh Gupta, CMT
roduction ManagerGanesh Deorukhkar
Database ManagerVishal Randive
r. Manager – Equities Sosie Ferns
arine DamaniaCorporate Commun
adox | Mahindra
KA
in
(9122) 6667 9
(9122) 6667 9
(9122) 6667 9
Support(9122) 6667 9
(9122) 6667 9nications
a CIE | 25
9762
9966
9944
9971
9976
Novem
Disclosures
PhillipCapitaDerivatives expressed inof the other This report iPhillip (Maustated. This herein nor apurposes ofReport wereparties. Theensure thatinformationdoes not acmovements This report specific persfinancial advdiscussed orealised. In Securities mservices andcompanies dopinions exp Important: TReceipt andabout the is Certificationresearch repthe analyst indirectly, rethat he /she Independenreceived anPhillipCapitafrom the sumentioned i PhillipCapitaRegistered o
mber 10, 2014
and Disclaimers
al (India) Pvt. Ltd. has thand Private Client Group. Tn this document may or mar equity research groups of
is issued by PhillipCapital (Iuritius) Pvt. Ltd. Referencereport is prepared and disany opinion expressed shouf the purchase or sale of ae considered by PCIPL to bee source of such informatiot this information is corre. Any person placing relianccept any liability as a resu and past performance is n
does not have regard to tson who may receive this visors and reach their ownr recommended in this reno circumstances it be us
mentioned in it. The informad other sources, which we do not guarantee that sucpressed reflect judgments a
These disclosures and discd use of the research reporsuers and securities discuss
ns: The research analyst(s)port accurately reflect the have no known conflict of ielated to the specific viewse or his / her family membe
nce/Conflict: PhillipCapital y compensation for investal (India) Pvt. Ltd does notubject issuers in the next tin this research report, alth
al (India) Pvt. Ltd. office: No. 1, 18th Floor, Ur
hree independent equity This report has been prepaay not match or may be coPhillipCapital (India) Pvt. Lt
ndia) Pvt. Ltd. which is regues to "PCIPL" in this reporttributed by PCIPL for informuld be construed or deemeny security, investment ore valid when published. Theon will usually be disclosed ect, PCIPL does not offer nce on the report to undertult. Securities and Derivatiot necessarily an indication
the specific investment obreport. Investors must unn regarding the appropriateport and should understased or considered as an oation contained in the resebelieve are reliable. Phillipch information is accurate at this date and are subject
claimers must be read in crt is subject to all aspects sed in this research report i
who prepared this researresearch analyst’s personainterest and no part of the s or recommendations conrs does not own the stock(s
(India) Pvt. Ltd. has not htment banking services frot anticipate receiving or inthree (3) months. PhillipCahough it or its employees, d
rmi Estate, 95 Ganpatrao Ka
research groups: Institutioared by Institutional Equitintrary at times with the vietd.
ulated by SEBI. PhillipCapitat shall mean PhillipCapitalmation purposes only and ed to be construed as solicitr derivatives. The informate report also contains inforin the report. Whilst PCIPLany warranty as to the atake trading does so entireives markets may be subjen to future performance.
bjectives, financial situationndertake independent analeness of investing in any snd that statements regardoffer to sell or a solicitatioearch reports may have beeCapital (India) Pvt. Ltd. or or complete and it shouldto change without notice
conjunction with the reseaof these disclosures and dis available on request.
rch report hereby certifiesl views about all of the subresearch analyst’s compentained in this research reps) covered in this research r
had an investment bankinom, the subject issuers in ttend to seek compensatiopital (India) Pvt. Ltd is notdirectors, or affiliates may
adam Marg, Lower Parel W
onal Equities, Institutionales Group. The views and oews, estimates, rating, targ
al (India) Pvt. Ltd. is a subsi (India) Pvt. Ltd unless otneither the information cotation or as offering adviceion and opinions containedrmation provided to PCIPL L has taken all reasonable sccuracy or completeness ly at his or her own risk anect to rapid and unexpecte
n and the particular needsysis with their own legal, securities or investment stding future prospects mayon of any offer to buy or en taken from trade and stany of its group/associate/d not be relied upon as su
rch report of which it formdisclaimers. Additional info
s that the views expressedbject issuers and/or securitisation was, is or will be, dirort. The Research Analyst creport.
