Apsa Cdjune2012

download Apsa Cdjune2012

of 42

  • date post

    08-Aug-2018
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    213
  • download

    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of Apsa Cdjune2012

  • 8/22/2019 Apsa Cdjune2012

    1/42

    Comparat ive Democrat izat ionVolume 10, No. 2 June 201

    The Ame r i c an Po l i t i c a l Sc i ence Assoc i a t i o n

    ODolltCocptalArttMichael Coppedge

    ArbttoGllrmoODollRobert Kauman

    EdtoralLttrODolladAmrcaPoltcalSccLaurence Whitehead

    AItllctalRblRobert M. Fishman

    RctootCotrbtooGllrmoODollJames Mahoney

    Strog-StatDmocratzatoAaDan Slater and Joseph Wong

    CaPacBEgrd?Andres Wimmer

    TUtltotVartoDmocarcyDatatKelly M.McMann

    SctoNw

    EdtoralCommtt

    OD Onnellthe COnCeptual artist

    r ar may way to cotrbt to t col lct v trpr w cal lcomparatv polt c. Som o drv t logcal mplcato o bacampto;omgtdtadotactortytdy;omrcotrctcaalproc;omgatrdata;omdvlopbttrrarcmtod;omttypot.Adom,lkGllrmoODoll,cagtwaywt

    wor ld.

    Gllrmo ODoll mad may kd o cotrbto to ocal cc, cldgmtorggratootdtadbldgCEDESadtKlloggIttt;btgrattcotrbtowrtcocptcratd.Itmaymaytocoawtrm,bt vtg a cocpt tat captr amportat pomo owll tat vryopcktpadtararacvmt.RobrtDal(adCarlLdblom)ddtwt pol yarcy, JaLz wt ator tar am,Ard Ljpart wt cooc at oaldmocracy,daSkocpolwtocalrvolto;adtrarawotr.Gllrmoaccompld t at rpatdly, wt bracratc-atortara rgm, mpoblgam, brow ara, dlgatv dmocracy, ad at lat om o t may vocatv

    Michael Coppedge, University o Notre Dame

    (continued on page 5)

    a tributetO GuillermO O DOnnell

    Robert Kauman, Rutgers University

    IadtgratprvlgokowgGllrmooralmotortyyaradoworkgwtmatvaropo ta logtway.Hwabotatllctamodladapoltcalprato.Aaacadmc,ltamajormarkoalat trgratoo colarp oLatAmrca, bggwt

    brllatworkobracratc-atortaramadxtdgtrogwrtgodmocratc trat o,dmocratc accotab lt y,adrlolaw.I tkgadwrtg,waotolyaadotcrv;apdt.ODollltalworkobracratcatortaramwaprrdbytmrgco rgt-wg mltary dctatorp t two mot dtralzd cotr o LatAmrcaBrazl1964adArgta1966.1Haalyotvtprovddagcatcallgtowdpradamptoabott potvcto dvlopmodmocracy.Itocdtadotcocratcrpototxatoomport-1.GllrmoODoll,Modernization and Bureaucratic Authoritarianism: Studies in South American Politics. Politics o

    Modernization,o9.(Brkly:ItttoItratoalStd,1973).(continued on page 6)

    RememberingGuillermo

    ODonnell

    In h i s I s s u e

    CDAP ASS

    1

    1

    12

    2

    3

    3

    4

    4

    29

    42

    T a or arwll.Or ympom aclbrato o t work adloGllrmoODoll,

    atowrggrttdyo dmocratzato wopad away o Novmbr29,2011.Wakdvralo collag, collaborator,ad admrr to p ortrcollcto abot mad cotrbto. Tmblattttotrgardwc t dcpl ldm. W alo prt tr

    FrO mthe eDitOrial

    bOarD

    (continued on page 5)

  • 8/22/2019 Apsa Cdjune2012

    2/422

    C om p a r a t i v e D em o c r a t i z a t i o nVol. 10, No. 2 June 20

    A r t i c l es

    GuillermO ODOnnellan D ameriCan pOlitiCal sCienCe

    GllrmoODollddBoArNovmbr2011attago75.Aa por teotwawrblogdattdol,adMarc2012waaccorddacommmoratotr.Btwa alo a ctz o t wor ld, ad a mot lta l ad d tctv voc dmocratzato td adcomparatvpoltc, rt atYaladt WloCtr, adort latqartrctry atNotrDamwrwaodg drctoro t ovat v HlKl loggIttt.Hwaaloa powr lcotrbtortoaboyattradorarcoAmrcaPoltcalScc,botaadradaotdr.

