A Dissertation on Mans Fall, Translated From the High-German Original
Article translated from original Dutch language The water method · 2018. 3. 7. · 1 Article...
Transcript of Article translated from original Dutch language The water method · 2018. 3. 7. · 1 Article...
1
ArticletranslatedfromoriginalDutchlanguage
The water method Intact preservation of the young deceased fetus
Dr.I.K.F.Tiemens-vanPutten,co-assistantVUH.J.LenderinkclinicalobstetricianSpaarneGasthuisDr.J.F.M.MolkenboergynaecologistSpaarneGasthuis
Whattodowiththefetusaftera(spontaneous)abortionorimmaturebirthuntilthefuneralorcremation?Wewilldescribeawayinwhichthefetusremainspresentableforlongersothattheparentscansaygoodbyetotheirchild.
Case 1 A33-yearG3P2presentedat17weeksgestationwithaIUFD.ACRLwasechoscopicallymeasuredinaccordancewith14+0weeksandHCinaccordancewith14+5weeksgestation.ItwasanundisturbedpregnancyuntilthatpointwithanormalNTmeasurement.Labourwasinducedwithmisoprostolafterpreparationwithmifepristoneat17+2weeksgestation.Thepatientindicatedthatshewantedthefetustobekeptinwaterafterthebirth.Shehopedthatbykeepingthefetusinwater,itwouldremainpresentableforlonger.Accordingtothepatient'swish,themaceratedfetuswasplacedinatransparentplasticcontainerfilledwithcoldtapwaterimmediatelyafterbirth(Fig.1).
Fig.1.Fetusintapwater
Thismadeiteasierfortheparentstolookatthefetus.Thefetuswaskeptathomeinthefridgeuntilthefuneralthefollowingday.Notable,wasthatthefetus’scolourturnedfrombrowntopinkduringthenight.Loosebitsofskinwerealsoremovedbyhand,makinghimevenmorephotogenic(Fig.2).
2
Fig.2.Fetusafteranightincoldwater
Unfortunatelymorethanhalfayearlaterthepatientpresentedwithanothermissedabortion,thistimeat14+6weeks,withafetuswithaCRLof14+0weeks.Thispregnancy,too,hadbeenundisturbeduptothatpoint,andnothinguntowardhadbeenobservedatthe12-weekultrasound.
Thisfetuswasalsobornfollowinginductionwithmifepristoneandmisoprostolandplacedincoldtapwaterafterthebirth.Giventhatthisfetuswaslessmacerated,thebloodvesselswereclearlyvisibleatbirth.Afterafewhoursinthewatertheysubsided.Thisfetuswaspinkatbirthandfollowinganightinthefridgeonlybecameslightlypaler(fig3).
w
Fig.3.Fetusinaccordancewith14weeksgestationincoldwater
Case 2 Thepatientwaspregnantwithmonochorionicdiamnioticgemelli.Shepresentedat16+6weeksgestationwithanIUFDofbothchildren,bothwithhydropsanddifferenceinamnioticfluid.Thepatientgavebirthvaginallyfollowinginductionwithmifepristoneandmisoprostoltotwolifelessboys.Givenourexperiencewiththepreviouspatient,theoptionofplacingthechildrenincoldwaterwasdiscussedwiththepatientandherpartner.Theywelcomedthis(fig.4).
3
Fig4.Gemelliinaccordancewith16weeksgestationincoldwater
Thetwinswerelater,asisthenormintheNetherlands,laiddryinatray,afterwhichtheusualsofteninganddistortionofbothfetusesquicklyoccurred.(Fig.5).
Fig5.Gemelliafterbeingremovedfromthewater
Discussion
The(unexpected)lossofan(early)pregnancyisaneventthatmostexpectantparentsarenotpreparedfor.Thiscanhavepsychologicalconsequences,suchasdepression,posttraumaticstressdisorderoranxiety,whichcanhaveanegativeeffectonlaterpregnancies1.IntheirstudySäflandetaldescribe6qualitiesthatparentsofstillbornchildrenseekintheircareproviders2.Oneorbothparentsof31stillbornchildrenwereinterviewedtwiceabouttheirviewandexperienceontheprocessaftertheirstillbirths.Oneofthequalitiesishelpwithmeetingandsayinggoodbyetothestillbornchild.Inouropinionitmeansparentscansaygoodbyetothefetusinhis/hermostintactform.Traditionally,deceasedfetusesusedforeducationorexhibitionsareconservedinso-called'strongwater'.Acombinationofwaterwithformaldehydeorethanol.Thismethodishighlysuitedforviewingandpreservingthefetusfromallaspects.Duetotheincreasedavailabilityofprenataldiagnostics,(wanted)pregnanciesaremoreoftenterminated.Thegynaecologistwillthereforebeincreasinglydealingwithparentswhowanttosaygoodbyetotheirnewbornchild.Inthissituation
4
thereisnoneedtoaddethanolorformaldehydetothewater,sincethefetuswillonlybekeptforashorttime,untilthefuneralorcremation.
Previously,afetuswasoftenplacedonacellulosemat,acardboardbasinoronacloth.Thefetuscouldthenreallynotbemovedduetoriskofdamage.Thechild’scolourwouldgetdarkerand,formostpeople,lessbeautifulandrecognizableduetosofteninganddeformation.Inmaceratedchildren,thiseffectismuchfasterandmorevisible.Wehavenowappliedthismethodofpreservingthefetusinthiswayonnumerousoccasions.Weseegoodresults,thefetusesstaypresentableformuchlongerandifthey’dliketo,theparentscantakepictures.Nomatterhowyoung,afetuscanbeverypresentable,evenwithextensivemaceration.
Thewatermethoddoesnotrequireanyspecialchangeofprocess,andisinexpensive.Itisadvisabletohavesomeclearplasticcontainerswithlidsindifferentsizesinyourdeliveryrooms,forthefetustobetakenhomein,ifsodesired.
Wehavenotbeenabletofindthiswatermethodinanyliterature.Wehopetoraiseawarenessofotherwaysoflookingafteradeceasedfetusthroughthisarticle.
Wewouldbegladtohearabouttheexperiencesothershavehadwiththewatermethod.
Conclusion Thewatermethodispotentiallyagoodwayofpreservingtheyoungfetusuntilthefuneralorcremation,anddeservesfurtherattention.
5
Summary
Thisarticleintroducesthewatermethod,inwhichcoldtapwaterisusedtoshowtheyoungdeceasedfetusinitsmostoptimalformtotheparents.Theresultisthatthefetusretainsitsshapeandcolourforlongerandtheparentshavetheopportunitytosaygoodbye.
Keywords
IUFD,partusimmaturus,watermethod,spontaneousabortion,preservation,shaperetention
Authors
Dr.I.K.F.Tiemens-vanPutten,co-assistantH.J.LenderinkclinicalobstetricianSpaarneGasthuisDr.J.F.M.Molkenboer,gynaecologistSpaarneGasthuisContactdetailsI.K.F.Tiemens-vanPuttenMambo65 2152SXNieuwVennepilonatiemens@live.nl0252-685538DeclarationofconflictofinterestTheauthorsstatethatthereisno(financial)conflictofinterest.
1WeissL,FrischerL,RichmanJ.Parentaladjustmenttointrapartumanddeliveryroomloss.Theroleofahospital-basedsupportprogram.ClinPerinatol1989;16:1009-19.2SäflundK,SjögrenB,WredlingR.Theroleofcaregiversafterastillbirth:viewsandexperiencesofparents.Birth2004;31:132-7.