An Assessment of the Value of the term "Cultural Industries" in Reference to Comedic Practice at the...

7/31/2019 An Assessment of the Value of the term "Cultural Industries" in Reference to Comedic Practice at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe

1/23

%%%%%%%%%%

40094>9

Hgfqka PAIJ 930:

Igovahpgtctz Jyyqay jo vma Iqkvqtck Jofqyvtjay

Vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy qyaf jo c |jfa tcola gn igova}vy vg fayitjda

igovahpgtctz itacvj~a ptcivjia/ Cyyayy vma ~ckqa gn vma vath dz tanataoia vg goa ctac gn

itacvj~a ptcivjia |jvm |mjim zgq cta nchjkjct/

Ckjia GLtcfz

Yimggk gn Patngthcoia cof Iqkvqtck Jofqyvtjay

Vma Qoj~atyjvz gn Kaafy

3:'01'4033

%%%%%%%%%%


2/23

40094>9

( 3 (

Vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy qyaf jo c |jfa tcola gn igova}vy vg fayitjda

igovahpgtctz itacvj~a ptcivjia/ Cyyayy vma ~ckqa gn vma vath dz tanataoia vg goa ctac gn

itacvj~a ptcivjia |jvm |mjim zgq cta nchjkjct/

\jvm 4+619 ymg|y joikqfaf jo Cqlqyv 4030y vmtaa(|aae a~aov+ vma Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck

Ntjola jy ctlqcdkz vma hgyv jhpgtvcov cooqck a~aov go Dtjvcjoy iqkvqtck ickaofct+ pqtpgtvafkz

laoatcvjol dav|aao


3/23

40094>9

( 4 (

340(3>0y go|ctfy -Mayhgofmcklm . Dceat+ 40332 6*+ vma

vath mcy daao taptayaovcvj~a gn vma ighhgfjvjycvjgo gn iqkvqta+ lg~atohaovck kaljvjhjycvjgo

gn vma ctvy+ cof gqt aigoghji takjcoia go itacvj~jvz/ \mcv hceay cockzyjy gn vma iqkvqtck

jofqyvtjay yqim c ighpka} ctac jy vma nciv vmcv iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy c vath fanjoaf dz jvy

qycla+ cof jvy qycla mcy daao a}vtahakz dtgcf cof ~ctjaf/

Mayhgofmcklm -400


4/23

40094>9

( 9 (

Fc~jf Vmtgydzy hgfak qyanqkkz taiglojyay vma igovtcyvjol yimggky gn vmgqlmv jo takcvjgo vg

vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jo vmcv+ go vma goa mcof+ vma vath ptg~jfay c ngiqy go vma ta~aoqa(

actojol pgvaovjck gn jovakkaivqck ptgpatvz tjlmvy cof go vma gvmat c ngiqy go vma iqkvqtck

~ckqa jomataov jo vma ptgfqivy gn vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay -400=2 36=*/

Jo jvy dtgcfayv yaoya+ vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy c qvjkjvz vmcv ico da cpptgptjcvaf vg

ckkg| dgvm vma pqt~azgty gn itacvj~a ctvy vma gppgtvqojvz vg ciiayy vma njocoijck pgvaovjck gn

vmajt |gte ngt vma ptgkjnatcvjgo gn vmcv |gte+ cof ighhatijck gtlcojycvjgoy vma gppgtvqojvz vg

vqto iqkvqtck icpjvck jovg njocoijck icpjvck/ Vmjy a}imcola dav|aao vmaya v|g aovjvjay jy og

davvat fjypkczaf vmco |jvmjo vma gtlcojycvjgock ctimjvaivqta gn vma Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck Ntjola+

cof hgyv yjlojnjicovkz |jvmjo vma ighafz yaivjgo gn vma ptgltchha/ Jv jy jo vmjy yaoya gn vma

vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay vmcv J ch lgjol vg a}pkgta jvy ~ckqa/

Cy Hafmqtyv yvcvay+ ighafz pkczy co cdygkqvakz pj~gvck tgka jo vma igoyvtqivjgo gn gqt

iqkvqtck jfaovjvz -400


5/23

40094>9

( 6 (

ngqt ojlmv gqvfggt ighafz ymg| -Yqimyhckkpgtvjgoy/igh+ 4033**/ Jn vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola

joypjtay vma vmacvta ighhqojvz dazgof Yigvkcof -Dcvimakfat+ 400>2 1*+ vmao jv yjolka(

mcofafkz ftj~ay vma Dtjvjym ighafz ighhqojvz ngt|ctf/

Ighafz ngthy 91! gn vma Ntjola ptgltchha -Fc~jy+ 400:5 Mckk+ 4030*+ cof zav vma =00%

ighafz ymg|y yaa nct kayy vmco 91! gn vma cof ncijkjvcvay vma yvcljol gn -hgyvkz ighafz* patngthcoia |gte |jvm

og ~aoqa g~atmacfy ngt vma patngthaty+ cof og vjieav igyvy ngt vma cqfjaoia/ Dz kggejol cv

Ntjola ighafz cy c qojsqa+ dqv joitafjdkz jhpgtvcov+ ctac gn itacvj~a ptcivjia+ J |jkk pgyjvjgo

co ctlqhaov vg|ctfy c vmagtavjick cof ptcivjick cpptgcim vg vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay+ jo |mjim

vmaya jofqyvtjay cta fanjoaf cof igkkaivaf ogv dz vma ocvqta gn vma |gte vmaz ptgfqia+ dqv jo

vma ighhatijck hcooat jo |mjim vmaz ptgfqia jv/


6/23

40094>9

( 1 (

\mao vmjoejol cdgqv vma a}jyvjol pgyjvjgo gn kj~a patngthcoia |gte+ jv jy jovatayvjol vg

igoyjfat Mayhgofcmklmy ~ja| vmcv vmacvta yjvy go vma patjpmatjay gn vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay+

fqa vg vma nciv vmcv jv fgay ogv qvjkjya jofqyvtjck ptgfqivjgo havmgfy qdjsqjvgqykz -400 Ntjola+ Yqofcz

Matckfigkqhojyv Jcjo Hci|mjtvat tanattaf vg vma Qofatdakkz -oa Yhjtognn Qofatdakkz*+ goa

gn vma Ntjolay kctlayv ighafz ~aoqay -cof Yva|ctv Kaay ~aoqa jo 400>*+ cy c v|g hjkkjgo

pgqof yqdvattcoaco iqkvqta ncivgtz -400>*/ Vma igoogvcvjgoy cyygijcvaf |jvm Hci|mjtvaty

ighhaov+ gn co cqvghcvaf+ paiqojctz+ jofqyvtjckjyaf Ntjola icoogv da ayicpaf/ Nqtvmathgta+

Hci|mjtvaty ighhaov pkczy jovg vma mcofy gn vma jovaoya itjvjijyh vmcv daao ka~akkaf cv vma

Ntjola ~aoqa ighpcojay g~at vma kcyv 30 zacty+ ngt |mcv ico gokz da fayitjdaf cy vtacvjol vma