    Hrtwortpagoramomt,botovrtlablAmrcaadPoltcalScc.IbyAmrcawdrtadactzotAmrcawolvdadbratdtopadtragdopoltcallmaypartotwtr mprovrtpatalctry,tddwamoroaAmrcatamot.NotolytbttrtrmoloArgta,balotcomplxadmood-wtcgjei tinhooBrazlapoltc,adtmorordrly,btotcarlymoradmrabl

    poltcotUSAaborbddalyrgadlpdtoprcomparatvadtortcalcratvty.Byoddrctgagmtaactzawllaacolartotrato,waclolyxpodtopoltcalraltotAmrcarpblcwrdaacqrdroacad/orwrcollagadtdtdrwm.Byodtwtrmpraloxrtdlc,orxamplSpaadawa,btabovallwagroddtAmrca.Atamtm,ad odobtaa coqcotcott-wdbackgrod, waalovry rm tctat t Amrca dgatoold ot b mproprlyappropratd by jt o o t cotr to wc trr

    Laurence WhiteheadNu ield College, Oxord University

    an intelleCtual rebel WhO ChanGeD the mai nstre am

    GllrmoODollwaatllctalrbltrogadtrog,ytcagdmatramacadmcworkar mor ta maygtd colar woavcot tlyworkdwttparamtr tab ldbyxtgcovto.Hlavbdawaltoworktatwllamplyrwardtoworadadrradtdpt.Hcallgtotmatramwaatoctortcal,mtodologcal,btatvadtyltcytcottlyogttogagwttworktatcrtqdaogogdalog

    trogwcdamtallytraormdvralltratr.

    ODollworkxmpltvrtorgtocoobtwtllctalpoloroptotatmotcovtoalcolar td to aaltratvapproac toocal ctc work. Bot t xtraordary tmatc bradtotrdcplary radgad commtmt toormlatgtorzatorootd cotxtallyrcadotca-pcckowldg, ODoll wa a dtgd practtor o t o-Wbra cool, caractrzd by tmltaombracotarcortorcallymbdddcomplxtyadgralzgtory. 1Ytwaaadptaayoprat gaggtlattargmtcomparatvpoltcalcc,poltcaltory,poltcalocologyadpoltcalcoomy.

    1.RobrtM.Fma,OBgaWbra(atrSpa1114Marc):NototCotgRlvacotMtodologcalPrpctvPropodbyWbr,LarcMcFall,d., Webers Objectivity Reconsidered(oroto:UvrtyoorotoPr,2007),261-289.

    Robert M. FishmanUniversity o Notre Dame

    (continued on page 8

    (continued on page 9

  • 8/22/2019 Apsa Cdjune2012

    3/423

    C om p a r a t i v e D em o c r a t i z a t i o nVol. 10, No. 2 June 20

    reFleCtiOns On the COntributiOns OF GuillermO O DOnnell

    ItmpobltomagwattldocomparatvpoltcwoldlooklkwtottcotrbtooGllrmoODoll.Hrpobloromayoorbtcocptbracratcatortaram,dlgatvdmocracy,orzotalaccotablty,browara,toamawadomayormotproodtortcalgttattxrcovogacomparatvpoltcwtotODollvolattmmalrwrtrlocotractalaaly.WGllrmoODolldd,poltcalcclotootgratttkradmotltalcolar.

    Drgcarr,ODollrpatdlytttortcaladmprcalagdaorworkcomparatvpoltc.HalyottcocratcadarbradoatortaramxprcdSotAmrcat1960orvrcagdldocomparatvpoltc.otday, Modernization and Bureaucratic Authoritar ianismtadaatgxampltortcallgac,cocptalorgalty,adttltyopoltcalccortaalyomalymportat

    to.1WIoctrdtoakowldgaccmlatococrgatortaram,IodtatODollworkadtrggrd calargad rt ltramo rarcatocotttadt ct vGllrmoODollRarcProgram.tramorarcrpobloragooddalowatwowkowabottotadworkgotortaram.

    GllrmoA.ODoll,Modernization and Bureaucratic-Authoritarianism: Studies in South American Politics(Brkly:ItttooItratoalStd,UvrtyCalora,Brkly,1973).

    ames MahoneyNorthwestern University

    (continued on page 10 )

    COnCeDinGan D thrivinG: strO nG-state DemOCratizatiOnin asia

    Dan S later,University o Chicagooseph Wong, University o oronto

    Itwdlyargdtatrlgpartlptaatortarargm.Ootmotltalargmtorwyttcactropartycadrwlltopowr.prrcopartycadrarmcmplrtatoo[mltary]ocr,Gddpravly arg. Lk dmocratc poltca, ty mply wat to old oc.1

    Byodavgtttoalcapablttatmltarlack,atortararlgparttypcallyavtrogrrtctvtatrmltarycotrparttoclgtopowr.

