Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load...

9
Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr´ ed´ eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet, A. Miraoui To cite this version: Fr´ ed´ eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet, A. Miraoui. Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor. Aegean Conference on Electrical Machines and Power Electronics (ACEMP), May 2004, Istanbul, Turkey. pp.283-290, 2004. <hal-00322428> HAL Id: hal-00322428 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00322428 Submitted on 17 Sep 2008 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ ee au d´ epˆ ot et ` a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´ es ou non, ´ emanant des ´ etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´ etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´ es.

Transcript of Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load...

Page 1: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface

Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor

Frederic Dubas, Christophe Espanet, A. Miraoui

To cite this version:

Frederic Dubas, Christophe Espanet, A. Miraoui. Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density inSurface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor. Aegean Conference on Electrical Machines andPower Electronics (ACEMP), May 2004, Istanbul, Turkey. pp.283-290, 2004. <hal-00322428>

HAL Id: hal-00322428

https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00322428

Submitted on 17 Sep 2008

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinee au depot et a la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publies ou non,emanant des etablissements d’enseignement et derecherche francais ou etrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou prives.

Page 2: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

������������ ���������������������������� "!#����%$&��'�(*)��+�-,.�//�

���10'�23�4�� 3�5����'���4�3�768�32391����������:�;�����3<�=��4��23,>@?.A8B3C3DFEHG�I&?4J�ELK3D4MONQPRGTSVU.WYX�U"Z[G�\�]^]^]_G"D"Ma`cbc?"dfehg�DFiFB�ej?

klnm�lno�p�q/r�sOo�t"u4pvo�wxuQpzy�{ |~}O��l�qLw�p�u�|�{xq�m��L}O�xl�q�wxp�{xq4o��[l/|��Q{�|�lLl�p�{ |F�^o�|����4y[mvw�lL�-m3�hsF}3};�[�v�T�;r�{�q/r�{�mOo���u[{�|[w.k�l�m�lHoRp�q/r��^|[{�wuQ�Fw�r�l��^|"{ ��l�pRm�{ w�y~u.����lnq�r[|[u[��u"��y^u.���;ln����uQp�w����#u�|4tF�/�x{�oRp������������#��o�|"�;wxr"lO�~|[{��[l/p�m�{�wxy^u.�F�Fpvo�|[qTr�lH����u���w������^������@{�wxr~wxr[l; �¡^k�}¢������|�£asFk�}¢�z�<¤a¥���¦�s�}O}������������1���o�wz¦ ���z�§k¢¨"l��r�{�lTp�pzy^�© �}¢ª;�L��«.¬4¬3¥�¬^��ln����uQpzwj¦}¢���-o�{x� ­ �hpvln�4lTpz{�q4¦ �Q¨4t�o�m�®c¨4wxt.�_¦ ��p � q�r[pz{�mRwxu4¯[r"l�¦ lTmv¯�o�|[lTw�®c¨4|[{������zqnu4�~w�l4¦ �xp ° oRtF�4ln����o�w�{���¦ ��{�p�o�u4¨[{�®c¨4wxt.�_¦ ��p��ln� ­H¤4¤���¬���¤�¦ ±Q²F¦ ³[±"¦ ¤�´�¦ µ�«@¶���o�· ­�¤4¤���¬.�z¤�¦ ±4²�¦ ³4±�¦ ¤�´F¦ ¤4´

¸@¹3ºh»R¼/½.¾�» �|¿w�r�{�mÀ¯�o�¯�l/pv��wxr�lÁo�¨4wxr[uQpRm#¯�p�lnm�l�|[w#oR|ÂoR|�o��xyQw�{�qnoL�qHo/�xq�¨"��o�w�{�u4|&{�|_u�p��4l/p�w�u�¯.pvl/�.{xq�w�w�r�l;|[u"���xu"o/���j� ¨[·_�4l/|�m�{ w�y{�|fmh¨.pz�zo/qnlÃ��u�¨.|4w�ln�*m�yL|Fq�r[pzuQ|[u4¨�mc¯Fl�pz��oR|�l�|[w���on�L|�lTw�-o/q�rF{ |�lnmL¦-��r"{xmÄo�|�oL� y§w�{�qHo/�&��u4�4l��<{�mÅt�oLmjln�¿uQ|%w���u[��[{ ��lT|�m�{�u�|�o/�"o�|�oT�xy[m�{xm�{ |�¯Fu4��o�pOq/u.u�pv�4{�|�o�w�lnm�o�|[�^rFo�m+t"lnl�|�[l���l/�xu�¯Fl/�~��u�p3t�u4w�r~¯�o�p�o/����ln�Fo�|"�^p�o��[{�oL�4��on�L|Fl�w�{�Ƨo�w�{xu�|�u4�wxr[l^�<o��§|[l/w�mT¦���r�lÇ|[u��h��uFo��È�-oL�L|�l�w�{xqÇ��lnqTw�u�p�¯"u�w�l/|4w�{�o��3{�mlHmhwzo�tF��{xmjr[ln�Ét"yÊmju.� ��{ |F�Ës+oR¯F��o�q�l�Ì�Í�u[{xm�mju4|�Î mÏlnÐQ¨�o�wx{xuQ|�m¨�mj{�|��Çw�r�l;�Fu4¨4p�{�l/p�Î m�m�l/pz{�lHm�oR|��-w�r�l��-lLw�r�u4��u.�am�l�¯�o�p�oRw�{�|����oRpv{xo�t��xl�m/¦����^u*qn{�pzq/¨���o�pÑpzlH��{�u�|�m5o�p�l�q/uQ|�m�{��.l�pvl/�3­^w�r[lk�l���{xu4|F¦  ��;�;r�{xq�r*{�mYw�r[lÒon{ p����.o�¯Á��u[�4{��z{xlL�Ät[y���o�phw�lTpvÎ mqnu4ln�h�z{�q�{�l�|[w��8o�|[�Ów�r[l*k�lH�Q{xu�|�¦  � z�Ô�r[{�q/rÉ{�|�qL��¨[�[lnmÕw�r[l�-on�L|"l/w�mÕo�|"�7w�rFl�oL{�pv�jmj¯Fo�qLlHmÅtFl�w��@l�l�|%�_on�L|�l�wzm�¦-�ar[lo�|�o/��y4w�{�qHo/��pzlHmh¨F� wzm�o�pzl�q/u4�~¯�o�pzlL���@{�w�r&w�r�l^u�|Flnm�u4t.w�o/{ |"l/�t�yÖoÓ|4¨[��l�p�{�qHo/�*oR|�o/��y[m�{�mϨ�mj{�|��×w�r�lË��{�|�{�w�lH�hln�xlT�-l�|.w��l/w�r[u4�����F}3�Ñ��¦

Ø ÙHÚ�Û�Ü[Ý�Þ�ߢà"Û�ájÝ�Ú

âwÈwxr[l5¯[p�lHmjl/|4wÈw�{���lH�Çw�r[l5|[¨4��lTpv{�q§o�����l/w�r[u[�[mc�zu�p�z{xl��x�©q/uQ��¯[¨.w�o/w�{�u4|���mv¨[q/r�o�m-wxr"lc��{�|�{�w�ln�hln�xlL��l�|"w�m�uQp�w�r[l�z{�|"{�w�l����[{����zl�p�l/|[qLlHm���¯.pvu��"{��[l_o/qLq/¨4pRo�w�l�p�lHmj¨[��w�m�q/u�|"q�lTpz|[{�|��wxr[l~��o�p�{xu�¨Fm;��o��§|[lnw�{xq_mR{�ÆHl�m^u4��wxr[l&l���l/qLw�pv{�qnon�+�-oLq�r�{ |�l�m���@{�wxrãoTqnq/u4¨4|[w~w�rFlÒm�o�wx¨4p�oRw�{�u4|Ál�w�qQ¦��¢¨4w���wxr"lny�oRp�l©u4��w�l�|w�{���ln�hq�uQ|�mj¨.��{�|F�4��{�|%¯�oRpjw�{xqT¨[��o�pÒ��u4p©w�r.pzlHln�h�4{���l/|�mR{xu�|�oT���u[�4lL�xm��4o�|[���4u�|FÎ w[r�o��[l;w�r�l^o��Q��o�|[w�on��l�w�u^t"l@mh¨"���z{�qn{�l�|"wx�xyl/·4¯F��{xq/{�w¿{�|=qnu��~¯�oRp�{�mjuQ|ä�^{�wxr�o�|�oL��y4w�{�q4o��7lHЧ¨�oRw�{�uQ|�m/¦��r�l�pvlL��uQpzl4�¢m�l���l�p�o/�^o�¨4wxr[uQpRm~¯.pvuL¯Fu[m�l/�Ñw��@u[�h�4{���l/|�mR{xu�|�oT�o�|�o/��y4w�{�qHo/�.��u4�"l/��m�{�|�u�pv�4lTp�w�u^¯"pzln�4{�q/wFw�r�l��z� ¨.·��[lT|�m�{�wxy�{�|wxr[lÄm�y�|�q�r.pzu4|[uQ¨�m<¯"l/pj�-oR|�l�|[wÈ�-o/��|[lLw��ÈoTq�r"{�|"lTm5åR¥T�hæ[ç�¦ �|[�[lnlL�[��wxr�l<o�qHq�¨.pvo�w�lÈè4|[u4�^�xl/�"��l�u.��wxr"l��-on�L|"l/w�{xqÈ��{�lL����[{xmjw�pv{�t[¨.wx{xu4|é{�m×oêè[lnyé{xm�mh¨Flëu[�Ówxr"lÖ¯Fl�p���u4ph�ÈoR|Fq/ll/��o/� ¨�oRw�{�u�|ìu4�Õ¯�l/pj�-oR|�l�|.wÄ�Èo/�§|[l/wÄ��uQw�u�p�m��Òmv¨[q/räo/m�[l��-on�L|"l/w�{�ÆHoTw�{xu�|&�x{���{�w��.�@{�|[�[{ |F��{�|[��¨"q�wzo�|[q�lnm��"mjw�o�wxu4p¢o�|[�pvu�w�u�p_�xu"m�m�lnm���t�o/q�è��hl����v�^o��[l�p�on��lÒo�|[�Äq/u"�4�4{ |��íwxu4p�Ð�¨[lH��zu�pvqLlHmÉ��uQp%wxr�lׯ"pzlL�4{xq�w�{xu�|�uQ�Âo�qLu�¨�mjw�{�q1|"u4{�m�lÊo�|[���{ t"pvo�w�{�u4|îmv¯�lnq�wxp�on�ÁlTw�q.¦Ã�ar[lÖ|[u"���xu[o/�:����¨4·î�4l/|�m�{�w�y�Ço��[lL��u4pj�f{�m���on{�|[�xy<o��j�zlnq/w�ln��t[y�|.¨4��tFl�p�uQ�3¯Fu4�xln��¯Fo/{�p�m��o/{ pR�j�4o�¯���l/|��Qwxr��§�-on�L|"l/w�q/u4|.�z{��L¨4p�oTwx{xu�|_��w�r[l��_o/��|"l�wF¯�u.��lH�

o�pvqÈwxu<¯Fu4�xln��¯�{�w�q�r8p�o/wx{�u©o�|"�<w�r�l�p�o���{xoL��wxr[{�q�è.|�lHm�m~uQ�w�r[l�_o/��|[lTw�m��ïo�|[� wxr"l �.{�pzlLq/w�{xu�| u.�ðw�r�l ��o��§|[lnw�m�_o/��|[lTw�{�ÆHo/w�{�u4|*å�²"ç�¦���r�¨�m���{ |Ä�[lnm�{x�§|íqnoL�xq�¨���o/wx{�u�|�m���{�w�{xm|"l/qnlHm�m�oRpvy7w�uVmhwx¨��4y%�4{��j��l/pvlT|4w8�-oL�L|�l/w�{xÆHoTw�{�u4|7¯�oRw�w�l�pz|�m��¯�o�pRo��x��ln���§pRo��"{xoL���4lLwxq.¦ ����¯Fu[m�mj{�tF� y�{�|"qn��¨[�.{ |��~{��~¯�l/pj�zlnqTw�{�u4|�m{�|Áwxr[l5�_on�L|�l�w�{ Æ[o�w�{�u�|��Ç�zu�p#oÅ�^{x�[lÅp�o�|F��lÒu.�<��o��§|[lnw�mmvr�o�¯�l�m�¦í��r�o�w�{�mñ�;r[yòwxr[lÖoR¨"wxr[u�p�mVl�·.w�l/|[�.l��ëw�r�ln{ po�|�o/�xy�w�{xq�o/�1��u[�4ln�ów�uôo/qLqnu�¨[|4w×�zu�pìw�rFlõwzo�|F��l/|4w�{�o���_o/��|[lTw�{�ÆHo/w�{�u4|�q/uQ��¯�uQ|[l/|4w"�r[{�q�r-q�o�|-oR¯[¯"lHoRp¢oRw[wxr"l�w�{���lu.�"�-oL�L|�l/w�Î ma�_o�|4¨"�hoTq/wx¨4p�{�|���å�²��hæ4ç�¦ x|Öu4pj�[l�pÁw�uöm�o�w�{�mj��y×w�r�lÓq�uQ|4w�{ |[¨[{�|��óp�lTÐQ¨[lHmhwÄ��u�p{���¯"pzuQ�[{�|��5w�r[l©�[lnmR{��L|�Î m&¯"pzlnq/{�m�{�uQ|ãoR|����Ql�|�l�pRo���{�w�y[�;w�r[lo�¨4wxr�u�p�m~r�o��[l<�.l��[lH��u�¯�l/�ÒoÈw��@u[�h�4{���l/|�m�{xu�|�oL�o�|�oL� yQw�{�q4o����u4�4ln�Ï{ |ä¯"u[��o�pVq/u.u�pv�4{�|�o/w�lTmÂ�zu�pÂmh¨[pj�voLq�l×��u�¨[|4w�l��mjy�|"q�r[pzuQ|[u4¨�m�¯Fl�pz��o�|[l/|.wF�Ôo/�L|�l�w3�_o�q/r�{�|�lnm/¦���r"{xm���u4�"l��{�|�q/��¨[�"lnm5t"u4w�r%¯�oRp�o��x�xlL�Ào�|[�%p�o��.{�o/�c��o��§|[lnw�{�Ƨo�w�{�u�|F¦_ �w{�|[�[u4����lnm�wxr[l�mju"� �"{�|��~sao�¯���oLq/lnÌ�Í3u4{�m�mRu�|�Î m�lnÐQ¨�o�wx{xuQ|�m+¨�mj{�|��w�r�lÁ��u�¨[pz{�l�p�Î mÁmjl/p�{xl4m�o�|[�Ów�r[l*��l/w�r"u4�ÂuQ�ím�l�¯�oRp�o�wx{�|���FoRpv{�o�tF��lHmT¦���r[l5p�lnmj¨[��w�mÀu4�Ào�|�on��yQw�{xq4o/��q4o���q�¨"��o�w�{�uQ|�mÒo�pjlqLu���¯FoRpvln�Ã��{ wxrÁwxr[lÅp�lHmj¨[��w�mYu.��|4¨[��l/pv{�qHo/��m�{ ��¨F��o�w�{�u4|�mq�o�pjp�{xln�^uQ¨4w[t�y;w�r�l��j{�|�{�wxlH�hln��l/��l/|.w"��l/w�r�u4��å�±4ç�¦÷ ø8Ú�ù�ú�ûOÛ�ázà"ù3ú�üÂÝ3Þ�ý"ú

þ"ÿ�� � ¼��4¹������ �nº�¾n¼�����»������_½����Ǹ�º�º������»�������º��r�lÄo�|�oT�xy[m�{xmcu[�#o5mh¨[pj�voLq/l5��u4¨4|4w�ln�*mjy4|"q�r.pvu�|[uQ¨�m¯Fl�pj�-o�|[l/|4w3�_on�L|"l/wO�_o�q/r"{�|[l~��{��x��tFl��4l/��ln��u�¯�ln�Y��u�pw�r[lmR{��~¯��x{���{�l/�#�4l/uQ�-lTw�pvyÑmhr�u��;|À{ |c��{x�"¦�¥4¦F��r�l~¯�o�pvo���lTw�l/pvmu.��wxr[{�m~��lnu���l/wxpzyÑo�p�l[­"w�r[l_{ |.|�l/p�mhw�oTwxu4p;pRo��.{ ¨�m;��u4�[{���{�l��

t"y©�¢o�p�w�l�p�Î m�q/u[l/�j�z{�qH{�l�|"w�� �� ′�+wxr[l<uQ¨4w�l�p��-o/��|"l/w�pvoT�[{�¨Fm��

�� �4w�r"l^{�|4|"l�p��-o/��|"l/w"pRo��"{ ¨�m�� ! ��w�r�l�pRoT�4{�oT�"wxr[{�q�è.|�lHm�mu.��wxr�l~�_on�L|"l�wzm�� "# �"w�r�l_o/{�pR�h�[oR¯8��u[�4{���{xln�&t[y8��o�pjw�l/p�Î mqLu4ln���j{�q/{�l/|4wz� $

′�Lw�r[l;�-o/��|[lLw[¯Fu4��lT�joRp�q�w�uǯ�u.�xln��¯"{�w�q/r�p�oRw�{�u[�

%α�Twxr"l�|4¨[�~t�l/pF¯"u[��lT��¯�oT{ pRm�� & ¦��r�lÕ�_o�{�|óonm�mh¨[�~¯[w�{�u�|�m�o�p�l[­('�)5}O|[�Vl����jlnqnw�mÁo�pjl{���|[u�p�ln�+*-,�)���r�l�¯"l/p���lHoRt�{���{�w�y8uQ��tFu�wxr©mhw�oTwxu4p�o�|[�<p�u�w�u�pmvw�lnlL��m�oRp�l_o/m�mh¨"��lL�8{ |"��{�|[{�w�lH�aw�r�l�|<wxr"l_m�oTw�¨[pvoTw�{�uQ|#l/���jlnqnw�mu.��wxr"l�o�pz�_o�w�¨4pvlnm;{xm�|[lH�4��lnq/w�ln�+*/.0)��ar[l^qnu�|���¨"q�w�{��[{�w�{�lHm�uQ�

Page 3: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

o/�x�.pzlH�Q{xu�|Fm3u.��w�r[l���u[�4l���o�p�l�o/m�mh¨.�-l/�~w�uÇtFl�|4¨�����*���)O��r[l¯�l�pj�-oR|�l�|.w_��on�L|[lnw�mÒoRp�lÁo�m�mh¨[��l/�*w�u*t"lÄ|[uQ|§uQpz{xl/|4w�l/����^{�w�rð|[u ¯�o�p�w�{xq�¨���o�pì�[{�pzl�q�w�{�u�| u.�×�_o��§|[l/w�{�ÆHoTw�{�u4|[���{�mju4w�pzu4¯"{xqn�ÖoR|�� rFo��"{ |�� o ��{�|[lHoRpé�4ln��on�L|[lLw�{�Æ4o�w�{�u�|q/r�o�pvoLq�w�l�p�{�mvw�{�qf��pRoRp�l7lHo�p�w�rÂ�_o/��|[lLw�mj� *���)���r"lfmj��u�w�w�l/�mjw�oTw�u�p�{�m�w�p�o�|�mR��u�p���l/�<{�|[wxu8o�m���u�w���lnm�m;mjw�o/wxuQp�tQy<o�¯4¯F��y4{�|��wxr[l��oRpjw�l�p�Î m3q/u[lT�z�z{�qH{�lT|[wz¦�

����

� ′

�� � � ������������� � � ��� �"! � � # � � $ %'&��(�)� � � & � �)*(#

+',πα�Θ

-.