Ntjola cy c iqkvqtck jofqyvtz/

Jv jy jhpgtvcov vg yvcva+ cv vmjy pgjov+ vmcv vma kctlayv ptgltchhjol ~aoqay cv vma Afjodqtlm

Nayvj~ck Ntjola cta ighhatijck gtlcojycvjgoy5 vg c iatvcjo a}vaov+ a~ao tafanjojol |mcv jy

hacoy vg ickk yghavmjol c ~aoqa/ Vma Cyyahdkz+ Ljkfaf Dckkggo+ Pkacycoia+ cof

Qofatdakkz -vma Djl Ngqt ~aoqa ighpcojay* gpatcva citgyy hqkvjpka ptahjyay -|jvm vma

a}iapvjgo gn vma Dckkggo*+ cof tqo dav|aao : cof 43 vmacvta ypciay acim/ Faypjva vma qojsqa+


7/23

40094>9

( > (

jofj~jfqck+ ctvjyvtz gn vma patngthcoiay vmcv vcea pkcia |jvmjo vmaya tgghy+ vmaya ~aoqa

ighpcojay cta vqtojol g~at patngthcoia |gte go co jofqyvtjck yicka |jvm hjkjvctz(ptaijyjgo+

gnnatjol jonka}jdkz vjlmv vqtog~at vjha dav|aao ymg|y+ yg cy vg itch cy hcoz itacvj~a hgoaz(

hceaty jovg vma fcz cy pgyyjdka/ Vmaya ighpcojay yakk vma kctlayv oqhdat gn vjieavy+ cof

ptg~jfa vma ltacvayv ka~ak gn pqdkji a}pgyqta ngt vmajt yvclaf patngthcoiay/ Vma Ntjola

nayvj~ck hgfak+ |mjim |cy fa~jyaf jo Afjodqtlm jo 3:62 310*/ Hgyv ntjola nayvj~cky gpv ngt iaovtckjyaf

~aoqa hcoclahaov+ mg|a~at jv jy yjlojnjicov vg ogva vmcv vma |gtkfy vmtaa kctlayv ntjola

nayvj~cky mc~a fa~akgpaf qofat Afjodqtlmy ~aoqa hgfak -Dcvimakfat+ 400>2 313*/

Vmata jy og fgqdv vmcv vmjy ntaa hcteav ckkg|y ngt vma gtlcoji ighhatijck ltg|vm gn vma

Ntjola+ mg|a~at cv |mcv igyv vg jvy itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty7 Jo ~ja|jol Hci|mjtvaty ighhaovy

jo vmjy igova}v+ jv jy jhpgtvcov vg igoyjfat vma a}vaov vg |mjim ma qyay vma |gtf ncivgtz ogv jo

c ighhatijck yaoya+ dqv c laoatcvjgock yaoya/ Yjoia vma djtvm gn iqkvqtck yvqfjay jo vma 3:>0y+

vathy vmcv ntcha iqkvqtck civj~jvjay cof ctvancivy cy ighhgfjvjay mc~a taiaj~af ighhgo qycla/

Jy jv pgyyjdka vg igoyjfat vma vathy iqkvqtck icpjvck+ iqkvqtck cyyavy+ cof iqkvqtck ptgfqivjgo

|jvmgqv vma jonkqaoia gn aigoghjiy7

Vma coy|at vg vmjy sqayvjgo kjay jo vma yqdbaivj~jvz gn vmaya vathy qyay/ Mg|a~at+ vmjy

sqayvjgo tcjyay vma ptayaov fcolat jo qyjol kcolqcla vmcv ico da acyjkz cpptgptjcvaf vg njv

|jvmjo vma jofj~jfqck cjhy gn c pctvjiqkct dgfz/ A~ao igoyjfatjol vma vath ~ckqa+ jo vma

igova}v gn vma vjvka gn vmjy pcpat+ ngtiay qy vg igoyjfat dgvm co aigoghji fanjojvjgo gn ~ckqa

vmcv cvvtjdqvay njocoijck |gtvm+ cof c vmagtavjick fanjojvjgo vmcv yjlojnjay iqkvqtck jhpgtvcoia/


8/23

40094>9

( < (

Patmcpy vmata jy tggh ngt c yav gn vathjogkgljay vmcv ptgnayy vma jhpgtvcoia gn vma itacvj~a

ctvy+ cof vma iqkvqtck jhpciv gn vmgya ctvy go gqt ygijavz+ |jvmgqv nckkjol jovg co aigoghji

hgqkf/

Vma nciv vmcv Hci|mjtvaty iqkvqta ncivgtz jy ntchaf dz vma 4 hjkkjgo pgqof/// vmcv

ptaiafay jv+ kgicvay mjy ighhaov ~atz hqim jo vma ao~jtgoy gn aigoghji fjltayyjgo/ Mg|a~at+

jo gtfat vg cyyayy vma ~ckqa gn vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jo tanataoia vg Ntjola ighafz+ jv jy

jhpgtvcov vg a}pkgta vma aigoghjiy gn vmjy cttcolahaov dav|aao itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoat cof

vmajt ~aoqa ighpcojay/

Jv jy c |jfakz ciiapvaf pctv gn vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola a}patjaoia vmcv ighafjcoy -cof Ntjola

patngthaty laoatckkz* cta kjeakz vg kgya yjlojnjicov chgqovy gn hgoaz cy pctv gn yvcljol vmajt

|gte -Ctvmqt+ 400=5 Icttakk+ 400:2 365 Ig}+ 400=5 Natlqygo+ 400:5 Kglco+ 400=2 4>5

Tc~aomjkk+ 400=2 4=*/ Dtjco Maoojlco+ vma Dtjvjym hcoclat gn Chatjico ighji Fgql

Yvcomgpa+ ikcjhy vmcv vma c~atcla chgqov vmcv ighafjcoy kgya cv vma Ntjola acim zact jy bqyv

g~at */ Vjha Gqvitjvji Vjh Ctvmqt cltaay+ yvcvjol vmcv hgyv

ighafjcoy go vma ntjola kgya dav|aao 6+000 cof =+000 -400=*/ Jo Cqlqyv 400=+ Vma

Yigvyhco tapgtvaf go yeavim ighafjco Dcttz Nactoy2 vma njtyv patygo eog|o vg mc~a lgoa

dcoetqpv cy c tayqkv gn patngthjol cv vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola+ cnvat pkgqlmjol 40+000 jovg vma

yvcljol cof hcteavjol gn mjy ymg| Vmjy Yeavim Ymg| Dakgoly vg Kjgoak Tjvimja -Ig}+ 400=*/

Vma qofatyvcofjol chgolyv ighafjcoy jy vmcv vma kgyy yqyvcjoaf cv vma Ntjola jy c ictaat

jo~ayvhaov+ cy vma nayvj~ck ptg~jfay ~ckqcdka gppgtvqojvjay ngt pqdkji a}pgyqta cof

oav|gtejol |jvmjo vma ighafz ighhqojvz vmcv fg ogv a}jyv ngt 33 hgovmy gn vma zact/

