AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch...

22
Ammonia Ammonia-Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch Reductions Using Stabilized Sodium In n Stabilized Sodium In n-Silica for Safer, More Silica for Safer, More Michael J. Costanzo, Mitul N. Patel, Kathryn A. Petersen, and Paul F. Vogt Sustainable Synthesis Sustainable Synthesis June 2009

Transcript of AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch...

Page 1: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch Reductions Using Stabilized Sodium In nStabilized Sodium In n--Silica for Safer, More Silica for Safer, More

Michael J. Costanzo, Mitul N. Patel, Kathryn A. Petersen, and Paul F. Vogt

Sustainable SynthesisSustainable Synthesis

June 2009

Page 2: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

About SiGNa ChemistryAbout SiGNa Chemistry

A chemical technology company with a growing portfolio ofA chemical technology company with a growing portfolio of“GREEN” products and processes for

improved efficiency and a cleaner environmentimproved efficiency and a cleaner environment

Alternative Energy:Cl H f t f b d f i d t i l d t bl f l• Clean H2 from water for a broad range of industrial process and portable fuel cell applications

Green Industrial Processes:Green Industrial Processes:• Improved industrial efficiency and yield with critical cost reduction using green chemical processing

Clean Technology:• Cleaner burning conventional petroleum‐ and bio‐based fuels• Remediation of hazardous environmental contaminants

Page 3: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

SiGNa Technology OverviewSiGNa Technology Overview

H Fuel Technology SiGNa’s Scientific CouncilH2 Fuel Technology 

H2 gas produced from waterRoom‐temp. operation, no catalystNear instant start‐stop functionalityN t i b d tNon‐toxic by‐productsProducts: Reagents (NaSi) and fuel systemsApplications: Fuel cells and industrial H2

“Green” Catalysts

JL Dye Sir JM ThomasKnighted in 

1991

RH Grubbs2005 Nobel Prize 

Chemistry

GD Stucky

Green  Catalysts

Low cost and scalableRenewable starting materialsEnvironmentally‐friendly operation

Specialty Chemicals

Non‐toxic by‐productsProducts:  EP Catalyst and AlPOsApplications:  EPDM rubber and ethylene

Stable in dry air / safe to handleRetains chemical power of base alkali metalFree‐flowing conductive powderNon‐toxic by‐productsNon toxic by productsProducts:  M‐SG, OrganoLi‐AG, and MH‐SGApplications: Chemical manufacturing, desulfurization, and remediation (PCBs)

Page 4: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Desulfurization

Applications of SiGNa MaterialsApplications of SiGNa Materials

Desulfurization

Dissolving Metal ReductionsChemical Reductions

Fuel Cells and Alternative Energy

Hydrogen Generation

Palladium Replacement 

LAH Replacement

Solvent Drying and Purification

Olefin  Isomerization

Carbon‐Carbon Bond forming

PCB/CFC Remediation and Freon Conversion

Deuterium and Radio‐label Incorporation

Bond forming Reactions

Page 5: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Alkali Metals React with WaterAlkali Metals React with Water

Page 6: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Overview of SiGNa’s TechnologyOverview of SiGNa’s Technology

Metals solvated in nano‐structured porous oxides 

Alkali metal silica materials (M‐SG); capacity up to 40 wt.%

Stable in dry air / Safer to handle / easier to transport

Free‐flowing powders

Reducing power of the parent metal/alloy retained

Non‐toxic by‐products and waste streams

Page 7: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

SiGNa’sSiGNa’s Commercial PipelineCommercial Pipeline

CONCEPT FEASIBILITY VALIDATION LAUNCH

ChemicalsStage I M‐SG

OrganoLi‐AGM+H‐‐SG

Stage II M‐SG

M+H‐‐SG

Alt. Fuels NaSi

Fuel System

Catalysts EP CatalystAlPOsBio‐Zeolites

Page 8: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

The Birch ReductionThe Birch Reduction

Birch, A. J. J. Chem. Soc. 1944, 430.Rabideau, P. W.; Marcinow, Z. Org. React. 1992, 42, 1. 

