“Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... -...

35
DESY, 20.06.2008 “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of Wuppertal with W. Bartel, B. Löhr, E. Lohrmann and S. Schubert

Transcript of “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... -...

Page 1: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

DESY, 20.06.2008

“Testing Gravity”

Hinrich MeyerUni. of Wuppertal

withW. Bartel, B. Löhr, E. Lohrmann

and S. Schubert

Page 2: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

1.) Astronomy and Astrophysics

2.) Experiments in the laboratory

Outline:

Page 3: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

The are more things in heaven and earth,Horatio,

Than are dreamt of in your philosophy

Hamlet Act1, scene5

Page 4: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

anno 1632

Page 5: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

BBN successfully describing light element abundances in the

universeall but H

missing baryon problemFukugita, Peebles 1988

(BUT!!!!!)

Q: how much matter there is in the Universe???

Page 6: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

XMM NewtonESA X-RAY

Satellite

observingmissing

baryon fractionsolved??

Text

also spectral lines from intergalactic clouds

Page 7: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

virial lawE(kin)=-1/2E(pot)

Helvetica Physica Acta1933

Page 8: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Sanders, 1996

Page 9: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

MOND works:howeverneeds

Neutrinos with masssee

Zhao 2007

Page 10: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Vera Rubin 1970, with K. Ford

Rotation curves a generalphenomenon

Andromeda M31

Page 11: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Spiral Galaxies

Page 12: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

dwarf spheroidals

Page 13: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Sanders, Noordmeerearly type disks

2007

Page 14: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Scarpa, Gilmozzi, et al. 2006, globular clusters

Page 15: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

In the solar system??

at least two dramatic effects

a: “Pioneer” anamoly

b: “fly by” effect

again seem to be ruled bya(0) about cH!!

Page 16: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

F(grav)=GmM/r2

Newtons law

rules all bound systems in the universe

a: change M , by introducing CDM

b: change accel. by introducing a(0) at very small accel. a MOND

actually, a(0) is about cH

c: adding an Yukawa like term at very small distance

d: consider G to be time dependent

Page 17: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

“MOND”Milgrom 1983nonrelativistic

“TeVeS”Bekenstein 2004

relativistic extension

Proposals, to change Newtons Law

Page 18: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Thus, it is my personal opinion – and I am the only one responsible for it if proved wrong-- that if Newtonian dynamics fails below a0, this should be true irrespectively of the total field and one should be able to observe MOND effect also here on earth. For instance, I think a refined version of the Cavendish experiment studying gravitational forces in the horizontal plane should detect MOND effects.

R. Scarpa 2006

Page 19: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Laboratory experiments

Page 20: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

fieldmass560kg

now only5-40kg

thesis work bySchurr, Walesh, Schumacher,

Kleinevoss1992 - 2002with H. Piel

Univ of Wuppertal

Page 21: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint
Page 22: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

db =df constconst=10-9

(m/kHz)

thesisH. Walesch

Page 23: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

2006recent “G” results

Page 24: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint
Page 25: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint
Page 26: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Earthquake signal in GRAVI

Page 27: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

TextTextText

Noisenicely

Gaussian,very

crucial

frequencyvs.

time

Page 28: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

“Gravi” at DESY works!!! (18.6.2008)127Hz in 22GHz (1/10 nm)

Page 29: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint
Page 30: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Goals with “GRAVI” at DESY

a: measurements in theMOND region

b: accurate determinationof big “G”

Page 31: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

blue line prefered by astrophysical considerations

Page 32: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Schlamminger et al.Zürich

G measurment

Page 33: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

Eötwash

AdelbergersgroupSeattle

Page 34: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

equivalence principle

testSchlamminger et al.

2008

Page 35: “Testing Gravity” Hinrich Meyer Uni. of ... - DESYaxion-wimp2008.desy.de/e30/e259/talk-20-meyer.pdf · I like to thank DESY for unbureaucratic support. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint

fascinating timestesting

GRAVITYin the lab

I like to thank DESYfor unbureaucratic

support