Patngth c itjvjick mjv cv vma Ntjola+ cof jv igqkf da aogqlm vg ngtia vma yvap(qp ntgh chcvaqt

vg ptgnayyjgock ighji/


9/23

40094>9

( = (

Go vmjy dcyjy+ jv jy pgyyjdka vg yaa vmcv vma njocoijck kgyy yqyvcjoaf dz ighjiy jo Cqlqyv a~atz

zact jy c |tjvvao pctv gn vma ighafz jofqyvtz/ Jv jy c fzochji vmcv jy kchaovaf+ cof ciiapvaf jo

asqck hacyqta/ Daicqya ptgnayyjgock ighjiy cta jofj~jfqcky |mg mc~a yqiiaafaf qofat vma

iqttaov yzyvah+ vmjy njocoijck yvtqllka jy yaao cy c tjva gn pcyycla ngt oa| ighafz

ptcivjvjgoaty/ Mg|a~at+ fgay jv mc~a vg da vmjy |cz7 Vma ighafz jofqyvtz jy co ctac gn

itacvj~a ptcivjia vmcv fgay ogv qya vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay vg ptgnayy vma iqkvqtck |gtvm

gn vma |gte vmcv jv itacvay vg ygijavz cv kctla/ ^aoqa ighpcojay go vma gvmat mcof+ fqa vg vmajt

takcvjgoymjp |jvm Afjodqtlm Igqoijk3+ cta nct hgta jo vqoa |jvm vma lg~atohaovck

cfhjojyvtcvj~a yvtcvaljay vmcv kgge vg vcp jovg vg vma aigoghji pgvaovjck gn vma Ntjola cy c

iqkvqtck jofqyvtz -Dgrvcy2 400=*/

Jv jy jhpgtvcov vg qofatyvcof vmcv c yjlojnjicov ptgpgtvjgo gn vma igyvy joiqttaf dz ighjiy cv

vma Ntjola cta cvvtjdqvaf vg ~aoqa mjta naay/ Vma yzyvah jo pkcia |gtey |jvm acim ptgfqivjgo

ayyaovjckkz mc~jol vg dqz vmajt cqfjaoiay vjieavy ntgh vmajt ~aoqa jo cf~coia gn vma nayvj~ck+

jo vma mgpa vmcv vmaz lcjo aogqlm cqfjaoia hahdaty fqtjol vmajt tqo vg tavqto vmcv

jo~ayvhaov/ Hcoz ymg|y fg ogv cimja~a vmjy+ cof vmjy jy dangta hcteavjol cof kj~jol igyvy cta

ncivgtaf jovg vma asqcvjgo2 ymg|y ico yakk gqv cv vmjy nayvj~ck cof vma pagpka |mg cta fgjol

vmah ico yvjkk kgya vmajt hgoaz -Dqvkat jo Dcvimakfat+ 400>2 316*/ Ntaakcoia ptgfqiat Yvq

Faojygo dakja~ay vmcv vma ~aoqay bqyv yaah vg yaa vma nayvj~ck cy c ltacv imcoia vg tjp

a~atzgoa gnn -Vqtoaz+ 4030*+ c ~ja| pgpqkct chgolyv vma Ntjolay ighjiy cof ymctaf dz

Fgql Yvcomgpa+ |mg ctlqay vmcv ~aoqay vcea qp |cz vgg kctla c imqoe gn vma hgoaz

-Kglco+ 400=2 4>*/ Jo 4000+ Vma Gdyat~aty ctv igttaypgofaov coayyc Vmgtpa a}ptayyaf

igoiatoy vmcv c |akk(eog|o ntjola nayvj~ck ~aoqa |jkk vcea qp vg 60 pat iaov gn vma dg}(gnnjia

3 C takcvjgoymjp ayvcdkjymaf vmtgqlm vma ~aoqay cooqck pqtimcya gn vahpgtctz aovatvcjohaov kjiaoiay -Vqtoaz+

4030*/


10/23

40094>9

( : (

hgoaz ngt co civ -40002 =*/ Jo 4033+ vmjy 60! jy vma dcta hjojhqh+ |jvm hgyv ighpcojay

joiqttjol mjlmat naay/ Go vma yqtncia jy yaahy cy vmgqlm vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay+ cy co qoqyaf

qvjkjvz+ mgkfy og ~ckqa |mcvyga~at vg vma itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty gn Ntjola ighafz+ oajvmat jo

vathy gn vma iqkvqtck jhpgtvcoia gnnataf vg vmjy |gte -kj~a ighafz jy yvjkk |mgkkz igoyjfataf c

laota gn aovatvcjohaov cy gppgyaf vg co ctv(ngth -Ntjafhco+ 40332 96=**+ ogt jo vma njocoiay

vmcv yaah vg da yjpmgoaf c|cz ntgh ighafjcoy pgieavy cof jovg vma dcoe ciigqovy gn vma

~aoqa ighpcojay/

Mg|a~at+ qoyqtptjyjolkz+ jv jy ogv vmcv yjhpka/ Dcvimakfat yvtgolkz ctlqay jo nc~gqt gn vma

~aoqay aovtaptaoaqtjck ptcivjiay+ go vma dcyjy vmcv vmaz cta vma yvtqivqta hgyv taypgoyjdka ngt

vma Ntjolay cdjkjvz vg ltg| acim zact -400>2 314*+ cof mc~a daao qoncjtkz fahgojyaf dz

Ntjola patngthaty/ Mg|a~at+ J |gqkf ctlqa asqckkz yvtgolkz vmcv vma Ntjolay cdjkjvz vg ltg|

|gtey go c yjhpka dcyjy gn yqppkz cof fahcof dav|aao vma ~aoqa ighpcojay cof vma

patngthaty/ Vmata cta ogv aogqlm cqfjaoiay vg lg ctgqof+ vmata cta c yqtpkqy gn patngthcoia

ypciay4+ cof co joitacyjolkz kctla oqhdat gn patngthcoia ighpcojay ptapctaf vg pcz lggf

hgoaz vg patngth9/ \mcv Dcvimakfaty ctvjika fgay tcjya mg|a~at+ cta sqayvjgoy g~at vma

cyyqhaf njocoijck yaiqtjvz gn vma ~aoqa ighpcojay/

Dcvimakfat fjyhjyyay vma itjvjijyh gn ~aoqay dz patngthaty cy yjhpkjyvji faoqoijcvjgoy gn

~aoqa hcoclaty |mjka cfhjvvjol vmcv vmaz eog| ~jtvqckkz ogvmjol gn vma aigoghjiy jo~gk~af

-400>2 3>9*/ Yma mcy c pgjov/ Imctkja \ggfy+ vma ig(fjtaivgt gn vma Qofatdakkz yvcvay vmcv vma

joigha vmcv |a dtjol jo fgayo,v a}iaaf gqt igyvy cof hcjovcjoy vmcv vma tayv gn vma Djl Ngqt