• Alternative to hydrogenation that yields cyclohexadienes.• Carried out in liquid ammonia with dissolved Na Li or K• Carried out in liquid ammonia with dissolved Na, Li or K.• Metal cation and a solvated electron are formed.• Mixture contains stoichiometric amounts of an alcohol

Problems include:• Handling of alkali metal and ammonia gasC i• Cryogenic temperatures

• Special design of the equipment• Choice and handling of materials • Operations waste treatment and both safety and economic issues• Operations, waste treatment, and both safety and economic issues

Page 9: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

The Classical Birch ReductionThe Classical Birch Reduction

Typical Reaction Conditions:

• Phenanthrene was dissolved in THF• Solution was added to refluxing ammonia at ‐33 oC• Lithium metal (3 5 equivalents) was added to the mixture• Lithium metal (3.5 equivalents) was added to the mixture• Reaction quenched with ethanol then water then warmed to rt• Desired product is isolated in 57% yield

“Lithium wire was wiped free ofoil and washed with hexaneimmediately before use…….”

Page 10: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

The SiGNa Birch ReductionThe SiGNa Birch Reduction

SiGNa’s Reaction Conditions:

• Phenanthrene and Na‐SG(I) (3.5 equivalents) are charged to a round bottom flaskTHF i dd d d th i t i l d t 0 oC• THF is added and the mixture is cooled to 0 oC

• tert‐Butanol (1.75 equivalents) is added in one portion• Reaction is allowed to warm to room temperature

D i d d i i l d i 60% i ld• Desired product is isolated in 60% yield

NO LIQUID AMMONIA!NO LIQUID AMMONIA! NO CRYOGENIC TEMPERATURES!NO CRYOGENIC TEMPERATURES!

NO PYROPHORIC REAGENTS!NO PYROPHORIC REAGENTS!

Page 11: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

MM--SG Reaction ParametersSG Reaction Parameters

Temp (Temp (°°C)C) Prod (%)Prod (%)Temp. (Temp. ( C)C) Prod. (%)Prod. (%)-78 90

0 81

Similar conversions were observed with:

2 0 to 7 5 equivalents of metal0 81

22 82

2.0 to 7.5 equivalents of metalStage I with Na, Na2K and K2Nat‐butanol and t‐amyl alcohol

40 87

reflux 81

Page 12: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

MM--SG Solvent CompatibilitySG Solvent Compatibility

SolventSolvent Prod. (%)Prod. (%) SolventSolvent Prod. (%)Prod. (%)( )( )THF 81

Me-THF 85

( )( )Cyclohexane 83

Heptane 82Me THF 85

Dioxane 76

MTBE 75

Heptane 82

DME 67

EtOA 0MTBE 75

DMSO 3

EtOAc 0

NMP 19

Toluene 84 t-Amyl-OH (neat) 2

Page 13: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Polycyclic Aromatic HydrocarbonsPolycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons

SiGNa’s safer and more practical modification of the classic Birchreduction that avoids the use of liquid ammonia and cryogenic temperatures

Entry Substrate Major Product Rxn Equiv. Time (h)Na-SG(I)

Prod./Yield (%)Na/NH3 (lit.)

Prod./Yield (%)

1 3 5 2 0 96 / 70 / 851 3.5 2.0 96 / 70 - - / 85

2 2.0 1.0 87 / 83 - - / 97

3 3 5 2 5 99 / 94 - - / 963 3.5 2.5 99 / 94 / 96

Page 14: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Aromatic HydrocarbonsAromatic Hydrocarbons

Entry Substrate Major Product Rxn Equiv Time (h)Na-SG(I)

Prod./Yield (%)Na/NH3 (lit.)

Prod./Yield (%)( ) ( )

1 3.5 2.0 100 / 83 - - / 80-90

2 3 5 2 0 100 / 82 / 80 902 3.5 2.0 100 / 82 - - / 80-90

3 14 24 9 / - - - - / 63

Page 15: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Aryl EthersAryl Ethers

Entry Substrate Major Product Rxn Equiv Time (h)Na-SG(I)

Prod./Yield (%)Na/NH3 (lit.)

Prod./Yield (%)Prod./Yield (%) Prod./Yield (%)

1 14 24 30 / - - - - / 74

2 3 5 24 12 / - - - - / 19OMe

2 3.5 24 12 / - - - - / 19

3 3.5 24 68 / 43 - - / - -

4 14 24 85 / 68 / 74

OMe

4 14 24 85 / 68 - - / 74

5 5.6 24 - - / 56 - - / - -

6 3.5 2.5 92 / 80 - - / 74(liq. NH3)

Page 16: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Polycyclic Aromatic Polycyclic Aromatic HeterocyclesHeterocycles

Entry Substrate Major Product Rxn Equiv Time (h)Na-SG(I)

Prod./Yield (%)Na/NH3 (lit.)