ng relationship with, and the past twelve (12) montn for investment banking t a market maker in the sehold either long or short p
est, Mumbai 400013
l Equity opinions get price
idiary of herwise ontained e for the d in the by third steps to of such nd PCIPL ed price
s of any tax and rategies not be sell the tatistical /affiliate uch. Any
ms part. rmation
d in this ies, that rectly or certifies
has not ths, and services ecurities positions
in suchreport SuitabobjectsubstaappropapplicaThe vaother f Sourcethe reinformcurrenunder Copyridisclosexcept Cautiolight o For U.analysthe Unnot suFINRA subjec This reRule 1SecuritInstituthis reInvesto In reliaSEC inagreemin this
h securities. PhillipCapital (t.
ility and Risks: This researives, financial situation or antial risks and may not bepriateness of any securitiesable to such investor and ialue of any security may be financial, economic or polit
es, Completeness and Accuesearch analyst believe to mation contained herein is ant opinions as of the date ano obligation to update or
ight: The copyright in this rsure is prohibited. No reprt that a recipient may reprin
on: Risk of loss in trading inf your experience, objective
S. persons only: This reseast(s) who has prepared the nited States (U.S.) and are nbject to supervision by a Uor required to otherwise c
ct company, public appeara
eport is intended for distri15a‐6(b)(4) of the U.S. Seties and Exchange Commitional Investor as specifiedeport may not be copied, dor.
ance on the exemption from order to conduct certain bment with a U.S. registeredresearch report should be
(India) Pvt. Ltd may not hol
rch report is for informatioparticular requirements of e suitable for certain inves referred to in this researcts own investment objectivpositively or adversely affetical factors. Past performan
uracy: The material herein be reliable, but neither Paccurate or complete and itappearing on this materialkeep the information curre
research report belongs excrinting or reproduction, in nt it for internal circulation
n can be substantial. You ses, financial resources and
arch report is a product of Presearch report. The reseanot associated persons of aU.S. broker‐dealer, and is/acomply with U.S. rules or rnces and trading securities
bution by PhillipCapital (Inecurities and Exchange Actission (SEC) in reliance ond above, then it should notuplicated and/or transmitt
m registration provided by business with Major Institud broker‐dealer, Marco Poloeffected through Marco Po
Simpson’s Para
ld more than 1% of the sha
onal purposes only and is any individual recipient hestors. Each investor must ch report based upon the lves or strategy, its financiaected by changes in foreign nce is not necessarily indica
is based upon informationCIPL nor the research anat should not be relied uponl and are subject to changeent.
clusively to PCIPL. All rightswhole or in part, is permionly and only if it is reprint
hould carefully consider wother relevant circumstanc
PhillipCapital (India) Pvt Ltdrch analyst(s) preparing theany U.S. regulated broker‐dre not required to satisfy tregulations regarding, amonheld by a research analyst
ndia) Pvt Ltd. only to "Majot, 1934 (the Exchange Acn Rule 15a 6(a)(2). If the t act upon this report and ed onward to any U.S. pers
Rule 15a‐6 of the Exchangeutional Investors, PhillipCapo Securities Inc. ("Marco Poolo or another U.S. registere
adox | Mahindra
ares of the company(ies) co
not tailored to the specifiereof. Certain securities mamake its own determinatlegal, tax and accounting cal situation and its investinexchange or interest rates,ative of future performance
n obtained from sources thalyst represents or guarantn as such. Opinions expresse without notice. Furtherm
s are reserved. Any unauthitted without the PCIPL’s pted in its entirety.
whether trading is appropriaces.
d. which is the employer ofe research report is/are resealer and therefore the anthe regulatory licensing reqng other things, communicaccount.
or Institutional Investors" act) and interpretations therecipient of this report is return the same to the senson, which is not the Majo
e Act and interpretations tpital (India) Pvt Ltd. has enolo").Transactions in securited broker dealer.
a CIE | 26
overed in this
ic investment ay give rise to ion as to the onsiderations g experience. , as well as by e or results.
hat PCIPL and tees that the ed herein are more, PCIPL is
horised use or prior consent,
ate for you in
f the research sident outside alyst(s) is/are quirements of cations with a
as defined by ereof by U.S. not a Major
nder. Further, r Institutional
hereof by the ntered into an ties discussed