4Vmaya v|g cyyatvjgoy cta ka~akkaf go vma dcyjy vmcv2 njtyvkz+ c fjyvjoiv hjogtjvz gn ymg|y cv vma Ntjola patngth vg

ygkf gqv tgghy -vma c~atcla cqfjaoia yjra cv vma Ntjola jy pqtpgtvafkz ojoa -Ljt~co+ 4030**+ cof yaigofkz Vma

Nayvj~ck Ntjola Ygijavz yaofy gqv co a(hcjk vg|ctfy vma aof gn ptgltchhjol -hjf(Cptjk* a~atz zact+ |jvm

jongthcvjgo go ckk vma patngthcoiay ykgvy vmcv ~aoqa ighpcojay cta mc~jol fjnnjiqkvz vtzjol vg njkk/

9 Vma 4030 nayvj~ck nacvqtaf c 3


11/23

40094>9

( 30 (

cta ckyg gpatcvjol cv c kgyy -Ig}+ 400=*/ Jv jy fjnnjiqkv vg qofatyvcof mg| vmjy ico da vma icya+

dqv cy Ig} yvcvay+ |jvmgqv ciiayy vg vma taka~cov pcpat|gte jv,y jhpgyyjdka vg vakk/ -400=*/

Ighafjco Bjh Bannatjay+ |mg patngthy cv vma Qofatdakkz igoyjfaty vma ogvjgo vmcv vma ~aoqa

ighpcojay cta gpatcvjol cv c kgyy cy c kgcf gn tqddjym# J eog| |mcv J pcz ngt hz tggh#

-Hc}|akk+ 400=*/ Mg|a~at+ Bannatjay ctlqhaov yvjkk nckky |jvmjo vma tackhy gn ypaiqkcvjgo/

\mcv jy ygha|mcv igonqyjol mg|a~at jy vmcv |mjkyv ighafjcoy cta a}vtahakz ntcoe cdgqv vma

patygock kgyyay vmaz joiqt+ vma ~aoqa ighpcojay cta nct kayy yg/ Jn Imctkja \ggfy jy

fayitjdjol vma yjvqcvjgo |jvm c ygha|mcv kggya cpptgcim vg vma vtqvm+ ngt vma Qofatdakkz vg

cppact hgta ctvjyvjickkz yzhpcvmavji vmco jv civqckkz jy+ vmao jv jy qofatyvcofcdka |mz ypaijnji

njlqtay mc~a ogv daao dcofjaf ctgqof/ Vma ~aoqay takz go vma igovjoqaf iggpatcvjgo gn vma

patngthaty/ Mg|a~at+ vg nqtvmat ighpgqof vmjy jyyqa+ Ectao Egtao+ vma ctvjyvji fjtaivgt gn vma

Ljkfaf Dckkggo+ fanaofaf vma tgdqyv ighhatijckjyh gn vma Djl Ngqt dz faikctjol vmcv J

mc~a vma djllayv hgtvlcla jo vma |gtkf/ \a mc~a vg yqt~j~a -Hc}|akk+ 400=*/ \mjima~at

|cz zgq kgge cv jv+ zgq icov pcz c hgtvlcla |mjkyv joiqttjol c patygock kgyy gn


12/23

40094>9

( 33 (

mcf vmtaa gqvjoly+ |jvm c ngqtvm afjvjgo gn vmajt yqd(nayvj~ck pkcooaf ngt Cqlqyv 4033/

Mg|a~at+ yg nct+ vmaz mc~a ncjkaf jo vmajt lgck -Hjkkat+ 4030* vg yaiqta c Uvjvka ypgoygtymjpX

fack |gtvm hgta vmco >00+000 -Natlqygo+ 400:*/ Fghjoji Hc}|akk+ ngt Vma Vjhay+ ikcjhaf

vmcv vma hg~a |cy ptghpvaf dz vma dakjan chgolyv vma Djl Ngqt vmcv Ntjola ighafz |cy

qofat~ckqjol jvyakn cy c dtcof -400=*5 c vayvjhgojck vg vma ~ckqa gn vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay/

Vmjy hcz |akk da vma icya/ Mg|a~at+ yjoia 400=+ |mg mcy daoanjvvaf ntgh vmjy jofqyvtjck

hgfak7

Njtyvkz+ patngthcoia ighpcojay jo~gk~af jo vma AIN -ighpqkygtz jn patngthjol jo goa gn vma

Djl Ngqt* cta tasqjtaf vg pcz >00+ jo cffjvjgo vg vma iaovtck Ntjola taljyvtcvjgo naa gn

4:1/40+ vg da joikqfaf jo vma AINy g|o ptgltchha/ Jo cffjvjgo vg vmjy cffaf igyv+ ~aoqa

mjta naay mc~a daao yvacfjkz tcjyaf ckgolyjfa co g~atckk tjya jo vjieav ptjia/ Tcvmat vmco

ckkg|jol Ntjola ighafz co gppgtvqojvz vg tacp vma ta|ctfy gn jvy g|o dtcofjol+ vma AIN

cppacty vg mc~a kjoaf vma pgieavy gn vma Djl Ngqt+ yjoia jvy joiapvjgo jo 400=/ Jofaaf+ vma

~aoqa fjtaivgty mc~a ogv ptgnayyaf vma njocoijck ~qkoatcdjkjvz vmcv vmaz |ata ikcjhjol jo actkz

400= -faypjva mc~jol ncjkaf vg cimja~a c igtpgtcva icym jobaivjgo*/ Vma yaahjol yqiiayy vmcv

vma AIN mcy cimja~af mcy daao ka~akkaf vmtgqlm ayvcdkjymjol c hgogpgkz g~at vma gvmat + vma Yigvvjym Ctvy Igqoijk -jo

pctvoatymjp |jvm Nayvj~cky Afjodqtlm+ vma Ijvz gn Afjodqtlm Igqoijk+ vma Yigvvjym A}aiqvj~a+

A~aovYigvkcof+ cof Yigvvjym Aovatptjya Afjodqtlm cof Kgvmjco* pqdkjymaf Vmqofatjol

Mgg~ay+ c tapgtv ighhjyyjgoaf vg jfaovjnz yimahay vmcv |gqkf igoygkjfcva Afjodqtlmy


13/23

40094>9

( 34 (

nayvj~cky |jvm c lkgdck ighpavjvj~a afla/ \mjkyv cieog|kafljol vmcv cv vma Ntjola vma

patngthaty vcea vma njocoijck tjye -Yigvvjym Ctvy Igqoijk/ av ck+ 400>2 91*+ vma tapgtv kggey vg

aoigqtcla cof taighhaof co joitacya jo vma ka~ak gn cf~atvjyahaov gn vma Ntjola vg co

jovatocvjgock hcteavpkcia -400>2 30*/

Jv jy ptaijyakz qofat vmaya cqypjiay vmcv vma Djl Ngqt vtjaf vg bqyvjnz vma ayvcdkjymhaov gn vma

