Alternative Sources of Finance - ICAEW.com
Transcript of Alternative Sources of Finance - ICAEW.com
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
Alternative Sources of Finance
Making it big in business
Clive Lewis, Head of Enterprise
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Alternative Sources of Finance
Presentation will cover:
• Do you need finance or better financial management? (slide 3)
• Key questions before raising finance (slide 4)
• Risk Profile (slide 5)
• Start-up & Early Stage Finance – the Alternatives (slide 6)
• Bank, Asset & Equity finance (slides 7 – 9)
• Bank’s Appeals Process (slides 10 - 11)
• Lesser known sources of finance (slides 12 - 17)
• On-line sources of finance (slides 18 - 29)
• British Business Bank (slide 30)
• How an accountant can help you access finance (slide 31)
• ICAEW Business Advice Service (slides 32 - 34)
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Do you need finance or better financial management?
• A business should have a continuous focus on cash flow
• Good practices and clear lines of responsibility are important.
• Have clear credit agreements with customers and suppliers
• Have a system for following up late receipts from customers
• Knowing your current bank balance and how you expect it to
change over next 3 months is vital
• Good financial management not only helps manage cash it will
reassure finance providers
• A growing business can mean increased working capital.
Arrange your finances to meet any increased need.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the appropriate finance for your
business
Key questions to consider before seeking finance:
• How much are you looking to raise?
• Are monies needed for short or long term needs?
• Are monies needed for growth or just to sustain your
business?
• Are you prepared to offer security over an asset being
personal or business?
• Are you prepared to bring in an outside investor and give up
either a minority or majority stake?
• How do you plan to repay the finance?
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
The business’ risk profile matters.
• Banks use a variety of information to assess risk
• Behavioural scoring data (how accounts are run, facilities
repaid and evidence of a drop in turnover)
• Credit reference data also referred to (paying suppliers later,
court judgements, late filings at Cos House)
• If the business is a limited company, finance providers will look
behind the company at the directors credit history
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Possible types of Start-up & Early Stage Finance
• Your own personal savings
• Friends and Family
• Credit cards
• Credit Unions
• Grants (usually for specific groups of people or sectors)
• StartUp Loans
• Bank finance – overdraft or loans
• Invoice Factoring and Discounting
• Hire purchase , leasing or hiring
• Small scale equity finance such as Business Angels
• Crowd Funding or Peer-to-Peer Lending
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the appropriate finance for your business
Bank and Invoice Finance
Loans - Normally secured by a charge over asset(s). Often has
conditions attaching to the loan (“covenants”) which can trigger a
demand for immediate repayment if they are not met.
Overdraft -The lender offers a facility with a limit with an agreed
interest rate and probably secured. The business can dip in and out of
the facility up to the limit.
Debt Factoring – To consider factoring the business needs debtors
with a good credit record. The factoring company pays a percentage of
the debtor book immediately to your business. Factor chases debt
Invoice Discounting allows the business to administer the sales
ledger and the customer is unaware that the debt has been discounted.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the appropriate finance for your business
Other Asset Finance
Outright Purchase or Deferred Payment -asset(s) can either be
purchased outright or paid for by instalments. There are various
types of deferred payment - hire, hire purchase or leasing.
Mortgage – normally be used to finance a property acquisition or to
expand an existing business premises. Similar to a bank loan with the
mortgage usually being secured over the premises. Loan to value
ratios vary but unlikely to exceed 70%
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the appropriate finance for your business
Equity Finance
Self funding, friends and family -Business owner with their own funds or those
of friends and family, inject monies into your business. This can be by way of a
loan or equity finance. Must put agreement in writing
Small Scale Equity Finance - businesses sell a share in the business to friends,
family, business angels or other private investors. They must be prepared to
allow others a say in how the business is run. Business angels bring (up to £2
million) finance to a business and they normally have experience in what makes
a successful business
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the best from your bank
If refused credit by a bank
• Get a written explanation for the decision
• Consider requesting an appeal – 40% of appeals result in the
decision being overturned frequently because business
provides additional information.
• Bank should offer suggested alternative sources/types of
finance
• Review banks feedback and consider applying to another
bank or source of finance
• Ask is equity finance the way forward?
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting the best from your bank
• All major UK banks have agreed a set of principles if your formal
application for finance has been refused and you appeal the decision
• An independent and external team of reviewers monitor the
principles and the banks application of them
• The appeal is reviewed by a second person from the bank not
involved in the original decision
• The reviewers have 30 days to communicate the result of your
appeal to you.
