AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)...

29
AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH Associate Professor Ramon L. Varcoe FRACS, PhD Sydney, Australia

Transcript of AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)...

Page 1: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH

Associate Professor Ramon L. Varcoe FRACS, PhD

Sydney, Australia

Page 2: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Disclosure

Speaker name:

.........Ramon Varcoe........................................................

I have the following potential conflicts of interest to report:

Consulting Abbott, Boston, Gore, Medtronic

Employment in industry

Stockholder of a healthcare company

Owner of a healthcare company

Other(s)

I do not have any potential conflict of interest

Page 3: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Charles Dotter: 1920-1985

Page 4: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

A Number of UNMET needs in the Femoro-popliteal Segment

IT’S A HOSTILE ENVIRONMENT…

1. Considerable mechanical strain

2. Often heavily Calcified

3. Elastic recoil and dissection are common

4. Metallic devices are prone to fracture

Page 5: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA…

POBA

Page 6: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA…

BMS POBA

Page 7: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA…

DCB POBA BMS

Page 8: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA…

DES POBA BMS

DCB

Page 9: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA… MIMETIC STENTS

POBA BMS

DCB DES

Page 10: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Options for the SFA… STENT-GRAFT

POBA BMS

DCB DES

MIMETIC STENTS

Page 11: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Other Devices (Less frequently used in Aust)

ATHERECTOMY TACKS

SHORT MULTI-STENTS

CRYOPLASTY

HYBRID STENTS

Page 12: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

It’s a Minefield!

Page 13: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

%

Lesion Length (mm)

12-month Primary Patency – All Multi-CTs and Registries

POW. Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

DURABILITY 200. BosiersM. JVS. 2011;54:1042-50

STELLA. Davaine JM. EJVES 2012;44:332-41

VIABAHN TASC C&D. Schneider JR. VES 2011;45(5):391-7

SUPERA 500. Werner M. Euroint 2014;10:861-868

BRESCIA etal-

SUPERA

ZILVER PTX. Bosiers M. JCS 2013; 54:115-22

STELLA PTX Davaine JM. EJVES 2015;50:631-7

Brescia AA. Etal 2015;61:1472-8

VIPER. Saxon RR. JVIR 2013;24:165-173

VIBRANT. Geraghty PJ. JVS 2013;58(2):395

SUPERA 500-SUPERA

DURABILITY 200-BMS STELLA-BMS

ZILVER PTX-DES

VIABAHN TASC C&D-SG

STELLA PTX-DES

VIPER-SG

POW-SUPERA

VIBRANT-SG

VIBRANT-BMS

Combination of All Publications

Page 14: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

%

Lesion Length (mm)

12-month Primary Patency – All Multi-CTs and Registries

BMS

POW. Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

DURABILITY 200. BosiersM. JVS. 2011;54:1042-50

STELLA. Davaine JM. EJVES 2012;44:332-41

VIABAHN TASC C&D. Schneider JR. VES 2011;45(5):391-7

SUPERA 500. Werner M. Euroint 2014;10:861-868

ZILVER PTX. Bosiers M. JCS 2013; 54:115-22

STELLA PTX Davaine JM. EJVES 2015;50:631-7

Brescia AA. Etal 2015;61:1472-8

VIPER. Saxon RR. JVIR 2013;24:165-173

VIBRANT. Geraghty PJ. JVS 2013;58(2):395

BRESCIA etal-

SUPERA SUPERA 500-SUPERA

ZILVER PTX-DES

VIABAHN TASC C&D-SG

STELLA PTX-DES

VIPER-SG

POW-SUPERA

VIBRANT-SG

Combination of All Publications

Page 15: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

%

Lesion Length (mm)

12-month Primary Patency – All Multi-CTs and Registries

BMS

POW. Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

DURABILITY 200. BosiersM. JVS. 2011;54:1042-50

STELLA. Davaine JM. EJVES 2012;44:332-41

VIABAHN TASC C&D. Schneider JR. VES 2011;45(5):391-7

SUPERA 500. Werner M. Euroint 2014;10:861-868

ZILVER PTX. Bosiers M. JCS 2013; 54:115-22

STELLA PTX Davaine JM. EJVES 2015;50:631-7

Brescia AA. Etal 2015;61:1472-8

VIPER. Saxon RR. JVIR 2013;24:165-173

VIBRANT. Geraghty PJ. JVS 2013;58(2):395

DES

BRESCIA etal-

SUPERA SUPERA 500-SUPERA

VIABAHN TASC C&D-SG

VIPER-SG

POW-SUPERA

VIBRANT-SG

Combination of All Publications

Page 16: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

%

Lesion Length (mm)