Prod./Yield (%)

1 5 6 24 / 58 / 69Et

1 5.6 24 - - / 58 - - / 69

2 14 48 94 / 62 - - / 15

OH

3 3.5 2.0 89 / 38 - - / - -

4 3.5 2.0 77 / 40 - - / 89

Page 17: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Case Study Case Study –– Birch Reduction Birch Reduction

Goal: Develop a manufacturing process for a Birch reduction of a steroid that does not require liquid ammonia and cryogenic temperaturesp

Results: Conditions were developed which used SiGNa materials in THF at 0 °C without the use of liquid ammonia.

Minimized the amount undesired side-products and comparable yields and purities were observed.

Eliminated the expensive part of the client’s regular Birch reduction which was the required cooling capacity of the reaction and ammonia recycle.

Lowered the client cost of goods by 18% –ll d th t d t liallowed them access to a new product line

Page 18: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Birch with Deuterium IncorporationBirch with Deuterium Incorporation

SiGNa’s Reaction Conditions:

• Phenanthrene and Na‐SG(I) (3.5 equivalents) are charged to a round bottom flask and stirred

• THF is added and the mixture is cooled• THF is added and the mixture is cooled• Reaction is allowed to warm to room temperature and quenched with   D2O

• Desired product is isolated in similar yields and purities• Desired product is isolated in similar yields and purities• NMR integrations shows deuterium incorporation product in 81% yield

When performing a reduction with SiGNa materials,When performing a reduction with SiGNa materials,When performing a reduction with SiGNa materials, When performing a reduction with SiGNa materials, any Cany C‐‐H bond formed can be also be converted into a CH bond formed can be also be converted into a C‐‐D bondD bond

Page 19: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

SodiumMetal (Na0) in Water: SiGNa Na‐SG in Water:

SiGNa’sSiGNa’s Competitive AdvantageCompetitive Advantage

Sodium Metal (Na ) in Water: SiGNa Na‐SG in Water:

SiGNa’s alkali metals solvated in nano‐structured porous oxides:

Significantly simplifies processes while mitigating risks

Potential to Save $MMs for Each Process!!

Generates non‐toxic by‐products and waste streams

Potential to Save $MMs for Each Process!!

Page 20: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

SiGNa SiGNa DeprotectionsDeprotections

Deallylation Debenzylation

Desulfonation

f f ONandi, P.; Redko, M. Y.; Petersen, K.; Dye, J. L.; Lefenfeld, M.; Vogt, P. F.; Jackson, J. E. Organic Letters 2008, 10 (23), 5441.

Page 21: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Case Study Case Study –– Palladium ContaminationPalladium Contamination

Goal: Develop a deprotection step which minimized palladium in the API and that does not require a resin treatment or other precious metal removal stepprecious metal removal step

Results: Desired deprotection was achieved using SiGNa materials to give target API in comparable yields and purities to Pd/Cgive target API in comparable yields and purities to Pd/C hydrogenolysis route.

Palladium content of API, inherently, was 0 ppm. No extra work up steps or purifications were required.

New route removed regulatory hurdle to filling New Drug ApplicationApplication.

Lowered the client’s cost of goods by 24% –Increased productivity by 50%

Page 22: AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free Birch ...acs.confex.com/.../4db77adf5df9fff0d3caf5cafe28f496/paper69625_5.pdf · AmmoniaAmmonia--Free Birch Reductions Using Free

Order SiGNa Materials TodayOrder SiGNa Materials Today

www.alfa.com

Prod. No. Product Name Size44893 Stage I Sodium-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g44894 Stage II Sodium-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g44892 Stage I Na2K-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g44890 St g I K N Sili G l 5g 25g 100g44890 Stage I K2Na-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g

www.sigmaaldrich.com

Prod. No. Product Name Size660167 Stage I Sodium-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g660175 Stage II Sodium-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g660159 Stage I Na2K-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g660140 Stage I K2Na-Silica Gel 5g, 25g, 100g

To purchase development and commercial volumes of SiGNa materials or for technical support, please contact SiGNa Chemistry directly at 

[email protected]