Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

24
Assemblages of Resistance: New media, old technology & the Egyptian uprising

description

Paper presented by Dan Mcquillan and myself at the Network Politics conference, Cambridge, 15 May 2011. The presentation is text heavy, so I strongly suggest consulting the notes as you view.

Transcript of Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Page 1: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Assemblages of Resistance:New media, old technology & the Egyptian

uprising

Page 2: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Our aim is to kill over-simplistic conceptualisations of the social web that lead to unsatisfactory analyses and limit

scope for praxis

We then suggest what this re-conceptualisation tells us about the direction of future research as well as tactics for resistance

Page 3: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Current theories are built predominantly on ‘relations between parts and wholes, wholes that constitute a seamless totality or that

display an organic unity" (DeLanda 2006, 9) represented by platform or technology focused approaches to analysis

Page 4: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Chadwick’s work on ‘digital network repertoires’ and ‘organisational hybridity’ (2005 & 2007) opens new

possibilities for conceptualising the social web’s role in political mobilisation

Page 5: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Organisational hybridity limits a full reconceptualisation of the social web due to it recombination of ”pre-existing forms"

(2005, 2)

Chadwick’s recent work opens up further possibilities by drawing on the concept of assemblages (DeLanda 2006;

Deleuze & Guattari 1987)

Page 6: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Assemblage theory is taken as our conceptual starting point as it enables us to interpret networked activism as ‘a

multiplicity of elements without effacing their heterogeneity or hindering their potential for future rearranging’ (Deleuze

& Guattari 1987)

Page 7: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Networked activism emerging from assemblages built on contingent logic can’t be interpreted by thought alone. We need to empirically capture and study the associative ‘traces’ left behind (Latour 2005)

Page 8: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Following internet cut-off a “pragmatic deconstruction of the social web” (McQuillan 2011)

takes place a re-assembling of activist practices becomes visible

Page 9: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Post cut-off timeline

McQuillan 2011

Page 10: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 11: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

Components function at different scales and in different forms along a

material <-> expressive axis…

Page 12: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

… and territorialising <-> deterritorialising

Page 13: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

The emergence of capacities expressed through open-ended combinatory possibilities of material-expressive and territorialising-deterritorialising effects can’t be accounted for a priori.

Thus containment strategies become impossible and the contingent logic of assemblages becomes a tactic of resistance.

Page 14: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

(CC BY-NC-SA 2.0) by 3arabawy on Flickr

Page 15: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 16: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 17: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 18: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 19: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 20: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 21: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 22: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 23: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising
Page 24: Assemblages of Resistance: new media, old technology and the Egyptian Uprising

“We do not know of what the body is capable”