8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

1/28

^|fzf`tfo lw=

^bgccg~ I|fglf|d .

Kg|tg Khkkh|.

_v @da.

\hmyff| Ogooh`

HZZF_ EH\KF_ LVLLCF

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

2/28

HDF@OH

Ov|g`d tbf jv||f`t ig`h`jghc j|gzgz# yh|gavz fja`aegztz h`o eh|kftjaeef`thta|z bhyf |f~fhtfocw hzkfo ia| ea`fth|w hvtba|gtgfz tazth|t ~v|zvg`d |fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ~acgjw bf`fyf| tbf|f h|fjhzf ai hzzft eh`ghz h`o tbvz ~|gjk hzzft eh|kft lvllcfz"g`jcvog`d ztajk eh|kft lvllcfz'.

Ba avco wav hzzfzz tbfzf ~|a~azhcz gtb |fz~fjt ta ztajkeh|kftz1 Tbht avco tbf ge~cgjhtga`z lf ia| jh~gthc hccajhtga`g` tbf fja`aew gi ea`fth|w hvtba|gtgfz ofjgofo ta ~v|zvf tbgzzt|htfdw1

Gz gt ~azzglcf ta ofzgd` h` g`yfztef`t zt|htfdw tbht avco dhg`i|ae tbf v~zgof ai h lvllcf lvt hyago h`w ~atf`tghc oa`zgof1"gf. Jh` wav eh|kft tgef1' .

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

3/28

LvllcfzLvllcfz j|fhtf jh~hjgtw# bgjb gz `a ca`df| `ffofoa`jf tbfw ofichtf. g#f# "xvgjk h`o ~hg`ivc' ja||fjtga`

lftff` tbf |fhc yhcvf ai tbf v`of|cwg`d hzzftz h`o tbfg`ichtfo ~|gjf

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

4/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

5/28

8. _vcg~ Eh`gh

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

6/28

\fzt|gjtgyf a`fth|w ^acgjw

w Tbf` ea`fth|w ~acgjw ehkf|z thkf hjtga`z ta |fovjf h`htga`$z ea`fw zv~~cw.

w ^|fyf`tga`!Zacvtga`= \fovjf g`ichtga`.

w Hjtga`z=

Zfccg`d dayf|`ef`t la`oz# g`j|fhzg`d lh`kz$ |fzf|yf |fxvg|fef`tz#

g`j|fhzg`d tbf ogzjav`t |htf.

Fiifjtz=

|fovjf tbf ea`fw zv~~cw "bh|of| ta la||a'. fhzfz g`ichtga`h|w ~|fzzv|fz lw caf|g`d tbf heav`t ai

ea`fw hyhgchlcf ia| z~f`og`d.

w Lf`figtz= F`zv|f zthlgcgtw g` tbf `htga`$z ~|gjf zwztfe.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

7/28

Ogiif|f`t Ygfz= ea`fth|w fja`aegjz

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

8/28

Tbw \fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ^acgjw11

La|oa h`o Mfh``f zvddfzt tbht |fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ~acgjw g` tbf ihjf ai h ztajk eh|kft

laae gz a~tgehc bf` tbf |gzk ai h lvzt gz ch|df h`o ea`fth|w hvtba|gtgfz jh` ofivzf gt

ht h |fchtgyfcw ca jazt.

H jazt zbajk tbht g`j|fhzfz g`ichtga` ehw |fxvg|f h |fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ~acgjw g` a|of| ta

~|fyf`t |fchtgyf ~|gjf g`j|fhzfz i|ae z`alhccg`d g`ta h` g`ichtga`h|w z~g|hc .

\fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ~acgjw bhz zba` gtz fiifjtgyf`fzz gtb ja`zgof|hlcf ia|jf. Df|eh`w#bgjb fr~f|gf`jfo bw~f|g`ichtga` ov|g`d tbf Tfgeh| \f~vlcgj h`o fyf| ia|dat# bhz

ehg`thg`fo h yf|w zthlcf ea`fth|w |fdgef h`o |fzvctg`d ca cfyfcz ai g`ichtga`

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

9/28

Tbw @at \fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ^acgjw1

Oa`$t |fz~a`o ta hzzft ~|gjfz ~f| zf |htbf| |fz~a`o ta jbh`dfz

g` tbf avtcaak ia| g`ichtga` h`o hdd|fdhtf ofeh`o |fzvctg`d

i|ae hzzft ~|gjf eayfef`tz .

\fhza`z=

00Hzzft ~|gjf lvllcfz jh` lf bh|o ta gof`tgiw = jh` cfho ta

fhkf| fja`aegj d|atb .

00Fiifjt ai g`tf|fzt |htfz a` hzzft ~|gjf lvllcfz gz bgdbcw

v`jf|thg`.

00_bf|f h|f eh`w hzzft ~|gjfz# h`o ht h`w a`f tgef h lvllcf

ehw lf ~|fzf`t g` a`cw h i|hjtga` ai hzzftz.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

10/28

Ja`zgof|htga`z

Jf`t|hc lh`kz evzt jh|fivccw fgdbfja`aegj ja`ogtga`z# hz efhzv|fo

lw ohth a` |fthgc h`o bacfzhcf~|gjfz# v`fe~cawef`t |htfz# d|azzoaefztgj ~|aovjt# h`o atbf|efhzv|fz# lfia|f f`hjtg`d ea`fth|w~acgjw.