/0 Θ

1 1 1 23�4 �)# 4 ��% %'% # ��# ���56�)# �(�

789 9 :

;<

=>� ��*?� # @� � � % �A�)&)� ��# B��(� *@�"� ��*C� # %5�� �(� ��*ED F F5G� ��� ��*?D F

H>I)J�K�L�KNMOI PRQ�S)I T?I)U6VWPYX6Z�X\[]J�U�X�P^UAZ�[�_�K`]a `

bdc�egf�h(i)jlkmc�npoAqpfWbsr�k�jgf�oAi)tur\o'i)c>jwv^i�x6f@y6oGi(c�j{zp|'i�j]ko}qgfW~�c"zlx6i(f@x�� |W|Af�x6i�f�|�����@���'���)�]���(���(�>�w�����E�>�m�>���������R�E�]���R�����]���>�����)�{�(�>�

�N�N�'���"�N�'�����w�@�\�]�������� ¡�\���u¢u�£�����¥¤?¦��A���]¤�§¨�O�C���©�6�>�ª��N�£���C�)���¥¤?«W���g��¬)�(­'�®���{���'�¯¬��)°>���¯�)�]�{���@�w�@�\�>�\���)±��6����������]�6�}�\�6���6�'���}�����{�(�²��¬��)�>���N�³�����A�]���O´µ�6¬)����� ¶¸·)¹

µ ⋅µ�6�>�

�(�>�R´?¬)��º»�]�6�g�A�(��¢¡�@¼O�]��¬��®�(�m�)�g�W�'���£�6�������g���>�u� ½)¾¿ ��´����À�

�¥���\�]�������»´C���"¬)���Á´ÃÂ��RÄ(��Å�Æ����C���]���E�³���A�u�Ç�6�È���>�6�G�"�@�'�»�O´���]�w�������G�'���)�]�É�����m���6�G�N�(�>�A� ÊË �O´W�(�]�£�£�@�\�����Ã�"�6�]�'�@�m��'�@���>���?�)�O�¥��´��)���R�'���w�6�]�����Ç´C¬���º¥�Á�G�g�'����¢��'���w�)���6�}��´A���C�»��O�C���s��´^�)�]�����\�£������������±O�N�?�)���²�6�Á�?�]��ÅÀÌÍ�>���»�)�Á´C¬)�����>�"���(�¼O�]�6������´������Î���N�)�]�Ï�дC�\�G����� Ñ)ÒÓ

∆�C���>�'���N�6�>�(�)�g�Ô�(���

�'���w�'�g�6�>�^´?¬��>º²�Á�G�g�'����¢Õ�]�6�}�����(�����Ö�Á´m�(�>�×�£�@�\�����R�Y���G����]�W�(�\�¡�g�6�G�'�����}�¨�}���'�"�ÙØ6ÚÜÛ�Ý>Þ�ß

( ) ( )à á â à ápã à)á â â'ãä å ä æ ä å åç è= ⋅ + ∆ ⋅ −é ê ��Ø�­

�^�>���C� ë'ìí ���µ�(�>�����¡�]���6�>�W�?�G�m�g�G�G�6���>�C�{�Á´Ã�(���w�w�@�\�]������>� î)ïpðñ ���®�)���W�}���£�6�������g´?¬)��ºw�>���]�'�)��¢¡�Á´g���>�Ã�w�@�\�]���l�'����]�W�(�\�¡�g�6�G�'�����}� Ê'òË Å

ÌÍ�]���C���£�N�g�6�>�ôA¬)�>º¯�����]�6� ��¢ó�]���\�(���¡���������>�]�m���¯���>��Á�)�C�\������������´Ô�)�]�ô�w�@�\�]���?�õ�¥�����>�\�(��±u�6���)�O�gÅöÆg����Å÷Ý�\���³�g�N�}�"� �g�N�N��¬�¬(�@¬ �N�]� �G�G������¬ �w�@�\�]������±\���(�(����Á���E���}���]�����)���]�{Û�ø�ÞGÅǦ��ù�>�>¬��N�¡�@���O�C�>� �g�N�����'�ú�A�������]�A�)�]�������N����]�{�w���u�]�������6�G�{�}�����?�6¬�¬(¢×�>���»�>���6�g���O�]�G�®�(���{�}�6�w�6�]�����´A¬)��º³�Á�6���A����¢R���@�������l�?�Ç�)�Á�]�ú���)�����^�>¢pß

( ) ( ) ( ) ûüü ý þÿü ü)ý þÿü ü ü)ý þÿü� ��� � ��� � � ��� �ΘΘΘ = Θ ⋅ + Θ ⋅

������������������ � � � �� � ����� � �?ÝÁ­�^�>���C���»���É�(�]�Õ�)�>�>�6º ��´{�)�]�Õ�£�����>�\�(��±u�6�?�)��� ���)�'���\�(�(���� ��� ß�� �6�G�G¬�¬)��¬ ��� ��� ß�� �����?�6¬(­'� �

��� ���>�

�w�����g�6�>�����\¬ú�N���\��¬��6�Ã�g�>�N� ������� �Á´À���>�»�'�������¡���(���¡�g�>�N�)�(�(���� �Θ =

��� � � �)�g� ���6�>�?�6� �O´ �  ³���A�)� �¥�����>����­��( )

�� � !"�# $�%Θ

& ���>� ( )� � !"�# $�%Θ Θ& �6�C�Ð���>� �G�����?��¬ �6�>�

�?�6�]���6�Á���?�6¬³�\���³�����]�6�>�?���O´¥���>�ù�G�6�£�6�������»´C¬���º÷�>�6�]�6�)�(¢�����������Ã�Á´ú���>�^�£�\�\���6�'Å�Æp�(��Å('��A�>�O�µ�¨�(¢\���)���6¬Ç�³�N�]��´C�O�?�£��Á´ö�)�g�@�'� �Í�N�'�(���g� �\���¡�g���]�6�>���6�d��������� � �g��¬(�@¤������ �G������\���}�Á�)��� �(� �(��� �����G���\�(�(��� �O´ �(�>� �w���u�>�@����¥�����>������±"�����)���gÅ³Ì �>�G�g� ( )

�� � !"�# $�%Θ

& �N�]� ( )� � !"�# $�%Θ Θ&

���'�m�]�W��º����C�"�'�N���£��� Æp���>�C�����*) ���'�6�G�(�@��ß

( )( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

++ ,.-0/21 +/4365 7�8 8 8++ , 1"+ + ++ ,9-:/*;�3<1 + + ,.-0/21 +/=7�5 >*8 8 8

? @�ACBEDGFIHJBLK? @�A

? @ DMFIH ? @�ANBEDMFOHJBLK

+∞

=+∞

=

⋅ ⋅Θ ≠

Θ =

⋅ Θ + ⋅ ⋅ Θ

P

P

QQ

Q Q

R S

RUTVS�'�Å �6­

( )( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

W XVY[Z]\ WZ_^a` bGc c cWNX \"WW6X9Y[ZMdG^<\ W W6XVY[Z]\ WZ�b*` e�c c c

f g�hNiEj�k i�iLlf g�h

f g j�kmi f g�hniEj�k i�iLl

+∞Θ

=Θ+∞

Θ Θ

=

⋅ ⋅Θ ≠

Θ =

⋅ Θ + ⋅ ⋅ Θ

o

o

pp

p p

qsr

qUt9r�'�Å ��­

�Y���G�'� ( )uu v9w:x2yz {�|a}~ � ( )� ���:�2�� ���N�Θ � � ( )

�� �9�0�*������ �� �A�"�

( )� �9�:�*������ �Θ� �C���>�'���N����� ���]� ���N�'�(���g� �]�6�A�£���>���

�\�w�p¬?���?���g�u�\�Á´}�Á� �L���≠

�\�g� �L���=�Í�Á´l�?�g�¡�������C�\¬l�\���

�'�6�]�������?����¬R�@���»�]�����6�>����´����»�(�����'�6�����>�����^´C¬)��ºs�>�6�]�6�)�(¢�����������ö��´ �(��� �£�\�\���6�?��ÅÈÌ �>� �6º>�Á�}�@�G�A�����]� ��´ �(�>���A��g�N�C�»���>�(�R�6�»�]¬(� ���]���"���N�G�¨�Á� ���G�»�)�m�(�>�W�R�>�g�6�]����º�Ø"Å

Page 4: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

���πα�� �Θ

�� Θ

� ��

� �

� �� � �� � ��

��� � �

� ���� � � ��

� ��� �� � ��

� ��� �� � ��( ) !#"$ %'&)(Θ Θ*

( )+ ,.-/+02143Θ

55 55 55 55 5 55 5 5 67

( )88 9;:<8=2>)?Θ

@

BDCFE

G�Hπα IJ KΘ

LM Θ

NN N O

P

Q R

S T

S T

S T

UVWW X

Y Z[\\ \ \ ]^

Y Z[\\ \ \ ]^

_ `abb b b cd

e fghh h h ij( )kk l.m$knporq

Θs

( )t u.v<tw2x4yΘ

z zz zz z zz zz zz z {|

}�~����� ����������� �D������� �������4����������� ���¡�£¢¤�¥���������¦� §��¨�¦�� �©��}Dª«�4¬����­��®® ��®����� ���¨�¦� §��¨�¦�� �©��}�~¯�±°²��³����®������F���¡��� §«�¡��������

´π−

µΘ

( )¶ ·¹¸º#»

¼�½πα

¾­¿π− À­Áπ ÂπÃ

Ä ÅÆÇÅÈÉÈÊ ËÅÌÊÍ ÉÎÉÆÏÈÉÈÊÌÐ ÑÒÓ ÉÈËÔ Ê ÕÖÉ×Ê ÅÎ

ÅÌ ÊÍ ÉÆÏØÈÉÊ ÙÔ ÊÍ ÏÇÏÎÏÐÐ ÉÐ ÆÏØÈÉÊÔ ÚÏÊÔ ÅÈÛ ÜÝ

Þ±ßà áãâ ä­å àâ æ¨â ä�ç­è¦æ â é¨ê�ë­ì å í å ë­ä�î é âïDð ñ

òãâ­ä�ç¦ßä¦í å âæ óô�âïå âæ ó ( )