AIN -Hc}|akk+ 400=*/ Jo Vmqofatjol Mgg~ay+ jv jy ctlqaf vmcv vmjy pgkjiz oaaf ogv+ cy c

haimcojyh+ imckkaola vma ctvjyvji cqvgoghz gn vma Nayvj~ck -Yigvvjym Ctvy Igqoijk/ av ck+

400>2 61*/ Mg|a~at+ mg| ico jv ogv7 Vma iqttaov ~aoqa yvtqivqta igovtcfjivy vma ~atz

pmjkgygpmz gn vma Ntjola/ Jo 3:+ vmao Ntjola fjtaivgt+ Ckjyvcjt Hgnncv fayitjdaf vmjy

pmjkgygpmz+ yvcvjol vmcv2 coz ngth gn sqckjvz igovtgk jy ajvmat dz vma ctvjyvy vmahyak~ay+ gt

vmajt pqdkji+ jo c fjtaiv+ jhhafjcva goa(vg(goa takcvjgoymjp+ |jvm og hjffkahao -Hgnncv+

3:+ Njocoijck Vjhay Covmgoz Vmgtoitgnv ctlqaf vmcv vma jo~gk~ahaov

gn Djl Dqyjoayy mcy qoyavvkaf vma lkgtjgqy coctimz gn vma Ntjola dqv mcy ogv g~at|makhaf jv

zav -Vmgtoitgnv jo Dcvimakfat+ 400>2 3>4*/ \jvm vma pgyv(AIN Ntjola vmcv jy og| jo pkcia+

igoyjfat jv g~at|makhaf/


14/23

40094>9

( 39 (

Vg |mcv a}vaov vmao+ |gqkf Ntjola ighafjcoy daoanjv ntgh vcejol vmjy yaoya gn iqkvqtck

jofqyvtz jovg vmajt g|o mcofy7 Jo 400=+ Fgql Yvcomgpa kgflaf mjy ptgvayv clcjoyv vma

ayvcdkjymhaov gn vma AIN vma ciha gn g~atighhatijckjyh -Hc}|akk ijvjol Yvcomgpa+

400=* dz coogqoijol pkcoy ngt c ymg| kcyvjol 3=(mgqty/ VjvkafC Fcz |jvm Fgql+ vma ymg|

mcf bqyv goa vjieav+ igyvjol */ Tcvmat vmco dajol c ~jcdka gppgtvqojvz vg taikcjh pgvaovjck kgyyay+C Fcz

|jvm Fgql |cy co ctvjyvji yvcvahaov+ fayjloaf vg ftc| cvvaovjgo vg vma pkjlmv gn itacvj~a

ptcivjvjgoaty cv vma Ntjola/ Jo vathy gn Yvcomgpay hgta igo~aovjgock patngthcoiay fqtjol

Afjodqtlm 400=+ ma patygockkz ptgltchhaf c yatjay gn lqatjkkc ljly vcejol pkcia |jvmgqv

gnnjijck Ntjola iatvjnjicvjgo -Hc}|akk+ 400=*+ go vma ntjola gn vma Ntjola jvyakn/ Vmjy jy c

hgfak ma mcy ahpkgzaf citgyy vma |gtkf/

Jn J |cov vg pkcz Tgiengtf+ Jkkjogjy ( cof J,~a oa~at pkczaf vmata dangta ( J,kk njkk gqv c

dqkkavjo go Uvma ygijck oav|gtejol |adyjvaX HzYpcia lgjol+ Maz+ |mg eog|y c ~aoqa

jo Tgiengtf+ Jkkjogjy7 Dz vma aof gn vma fcz J,kk mc~a jv dggeaf/ Ojoa gqv gn 30 vjhay/

J,~a fgoa jv tapacvafkz/ -Yvcomgpa jo Kglco+ 400=2 4>*

Jo mjy ctvjikaDcie Vg \gte2 Iqkvqtck Kcdgt jo Ckvataf Vjhay+ Ltcmch Hqtfgie ctlqay vmcv

goa gn vma eaz ptcivjiay jo iqkvqtck ptgfqivjgo jy vma ptgiayy gn jo~ayvjol cy mac~jkz jo

hcteavjol ptgfqivy cy jo ptgfqijol vmah -40092 4=*/ Jn |a ~ja| ighafjcoy Ntjola kgyyay cy

c ngth gn hcteavjol+ jo vma |jfat igova}v gn c ighafjcoy dgfz gn |gte+ vmao vma Ntjola

fahgoyvtcvay c yjlojnjicov ka~ak gn djcy jo nc~gqt gn hcteavjol igyvy/ Jo vathy gn Yvcomgpay

ptcivjia mg|a~at+ jv jy vma gvmat |cz tgqof+ nc~gqtjol igyv(ntaa |ad(dcyaf ptghgvjgo+ cof

vtcfjvjgock |gtf(gn(hgqvm -G,Igoogt ijvjol Yvcomgpa+ 400=*/ Vmjy |gqkf vmao+ nckk gqvyjfa gn

Hqtfgiey jfac gn vma ptgfqivjgo gn iqkvqta/ Mg|a~at+ jv jy jhpgtvcov vg taiglojya vmcv vmata


15/23

40094>9

( 36 (

jy yghavmjol jhptayyj~akz jofqyvtjgqy cdgqv Yvcomgpay ahcoijpcvgtz havmgf2 cy yggo cy

vmata,y c fgkkct vg da hcfa coz|mata vmatay lgooc da c yac gn ymctey |mg cta lgjol vg njlqta

gqv mg| vg lav dav|aao yqppkz cof fahcof vg lav c patiaovcla/// J mc~a akjhjocvaf ckhgyv

a~atzdgfz J ico vmcv fgayo,v cff yghavmjol vg vma asqcvjgo/ -Yvcomgpa jo GIgoogt+ 400=*/

Yva|ctv Kaa ymctay vmjy cpptgcim/ Ngkkg|jol vma coogqoiahaov gn vma AIN+ Kaa mcy ~g|af

oa~at clcjo vg patngth cv coz gn vma djl ngqt ~aoqay -Kglco+ 400=2 4>*+ joyvacf imggyjol

vg patngth cv Vma Yvcof ighafz ikqd+ goa gn vma gokz Ntjola ~aoqay vmcv gpatcvay jo

Afjodqtlm ngt 34 hgovmy gn vma zact/ Vma Yvcofy fjtaivgt+ Vghhz Ymappctf+ ptghjyay vma

civy |mg faijfa vg patngth vmata vmcv+ ymgqkf vmajt vjieav ta~aoqa ncjk vg ig~at vmajt ~aoqa

taovck naa+ ma |jkk hcea qp vma fjnnataoia -Ig}+ 400=*/ Dz njkkjol yhckk tgghy+ takzjol go

vtcfjvjgock |gtf(gn(hgqvm hcteavjol+ vma cdyaoia gn vma igyv gn c vahpgtctz ~aoqa kjiaoia+

cof c kgzck kgick cqfjaoia+ Ymappctf ico kac~a vma Ntjola jo ptgnjv -Ig}+ 400=*/ Kaa mcy

ngkkg|af vmjy hgfak+ ctlqjol vmcv vcejol taypgoyjdjkjvz cy co ctvjyv ngt goay g|o aigoghji

yaiqtjvz tasqjtay vma imgppjol c|cz gn ckk a}vtcoagqy g~atmacfy cof pkczjol vg zgqt

yvtaolvmy gn |mcv vmaz Uvma cqfjaoiaX |cov+ tcvmat vmco vtzjol vg fj~atyjnz -Fa~ataq}Gojcoy+