    Yttr aaddtoaldamtal drcbtwr lgpartadml ta rtata otbadqat lyxplord,

    dwcoldmportatmplcatoor tlkloodo dmocratzato party-ldrgm. For rlgmltar,mocratzatoadwtdrawalromocaroadtam.Ytlkrlgmltar,rlgpartcadmocratzwtot logpowr.Forator tar apart,dmocratzato ta ltbtat al coco ad r k to oldradarlcto,btotcarlytolotolctoadwtdrawromoc.WatPrzworkmmorablycalldttttoalzdcrtaty2odmocracymaymacwgcrtavctory,bttdootmaaccptgcrtadat.Rlgpartcamatapowradavmatadpowrwtotmatagatortararl.Dmocratzatomaytbmorctv-compatbloratortaraparttatcovtoalwdomggt.

    BarbaraGdd,WatDoWKowAbotDmocratzatoAtrwtyYar? Annual Review o Political Science2(1999),p.129.

    AdamPrzwork,Democracy and the Market: Political and Economic Reorms in Eastern Europe and Latin America(NwYork:CambrdgUvrtyPr,1991).(continued on page 12)

    A r t i c l e

  • 8/22/2019 Apsa Cdjune2012

    4/424

    C om p a r a t i v e D em o c r a t i z a t i o nVol. 10, No. 2 June 20

    Can peaCe be enGineereD? institutiOns , pOlitiCal inClusiOn, anD ethniCCOnFliCt

    rarc ot addr t log-tadg dbat amog cotttoal gr ad comparatvpoltcalcttabotwctttorprttbttoolorprvtgcolcttcallydvddoct.mototdcdcaddatardmocracy,dralm,proportoalmormajortaram,adprdtalmorparlamtarm.Bycotrat,Iowotbaoytmatcqattatvvdctattttoarotctvprvtgarmdcolctorcvlwar.

    Ratr,Iarg,tdrlygpowrcogratoacotrycrcaltodrtadtcodtoorpac.Irlyoaroprvodg,1wcrprttbackdroportollowgaaly.UgtEtcPowrRlato(EPR)datattatcodpoltcallyrlvattcgropadtracctogovrmtpowrallcotradyarc1945,tprvorarcaowtattwopowrcogratoarpartclarlywar-pro:Wlarg,tcallyddgmtotpoplatoarotrprtdattgtlvlogovrmt,armdrbllotamo

    xclddpoplatomaymrg.Scod,agmbropowrargpartrcracrtyabottrallacadtcommtmtproblmtprt,makgtmorlklytatcompttobtwtcltargpowrcalattoarmdcolct.Scgtgbtwpowrargpartr,owvr,mclrqttarbllobyxclddgrop(20v.90armdtccolctogttworldc1945).powrcograto

    1.AdraWmmr,Lar-ErkCdrma,adBraM,EtcPoltcadArmdCoct.ACogratoalAalyoaNwGlobalDatat,AmericanSociological Review74(Aprl2009):316337.

    Andre as WimmerPrinceton University

    (continued on page 16)

    growtobatoaldmocratzatotddrgtlattwodcadalpllycomplcator drtadg o dmocracy ad, mor broadly, rgm ad rgm cotty ad cag. Wowavvdctatdmocratcclavxt mrocotr,wcwadcomortabllabldadmocratcordmocratzg.Ad,wavdtdcatoaccotortclavpcccotr.xttptoxpadtcopaddptoorkowldgotatwcarrgmtypologadtororgmcottyadcag.artclxamowbatoa

    datagratdbytVartoDmocracy(V-Dm)projctcalpacvt.Idogo,tollowromtprvowlttr,wccalldorw approacaddata tdygbatoaldmocratzatoHr,Ixamcallgbatoaldmocratzatotdavpodtotcovtoalwdom.,Icodrqtotatdtobawrdordrtomprovxtgtypologadtor,ad,ally,atactattV-Dmbatoaldatacaprovd.2

    1.S,partclar,omlaLaka,SypaEdavororWortwlUdrtakg? Te American Political Science Association Comparative Democratization Newslette10( Jaary2012)adAgtaGrady,SbatoalDmocracy:LoromLatAmrca,Te American Political Science Association Comparative Democratizatio

    Newsletter10(Jaary2012).

    2.TartclbtdromggtoromAgtaGrady,partcpattMargDmocracyWorkgGropatUvrtyoNotrDamKlloggItttorItratoalStd,adotrmmbrotV-Dmtam.Allrroradomoarmyow.

    imprOvinG theOriesOF reGimes, reGime COntinuity, anD reGime ChanGethrO uGh subnatiOnal researCh: the util it yOFthe var iet ies OF DemOCraCy Datas et

    Kelly M. McMannCase Western Reserve University

    (continued on page 24

    A r t i c l es

  • 8/22/2019 Apsa Cdjune2012

    5/425

    C om p a r a t i v e D em o c r a t i z a t i o nVol. 10, No