• 40% of appeals reviewed in the first year resulted in the original
refusal being overturned. In a majority of these cases this followed
additional information being submitted.
• For more information ask your bank or look on the Better Business
Finance Website – www.betterbusinessfinance.co.uk
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Own Personal Savings & Friends & Family
• Business owner with their own funds or those of friends and
family, inject monies into your business. People who have
previously run a business are often more prepared to lend /
invest
• This can be by way of a loan or equity finance
• It is important to understand the expectations of the family and
friend on what they will receive back and when. To avoid
arguments put the key features of the arrangement into a
written agreement
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Start-up- Loans
• Start-Up loans are loans aimed at start-up businesses. This
scheme started as only for 18-30 year olds, but has now been
extended to all ages. Applicants must be living in England and
looking for finance to start a business.
• After applying on-line a Delivery Partner is selected to identify
what stage the start-up is at in the ideas process, and help
them present their business proposal to a panel where they
will pitch for a personal loan
• Originally the maximum amount was £2,500 but this has been
increased to a maximum of £25,000. The loans are typically
less than £10,000 and average around £5,000 at present
Start-up Loans - http://www.startuploans.co.uk/
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Credit Cards
• A regular source of finance for start-up businesses
• Often used for items such as travel, stationery, petrol, car
repairs
• A good way of smoothing out unexpected big bills
• Allowing debt to get out of control will damage a business
owner’s credit rating
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Credit Unions
• Association of British Credit Unions (ABCUL) website provides
information regarding location of member credit unions and
their services
• Some larger CUs offer current account facilities
• Savers in a CU (usually for a period of at least 3 months) will
allow you to access lending facilities.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Community Finance
Community Development Finance Institutions (CDFIs) provide
community finance tailored to the needs of businesses in
deprived areas, owned by entrepreneurs from disadvantaged
communities or unable to access mainstream finance
• Most CDFI business loans unsecured
• Banks now routinely refer businesses refused credit to CDFIs
• CDFIs can help business owners become “finance ready”
More information including finding the right CDFI and an on-line
application for finance go to:
Community Development Finance Association
• http://www.cdfa.org.uk/
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Grants
• Grants and support tend to be sector specific, so your trade
body or association are a good place to make enquiries
• The Local Enterprise Partnership should also be a first port of
call for grants and training courses
• Technology and green projects can be incentivised
• The government offers help with moving from benefits to work/
self-employment and the Job Centre Plus will have details.
• The GOV.uk website has a “Business finance and support
finder”
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Newer online sources of finance:
• Debt funding
• Equity finance
• Working capital funding – factoring & invoice discounting
Seeking to match businesses looking for finance with individuals
and businesses looking for diversification of risk and yield.
Business models vary. Vital to understand how risk of
proposition has been assessed.
Cost proportionately higher than bank finance but risk often
greater.
Internet Finance not within the Financial Services Compensation
Scheme
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Debt Funding (or Peer to Peer Lending) through the
Internet
• Applicants fill in on-line application form
• Acceptance criteria vary but for Funding Circle will include the
following:
– Must be UK based limited company
– At least two years financial reports
– Making a profit and a good credit rating
– May require up-to-date management accounts
– Details of other loans and commitments
– Responses are usually quick. Funding Circle says it’s credit
assessment team will give an answer on the application in 2 days.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Peer to Peer Lending – On acceptance
• Once accepted for entry loan applicants enter auction in a marketplace. A
risk rating is applied to guide lenders
• Registered lenders start bidding the amount they are prepared to lend and
the interest rate they expect to be paid
• As bidding intensifies the interest rate tends to drop
• Applicants can accept the loan as soon as it is fully funded . Alternatively the
loan can be kept live for 14 days to see if the rate drops further
• Once loan accepted applicants can expect the money to be in their bank
accounts. This varies from same working day to two weeks
• An arrangement fee – either a percentage of the loan or a fixed amount – is
charged on the loan.
• The applicant repays the loan to the peer-to-peer lender who is responsible
for distributing the repayments to all lenders involved in the loan
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Peer to Peer Lending
Some providers :
• Funding Circle – loans £5,000 to £500,000
www’fundingcircle.com
• Thincats – loans £50,000 to £1M – www.ThinCats.com
• Rebuildingsociety - £2,000 to £50,000 to cos with turnover
over £200,000. www.rebuildingsociety.com
• FundingKnight – loans £25,000 to £100,000 to well
established SMEs. www.Fundingknight.com
• Wonga for business – short-term loans to £30,000
www.wongaforbusiness.com
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Peer to Peer Lending Vs Bank Finance
Advantages over bank finance:
• Application process is generally quicker
• Generally less onerous security requirements
Disadvantages over bank finance:
• Interest rates generally higher particularly where security and
guarantees not available
• Arrangement fees higher
For lenders:
• P2P in early stages so bad debt levels low.