õõ öø÷ùõú#û�üΘ

ý( )þ ÿ��ùþ�����Θ Θ�

���

π− �Θ

( )� ������

���πα

���π− ���π �π�

"!$# %'& (�) #$& *+& (-,�.* & /+0-1�2 ) 3 ) 1�(54 / &$687 9

:'&�(;,!$(3 ) &$* <=>&$6$) &$* < ( )?? @BAC?D�E�F

ΘG

( )H IKJLHMON�PΘ ΘQ

R STUSVWVX YSZ X[ W\WT]VWVXZ^ _`a WVYb X cdWeX S\

SZ X[ WT]fVWX gb X[ ]\]ab ]^ T]fVWXb h]Xb SVi jk

l;monprq$sut"vrtuwyx>z>{>|-}�~-����}�|��;�5{�~x>��q$x���x������x���s�{����q x�����}�����}��u{����-�|}u~��;��{�~8{���x���{�����|� �u���>{����+q �;��z�{����$}u~�}>|B�;�u{���x�s>��{+�8tl8��n��rx�~x��$�${��5��x�s��u{��q ��x��;q$}��ot>l;mon���x���q$x>����x�s>��{ �;q �¡x+�q$}>�rt

¢¤£ ¥ ¦¨§>©�§¡ª�«�¬"­¯®o°±«³²µ´$¶�©±·�¸�©º¹»¶�¬;«oª�¼�¶�¶"ª�½r´$©�«¾²'§5·

¿¤À Á¤À$ ïġűÄ�Æ�Ç"È�ÉËÊ Ì8ÌÍÄ>Æ�Ä>Å�ÎÊ$ǤÈ�Ï�ÐrÑrÇoÎ;Ê;Ò�ÅÍÓÔÍÕ"ÖØ×ÚÙ�Û�Ü�Ö�Ý;ÝÞ ßàÖ�á¾â¤Ù�ã;ä;åuæ�ßçå�è�éêÙ�ë�æ"Ö�ã-å"ßµãìÙ�ã8ä$íîÙ ï�Ö

Üðï�ä$ã�ã-Ö>æ�ñ

( ) ( )ò8ó�ô¨õ ö ÷Ëø'ù�óuú�û±óuü�ý= =þ+þ8þ8þ+þ8þ'þ þ ÿþ;ÿ ÿ ÿ ����������� �� ���� ����� Ù��

( )������� =

! " # �%$'&��%(�)�*,+- �.�/0*�12&���%�435��(�)617& ����� 8 �

ÜðÕrÖ�ï�Ö 9: äß ã;Õ"Ö<;¤Ö�í¡ã-åuïêå¾è í�âoï8ïµÖ�ærã>=�Ö>æ¤ß ä;ã�?A@ BC�D äß ã;Õ"Öé Ù�ë�ærÖ>ã-äí è'äÖ�Ý6=E;"Ö5í�ãåuï Ù�æ2= FG H ä8ß ã�Õ"ÖBéËÙ�ë�æ¤Ö>ã8ä�íBè'Ý â�Û="Ö�æ ß+ä�ã ?I;¤Ö�í�ãåuï � ÔÍÕrÖ é Ù>ëuæ"Ö�ã;äíJ;"Ö�í>ãåuïLK¤åuãÖ>æ�ã-äÙ>Ý MN6O ä-ß="Ö>è'ä ærÖ�= 8 ?�ñ

( ) ( )P QSRUTWV X7Y�Z[V \]W^`_ba= =cdcScdcScecfc c gc g c6g c6g h 17.A 1��Wij �k$A��$'�l����� í%�

mN O Ù�æA= no6p ;¤Ö�ï�ä;è�?�ãÕ¤Ö é Ù�ë�ærÖ>ã8ä$í�éyÙ ã8Ö�ï�ä8Ù�ݤÖ�á¾â¤Ù ã-ä�åuæ�ñ

( )q r=

s t s6tu �ev �

ÜðÕrÖ�ï�ÖBã�Õ"Ö è-âoæ"í�ãä$å�æ + ä;ßw=oÖxK Ö�æA=�Ö>æ�ãyåuæçã;Õ"Ö éêÙ�ã8Ö�ï�ä-Ù¡ÝK¤Õ,?rß+äí�Ù�Ý�Krï'å-K¤Ö>ï8ãä;Ö�ß �

ÔÍÕ¤Öy=oåué Ù>ä æ åoè ß ã;â2=�?�í�å¾æ¤ß�ä;ß ãìß ä$æ�èå�â�ï�íuä ïµí¡â¤Ý-Ù ïï�Ö5ëuä�åuæ ß �{z äë �y| ��ñ ã�Õ"Ö ß�Ý$åoã;ÝÖ5ß�ß�ß ã'Ù�ã;å�ï}@Bã�Õ¤Ö Ù>ä ï~8ëoÙ}KéËå7=�ä�è'ä�Ö%= 8 ? ã�Õ"Ö���Ù�ï+ã-Ö¡ïµÞ ß í�å�Ö�è8è'äí�ä;Ö�ærã ���>�%�����7�'��� �}@�ã�Õ"Öï�Ö5ëuä�åuæ ä ærí�Ý$âA=�ä$æ¤ë ã$Õ¤Ö éyÙ>ëuæ"Ö>ã8ß Ù æA= ã;ÕrÖîÙ�ä ï4~+ßfK±Ù�í�Ö¡ß8 Ö�ã;Ü�Ö�Ö�æ�éËÙ�ë�æ�Ö�ã8ß �����5�������'���}� � Ù�æA= è8ä$æ�Ù>Ý;Ý�?�ã;Õ"Ö ï�åuã-åuï �� í>í�åuï}=�ä$æ¤ë ã-å ã;ÕrÖËÜ�å�ïS�rä$æ¤ë Ù>ß>ß+â�é>Krã;ä�åuæ ß}@ ã$ÕrÖ é Ù�ë�æ"Ö�ã8ä$íè+ä-Ö�Ý�=�å¾èBã;Õ¤Ö ß Ý;å¾ã-Ý;Ö�ß>ß�ßµãìÙ¡ã;å�ï Ù æA=�ã;Õ"Öçï�å�ãåuï í�Ù�æ 8 Öí�åuæ ß+ä�=oÖ�ï�Ö�= Ù�ß�æ�ârÝ;Ý � Ô�Õ"Ö>ï'Ö�è8å�ï�Ö,@Íã;ÕrÖ�=�åuéêÙ>ä æ å¾è ß ã�â2=�? ä;ßï�Ö%=uâ"í�Ö�=¨ã;å�ã�Ü å¨í�ä$ï+í>â¤ÝÙ�ï±ï+Ö5ëuä;å¾æ¤ß5ñ

~ �0�%�-���2������� � �� ��� ′′′′≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤

� � � � �� �= µ ⋅

�e�f��� �S�d� � � �S� �~ �0�%�-���2�����}�%� � �  ¡¢ 

≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤�

( ) ( )£ £ ¤ ¥§¦�£ £¨¦ £ £ ¤ ¦�© ª«¦¬ ­ ¬ ®°¯= µ ⋅µ Θ ⋅ + Θ

±d±S±d± ² ±S±d±S± ²³±S±d±S±d±S±e±f±e±S±d±S±d± ± ² ±´ ´ ´ �Sµ �

Ü�Õ"Ö¡ï'Ö ¶µ

ä-ß ã�Õ"Ö·K¤Ö�ï+é Ö5Ù 8 ä$Ýä$ã�? å�è�è8ï'ÖuÖËßdK Ù¡í�Ö�@ ( )¸�¹ ¹¨¸µ Θäß�ã�Õ"Ö�ï�Ö�Ý-Ù�ãìä ;rÖ�éËÙ�ë�æ"Ö�ã8ä$íºK¤Ö�ï'éºÖ³Ù 8 ä$Ý;ä�ã�? å�è�»ðÖ�ë¾ä;å�æ � ¼S¼}�2½ ÖíuÙ�æ ïµÖ�éêÙ�ïd�¾@ åuæ ã;Õ"Ö z ä-ë �°| @Lã;Õ¤Ù�ã ( )¿�À À¨¿µ Θ

ä;ß æråuãí�åuæ ß ãìÙ�æ"ãµñÂÁ Ã�à Ä

µ =ä$æ ã�Õ"Ö Ù¡ä$ï~8ßdK�Ù>í>Ö 8 Ö�ã�Ü ÖuÖ�æ éêÙ>ëuæ"Ö>ã8ß�Ù�æ2=

Å�Æ Æ Å�ǵ = µä æ ã�Õ¤Ö�éËÙ�ë³æ¤Ö>ã8ß �

Page 5: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

� ß+ä$æ¤ë¨Ö�á¾â¤Ù�ã;ä;åuæ�ß �f� �}@ �S� ��Ù�æA= ��µ �e@oÙ æ¾=�æ"ÖuëuÝ;Öuí�ã8ä æ�ë�ã�Õ"ÖÖ>æ2=�Ö>è'è+Ö�í>ã-ß � �� � �� � �

∆ = ⋅����� � ��� � �}@ ã�Õ"Ö�æ"åA~Ý;årÙ�=ØéêÙ�ë³æ"Ö>ã-äí

;¤Ö>í>ã;å�ï Krå�ã-Ö�æoã-ä-Ù¡Ýb@Íä$æCÖ5Ù>í>Õ ïµÖ�ëuä�å�æ�@¾;¤Ö�ïµä�è8äÖ�ß�ã$Õ¤Ö¨è'å�ÝÝ$å¾Ü ä æ¤ëÖ5áuâ�Ù�ãä$å�æ¤ß�ñ

�� ∆ =

� ����� ��( ) ( ) ( )

�� ���� � � ��� � � �� � �� � �� ����� ∂ Θ ∂⋅ ⋅ + Θ ⋅ ∆ = ⋅ Θ

∂Θ ∂Θ

� �� � � ����� 8 �ÜðÕrÖ�ï�Ö ã;Õ¤Ö�èâoæ¤í>ãä;åuæ ß ( ) Θ! Ù æ¾= ( )"$#%�&

Θ' Ù ïµÖ�ë�ä ;rÖ�æ ä$æ

ã;Õ"Ö ��K2K�Ö�æ¾=�ä Û)( �*,+ -,+ *

.0/2143657578:9<;>=@?�ACB A@D EF1HG�IJ=@?�KC1MLNIPOQBR1S=T?VUW 1SX79Y1ZI\[0?TG�?�= ])^_A\9`ASO21aB21S?�= ]_? BbEc1�O2?�A\B + dadÔ�å�ß+å"Ý�;"Ö ã;Õ"Ö ="ä è'è+Ö�ï�Ö�æoã-ä-Ù�Ý�Ö�á�â¤Ù�ã-ä$å�æ¤ß Ù 8 å-;"Ö,@�Ü�ÖËâ�ß+Ö