4030*/ Kaa lgay go vg yvcva vmcv vmjy ptclhcvji yakn(talqkcvgtz cpptgcim+ pqvy vma ctvjyv jo

igovtgk gn vmajt g|o jofqyvtz2 |mao zgq kgge cv c vgqt pgyvat ngt Upgpqkct vaka~jyjgo yvcof(qpX

Tqyyakk Mg|ctf cof may fgjol ctaocy+ Jh ptgdcdkz yaajol Uc mjlmat patiaovclaX gn vma

hgoaz+ icqya UTqyyakk Mg|ctfyX lgv vaka~jyjgo cf~atvjyjol -Fa~ataq}Gojcoy+ 4030*/

Mgtemajhat cof Cfgtogy ogvjgo vmcv qoj~atyck pqdkjijvz jy og |cz oaiayyctz ngt pagpka vg

lav vg eog| vma ejofy gn lggfy |mgya yqppkz jy tayvtjivaf coz|cz -3::12 3>4* jy patnaivkz

hjttgtaf jo vma vaimojsqay qyaf dz Kaa cof Yvcomgpa/ J |gqkf ctlqa mg|a~at+ vmcv bqyv

daicqya vmaya ctvjyvy cta ogv imqtojol gqv vmajt iqkvqtck |ctay jo vma ngth gn c ncivgtjck

ptgfqivjgo kjoa+ jv fgay ogv haco vmaz cta ogv a}atijyjol igovtgk g~at vmajt g|o iqkvqtck


16/23

40094>9

( 31 (

jofqyvtz/ Jn vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay ico aoigqtcla itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty vg vcea

taypgoyjdjkjvz ngt vma ~ckqa -njocoijck gt yzhdgkji* gn vmajt itacvj~a gqvpqv+ vmao yqtakz vmcv

ico gokz da c lggf vmjol/ Yeavim ighafjco Dcttz Nactoy -vma dcoetqpv Ntjola patngthat |mg

kgyv 40+000* cpptgcimaf vma jyyqa gn pkzjol mjy |ctay cv vma Ntjola joyaoyjdkz5 vma fahcof

|cy ikactkz ogv vmata vg gnnyav mjy ka~ak gn njocoijck jo~ayvhaov/

Vma nciv gn vma hcvvat jy vmcv patngthaty cta qofat og gdkjlcvjgo vg pcz vmgqycofy gn pgqofy

jo ~aoqa taovck naay vg Afjodqtlmy ~aoqa ighpcojay/ Vma ~aoqay gpatcva jo vma |cz vmcv vmaz

fg daicqya vmata jy c yvacfz nkg| gn vckaovaf itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty |mg cta qofat~ckqjol vma

jhhafjcva ighhatijck pgvaovjck gn vmajt |gte+ cof cta |jkkjol vg kgya */ Vmjy ogvjgo jy a~ao

hgta taka~cov |mao cppkjaf ypaijnjickkz vg ighafjcoy/ Yvcof(qp ighafz fa~akgpaf ntgh vma

civy ngqof jo vma kcva 3:vm

Iaovqtz hqyji mckky+ c laota gn patngthcoia vmcv |cy cppaofaf

|jvm c yaoya gn tayjlocvjgo cof ncvckjyh -Hafmqtyv+ 4006* vmcv mcy imctcivatjyaf 40vm

Iaovqtz ~ja|y gn yvcof(qp ighafz/ Yvcof(qp mcy ogv fa~akgpaf |jvm vma ycha yaoya gn yakn(

taypaiv vmcv pqdkjickkz(yqdyjfjyaf vmacvta ctvy fahcof/ Mg|a~at+ vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola jy goa

gn vma na| hghaovy gn vma zact |mao ighafz jy lj~ao ctvjyvji dtacvmjol ypcia cy c kaljvjhcva

patngthcoia hafjqh jo jvy g|o tjlmv/ Jn vmata jy a~at c vjha ngt ighafjcoy vg ahcoijpcva

vmahyak~ay+ cof vcea igovtgk gn vmajt g|o patygock iqkvqta ncivgtz+ jv jy jo Cqlqyv/

Vg c iatvcjo a}vaov+ Pavat Dqiekaz Mjkk jy kacfjol vmjy ta~gkqvjgo+ |mjkyv ckyg taptayaovjol c

yaoya gn itacvj~a a}ptayyjgo g~at njocoijck ta|ctf/ Mjy gtlcojycvjgo+ PDMy Ntaa Ntjola+


17/23

40094>9

( 3> (

makpy patngthaty yvcla |gte jo ~aoqay vmcv fgov tasqjta ~aoqa taovck naay+ qofat vma

igofjvjgo vmcv patngthaty fgov imctla vmajt cqfjaoia aovtz vg cvvaof vmajt ymg| -c dqieav jy

pcyyaf ctgqof vma ~aoqa cv vma aof gn vma ymg|+ cof cqfjaoia hahdaty ico fgocva hgoaz jn

vmaz yg imggya*/ Tcvmat vmco |tayvkjol |jvm vma pgkjvjiy gn ighhatijck aovatptjya+ kjea

Vghhz Ymappctf cv Vma Yvcof+ Dqiekaz Mjkk tahg~ay vmjy |mgka akahaov ntgh vma asqcvjgo/

Vma ptgdkah |jvm vmjy hgfak -gn ogv yakkjol vjieavy* mg|a~at+ jy vmcv jv fgay ogv aoigqtcla

civy vg cvvtjdqva njocoijck ~ckqa vg vmajt |gte+ cof fgay ogv patyqcfa cqfjaoiay vmcv vmjy |gte

mgkfy ygijck hacojol cof jy |gtvmz gn vmajt vjha/ Jv igqkf da ctlqaf vmcv+ chgolyv vma imcgy

gn vma Ntjola+ vmjy jy co qojhpgtvcov favcjk/ Mg|a~at+ civy vmcv gpatcva ptgnayyjgockkz gqvyjfa

vma Ntjola ymgqkf ogv mc~a vg kg|at vma ~ckqa gn vmajt ighafz ngt co Afjodqtlm cqfjaoia/