• Bad debts not tax deductible for lenders
• But some P2P lenders have central fund to help mitigate bad debts
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Equity finance (Or Crowd Funding) through the Internet
Businesses seeking equity must:
• Complete a questionnaire specifying how much finance
required and the equity on offer
• The disclosures are reviewed to ensure they are fair, clear and
not misleading. Listing is then approved
• Investors can invest from up to the full amount required
• If full amount offered within a specified period go to closing, if
not investors get money back
• In closing legal due diligence is conducted and business signs
documentation and on-line platform subscribes for shares on
behalf of investors
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Crowd Funding Continued
• Fee for obtaining finance paid at this point
• Post-investment online platform holds shares as nominees for
investors.
• Dividends or when business floats or sells out the on-line
platform passes the proceeds back to investors
Some on-line equity funding: (eight in UK, these two are FCA
regulated)
• Crowdcube – www. Crowdcube.com Raised £11m for 60+cos
with 42,000 registered investors
• Seedrs – invests in seed-stage start-ups seeking up to
£100,000 of equity- www.seedrs.com
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Other Points on Crowd Funding
• Tax breaks such as Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme
(SEIS) can make Crowd funding more attractive
• Issues with second round funding with so many first time
shareholders.
• Research indicates that around 50% to 70% of business start-
ups fail completely. Likelihood is that investors will lose all their
money.
• FCA intention is to restrict financial promotions for unlisted
shares or debt securities to sophisticated investors, high net
worth individuals, investors taking authorised advice and to
limit investment in this class to 10% of net investible portfolio
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Working capital through the Internet
Lending usually based on factoring and invoice discounting or
selling future credit card income
Factors & invoice discounters include
• Marketinvoice – www.marketinvoice.com
• Platform Black – www.platformblack.com
• Receivables Exchange – www.receivablesxchange.com
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Working capital through the Internet
Credit card companies include Boost
- Business supplies evidence of recent card turnover
- Boost makes an offer of a cash advance based on turnover
- Boost agree to by future credit/ debit card receivables at a discount
- Daily repayment made via small fixed percentage of future credit/
debit card sales
- Business advises card processor to send settlement funds to escrow
account
- Funds collected and remitted through a proprietary escrow service
using Barclays AMS client account
www.boostcapital.co.uk
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
E-Invoicing, debtor management & arranging
finance
Various packages available. Following is Bilbus
• Create a sales invoice or upload from a template
• Invoices can be electronically submitted to customers in a
number of ways including by email direct from your accounting
platform or integrating with accounting platform and sending
direct to customer portal
• Platform sends automated reminders to customers
• Customer updates to status of invoice in their system can
result in automatic update of your collections forecast
• Platform provides feedback on customers’ payment
performance and cost of outstanding debt
• Platform can be linked to an application to a finance provider
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Recent Developments in Internet Finance
• The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has issued a
consultation paper on regulation of the sector scheduled for
early 2014.
• Discussions likely to focus on areas such as establishing
standards for credit checking procedures and minimum capital
requirements
• Concern that too strict standards will push up costs making
alternatives forms of finance more attractive.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
British Business Bank
• The British Business Bank has been formed by the UK
government and will control £2,8 billion existing government
finance schemes and will get £1 billion in new funding.
• Working with 70 partners, it uses its funds to unlock finance for
thousands of smaller UK businesses
• http://british-business-bank.co.uk/applying-for-finance/
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
Getting finance – how might an accountant help?
Many accountants offer advice on business finance. An adviser
can help with:
• Reviewing the business to identify its financing status and
needs
• Identifying the most appropriate sources of money
• Guidance on investor expectations and attitudes
• Preparation of the business plan and of the live presentation
• Mentoring through the funding and due diligence process
They will make a charge for the work – ask for a quote before
you ask them to help.
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
ICAEW Business Advice Service (BAS)
ICAEW firms displaying this logo:
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
ICAEW Business Advice Service
• BAS offers an initial consultation for businesses and start-ups with
an ICAEW Chartered Accountant free of charge.
• An opportunity to discuss your business issues with a finance
professional
• Discussion can cover business issues from record-keeping to
managing cashflow
BUSINESS WITH CONFIDENCE icaew.com
© ICAEW 2012
ICAEW Business Advice Service
Go to:
businessadviceservice.com
Or email:
To find BAS firms in your area.