ã;Õ"Ö�éËÖ>ã�Õ"å2=Ëå¾è»ß�Ö�K�Ù�ïµÙ�ãä$æ¤ë ;¤Ù�ï�ä-Ù 8 Ý$Ö5ß � ÔÍÕrÖ�Ö�á�â¤Ù�ã-ä;å¾æ ����� Ù��ä-ß í5Ý;Ù�ß�ß�äí�Ù�Ý�@"í>å¾æ"ã;ï�Ù�ï ?¨ã;å �e�'� 8 ��ܯդä$í¡Õ ï�Ö�ß+â"Ý�ãìß ä æ ß+årÝ ;rä$æ¤ëºÙß�Ö>í�åuæ¾=2~ åuï}=�Ö>ï =�ä�è-è+Ö�ï'Ö¡æ"ã-ä8Ù�Ý Ö5áuâ¤Ù�ãìä$å¾æ Ü ä ã�Õ æ"åA~í�åuæ�ß ã Ù æoãí�å�Ö�è è'äí�äÖ�æ"ã-ß � Ô�å Ö�Ý;ä é ä$æ±Ù ã8Ö ã$Õ�ä-ß K"ï�å 8 Ý;Ö>é @ ã;Õ¤ÖÚïµåuãåuïyäßã;ïµÙ�æ¤ß è'åuï+é Ö�= ä$ærã;åêÙ�æCÖ�á¾â"ä�;¤Ù>ÝÖ�æ"ã�åuæ¤Ö%@ ÜðÕ"Ö>ï�Ö�ã$Õ�Ö�ï�Ö>Ý8Ù ãìä`;"Öé Ù�ë�ærÖ>ã-äí K�Ö�ï+é ÖuÙ 8 ä�Ý;ä$ã�? å¾èl»¯Ö¡ëoä�åuæ � ¼d¼ ä8ß�ß â2K2K�å"ß Ö�=í�åuæ ß ã8Ù�ærã � ( )f�g ghf f�g�gµ Θ = µ

� � � å�æ�ã�ï Ù ïe?ºãåji µ0k @oÜ�Ö ß+â7K�K¤å"ß Öã;Õ¤Ù�ã l m�m

µÖ¡á¾â¤Ù>Ýß ã;å | Ù æ¾= Ü Ö�í�åuï+ï'Öuí�ã�ã$Õ¤Ö�ï�Ö�éêÙ�æ"Ö>æ�ã�è'Ý â�Û

="Ö�æ ß+ä�ã ? å�è�ã;ÕrÖ¯éêÙ>ëuæ"Ö>ãS@ ( )nVo pq r @³ã-å¨é ä æ"ä$éËä�s5Ö ã;ÕrÖ�Ö�ï'ï�åuïå"è�í>å�é�K"âoãìÙ ã8ä;åuæYiV( k @ti �tk ñ

( ) ( ) ( )u vu vRwyx v u v x u�v xu�vz{ | } { | { |~ + µ= ⋅ = ⋅

⋅µ

��� �

Ü�Õ"Ö¡ï'Ö ���R�� äß�ã;Õ"Ö í>åuï'ï�Ö�í>ãÖ%= ï�Ö�éêÙ�æ"Ö¡æ"ã�è+Ý$â�Û[=rÖ�æ ß+ä�ãb? Ù�ãã�Õ¤ÖºãÖ>é>KrÖ>ï�Ù�ã�â�ï�Ö �� Ù�æA= � �

µä;ß�ã�Õ�Öºï'ÖuÝ;Ù>ãä ;¤Ö é Ù�ë�æ"Ö�ã8ä$í

K�Ö�ï+é Ö5Ù 8 ä$Ý;ä�ã�? å�è�ã�Õ¤Ö é Ù�ë�æ¤Ö>ã � ½ Ö ïµÖ¡é Ù ïd�îã$Õ±Ù ã�è8åuï��� �P� �µ =

@ ã�Õ¤Ö éêÙ�Û"ä�é âoéOÖ>ï8ï�åuï ���� ����ε = −

åuæ�ã�Õ"Öï�Ö>éËÙ�æ�Ö�æ"ãoè'Ý$âoÛ>=�Ö>æ¤ß�ä$ã�?¨Ö5áuâ�Ù�Ýß�ãå �'� �t���[���?BÙxK2KrÝ ?oä æ ëÚã$Õ¤Ö�Ù>ß>ß â"é�K"ã-ä�åuæ åoè�ï�Ö�Ý8Ù ãìä`;"Ö é Ù�ë�æ"Ö�ã-ä�íK�Ö�ï+é Ö5Ù 8 ä$Ý;ä�ã�? Õråué å¤ëuÖ¡æ"Ö5ä ã`? ä æw»ðÖ�ë�ä�åuæ � ¼d¼ Ù æ¾= 8 ?Úâ ß+ä$æ¤ëã�Õ¤Ö Ö5á³â Ù ã-ä$å¾æ ���A� 8 �d@ ã;Õ"Ö æ"å¾~Ý�å"Ù�=OéËÙ>ëuæ"Ö>ãä;í ;"Öuí�ã-åuïK�åuãÖ�æoã-ä;Ù�Ý"ä æ0» Öuë�ä;åuæ � ¼S¼ ;"Ö>ïµä�è'ä�Ö5ß�ã�Õ"Ö¯è8åoÝ;Ý;åuÜ ä æ ë�Ö�á¾â¤Ù�ã-ä�åuæ ñ

( ) ( )�� ���y������� � ���R� ��� �¡ ¢N£¤¥ ¡ ¢N£¦ Θ

§ ¨∂ Θ© ª

∆ = − ⋅ Θ −∂Θ

© ª« ¬­­ ­ �x|S® �

¯0° ± ²6³H´Q³Cµ·¶�¸,¹0ºJ¸�»0¼�½Vºt´R¾�¿Z´ÁÀºt¸�¶0µ>ÃFºJºtµSÄ0½T´Q¶�¼�³Å¾ÔÍÕ¤Ö 8 åuâoæ2=¤Ù ïe?�í>å¾æ2="ä ã8ä;åuæ�ßCä æ ã;Õ"Ö ã;Ü�åBï�Ö�ë�ä$å�æ¤ß Ù�ï+Ö

=oÖ>è'ä æ"Ö%= 8 ?±ñ

( )Æ Ç ÈÊÉË ÌÎÍ ÏΘ ′ Θ =Ð �5|2|�� Ùx�( ) ( ) ( )Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ñ Ñ Ò Ó Ô Ô�ÓRÕyÖ�Ô× Ø4Ù × ØÚÙ × ÛÜÙΘ Θ ΘΘ = Θ − ΘÝ Ý Ý �x|2|�� 8 �

( ) ( )Þ Þß à á Þ ß ß à á Þâ ã4ä â ã4ä

Θ = Θå å �5|2|�� í��

( ) ( )æ æ ç èéè è�êRëyì�èí îÎï í ð�ïΘ ΘΘ = Θñ ñ �x|2|�� =7���?�ß å"Ý�;"ä æ¤ë ã�Õ"Ö Ö5á³â Ù ã8ä;åuæ�ß ����� Ù��ËÙ�æ2= �x|7® �¨Ü ä ã$Õ�ã�Õ"Ö

Öuáuâ Ù ãä;åuæ ß �5|2| �}@ ã$Õ¤Ö z åuâ"ï�ä;Ö>ïµÞ ß ß�Ö�ï�ä$Ö³ß å¾è ã;Õ¤Ö ærå2~8Ý$årÙ=;rÖ>í>ã-åuï é Ù�ë�æ�Ö�ã8ä$í K åuãÖ�æ"ã-äÙ>ÝËí5Ù�æ 8 Ö�å 8 ã8Ù�ä æ"Ö%= �>¼ æ�Ö5Ù¡í�Õï�Ö5ëuä�åuæ�@ ã;ÕrÖ�í>â�ï�Ý�å¾è�ã�Õ"Ö�æ"åA~Ý;å"Ù�= éêÙ�ë³æ"Ö�ã;äí ;"Öuí�ã-åuïK�åuãÖ�æoã-ä;Ù�Ýb@ �f�'� í%�d@àëuä�;�Ö�ß ã$ÕrÖ ï�Ù=räÙ>Ý�Ù�æA= ã'Ù�æ�ëuÖ>æ�ã8ä8Ù�Ýí�åué Kråuæ¤Ö�æ"ã-ß�å�è�æ"å2~ Ý;å"Ù5= è+Ý â"Û>=�Ö>æ¤ß�ä$ã�?º;¤Ö�í¡ã-åuï�ñ

( )( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

ò�ó0ôJõ÷ö òõùøTú û7ü ü üò�ó4ö ò ò òó:ôtõaý7øþö ò óJô0õÚö òõjûaú ÿ7ü ü ü

� ������������ ����� �������

� ��������� � ������������ ����

+∞

=+∞

=

− ⋅ ⋅Θ ≠

Θ =

⋅ Θ − ⋅ ⋅Θ

���� � �� �

� �

������5| ( � Ùx�

( )( ) ( )

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

"!"# $#�%'& (*) ) ) + $ "!,#.-/%0+ $ �!1#2+ $#3(4& 5�) ) )

6 7�8�9:<;=9�9�>6 ?@8�7�8

6 ?A8�7B:C;=9 6 ?@8�7�8�9D:C;=9�9E>

+∞Θ

=Θ+∞

Θ Θ

=

− ⋅ ⋅Θ ≠

Θ =

⋅ Θ − ⋅ ⋅ Θ

F

F

GHGH G GH H

I J

I�KLJM.N�O1P Q"R

SUT"V�W4VYX�Z\[^]�T,V_Z `,a�Vcbed�fg]hT"V�WiV�jkZhdE` M lmn oqp V�jEZhdE` P r dEWs�stu ovp V�jEZhdk` P rwr R�x ( )

y=z"{q|~}� ����������� � ( )z�{�|�}� ����������� �

( )�=�"���4�.���� ������� � `�a ( )�q�q�����0��  �¡�¢Θ £¤ W4V�¥"WiVE[<Vc`�]¦]=T,V¨§ � W4Zhdk©,[

