Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of...

27
Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of the Past: Text Mining for Historical Documents (WS 2009/10)” 2010-02-24 Kate Byrne and Ewan Klein

Transcript of Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of...

Page 1: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text

Alberto González PalomoSeminar “Unlocking the Secrets of the Past: Text Mining for Historical

Documents (WS 2009/10)”

2010-02-24

Kate Byrne and Ewan Klein

Page 2: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Site456

SOUTH WALLS, MISBISTER, THE LOFTSND38NW29 centred 3325 8885

Sites recorded during an archaeological survey undertaken on the lands of the Loft, Longhope, as part of the pilot scheme for the Historic Scotland Farm Ancient Monument Survey Grant Scheme.8885 Cairn. ND 3339 8886 Clearance cairn. ND 3342 8884 Sub-rectangular cairn. ND 3339 8883 Well Sponsors: Historic Scotland, M J Jones. N Card 1998

Page 3: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Clearance cairn in Germany

Page 4: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Memorial cairn in South Africa

Page 5: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Site456

SOUTH WALLS, MISBISTER, THE LOFTSND38NW29 centred 3325 8885

Sites recorded during an archaeological survey undertaken on the lands of the Loft, Longhope, as part of the pilot scheme for the Historic Scotland Farm Ancient Monument Survey Grant Scheme.8885 Cairn. ND 3339 8886 Clearance cairn. ND 3342 8884 Sub-rectangular cairn. ND 3339 8883 Well Sponsors: Historic Scotland, M J Jones. N Card 1998

Page 6: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 7: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Results: Named Entity Recognition

ADDRESSPLACE

SITENAME

DATE

PERIOD

EVENTORG

PERSNAME

ROLE

SITETYPE

ARTEFACT

Average

0

50

100

Precision %Recall %F-score %

ADDRESS 3458

PLACE 2503

SITENAME 1712

DATE 3519

PERIOD 400

EVENT 3176

ORG 2730

PERSNAME 2318

ROLE 90

SITETYPE 5668

ARTEFACT 879

Total 27453

Page 8: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Results: Relation ExtractionAgent

AgentRole

Date

PatientPlace

Events avg.

Overall avg.

0

50

100

Precision %Recall %F-score %

Agent 3794

AgentRole 13

Date 3189

Patient 1553

Place 341

Events 8890

Overall 21932

Page 9: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Results: whole pipeline NER + REAgent

AgentRole

Date

Patient

Place

Events avg.

Exc. AgentRole

Overall avg.

0

50

100

Precision %Recall %F-score %

Page 10: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 11: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 12: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 13: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 14: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 15: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Site456

SOUTH WALLS, MISBISTER, THE LOFTSND38NW29 centred 3325 8885

Sites recorded during an archaeological survey undertaken on the lands of the Loft, Longhope, as part of the pilot scheme for the Historic Scotland Farm Ancient Monument Survey Grant Scheme.8885 Cairn. ND 3339 8886 Clearance cairn. ND 3342 8884 Sub-rectangular cairn. ND 3339 8883 Well Sponsors: Historic Scotland, M J Jones. N Card 1998

Page 16: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 17: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 18: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 19: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Named Entity Recognition

Page 20: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Relation Extraction

Page 21: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

ADDRESS

PLACE

SITENAME

DATE

PERIOD

EVENT

ORG

PERSNAME

ROLE

SITETYPE

ARTEFACT

Page 22: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 23: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 24: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of
Page 25: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Results: whole pipeline NER + REAgent

AgentRole

Date

Patient

Place

Events avg.

Exc. AgentRole

Overall avg.

0

50

100

Precision %Recall %F-score %

Page 26: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Questions?

Page 27: Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text€¦ · Automatic Extraction of Archaeological Events from Text Alberto González Palomo Seminar “Unlocking the Secrets of

Image sources

● The standing stones of Callanish on the Isle of Lewis, Scotland.

● http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Callanish-circle.jpg

● Clearance cairn at landscape conservation area Königswald (Potsdam).

● http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lesesteinhaufen,_K%C3%B6nigswald,_Potsdam.jpg

● Memorial cairn at the Isandlwana hill in Kwazulu Natal, South Africa.

● http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Isandlwanamassgrave.JPG