Vma nciv vmcv vma oqhdat gn ighafjcoy vcejol go oa| cof gtjljock yimahay gn ighhatijck

cvvtjdqvjgo+ yjhjkct vg vmcv gn Kaa cof Yvcomgpa+ jy yg yhckk+ fahgoyvtcvay co jofqyvtz(|jfa

kcie gn itacvj~jvz vmcv jy cv gffy |jvm vma ocvqta gn vma ctv ngth/

Vma ighafz jofqyvtz gpatcvay a}vtahakz |akk dgvm iqkvqtck cof njocoijckkz ngt 33 hgovmy gn

vma zact/ Mg|a~at+ |mao jv haavy vma haimcojyaf gnnjijckfgh gn vma Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck

Ntjola jv itqhdkay qofat jvy g|o jonatjgtjvz ighpka}/

Jo vmjy igova}v+ jv jy yjlojnjicov vg igoyjfat vma pkqtckjyh gn vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay/ Vma

Dtjvjym ighafz jofqyvtz cof vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola jofqyvtz cta v|g cqvgoghgqy iqkvqtck

jofqyvtjay+ cof zav |mao vmaz igkkjfa c ncyijocvjol mjatctimjick fzochji ahatlay dav|aao

aigoghjickkz yc~~z ~aoqa ighpcojay+ cof jofqyvtjgqykz qoimckkaoljol itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty/

Jn |a igoyjfat PDMy Ntaa Ntjola cy cogvmat iqkvqtck jofqyvtz+ fqa vg jvy ptgfqivjgo gn ygijck

hacojol+ |jvmjo Afjodqtlmy jofqyvtjck kcofyicpa gn iqkvqta+ vmao |mcv jy ta~ackaf cta vmtaa

iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay |jvm vmtaa ~atz fjnnataov cjhy/


18/23

40094>9

( 3< (

Go taiaj~jol vma pcoak ptjra ngt Ypjtjv gn vma Ntjola cv 400:y Afjodqtlm Ighafz C|ctfy

-ngthatkz vma Pattjat C|ctf*+ Pavat Dqiekaz Mjkk pcjf vtjdqva vg c|ctfy fjtaivgt Ojic Dqtoy

yczjol J cfhjta vma |cz yma mcy fgoa vmjy |jvmgqv igtpgtcva ypgoygtymjp+ vma Ntjola mcy

daao vgg igtpgtcva ngt vgg kgol/ Ymay ymg|o vmcv |a ico fg jv dz gqtyak~ay -Dqiekaz Mjkk jo

ImgtvkaQE+ 400:*/ Mg|a~at+ Dqtoy kgyv ctgqof 300+000 tqoojol vma c|ctf jo 400: -DDI+

400:*+ dangta taiaj~jol c vjvka ypgoygtymjp pciecla ntgh Ngyvaty ngt vma c|ctfy jo 4030+

4033+ cof dazgof/ Dqiekaz Mjkk ikcjhy |a ico fg jv dz gqtyak~ay+ cof zav vmata jy og |cz

Dqtoy ico joiqt c kgyy gn 300+000 pat zact jo gtfat vg lj~a vmtaa ighafjcoy c vtgpmz/

Dqiekaz Mjkk mjhyakn mcy vg tcjya 36+000 jo cf~atvjyjol jo gtfat vg cnngtf 300+000 igpjay gn

vma PDMy Ntaa Ntjola nayvj~ck dtgimqta/ Yg+ vmata jy c yaoya gn aovatptjya cof jofqyvtz vmcv jy

jhdqaf |jvmjo Dqiekaz Mjkky gtlcojycvjgo/

Vma coy|at jo vmjy icya jy patmcpy vma yicka gn vma aovatptjya/ Mgtemajhat cof Cfgtog

gdbaivaf vg vma ighhgfjvjycvjgo gn iqkvqta fqa vg vma |cz jv |cy dajol ntj~gkgqykz imqtoaf

gqv cejo vg ncivgtjck ptgfqivjgo -3::12 343*/ Jo vathy gn vma ocvqta gn vma jofqyvtjay+ jv cppacty

cy vmgqlm vma aovtaptaoaqtjck ~aoqa hcoclahaov cv vma Ntjola mcy hgta jo ighhgo |jvm c

\ayv Aof vmacvta hgfak+ vmco |jvm vma Ntjola ctvjyvy |mg ltcia vmajt patngthcoia ypciay/

Ckvmgqlm+ pqdkjickkz jv jy qyanqk vg mc~a Mayhgofmcklm cof Ptcvv gnnatjol vmajt kjyv gn

icvalgtjay gn iqkvqtck jofqyvtz+ vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy ogv c pqdkji vath/ Jv |gqkf da nct

hgta cpptgptjcva vg ngkkg| Vmtgydzy hgfak cof ngth c igovjoqqh fanjoaf go vma dcyjy gn

mg| vmgya jofqyvtjay lg cdgqv vmajt havmgfy gn ptgfqivjgo+ tcvmat vmco |mcv vmaz ptgfqia/

Vma vath iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay jy+ jo jvy iqttaov lqjya+ fgjol Ntjola ighafz c fjyyat~jia/

Mg|a~at+ jn |a ico aongtia c dtgcfat fanjojvjgo gn vma vath vmao c |mgka laoatcvjgo gn


19/23

40094>9

( 3= (

ighafjcoy ico da ahpg|ataf vg vcea igovtgk gn vmajt g|o jofqyvtz cv vma Ntjola/ Jo vma :0y+

vma vath itacvj~a jofqyvtjay |cy igjoaf jo gtfat vg ygk~a igonqyjgo yqttgqofjol vma vath

iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay -Ajyaodatl+ Latkcim+ . Mcofea+ 400>2 2 3=*

Mg|a~at+ J |gqkf ctlqa vmcv iqkvqta ymgqkf da fahgitcvjyaf vmtgqlm vmgya |mg itacva cof

a}patjaoia jv+ ogv vmtgqlm ighhatia/ Jn vma itacvj~a ctvy daigha vgg yzogozhgqy |jvm

ighhatijck aovatptjya vmao vma fzochjyh gn vmaya ctvy |jkk da kgyv/ Jv jy ptaijyakz vmjy

takcvjgoymjp vmcv mcy kacf bgqtockjyvy cof ighhaovcvgty vg ptgpmaiz vma igkkcpya gn vma Ntjola

g~at vma kcyv 30 zacty cy joa~jvcdka/ Hz hgfak gn vma iqkvqtck jofqyvtjay mgkf vma v|g cv cthy

kaolvm+ cof zav ckkg|y ngt itacvj~a ptcivjvjgoaty gn Ntjola ighafz vg ogv |cjv ngt vmajt djl

dtace dqv vg vcea taypgoyjdjkjvz ngt vma fjyyahjocvjgo gn vmajt g|o ctv/

\gtf igqov2 >+1=1


20/23

40094>9

( 3: (

Djdkjgltcpmz

Ckkco+ V/ -4030* 4030 Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck Ntjola yav vg da 3

Lqctfjco Afjodqtlm/ UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2

mvvp2''|||/lqctfjco/ig/qe'afjodqtlm'4030'bqo'30'afjodqtlm(nayvj~ck(ntjola(4030(ptgltchha(kcqoim7JOVIHP8YTIM/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Ctvmqt+ V/ -400=* Mg| Mackvmz jy Ighafz cv vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola Nayvj~ck7 Vjha Gqv/

UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2 mvvp2''|||/vjhagqv/igh'njkh'nacvqtay'ymg|(nacvqta'1134'mg|(

mackvmz(jy(ighafz(cv(vma(afjodqtlm(ntjola(nayvj~ck/mvhk/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Dcda+ T/ -400:* Iqkvqtck Yvqfjay cof Pgkjvjick Aigoghz2 Vg|ctf c Oa| Jovaltcvjgo/ Kcomch+

HF2 Ka}jolvgo dggey/

Dcvimakfat+ ]/ -400>* Vma \gtkfy Kctlayv Ctvy Nayvj~ck+ Vma Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck Ntjola2

Haimcojiy+ Hzvm cof Hcoclahaov/ PmF Vmayjy/ Igkqhdqy+ GM2 Vma Gmjg Yvcva Qoj~atyjvz/UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2 mvvp2''avf/gmjgkjoe/afq'yaof

pfn/ilj'Dcvimakfat!40]akc/pfn7gyq336:306644/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

DDI/ -400:*C|ctfy dgyy vg nqof ighafz ptjra/ UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2

mvvp2''oa|y/ddi/ig/qe'3'mj'yigvkcof'afjodqtlmWcofWacyv'=0=944=/yvh/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Dgrvcy+ Y/ -400=* Djl ^aoqay Ysqaarjol gqv vma Ypjtjv gn Afjodqtlm Ntjola/ Vma

Jofapaofaov/ UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2 mvvp2''|||/jofapaofaov/ig/qe'ctvy(

aovatvcjohaov'ighafz'oa|y'djl(~aoqay(ysqaarjol(gqv(vma(ypjtjv(gn(afjodqtlm(ntjola(

==13::/mvhk/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Icttakk+ Y/ -400:* Afjodqtlm Nayvj~ck Ntjola Yckay Daoanjv ntgh Taiayyjgo Lkggh/ Vma

Lqctfjco/ p36/ U03'0:'400:X Hcoimayvat2 Lqctfjco Hafjc Ltgqp/

ImgtvkaQE/ -400:* Pavat Dqiekaz Mjkk |joy vma Afjodqtlm Ighafz C|ctfy pcoak ptjra/

^jfag ygqtia UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2

mvvp2''|||/zgqvqda/igh'|cvim7~8tL^\hJ94:


21/23

40094>9

( 40 (

Afntjola/igh/ -4033* Vma Nayvj~ck Ntjola Ygijavz/ UGokjoaX mvvp2''|||/afntjola/igh'cdgqv(

qy'ntjola(ygijavz/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Ajyaodatl+ I/ Latkcim+ T/ . Mcofea+ I/ -400>* Jovtgfqivjgo/ Iqkvqtck Jofqyvtjay2 Vma Dtjvjym

A}patjaoia jo Jovatocvjgock Patypaivj~a/ -Ajyaodatl+ I/ Latkcim+ T/ . Mcofea+ I/ afy* Datkjo2

Iaovta ngt Dtjvjym Yvqfjay+ Mqhdgkfv Qoj~atyjvz gn Datkjo/

Natlqygo+ D/ -400:* Djl ngqt ighafz ikqdy vg lg jv ckgoa clcjo/ Vma Yigvyhco/ UGokjoaX

C~cjkcdka ntgh2 mvvp2''oa|y/yigvyhco/igh'yigvkcof'Djl(ngqt(ighafz(ikqdy(vg/1016011/bp/

UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Ntjafhco+ Y/ -4033* Vma Iqkvqtck Iqttaoiz gn c Lggf Yaoya gn Mqhgqt2 Dtjvjym ighafz

cof oa| ngthy gn fjyvjoivjgo/ Vma Dtjvjym Bgqtock gn Ygijgkglz/ ^gk/ >45 Og/ 4/ Kgofgo2

Kgofgo Yimggk gn Aigoghjiy cof Pgkjvjick Yijaoia/

Ljt~co+ C/ -4030* Vgp Nj~a \czy vg Yc~a cv vma Afjodqtlm Ntjola/ \mcvygoyvcla/igh

UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2mvvp2''|||/|mcvygoyvcla/igh'nacvqtay'vmacvta'kgofgo'A==934=316039:'Vgp%Nj~a%\czy%vg

%Yc~a%cv%vma%Afjodqtlm%Ntjola%/mvhk/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Mckk+ B/ -4030* Ckk vma nqo gn vma Ntjola2 Vma dayv gn Afjodqtlm vmjy yqhhat/ Vma

Jofapaofaov/ UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2 mvvp2''|||/jofapaofaov/ig/qe'ctvy(

aovatvcjohaov'ighafz'nacvqtay'ckk(vma(nqo(gn(vma(ntjola(vma(dayv(gn(afjodqtlm(vmjy(yqhhat(

409=>=4/mvhk/ UCiiayyaf2 31'01'4033X

Mayhgofmcklm+ F/ -400/ U33'33'4030X Hcoimayvat2 Lqctfjco

Hafjc Ltgqp/

Kglco+ D/ -4030* Yvcofqp Ighjiy Mjv vma Dggh Vjha/ Vma Lqctfjco/ L4 p3:/ U01'0='4030X

Hcoimayvat2 Lqctfjco Hafjc Ltgqp/

Hci|mjtvat+ J/ -400>* Mg| vg yqt~j~a c fcz jo vma dakkz gn vma acyv/ Vma Yqofcz Matckf/

UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2

mvvp2''njofctvjikay/igh'p'ctvjikay'hjWso631>'jyW400>0=4


22/23

40094>9

( 43 (

Hafmqtyv+ C/ -400'01'4033X

Yqimyhckkpgtvjgoy/igh/ -4033*Affja Jrrctf cof Tgyy Ogdka yav ngt Kcqlmy Jo Vma Pcte/

UGokjoaX C~cjkcdka ntgh2

mvvp2''|||/yqimyhckkpgtvjgoy/igh'pl'oa|y'yqimyhckkpgtvjgoy'tacf'93499'affja(jrrctf(cof(

tgyy(ogdka(yav(ngt(kcqlmy(jo(vma(pcte/ UCiiayyaf2 30'01'4033X

Vmgtpa+ ^/ -4000* Nayvj~ck Dgyy Cvvciey Dkcof Ntjola/ Vma Gdyat~at/ p=/ U0>'0='4000XHcoimayvat2 Lqctfjco Hafjc Ltgqp/


23/23

40094>9

44

Vmtgydz+ F/ -400=* Vma Igoiaovtji Ijtikay Hgfak gn vma Iqkvqtck Jofqyvtjay/ Iqkvqtck Vtaofy/

^gk/ 3

An Assessment of the Value of the term "Cultural Industries" in Reference to Comedic Practice at the...

Documents

Transcript of An Assessment of the Value of the term "Cultural Industries" in Reference to Comedic Practice at the...