T � W4ª�dk`¦Zh« � ª_¥¦¬\Zh]\©"a�V�[ � Z=`eV � «cT_W�V�jqZhdq` � fwdqW ­�®2¯≠ � `¦a

°E±D²= d�f³]�T�V�W � a,Z � ¬ � `�a_] � `,jEVc`�]wZ � ¬³«�dkª´¥"d�`�Vc`�]w[^fidEW^]�T�V`"d�µw¬�d � a¶fw¬=©�b·aqV.`�[<Z�]�¸¹§�V�«.]�dEW P»º T�V¼Vcb�¥qW�V�[4[�Z=d�`,[Ld�f¨]hT�V�[<VT � Wiª_d�`�Zh« � ª_¥,¬hZ ]�©,a�V�[ � W�V½jqZ §"V�`_Z=`L]hT�V^¾¿¥�¥¦V.`,a�Z'bÁÀ P

Page 6: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

� ������������ ���������������������� ��� �!��"$#&%��'�(�)��

����%+*-,.%/���0� ���� º T�V_a�V.§,Vc¬hdk¥,Vcaeª_d�a�Vc¬ T � [ Q VcVc` � ¥�¥"¬hZhVca¼]\d � ]�T�W�VcV�µ¥,T � [<V � [4¬=dk]�¬\V�[4[ ¥,V.W<ª � `�Vc`q]"ª � j `�Vc] Q Wi©,[�T�¬hV�[.[³ª_dE]�dEW³S´Z ]�T� `�Z=`�]wV.Wi` � ¬ Wid�]\dEW � `,a V*Z']hT,V/W�¥ � W � ¬h¬\Vc¬ d�W�W � a�Z � ¬ª � j `"Vc]�Z21*V*a ª � j `"Vc]�[ P43 dEW ]�T,V � ` � ¬h¸ ]�Z\« � ¬hµ\`�©qªÁVcW4Zh« � ¬«*dEª´¥ � W�Z\[<d�` � ]�T�V jEV*d�ª_V*]=W4Z\«�[4Z51EV�[¿dqfY]=T,V_ª_d�]hdkW � `�ae]�T�V¥,T�¸�[.Zw« � ¬1¥ � W � ª�V ]wV*W�[¿dqf³]�T"V�ª � jE`¦Vc] � W�V o 67 8:9<;=;′ = �

>? @BADC<C= � EF G�H<I=I

= � JLK= � MONP QBR SUTWV= fwdEW

X/YZ [:\�]+^= � _` a�b-cOd�e=f=g2h

∆ = � `�a i5j kBl \U[nmµ =Mpo V*d�a�¸ ª�Z=©�ª�µ r Wid�`,µpqYd�Widk` o!r<s�t!u R4P3 Z\j�[ P�v � `�a�w�[<T�dES Vcb�«*V*¬�¬\V�`�] � j WiV�V.ª�Vc`�] Q Vc]=S´V V�`� ` � ¬h¸E]wZh« � ¬ � `,a f�Z'`¦Z ]�V*µCV�¬=V ªÁV.`"]¦¥"WiV*a�Z�«c]�V a a�Z\[<]hW4Z Q ©�]�Z�dE`�[^dkf]�T,VY«cdqª´¥"d�`�Vc`�]w[³dqf"`�d,µ\¬�d � aLfi¬'©�bÁaqV�`¦[4Z']'¸ P�º T�Zw[ Z�[ ]hWw©"V � Z `V � «/T�W�V*jqZ=d�` � f�dkW Q d�]=T¼¥ � W � ¬=¬hVE¬ � `,a_W � a�Z � ¬¦ª � j `,Vc]\Z21 � ]hZhdE`� `�a�fwd�WLx yα = dEW{z |-} ~α =P

� �������� ��� �� ��� �� ����� ��� ���� � �� ��

���� ��

��� ��

�!� �O� � � � �O�5���2 �¡�¢/� �£�/¤�¥�¦ � � � ¥� �§ ¨©�£¡/� ª�¬«��®­��°¯��(�O± �²�2���4�5³���±p�p��±�´��µ±�¶��·«����=«�«��<«O­��¸¹�2¨�� ���º���»¼/�2� �5� � �5�

½$�5 �¡��O 2� � �2���O¥2¾:¤�¥O +�  ©� ¦

¸¹�5¨�� �O� �O¥2¾�¤�¥2 /�  �� ¦

¿�ÀÂÁ

ÃÄ�Å ÆÄ

Ä�Å ÆÃ

ÄÈÇ�Ä°É�ÄËÊ�ÄÌÃ5Í+IJÃ2Æ�Ä4Ã2Î�Ä·Í©Ã Ä�Í�Ï�Ä�ͩРĵÇ�Ä�Ä�Ç�Ç�ÄWÇ�É�Ä

Ñ+Ò2Ó©Ô�Õ2Ó�Ö × Ò�Ø�Ù5Ú2ÛUÜ�ÚOÓ+Õ Ó©Ö ÝÞBÒ5ß©× Ò�Ø�Ù5Ú2ÛUÜ�Ú5Ó$Õ Ó�Ö Ý

Þ¹Ò2ß�× Ò�Øà�á�âã/Ò2ä Ò5Ø Ø Õ5Ø

áåØ Õ5Ù£Ö ä × ÙOÒ5Ø+Ò5Ó�Ô�æ/Ø Ò ä$ÜpÚ Ý × Ö × Ú�Ó:ç ß�ÕOÔ/Å èé êëìêíîíï ðêñ ïò îíê óô êõöñô ÷øö îíðù ï úû üý

¿OþÿÁ��� ��������� �� ��������� �� ������� ��������������! "�����# $�!����!�% �� �! '&!�(#)����!�% ��* � $�+�,)%�!���- � ��! .�����/������- .(#�!�����0 �� 1��� $����+�0 �243.576-88:9�;<�$��α = 5>6��&¿©ÀÂÁ@?.�!�%� ���4� ACB/�@5D6�E4� FG(H(#I�� ¿©þ ÁC?J���K�����4� A/AB���5L6-MN� FJ(#(HI0�

OP�Q RPP�Q RO

S TUVTWXWY ZT[ Y\ XWT ]^ T_`[^ ab` XWZc Y de fg

Pih/Pkj/Pml/PnO$o�PpOqR�P7O$r�Ppo�O/P,o/s�PLo/t�PLh/P�Puh/h�P#h/j�Pv!w x�y�z {$| y$}�w�}�~/�/��w } {����0� | z | ��~K� �/x���Q �

�}$�/| }/w��v!���}�{ }�w w x�w

��}�~/��x�~�z | }�w�y$��������~�xq~$z �

�}��/| }/w�y���������~�x ~/z �

¿�ÀÂÁ

���� ����� ��

� �������� ��� �� ��� �� � ¡�� ¢£¡ ���¤ � ¥¦ §¨

�i©/�kª/�m«/�¬��­��p� ���C��®��p­����¯­/°��p­�±��L©/���u©/©��H©/ª��²0³ ´�µ�¶ · ¸ µ$¹ ³�¹�º$»/¼�³ ¹�·0½�¾�¿ ¸ ¶ ¸ ¾�ºÁÀ Â/´q»�� Ã

Ä�¹$Â�¸ ¹�³Å�²!ÆÇ�¹$· ¹ ³ ³ ´ ³

È�¹$º/»/´$º/¶ ¸ ¹�³�µ�¾�É�½�¾�º�´�º/¶ ¿Ä�¹$Â�¸ ¹�³�µ�¾�É�½�¾�º�´�º/¶ ¿

¿OþÿÁ�4�����ÊFN�%H� �� $�/����% ���������" $�������!�%���! "�����# ��������!�% �� �! "&��(#)����!�% ��* � $�+�,)�-���� ��� ����#�$������� �(H�-�����0 �� 1Ë�Ì �� ��+�0 Í2 3 576-88:9�;<�/���α = 5Î84� Ï���¿�À¹Á:?J��������4� AÐB��Ñ5Ò6�E4� Fm(H(#I��·¿OþÿÁÑ?.���K�����4� A�AB/�N5L6�M4� F�(�(#I0�

Ó Ô+Õ�ÖØ×NÙ�ÚJÛ�Ü�Õ�Ö

¾ ]hS�d�µwa�Z'ªÁVc`,[.Z=d�` � ¬ � ` � ¬=¸E]wZ\« � ¬ ª_d�a�VE¬ Z ` ¥,dq¬ � W«*d�d�WiaqZ ` � ]wV*[_T � [ Q V V�`�a�Vc§�V�¬�dE¥¦V�a fwdEW�[�©�W4f � «cV¶ªÁdE©�`�]\Vca[i¸ `,«.T�Widk`�d�©,[g¥¦V.W<ª � `,V.`"]¦ª � j `,V.]³ª � «cT,Z'`�V�[ P¦º T�Z�[gª�d�a�V ¬ª �-Ý V�[gZ�]�¥¦d�[.[<Z Q ¬�VY]\d´a�V ]�V.W<ª�Z'`�VY]�T�V¿`�d�µw¬�d � aLfi¬=©qbÁa�Vc`,[.Z ]�¸«cWiV � ]\V*a Q ¸ ]hT,V ª � j `"V�]i[ Z ` p V�jkZhdE` P r M ]hT�V � Z'W�µwj � ¥ªÁd�a�Z�fiZ�V*a Q ¸¿]�T,VHÞ � W<]�V.WËß [³« d�V*fwf<Z�« ZhV.`"] R � `"a p V�jEZ�dE` P r<r»M ]�T�VW�V*j�Z=dk`�Z'`,«*¬'©�a�Z `�jB]hT"V ª � j `,V.]i[ � `"a�]�T�V � Z W�µ<[C¥ � «*V*[Q V.]�S V*V.` ª � j `,Vc]w[ R�P³º d Z ªL¥"Wid�§�V_]�T,V¼a�V�[4Z\j `àß [¿¥qW�Vc«EZh[4Z�dE`� `�a jEVc`�VcW � ¬�Z']h¸ � ]�T�V � ©�]hT�dEW�[ T � §�V Z=`"]=W4d�a�©�«*VcaAZ'`�]�d�]�T�V� ` � ¬=¸�]\Z\« � ¬¼ªÁdqa�V�¬¼]=T"V «�T"d�Z\«�V Q V.]hS�V�V.` ]�S d ]=¸E¥¦V�[�d�f