12-month Primary Patency – All Multi-CTs and Registries

BMS

POW. Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

DURABILITY 200. BosiersM. JVS. 2011;54:1042-50

STELLA. Davaine JM. EJVES 2012;44:332-41

VIABAHN TASC C&D. Schneider JR. VES 2011;45(5):391-7

SUPERA 500. Werner M. Euroint 2014;10:861-868

ZILVER PTX. Bosiers M. JCS 2013; 54:115-22

STELLA PTX Davaine JM. EJVES 2015;50:631-7

Brescia AA. Etal 2015;61:1472-8

VIPER. Saxon RR. JVIR 2013;24:165-173

VIBRANT. Geraghty PJ. JVS 2013;58(2):395

DES

SG

BRESCIA etal-

SUPERA SUPERA 500-SUPERA POW-SUPERA

Combination of All Publications

Page 17: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

%

Lesion Length (mm)

12-month Primary Patency – All Multi-CTs and Registries

BMS

POW. Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

DURABILITY 200. BosiersM. JVS. 2011;54:1042-50

STELLA. Davaine JM. EJVES 2012;44:332-41

VIABAHN TASC C&D. Schneider JR. VES 2011;45(5):391-7

SUPERA 500. Werner M. Euroint 2014;10:861-868

Combination of All Publications

ZILVER PTX. Bosiers M. JCS 2013; 54:115-22

STELLA PTX Davaine JM. EJVES 2015;50:631-7

Brescia AA. Etal 2015;61:1472-8

VIPER. Saxon RR. JVIR 2013;24:165-173

VIBRANT. Geraghty PJ. JVS 2013;58(2):395

DES

SG

SUPERA

Page 18: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Tepe G. LINC 2016

40.4% Had Bailout

Stent

Page 19: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Long Complex Disease: Lesion lengths 126-199mm; ISR 13-27%; Retro access 3-11%; Prov stent(DCB) 21%

Page 20: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

“The Algorithm” (lesions >15cm) Pre-Dilate

Good Result (VERY RARE)

(DCB)

Page 21: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

“The Algorithm” (lesions >12cm) Pre-Dilate

Good Result (VERY RARE)

Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)

(DCB) STENT

Page 22: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

“The Algorithm” (lesions >12cm) Pre-Dilate

Good Result (VERY RARE)

Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)

(DCB) STENT

Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved

SUPERA

1o

Page 23: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

“The Algorithm” (lesions >12cm) Pre-Dilate

Good Result (VERY RARE)

Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)

(DCB) STENT

Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved

SUPERA DCB with Provisional (SPOT) Stent

BMS

1o 2o

Page 24: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

Tepe G. LINC 2016

Page 25: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

“The Algorithm” (lesions >12cm) Pre-Dilate

Good Result (VERY RARE)

Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON)

(DCB) STENT

Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved

SUPERA DES or

SG

DCB with Provisional (SPOT) Stent

BMS

1o 2o

Specialised applications

eg Fresh thrombus or SFA ostium 3o

Page 26: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

POW Supera Experience 2012-2014 (n=146 Supera stents; n=111 Limbs; mean length 151mm)

Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

12-month

Primary

Patency

78.4%

Page 27: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

POW Supera Experience 2012-2014 (n=146 Supera stents; n=111 Limbs; mean length 151mm)

Myint M. 2016 JEVT (in press)

12-month

FF

CD-TLR

86.3%

Page 28: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

CONCLUSIONS

• Little DATA for Long, Complex Fem-Pop Lesions

• Almost none is comparative

• Most complex disease requires scaffolding

• What data exists suggests Interwoven Nitinol Stents have excellent patency

• Alternatives such as DCB with spot stenting may have particular utility in small arteries

Page 29: AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH · Pre-Dilate Good Result (VERY RARE) Dissection or Recoil (MOST COMMON) (DCB) STENT Heavy Ca/Severe Recoil/Pop involved SUPERA DES or SG DCB with Provisional

AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE WITH

Associate Professor Ramon L. Varcoe FRACS, PhD

Sydney, Australia