Ayf|cw |fzt|gjtgyf efhzv|fz javcobhe~f| ja`zve~tga` h`og`yfztef`t.

G VZ ea`fth|w ~acgjw hz bgdbcw |fzt|gjtgyf i|ae 87

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

11/28

Fiifjtz ta jh~gthc hccajhtga` g` tbf fja`aew

w Ea`fth|w ^acgjw a` tbf Frjbh`df \htf h`o Lhch`jf%ai%^hwef`tz

w _bf ogiigjvctw ai ja`t|accg`d tbf ea`fw zv~~cw v`of| igrfo

frjbh`df |htfz gz frhjf|lhtfo lw g`tf|`htga`hc jh~gthc ealgcgtw

bgjb ~|fyf`tz oaefztgj g`tf|fzt |htfz i|ae ofyghtg`d

zvlzth`tghccw i|ae g`tf|`htga`hc cfyfc.

w \fzt|gjtgyf ea`fth|w ~acgjw |hgzfz tbf zv~~cw zjbfovcf ai iv`oz

h`o tbvz |hgzfz tbf fxvgcgl|gve jazt ai jh~gthc# |fovjg`d

g`yfztef`t

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

12/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

13/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

14/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

15/28

zv~f| lvllcfw zvl ~|gef bavzg`d lvllcf ai >2 g` VZ# cfho ta tbf

lv|zt ai tbf zv~f| lvllcf ai tbf j|fogt fr~h`zga` % tbf

fyf| g`j|fhzg`d vzf ai j|fogt h`o cfyf|hdf.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

16/28

^|aigt i|ae tbf lvllcf1w |fjad`g}f h`o ~|aigt i|ae gof ogz~h|gtw lftff`

g`yfzta| ~f|jf~tga`z h`o eh|kft iv`ovef`thcz

w Lf ifh|ivc bf` fyf|wlaow gz d|ffow h`o d|ffow bf`fyf|wlaow gz ifh|ivc

Th||f` Lviift

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

17/28

Eftbaoz=w V`of|zth`o tbf V`of|cwg`d G`ovzt|w

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

18/28

w

^fa~cf f|f ~v|jbhzg`d lvclz ht bgdbf| h`o bgdbf|~|gjfz# g`tf`og`d ta |f%zfcc tbfe ia| h ~|aigt.Ht tbf~fhk ai tvcg~ eh`gh g` Ifl|vh|w89:4# zaef zg`dcf tvcg~lvclz zaco ia| ea|f tbh` 8> tgefz tbf h``vhc g`jaef ai hzkgccfo j|hitzeh`. "46 >>> /'

w Bafyf|# zvjb h zjbfef

javco `at chzt v`cfzz zaefa`f

hz vctgehtfcw gccg`d ta ~hw

zvjb bgdb ~|gjfz h`o thkf~azzfzzga`

ai tbf lvclz.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

19/28

Eftbaoz=w Iacca tbf Jv||f`jw

w ,Gjavco`$t bhyf `at cazt ea`fw chzt wfh| v`cfzz Ghz8>>& g` jhzb

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

20/28

w Ia| frhe~cf h bgdbf| agc ~|gjf h`o z~fjvchtgyf jh~gthc g`icazo|gyg`d \vzzgh` h~~|fjghtfo tbf \vzzgh` |vllcf. Lvt bgcf tbfzt|a`d |avlcf ehw lf h ~azgtgyf zgd`hc ia| g`yfzta|z# gt bhz j|fhtfogtz a` ~|alcfez= fr~a|t jae~ftgtgyf`fzz h`o# a|zf# tbf~azzglgcgtw ai h f hzzft lvllcf a||w fr~f|tz. "I_'

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

21/28

w Jbgffzf tbf |f`eg`lg gz v`of|yhcvfo# h`o z~fjvchta|z jh`la||a ayf|cw jbfh~cw g` @f Wa|k ta ig`h`jf bat ea`fw icaz

g`ta Jbg`h h`o atbf| fef|dg`d eh|kftz. A`f ja`zfxvf`jf gz hbvdf lvllcf g` Jbg`h$z jaeef|jghc h`o |fzgof`tghc |fhc fzthtfeh|kftz# bgjb gz ia|jg`d tbf ^LJ ta t|w ta jv|l tbf fr~h`zga` aioaefztgj lh`k j|fogt.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

22/28

Eftbaoz=w Iacca tbf Jav`t|gfz

w Jbg`h= eh`w g`yfzta|z h|f ja`jf|`fo tbht hzzftlvllcfz tbht ia|eg`d g` |fhc fzthtf# lh`kg`d# h`o g`tbf ztajk eh|kft.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

23/28

Ka`o|htgfii Thyfzw tbf v`of|cwg`d fja`aegj ja`ogtga`z gcc |f~fht ayf|

tgef ovf mvzt ta tbf ~bwzgjhc `htv|f ai av| a|co

w

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

24/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

25/28

w

Lvw h ztajk h hgt ia| jf|thg` zgd`hcz "fd. G`j|fhzf g`g`tf|fzt |htf' lfia|f f jh` zth|t zfccg`d gt.

w Da ca`d h jhcc.

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

26/28

wLvw ztajk h`o zfcc h ~vt ^|atfjtgyf ~vt

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

27/28

8/8/2019 Asset Market Bubble

28/28

_B @K IA\ G _ @G@D