ª � jE`�V/]�[ ª � j `,Vc]\Z51 � ]�Z�dE` oGá � W � ¬�¬�Vc¬ dEW p � a�Z � ¬ P º T�V� j W�V*V/ªÁVc`�]�dqf´]hT�V¹W�V*[�©,¬=]i[ d�f � ` � ¬=¸�]\Zh« � ¬ � `�a `�©�ª_VcW4Zh« � ¬« � ¬h«c©�¬ � ]\ZhdE`¦[^Z�[#âE©"Z ]�V´j�d�d�a P�º T�V¿ª � b�ZhªL©�ª V/WiWidkW^f�dEW^]�T�V« dEªÁ¥ � W�Z\[<d�` � ` � ¬h¸E]wZ�« � ¬hµ�`�©�ª_VcWiZ\« � ¬�Z\[ ãä å"ãËæ � SUT"Zh«cT Zh[W4V � [4dE` � Q ¬hV fwd�W � � ` � ¬�¸E]wZh« � ¬ ªÁdqa�V�¬ P�º T�Z�[ V.WiWidkW Zh[¥"WiZ'ª � W<Zh¬h¸ aE©"V¼]hd ]hT"V � [.[C©"ª´¥�]\ZhdE`�dqfYW4V*¬ � ]wZ §"V¼ª � j `�V ]wZ=«¥¦V.W<ªÁV � Q Z=¬hZ�]h¸�T�dEª�d�jEVc`�VEZ�] ¸LZ=` p V*j�Z=d�` P rwr.P

çéè4ê!è�ëNè ÖØ× è Ûì�NËíÑîYP ï_P�î T�© �Êð P�ñ dES�V �%ò P q½dq¬=]wV � `�a q P ¾´« Ý VcWwª � `�`,óô<r `,[�] � `�] � `,Vcd�©,[öõ � j `�Vc]wZ=« 3 Z\¬hVca ð Z�[C]hW�Z Q ©�]\ZhdE`�Z `

qYWC©�[CT,¬=VE[�[ á VcWwª � `�Vc`q]Øõ � j `,V/]Ua�«Lõ d�]hdkW�[ � á � W<] r o

Page 7: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

� ¥¦V.`�µ�Þ^Z W4«c©�Z'] 3 Z�V*¬ha ô ������������� ��������������������� ���� ���!�����4�#" d�¬ P O�$ � o d PhN �&%�� `�© � Wi¸ N'$�$ À � ¥�¥ PhN�Oÿv µN ÀUw PìhONí Þ P ò [<¥ � `�Vc] ó ô õ d�a�(E¬hZ�[ � ]�Z�dE` Vc]0«*dE`,«cVc¥q]�Z�dE`d�¥q]�Z ª � ¬�V a�V ªÁdE]wV.©�W4[ [ � `�[ Q � ¬ � Z�[*) [�]hWw©"«c]h©�W4VZ=`�§"V�W�[+(EV P ¾U¥q¥¦¬=Zh« � ]\Z=d�` � © ªÁdk]�Vc©�W�µ�W4dE©,V ô �,�#-������.���/ `,Z §"V�W�[4Z ]\¸0d�f 3 W � `"«�T"V*µ�Þgd�ª_]0( M./=3 Þ R � qYV�¬'fwd�W<] �%�� `�© � Wi¸ N�$�$�$ � ¥�¥ P=N w�À"µ N'1 w � `�a¿¥�¥ P O�2 À�µ O�2 w Pì À í õ P õ � W Ý dE§,Z�« � õ P % ©"fiV.W � `"a ¾ P Þ � [�[ � ]Ðó ô ¾ªÁdqaE©,¬ � ]�Z=d�` ª�Vc]�T�d�a ]\d a�Vc]\VcWiª�Z `"V ]=T¦V ª � jE`�V ]�Z�«fiZhVE¬ha¶Z ` á õ ªÁd�]\dEW�[ ô �3�#4.�����'��056����4� ¾¿©,jE©,[�] O87�7�O �¥�¥ PhN µ 1¦PìOvNí o�P qYdE©,¬�V/[Øó ô á W4Vca�Z�«c]�Z�dE` d�f o d�µ:9»d � a 3 ¬=©�b ð Vc`,[4Z ]�¸

ð Z�[�]=W�Z Q ©�]hZ�dE`BZ'` á V.Wiª � `�Vc`q]Cõ � jE`�Vc]<õ � «cT�Z'`�V [ ô ��;�����<�������� ���������=���>����?A@��!�B�CEDGF F�4��H��������������" d�¬ P r ¾´µ O N � o d P v � õ � ¸JI % ©�`"V NK$AL w � ¥�¥ P 1 À�À"µ 1-v À Pì w íNM_P 3 P p � [�ª´©,[.[<Vc` ó ô ¾¿` � ¬=¸k]�Z\« � ¬ á W4V�aqZh«.]wZhdE` d�f

õ � j `,V.]wZh« 3 Z�V ¬ha fwWid�ª>O�©�W4f � «*V õ·dE©q`�]�Vca á V.Wiª � `�Vc`q]õ � j `,V.] õ d�]�dEW ô �>�0�QP#����R������� �#4H�����BK�0�� 4

� A�;-��������SA�T?VUS���W8�K�YXZ��� []\h� O"V � ]=]w¬\V �_^ ¾ � õ � ¸N�$�$�$ � ¥�¥ P À v µwÀ 1 PìH1 í`M�P 3 P p � [<ªL©�[4[.Vc` �_% P ñ�P ðÁ� §�Z�V/[ � ºgP % P ò õ Z�¬�¬hVcW � õ P r4Põ «�aYZ\¬'¥ � `,a õ Pb� ¬ � W<© ó ô ¾¿` � ¬=¸E]wZ\« � ¬ � `�ao ©�ªÁVcWiZ�« � ¬mÞ dkª´¥q©�] � ]\Z=d�` dqf ¾´Z W�µ+a � ¥ õ � j `�Vc]�Z�«3 Z=VE¬ha�[ Z'` qYWw©¦[CT,¬=V�[�[ õ·dE]\dEW�[ S´Z']hT Oq©�Wif � « Vá V.Wiª � `�Vc`�] õ � jE`,V/]�[ ô �c�;�����R�����&�dA���!���A���e�������?8@��!�!�C DGF FT40����J�!�H���f�4� " d�¬ P À 1 � o d P 1 �o dE§�Vcª Q V�W+I ð Vc«*V.ª Q V.W O�7�7A7 � ¥�¥ P'N w v�2 µ N w-w v PìH2 íÑîYP ï_P4î T�© �'ð P4ñ dkS V � `,aéÞ P Þ P ÞgT � `Ñó ôwr ªL¥�W4dE§,Vca¾�` � ¬=¸k]�Z�« � ¬Ñõ d�a�V*¬ f<d�W á WiV a�Zh« ]hZ=`,j ]�T�V¬õ � j `�V ]�Z�«3 Z=VE¬ha ð Z\[C]hW�Z Q ©�]�Z�dE`�Z'`·q W<©,[<T�¬�V*[�[ á V.W<ª � `"V.`,]4õ � j `,Vc]õ � «.T,Z=`"V�[ ô �g�������h���A��������+�0���&�N��� � �� �T���d�H���4�" d�¬ P À L � o d P\N ��%c� `�© � Ww¸ O87�7�O � ¥�¥ P OqO�$ µ O À L"Pì.L�í 3 9 /ji�O ð ó ô�o dE]�Z�«*V a ß ©�]wZh¬�Z�[ � ]wZhdE` j (�`8(.W � ¬�V ô �" V�W�[<ZhdE` 2 P w 7¦P ÞgV*aEW � ]jO P ¾ ò ¬=V*«.]hW�Z=« � ¬ ò `,j�Z `,VcVcW�Z `¦j �N�7 Þ T"V�ª_Z=`�a�V_¥"Wd(e« � WwW�( � î Z'W�[�] � À L�OUvA1 õ òlk 9¦¾ o

Þ^VcaqV�b¦µ 3 p ¾ o Þ ò P

mon�n è Ö�p�Ü.qDGF8F����r? �0s,t�u º T�V¿a�Z fwfiV.W�V.`�]"T � W<ªÁdE`¦Z�« � ª´¥¦¬=Z�]h©�aqV*[ x f�dEW v�wyx≠ � v�wzx= � `"a�¥ � W � ¬h¬=VE¬"d�W³W � a�Z � ¬qª � j `,V/]�Z21 � ]hZ�d�` x dqf¦]�T�VW � a�Z � ¬ � `�a¿] � `,j�V.`�]\Z � ¬"«cd�ªL¥,d�`�V/`�]�[ f<dEW³]=T,V^W4V.ª � `�Vc`�]"fw¬=©�b_a�V.`�[<Z�]h¸�§�VE«.]�dkW»d�f ]=T,V^ª � j `"V.]C[ � W�V o{

|H}�~_}f� ���������0�����#�_�H��|�� ��~��&�]�g|0}�~_���������8�������#�����f~B�T|:�( ) ( )

( )( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

�0� �����&��� � � ��� ��� �� ��� � ¡¢���z£B¤���¡*��� ¡¢���z£B¤���¡*���� � � �¡ ���

¥ ¦⋅ § ¨ § ¨π π

© ©= ⋅ − ⋅ + ⋅α + + ⋅ − ⋅α

ª «¬ ­ ¬ ­§ ¨ © ©® ¯ ® ¯° ±

π −¬ ­® ¯² M ¾ NEP � R

( ) ( ) ( )³�´ µ³³�´&¶;·�¸�¹ºµ ¸ ¸» ¼» ¼ ½�¾À¿Á Â

= ⋅ α π + α πà Äπ

Å M ¾ NEP Q"R

( ) ( )Æ�Ç ÈÆÆ�ÇgÉ�Ê ÈËcÌ ÍÌ Í�Î Ï Ð+ÑHÏeÏÓÒÏ Ô⋅ π

Õ Ö= ⋅ α× Ø

π Ù ÚÛ M ¾ NEP « R

( ) ( )Ü0Ý ÞÜÜ�ÝSß8à�á�âzÞãcä åä åçæ!è é+êHè ë ì⋅ π

í î= ⋅ αï ð

π ñ òó M ¾ NEP a R

ô õHö�÷_öfø ù�ú�û�ü�ý0þ�ø�ú#ÿ��Hý�õ�����÷��&û�gõ0ö�÷_õ.ø�ü��÷;ü õ�ý�ø���þ�û�ú#ÿ�û�ü&÷�ü�õ�

( ) ( )( )

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )��� �������� � � ��

����� �� � �"! #$!%�'&)(�!*#+!�� #$!��'&,(-!*#.!/���� �%�# !%�Θ0 1

⋅ 2 3 2 3π π4 4

= ⋅ − ⋅ + ⋅α − + ⋅ − ⋅α5 67 8 7 8

2 3 4 49 : 9 :; <π −7 89 :

= M ¾ NEP V R

( ) ( ) ( )>-? @>�?�ACBCD%EF@ D DG HG H IKJ-LΘ M N= ⋅ α π − α πO P

π

Q M ¾ N�P f R

( )R�S�TCU VW XZY"[ \Θ =] M ¾ NEP j R

( )^�_�`Ca�b%c'de f gΘ =h M ¾ NEP T R

Page 8: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

������������� �� ( ) ( )� � �������

�Θ =

µ ⋅µ Θ� M ¾ O1P � R

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )�� ��� ����� � ��� ��� � ��� ���� �� ������ �!� � �"� � ���Θ

# $∂ Θ ∂ Θ% &

Θ = ⋅ Θ − Θ ⋅ Θ −∂Θ ∂Θ

% &' ()) )*+ * M ¾ O1P Q"R

�,�-���.�/��0�213� º T,V¶a�ZhfCf�V/W�Vc`�]�T � Wiª_d�`�Z\« � ªL¥¦¬hZ=]�©�a�V*[ � Z=` V � «.TAW�V*j�Z=dk` � fwd�W 46587≠ � `�a 46597= dkf´]hT�V¹W � a�Z � ¬ � `�a] � `�jEVc`q]�Z � ¬"«�dEª_¥"dE`,V.`�]w[ fidEW ]hT�V¨`�d,µ\¬�d � a�f<¬=©�b´a�V/`,[�Z']h¸�§"V�« ]�dEW � W4V oµ �;:��=<>0?6�3@ A�� B CD EFD ′′′′≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤

�G

H I3JKIML>NPO;Q6R3S0TULVOXWKY S�H[Z�\]J.^_Qa`bH0I3JKN.LV\�S�L-YVT�Q6OXWcQ6RMJdRHfe

( ) ( )gPh g!h gPhi j j jk l/m g8n k l-m gon p pq r q qs t�u r!u v s t�u v q q r r

w xy z{y z y z| }= ⋅ + ⋅

~ ��~ � ~ �′ ′

| }� �� �{� �� �� � M ¾ÁÀ P � R

( ) ( )�� �� �/�]�P�!��� � �����!�!��� �� ��� � � � � �

� �′

� �� �= ⋅ + � �� �  ¡¢ £

¤ ¤ M ¾ÁÀ P Q"R

G H I3JKIML>NPO;Q6R3S0TULVOXWKY S�H[Z�\]J.^_Qa`bH0I3JKH¥LVR]¦�J!R�H[S�L-YVT�Q6OXWUQ6R_J§R3H[e

( ) ( )¨P© ¨P©¨P©ª ª ª« ¬/­ ¨8® « ¬-­ ¨o® ¯ ¯° ° ± °² ³�´ ±!´ µ ² ³�´ µ ± ° ° ±Θ

¶ ·¸ ¹F¸ ¹¸ ¹º »= ⋅ − ⋅

¼ ½¾¼ ½¼ ½′ ′

º »¿ À ¿ ÀF¿ ÀÁ Âà à M ¾ÁÀ P « R

( ) ( )��� �/�]�P�!��� � �����!�!��� �� ��� � � � ��Θ

� �′

� �� �= ⋅ −� �� �  ¡¢ £

¤ ¤ M ¾ÁÀ P a R

µ Ä Å;Æ�Ç=È>Ä0É6Å3Ê Ë!Ë.Ì Í ÎÏ ÐÑÏ≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤≤ ≤ Ì

Ò H I3JKIML>NPO;Q6R3S0TULVOXWKY S�H[Z�\]J.^_Qa`bH0I3JKN.LV\�S�L-YVT�Q6OXWcQ6RMJdRHfe

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )ÓPÔÖÕ ÓPÔÖÕ ÓPÔÖÕ ÓPÔÖÕ× × × ×Ø Ø Ù-Ú ÓoÛ Ø�Ø Ù/Ú ÓoÛ Û ÛÜ Ü

Ý Þ Þ Þß à�á Ý á â ß à"á â à�á[â âVã à�á âÞ Þ Ý Ý− − + +

ä åæ ç æ ç æ ç æ çè é= ⋅ + + ⋅ + ⋅

ê ë ê ë ê ë ê ëè éì í ì íì í ì íî ïð ð ð ðñ ò M ¾ÁÀ P V R

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )ó óôõ õ õ ö÷ ÷ ø/ù]úPû.ü ô ÷�÷ ø/ù]úPû!ü ô õ�ö�ý ùPúPû�ü ôö õ

þÿ � ÿ ÿ� þ���� � þ � ��� � � � � þ� ÿ � ÿ Θ

� �� � � � � � � �= ⋅ + + ⋅ − + −

� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � ��� � �� M ¾vÀ P f R

� ������� �"!$#&%('�)+*,�-#/.�0�)1�32546�879%;:<�+�����=�-'6>?�@'5�3)1�A0-*B%(#/.,%('9�C'��3D

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )E$FHG E$FIGE$FJG E$FJGK K KL L MAN EPO L1L MQN EPO O OR R

S S T SU V�W�T@W�X U V�W3X V�W�X VYW=XS T S T− −+ +Θ

Z [\ ] \ ]\ ] \ ]^ _= ⋅ − + ⋅ −

` a ` a` a ` a^ _b c b cb c b cd ef f f fg h M ¾ÁÀ P j R

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )i ijk k lm m nAoqp$rts j m m nAo6p$r8s j k1l?u o$p$rvs jl k

wx y x xz w�{�y z w | } ~ } ~ z wy � x y xΘ Θ

� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �= ⋅ − + ⋅ + +

� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � ��� � �� �����Q� �6�

Page 9: Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted ...Analytical Modelling of No-Load Density in Surface Mounted Permanent Magnet Motor Fr ed eric Dubas, Christophe Espanet,

� � ������� ( )( ) ( ) ( )

��� ������ � � �� ��� �� �������

� �� ����� ����� ������ �� �������! �

+" #$ % $ %& '

⋅ ⋅ + ⋅ +( ) ( )& '* + * +, -

= " #$ %& '⋅ −

( )′

& '* +, -

. . ..

/ 0 1 ��� �5� 2��

( )

( ) ( ) ( )3 3 34 5 6 6 56 587:9�;�<>= 4 4? ? ? 6@ A 9B;�<C= 4 36

?

D E E E EF D D G HI E E E EF D

EIKJ E

Θ

L ML MON P N P N P N PQ RQ R− ⋅ − + ⋅

S TUS T S T S T′ ′ ′

Q RQ R V WV W V W V WX Y X Y= L MN PQ R

⋅ −S T

′Q RV WX Y

Z Z ZZ

[ [ ��� �5� \ �

( )( ) ( ) ( )

]�^`_ ]�^`_ a�]b^c d de e ef f fg g hji ]Ue a�]�^cf

k k kl m�n:o m�n�o m�n�ok k kp m�n�o

klrq k

+ −s tu v u v u vw x

⋅ ⋅ + + ⋅y z y z y z

′ ′ ′w x{ | { | { |} ~

= s tu vw x⋅ −

y z′

w x{ |} ~

� � ��

� � � �����Q� �6�

( )

( ) ( ) ( )� �� � � ������������>� � �� � �� � � �B����� � ���

� � � �� � � � � �� � � �� �

���� �

Θ

� �� �O� � � � � �� �� �− ⋅ − + ⋅

  ¡   ¡   ¡′ ′

� �� � ¢ £¢ £ ¢ £¤ ¥ ¤ ¥= � �� �� �

⋅ −  ¡

′� �¢ £¤ ¥

¦ ¦ ¦¦

§ § ��� �5� ¨��

( ) ( ) ( )© © ª�«�¬>­¯®�©°�±�² °�±�² ³ °�±�²Θ= −´ ´ ´µ ¶ �=� �A� · �( ) ( ) ( ) ( )¸ ¹�º�»�¼¯½U¸ ¸¾�¿�À Á ¾�¿�À ÀÃÂ!Ä ¾�¿�ÀΘ= − + ⋅Å Å ÅÆ Ç �����Q� È6�( ) ( ) ( ) ( )É Ê�Ë�Ì�ͯÎUÉ ÉÏ�Ð�Ñ Ò Ï�Ð�Ñ ÑÔÓÖÕ Ï�Ð�ÑΘ= + − ⋅× × ×Ø Ù �����Q� Ú-�

( ) ( ) ( )( )

ÛÛ�Ü�ÝßÞBàUá Û Ü�ÝßÞBàUáá âã äæå�ç çÃèéã ä�å�çä�å�ç ê ç�è

Θ + ⋅= ë ì

−í îï ðñ ññò �����Q� óA�

( ) ( ) ( )ôõ ô�ö�÷ßøBù�úbûüõ ô�ö�÷�ø�ù�úbûüõý þ ý þ ýΘ= +

ÿ ÿ ÿ������Q�

��